[토론회] 2012 총·대선과 유권자 표현의 자유를 위한 선거법 개정방향
Post on 12-Mar-2016
222 views
DESCRIPTION
지난 12월 15일, 현행 공직선거법의 주요 독소조항들에 대한 종합적 개정안(일명 ‘유권자자유법’)이 발의되었습니다(대표 발의자: 민주통합당 김부겸 의원). 은 유자넷과 김부겸 의원실의 정책 협의를 통해 발의되었으며, 최근 재보궐 선거에서 첨예한 문제로 나타난 SNS 규제 문제를 비롯해 지난 10여 년간 유권자의 참정권과 정치적 표현을 제약해왔던 제반 독소조항에 대한 개정 내용을 담고 있습니다. 유자넷과 민주통합당 김부겸 의원은 12/21(수), 국회 의원회관 130호에서 ‘ 2012년 총·대선과 유권자 표현의 자유를 위한 선거법 개정방향(부제 : 유권자 자유법 발의와 쟁점 토론)’을 진행했습니다.TRANSCRIPT
-
2012
| 2011 12 21() 10 30 | 130 | , ()
-
2
2012
/ , / , / , - ( )
/ / /
-
3
2012
/ , - ( ) 4
/ 36 / 38 / 45
- 2000-2010 ( . 2011/6/1)
-
4
- ( )
/ ,
.
1.
, . . . .1) .2) . () .3)
1) , (),(, 2004), 303.2) , , , 19(2008), 695.3) , , 9(, 2009), 144.
-
5
. , . , , , , , , . . , , , . . . , . .
. . . .
2.
. 4) .
4) , , , . : , , , 26 1, 35.
-
6
. . .
. 58 1 . . , . , .5) . .
, . . . . 21 , 24 , .6)
5) , , 4 (, 2009), 1308.6) 1994. 7. 29. 934, 6()
-
7
.7)
, . . .8) , , , , , .9)
. UN 2011. 7. 28. 34 , .10) UN 93 180 , . 2010. 6. 2. 4 . , .
7) 2004. 3. 25. 20017108) 1999. 11. 25. 98141( , )9) 2004. 4. 29. 2002467 10) 2, Human Rights Committee 102nd session, Geneva, 11-29 July 2011, General comment No.34.
-
8
, . , .
3.
, , , , . ' ' . 2002. 6. 27. 99480 11) 2010.12.28, 2008157 12) . .13) , , (representative democracy) .14)
SNS 2.0 . 2.0 , , , . 1.0 , , 2.0
11) , .12) ,
.13) , : , , 24 1
, 232.14) , (twitter) , , 35 (2010. 3. 15.)
-
9
. 1.0 , 2.0 .15) 2.0 SNS (, , ) , . SNS . , SNS . , ' ' . SNS .
.
. , , . . , . , , ,, , , 16)
15) , 2.0 UCC -, , , 201(2009), 6416) 1995. 4. 20. 9229 , 2001. 12. 20. 200096, 200157()
-
10
. .
, , . .17) (SNS) . , . .
, , . (90), (93), (103), (107) . . , . .
17) , , 2003. 8,16,, , 2011.4,37.
-
11
. 18)
, . 93 1 , 180
. , , , . 2007 UCC
2010 , (4) . ,
. , , , , . ,
. , . , .
18) // . ( 10. )
-
12
.
. , , ( 581).
. ( 59, 8241).
. , ( 826).
. , , 180 60 ( 901).
. 180 , ( 931).
. , ( 101).
. , ( 1033).
-
13
. , ( 8242, 110, 251).
. ( 1482).
. 9 ( 1551, 2, 5).
. ( 2301).
. ( 2542).
-
15
.581 (49 602 ) , , 5 .5.
593 , ( 211 . ) .60313 7 .8241 211 ( ) , , 2 .826 .901 180 60, , , 2 .931 .101 .1033 .1092 67 824123 6, .110 .
-
16
1482 5 , , ., (
) 5 .1551 6( 8) 9 , 2 4 9 , 5 6( 8) 9 .1762 6( 8) 9 .23011 .251 .2542 , , , , , .25525 1 , 2 2 .26111 33 .
.
-
17
58( )
.
, 1
.
58( ) ----------
----------------------
(49 602
)
-------------
----------------------
-------. ----------------
--------------------------
----------------------.
1.4. ( ) 1.4. ( )
5.
( ) ( )
59()
. ,
.
59() -------
--------------------------
--------------------------
------.--------------------
--------------------------
---------------------.
1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )
-
18
3. ,
3. (
21
1
. )
---------
603(
)
.
603(
) ----------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------.
1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )
3. (
.
)
4.6. ( ) 4.6. ( )
7. (
.
)
-
19
.
(
)
5
.
( ) ( )
824(
)
211
(
)
.
824(
) ----------
------------------
-----
----------------.
1.
2.
-
20
3. (
)
.
,
5
.
(
),
,
. ,
-
21
.
( ) ( )
826(
)
(
)
24
(
)
.
,
445
-
22
.
1
.
1 2
,
.
1
-
23
.
.
.
6
.
90( )
180
(
)
90( )
---------60-------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-
24
. (
)
(
.
)
.
----------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
----------.
1.3. ( ) 1.3. ( )
1
.
1.
37
2
2.
-
25
93(
)
180
(
)
(
. )
(
.
)
, , ,
,
93(
)
-
26
.
,
.
1. ,
6032
( 2
,
) 60
312
2.
37
2
( ) ( )
101( )
101( )
--------------------
----------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-
27
.
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-.
103( )
( )
103( )
( )
,
.
---------------------
------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-----------------.
( ) ( )
109(
) (
)
109(
) (
)
603167
82412
3
( 11
6
) .
--------------------6
----------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------.
( ) ( )
110( )
-
28
(
.
),
,
. ,
.
148( )
( )
148( )
( )
.
------------------------
--------------
5
--
--------------------------
-------
. ,
-
29
(
)
5
.
( ) ( )
155()
6
6(
8) .
,
.
155() --------
--------------------------
---9-------. ----------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
----.
-
30
148(
)
10
4 . 1
.
------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
9-------. -------------
--------------------------
-----------------.
( ) ( )
6(
8)
.
------------------------
-9------------------
--------------------------
-.
176( )
( )
176( )
( )
6
(
8)
.
------------------------
-----------------------9
--------------------------
--------------------------
------------------.
230( )
5
1
230( )
------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-
31
. ------------.
1.
(
.
)
( )
(7912
81182
1 8221
2
.
)
(
.
1.
-----------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
-
32
)
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------
2.5. ( ) 2.5. ( )
( ) ( )
251()
(
),
3
500
. ,
.
254() 254()
-
33
( ) ( )
,
, ,
,
, ,
,
,
2
400
.
------------------
---------------------
-----------------------
-----------------------
-----------------------
-----------------------
-----------
,
-----------
-----------------------
-----------------------
---------.
255()
( )
255()
( )
2
400
.
------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
------------.
1.4. ( ) 1.4. ( )
5. 93(
)1
5. ------------------------
------------------------
-----2------------
------------------------
-
34
, 2
3
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
------------------------
---------------
6.8. ( ) 6.8. ( )
( ) ( )
261( )
1
.
261( )
-----------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
----------.
1. 8261
2. ( ) 2. ( )
( ) ( )
30
0
.
------------------------
--------------------------
--------------------------
-----.
1.2. ( ) 1.2. ( )
-
35
3. 8266
( ) ( )
-
36
1
/
1.
( )
, -
-
-
37
2.
,
- -
, QR 2012 ,
( ) ,
3.
, , ( 58 1)
, , , , ,
-
38
2
1)
/
1.
.
, , , .
, 1 1 .
.
, .
1) .
-
39
, , , , .
. , .
2.
.
, .
,
.
, , .
.
.
-
40
.
ucc, sns (, ) .
- 8241 - 60316 - 109 ,
- 2010 (62%), (21%) .- .
.
.
- (445) , , 10 .
-
41
.
, ,
931 .
931 - 931 sns , .- , 931 .
.
.
.
.
-
42
.
- , , .- ,- .- , .- .
.
5 ,
9 .
,
.
, 2010 15 , 69.1% 89.7% ,
-
43
.
,
.
.
.
, , .
.
.
.
-
44
.
. ,
.
, , , 2).
, .
3.
.
, , , .
, , , , .
2) .
-
45
3
/
.
211 , Access . , , , , , . , , , .1)
2), () . , , , .3)
1) 1998. 2. 27. 962, 2000. 3. 30. 97108, 2002. 4. 25. 200127 .2) , 1995. 7. 21. 92177, 199.
-
46
.
.
1.
, 1910 , 1925 , 1939 (Hatch Political Activities Act 1939), 1947 (Taft-Hartly Act 1947) . , , , , , , , PC , , , , , .4)
2. , ,
, , , , , .
3. .
, , , .
4. ,
3) , 1995. 4. 20. 9229.4) , , , 2001, 33.
-
47
. 2007 UCC . UCC SNS .5)
. 93 1
. , . 90 1, 93 1, 107, 254 2 59 , SNS 93 1, 82 6 .
1. 93 1(90 1) ,
90 93 .6)
. .
5) , , 2009 55(2009. 12), 88.6) , 2007. 6. 15. 2007175, 2009. 5. 28. 200811857 ; 2001. 8. 30. 9992,200039, 2000167168199205280 .
-
48
, , , , , . , , , , , .7) .
2. 93 1
93 1 UCC() ( 2009. 7. 30. 2009718) ( 2009. 5. 28. 200724) . 9 4, 5 6 () .
. . , , .8) , UCC, SNS .
7) , , 2011, , 198,8) , , 202.
-
49
3. 93 1 180 .
. 86 2
1. 1997 15
2000 16 . 2002 16 , 2004 17 .2005. 8. 4.
(826), 2007. 1. 26. 30 20 () (445), 2007 7 .
2. 9)
OECD . , , PC .10)
.(EU)
9) , , 2008.10.1710) (2008.7)
-
50
, .
, .
.
3. (86 2)
., .
, (), remailing service .,
. 18 , .,
., ,
.11)
. 1995 (McIntyre v. Ohio ElectionsCommission)
11) , , , 2011, 42
-
51
, .
, . , .
, , , , , . 12) . ,
, .13)
.
12) , 2007, - -, , 15 2, ,13) , 2003, , CLIS Monthly 2003-5/6, ;
-
2011 6 1 . 2010
, FTA , SNS SNS .
2011. 06. 01 | 2011-07
2000-2010
-
. 2000 , 2002 , 2004 , 2007 , 2008 , 2010 .
, , , , , UCC , , SNS .
, 90(), 93( ), 103( ), 105( ), 107( ),251(), 254() . 33 180 , , UCC 93 1.
10 , . , . , .
(
-
), ( , , ), ( ) .
-
; ? ?
1 ? ? ? ? . 2010 62 ( ) 108( ) . . . 2004 100 . . , . . . . . , , . 20 . . . . . 10 . . . .
-
. . , . . , .
, 2000 16 ~ 2010 62 33. .
33 6 , 33 12 .
. , .
-
20 0 0
16
7
16 15 66 ,
50 ( 1 2 5 )
*90( )91( ) , 93( ) 95( ) 101( )105( ) ,107(
2000 413 2010 62 , , .2000 16 2010 62 , 500 2000 , 2002 16 () , 2004 , 2007 17 , 2008 2010 62 . , .
2000~2010
-
)254( )20 0 2
16
1
100, 80
90( )93( ) 107( )2 0 0 4
17
150
93( )
20 0 7
17
MB
2007 6 ... ..
50
93( )
20 0 8
18
2008 1
100
93( )
20 1 0
,
1 200 (2 )
90( ) 107( )254( )
*
-
2000 2000 3 . . , , . . .
2002 2002 40 . , . 90 . , , 90 ' ' . 90 .
2004 2007 MB 2004 , , . , , , .
-
, (www.auction.co.kr) . (vote2004.nec.go.kr) , . 93 1 . 20 , , , . MB 1 3 , , . . 93 1 . .
2008 . , , 27 ,
-
. , . . . .
2010 . 2010 , 4 4 .10 , , , . . , , . , .
-
.
-
, 1
52004 4
70 ~ 1 5 0
103( )
2010 5 " , 2 1 ", " , . . "
50
90( )
1
2010 5 4 "1 , 6 2 "
300
93( )
6 33 12 . 12 , 1 , UCC , , , , , , , , . .
2002
80
254()
2004 , i 3,127
70
95( )
-
2010 4
1 50 (2 )
254()
2010 , , 4 , 62 1
50
90( )
4 , ,
1 80 (2 )
90( )107( )
1 90(
14 " " . PC ,
100
93( )
2002 - , , , '
50
93( )
, UCC (1~5)
80
93( ) 254()
150
93( )
MB
2007 6 ... ..
50
93( )
-
,
200 (2 )
) 107( )254()
2003 11 .
70
93( ) 251()
2004 4 " " " , ~!"
100
93( )
2004 3
250*
93( )250()
2007 6 , ,
30
93( )
2007 10 , '
42 '
50
251()
2007 9 , , , , ?? ~~~
50
93( )
2007 50 (Extreme Dirt Mr. Lee !! )
30
93 ( )
-
251() 2007 1 ,
108
100
251()254()
2008 1
100
93( )
* 612 931 250 250
2007 11
, 14? ? !
100
93( ) 251()
2007 ""
90
93( )
2007 12 , , ,
80
93( ) 251()
2004 ,
100
108( ) ,
-
2007 105
600
824( ) ,
2007
500
826( )
[]
!
10
93( )
7
16 15 66 ,
50 ( 1 2 5 )
*90( )91( ) ,93( ) 95( )101( )105( ), 107(
(),(), () 21
20 20
230( )
-
)254()
1
1 0 0 ,80
90( )93( ) 107( )
12 ~
.14) . .
1 UCC 2007 17 UCC . . , . , 2007 87,812 , .
14) 824( ) , .
-
.
24 , . , , , , , .
, , , . 251( ) , . , , .
-
33 15, 824( ), 826( ), 90(), 91( ), 93( ), 95( ), 101(), 103( ), 105( ), 107(),108( ), 230( ), 250(), 251(), 2542() . 93 1 33 19 . .
UCC (931) 2007 UCC 93 115) , UCC . , . 93 " UCC . , . . .
15) 93( ) 180( ) ( . ) ( . ) , , , , .
-
.
931 . 90116) , . . 10317), 10718) . . 4 , 103 107 .
(251) , . 16) 90( ) 180(
) . ( ) ( . ) .1. , 2. 3. 17) 103( )
, .18) 107( )
.
-
. (25119)) . . .
(230) 2010 62 4 230 . , . 230( )20) , .
19) 251() ( ), 3 500 . , .20) 230( ) 5 1
. 1. ( . ) ( ) (7912 811821 82212 . ) ( . )
-
. . , . . . 1 . . . . ( , ( , , ), ( ) . , , , .