الاعتراف وحجيته في الحكم القضائي
DESCRIPTION
الاعتراف وحجيته في الحكم القضائيTRANSCRIPT
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
tO d
w
wzUCI rJ(
b
wKOe bLWO Ub WFdA WOK bOL
WUA WFU
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
WbI
vK ? ?B? .u?I d?A UMOK e sb? UM - c b?L?(
t t vK rO?I* dB t s 5* 5*UFK WL? uF* u
bF 5FL
R rO?EM UJ_ tOK e UMO? bNU t?u q vU?F S
vK U?H??K bb? odD rN? r U??u u?I?( UM?K 5 U?O?(
WUd W?O? Wb U d{ n?F bF U?NU2 u?I(
i UUM* qB? bF WU? UCIU Wb XU UJ_ oO?D dA
v UCI b UCI UL XLE r U) q rKE lM UuB)
UNzUN UJ_ b UNO dEM ub UL w bF o( ZNM
dA l{u UN rJK UU?CI WIOI lzUu WdF? w{UI vK qO
w% w U?NAU? w{UI U?NOK b?L?FO U? UC?IK WO?d U?d nOM(
U l?b w 5LO Ud?NE c d U?NIu w W?UJ u?I(
WOdA U qzU s p dO o( VK&
pc UMO Z( r W_ bO u U WOdA dD b d
WU tKzU? w uKB t?UJ UNIH? l{ tO V t?O b
W9U YU W w t{d c Y q u c tIOD w w{UI
td tU d ndF _ Y*
UCI WOdA wU Y*
tUJ r UCI WO YU Y*
Y UJ r hOK w W9U)
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
U?O WF_ W?ON?IH Vc* 5 W?UI* ZNM u?{u* d w b?L?
U Xd? U?: t `?L? U0 `O?d? W?A?UM?* iF W_ r
wu( w ld* UB* X WM V v YU_ e
tIH s U?U dFM U{d t? ULO qLFK b oO?u Q
tb oO?I% tb vK dO? U p UMK 5 rOEF d?e w
5*UF bL( bBI s
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
_ Y*
td tU d ndF
tU d ndF
d?F d U? WU? UEH? o( UN! u d?? WG d?
qzU?* w d? qL?F? W?Ob* u?I?( w d qL?F?? vzUC?I
o(U dO d d o(U d d? s d WuML* UF_ WOzUM'
U d? qLF? t d? vK tKL wAU U? ddI d? v
t d oK
td w? rN? UF? WHK? UHd?F UN?IH t?d U?D d
dB UN{dF wHJ UNuLC w WUI UHdF w tOK Wd* tUJ
tH vK dOGK o u s U t WOHM( tdF
tzU kH tEHK jI tKzU vK Wb rJ Vu d tQ WOJU* tdd
-
&
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
t?H vK o h?A U? d? uQ? U?{ U?UM UHd?F d?
WGOB t dI* t dI* dI* d U sLCO dOG
U? u wFO?D hA qL?A t?OK d o( d?NE c u dI*U?
d{U( dBF w tO d U c U uMF* hA
VU u t d) tu t(UB d bB c hA u t dI*
t dI* o(
jI U*U hAK X" U q?LA dI* tM d c o( u t dI*
U?B?I s u?H?F? U?H u?I? U?O?_ ub qL?A? sbU? tM
s XU u dA Ud w uI( s p dO WUI* D d
W?Od?A WuMF* W?OU* d?_ uI? s U?HJ UeU? vU?F uI?
u?I?F d?zU? lO?U? U?U? qL?A d?O?? c?I WU?C?( V?MU?
dO UBI s uHF WFHA UI sb UI DU UUI
U2 U W?U s t?UI? uI U? kHKU o( s U? w WG?OB
_ uJU v?? UML?{ W?d? fH?M vK d?O?GK o( u?? vK b
e w UNc?# bM dJ? uJ UO U?O v WU( d?F w uJ
qOu? uJ lOU t?LK bF lO?HA uJ d?NLK UN?O i bM U?NuJ
uu*U t UM W#MN bF e uJ qOu bM
U? uJ b U?OzU?C d? vL? UC?I fK? w uJ b d?
WOdA U d bQ w{UIK qIM WU UEH UCI fK
dI U _ b?B VU `d cJ bB qL U? d
r YU b s U* d dCU UN?OK uF U0 UU tH vK
W36I LI X$(% L X$(% X$( #XY% Z>9X[; -\% ,$X0 8XSX #\ XM HV ]^ 8XX_'@ `5 J W3'
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
`U?B* VK vK qLF U?N V vK Wu? Wd?A fHM _ u? l
tO?K d( tzUM? U* V vK uDH U?N UL? Q UN?1 U l U?N
`d qIF S rNuI sd WKB U?bI tdD UHU h d S
Ud?C Uc t?H vK cJ q?UF _ cJ U?L? bF? bB VU?
d vCI0 te WKO UCI U O tOK W d uJO
d d
t dI* w d?I* w U d?A c dO"? d d w d?A
w
dA c r UBU dc WGOB w t dI* w
tuI? dJ uM: wB d? `B ?U UGU d?I* uJ s rK v
wB s kI?O v
rzUM s W s rKI l
dCK UU t Q* eOL* wB d qI
qIF v
uM:
QD) w s l tuI dJ* d `B ? U dI* uJ
tOK udJ U UOM
O! -'SX ,J W3' W36I ,& P41 W:a ,
56X$ 70 89:/; XXX);, -#XXB6 8XXXCXD , bcXP( , OXXX! 85XXP4 ,,& -'SX( ,Jd '$ UXXQXV , eX9f g\#XX ,Z/@
d H56IG HI 8CD89:/; , ?3X$X@ AX); , W3' W36I :8XX X( -0 XM i%XC j4 Z/@ XXX); ,&
-XCXE XC , -X#XB6 8XXXCXXD ,&
56X$ 7XX0'$ UXQXXV , bcXP( , OXX! 85XP4 ,& OXXX! -'SX ,
8:/@ kl ,& -'S( ,mVXXX@% & LXXYXXX HI% & ncXXXXX% & % #I^ *% o56XXX@ c\ AI p#X)X$I o56X@ c\ 8X1 q$9; 6X% r :-4XV#XQ pX% ,sG#X0X -9G HG ,&
p#_ Ct us W:a ,& )@ {9 -w#[
-
J
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
vK bB VU Ud q WLN? _ d w ULN dI* uJ bM u c UU0 rN tS? sb tu id* dQ cJ VU
sb* d? c WK?UM( iF bM wM_ id* d? U?NI?H iF
dG sb
uN: vK UCI cF d `B r uN U uK UuKF dI* uJ U?Nd? w U?d?B? U?H s lM?1 U0 t?OK u??? d?I* uJ
hA U0 tOK u; sb* tOHU
d{ rKF s u U s d `B ? U U dI* uJ
o( eK U d _ t oD c kHK vMF bBI r t sE
d fO eN
W?U??L? sL?{ uJ? W?UD* tM?J1 YO? UM?O?F? t d??I* uJ uJ p vK dH? WAU? WUN u?N uJ uB?
`B uu dO u qL( d S 5M'U uu oI t dI*
t dILK X" t dI* o( uJ Q qL(U U*U t pKL WOK t dILK uJ &v
d? qD tc S? d w d?I* qUF mU t? dI* cJ q?? r tc?? S? t t????? b t d??I* pK w? w qb
qD tS?? UJM nu Wd?( V?MU d? vM"??? `B
` q r tc S t dI* VcJ
dU? qD I u?I t d?ILK t dI* U?I? V uJ JUI? V U?O s dI* XJ S? tM d qU?F V? qL(
v J U?L _ `O? V vK tKL? sJ1 t_ `B uN?L'
U vK qL t_ `B tu w wFUA nu u U tUL s
bF U2 u?L? U "? uJ Q dA d?I UI t? dI* uJ WO_ WuMF* uI( UH uI d UI U Ud U
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
WU?N' l W?O? uJ w U?dB? w U?uKF t d?I* uJ dOH dI* s VKD uN:U d `B p b U U lOU
Ud WG tEH l oH U0
S t d?ILK uK2 o?( UN! d _ d?ILK UJK t d?I* uJ u WKUM( U pK* W fO d iUM u?N tJK t dI* U
W v_ UC t_ U uJ tJK* tU{
U U( dU! tcJ U2 Ud ?I U t dI* uJ d VM d?F* VM d WLOK w b lDI d?U U
dA nU s VOBM u d tK"* tK" bu s VM
O?BH p w d U WU? UEH d WG?O uJ uD U2 W?GO? q ub bb?% WU q U?O U?NI?H 5 UA?UM
t{d t"
d vK dBI vK `B 5IO e' vK W WGOB uJ
tU t cR U d U pA sE
o( UN! U? d _ d vK W?IKF eM U?F uJ l sJ UO?) d tO `B q?I* vK t?IOKF `B tH?A
WOJU* bM `BO W#OA vK oOKF U S U( iF w qOBH
d `B WOFUA WOHM( U? h W#OA vK oOKF `B
h W#OA vK oOKF UNOK sJ1 W#OA _ 5U( w
WKUM( U? dD)U oOKF? qL?? oOKF? u?u dD vK tKF?
lHd ? tF?d U0 t?I b? b d? _ 5U( w d? `B
UU d tM bBI W#OA vK oOKF rJ(
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
d?I* w d??A d?O? rK* s `B?O? ? d? w d??A
qd s `BO uc tO dA oUH bF s d `BO WbF
d*
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
wU Y*
d WOdA
d s UId U qzU s WKO tKF d dG WFdA U
UOI UL WM UJ w p vK qOb t d tUB o( UN!
UJ
p vK b U? qJA? U?? d? u?? vK b d?O?"? U
UNCF dc W Wd
s rJ?H ud? rU uJH? rJU"?O Uc? vUF? U
rdS rN?OK W( U vU?F U u&$)r bN?A r -d r rUt tU e W o( U w W uJO U"O* cQ
rU? r WLJ U? s rJ?O U* 5O?M U"?O c? vUF U?
d rJ vK -c? -d U? tdBM t 4R r?JF U* bB? u
vUF? 5 u&]X:G p|rsbU?A s rJF? U bN?U? U? Ud uU?rNM tK U* dI* vK W d
f? t o?O o( tOK c? qKLO sb W? w vUF U?
szbK tOK c o( UJ vK wK1 sb* d vUF U u&$)r U#O tMb pc t qLF t e t UN! sbU d d u u
UNUL s wNM UNA P d_U tM hIM o( UL s wNMU vUF
vK u b??N? j??IU 5u? u?u? uM sc U??N U vU??F U?
b t vU?F d b o(U d fHM vK U?NA u}['rrJHW?Fd?A t vF? c b?F U? vK fHM vK U?N?A U?N? t
g$XG ]XV1 XVc 4l. H/% ,Lw%XC% L4XV^ ~XG e)X XM 8XXG%XQX ]XI ga5 P[_4 ]V i%C P41 ,i%Q 4V mz ,:P'I I9 ,5
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
vK d w t?H vK UNA dA?e U W_ bO? d U pc
UN o( eS UNOK UNA vMF w t_ tH
U U? s U u8X$rdO?B tH vK U q vU?F Ud u vK b c WMO W u b? bU UU bU dOB
tH vK d*
WM
W? d U? w Wdd?I WOKF? WOu d?O" YU? WM w
p sL d Vu0 UC dI* eK t q?LF w{UI eK dI* t eK
ULJMO 5C_ bO wH c u U? tO quD nOF Yb
fO U b U? VdG WzU? bK pM vK pOK rMG bO?u UJ
vK d* rd rJ( u oKF
UNL?U Xd S? c d v
w c UJ_ tOK vM qO tU vK W d vK b UNd
v UdO w WKO tuJ b(
tM dQ XO w? uU U b* v c e?U Yb
wM U? U?N l t??H vK b?N? ULK? d l t?OK v?
tLd? v t d l tH vK b?NA W w uL?U t u
c
tLd dQ d l wM bM dQ U eU bL W w
UJ_ bS tOK w{UI UL d WOdA w `d `{ qO
-)wX$ XX[X_; :-0 XPXX0 }XPX$_X% }:X9
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
u?U XU??I? Ue s vK? w? wM X w WMO??N?' Yb?
wMQ XF{ S UNO s UI UN?O wM Ub wK tLQ b X
vK r XLd? UN d r UNUO U?NOK bA u? UN dQ qF?H UN
u U XUI wM U _ s bU s d UN W w UNOK
qO W dU
UNLd Ue s vK UN XU UU wdN
v UdO w U WKO tuJ UNAU b w b( w
s U?NKKOK tU? t{d? s tO? s WL?KE bM XU s wM U?
UN dI Q p t s UNd WLKE bM s2 VKD
Yb( tU
UNU UNLK
UL
qL UN! o( U W d? vK UHK UHK 5LK* WLK XIH
ULKF UCI bN: Vc* WLz uFU WUB bd UHK) t
dI* vK W d u vK uFL? c UMu v
bL UbO s cM
nU? d UOb w U?CI w UM? 5 qUF p? w u
UUL UJ t U
dJM p w rK
UOI
vK u_ UO?IU X" U qzU s WKO? U d?U qLF
U d w{UI U dO vK dO?G o hA U UNAU UNA
8'\ :-4X[XS pX :%#I^ pX , w%1 eX4 7XXF o56XD c\ :-'l6 pX -)9@ i % -I^ B 6D% kI% 6%
`X)/ [ , nX) 856\ , n6'[ 8XXCXI nX) 7XXF L _9%
}XPX$X_ 8X_ ,JJ XXc ,&
-[XX[9 i#X[X)( ,&
56X$ 7X0 n%XXX@ ,& -'S( , -X'BXX! ,8XXX6XXX
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
U ULNM lU UNA vK d UIO tH vK dOG o hA
dI? w UNO?K uBM U? w WO?d W? UN?A XU U* d? o
s o U?? U?N UN?O? cJ U?L?? r UN? rJ( w{U?I eK WM
fHM vK cJ WLN _ v_U WOd? W d uJ pcJ d h
uJO? dO? vK c t?H vK U?U cJ U?U d?OG vK U?NM q
vK U?NA q?I UM S? pc? t?u0 rJ( eK U?CI d s d?
uIU v w{UI U tH d S WLJ; U o(U d
tMU d WLJ
tO U? XI? UL?L tMU? d W?LJ v UB?U UM d?OA
dC _ s UN1 U l UN `U?B* VK UN V vK Wu fHM
c tzUM U* lL vK uD?H WdA c UL wb? U* UIF
w u?u bF w?UF* UJU h? d? S WdD? WO?IK l
WF bM 5F d? d sb t U?GAU dOGU d?C UI QD)
VU `d qI?F S rNuI? sd WKB U?bI u UHU? WU
Ud?C Uc t??H vK U?U cJ qU?F _ cJ U?L? b?F b?B
d vCI0 dI* e UCIK O tOK W d uJO
vK t U?LJ UNM UM U?N dB? uI( U?A pK U* dI* U?L
uI( U w W d UJ b X% t w UL U pK tU tH
UNO cF U?NA UNO bFM uI( s dO"? _ b WLOE d WLJ
qO ? UN ueK* U?NU UN?dF U WKO UN b?u WUJ
qB U?N dI U?S dO?L{ sb* W tU? v o( U?I v
XUJ UOb w UNU vK lOC UNK UNLCN UdJM U UN v
t qLF w WK dC dU c_ v WO WU(
bcXXP( XXC #XX:XX ,J 'M ,& OXXXX! -'SXX ,^k :n%XX@ Z[) # ,&
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
UB bF 5Q UN d? uI( UN! nOM( dA V pc
s u) vUF Wd w w?Mb u d dNE UM UOb w qUF w
uI( U?O wK l w YU d c?OHM tU{d w lL?D tUI
U1 W?FO?d ?_ WuI W?OU?B b?OI?F d d?NE c UN d?
UOb w bF oOD o( WU w WOUF WOMb WOd wIOI(
t s UM V UI d sU sL tL w{U U
v u?J* lOK? t?U? v o?( UB? UN?M t??c s? rN?M lD
UM UL? UNM oK) oU? U{ o( VU? UH tO? uJO t?UJ
uM WU bNF Uu U rNH uI bB dI*
8$I[ WY( j4% ,
L ,56$ 70 89:/; /01 234
-
&
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
YU Y*
UCI U d WO
w WLE_ U?FdA? lzdA lOL? w U"b? U1b W_ bO? d
UN! nu? U d?O"? w{UI U? eM UN w rU?( qBOH u? rUF
dO" UOb w bI U o( U{ d d vK tdF o(
v w{U?I dD{ d?? d? vK? W?OzU?C?I UJ_ nu? U?
vb* o( X" eM lDIO d?I U tOK vb* _ rN* d ub
UU dU! t vb* o( `B tU bF U V s wb* vHF t
wb* vK lI czbM dJ?M U t?H vK d? Vu0 t?H dI* e?K
tI U UMO Z( W#ON W_ UCS UOI tOK V U V
s V U?I? bF* qOb bI?H eF qA?H U dO?" UUO? `KH b
d dDC c w{UI t?OK vb* U ULK? Uu wU `?B U_
o( d tOK vb* d u
d WOzUCI UJ_ Y* c w 5
d wNIH rJ(
td? t?U? d?u c? `O??B d?? vK Vd??* d_ t d*
w tOK WOKL U rOJ( UA V wUU
o( UN
WOdA t?d tU UOu? b v ndF w o? UL d
`B U?zU u?N U?OH? Uu? U c o( UN! t?OK Vd
5 tMO lL? d qO WMO v U? pc UOF?K dU! tQ o(
q s U?U U o( wMF c dM UL? UM" UMO? W_ dzU
dIU? UNu? UMO U?N UHU? d U XHK b? t W#AM* W?Fu
dO bIF qUF dO*
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
XF Xc? tuI b( w d? s ud `B UM s
t dI* d* rOK " rd s dNU ud qB UL " XO U
d v
ud b( u? w dR WN d s ud? vK UNIH oH
Yb( w U* UNAU b b( _ Wd dL) d UeU dI*
pKFt U?I? UeU d? s u?dU eU?* ud id?F s `O??B
pU Ut UI WdU d c UK tCdF
X pKFXK
tuI UN?AU b b( _
U 5d t?OK UQ vK U? Xd
s udU? WU?* vK wM o _
UN?AU b(
UNM ud w b(U dI* 5IK u pc d qD UNO d
b w v?U?F u??I? 5O?? u?I? w d?? s u?d? U?
oKF UNM ud qI UNO dR W?NA S UHJ UeU UNAU
UF uI _ iI ? nKJ* UG u t_ t dI*U t dI* o
c XU u tUI dI* pK1 ? hA X o t_ WUA* vK WOM
H e^ ]V% ,L' R'xX[( 'Y H% ,kSX[ X% ,svX ]V t M -0 }'xXB 75 oI Rt OXX5 ,i%Q -0 UvXX W% H/ ,kX_;I }'xXB 75% ,L' R'XxX[( 4
M -0 6B KcV% ,e$[L4I ?)B >G o56D
8XXXX^ -I^ HG &
LXXYXX HI% J& -3XX['X% % #I^ *% o56XX@ c\ sG#0 -%>
HI% ,7F^ # p% ,sG#0% s0## && nc *% ,#PQ o56D H Uw c\ ,-9G% ,8Q3G% ,5\ -I^ HG && -$P)% & LF% mV@% &J LY7F :G HG *'Bt% :aD HI p% ,mP'G -. :G%
-
J
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
_ UNM u?d qI ? D UJM VMU? WOU d?O t?OU u?I(
WNA l X" b uI( c
dI* e
vL wd dB d _ t d U0 dI* e UO d b v
t?H b?OI? t?H e c u d?I* d tOK V?d tK w tK s b?
dS cR dI* _ o UL d s ud t o pc oOK
b% w uOIU bOI tB?IM tCIM tFd U0 d VI sJ
UBU tO dOA UNIH 5 qOBH tOH d VU w d dB%
UI U deM dL sL s tQ tu?I tIF r U0 h dI
bOI c WB u w WOFU?A WOHM( s UUB u w WOJU*
d?N!_ w WO?F?UA W?OJU* W?HOM u U? U? d e b?
t_ t d U teK p w dI* bB bOI c u WKUM(
dF Uu Ub bFO lu l U s u t d U jI
teK? r tC? r U r lO? sL s r? nQ d h? d
tKUI? w U rOK t?eK lO* i?I r t q_ _ n_ rOK
WO?HM( s 5?UB W?OF?UA u? u lDI r J qB c
WOJU* W?HOM u U U? b rJ tK b? t_ WdUE
t?? d _ v_ u?BU? d? t?eK tu? q?I WKUM(
d s ud `B u u qI t d U iUM
-0$9 k%_ ,
8XP$_ A4#$ , W3' W36I , ?3X$@ A); UXQXV ,J& n%X@ ,& OXX! R'SXX , n+XXQ9 bcXP( ,&( 8XX6XXXXD HI R9! , -'SX( , '$
&&
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
lO? _ b?O?' t?e dU t?H r? d lO?? sL?" d?
u qI d s u dO?H bO' vK U lI dI
WFu VBG w p U U W?HOM w U bM qB q
uJ t?b d VB U?L?
qB? q u b?BO?
dO?H q?I UU?B WKUM( U q?IO? uMK UUO q U?u
uu bBO dOOG UO t_ lOL' w q
w{UI e
te WUJU sbUA bM X w{UI U U?O d b v
v U? UU o( `?Q d?I* U vK b? d _ t?u0 rJ(
cO?HM bN?F s d)U d?I* w{UI d?QO? t?" W? v bR qO
vUF? U dN! b? o( dN! v? rJ(U uQ? w{UI _ d? vC?I
ur o(U UM 5 rJU _ w WHOK UMKF U UbM u?b w WO?U W?? U?U t?UL? d?0 dU w{U?I rJ
W d _ WOJU* iF `d w WKUM( WOFUA WOHM( s uNL'
s9R u tHO! tKLF ULzU d?F rJ( fK w w{UI _ UNc WLzU
dU t?LKF o( W?dF U?NA s d* _ d vK? UN U?
UNA s d"
d?0 w{U?I rJ WKUM( s vKF u? w{UI W?OJU* s o?d U?
fO ULNu?I rJ r dI* vK bNA bU dC? tOK V q d
, ,KX[ 8XXS9I , XP41 W:XaXX , ?3 XX) ,J W3X' W36I bcXP( ,& k%X_ g5cXP; , Z/@ X); , X569 XSX XQ%, :G% -I#9 8CD , ->XS9 >Y# , -4>( ,
& n%@ ,& R9! , -'S( ,J '$ UQV
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
d? s d?I* ld W?O?A? rU?( rKF? rJ( uJ v? d?U
rNc? UOU? vUF tL? U U? w{UI vK W?LN lI? dJM
d u U?NK t w pc b?N tLKF wC?I rU( U?( q U
v
rNC?F u w tOK wCI t?S UCI fK w o? d bM rB
d ULdCO sbUA ub
tLKF dU w{UI rK _ U?CI w qLF tOK _ uI u `d
vK rzU t_ oOD Vu w?dA rJ(U tLK q" uNA s U?H*
WNAK d? tU dN! c o(U rJ tOK d?F* eM qBH t
WOJU* s uII; td U u WLN
eM lD
UU t vb* qF 5LU* 5 ) wNM eM lDI o(U d
rOK?U d_ vK w?{UI rJ d?B?I rU( r?J q u t?O UM? dO?
lO?L d?G u? UM UMO d?O"? OK U? u t d?ILK t d?I* l
qOQ WKUL* rJ( s UM d?Q nu w{UIK fO tU
cN eM qB? o( UI? s UFM2 dB?I UL U? `KB VK
U Z( UMO? _ WIOI fO U? U WKO d UNI?H d
eM UM lHU d? fHM UU o( ` d bM t?O UM* o(
)
C ,J ?3 ) ,J
i#[)( :j4% g
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
WKU W d UOU
tU? UC?I U U? w WKU W? d? o UL? ZM
U?N! w t?Lb t?I? bR U? v U? wb* u t d?I* w{U?I
Wd? o c W_ bO? t d? vK ULKF? oK pc t rJ( o(
U?U t?O? pA W?d UI? U?d ?I? tO? bB? VU `O?d? tO?
sJ1 U qU? ju tU? t?H vK WKUJ Wu t s2 b?B
iG b?F U?O W?L?N? Wu? u% U?L?? t?O dD
qIFU WOK_ qU u dF d?I*U dO de UO qU%
oOK tH bOI q"* w qO tHM tH eK
cN W?IOI?( v UNd U?N! w Ub UMO? Z( qL d?U
dM UL uI( lOL W t W_ bO tQ uH
_ WO?FD WOMOI? XO UNMJ b?B UNO? VUGU? WOM! W? d sJ
b tO d pc wB YU U? V UUO tH vK cJ b dI*
sb dI sL? UNOK ? w{UIK sJ1 WO?H WL?N uJ b ?" WL?N
dI s t b_ t dI* dO tF? RuU wM_ dI 5Mzb dzU dCO
t?Ib tM t? s WuI?F u?O U?NM d? W1d wH?O W1d?
ULNMO Ru WHUFK
dU W d UU
tH dI* vK dU UNMJ rJ( UCI U w WKU W d u l
WOK_U lL dI* _ pdA ob?B _ _ s eU dO v bF
dO vK W t fO sJ bU UN vH UNOK bU QJ tH vK WU
& A[D -9G 6)G 6B ,8
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
cRO UeU? b d u t d U te ` tU t?L w o d uK
d?O? l d??U WU?M d? u wU?" dD vK? b?( X?" d?S
`B UCI U w t WLO dO? vK d d dS cRO
dOG UN uJ b dO vK d qD tH vK d
X? n?u d!U rO?I w?u wu d? `B p? vK UM
UNA s r d S c l WbF W? UNA _ rNOK UNA WU
bF U?NAU X" sJ1 w? U( iF dU X?" b w e t_
VM Yb?( l{ e UN? d?U q?I q"? UN?OK UJ
dOG s Z( wIOI(
UNA d
rJ( uJ U?Nc WKU? W? d? UN?A d? 5 dH d?NE
o( X" UNc W? XO UNS U?NA U d vC?I bR U?"
`B rJ( q UNA s ud `B pc UN rJ( dU q Ud0
sE v bM U?NAU UCI? V bF rJ( q d? s ud
s U? w u dU? dU qU?( rKF vK b?L?F dU U?CI
cJ vK bB `Od w UMO lD UNA
dB?I dU U_ vK uL?A WN s UNA s d nK? UL
l{ pc WUJ vK WbF W UNS UNA U dO v bF dI* vK
dU W d dOG vK WbF W WMO WONIH bUI ULKF
w U* rKF U0 b?NA bU?A W"U WN? s d s U?NA d?H
vUF tuI
bNU UNK" vK rF U fLA d ndA Yb(
-9D> 6: #V6 B 8P$_ 6G#$ ,& ( 86
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
vK UM d t u tS dI* U uU>ruLKF r o(U bN s
sb UHO bF d tO j vK u dS sE WK
d l WMO
_ tu?I bF bU?A UL? U Z?( u W_ bO? d
dJM vK UI WMO _ nOFCU rb uI
ub l? dO v b?F t?H d?I* vK dU? W d? sJ
U pc dO dI*U oKF t vb* _ d?OG dI*U jd uJ b WOCI
s rJ( bF t dI?LK bzU UNO U UM" d l WMO? UL UNIH
UNL U w p dI* dO s d{ UMFu dO v dI*
c vK WMO rOI t dILK uO XO* vK d sb Wu b d
vK sbU Wu lO?L d c? Wu WO?I v rJ( bF?O sb
dzU o w sb U v U? t dI* _ UNA WU? uO XO*
Wu o w tU U UL 5OMzb
t?OK vb?* sb* d?Q? sb i? w ? q?O? t h? v
s tM d?C lb t?U u? vK sd? qOuK u??O WU?uU
qu* dJ r WUu vK WMO qOu v sb l sb* _ sb*
WUu X? dCO? WOU lbK dDC sb* W d ? WUu
WU t U pK v
tC U vK WU qOu b X bI WMOU
u lO?L' vK WU WUu qF?& WMOU WUu U s?LC
dJM U d tOK vb q U WUu U U dO dI*
*X)C1 ,& W3' W36I ,&
56X$ 7X0 89:/; ,J H56IG HI 8XCXD Z/@ XXXX); ,J , -w#XXXX[9 3jX'% *X)XXC1 ,J mXX HI 3Xj'%
-4>( , , -#B6 8CD ,& i#[)( ,
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
vb* dQ? sbU sb* wu VU w? t h v
WMO? rOI? v
sb* d?S t?U X?" w{U?IU W?UuU t?OK
dJ sb* W? d b? d? vK UL?? U* l t_ UN?OK
_ d tFHM tU? dJQ d sb s UM VK c u
lOL' vK WU uJ WMOU X p w
o* s WMO qI d lO* U?IU tOK o* dA* d
s tMJ1 oLK pK*U dA* d _ lzU vK ud s sJLO
tMJ WMO? XLO u d?U W d? _ lzU vK sL?"U ud
WbF W UN_ p
b?F?O d l WMO? WU? U W?O?uU t vuLK u d?
Wu dzU w rJ(
tO?K UI W?uB?) s d ? wB vK o d?Q _ r?u
WuB) s Ud d S w{UI 5 wu d l WMO
U bzU U?NA w U? UN?O jUC p w? uB? dO? qzU*
qI d vK
d Wze& UF
w rJ( nK Vd uu jO u W WGOB V d
u_ V tFM tze& u
U d dI* d? s bd U w{UI t dI* U? u d Wze&
Wze d qI qN dC U d tFHM U d s cQ bd
U?L? o(U h?A d?I u qUJ U? vL? jO?? d?
u U?L? UN vb?* WF?u vK VBM? qbF U?U9 wb* t?O?b
WF v U?LN dQ ?R U{d v t d?Q U{d U?GK v
J m HI 3j'% *)C1 ,& H56IG HI 8CD
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
t vb* dQ UMOF Ub UHK v w U?L UN dQ WMOF UQ
UU9
u U?L? t vb* o(U d?? b? u b?F* u?u* d?
UM wb q" nuU b?F oK bF? o(U d uJ U/
v qR* s?bU sb* d?I?O?? q_ vN? b? 5M? v ?R?
vK U?I?KF? sb* t d?Q? e??M UM v q_ iI?M r uM
b?O VU d?I?O U t?O XKI? tu* XU? UMO v d?A
w WuBG UMO tOK v WNU dI* v XKI UN uLK UNuJ
WF WU UNMJ b X% 5FU dIO b X%
5u v uu* d Wze& u w UNIH nK
WO?JU* s Wd? s `_ w WO?FU?A u u u?' b _ uI
tK d tK q?I U?S b? WKL? d _ WdU?E WKUM( iF
WL Wb? s U nuU teKO X v qR tQ u?u t dI*
uI Vc?*U w{UI U? tC? r lO? sL s nQ d u? vUF
d s ULb pHM t o WKUI w o d t_ tu
WOJU* WKUM( WOHM( u u uu* d Wze& u wU uI
tO? t?HM UI? v U0 tH v?K d dI* _ u? w WO?FU?A u w
s U? v r b d U?L u?b W? t_ d w b?BO?
,^>Xa5 eYI U#XF#( ]^ 89I'@ g\cX% ,\$ 8X)X/ 8aX5 :8X9I'@ N
-
&
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
w UH fO q_ _ Vd* d vK uu* d u?U UNU
UU U d tO q_U WUHJ bI dOG Vu sb
d? W?F?u U?Nd?? r W?OK_ W?F?uU d? u Vd* d?
tM d tO WUI* b v sb d q" UNM WKBHM
d?O? u? W?F?u d??I Vd* u?u* Vd* d? 5 d?H
nu S uu* U WUI* d U?uU wK_ t dI* Xu WdI
dQ UI u q lU Xu dFU dA q_U t dI* X l dI
5u vK Vd* d Wze& u w UNIH nK
u w WOFUA WOLO s WdUE u u Wze u b _ uI
q?I d? tK d tK q?I b W?KL d? _
WKUM( iF
w W?I dI* _ iF t?CF? c_ u? b? t_ iO?F?
j?IU 5u? uu? uM sc U?N U U?I pc? d vU?F _ d?
u}['rrJH vK u bNWOJU* `d w WOFUA? WOHM( p v V Wze u wU uI
w dI uN U WOU" d v_ 5Fu rKJ dI* _ WKUM( uNA* w
XXP41 W:XXaXX ,J& ,JJ , H56XIXXG HI 8XXXXCXXD ,
56XX$ 7XX0 89X:/; >XY# , bcXP( , e9VM% OX ,J -#B6 8XCXD ,
&& R9! ,\$ 8)/ i -'S( , ,J& n%@ ,J}#XB ,U#XF#X(% gV( -0 sX$9l ^>XXa5 XM : LX:XD 8XXX:X; HI% 85X\j pX :p$X0 p@ -0 ?@ $( q)z^ ]t :#$X0 ,T@ AI 89I'@ k0% ,eX; m %^ W3# q9;%^ }$ }XG e)$5% 1 L>90 ,XM ^>a0 XP ^ -9G %^ XP; 8Y# , bcP( ,&&
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
d? e pc W?UI* d U?C?I b lb w b? v_
u fO ub d? 5 WdH? w UL u? Wze w V? tOK
b U UNMLC U d 5 WdH q WIOI( w d Wze&
d? Wze? uI `O?d WI?KD* WbF oO?D WdEM W?OUM s d?NE
`d lzc b uU c_ wKL?F lu oOD sJ Vd* uu*
`B t_ ub w bO?u W( u d _ d Wze?& bF uI
bF lb b c t?FHM U d d?C U tM cR YO d?I* e
UN! ub w d? t UbL? b U o( UO?{ r d
w tb? dH p? vK dO V?O d w t?b UM{d? o(
d w Wb e WO?U d sb lb UMe UCI U nu
UIKD o( UJ cJ vK Ud
dU X w uI( UU
U vK V o qJ u?I( lOL t X?" d vK UNI?H oH
d XU `? h t d W?UL d d? w vUF
UM UMO? U* w? b? w o( U? u? UM ?) dz s
UJ WOU* ?UF* U?F w U u wU? dO UOU? UI W?FHM
WOBA UF* w bF U{d VM WIHM D UJMU d_
U? b?H W?c d?_ wH rzUM?G U??I U?N?' UJ WU?uU?
p dO U_U b_
Udc s dU X" w U( b% w juC iF UNIH d
t UH? u U? q t d U? t WUD* U? w q uUI? bF
,J -#B6 8XCD ,
56$ 70 89:/; , H56IG HI 8XCD -'SX( ,& n%X@ ,J >XXXXY# , bcXXP( , eX9VM% OXX
-
J
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
UA hA pK1U q UO( W?OK lI t UH u U t d `
t d?? pK U?? U??A tMJ1 U2 U?? S?? tJK1 U?? t d?? pK1
Wu* UF_U WKL' w t UA tMJ1 U2 U uI Vu U VMU
dBU d? hA t eK o q UL?N sJ r t d U? WuIFK
t d U wd rU o
w Vu?' iF UM v?I U?B??U d? UJ r c?N? d?O
WMO?F d?A dHM W?U W?OzUM"? UJ UN qO?UH? s be* U?%
d U?NL U?O( w W?OKLF WO?NI?H UN?OL_ U?N WKBH? W wC?I
vUF U WKI W q w u* d w d VMU
X:G% -I#9 8XCD% ,& n%X@ , 'M ,& OX! -'S :j4^ -w#[9 3j'% *)C1 , R9! C R9G
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
W9U)
WOzd Y UJ W w
w{UI bM tH vK dOG o hA U u d u d d s qJ WGOB t dI* t dI* dI* w WF d U
tOK d?( b WLN b? UO qIF uK d?I* w dA U uJ
dI* cJ U*U u pKL WOK t UOMF uJ t dI* w dA Ud I U fO UuKF dA dI UI uJ t dI* w dA
uJ U WU? UEH W W?d uJ WG?OB w d?A
I uI UI V uJ WIKF eM 5IO e' vK
UOI UL WM dI w X uI( U UHU dA d b( w tO ud u o( dNE d &
t d U0 dI* e UO d b v tOK UM rJ(U e w{UI bM d X v J
5LU* 5UM* 5 o( w ) wNM eM lDI d WOM! W tMJ Z( qL W_ bO u U w WKU W d
W UNS UNA s nK dO v bF dI* vK dU W d dI* dO uLA WU( bM d l WMO qI pc WbF
Vd* uu* d Wze& w UNIH nK jO d Wze& `B WUF WKBLK tze& u b UM 5u vK
o q UN?L dO?" ju{ U?NO? ULKF UH?U dU uI?( lOL? X" t d u d hA t eK
-
WObF W?LE_ UCI b
U?NO? W?U d? WMO?F? UJQ dH?M w d Y?U? r s
UL u* d0 d? VMU d U?NIH 5 ? qO?UH
WU Wb UU
c e vK vU?F dJA U(U?B t?LFM r c b?L( Uu? d
w UF oIM UNO U0 qLF UN e UMIu vUF Q dG WFdA
J vK d UOb w tIOu tu U{d vE UOb
b wKOe bL