div class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=1Page 1button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=1 data-page=1 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 1: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails1jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=2Page 2button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=2 data-page=2 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 2: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails2jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=3Page 3button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=3 data-page=3 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 3: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails3jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=4Page 4button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=4 data-page=4 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 4: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails4jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=5Page 5button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=5 data-page=5 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 5: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails5jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=6Page 6button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=6 data-page=6 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 6: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails6jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=7Page 7button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=7 data-page=7 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 7: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails7jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=8Page 8button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=8 data-page=8 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 8: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails8jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=9Page 9button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=9 data-page=9 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 9: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails9jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=10Page 10button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=10 data-page=10 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 10: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails10jpg width=140 height=200 divdivdiv class=ts-pagebutton class=gotoPage data-page=11Page 11button div class=ts-imageimg data-url=-2-soriano-vs-laguardia-gr-nos-164785-and-165636-march-15-2010-dissentinghtmlpage=11 data-page=11 class=ts-thumb lazyload alt=Page 11: · 2 Soriano vs Laguardia GR Nos 164785 and 165636 March 15 2010 dissenting opinion of Carpio J December 9 2016 Respectfully endorsing to ATTY loading=lazy src=data:imagegifbase64iVBORw0KGgoAAAANSUhEUgAAAAIAAAACCAQAAADYv8WvAAAAD0lEQVR42mP8X8AwAgiABKBAv+vAXklAAAAAElFTkSuQmCC data-src=https:reader031vdocumentssitereader031viewer20220218015b3dd40e7f8b9ace408e543ehtml5thumbnails11jpg width=140 height=200 divdiv
