watchmen : society’s genuine critique

8
Ramos Juliana Ramos Tenbarge 23 February 2012 College Prep H Watchmen: Society’s Genuine Critique Watchmen , by Alan Moore, is literature extraordinaire that goes far beyond set comic standards and changes the future, quite literally. Set in an alternate 1985 America, the murder of ‘The Comedian’ spurs an epic mystery that intermingles the evils of heroism and the certainties of justice. In pursuit of the truth, protagonist Rorschach uncovers a former superhero’s scheme. Ozymandias proceeds to kill three million innocent bystanders in a successful attempt to end the Arms Race. Though it ends with no ‘happily ever after’, the graphic novel effectively depicts insight on how America would realistically progress with superhero’s in society. The comic proves it is a masterwork piece of fiction through its complex characterization, profound symbolism, and insightful theme. 1

Upload: jewwless

Post on 21-Apr-2015

43 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

DESCRIPTION

Critical Analysis

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Watchmen : Society’s Genuine Critique

Ramos

Juliana Ramos

Tenbarge

23 February 2012

College Prep H

Watchmen: Society’s Genuine Critique

Watchmen, by Alan Moore, is literature extraordinaire that goes far beyond

set comic standards and changes the future, quite literally. Set in an alternate 1985

America, the murder of ‘The Comedian’ spurs an epic mystery that intermingles the

evils of heroism and the certainties of justice. In pursuit of the truth, protagonist

Rorschach uncovers a former superhero’s scheme. Ozymandias proceeds to kill

three million innocent bystanders in a successful attempt to end the Arms Race.

Though it ends with no ‘happily ever after’, the graphic novel effectively depicts

insight on how America would realistically progress with superhero’s in society. The

comic proves it is a masterwork piece of fiction through its complex

characterization, profound symbolism, and insightful theme.

Moore’s gift for creating multidimensional characters enriches the reader’s

experience and enhances the depth of the plot. Well into the beginning of the story

Moore inserts hard-hitting words that reflect Rorschach’s thoughts about the world

and gives readers a better look into his mind. Frustrated by unmet expectations

Rorschach states, “Meeting with Veidt left [a] bad taste in [my] mouth. He is

pampered and decadent, betraying even his own shallow, liberal affections… Why

are so few of us left active, healthy, and without personality disorders?” (Moore 19).

One does not anticipate such words from an almighty superhero, yet Moore bravely

1

Page 2: Watchmen : Society’s Genuine Critique

Ramos

strays from standard portrayals of heroes and gives them a darker personality.

Moore insinuates that heroes are just as blemished as anyone else; the difference is

they can hide behind a mask. Subsequently, Moore introduces Dr. Manhattan as an

apathetic figure. When faced with the news of The Comedians death, the doctor

carelessly establishes that his death was of no distress to him, “A live body and a

dead body contain the same number of particles. Structurally there’s no discernible

difference. Life and death are unquantifiable abstracts. Why should I be concerned?”

(21). Dr. Manhattan portraying life and death as interchangeable concepts testifies

that even the most brilliant are not necessarily the most compassionate. Dr.

Manhattan is far from a flat character and is even seen as having a personality

disorder. In an emotion break down Dr. Manhattan lets out his true feelings,

The world is so full of people, so crowded with these miracles that they become

commonplace and we forget... I forget. We gaze continually at the world and it

grows dull in our perceptions. Yet seen from the another's vantage point, as if

new, it may still take our breath away (7).

His conflicting personality resembles the worst in everyone. Even minor characters

reflect a multidimensional behavior. Sally Jupiter cries to her daughter after being

scorned for her past superhero life and says, “Everyday the future looks a little bit

darker but the past even the grimy parts of it… well, it just keeps on getting brighter

all the time” (5). Moore liberates superheroes of their commonplace stereotypes

and replaces it with realism. Not all superhero’s are genuine and loving, they can be

cynical and a bit mad too. Moore’s use of characterization is noteworthy, and the

equally as vital symbolism makes the comic an exceptional piece.

2

Page 3: Watchmen : Society’s Genuine Critique

Ramos

The symbolism in Watchmen is correspondingly as cunning as Moore’s use of

characterization. Though symbols may be interpreted to suit ones personal

opinions, Moore makes suitable use of evident symbols. With a distinct

disadvantage, Russia failed to do any harm to the United States. Dr. Manhattan had

the ability to stop 99% of the nukes headed towards the US and the ability to read

into the future. The Arms Race was prolonged but the use of clocks throughout the

graphic novel indicated the severity of what could perhaps be the end of the world.

Bloody clocks are efficiently placed within the books chapters (1). These clocks tick

down one minute per issue till they hit midnight on issue 12. This is a clear

representation of the constant movement towards the end (midnight or total doom).

To draw emphasis there is drips of fresh blood, symbolizing the already atrocious

struggle and foreshadowing a gory future. Some clocks alert us when its’ hands hit

twelve. It is to make you wary of your use of time because you never know when

ones clock will hit 12(death). The smiley face badge in Watchmen also makes

reference to the clocks. The blood represents the hand of the clock, one that is fairly

close to reaching midnight. This symbol is crucial to the novel and is the cause of a

lot of emotional disturbances that tie together in efficiency. Laurie yells, “had seven

scotches inside me, one in my hand… I let him have it!” (21). The scotch that

proceeds to fall makes its way onto a smiley face badge in the shape of the blood.

The face represents the happy exterior individuals flaunt, but the blood and the

scotch represent our ugly stored emotions. Moore make note that imperfection is

relatable and inability to manage time is just as well. By adding depth, the story can

pick up an extra intimate meaning for the reader. The strong symbols make the

3

Page 4: Watchmen : Society’s Genuine Critique

Ramos

graphic novel an analytical medium but the theme translates the upmost vital

message.

Watchmen’s theme is direct and concise, good triumphs over evil. The efficiency

of the theme is due to Moore’s interpretation of evil. Rorschach is depicted as

morally abiding citizen. He makes it clear that no amount of corruption can delay

justice, yet one individual’s perception of justice can easily be another’s venality.

Aware of The Comedians death Rorschach articulates,

Dog carcass in alley this morning, tire tread on burst stomach. This city is afraid

of me. I have seen its true face. The streets are extended gutters and the gutters

are full of blood and when the drains finally scab over, all the vermin will

drown. The accumulated filth of all their sex and murder will foam up about

their waists and all the whores and politicians will look up and shout "Save

us!"... and I'll look down and whisper "No." They had a choice, all of them. They

could have followed in the footsteps of good men like my father or President

Truman. Decent men who believed in a day's work for a day's pay. Instead they

followed the droppings of lechers and communists and didn't realize that the

trail led over a precipice until it was too late. Don't tell me they didn't have a

choice. Now the whole world stands on the brink, staring down into bloody Hell,

all those liberals and intellectuals and smooth-talkers... and all of a sudden

nobody can think of anything to say. (1)

Who is deemed worthy of validating whether or not the politicians are good and not

evil? What indicates that police will not do wrong? Universally, the answer is

nothing. For no two people can come to same conclusion of good and evil.

4

Page 5: Watchmen : Society’s Genuine Critique

Ramos

Justifications are intended to be necessary in order to validate such accusations.

Alan Moore shows that the real world does not work like that. Mr. Moore shows

Ozymandian’s scheme and lets the reader decide if it was good. He implies that one

must live by a social contract in which one gives up a little for the greater good.

Watchmen’s theme attributes to the success because it is clear theme with an

ambiguous interpretation.

In Watchmen, Moore effectively keeps the reader tangled in his novel with his

characterization, symbolism and theme. All together Moore pulls his best literary

elements forth which result in the effective graphic novel, Watchmen. The

multidimensional characters, dark symbols, and themes of justice piece together a

novel worthy of recognition. One cannot alter time or the subsequent consequences

of ones actions, but one can rewrite the future as Moore brilliantly did.

5