æ : 5,œ,piqr:‰3$› 3“‰i,“” •’()*+ œ,jmn · 13...
TRANSCRIPT
11
� ñ´:�5,ú,PIQR:½3$��3ª½i,�����'()*+�ú,JMN
,)*+�w:'(�)*+x���u$3=4��)*+T'(�)*+K[\n=T�
��Á¦�)*Ë�ð��,�<pux,��:;3$�'(�)*+,²³:!·2
$3=6T�ßi=4
� 6,xÆ:�ogplmqNGIrs���5uvu,JMN,)*+�wWK*i2�
wX,b��x�y3S,PIQRKz-2$3=6T�ßi=4{|T2$}u~�T
r�������'()*+�ñ��u$3=,:!2$�5,ú,PIQR,`õö_
I���3ku����'()*+���'()*+�'(�)*+,���PIQR,
S�y34�� ���q,y3'(�)*+��-4��,¸��·¸)*,`���
�Á¦�)*Ë�ð���<pu�Ò�'()*+,)*PIQRK��n=��Ke
_2$3=6T�ßi=4
� 66����>�,���� ��L�,�p����)*+,JMNO:}=T�
!Z:ñ�PIQR,S,¡3'(�)*+KL2$3=T3Æg��=47���
��'()*+,PIQR,S�yª�i½��'()*+��¬�[HK�#$;��
S,y3PIQRK �2$3=L�,�%�±342i2��� ���õ`:±ª
,L��y3S,)*PIQRK�<=�ÎK¹$3�3T3Æ6T:�=4_ò2�
«�¬Ë¦®¯°,±3�����²³�)*PIQRKã#=µI¶�yª�'(�
)*+�5,µI¶:·�$3=T�3�=4
��������� ������ ������
� øV,ogplmqNGIrs:�ßi�Ën3T3^_gT��:�3ª½i,Æ
g��=4ñ�, !g����,�X�8�:x^$jîjî��n=Z�!MqR�
"�¬�3T3Æg��=456�7V��¥ 2,o���,SqNGIrsKL3=4
� )*PIQR���¥#Z�������,S�PIQR:�¬���K$�=46,
V������,S,�3Kx��}%Þ�.an=_#:�PIQR,S,lm!ÑK
5uvu,��:;<=���,wW�ï�~BL³L�[VË)*{¦k_�,��
px:îXn=45,���P¨N@&>F�'¨Á!MqRK��2_��PIQR,
S,�(Klmn=4w:��2�<u~���3,��)*+,JMN,�3:x=ì
íg°��=�éêÙëmØìí�2003��+���Á���2004b��4
� 66�L3=HIJ�¥ 3V�Rh2_�,��=4P¨N@T2$��130i+,��
)*+i� 1,986 �153 i+,��'()*+i� 3,309 �316 i+,'(�)*+i
� 2,064,HIJK¹_46,ÆîÆ)*,�=�K¬���'(���'(�+'(
�)*+i�5uvu 1,125�1,883�1,095,)*{,HIJKL3=4
� ÷ 5å1��7��YK;2$3=4lm&'�}=T�ó.Áô.Á+.?IR,3k
u�[\n=i:�x=����)*+,&'ìí�ó.?IR���26.9 ,-���'
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
12
()*+:[�$# 30å40�yª�&'ó.� 17.5 ,-��'(�)*+:[\n=T�
�:# 80å90�y3�&'ó.� 11.5,-�11
4��'()*+T'(�)*+,&'ìí
,���# 50�ø´,g°�.ön=12
46Æ2_ìíg°:x^$�����5uvu,
JMN,)*+:Ó¨/0:��1�u$3�3(0W��=_#��f,xÆ:&>F
�'¨Á!MqRK��n=4
11 ��������� � 4�5����������������� ��!"#$���% &�
���'"()*��+�',*-.��%�/0123*456'71�� 5�1��89���+��
���� !":;/<=>?=@AB#C123*4DE2������ F!"#$GH��%I
JK@LGE23*412 GM���N�OP�',*QRST'U32��VWX>YZ 2004b�I[\']^123*4
�� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� ��
I. �Treatment��
�� ���������������� 184716.200 (101763.200) 268580.000 (133003.300) 174810.000 (52065.350) 115302.700 (63938.420)
���� �� 11.993 (0.546) 12.355 (0.575) 12.025 (0.343) 11.558 (0.513)
�� ��!������������� 8602.356 (6518.593) 13208.470 (8605.494) 7872.883 (4540.772) 5125.967 (3693.838)
���� �� 8.906 (0.541) 9.322 (0.580) 8.917 (0.317) 8.449 (0.450)
�� ��"������������� 1189.523 (925.486) 1683.446 (885.892) 1185.910 (960.680) 684.544 (553.553)
���� �� 6.911 (0.555) 7.281 (0.557) 6.962 (0.397) 6.432 (0.445)
��#���� 0.670 (0.470) 0.955 (0.208) 0.853 (0.354) 0.062 (0.241)
!�#��!� 0.570 (0.495) 0.955 (0.208) 0.643 (0.479) 0.051 (0.220)
"�#��"� 0.517 (0.500) 0.952 (0.214) 0.520 (0.500) 0.066 (0.248)
II. ������� ����$%&'()* 0.539 (0.210) 0.562 (0.224) 0.457 (0.152) 0.655 (0.220)
&'(+,&-.)* 0.649 (0.259) 0.725 (0.265) 0.694 (0.231) 0.492 (0.232)
&'(1/�0123456� 6.317 (2.779) 6.158 (1.932) 5.477 (1.269) 7.923 (4.304)
$%&'(1/�0123456� 9.297 (4.051) 8.871 (3.636) 9.037 (2.527) 10.185 (5.998)
&'(+,&-.1/�0123456� 9.384 (12.756) 6.638 (6.111) 7.888 (15.582) 14.622 (10.593)
III. ������
200374�829:!� 22.181 (3.080) 20.955 (2.507) 22.379 (2.852) 23.100 (3.557)
2003�2;!��:<"= 7.595 (1.478) 7.768 (0.972) 7.364 (1.507) 7.816 (1.773)
>? 0.019 (0.135) 0.005 (0.073) 0.019 (0.137) 0.031 (0.174)
7@ 36.384 (10.478) 39.932 (10.876) 34.324 (9.485) 36.280 (10.728)
7@2AB 1433.531 (817.149) 1712.707 (843.615) 1268.057 (722.751) 1431.259 (864.048)
CD7� 10.772 (9.115) 15.274 (11.074) 8.996 (7.444) 9.202 (7.840)
CD7�2AB 199.105 (272.570) 355.814 (355.263) 136.310 (189.667) 146.086 (228.378)
47EFGH 0.022 (0.148) 0.006 (0.079) 0.019 (0.137) 0.045 (0.207)
IFH 0.706 (0.456) 0.775 (0.418) 0.798 (0.402) 0.477 (0.500)
JKGLH 0.147 (0.354) 0.160 (0.367) 0.116 (0.320) 0.186 (0.390)
&'(+,-+,. 0.785 (0.411) 0.863 (0.344) 0.860 (0.347) 0.575 (0.495)
$%&'( 0.712 (0.453) 0.720 (0.449) 0.657 (0.475) 0.799 (0.401)
M"=%NO$%&'( 0.216 (0.412) 0.246 (0.431) 0.278 (0.448) 0.079 (0.271)
I"=%NO$%&'(� 0.074 (0.262) 0.036 (0.185) 0.064 (0.245) 0.132 (0.338)
PM 0.038 (0.190) 0.037 (0.190) 0.008 (0.089) 0.089 (0.284)
QR&'( 0.058 (0.233) 0.067 (0.250) 0.041 (0.198) 0.078 (0.268)
IV. �����STUV&'4 0.274 (0.446) 1.000 (0.000) 0.000 (0.000) 0.000 (0.000)
WTUV&'4 0.459 (0.498) 0.000 (0.000) 1.000 (0.000) 0.000 (0.000)
UVX&'4 0.267 (0.442) 0.000 (0.000) 0.000 (0.000) 1.000 (0.000)
YZ.� 17.956 (8.201) 18.511 (7.208) 22.495 (5.971) 9.580 (5.608)
YZ.���� �� 2.749 (0.585) 2.844 (0.396) 3.075 (0.287) 2.091 (0.595)
[\&']^2_`�aM&'� 0.521 (0.500) 0.253 (0.435) 0.753 (0.432) 0.399 (0.490)
[\&']^2_`�b!&'� 0.027 (0.162) 0.023 (0.150) 0.010 (0.100) 0.059 (0.236)
[\&']^2_`�c=&'� 0.020 (0.139) 0.000 (0.000) 0.013 (0.114) 0.051 (0.220)
[\&']^2_`�de5&'� 0.391 (0.488) 0.539 (0.499) 0.491 (0.500) 0.069 (0.254)
[\&']^2_`�fgh;"&'� 0.353 (0.478) 0.140 (0.347) 0.550 (0.498) 0.236 (0.425)
[\&']^2_`�ij5&'� 0.008 (0.091) 0.000 (0.000) 0.008 (0.089) 0.017 (0.131)
[\&']^2_`�k5l'� 0.214 (0.411) 0.000 (0.000) 0.196 (0.397) 0.467 (0.499)
mP"= 11.378 (0.962) 11.032 (0.628) 11.738 (0.822) 11.115 (1.220)
mP"=��� �� 2.431 (0.076) 2.399 (0.057) 2.460 (0.076) 2.413 (0.074)
19757nopqT 0.243 (0.429) 0.572 (0.495) 0.141 (0.348) 0.080 (0.272)
19757rs198572=pqT 0.491 (0.500) 0.343 (0.475) 0.699 (0.459) 0.285 (0.452)
19857rs199572=pqT 0.162 (0.368) 0.035 (0.183) 0.084 (0.277) 0.426 (0.495)
19957njpqT 0.105 (0.306) 0.051 (0.219) 0.076 (0.265) 0.209 (0.407)
tu24-vw�xu� 0.262 (0.440) 0.047 (0.212) 0.354 (0.478) 0.322 (0.468)
&'434yz{|}_`2-~ 0.753 (0.432) 0.865 (0.342) 0.975 (0.156) 0.255 (0.436)
wP�1 0.015 (0.121) 0.000 (0.000) 0.026 (0.159) 0.011 (0.104)
3456��yz��0�5� 0.940 (0.396) 1.046 (0.404) 0.955 (0.335) 0.623 (0.454)
3456��yz��1-2�5� 1.119 (0.297) 1.177 (0.288) 1.188 (0.212) 0.834 (0.343)
3456��yz��3�5� 1.028 (0.286) 0.971 (0.273) 1.147 (0.213) 0.782 (0.307)
3456��yz��4�n�5� 1.042 (0.379) 0.958 (0.351) 1.175 (0.304) 0.800 (0.454)
����� STUV&'4 WTUV&'4 UVX&'4
(n=1,095)
�5�1: ������� ���������������
(n=4,103) (n=1,125) (n=1,883)
� +������� �234��56789:;<=�
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
13
� �:PIQR,SK;n��,lm&'K[\n=T�Bê)*{[V�'(�)*+�
��)*+���'()*+,��yª�^$3=4)*{fg)��,[V���T�
�'(��# 7 ���¬ªÕß��3�,,�'(�)*+�� 5 �T¡ª�^$3=4
)*{¦k_�,-,p����'()*+,¬���)*+x����ª5,g�
º^$3=,:!2�Bê)*{Ë)*{fg)��¦k_�,Ò�p������
�'(�'(�)*+,�:±ª�^$3=4
� ��2_xÆ:�)*+,JMN:x^$�¬�ìíg°��������5,3ku
i��ªi,56�Ó¨/0���34¸^$�lm&'�2_PIQR,S,�3��
m3:)*+,JMN,�3:x=�,�,i��=3��S,y3����ìí,x�
y3��)*+KêëWT2$56n=×À:�=6T�&>F�'¨Á!MqR�:¾
½n=�3�,iK45:6O2$Ǽn=>Å��=466���&>F�'¨Á!M
qRK��Z:��2_���)*+,JMN:x=PIQR,S,�3K�þn=_#
:�treatment effect modelKL3=(Barnow, et.al. (1981))4
� 6,7H@��f, 2½,8i�G��^$3=4
(1) iii
l
iwDVZ +++=
''*
λγω � where l=1,2
(2) ii
l
iiiDZXY εδβαϕ ++++=
'''
where i
ε , i
w 9 ( )ρ,σ,σ0,0,N2
w
2
ε
�
� 66�(1), Zi
l*
�ìí�&'x��y3iÒÆi�6,�%, treatment���=13
46,
ìí�pK�Xn=_#,RhÕpT2$�Vi�WO�ãä�,jãp�h*�i�)*{
fg,���BêËABêT3^_���,�ý�Ò,�ZûW���:�ðãO��
�+�6b�z-�u$3=PIQRé7��¿À/EI�Ò��Þ,����êën=
��,ûWK�Þ�3=4j_i
D �)*+,JMNO,/EIÕpK;n4
� ¦¬��X8(2), Yi����T,���,&'Z�SK;n����=466��(1)�
��,R:@�Bê)*{[V�)*{fg)��[V�T(2)���¦k_�,��p
����{��Bê)*{�)*{fg)�����=4YiK�Xn=_#,RhÕpT2
$�i
X ��X8�1�, ViT�Â:��;2_�ûWË��ûWK;n4Z
i
l
�ìí�`
I:&'x�y3�%Ko1s�&'�f,�%Ko0sTn=/EIÕp��=14
4(1)T(2)
��X�u=<Ó^IJI��Xp�,ωTϕ�éRhÕp,|p��= ,,,, βαλγ �+δ �
13
Treatment��������� ��������������������������� !
"#�$%&'()�*+,-(.14 /01�23�4526�7(��8�9:;<�����=>?�@*A-BC�7(�DE&'(.
FGF�HIJ�KLM'NOPQ=R"STU�VW�X'�Y�RZ����[����\U;��
]^�7()��_`a"b&G";c%d��Noguchi, Shimizutani and Suzuki (2003a,b)��e1�fg-
(�=>?�@*hi-(Nj"����]^"(/01�klmno�pqZr?*stF;u'v
;&;�.wxy�������z�� �G<{G*|}b~6�-(��>��������(1)�
"d�%�/01�23�4526�8�9:*����6*��-(Nj�}b~6 Vi�F%��FN
Nj��=>?�@*��-(����2��|}b~6�F%)'&*��-'v causality�����P
(���))����;GcN.
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
14
=°�,i
w Ti
ε ��=4
� 2i2�)*{��ìí�&'x��y3��T&'�f,��:Ó¨/0:��k$
�u�3��X8(1), Zi
l*
�=>�u�34¸^$�(3),xÆ:�`I,=>�u_ì
íHIJK?RhÕpT2�NGQ@ 7H@��An=4
(3) Zi
l
=1 if Zi
l*
is greater that or equal to zero )(''
iii
DVw λγ +≤−
Zi
l
=0 if Zi
l*
is less than zero )(''
iii
DVw λγ +>− where l=1,2
� 66����X8�3�, Zi
l
T�X8(2),?RhÕpi
Y T,åV,�:B�bCKDX
2$�ñE:x=���XK]Æ4�X8(2), Zi
l
:(3)��X�u_ìí�pKop2$
i
D :½3$�vn=T�)*+,JMN�PIQR,SK;n Yi:$�=�����3��
�X�u_i
D ,|pλTβ KF<%ß®_�,:�2���X�u_i
D ,|pδ KÑ�_
%�*T�=4
� ÷ 5å2����deK;2$3=4÷ 5å2,�æ����T��'()*+�/æ�
��T'(�)*+�f��'(T'(�)*+TK[\2$3=4)*+,JMN
,/EI���æ����'()*+KGTn=/EI�/æ�+fæ�'(�)*+K
GTn=/EI��=4¥ 2H�éRhÕpK�¥ 3H� Log-likelihood�¥ 4H� Zi
l
,|
pβ �¥ 5H�i
D ,|pδ �¥ 6H��X8(1)T(2) ,de:��¬���u_)*+,
JMNO/EI�PIQR:$�=��K;2$3=15
4
� jk��æ,��)*+T��'()*+K[\n=T�Bê)*{[V�)*{fg
)��[V����Z:���°��342i2�)*{�Bê)*{�)*{fg)�
�¦k_�,p+��p�}=T�h�i:��'()*+���ª�5,g�º^$
3=4øV�}_xÆ:�ogplmqNGIrs���Tr������)*+���'
()*+K��^$3_42i2�3^_Þ&>F�'¨Á!MqRK��n=T©2t
��'()*+,¬�º^$3=4�:�/æ,��)*+T'(�)*+T,[\���
±ª,������)*+,¬�x��u$3=4j_�fæ,��'()*+T'(�
)*+T,[\�����'(�'(�)*+K��^$3=6T�ßi=4
� o���,SqNGIrs�h�i:�^_6T����'()*+,PIQR,S�
ñ��u$;����)*+�'(�)*+,��5u:�3$3=T3Æg��=4og
plmqNGIrs���Tr��:;3$������'()*+K��^$3_42
i2ogplmqNGIrs������3ku,JMN,)*+K5IiT3Æ!Mq
RK��2$3�34o���,SqNGIrs:x=de��h;Z:&>F�'¨Á!
MqRK��2_�%����,S:Edn=Tr��:;3$����'()*+,z
15 ��[���*�u(Nj"����������������;<������S:*�N-���
7(.))���Treatment effect model���"$Nc%� (2)����~6 Yi����S:"��*�E
%�;����F���[�RZ� � ¡=*Y�~6�F%�c%�(.)��"¢�%��£¤M
&"¥¦����7§{.
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
15
-n=PIQR,S,¬����)*+Ë'(�)*+K��=6TK;2$3=4
��������� ���������
� �:�PIQR,S,XYZlmK�j�$�7V��SK��2_�R �p
�quality-adjusted cost function�K�X2�)*+,JMN:x=-.UVW,�3Kh�i
:n=4
� �L�p,��:p=ø:�)*+,�R TrKh�i:2$;ª>Å��=4)*
����� Log-likelihood ����� � ������� ��
(t-���) (t-���) (t-���)
������� 862.639 -0.230 ** -0.039 ** 0.162
-(33.380) -(3.450) (0.770)
���� �!"�� 1409.603 0.034 ** -0.013 * -0.029
(2.220) -(1.700) -(0.136)
���1#$%&'()*+� -5784.146 1.230 ** -0.127 -0.646 **
(6.800) -(1.480) -(3.003)
�����1#$%&'()*+� -7711.989 1.669 ** -0.404 ** -1.477 **
(5.110) -(2.380) -(7.045)
���� �!"1#$%&'()*+� -10815.5 5.411 ** 0.253 -0.822 **
(3.610) (0.390) -(3.575)
����� Log-likelihood ����� ��,����� ��
(t-���) (t-���) (t-���)
������� 460.934 0.199 ** 0.232 ** -1.398 **
(6.320) (7.080) -(46.057)
���� �!"�� 494.251 0.087 ** -0.075 ** -0.793 **
(2.860) -(2.360) -(26.996)
���1#$%&'()*+� -5755.953 -1.043 * 2.930 ** 11.478 **
-(1.750) (4.930) (388.837)
�����1#$%&'()*+� -6410.216 -6.580 ** -2.050 ** 58.618 **
-(10.410) -(3.000) (1841.264)
���� �!"1#$%&'()*+� -7185.742 5.466 ** 14.580 ** -26.645 **
(5.090) (12.220) -(958.658)
����� Log-likelihood ����� ��,����� ��
(t-���) (t-���) (t-���)
������� 686.056 0.101 ** 0.234 ** -0.321 **
(4.300) (9.870) -(7.914)
���� �!"�� 539.809 0.194 ** 0.025 -0.994 **
(6.640) (0.870) -(24.443)
���1#$%&'()*+� -7654.655 3.801 ** 7.046 ** -10.003 **
(21.250) (25.160) -(313.924)
�����1#$%&'()*+� -8731.182 -2.205 ** 0.762 12.763 **
-(4.170) (1.390) (310.034)
���� �!"1#$%&'()*+� -11408.796 -16.335 ** -5.724 ** 75.711 **
-(15.050) -(3.960) (2173.928)
� 1. �������� ��������������������� !"#$%&
2. ** �5%'(�*10%'(#)*#$%+,-./&
� ��-.��,
��5�2������ ��������Treatment��������������
/ ��-.
� ��
/ ��-.��,
� �������� �������� ��������� ������� !"#$%&'
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
16
+,�-�R :��ìí|J�2K|���¡ãä�[V, 3 ½,ÅL��¬ª��2
$3=4¿ 6ü1��éæ�O:ii=¦k_�,�R K��LM×�,éèi�2_
ó8¿��=�éêÙëmØìí�2003��4ð�i���)*+�-�,�b�®i�,
)*¨�Ì��N�,�b�ð�+�¬�«Â|i�,��í�5uvu{|, 4 b,G
k½��ji�ßu=T2$3=4'()*+,)*¨��¦�¿À��u~�����
���� ��=4
� jk�ãä�¡3ÒO�¦�_�,)*{p�±36Ti��¡ãä�Ò)*:
ii=�R �y34¸^$�6Æ2_�R °,��b����M×b��=)*lm
�c,�b�:PQ�u=42i22K|:x^$�ð�ix��y3¤2,»ð�iK�
X2�5u�2K|�R®bT2$�R Ky#$3=6T:�=�b ,»ð,Ñ�b�4
����� ����2003�� ��
��������������
�� �����������������
��� !"�#$
�% &'(���)*+
�&,-�� !"�#$
�. ��/01���� !"��234
�5 67�89
��� !"�#$
�: ;<=>?@A��/
�BCD#$
;
<
=
E
E
F
�
�
G
H
I
&
'
(
�
�
�
�
�
( )�*���+,-./01234(5
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
17
��:�w:��)*+:�2$��)*lm�X#�u$3=ìí|Jx��ãSìí
,×T������6,U�b�Ë��2K|,�R®bT2$�R Ky#$3=�a,
�b�4j_�2K|:x^$��'()*¨K��:¢V2$3=�d ,)*¨¢Vb�4
6,_#�L��`I:E�n=mg��`I:ii=�R :[�$¡ªW��u�
'()*+KLn=�%x���'(�)*+KLn=�%,¬�)*¨�¦�:y
3�éêÙëmØìí(2003)�4_ò2��� ���'(�)*+,)*¨�'()*+
:[�$¡ªW��u$;��6,g�7�T�¬ª��^$3=16
4
66�L3=,��¥ 3 V�Rh2_o��:;<=)*PIQR�Ís,EFGHI
J��=4Æ)*,�=�,K¬�)*+?IR,P¨N@p��%� 599 i+�Æî
��)*+ 130 i+���'()*+ 153 i+�'(�)*+ 316 i+���=4ìí�
R K��n=_#:>�)*{,HIJ����)*+i� 1,125���'()*+
i� 1,883�'(�)*+i� 1,095��=4
� ÷ 6ü1 ��7��YK;2$3=4jk�\�-�,&'K}=T17
���'()*+
�'(�)*+:[�$ 7Xt318
4\�-���\ìíY�ìí��,Z��[�\]
k�ABê[�.$�^[«ÎFí�X_�,%���+Z���,�LK%�2
_�,��=4
16 ¨©ª"du(��Y��[���«��� 23,000¬G& 25,000¬®�M'%�(.¯°;�&�
s¦�±������[���Y��[���«�²�"¢�%�Q=R�³&';�.17 VW��[�����6� 1´�µ;�Nj¶YF%�(.18 ·¸¹6z�^"(.
�� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� ����
I. ������� * 11,500,000 (25,700,000) 8,096,000 . 21,900,000 (35,300,000) 3,191,236 (6,346,043)
�� � 7,417,584 (17,500,000) 6,339,000 . 15,000,000 (24,800,000) 1,966,776 (3,905,783)
���� 2,059,860 (1,821,970) 3,543,304 (1,589,353) 3,764,135 (1,026,246) 624,412 (610,918)
� ������ * 3,785,872 (11,200,000) 1,757,000 . 7,020,742 (15,900,000) 1,176,782 (2,991,273)
�������� * 14.872 1.793 15.907 . 16.108 (1.061) 13.876 (1.639)
�� ������� 14.331 1.945 15.662 . 15.707 (1.131) 13.335 (1.801)
���������� 13.124 3.722 14.229 (3.448) 15.004 (1.271) 11.758 (4.069)
� ������������ * 13.898 1.514 14.379 . 14.824 (1.153) 13.111 (1.334)
II. ��������� 1,047.342 776.207 1,619.025 (382.535) 1,224.572 (788.417) 690.151 (710.951)
������ 6.781 0.626 7.359 (0.257) 7.019 (0.353) 6.385 (0.595)
III. ����0�� !"� 4.359 3.512 4.715 (2.468) 7.197 (3.216) 2.386 (2.789)
1-2�� !"� 25.116 13.921 29.675 (10.939) 34.704 (10.069) 17.506 (12.729)
3�� !"� 15.460 8.971 18.500 (6.618) 19.664 (5.791) 11.757 (9.784)
4��#� !"� 23.975 16.115 22.878 (11.192) 29.320 (11.899) 20.704 (19.550)
IV. ����$%�& 11.216 1.033 10.967 (0.635) 11.648 (0.979) 11.108 (1.127)
V. ��������'()*� 4.484 1.884 5.746 (1.496) 5.366 (1.394) 3.538 (1.717)
+,-./)*� 11.397 2.177 11.500 (1.566) 12.353 (1.384) 10.892 (2.522)
01�234*� 2.796 1.951 2.362 (1.609) 4.536 (1.662) 2.133 (1.685)
5�6�*� 1.187 1.081 1.238 (1.018) 1.758 (1.214) 0.889 (0.914)
�7*� 19.865 5.014 20.846 (3.736) 24.013 (3.526) 17.453 (4.627)
�1. * �������� ���������2. ����������� !"�# $��%&'�()�*+�,-$�.��/01�234$5678�9:34;<�=>?/��@A�2BCDE�/FG�/�HI7�/JK�/LM�N�/OPQG�=>?/RSTUV2WXTV9:YZTV?�()�
�6-1:�������� ���
�� ����� ������� �� ���(n=599) (n=130) (n=153) (n=316)
� )�*6+,-7�89:;<=>9?5
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
18
� �:�\�-�,Æî,\Z��\ìíYTìí��,Z�,%��K�P¨N@
p,5t^_��)*+T�[\n=T���'()*+,\Z����)*+T[\
2$��`y3�# 5���,,��Õß��34¦¬�6Æ2_'()*+,\Z�
�'(�)*+:[�=T�ù:y34
� �:ÅLmgK}=T��.?IR,ìí���)*+,¬���'()*+x��#
34��y34¦¬���'()*+�'(�)*+:[�$ 70�z�y34��:��Ï
��T2$ãäO,��pK}=T���'()*+,¬����Ë'(�)*+T[\
n=T�h�i:¡ãä�K±ª�<pu$3=4ð�X#=oñ¡�is��¡ãä�
ÒO�¦�_�,)*{p�±36Ti��� ��p����)*+x����)
*+,�R �yª�=4'(�)*+�3ku,ãä���<pu��p���346
u�[\Zñòó,'(�)*+�±36TT�%Z��=4��wWK}=T�\:O
�����)*+,Æ��`¸34PIQR,S��:½3$��¥ 4V�.a2_og
plmqNGIrs,deKL3=4
� 66����a/ÉÓRÊT Ó¨RGÉÊ, 2 ï�,�R �pKL3$UVWKX
YZ:lmn=4Mocan (1995, 1997)�Ë8n=xÆ:�A-n|�ýp2$3$opm
g���Z:¤X�u$3=�������px���L�p,¬�x� relevant ��=19
4
¸^$UVWlm,]T2$�L�p,��KL3=4
��:L3=¯|Z�X8¾��f,T;���=4
(4) uKQXYPC
k
kk
j
jj
i
ii++++++= ∑∑∑ λδγβαα lnlnln
0
(5)
∑∑∑
∑∑∑∑∑∑
+++++
++++=
mi k
kiik
k l
lkkl
k
kk
i j
jiij
i
ii
uKQXYP
YYYPPPC
λμηρ
δγβαα
lnln
lnln
2
1
lnlnln
2
1
lnln0
where 0,1 === ∑∑∑j
jk
j
ij
i
iρβα and
jiijββ = .
66��?RhÕp�)*�R �!p���=4789���\ìíY�\Z��\
�-�, 3½,o)*�R sKL3=4RhÕp:��lnP�÷�u=�.�d÷�u=
ÅLopmg�\�-�,�%:�>¨J@�R K�©��lnY �ãäO��p,!p�
�=4X �\:O��Ë)*+,JMNO/EI��¿À/EI�Q �øV�Rh2_)
*PIQR,S����=4
� ��¬��a/ÉÓRÊ���8(4)�:½3$�ññBR��=4 Ó¨RGÉÊ
���8�5��:½3$��Shepard ,>¨bKL3$�,�6�8Kc¬���,UVW
Ky#=_#:�SUR (seeming uncorrelated regression) KL3$(5)T(6)K��:�Xn=4
19 ����������� ��(dual)�������������������� �!"
�#$Mocan (1995, 1997)%&'$
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
19
�6� ∑∑ ++=
k
kik
j
jijiiYPs lnln ρβα
� ÷ 6å2��a/ÉÓRÊ�R �p,��deK;2$3=45uvu,Õp,deT
��Z��W:½3$���Ð�U�,de�¹�u$3=4ÅLmgK2=T�ìí
\Y�y3Ò�R �y34�Ï��K2=T�1å2 æ�,|p��¬34j_���
Z:����3�,,�\:O���¸3Ò��R �y34PIQR,S��K}=
T���Z:����3�,,�;;©ÛNÓR��=4
� 6,xÆ�ÕpK�¨ GI@2$����)*+/EI�\ìíY,�åR��NÓ
R�����=4��de:x=T�\ìíYK?RhÕp:2_�%���)*+�'
(�)*+T[\n=T# 2 X���R �y34¦¬���'()*+/EI,|p�
NÓRò����Z:�����34½j����'()*+T'(�)*+,��UV
W,g����Z:���°�}�u�34
� ÷ 6å3� Ó¨RGÉÊ�R �pKL3_de��=45uvu,|p,de��7
Z:÷ 6å2T� ��=42i2� Ó¨RGÉÊ�L�p,de��\ìíYK?Rh
Õp:2_�%:����)*+T��Þ���'()*+��'(�)*+T[\n=
T 2 X���R y������)*+���'()*+x����:AUVZ��=4
¦¬�\Z�Ë\�-�K?RhÕp:2_�%:����'()*+T'(�)*+
,�:�UVW,g���Z:���°��34
� 6,xÆ:�UVW,=g�����)*+�'(�)*+:[�$h�i:AUVZ
��=4��'()*+T'(�)*+,�:�� Ó¨RGÉÊ�L�pK��2_�
%,¦�K3$�UVW,g:;3$��Z:����3��34¥ 4 V�¥ 5 V�l
�
� �� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� ���� �� ����
II. ������
��� 0.411 (0.068) ** 0.411 (0.067) ** 0.864 (0.227) ** 0.869 (0.225) ** 0.763 (0.192) ** 0.768 (0.190) **
III. ���
0��������� 0.155 (0.074) ** 0.152 (0.073) ** 0.233 (0.244) 0.276 (0.238) 0.083 (0.230) 0.095 (0.224)
1-2��������� 0.315 (0.070) ** 0.314 (0.069) ** 0.514 (0.251) ** 0.455 (0.242) * 0.442 (0.225) * 0.447 (0.217) **
3��������� 0.164 (0.081) ** 0.166 (0.080) ** 0.289 (0.289) 0.296 (0.287) 0.233 (0.262) 0.223 (0.259)
4����������� 0.187 (0.065) ** 0.188 (0.065) ** -0.017 (0.226) -0.002 (0.224) 0.138 (0.206) 0.140 (0.204)
IV. ��
�������� 1.208 (0.570) ** 1.234 (0.564) ** � � � � � � � �
�������� 0.695 (0.504) 0.736 (0.488) 1.753 (1.491) 1.335 (1.427) 0.483 (1.368) 0.596 (1.296)
�� !��� 0.304 (0.412) 0.322 (0.377) 0.569 (1.253) 0.548 (1.167) 1.570 (1.141) 1.701 (1.055)
V. ��������
"#$%� 0.010 (0.016) � � 0.051 (0.059) � � -0.015 (0.055) � �
&'()*$%� 0.012 (0.015) � � -0.036 (0.052) � � 0.009 (0.048) � �
+,-./0%� 0.014 (0.019) � � 0.008 (0.062) � � 0.016 (0.056) � �
1-%� -0.007 (0.024) � � 0.032 (0.085) � � 0.048 (0.079) � �
�2%� � � 0.009 (0.007) � � 0.007 (0.023) � � 0.011 (0.021)
34 7.921 (1.144) ** 7.905 (1.053) ** 4.930 (3.530) 4.767 (3.261) 3.505 (3.195) 3.053 (2.920)
56789:;<=��
>1. ** ?5%@�A*?10%@�BCDBEFGHIJKLMNO���-��-PQ?RSTUVFL
W2.�����-XYZ[�\]̂ _̀ aVbcAXYZ[defVbL
0.623 0.6300.874 0.875 0.570 0.576
�6-2: ���������� ����
�ghi�4%� �jkl*�4%� ����*�����ghi(�2%� ����*���� �mnl*�4%�
� �������� ������� ��
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
20
m2_xÆ:�PIQR,S�������'()*+���)*+�=3�'(�)*
+:[�$yfS,PIQRKz-2$;��'(�)*+,PIQR,S� !Z:¡
34¦¬�ìí:½3$����'()*+���'()*+�'(�)*+,��y34
½j����'()*+,op�R �x�y3�,,���:S,y3PIQRKz-
2$3=4¦¬�'(�)*+� !Z:�R D��=�,,�5uò<PIQR,S
�yª�34
� '(�)*+,PIQR,S�¡3:�iiß�k�UVW,=g�}_�%:���
�'()*+T[�$gh��3i��=3�©2tx�UVZ��=,����¥#Z
�)*+,-:;3$�x�¡ìí�x���3)*{�PIQRKz-2$3=i��
�tÆ4'(�)*+���Ab�ìíK�i^$Ab�)*{Kå)n=6T��¬�
3T3Æ@`KPQ2$3=4��:�x�Dm�)*¨�L�¬=)*PIQRKÇ
Å��'(�)*+:ã#$3=T3ÆÇÅ�,Ž��tÆ4x�y3PIQRKã#
=ÇÅ��x�y3)*¨K�i^$'()*+KL2xÆTn=,:!2�)*¨�
Dªñ��,¬ªPIQRKã#=ÇÅ��'(�)*+KL2$3=(0W�y34
j_�)*PIQR,S,lm�Ë82_xÆ:�«�¬Ë¦®¯°,±3�����
²³�)*PIQRKã#=µI¶�yª�'(�)*+�5,µI¶:·�$3=T�
3�=46,gK��:£h2$3ª_#:��-.Pò<��ª�M×2$3=)*¨
�
� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ��� �� ���
II. ������/III. ���
������� 4.166 (1.033) ** 4.101 (0.996) ** 2.685 (3.949) 2.613 (3.747) 3.639 (3.607) 2.711 (3.449)
[**]^2 -0.221 (0.075) ** -0.217 (0.073) ** -0.182 (0.325) -0.183 (0.312) -0.184 (0.259) -0.120 (0.248)
���������[c] -0.550 (0.891) -0.498 (0.876) 1.405 (3.524) 1.484 (3.454) -1.063 (2.956) -0.495 (2.874)
[c]^2 0.007 (0.052) 0.009 (0.052) 0.244 (0.193) 0.246 (0.192) 0.111 (0.200) 0.131 (0.197)
1�2��������[d] 2.201 (0.978) ** 2.247 (0.967) ** -0.220 (5.966) -0.669 (5.913) 2.703 (3.370) 2.348 (3.257)
[d]^2 0.152 (0.056) ** 0.156 (0.056) ** 0.282 (0.250) 0.266 (0.246) 0.103 (0.248) 0.147 (0.241)
3��������[e] 0.145 (1.249) 0.130 (1.242) -10.070 (5.502) * -9.956 (5.483) * -10.962 (4.798) ** -10.863 (4.751) **
[e]^2 0.196 (0.091) ** 0.197 (0.091) ** -0.185 (0.435) -0.169 (0.431) -0.011 (0.385) -0.020 (0.381)
4� ��������[f] -0.529 (0.927) -0.559 (0.919) 7.735 (3.691) ** 7.737 (3.671) ** 8.303 (3.269) ** 8.300 (3.250) **
[f]^2 0.091 (0.043) ** 0.085 (0.042) ** 0.214 (0.220) 0.200 (0.217) 0.408 (0.203) ** 0.379 (0.200) *
[c]*[d] 0.001 (0.115) -0.009 (0.114) -0.627 (0.467) -0.566 (0.458) -0.064 (0.536) -0.142 (0.524)
[c]*[e] -0.032 (0.121) -0.033 (0.120) -0.548 (0.484) -0.531 (0.481) -0.844 (0.441) * -0.792 (0.437) *
[c]*[f] 0.019 (0.091) 0.023 (0.091) 0.980 (0.391) ** 0.927 (0.387) ** 0.968 (0.357) ** 0.926 (0.352) **
[d]*[e] -0.051 (0.107) -0.053 (0.106) -0.015 (0.451) -0.060 (0.448) 0.275 (0.402) 0.245 (0.397)
[d]*[f] -0.097 (0.097) -0.094 (0.095) -0.458 (0.381) -0.393 (0.377) -0.667 (0.360) * -0.636 (0.354) *
[e]*[f] -0.155 (0.093) * -0.156 (0.092) * -0.022 (0.438) -0.014 (0.435) -0.254 (0.389) -0.228 (0.386)
[c]*[**] 0.109 (0.131) 0.103 (0.129) -0.162 (0.516) -0.179 (0.508) 0.087 (0.436) 0.029 (0.429)
[d]*[**] -0.361 (0.143) ** -0.368 (0.141) ** 0.094 (0.907) 0.150 (0.901) -0.311 (0.456) -0.280 (0.444)
[e]*[**] -0.025 (0.202) -0.022 (0.200) 1.779 (0.878) ** 1.766 (0.875) ** 1.827 (0.781) ** 1.810 (0.774) **
[f]*[**] 0.132 (0.150) 0.140 (0.149) -1.241 (0.605) ** -1.251 (0.601) ** -1.296 (0.536) ** -1.290 (0.532) **
IV. ��
�� ����� 1.700 0.653 ** 1.679 (0.647) ** � � � � � � � �
�� ����� 1.293 0.593 ** 1.326 (0.586) ** 1.440 (2.018) 1.101 (1.983) 0.603 1.860 0.665 (1.823)
��������� 0.481 0.386 0.463 (0.348) 0.984 (1.356) 0.885 (1.238) 2.152 1.190 * 2.256 (1.090) **
V. ��������
����� -0.001 0.015 � � 0.049 (0.061) � � -0.025 (0.056) � �
��� !��� 0.016 0.014 � � -0.052 (0.053) � � -0.003 (0.049) � �
"#$%&'�� 0.005 0.018 � � -0.023 (0.064) � � -0.010 (0.057) � �
($�� 0.007 0.022 � � 0.073 (0.085) � � 0.098 (0.078) � �
�)�� � � 0.007 (0.006) � � -0.002 (0.023) � � 0.004 (0.021)
*+ -7.214 (3.628) ** -6.915 (3.551) -0.646 (13.462) -0.015 (13.124) -9.196 (12.403) -6.268 (12.083)
,-./012345�
�1. ** �5%���*�10%��������������� !"#$%&�%'(�)*+,-��
.2./012�%3456�789:;<-=>�3456?@A-=�
�6-3:���������� ��
BCDE4FG� BHIJ*4FG� ����*����BCDE(BKFG� ����*���� BLMJ*4FG�
0.653 0.6570.899 0.900 0.585 0.588
� ��������������� �
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
21
K�©ÇÅP,HIJ�/(Æ��tÆ4
�����
� �� ������������������ !�"#$%&����'()*+,
-./0�123456��789���� :;<=)*+>?@,AB:CD�EF
GHIJKL3$�)*+,JMNO:PIQR,ST-.UVW,XYZ[\K]^_4
� `abc,de��f,g�h�i:�^_4
(1)jk�)*PIQR,SKXYZ:lmn=_#:�ogplmqNGIrsKL3_T
6t�5uvu,JMN,)*+��5uvuwX,b��x�y3S,PIQRKz-
2$3=4{|T2$}u~���Ëf7,opK;noTr��s����)*+�
!Z:ñ��u$3=�,,�oCyuvwZ��so±#,²Wso5,ú,PIQRs
,`õö_I���3ku����'()*+���)*+�'(�)*+,���PI
QR,S��u$3=4��:o���,SqNGIrs�lmn=T���'()*+
����,�����)*+K��^$3=6T�ßi^_4
(2)�:�6,PIQR,S��K�j�$�SK��2_�L�p�quality-adjusted cost
function�K��2�)*+,JMNO:-.UVWK[\n=T���)*+�'(�)
*+:[�$h�i:UVZ��3�,,���'()*+T'(�)*+,�:�UV
W,g:;3$��Z:����3��34
� ñ´:789�¹�u_deT��àtÔ 10� ,P¨N@�� ]�bcK]^_
éêÙëmØìí�2003�,deK[\2_34éêÙëmØìí(2003)���jk�àá
j�:;3$���)*+���'()*+:[�$�R y:�ii�k�PIQ
R,S� !Z:¡ª�UVZ��36T�h�i:�u_46,g��789�h�i
:2_��,)*PIQR��:�5,jj�$�j=4��)*+,�R ¡¢K¿^
$3ª6T������ !£¤,_#,¥¦§��=6T�«U2$3=4
� �:�'()*+T'(�)*+K[\n=T�éêÙëmØìí�2003�����P¨
N@���3����'(�)*+:[�$���'()*+�x�S,y3)*PIQ
RKz-2$3=6T���:���'()*+�±Y,��íK�<Ü^$3=_#:�
L��E�n=mg�©2t'(�)*+x��¡ª�5,_#�'()*+:ÇÅ�
¥/2����� !K%&¾�®$3=T3ÆdeK¹_4�� ,�%��6uT�
!�Z:�'(�)*+,)*¨�&'Z:2u~�©2t'()*+Kf�^$3=T
�u$;��)*¨�x�Dªñ��,¬ªPIQRKã#=ÇÅ��'(�)*+K
L2$3=(0W�y34'(�)*+��w:¹ô)*�·¸)*���Á¦�)*T
3^_g����)*+x��©2t�u$;��5Æ2_²³�)*PIQRKDm�
z-n=T3Æg����Z���Ke_2$3=4
� ú,JMN,)*+T[�_'(�)*+,L�,�0OË-,D{WÁC*´,
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
22
���Ò:½3$,lmK�½>Å��=��«�¬�32¦®¯°,±3�����
²³�)*PIQR´,µI¶�yª�5u:'(�)*+�·�$3=T3Æõk�P
Q2$3=,��tÆ46u�)*PIQR,SK{|Z:y#=T��:�L�,µ
I¶:�^_)*PIQR,±Â¾K¿^$3ª>Å��=6TK;l2$3=4�ît
Þ���,Ë8�&')*¨:��3$;��'()*+,)*¨�·0M×�¤#�u
$3=4¡+¹�º:»¼2½½���)*+,UV¾K¿��i½)*PIQR,±Â
¾KÃ#$3ª6T�ÄÅòtÆ4
���� !
������2002�m��_n��:;<=_nPIQR,¥o�lm�ix:�n=9p
qr.
����Á���2004a�o�� :;<=)*PIQR,S�+-.UVW,,-n|
O[\�EFGHIJ:x=.as��������� ��������
��������� No.98.
����Á���2004b�o�� :;<=)*{ìí,¤XŽ�,-n|O,ìí
NGÔsM@TA-ìíN>Eq0,EFGHIJ:x=.as������
��� ����������������� No.99.�
����Á���2004c�mt�Á)*PIQR��,,Îbc�EFGHIJ:x=`
u£hTØìzvràw,Îx9Í.
¡ñy%Á¢£z�2002�o)*PIQR-.,,Îbcå'(Á'(�)*+,[\ås
JCER� DISCUSSION� PAPER No.83.
¡ñy%Á¢£z�2003�o,-n|O:2_)*PIQR,Så'(Á'(�)*+,
[\bcs�{d|}~m21¯�,ÍÎ)�,�¶TØìr¥ 8��àw,Îx9
Í.
D)��2003�m¿�}=��,,Îr���.
éêÙëmØìí�2003�m)*PIQR��,õkTí!åo)*PIQRmg:�n=
XYÎs9pqår.
éêÙ,ÎÍÎ\%XY+�2004�m�� :;<=)*PIQR-.,`abc―o��
:;<=)*PIQR��XYÎs9pq―r.
Á���1996�o)*PIQR@4,õkTí!s� ��������� Vol.32, No.2,
158-166�I�.
ÃH�B�2001�oô7,)*+Øì,õkTí!å,ÎwZbcs� !"#� vol.125,
No.6, 69-86�I�.
Barnow, B.S., G. G. Cain, and A.S. Goldberger (1981). “Issues in the Analysis of Selection Bias.” In
E.W. Stromsdorfer and G. Farkas, eds., Evaluation Studies Review Annual 5, Department
of Economics, University of Wisconsin, Madison.
�����������
����
����������������������������������������
23
Blau, D. M. (1999). "The Effect of Child Care Characteristics on Child Development," Journal of
Human Resources, 34(4), pp.786-822.
Blau, D. M. and Hagy, A. P. (1998). "The Demand for Quality in Child Care,” Journal of Political
Economy, 106(1), pp.104-146.
Blau, D. and Mocan, H. N. (2002). “The Supply of Quality in Child Care Centers,” Review of
Economics and Statistics, 84 (3), pp.483-496.
Chipty, T. and Witte, A.D. (1994). "Economic Effects of Quality Regulations in the Daycare
Industry," NBER Working Paper, No. 4953.
Hagy, A. P. (1998). "The Demand for Child Care Quality—An Hedonic Price Theory Approach,"
Journal of Human Resources, 33 (3), pp.683-710.
Mocan, H. N. (1995). “Quality Adjusted Cost Functions for Child Care Centers,” American
Economic Review Papers and Proceedings 85 (2), pp. 409-413.
Mocan, H. N. (1997). “Cost function, Efficiency and Quality in Day Care Centers,” Journal of
Human Resources, 32 (4), pp. 861-891
Mocan, H. N. and Tekin, E. (2000). “Nonprofit Sector and Part-time Work: An Analysis of
Employer-Employee Matched Data of Child Care Workers,” NBER Working Paper
No.7977.
Mukerjee, S. and Witte, A. D. (1991). “Measurement of Output and Quality Adjustment When
Hedonics Cannot be Used: An Illustration for the Day Care Industry,” NBER Working
Paper No.3771.
Mukerjee, S. and Witte, A. D. (1993). “Provision of Child Care: Cost Functions for Profit-Making
and Non-profit Day Care Centers,” Journal of Productivity Analysis 4(1-2), pp. 165-182.
Noguchi, H. and Shimizutani, S. (2003a). “Quality of Child Care in Japan: Evidence from
Micro-level Data,” ESRI Discussion Paper Series No.54, Economic and Social Research
Institute, Government of Japan.
Noguchi, H. and Shimizutani, S. (2003b). “Quality Adjusted Cost Function in Japanese Child Care
Market: Evidence from Micro-level Data,” ESRI Discussion Paper Series No.57,
Economic and Social Research Institute, Government of Japan.
Noguchi, H., Shimizutani, S. and Suzuki, W. (2003a). “Wage Determinants and Age Profiles in the
Japanese Child Care Industry: Evidence from Employee-level Data,” ESRI Discussion
Paper Series No.33, Economic and Social Research Institute, Government of Japan.
Noguchi, H., Shimizutani, S. and Suzuki, W. (2003b). “Nonprofit Wage Premiums in Japan's Child
Care Market: Evidence from Employer-Employee Matched Data,” ESRI Discussion Paper
Series No.34, Economic and Social Research Institute, Government of Japan.
����������������������������������������
����
����������������������������������������
����������������������������������������