treasure island planning and zoning board city hall

87
TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL AUDITORIUM - 120 108 th AVENUE TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 AT 2:00 PM 1. MEETING CALLED TO ORDER BY PRESIDING OFFICER 2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 3. CELL PHONE ANNOUNCEMENT 4. ROLL CALL TIM BUTLER DENNIS FAGAN (CHAIRPERSON) RICHARD HARRIS KEVIN JOHNSON JOHN LAYNE JIM LORENZ (VICE-CHAIR) FRANK MCCONNELL DARRELL MEACHUM SALEENE PARTRIDGE GUY PETIX MITCHELL SHENKMAN DAN YOUNKMAN STEVE YOST 5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES DECEMBER 18, 2014 (Revised) and JANUARY 15, 2015 6. EX PARTE COMMUNICATION DISCLOSURE 7. ADMINISTRATION OF WITNESS OATH 8. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS: a. Case No. PZ-2015-08V A marine variance to increase the combined maximum width for a residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet at 11775 7 th St. East (RU-75) b. Case No. PZ-2015-09V A variance to reduce the southeastern side yard setback from 10 feet to 8.6 inches to install a pergola at 11120 8 th St. East (RU-75) c. Case No. PZ-2015-10V A variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth at 8490 West Gulf Boulevard on the Gulf of Mexico. (RM-15) d. Case No. PZ-2015-11SM A site plan modification to a single family property located at 8490 West Gulf Blvd., along the Gulf of Mexico. The applicant proposes to extend the perimeter wall and relocate the landscape water feature on the site. (RM-15) 9. REPORTS AND COMMENTS OF CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF, AND BOARD MEMBERS 10. NEXT PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD MEETING THURSDAY, MARCH 19, 2015 AT 2 P.M. 11. ADJOURNMENT Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by phone at 727- 547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed.

Upload: doandiep

Post on 06-Jan-2017

217 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

CITY HALL AUDITORIUM - 120 108th AVENUE

TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA

THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 AT 2:00 PM

1. MEETING CALLED TO ORDER BY PRESIDING OFFICER

2. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE

3. CELL PHONE ANNOUNCEMENT

4. ROLL CALL

TIM BUTLER DENNIS FAGAN (CHAIRPERSON) RICHARD HARRIS KEVIN JOHNSON JOHN LAYNE JIM LORENZ (VICE-CHAIR) FRANK MCCONNELL DARRELL MEACHUM SALEENE PARTRIDGE GUY PETIX MITCHELL SHENKMAN DAN YOUNKMAN STEVE YOST

5. APPROVAL OF MINUTES – DECEMBER 18, 2014 (Revised) and JANUARY 15, 2015

6. EX PARTE COMMUNICATION DISCLOSURE

7. ADMINISTRATION OF WITNESS OATH

8. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS:

a. Case No. PZ-2015-08V A marine variance to increase the combined maximum width for a residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet at 11775 7

th St. East (RU-75)

b. Case No. PZ-2015-09V A variance to reduce the southeastern side yard setback from 10

feet to 8.6 inches to install a pergola at 11120 8th

St. East (RU-75)

c. Case No. PZ-2015-10V A variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth at 8490 West Gulf Boulevard on the Gulf of Mexico. (RM-15)

d. Case No. PZ-2015-11SM A site plan modification to a single family property located at 8490 West Gulf Blvd., along the Gulf of Mexico. The applicant proposes to extend the perimeter wall and relocate the landscape water feature on the site. (RM-15)

9. REPORTS AND COMMENTS OF CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF, AND BOARD MEMBERS

10. NEXT PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD MEETING – THURSDAY, MARCH 19, 2015 AT 2 P.M.

11. ADJOURNMENT

Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by phone at 727-547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed.

Page 2: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1 P & Z minutes 12/18/2014

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

MINUTES Thursday, December 18, 2014

1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 2. ROLL CALL Tim Butler Absent Dennis Fagan (Chairperson) Present Richard Harris Present Cecil Hersey Absent Kevin Johnson Present John Layne Present Jim Lorenz (Vice-Chair) Absent Frank McConnell Present Darrell Meachum Present Saleene Partridge Present Guy Petix Present Susan M. Reiter Absent Mitchell Shenkman Present Steve Yost Present Dan Younkman Present

The Chairperson called the meeting to order at 2:03 pm. Present were the City Attorney, Maura Kiefer, the CI Director, Paula Cohen and the City Planner, Michelle Orton. It was noted that Mr. Hersey, Mr. Lorenz and Ms. Reiter have reported their absence.

3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:

Motion was made by Mr. Butler and seconded by Ms. Partridge to approve the minutes of the meeting of November 20, 2014 as printed. Upon a voice vote the motion was passed unanimously.

4. EX PARTE COMMUNICATION:

There was no Ex Parte communication reported. 5. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH:

All applicants, witnesses, members of staff and other persons wishing to address any item before the Board of quasi-judicial nature were duly sworn.

Page 3: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2 P & Z minutes 12/18/2014

6. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS:

A. [PZ-2014-32–SR – Site Plan Review ]- New Florida Property Rental, LLC, 275 104th Avenue, is requesting a site plan review for a new 4 unit multi-family structure, accessory garage and swimming pool along the Boca Ciega Bay. Resort Facilities Medium (RFM-30).

The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. The applicant’s agent, Hani Matta, addressed the Board and offered a review of the site plan. There were no public comments.

ACTION:

Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Mr. Butler to approve the site plan in accordance with subject site plan and subject to staff conditions. Upon roll call the vote to approve the motion was unanimous.

B. [PZ-2014-35-SM – Site Plan Modification] – PV-Treasure Island, LLC,

10681 Gulf Boulevard is requesting a site plan modification for an existing commercial strip center. Planned Redevelopment-Mixed Use (PR-MU Core)

The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. Board discussion ensued expressing a concern with the location of the proposed handicapped parking space, the outside dining area and the use of the second floor office space. The applicant, Meagan Vieren, addressed the Board and answered questions of the Board. Public Comments: Ms. Mel Lenehan, 8251 Bayshore Dr., addressed the Board and expressed a concern with traffic but stressed the need for improvement of the building and encouraged approval of the project. Public comments closed.

Page 4: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3 P & Z minutes 12/18/2014

Upon a request for clarification from Mr. Shenkkman regarding signage, the applicant responded that signage details have not been determined.

ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Ms. Partridge to approve the site plan modification in accordance with the submitted site plan excluding signage and subject to staff conditions. Mr. Meachum questioned the accuracy of the submitted site plan and the fact that the applicant has not determined signage criteria. The applicants architect addressed the Board and stated that the site plan submitted is a general representation of the planned project and the criteria for signage will be followed. Upon a question from Mr. McConnell regarding the prospect of another doorway being established to allow the handicapped parking to be moved further east, the applicants architect responded that there will be new doors installed but the doorways will remain on the Gulf Boulevard side but that there has been discussion pertaining to moving the handicapped parking further east. Upon a statement by Mr. McConnell in which he asked that if the approval was of the present figuration or a similar configuration which permitted the handicapped parking further to the east, could that be done without the submission of a new site plan, the CI Director responded that this could be included in the motion if the first and second persons agreed to amend the motion. Mr. Harris stated that since he made the original motion he has no objection to the idea of the modification of moving two spaces easterly and if this is possible it could be included in his motion. Further discussion included statements by the Chair that the modification would be according to code and from Ms. Partridge indicating that perhaps one of the windows could be made into a door and Mr. McConnell stating that the reconfiguration is not a requirement but that the applicant is permitted to the reconfiguration if allowed by code without presenting a new site plan. The Chair then asked Mr. Harris if this is how he wishes to amend his motion and Mr. Harris responded that it is and Ms. Partridge agreed.

Page 5: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4 P & Z minutes 12/18/2014

Further discussion ensued with Mr. Yost requesting clarification regarding the eastern alley as it is indicated on the plans and the CI Director responded that the alley in question is privately owned. The discussion then continued with Mr. Shenkman and Mr. Butler expressing a concern with the parking requirements if an eating establishment were to be a new tenant and were informed by the CI Director that parking requirements are a City Commission decision. Mr. Meachum than wished to confirm that the motion about to be approved is the site plan modification as proposed with the exception of signage and a caveat that if the owner wished to move the handicapped spots to the east they may do so without again coming before the Board. The Chair then added to include staff recommendations.

Mr. Harris agreed and Ms. Partridge agreed to amend the motion to include the caveat that if the owner wished to modify the handicapped parking spots there would be no need for a new site plan to be presented to the Board. Upon roll call the vote to approve the amended motion was unanimous.

C. [PZ-2014-36-SM – Site Plan Modification] – Jeffrey and Holly Pohler, 8484

West Gulf Boulevard, are requesting a site plan modification to a single family property along the Gulf of Mexico to install a swimming pool, deck and fence in the waterfront yard. Residential Medium (RM-15) The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board The applicant, Jeff Pohler, addressed the Board and indicated that there are no objections to the pool from neighbors. There were no public comments.

ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Yost and seconded by Mr. Harris to approve the site plan modification as presented with staff recommendations. Upon roll call the vote to approve the motion was unanimous.

Page 6: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5 P & Z minutes 12/18/2014

7. REPORTS AND COMMENTS FROM THE CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF AND BOARD MEMBERS:

The Chair wished to open discussion regarding the PD and upon a suggestion from the City Attorney the Chair decided to instead begin the LPA meeting with the discussion regarding the PD since it is an LPA item.

The CI Director informed the Board that there are seven cases for the January15, 2014 meeting and would like to see a full Board in attendance.

The Chair announced that Ms. Reiter has submitted her resignation effective December 22, 2014 due to a planned relocation.

8. NEXT MEETING:

The next regularly scheduled P & Z meeting will be Thursday, January 15, 2015 at 2:00 pm.

9. ADJOURNMENT:

Motion was made to adjourn the meeting.

The meeting was adjourned at 3:22 pm.

A. J. Sarko Dennis Fagan Recording Secretary Chairperson

Page 7: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

MINUTES Thursday, January 15, 2015

1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE 2. ROLL CALL Tim Butler Present Dennis Fagan (Chairperson) Present Richard Harris Present Cecil Hersey Absent Kevin Johnson Present John Layne Present Jim Lorenz (Vice-Chair) Present Frank McConnell Present Darrell Meachum Present Saleene Partridge Present Guy Petix Absent Mitchell Shenkman Present Steve Yost Absent (arrived 2:20 pm) Dan Younkman Present

The Chairperson called the meeting to order at 2: 05 pm. Present were the City Attorney, Maura Kiefer, the CI Director, Paula Cohen and the City Planner, Michelle Orton. It was noted that Mr. Hersey and Mr. Petix have reported their absence.

3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES:

The minutes of the meeting of December 18, 2014 were tabled upon a request by Mr. Meachum to report the discussion prior to the amended motion made in case PZ-2014-35-SM on page 2 in order to clarify the motion. The Chair requested a review of the meeting’s electronic record and then to include the discussion.

4. EX PARTE COMMUNICATION:

There was no Ex Parte communication reported. 5. ADMINISTRATION OF OATH:

All applicants, witnesses, members of staff and other persons wishing to address any item before the Board of quasi-judicial nature were duly sworn.

Page 8: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

6. PRESENTATION OF ITEMS:

A. [PZ-2015-01–SE – Special Exception ]- Biel Reo, LLC, 9700 West Gulf Boulevard is requesting a Special Exception Use for a single family structure in the Commercial General zoning district. Commercial General (CG) The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. There were no public comments:

ACTION:

Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Ms. Partridge to approve the Special Exception request as presented with all conditions set by staff. Upon roll call the vote to approve the Special Exception was unanimous

B. [PZ-2015-02-V – Variance] –Biel Reo, LLC, 9700 West Gulf Boulevard is

requesting a variance to reduce the north side yard setback along 97th Avenue from 10 feet to 7.5 feet. Commercial General (CG)

The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. Public Comments: Mr.Sierra, 117 86th Avenue, addressed the Board on the issue of variances and noting a trend to grant variances especially for utility platforms and accessories for new residential construction. Mr. Sierra objects to the side yard being obstructed which he feels is a safety concern and the platforms should be built in the buildable area. Public comments closed. The applicant’s agent Mr. James Deitch, 3840 Land O Lakes Blvd., Land O Lakes, FL addressed the Board to explain the positioning of the home. Board discussion ensued regarding the need to sometimes grant variances for accessories and also the specifications of Duke Energy for electrical service.

Page 9: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Mr. Butler to approve the variance as requested and in accordance with staff recommendations and conditions. Upon roll call the vote to approve the variance request was unanimous.

C. [PZ-2015-03-SR – Site Plan Review] –Biel Reo, LLC, 9700 West Gulf

Boulevard is requesting a Site Plan Review for a single family structure along the Gulf of Mexico located at 9700 West Gulf Boulevard. Commercial General (CG)

The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. Mr. Butler called attention to the error in referring to case PZ-2015-03-SR as case PZ-2015-03-SP. This error stands corrected. Mr. Johnson requested clarification on the method of construction regarding the pilings. Mr. James Deitch, the applicant’s agent, stated that the design criteria will be determined at the time the property is engineered along with the soil conditions and explained the proposed process for the pilings. There were no public comments.

ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Ms. Partridge to approve the site plan as presented in case PZ-2015-03-SP and in accordance with staff conditions. Mr. Yost requested clarification regarding whether the case referred to is SR or SP. The Chair requested the motion be amended to indicate the case be identified as PZ-2015-03-SR. Mr. Harris and Ms. Partridge agreed to amend the motion to identify the Site Plan Review as PZ-2015-03-SR. Upon roll call the vote to approve the Site Plan Review was unanimous.

Page 10: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

D. [PZ-2015-04-V – Variance] –GFG Alliance, LLC, 200 115th Avenue, is

requesting a variance to reduce the waterfront setback from 20 feet to 10 feet to install a 10 foot x 28 foot prefabricated aluminum panel to serve as a cantilevered overhang. Residential Medium (RM-15) The CI Director offered a Verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. The applicant, Francis Lizardo, 200 115th Ave., addressed the Board and explained the conversion of the house into a single family residence and offered a video presentation which indicated the position of the home and the area where the overhang is proposed. Mr. Lizardo emphasized that this is strictly a need for shade and not to add to livable space. Mr. Lizardo then answered questions of the Board. Public Comments: The spouse of the applicant, Ms. Olga Lizardo, 200 115th Ave., addressed the Board to express their desire to retire in Treasure Island and to enjoy the property. Mr. Philip Lewis, 190 115th Ave., an abutting neighbor, addressed the Board stating that he supports the proposed project and has no concern with the overhang but does have a concern of a future enclosed area. Mr. Jeff Hayden, 210 115th Ave, an abutting neighbor, addressed the Board and stated that he supports the overhang project. Mr. Rusty Peck, 5 Island Dr. the realtor and friend of the Lizardo’s, addressed the Board and stated that the overhang is needed. The Chair then read into the record an e-mail from Richard Birnbaum in which he objects to the overhang project and listed six reasons. Mr. Peck again addressed the Board and stated that he has represented Mr. Birnbaum in some real estate issues and that this overhang has no impact on his property. Mr. Hayden again addressed the Board and stated that he believes that Mr. Lazardo is an architect and that he will make the building beautiful. Mr. Lewis again addressed the Board and stated that he is totally in support of the overhang. Public Comments Closed:

Page 11: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

Board discussion ensued with Mr. Shenkman and Mr. Butler stating their reasons for granting the variance and Mr. Meachum reminding the Board that a requirement for granting a variance is proving a hardship and that the request is more than needed for reasonable use. Mr. Harris suggested a retractable awning and finds no hardship exists. Mr. McConnell has a concern with the hardship and minimal variance for reasonable use. Mr. Yost stated that the hardship is the waterfront footage and suggested a five foot awning. Mr. Lorenz agreed with the mentioned issues and suggested the applicant table the variance request and return after consideration of an alternative. The applicant, Mr. Lizardo again addressed the Board stating the issues with a retractable awning and noted that the project meets code and that he wants to move forward with the project. ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Mr. Meachum to deny the variance request as presented due to the fact that there is no hardship. Upon roll call the vote to deny the variance was 9 ayes and 3 nays (Mr. Butler, Ms. Partridge and Mr. Shenkman the dissenting votes)

Board recessed at 3:35 pm Board reconvened at 3:45 pm

E. [PZ-2015-06-SE – Special Exception] –Treas Island, LLC, 10800 Gulf Boulevard is requesting a Special Exception to permit incidental services used in connection with the hotel including restaurant and lounge and similar uses at 10800 Gulf Boulevard. Resort Facilities High (RFH-50) The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. There were no public Comments ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Ms. Partridge to approve the Special Exception as presented. Upon roll call the vote to approve was unanimous.

Page 12: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

6 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

F. [PZ-2015-07-SR – Site Plan Review] –Treas Island, LLC, 10800 Gulf

Boulevard is requesting a Site Plan Review for a new 77 unit hotel and swimming pool along the Gulf of Mexico located at 10800 Gulf Boulevard. Resort Facilities High (RFH-50) The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. The applicant’s agent, Attorney Kenneth Kaleel of Ocean properties, Delray Beach, addressed the Board and described other hotels presently operated by Ocean properties and then discussed the proposed project. Mr. David Bell, architect for the applicant answered questions of the Board. Mr. Kaleel thanked the Board. There were no public comments. ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Butler and seconded by Mr. Harris to approve the Site Plan as presented with staff conditions and an additional condition requesting an FDOT drainage permit or a permit exemption provided to the City prior to construction. Upon roll call the vote to approve the Site Plan was unanimous. [The Chair having to leave the meeting turned the gavel to the Vice-Chair who then resumed the meeting.] Ms. Partridge also left the meeting. Board recessed at 4:35 pm Board reconvened at 4:45 pm

G. [PZ-2015-05-V – Variance] –Tom and Melinda Lair, 8715 East Bay Dr., are

requesting a variance to reduce the north side yard setback from 7.5 feet to 2.5 feet to install a Duke Energy meter, stairs and platform 2 feet above the base flood elevation. Residential Medium (RM-15) The CI Director offered a verbal presentation of the staff report and answered questions of the Board. The CI Director wished to describe exactly what happened with this particular location.

Page 13: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

7 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

Ms. Cohen noted that the plans came forth from the designer and staff had received notice from Duke Energy that there was an issue with the electric meter. Staff then requested that the designer comply with the Duke Energy platform requirements. The CI Director explained the reasons for the Duke Energy requirements and noted that it is a safety issue. Ms. Cohen noted that when the design came back the meter was located on the back porch with access by a spiral staircase which according to Duke Energy is unacceptable. Ms. Cohen explained that at this point construction had progressed to where the options for a utility platform were limited. The applicants Melinda and Tom Lair addressed the Board to explain their situation and noted that they have no intention of enclosing the platform and stair area. Public Comments: Mr. Sierra, 117 86th Ave., addressed the Board and stated that he objects to the variance encroachment in the side yard and that the owner has a responsibility to research these items when considering building a custom home. Public Comments closed. The applicant, Mr. Lair, offered three e-mails from Mr. & Mrs. Zink, 8665 East Bay Dr., Mr. Fitzgerald, 8685 E. Bay Dr. and Ms. Pam Tushaus to the Vice-Chair to be read into the record with all supporting the variance. ACTION: Motion was made by Mr. Harris and seconded by Mr. Yost to approve the variance as presented and in accordance with staff conditions and an additional condition that no enclosure is permitted beneath the platform or stairs. Upon roll call the vote to approve the variance was unanimous

Page 14: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

8 P & Z minutes 01/15/2015

7. REPORTS AND COMMENTS FROM THE CITY ATTORNEY, STAFF AND BOARD MEMBERS:

The CI Director announced that there will be no LPA meetings in the month of February.

8. NEXT MEETING:

The next regularly scheduled P & Z meeting will be Thursday, February 19, 2015 at 2:00 pm.

9. ADJOURNMENT:

Motion was made to adjourn the meeting.

The meeting was adjourned at 5:15 pm.

A. J. Sarko Dennis Fagan Recording Secretary Chairperson Jim Lorenz Vice-Chair

Page 15: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND

PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

120 - 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706

Telephone (727) 547-4575; Fax (727) 547-4584

CASE NO. PZ-2015-08-V STAFF REPORT

Thursday, February 19, 2015 at 2:00 p.m. Planning and Zoning Board

PROPERTY Ronald Schmidt OWNER: 11775 7th Street, East Treasure Island, FL 33706 AGENT: Tampa Dock and Seawall 5409 S West Shore Blvd. Tampa, FL 33611 DESCRIPTION: A variance request to increase the combined maximum width for a

residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet. GENERAL INFORMATION:

Location: 11775 7th Street, East Land Use: Residential Urban

Zoning: RU-75 Adjacent Property (Use):

North: 11855 7th St. – single family house 715 119th St. - single family house

South: 11755 7th St. – single family house

East: Boca Ciega Bay West: 7th St. right-of-way 11770 7th St. – single family house 11800 7th St. - single family house

Page 16: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2

Lot Area: Approx. 10,790+/- square feet Waterfront Width: Approx. 103 feet Flood Zone: AE 11, Flood Insurance Rate Map

Community Panel No. 12103C0194G, September 3, 2003.

Site Legal: CAPRI ISLE BLK U, LOT 3

Parcel #: 14-31-15-13320-021-0030 BACKGROUND: The applicant purchased the property in 1997. On the subject lot is a single family home and swimming pool. The current waterfront structures include an 8 foot wide dock x 30 foot long dock and a 3 foot wide x 30 foot long catwalk. The applicant intends to lengthen the catwalk 16 feet and attach a new 20,000 lb. boatlift within 3 feet of the neighboring side property line. Outside of the purview of the Planning and Zoning Board, a property owner can obtain the notarized signature of a neighbor permitting the marine structure to come closer to the property line. In this case, the neighbor will be requested to allow the setback for the marine structure to be reduced from 20 feet to 3 feet.

Pertinent regulations pertaining to Marine Structures Chapter 69 - MARINE STRUCTURES AND COMMERCIAL FISHING DIVISION 1. - GENERALLY Excerpt from Sec. 69-32. - Definitions Private dock dwelling, single-family means any dock which will be used by an individual owner, his family and friends, or means any single structure dock facility which provides dockage for a duplex type residential unit. This definition is not to include docks servicing zero lot line attached units. A private dock shall not be used for the production of income. Catwalk means a narrow dock with a minimum width of 24 inches and a maximum width of 36 inches. Dock means any structure, otherwise known as a pier, wharf or loading platform which is constructed on piling over open water or which is supported by floatation on the water. Service catwalk means a structure on pilings over open water similar to a dock. The service catwalk shall be a minimum of two feet wide, a maximum of three feet wide and

Page 17: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3

used solely in conjunction with a boat lift for servicing the boat and lift. This structure shall the considered part of the boat lift. ARTICLE II. - MARINE STRUCTURES DIVISION 3. - CONSTRUCTION AND MAINTENANCE Excerpt from Sec. 69-71. - Docks, davits, boat lifts and boats.

(a) Maximum width, length and position of docks, davits, boat lifts and tiepoles. (1) All docks to be constructed on waterfront property of less than 60-foot frontage must be located so that no portion of the proposed dock is closer to either extended property line than one-third of the waterfront measurement. All docks to be constructed on waterfront property of more than 60-foot frontage must be located so that no portion of the proposed dock is less than 20 feet from either adjacent extended property line. Docks located on waterfront property on the inside corner of a canal may be located not closer than five feet from either adjacent extended property line.

(2) All docks, not to include boatlifts and davits, shall be constructed so that the width of same shall not exceed 25 percent of the width of the property involved at the waterfront. Residential docks and boat lifts shall be limited to a combined maximum width of 35 feet. The length of docks shall not exceed a maximum length of 50 feet, including tie-poles. Catwalks shall have a minimum width of 24 inches and a maximum width of 36 inches.

(3) All davits and lifts shall comply with all setback and locational requirements of docks.

(4) All tiepoles shall be located within the extension of the side property lines, project not farther above the surface of the water than is reasonably necessary for their use, and in no case higher than ten feet above mean high water. Tiepoles shall be located no more than 50 feet from the seawall.

(5) Docks shall be constructed so that no portion of the deck projects above the level of the seawall cap more than 12 inches.

(6) The location of all docks, including the measurements, limitations and restricted area in which docks are not permitted, shall be in accordance with the requirements of Exhibit A, attached hereto and incorporated herein, which, along with its locations, measurements, limitations and restricted area is incorporated in this Code.

(7) All docks, davits, lifts or tiepoles, as permitted, shall be located so as not to interfere with the riparian rights of adjacent properties.

(8) All boats and personal watercrafts moored at a private dock shall be located so as not to interfere with the riparian rights of adjacent properties.

Page 18: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4

(d) Number of docks.

Private docks. A private dock shall not be used to accommodate more than two boats for permanent mooring. No more than one dock structure shall be located at any dwelling, single-family, with the exception of service catwalks. Catwalks and service catwalks will be considered part of the private dock and shall be included in the width calculations for the total dock structure.

DIVISION 4. - VARIANCES Sec. 69-91. - Procedure. (a) Requests for variances from the requirements of this chapter shall be heard by the planning and zoning board. No variance may be granted unless the applicant establishes, by substantial competent evidence, that:

(1) A literal enforcement of the provisions of this article would result in extreme hardship due to the unique nature of the project and the applicant's property;

(2) The variance being sought to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the applicant's property; and

(3) The granting of the requested variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the chapter and will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental or of adverse effect to the public interest and welfare.

(b) In granting any variance, the planning and zoning board may prescribe appropriate conditions and safeguards.

(c) The planning and zoning board shall prescribe a reasonable time limit not to exceed one year within which the action for which the variance is granted shall be initiated.

(d) Variances shall not be deemed to set precedence for other applications should they be either standard applications or those requiring variances.

(e) In no event shall the planning and zoning board grant variances permitting construction of structures which interfere with or violate the riparian rights of adjacent properties.

STAFF ANALYSIS:

(1) A literal enforcement of the provisions of this article would result in extreme hardship due to the unique nature of the project and the applicant's property.

Page 19: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5

Applying the regulation to this location does not diminish the applicant’s opportunity to use the waterfront. The applicant currently has the maximum number of permanent mooring locations on the lot.

(2) The variance being sought to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the applicant's property.

The applicant has reasonable use of the lot and the waterfront of the property. The maximum number of permanent mooring spaces for a private residential home is two. The applicant currently has 2 permanent mooring spaces.

(3) The granting of the requested variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the chapter and will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental or of adverse effect to the public interest and welfare.

It is unlikely that the property owner at 11755 7th Street will object to the wider marine structure. According to the applicant, he has spoken to the property owners of 11755 7th St and expects them to sign off on the reduction in setback from 20 feet to 3 feet for the new 20,000 lb. boat lift. Without the signature of the owners at 11755 7th St, a formal variance from the Planning and Zoning Board must be obtained prior to the installation of the new boat lift.

The variance request does not appear to be similar with the pattern of marine structure sizes in Treasure Island. As one looks at an aerial of the City (especially at the end of the “fingers”), it does not appear that this variance request for the waterfront structure to be greater than 35 feet to be in harmony with lots in the city with a much greater waterfront width. Staff included a series of aerial photos of large lots along the waterfront. These photos illustrate that wider marine structures are not necessarily associated with lots with a wider waterfront width.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends DENIAL of the request for a marine variance to increase the

combined maximum width for a residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet:

There are two permanent mooring spaces on this site. Therefore, the maximum

number of permanent mooring spaces is already available at this single family

home.

The maximum width for a marine structure is the same for all private single family

residential properties in the City, without regard to the waterfront width. The

Page 20: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

6

maximum width regulation is applied equally to all lots bordering Boca Ciega

Bay, Johns’ Pass and Blind’s Pass.

This is not in harmony with other marine structures in the City.

If the Planning and Zoning Board members wish TO APPROVE the request for a

marine variance to increase the combined maximum width for a residential dock and

boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet, the findings would be:

The property owner has a wider waterfront width than most lots and would desire

to have a greater expanse of marine structures on the site.

The increase in the width of the marine structures on this site will not likely be

injurious to the other boaters or other properties in the vicinity.

Pursuant to Sec. 10-221 (g) The granted variance shall be valid for one year. To remain

in effect after one year, one of the following must have occurred:

(1) An extension of time has been approved by the approving body;

(2) Building permits relating to the requested variance have either been applied for or granted; or

(3) A site plan review relating to the requested variance has been applied for or approved by the planning and zoning board.

Any requests for an extension of time relating to a variance(s) must be in writing and

received by the city manager or specified designee at least three weeks prior to its

expiration date in order for the request to be placed on the approving body's agenda.

CASE PZ 2015-08V A variance request to increase the combined maximum width for a residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet. Planning and Zoning Board Action:

[ ] Approved [ ] Denied [ ] Deferred [ ] Approved with Conditions

Page 21: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Case Number: fzms-c&^l City of Treasure Island

Development Review Application Please use blue or black ink only. Failure to complete this form in its entirety will result in this application being returned without review. Note: A separate application is required for each request.

Owners' *7cWv\'^

Address \y\-y? £• IMW-. jv WW* phone MA- 'bw- <\

Fax

Agent ^OM\A ̂ (k DtX^- ^

Address ,9\oc^ uJeA>Wo "Vi W/i\

Phone

Fax

Email Vohw I Email ONev\| ^

List all Legal Owner(s) of Property: V-ovulA (^(V\\| 9 cV\w\> it

Complete legal description (may be placed on attached separate page): C.iX.^Vn \^\l ^ \A^

Development Name:

Site Location/Address: u-tw ^ ft. g. fekvA tu. Sfrvoy Area of Development (Acreage or Square Feet)

Parcel Identification Number (list all): \W^l t>y\ joQ-ho Application Request tyVtrA rtai- V^ov\l .^v,W\»oC\muw\ %' ijjJ-b

Future Land Use Designation,

Current Zoning T^S\^(V\\\(L\

Proposed Future Land Use

Proposed Zoning

I certify that I have reviewed the Land Development Regulations and that my submission meets all requirements. The only exceptions are those items to which I am requesting variances to or waivers from certain sections of the code and understand that they must be listed on the plans individually and on the attached transmittal. I understand that if an item does need a variance, it will be necessary to file through the appropriate review entity.

Signature must be original (No copies, scans, faxes ore-mails)

Owner/Agent Date

Page 22: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Narrative Due to the upland property being located at the end of the canal and given the location of the existing slip, the size of the applicant's vessel and the existing location of the adjacent property owners lift and dock, the proposed location for the lift makes for the safest place to set the applicant's lift. There is also a previously permitted wet slip in the location where the proposed boat lift would be going. Based on these unique conditions a literal enforcement of the provision would result in an extreme hardship.

By placing the lift in the location of the wet slip would be the minimum amount of space that could be used based on the unique nature of the property. The neighbor whom the variance is affecting has seen and signed off on the proposed location of the boat lift.

The purpose of the setback requirements is to ensure that one neighbor's use of his own riparian rights does not impair the other neighbor's exercise of their rights. The proposed variance would not impair the neighbor's use o.'the waterfront in any way and the construction is well within the petitioner's property lines. The petitioners are seeking to enjoy their own riparian rights and in no way propose to encroach on the neighbors. The granting of the requested variance will be in harmony with the general intent and purpose of the chapter and will not be injurious to the area involved or otherwise detrimental or of adverse effect to the public interest and welfare.

Page 23: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

NO INSTRUMENTS OF RECORD REFLECTING EA 'ENTS, RIGHTS OF WAV, OR OWNERSHIP WERE WSHED THIS S(J RVEYOR EXCEPT AS SHOWN. ' m •" measured p=plat c = calculated d = ueed SIR = set iron rod 5/8" EIR = found iron iud FPP- found pinched pipe FCM «• found concrete monument CONC = concrete CS «= concrete slab CP = covered patio SP - screened patio FIP = found iron pip<>

, , ,=• FIELD BEARINGS BASED ON NW'L Y LOT LINE BEING IN SECTION 23 TOWNSHIP 3f RANGE ! 5 SCALE 1" = 30'

i8 "t1*.

30

$ *•% >• Wi

lot 4 lit f

W\ «*!> <*»

X

^jfc

\ * "*• \ Hv

a •s W J

> /

ft (St//) OtlU, H0i£

#-?<> • A - 1; 41' S'tS.28 {i'l 9 . '8.4j {Ml / /'/ Vi?" if*"iv

Fo>j>.<o . "X"

A/ 6? 6' Vinyl Fence -•

tf.H

Camtin

t N £WC.

(»Mt< trt

• Wcw Fen;e • fovua DIULMOI. $ 9 n

$ 6i*ty at

\

LOT 3 BLOCK U

AS RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK 49 PAGE 59 SURVEY CERTIFIED TO RONALD P. AND KATHY L. SCHMIDT

CAPRI ISLE BLOCKS U-V AND P

PUBLIC RECORDS OF PLNELLAS COUNTY FLORIDA.

CHICAGO TITLE CHASE HOME FINANCE I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THE ABOVE SURVEY MEETS MINIMUM TECHNICAL STANDARDS AS SET FORTH BY THE FLORIDA BOARD.OF PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYORS TN CHAPTER 61G17-6. FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE PURSUANT TO SECTION 472.027,FLORIDA STATUTES.

TYPE OF SURVEY JOB NUMBER DATE JilGrsATCRi. sO f ^ sJr A BOUNDARY 10717 OJ/25/OS 4 UPDATE

REVISION

INVALID WITHOUT RAISED SEAL ROBERT D. LEHART R.L.S. # 2744 7319 LEXINGTON LANE CLEARWATER ^ FLORIDA 33764 727-531-6779 FAX 536-7521

Page 24: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

J U-

v ^4 ^

3^4 -iHim •§m x 3

^—S±

\

<P

3

_i (XT^K

r

~t- Q

t Xq <S

ft J-

c&

•& in <JA v

aoo \ll>- —7LJ£

m

pO 0

1 IP 0 Q~

1 EL.

Page 25: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

DEC

DATE: :i£fl0/l4

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTM^I

120-108™ AVENUE TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706

Phone: (727) 547-4575 Fax: (727) 547-4584^^^^ Inspection Line: (727) 547-4575 ext. 431

PERMIT APPLICATION ALL WORK & MATERIALS PER FLORIDA BUILDING CODE(S) 2010; NEC 2008, FMC 2010; FPC2010, FRC2010, FFGC2010, NFPA54 & 58, PCMC SECTION 166

PERMIT QMA! ( /fk PERMIT TYPE • l)oc£ * \i PROPERTY INFORMATION:

PROJECT ADDRESS: WTIS" SV- g"-SITE LEGAL DESCRIPTION: CfrPyx Wo ^ D;U\ *h PARCEL

AL DESCRIPTION: t, gpy\ \AL- 1

.D.#-. \H | *b\ j \<f \ Wlo( OlA / OQ'bO PROPERTY OWNER: j PHONE#: r\V\\*)U0~

OWNER'S ADDRESS: 1\"T15 g CITY: 'frfflSUVC. WU/U STATE: ZIP:

CONTRACTOR INFORMATION: REGISTERED COMPANY NAME: \ SCAWfll) ADDRESS: \x)lsbW"£ HfrM- CITY: i'flWN^

PHONE: FAX: \TK QUALIFIER'S NAME: PY\[lv\n AlL

ZIP: TV /aver>[ P-Wvup^ Aor)L

STATE LICENSE#: PCCLB LICENSE#: C(^f \<l

PROJECT INFORMATION: NEW { ) ADDITION ( REMODEL ( ) OTHER ( ) DESCRIPTION / SCOPE OF WORK:. 6)l-Wyvl fflW\£ \ul av\k \y\sh\W ,?J}Kvf)\U. V)Q/i>V vfr

VALUE OF WORK: ^10, VALUE OF EXIST. STRUCTURE: OTHER PERMITS REQUIRED: BUILDING: ELECTRICAL: . PLUMBING: MECHANICAL: GAS: ROOFING: LOW VOLTAGE:,

COMMERCIAL:

RESIDENTIAL:

AREA OF WORK (S.F.) BUILDING: GARAGE: PORCH: _ OTHER:

ZONING APPROVAL (IF APPLICABLE): BUILDING DEPARTMENT APPROVAL:

C:\Users\jiensen\AppOata\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Tempofj ry Internet Files\Content.OutlookUW9ZlSFT\BLDG DEPARTMENT APPLICATION ONLY 4-l6-14.docx 4/16/14

Page 26: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

PLEASE COMPLETE SUBCONTRACTOR VERIFICATION FORM, IF APPLICABLE

PLEASE COMPLETE OWNER/BUILDER AFFIDAVIT, IF APPLICABLE

"WARNING TO OWNER: YOUR FAILURE TO RECORD A NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT MAY RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOUR PROPERTY. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING, CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORE RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT." Section 713.135(1) (a.), Florida Statutes (F.S.)

NOTICE: In addition to the work described under this permit, there may be additional requirements applicable to this property established by city, county, state and/or federal legislation. Further there may be additional permits requ'red from other governmental entities such as the water management district, state agencies, or federal agencies, Section 553.79 (10), Florida Statutes.

Any permit for demolition or renovation shall contain an asbestos notification statement which indicates the owner's or operator's responsibility to comply with the provisions of Section 469.003, F.S., and to notify the Department of Environmental Protection of his/her intentions to remove asbestos, when applicable, in accordance with state and federal law, Section 553.79(11), Florida Statutes. A letter from Pinellas County Air Quality shall also be provided.

The applicant shall file with the issuing authority, prior to the permitting, either a certified copy of the recorded notice of commencement or a notarized statement that the commencement has been filed for recording, along with a copy thereof. Section 713.13, Florida Statutes.

Owners, acting as their own contractors, are required to provide direct on site supervision of all work not being performed by licensed contractors. The owner-contractor shall not delegate any supervisory role to anyone who is not properly licensed for that scope of work. Section 489.103 Florida Statutes.

APPLICANTS ARE RESPONCIBLE FOR COMPLYING WITH THE FEDERAL AND STATE OF FLORIDA REQUIREMENTS FOR THE AMERICANS WITH DISABILITIES ACT.

, ., for violation if inspection of the property reveals that I have made additions, renovations or remodeling to the property which were not included in the permit documents.

C:\Users\jjensen\AppOata\Local\Microsoft\Windows\Temporary Internet Files\Content.Outlook\lW9ZlSFT\BLDG DEPARTMENT

SIGNATURE CONTRACTOR / AGENT: DATE:

APPLICATION ONLY 4-16-14.docx 4/16/14

Page 27: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

I#: 2014350673 BK: 18627 PG: $10.00 KEN BURKE, CLERK OF DEPUTY CLERK: CLKDMC3

31, 12/23/2014 at 11:24 AM, RECORDING 1 PAGES ^OURT AND COMPTROLLER PINELLAS ^yNTY, FL BY

PCRMtT NL'MBER

STATE OF FLORIDA-PINELLAS COUNTY I hereby certify that the foregoing Is a true

copy as recorded In the official records of Pinellas County. f\ Thls^ffi'claV of Ajtc— . 20

KEN BURKE Circuit CouiJ^Comptroller

NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT

Tlic undersigned hereby gives notice uwil improvement will he made lo certain real propem. and in accordance with Chapter 713. Florida Statutes, the following information is provided in this Notice of Commencement

1. DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY (Legal deseripii'n oi'tlie property & wwei tuidresj, if available) TAX FOLIO NO.: ______________

SUBDIVISION _14 BLOCK 31 TRACT 15 LOT13320 BLOQ021 |MTQ030

CAPRI ISLE BLK U, LOT 3

2. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENT! Build catwalk and Install boat lift

). OWNER INFORMATION OR LESSEE INFORMATION IFTHE LESSEE CONTRACTED FOR THE IMPROVEMENT:

a Njme atti address Ronald Schmidt, 11775 7th St. E., Treasure Island, FL 33706 b Imerestin propeny QWITSr

c Name and aidreu ot'fee simple (iileholder (i liiVereni from Ouner listed above)

-i a. CONTRACTOR'S NAMK Tampa Dock & Seawall Contractor'siddre» 5408 S. Westshore Blvd., Tampa, FL 33611

5 SURETY (if applicable, a cup\ ofthepasnient bond isanached)

a. Name and address __

b Phone number __ ....

0. a. LENDER'S NAME:

Lender's address.

b Phone number 813-495-7727

Amount of bnnd S

h Phone number

7. Persons within the Slate of Florida designated by Owner upon whom notices or other documents may be served as provided by Section 7l3.l3(l)(a) 7.. Florida .Statutes:

it. Nain«amf address

h Phone numbers WdesiKimed persons' _.

8. a. In addition to himself or herself Owner designates of to receive a copy of the Lienor's Notice as provided in Section 713 13 (I) lb). Florida Statutes.

b I'fcme numbef of person « entity designated by (Junei ..

9. Expiration date of notice of commencement (the expiration date will be I year from the date of recording unless a different date is specified): , 20

WARNING TO OWNER: ANY PAYMENTS MAPI- BY THE OWNER \FTcK THE EXPIRATION OF THE NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT ARF. CONSIDERED IMPROPER PAYMENTS UNDER CHAPTER 71 V PART I. SECTION 713.1X FLORIDA STATU! liS. AND CAN RESULT IN YOUR PAYING TWICE FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO YOtJR PROPERTY. A NOHCE OF COMMENCEMENT MUST BE RECORDED AND POSTED ON THE JOB SITE BEFORE THE FIRST INSPECTION. IF YOU INTEND TO OBTAIN FINANCING. CONSULT WITH YOUR LENDER OR AN ATTORNEY BEFORC COMMENClNCi WORK OR RECORDING YOUR NOTICE OF COMMENCEMENT.

Ronald Schmidt, Owner (Print Name and Provide Signatory's Title/Office) nature ofOwnn'or Ceisee, or Owner's 6r1_tss<e'$

'Authorized Officer/Dircctor/Partner/Manager)

Slate of

Coimiy of _ MMllQS -jfi The foregoing instrument was acknowledged oefore me this _|JL day efflor&fflfop/'. 20M

.» _ (name"" - " " -

for (name of parr.' on behalf of whom insuuirein was rvecufcd)

Personally Known or Produced 'dem.itimtion of Identification ProJucfd J=/ PL

(type of authority.... eg. officer, trustee, attorney in fact)

TAMMY BSELHAUSER MY COMMISSION IFF 005079

EXPIRES: April 3.2017 Bonded Thru Notaiy PuUle Ufxfctwtars

(Si (Print. Type. or S

' of Notary Public) Commissioned Name of Notary Public)

Rev IO.IVI2

Page 28: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

V

Page 29: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Direct all correspondence to:

Clerk, Water and Navigation, 5th Floor 315 Court Street Clearwater, FL 33756

Application# (OFFICIAL USE ONLY)

PRIVATE DOCK PERMIT APPLICATION

PINELLAS COUNTY WATER AND NAVIGATION

I. PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION:

A. Applicant's Name:

B. Mailing Address: \m*7> 1^ "5T. g. City: State: rU _ Zip:

C. Telephone No: "^-/O ^U^V^E-mail Address; $£? k\Cf\hA^\L- OC>KV>

II. AGENT INFORMATION: A. Name:

B. Address: : ^Qg\ *>. Wfe^*toZ£-City: -TNVAPA State: ft- _ Zip:

C. Telephone No: "gfo -nan E-mail Address:

III. SITE INFORMATION: A. Construction Site Address:

City: -TR£A-^_y2e I'TMVJO _ State: _ Zip:

B. Parcel ID Number: \^\ /3\ / \*t> / l^^ZP <P2.\ / <^03*0

C. Incorporated: £> Unincorporated: •

c IxXJk <^gW-rA ~W/V/ D, Affected Water Body:

E. Previous Permits: Ti_nn^-2_ A- P^^iO F. Date applicant assumed property ownership:

_ month/year G, Obstructions: (Dogs, Fences, etc.)

H, Attach 8 V" X 11" vicinity map showing specific project location.

I. All other information pursuant to Section 166-328, Pinellas County Code, as needed.

J. For projects requiring a public hearing, attach a copy of the complete legal description.

Page 30: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY)

IV. PROJECT DESCRIPTION:

A. Nature and Size of Project: lot- "fopeC1^1 PT & V

Square Feet: : *tb B. Variance: Yes^Sl No •

Amount in variance: Length: Width: Setbacks: Left: Right:

Other:

NOTE: It is the applicant's responsibility to clearly demonstrate that any requested variances are consistent with the variance criteria of Section 166-291 of the Pinellas County Code. The applicant must demonstrate that a literal enforcement of the regulations would result in an extreme hardship due to the unique nature of the project and the applicant's property. The hardship must not be created by action(s) of the project owner(s). The granting of the variance must be in harmony with the general intent of the regulations and not infringe upon the property rights of others. The variance requested must be the minimum possible to allow for the reasonable use of the applicant's property. Should the applicant fail to demonstrate that any variance request is consistent with the criteria outlined in the regulations, staff cannot recommend approval of the application.

V. CONTRACTOR INFORMATION: , a certified contractor,

state that the dock has not been constructed and that it will be built in compliance with all requirements and standards set forth in the Pinellas County Code, and in accordance with the attached drawings which accurately represent all thlk information .required to be furnished. In the event that this dock is not built in accordance with the permit or ma Mfonpatiorjrarnished #s not correct, I agree to either remove the dock or correct the deficiency.

Signed: H/\jV/V/ V CertNo.: <*"

Company Name: XXZJ.C- •sg/Wtu, Telephone No: ^i5>T72n City:' State: Zip: V )

E-mail Address: . C-Q K/\

VI. OWNER'S SIGNATURE: I hereby apply for a permit to do the above work and state that the same will be done according to the map or plan attached hereto and made a part hereof, and agree to abide by the criteria of the Pinellas County Code for such construction and, if said construction is within the corporate limits of a municipality, to first secure approval from said municipality. I further state that said construction will be maintained in a safe condition at all times, should this application be approved, that 1 am the legal owner of the upland from which 1 herein propose to construct the improvements, and that the above stated agent/contractor may act as my representative. I understand that I, not Pinellas County, am responsible for the accuracy of the information provided as part of this application and that it is my responsibility to obtain any necessary permits and approvals applicable for the proposed activities on either private or sovereign owned submerged land.

Date Legal Owner's Signature

Page 31: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

PRIVATE DOCK

Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY)

MHW

MLW

BOTTOM

ENG. SCALE: 1" =

Profile View

\ / .N.

Plan View (applicant and adjacent docks)

TOTAL SQUARE FEET NEW SQUARE FEET WATERWAY WIDTH WATERFRONT WIDTH ToT

1FU \\c\Xb fUT

% \

<

Pu 26 h

\r- n —i T ' |>o

lfl

PL

{—•

SHORELINE The undersigned does not object to the proposed dock and requested variances as drawn in the space provided above

Left Owner Right Owner

Signature Date Signature Date

Municipality Approval Water and Navigation Approval

Page 32: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

VARIANCE REQUEST FORM

Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY)

Left Lot Owner's Name

Mailing Address Zip

I certify that I am the owner of Lot which adjoins the property owned by the applicant who proposes to construct a dock at the following address:

I have seen the plans of the proposed structure(s) along with any requested variances (see Section IV.B of the application) and: DO OBJECT • DO NOT OBJECT • to the proposed construction.

OWNER'S SIGNATURE: Date

NOTARY: STATE OF FLORTDA, PINELLAS COUNTY, BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared

, well known to me, or who provided a valid Florida Driver's License to be the person who executed the foregoing instrument and that he/she acknowledged to me, under oath, that he/she signed the same freely and voluntarily for the purposes expressed therein.

Witness my hand and official seal this day of , 20

Notary Public

My commission expires:

Right Lot Owner's Name UytvAkg- &<vAPSAPA. Mailing Address \VY*S> JE* Zip _

T certify that I am the owner of Lot Z which adjoins the property owned by the applicant who proposes to construct a dock at the following address:

1 \"rfe TBs <=,-y.u> T have seen the plans of the proposed structure(s) along with any requested variances (see Section IV.B of the application) and: DO OBJECT • DO NOT OBJECT to the proposed construction.

OWNER'S SIGNATURE: _ Date

NOTARY: STATE OF FLORIDA, PTNELLAS COUNTY, BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, personally appeared

, well known to me, or who provided a valid Florida Driver's License to be the person who executed the foregoing instrument and that he/she acknowledged to me, under oath, that he/she signed the same freely and voluntarily for the purposes expressed therein.

Witness my hand and official seal this day of , 20

Notary Public

My commission expires:

Page 33: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Application # (OFFICIAL USE ONLY)

DISCLOSURE FORM

In order to alleviate any potential conflict of interest with Pinellas County staff, it is required that the County be provided with a listing of PERSONS being party to a trust, corporation, or partnership, as well as anyone who may have beneficial interest in the application which would be affected by any decision rendered by the County (attach additional sheets if necessary).

A. PROPERTY OWNERS:

Name: Name: _ Address: \\-r\£> -rth.c3rx-Address:

Name: _ Address:

Name: _ Address:

B. REPRESENTATIVES:

Name: "T7W\?A A, 6^WA-U-Name; _ Address~^gVQglL iA/Pgfer4<Qgfc. 1*A4^ffldress:

Name: Name: _ Address: Address:

C. OTHER PERSONS HAVING OWNERSHIP INTEREST IN THE SUBJECT PROPERTY: Interest is: \ contingent • absolute •

Name: 1 specific interest held;

D. DOES A CONTRACT FOR SALE EXIST FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY? YES • N If so, the contract is: contingent • absolute •

Name of parties to the contract:

E. DOES AN OPTION TO PURCHASE EXIST FOR THE SUBJECT PROPERTY? YES • N< Name of parties to the option:

F. OWNER'S SIGNATURE: I hereby certify that the information stated above is complete, accurate, and true to the best of my knowledge.

X Date

Page 34: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

DAVIT MASTER ENGINEERING SPECS; ALUMINUM-2 MOTOR LIFTS Cradle lift engineering specifications

Davit Master Corporation

CUT-OUT VIEW

5560 Ulmerton Road, Ctaamater.FL 33760 1*<XW7«$60' 727-5734414 • FAX 727*572-0590

WWW.DAVTFMASTCR.COM " [email protected]

fltMnon SH 1OT 200V 300* 40V

a • g " D " TJ * '• £'• H ; ;• 'i;-;

Lift ; Capacity;

<!$*• :• Beams

LGra4|e V . '• 1 Sprcad/ ;-3^aiiacP

. .©&WS . .-

Winder: ;pCT?trinMf£

r rMtttdlpi. c

^w^MtY

Guide

- Pipis

7.000::. l5CrxS">t17 2.swx^a

f4C6Hx.1» 4TWX.29

y*«r 17Lfl.

441* » 3D 1 p«t tt ScftM 15*

2-3/7 M urtm. (2)1MP

llOr-27.2 22DM3.9

SO/9 <4) e-

r*ior 1.9**7

8* Small ei Med.-te

• iaootfc isr*«iLi7 3.5WX.23

15CT8HX-23 5"WX ja

3'*ior i* ia-

4^1 Fx 30 2 pal 9 SeMOL?

24ft* Dia 24-/Wilt (2J1HP

110*27.2 22&-13.6

eoy« (4) 3"

Tx W i.yxr

8* Srcst! a

i5or*r>tl7 2SWX.28

150* GHx.25 STWx.41

rxttf i? tfl.

4-Sfl«*x30 2 part 8 dciiSQ 1.S*

2-3nS" Oia 24VMSn. (2)1 HP

UOV-27J2 220v-1&&

50/1! (4) tr

rxicr i.yxr

Larg«- 1S Of 24*

iar*rx.i7 2.75WX.29

iB<riox.i& 4>Wx.29

T*l<r 1<Cl*

44Hr*» 2 part 9 SCM01.S1

2-3/8TD« W Mlft. 0J1-8HP t1Qv<36 220v*1$

SO/12 <*> «r

Tx Iff i^**r

Lirge- IS or 24*

^®1 iw*#v»8 7Wx.»

19T10HX.25 ffWx.4!

r*ir Iff 14

+W*3ff 2 pad 11 SchW!.S"

rota 27/MTn (2)tSHP 110*3® 22QM6

Otl 72/DU 14 (4) lor

TulS TxT

Larg«-13 Cf24*

1WXSX25 3t75"Wx.41

19T1QHX.2B 9"Wx.50

y*ir 4>7;1S*X36 2pM

4' -\2 senaour

rota 22*/Mft. ft IMP 110tr<36 22DV-I6

7tf72JTlpl 14 w icr

—r r*w r*r

Laq)«-1$ er24"

«•* *10 v» V/A H/A U**f, 2201 111 110 ia »llh

JL JL II II m.

»o» no id >«

no IS 14 12

Page 35: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

I , ft

\ *. W1

r. 4 » 1 j

t ;

.V.I

r.-c far.-

TOTAi./'' •

Wll-I

Made this 29th day ot December A.I). i'i 97 TOBY A. JOYCE, AN UNREMARRIED WIDOW

INST s 07-379260 DEC 31, 1907 3:3SP!'

hereinafter called llic itratilor, in RONALD P. SCHMIDT and KATHY L. SCHMIDT, HUSBAND AND WIFE

whitsc post office address is: 11775 7TH STREET EAST TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA 33706 Grantees' Tax Id # :

OFF

plSELLf WgUtyf BEC •Br' i '

n hereinaller called the grantee; . N

(WlicntM-r iiM.il IICICIII itw lerm "iiMiuor" anJ ,dl tlic |>iiriic.\ in I Ins inMrumcm •• _ . bars. Icy.'I rvprcNCi *;iii\c> and i>( mdiviJu^K. •HIO llic MKivs.\«>rs .UK! .ivsi^as nl c<>r|*«»r;ilinniI / s ^ _

Witncssclh, lliat the grantor, for ami in consideration of llic sum nf $10.00 , ' and other valuable considerations, receipt whereof is hercliy acknowledged. licrchv grants, InirgainV., sglis, aliens, a'nilses, releases, conveys and confirms nnin llic grantee, all that certain land situate in PINELLAS \ \ , ,

County. Florida. viz: v""— Lot 3, Block U, CAPRI ISLE BLOCKS U, V AND P, according to "the" plat thereof recorded in Plat Book 49, Page §9, Public Records of PINELLAS County, Florida. \\

SUBJECT TO Covenants, restrictions, easeavents oi-- ^ecojrd^nd taxes for the current year. \ ̂ ^ ~ - x

Said property is not the homestead,of thg Vsraptbr-ls") under the laws and constitution of the State of Flqrida iri^that neither Grantor(s) or any members of the household of Gr^ntor^s*) reside thereon. WHO RESIDES AT: 206 BOCA CIE(3A^.R0INT BfiVD #1,801, ST. PETE, FL 33708

Parcel Identification Nuu)2Ser: 14/31_/lN5_/'ll32 0/021/003 0 Together with all the tenements, hcrediiainejnis and .ipi>utf LNanciMhcretu bcloiiiiini; or in an wise appertaining. To HllVC iind lo Hoi.l, the same in lif simple lorcvej. And the urimior herein' aivcnanlsX^illvsatd^nmiyc lliaj (lie' ur.ttilor is lawfully seized of said land in fee simple;

thai the urailtur iias good riylit ami laxtftri auIh>>rity to scJI ^nui><invey said land: that llic grantor hereby lully warrants the litlc in said land and will defcnjl'llic'samc au;hijsNlic lawlul claims of all persons whomsoever; ;nnl that said land is free ot :dl encumbrances except laves accryitit; SUIISI'I^IILHI to Dcccmlier .M. I'' 97

III Witness Whereof,. Itic >rii^|'grantor liaS-signed and sealed these presents the day and year first above written. ' .' \ / Signed, sailed,in our pivscntr.

\\T0BY A

IQvA 206 BOCA CIEGA BLVD #1801 ST. PETE, FL 33708 )A.r ft t

s SLA mri \ siiito- of Florida

'CminiY of Pinellas

ni DEC-TOBY A JOYCE RECORDING i DOC STAMP - 0R219 2

The foregoing instrument was acknowledged bclon me this 29th day ol December bv " ' TOTf'i: ' TOBY A. JOYCE, AN UNREMARRIED WIDOW Af-JT, TEf'lOERhC1:

CHANGE: who is personally known to me nr who has jimtluicd DRIVERS LICENSE .

!') 97

as identification.

PREPARED BY: MARY A. BALL RECORD & RETURN TO: GOLD SERVICE TITLE INSDRANCE CO. 4762 Central Avenue St. Petersburg, FL 33711

r\ I'uhlu-S.i inc. 'mmimsi.

MAflYA BAIL

EXfllES: Aujtil 2. Ml j •••s:!5v" '""M'to Horny talk unaciwuiri

File No:97 006772

Page 36: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

11775 7th Street

2009 Aerial from Pinellas County GIS

11855

11850

750

11725

11755

11775

725

745

755700

11770

11800

11900

11950

11970

730

740

715

735

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E 119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

Page 37: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

PZ Case 2015-08 Marine Variance 11775 7th St

Treasure Island

Bing Maps – February 10, 2015

Waterfront

structures

Page 38: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

PZ 2015-08 Marine Variance 11775 7th St E

Source: Pinellas County GIS

2/10/15

11855

11850

11725

11755

11775

725

11750

11770

11800

11900

11950

720

730

740

715

735

75140 1

08

80

7575

83

13 1

20

70

120 103(S

)

75

81.2

120

75

83

14080.6

75

103(S

)

120(S

)

120

80(S)

75

70

60

7075

80(S)

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E 119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

Subject Site

Page 39: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1

LOTS WITH A LARGE WATERFRONT WIDTH -- ISLE OF CAPRI

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

7TH

ST E

126TH AVE

126TH AVE

126TH AVE

126TH AVE

126TH AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

Page 40: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2

CAPRI BLVD

CAPRI BLVD

CAPRI BLVD

CAPRI BLVD

CAPRI BLVD

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

123RD AVE

Page 41: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

119TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

116TH AVE

Page 42: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4

EXAMPLES OF LOTS WITH A LARGE WATERFRONT WIDTH - ISLE OF PALMS

8TH ST E

8TH ST E

8TH ST E

8TH ST E

8TH ST E

9TH S

T E

9TH S

T E

9TH S

T E

9TH S

T E

9TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

Page 43: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

7TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

5TH S

T E

5TH S

T E

5TH S

T E

5TH S

T E

5TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

6TH S

T E

Page 44: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

6

EXAMPLES OF LOTS WITH A LARGE WATERFRONT WIDTH IN PARADISE ISLAND

DOLPHIN D

R

DOLPHIN D

R

DOLPHIN D

R

DOLPHIN D

R

DOLPHIN D

R

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

TARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DR

4T

H S

T E

4T

H S

T E

4T

H S

T E

4T

H S

T E

4T

H S

T E

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

DP

AR

AD

ISE

BL

VD

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

3R

D S

T E

3R

D S

T E

3R

D S

T E

3R

D S

T E

3R

D S

T E TARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DRTARPON DR

TARPON DR

TARPON DR

TARPON DR

TARPON DR

TARPON DR

SANDY HOOK RD

SANDY HOOK RD

SANDY HOOK RD

SANDY HOOK RD

SANDY HOOK RD

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

HAVEN POINT DR

Page 45: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

7

145.9

90 75

148.9

75

80.

6

150

70.

1

129.5129.5147.7

60

39.2 129

.5

39.2

129

.5

142.3

39.2

60

39.2

115

138.3

77.3

115 60

75

77.1

75

132.1 135.8

60132

75.6

75.8

75.8

135 13575.6

135

75

75

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

TA

RP

ON

DR

TA

RP

ON

DR

TA

RP

ON

DR

TA

RP

ON

DR

TA

RP

ON

DR

100

7074.7

115102.9

120.1

70

69.5

127.6

95 80.1

154.9

115 100

61.1

70

70

35.8

102

.9

120.1 11074.321 5066.

8143.2

61.1

115104.3

80 37

77.3

87.9

115

40

113

.7

8085225

129

.6

10580 80

80 85

45 113

.6

80

140.1

79.8

80 106

.7

90

79.390

140

120

.1

5590 90 114

.4

125

.1

75 50

75 90133

.4

75

140.9

90 7

5

145.9

90 75

148.9

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

PA

RA

DIS

E B

LV

D

S YACHT C

LUB DR

S YACHT C

LUB DR

S YACHT C

LUB DR

S YACHT C

LUB DR

S YACHT C

LUB DR

Page 46: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA

PUBLIC NOTICE

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD PUBLIC HEARING

CASE NO. PZ 2015-08 VARIANCE

DATE: THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 at 2:00 P.M. TREASURE ISLAND CITY HALL AUDITORIUM LOCATED AT 120 108TH AVENUE

PROPERTY RONALD SCHMIDT OWNER: 11775 7TH STREET, EAST TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706 AGENT: TAMPA DOCK AND SEAWALL 5409 S WESTSHORE BLVD. TAMPA, FL 33611 PROPERTY ADDRESS: 11775 7TH STREET, EAST The Planning and Zoning Board will consider a marine variance to increase the combined maximum width for a residential dock and boat lift from 35 feet to 41 feet. PLANS FOR THE APPLICATION MAY BE REVIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT, 120 108

th

AVENUE, TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA, BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 8:00 AM AND 4:30 PM, MONDAY TO FRIDAY.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CALL THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT AT 547-4575 EXT. 239.

Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-

judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108

th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by

phone at 727-547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed.

NOTE: THE STAFF COMMENTS AND OTHER CORRESPONDENCE MAY ALSO BE VIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT OFFICE.

_________________________________________

Paulette E. Cohen Community Improvement Director

Page 47: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1

CITY OF

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

120 - 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706

Telephone (727) 547-4575; Fax (727) 547-4584

CASE NO. PZ-2015-09-VARIANCE STAFF REPORT

Thursday, February 19, 2015; 2:00 p.m. Planning and Zoning Board

PROPERTY Peter and Pamela Delaney OWNER: 11120 8th Street East Treasure Island, FL 32746 AGENT: David Greiner 6775 102nd Avenue Pinellas Park, FL DESCRIPTION: A variance to reduce the southeastern side yard setback from 10 feet to

8.6 inches to install a pergola. GENERAL INFORMATION:

Location: 11120 8th Street

Land Use: Residential Urban

Zoning: RU-75

Adjacent Property (Use):

West: Boca Ciega Bay

North: 11140 and 11145 8th St, East (single family homes) South: 11110 8th St., East (single family home)

East: 11105 and 11125 8th St., East (single family homes) Site Area: approximately 70 feet wide x 120 feet deep

Flood Zone: AE 11, Flood Insurance Rate Map

Community Panel No. 12103C0194G, September 3, 2003.

Page 48: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2

Site Legal: Lot 23, Block 6, Second Addition, Isle of Palms according to the plat thereof on file in the office of the clerk of the circuit court in and for Pinellas County, FL recorded in Plat Book 39, Pages 28 and 29, said lands situate, lying and being in Pinellas County, FL

Parcel #: 23-31-15-43506-006-0230

BACKGROUND:

This lot is located in a single family neighborhood of the Isle of Palms. The house was built in 1963. The swimming pool was built in 2012.

The building department electronic permit system does not list the construction or installation of a pergola for this property that the owner indicates was destroyed in 2012. This database lists building permit information from 1999 to the present.

On March 21, 2013 the Planning and Zoning Board approved a variance to reduce the southeastern side setback from 10 feet to 6 feet 6 inches to only accommodate a spiral staircase. On May 3, 2013 the relocation of the spiral staircase was completed.

The applicant or the agent would not provide a new survey for this variance case. City staff found a 2008 survey, which has been included with this case material. The 2008 survey does not show a pergola.

Section 68-541. - Setback classifications. No building shall be erected, converted, enlarged, reconstructed or structurally altered, unless it shall comply with the following setback classifications: ISLE OF PALMS 8th Street – “G”

Street: 20 feet Side: 10 feet Rear: 25 feet

Sec. 68-431. - Schedule of lot and bulk regulations.

The restrictions and controls intended to regulate the property development characteristics of each zoning district are set forth in the following schedule of lot and bulk regulations supplemented by other sections of this chapter:

District/Use Minimum Lot

Width (Feet)

Minimum Lot

Depth (Feet)

Minimum Lot

Area (Square

Feet)

Maximum Density Dwelling

Units (Per Acre)

Maximum Building Height (Above

BFE +2 feet of freeboard)

RU-75 Residential Urban (Single-Family)

Dwelling, Residential

Single-family 65 100 7,500 7.5 35

Maximum lot coverage in all districts: 50%

Impervious surface ratio—RU-75: 70%

Page 49: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3

STAFF ANALYSIS

1. The variance is in fact a variance as set forth within the Land Development Regulations and within the province of the Planning and Zoning Board based upon the opinion of the City Manager or his designee.

The variance being requested is set forth within the Land Development Regulations and under the purview of the Planning and Zoning Board. 2. Special conditions or circumstances exist which are peculiar to the building, structure, or

land for which the variance is sought and do not apply generally to buildings, structures, or lands in the same district.

The applicant wishes to install a pergola on the southeastern side of the house. 3. Strict application of the provisions of the land development regulations would not permit

the applicant reasonable use of the building; structure, or land. There is a single family home and swimming pool on the lot. The applicants have reasonable use of their subdivision lot.

4. The peculiar conditions and circumstances existing are not the result of the actions of the applicant, the applicant’s agents, or the applicant’s predecessors in title.

The house was built in 1963 by a predecessor in title. No changes have been made to the

lot since it was originally platted.

5. The variance proposed to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the building, structure, or land.

The applicant is requesting to encroach 11 feet into the side yard area which is 11.72 feet in width to install the sleeves for a pergola structure. While the contractor indicates there is 13 feet 9 inches from the house to the fence, the 2008 survey indicates the house is a maximum of 11.92 feet from the property line on the southeastern side of the lot. The pergola is removable. It is set in a 6 inch x 6 inch sleeve. When set in place, the pergola is 10 feet 6 inches in height and has an overall length of 11 feet.

Section. 68-457. - Yard regulations. Every part of a required yard must be open to the sky, unobstructed, except for the ordinary projections of steps, sills, belt courses, cornices and other ornamental features projecting not more than four inches from the building wall, provided, however, that roof overhangs up to 48 inches or one-half of the required yard, whichever is less, shall be permitted.

6. Owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement would result in unnecessary hardship. Special conditions to be considered pursuant to this section of the land development regulations shall include, but not be limited to, the following circumstances:

Page 50: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4

Redevelopment. If the proposed project involves the redevelopment or utilization of an existing developed or partially developed site.

Substandard Lot(s). If the proposed project involves the utilization of an existing legal nonconforming lot(s).

Neighborhood Character. If the proposed project promotes the established development pattern of a block face, including setbacks, building height, and other dimensional requirements.

Public Facilities. If the proposed project involves the development of public parks, public facilities or public utilities.

Architectural and/or engineering considerations. If the proposed project utilizes architectural and/or engineering features that would render the project more disaster-resistant.

Comments:

Redevelopment –The pergola will be an accessory structure on the lot.

Substandard Lot(s) - This is a not a substandard lot in the RU-75 zoning district There is a house and pool on the subject lot.

Neighborhood Character – This neighborhood consists of single family homes.

Public Facilities – not applicable

Architectural and/or engineering considerations – This variance request does not render the primary structure on the site more disaster-resistant

7. The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of this chapter.

The general purpose and intent of this chapter is to provide a variance where a hardship has been found. The applicant enjoys full use of this property. There is a house and swimming pool on the site.

8. The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise

detrimental to the public welfare.

The granting of this variance will be inconsistent with the existing development pattern of the homes in this portion of the subdivision.

While an emergency vehicle is not expected to travel between houses; fire and/or police may need access to the rear of the property in an emergency. A distance of less than 1 foot is inadequate for access to the rear of the property.

Page 51: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

The staff recommends DENIAL of the request; based upon the following:

this is a self-imposed hardship;

this request is for more than one-half of the size of the required setback and is not considered minor;

a setback of less than one-foot in width will hamper emergency access to the rear of the property; and

the applicant has reasonable use of the lot with the existing single family home and swimming pool.

Should the Planning and Zoning Board wish to CONDITIONALLY APPROVE this request for a

variance to reduce the southeastern side setback from 10 feet to 8.6 inches to install a pergola would be based on the finding:

This pergola is a removable, decorative feature in the side yard. This conditional approval is for the pergola only. Should the house be re-built in the future, the 8.6 inch southeastern side setback shall not apply to the house; only a removable pergola.

Planning and Zoning Board

Case PZ 2015-09V: A variance request to reduce the southeastern side yard setback from 10 feet to 8.6 inches to install a pergola.

Planning and Zoning Board Action:

[ ] Approved [ ] Denied [ ] Deferred [ ] Approved with Conditions

Pursuant to Section 10-221 (g) The granted variance shall be valid for one year. To remain in effect after

one year, one of the following must have occurred:

(1) An extension of time has been approved by the approving body;

(2) Building permits relating to the requested variance have either been applied for or granted; or

(3) A site plan review relating to the requested variance has been applied for or approved by the

planning and zoning board.

Any requests for an extension of time relating to a variance(s) must be in writing and received by the city

manager or specified designee at least three weeks prior to its expiration date in order for the request to

be placed on the approving body's agenda.

Page 52: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

i Case Number

City of Treasure Island Development Review Application

Please use blue or black ink only. Failure to complete this form in its entirety will result in this application being returned without review. Note: A separate application is required for each request.

Owners Agent

Address / f /(^O Address O ' > /• "?• \

p.,„ \U. < ...

Phone ~7r)cl^ phone /•- ^ > Co 1 I £

Fax Fax

Email Email f.

List all Legal Owner(s) of Property

iW ^T^>t=r£Sl KJt=i K

Complete legal description (may be placed on attached separate page): UUIIipitsie icyai ucowi(juwn imaj uw Vii wnuv-iiv^ y~l

/Lg TC2^]> /?/QC ̂ JO S^IACJ IT/OKJ ̂ JSLB Q-P fffLriS <=>f _S> Development Name:

///<&?. sr Area of Development (Acreage or Square Feet) _ nuiroxLu^c-x (3.2 3

Parcel Identification Number (list all): ,221111 ik j 4- Z^oiu&oc, /oJ3o Application Request {3b*K7-£>HCTrO/<-> fe"

c^/rfhr^t-ec^ <>2%2 ^-Aerr-v D ' D -Future Land Use Designation (<&' 0(rkjT7tf ̂ Proposed Future Land Use £fcrV /)fc-/w t vfC^

Current Zoning /W * I7y5><-Tf —. Proposed Zoning _ /es

I certify that I have reviewed the Land Development Regulations and that my submission meets all requirements The only exceptions are those items to which I am requesting variances to or waivers from certain sections of the code and understand that they must be listed on the plans individually and on the attached transmittal. I understand that if an item does need a variance, it will be necessary to file through the appropriate review entity.

Signature must be original (No copies, scans, faxes or e-mails)

Owner/Agent ' Date 'A j iS

Page 53: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

This letter is to explain why Mr & Mrs Delaney would like a Variance for there property at 11120

8th st east Treasure Island . When they moved in to the house there was Pergola on the side of the

house . Around 2012 when some big storms came threw and saverly damaged the pergola leaving them

with only one option was to tear its down . In recent weeks they contacted me to build them a new one

. In planning the new stucture we found out the old pergola was built over the set back and did not have

variance to do so . Mr. & Mrs. Delaney would greatly appriciate if you would allow us to rebuild the

structure back in the same spot it was before . Its a place were they injoy there morning coffe and daily

reading . Also with the completion or there garden on the side of the house the Pergola whould be the

finishing touches to there outdoor expieriance they invisioned . My designs has already been stamped

and approved for high wind speeds and is also a removable structure that can be taken down at any

time if needed . Also the Pergola will be a open ruff structer that wont hold water or cause water runoff

. Please help us and allow us to rebuild the structure they once had but with a different designe and

stronger design .

David Greiner

Sunsation Pools and Spa

727-225-6142

Page 54: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

10`Long

1`over hang 1` over hang

6x6post

11` from house

6x6 post

6x6 post

6x6 post

House House

8` to outside of post

Page 55: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

6"x6" Post

9`ft to Bottom Support

6 "

1` ft over hang 12"

2`5" Angle Beam

10` from ground to top of support beam

6"x6" Post

Concrete cylinder

Ground Level

House

From house to fence 13`9"

10" x 2" Cross beam

Top Support Beam 11`x 10"

10`6" tohighest pointof pergola

Pergola

Will not be attached to house .will be attached to 6"x2`concrete cylinder with a 6x6 steal sleeve . overall length of pergola is 11`leaving 2`9" from fence

6x6 sleeve 6x6 Sleeve

6x6 post

Page 56: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

BOCA

N43*34'00'V<BnB} S9.S6'<M>7€'(?>

a® ft. mjsm IO.OB^

2 STORY RESIDENCE

NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER SHOULD OBTAIN .. WRITTEN FIXED) ZONE DETERMINATION FROM THE LOCAL PERMITTING/ PLANNING' AND BUILDING DEPARTMENT PRIOR TO ANY CONSTRUCTION PLAWGNG AND/OR CONSTRUCTION.-

CERTIFICATION: f CEKHFY THAT WIS SURVEY Y/AS MADE. -UNDER1. ,MY',DIRECTION AND.. THAT (T MEETS -THE MINIMUM TECHNICAL STANDARDS SET FORTH :SY THE BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL.SURVEYORS AND "MAPPERS'.IN CHAPTER 6H3I7-6. FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE-'. CODE; PURSUANT TO SECTION 4-72-027. FLORIDA .STATUES. THIS SURVEY IS NOT TO -BE -USED 8Y ANY OTHER PARTY EXCEPT THOSE fTIS: CERTIFIED TD, THE SURVEYS? AND: MAPPER: «BiL -NOT"EXCEPT -ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY OTHER PARTY USING THIS SUR\O^^RTlRED TO TT^SURVEY DATE,- NOT THE .SIGNATURE DATE. ! J w

' sr s&rJr THIS. SJft Vt T UUTT, ,r UK • \ ti£.

STREET AffDRESg •. 11120 8TH STREET" f . TREASURE ISLANK ^FLORIDA 33706

SCALE r * 3<r

THIS SURVEY EXCEEDS. THE DISTANCE ACCURACY REQUIREMENT-" DF 1 FOOT IN 7500 FEET

raxsuavEvrrRS MS£»g

SESTBICTOKS AS, PER- RLAT EASEWENTO A y EASEMENT'ON EACH SIDE LOT LINE IS RESERVED FDR .UTILITIES

"REPARIAN RIGHTS* FULL .RIPARIAN RIGHTS SO WITH EACH LDT^'-BUT IT IS -EXPRESSLY UNDERSTOOD -THAT NO USE SHALL BE HADE OF SUCH . RIPARIAN

• RIGHTS 'EXCEPT THE DOCK HEREIN PERMITTED

LOT 24

THESE RESTRICTIONS' SHALL RUN TO THE YAER 1975 UNLESS .SOCNER .AMENDED AS HEREON PERM! LI tit.

BGB= BASIS CF BEARING FXC= FOUND CROSS CUT

MEASURED DIMENSION P=? PLAT DIMENSION AC-' AIR CONDITIONER. VPP= WOOD POWER POLE UGP- UNDER GROUND - POWER

CONCRETE

2 FENCE

WOOD -DECX.

10.54-'

70X10' S43*34'00'ECP&m

v-n> ro<=> <5 CO

r v?' I'-as ;.z: ̂

m<r»

^rn V

LOT CEKNEfc FALLS ON VPP VXW PHOK£ SISER

l5t37'«M0L3yViPJf^g :KI

8TH STREET E. SC RB3HTH3F--VAY

26' ASPHALT V/ 2T C0NC, OJRS

LEGAL .DESCRIPTION : LOT ,23, BLOCK 6, SECOND -VSOBIFiaN ISLE DF PALMS, ACCORDING TO THE.PLAT THEREOF ON :FIL£ 'IN -THE rOFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE-CIRCUIT COURT IN AND FOR:PINELLAS COUNTY, FLDREDA RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK:: 39, PAGES- -28 & S9, SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING AWS 3E3NG Bf PINELLAS CCUTY, FLORIDA

CERTIFIED' TO r

FLOOD ZONE : AE COMMUNITY PANEL: 121 DATED: 9/03/2003 (FLOOD ZuNE : "BTC'.'D' IN DESIGNATED FLOOD H

"X" ARE NOT ZONE AREA.)

KEVIN .P. -MABDODCS AND SARA A.- .HADDOCKS STUART B; TABM AN AND MELODY M..TA3MAN VERITAS TITLE, INC. ATTORNEYS' TITLE INSURANCE FUND

Page 57: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

BOCA

N43*34'00'V<BnB} S9.S6'<M>7€'(?>

a® ft. mjsm IO.OB^

2 STORY RESIDENCE

NOTE: PROPERTY OWNER SHOULD OBTAIN .. WRITTEN FIXED) ZONE DETERMINATION FROM THE LOCAL PERMITTING/ PLANNING' AND BUILDING DEPARTMENT PRIOR TO ANY CONSTRUCTION PLAWGNG AND/OR CONSTRUCTION.-

CERTIFICATION: f CEKHFY THAT WIS SURVEY Y/AS MADE. -UNDER1. ,MY',DIRECTION AND.. THAT (T MEETS -THE MINIMUM TECHNICAL STANDARDS SET FORTH :SY THE BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL.SURVEYORS AND "MAPPERS'.IN CHAPTER 6H3I7-6. FLORIDA ADMINISTRATIVE-'. CODE; PURSUANT TO SECTION 4-72-027. FLORIDA .STATUES. THIS SURVEY IS NOT TO -BE -USED 8Y ANY OTHER PARTY EXCEPT THOSE fTIS: CERTIFIED TD, THE SURVEYS? AND: MAPPER: «BiL -NOT"EXCEPT -ANY RESPONSIBILITY FOR ANY OTHER PARTY USING THIS SUR\O^^RTlRED TO TT^SURVEY DATE,- NOT THE .SIGNATURE DATE. ! J w

' sr s&rJr THIS. SJft Vt T UUTT, ,r UK • \ ti£.

STREET AffDRESg •. 11120 8TH STREET" f . TREASURE ISLANK ^FLORIDA 33706

SCALE r * 3<r

THIS SURVEY EXCEEDS. THE DISTANCE ACCURACY REQUIREMENT-" DF 1 FOOT IN 7500 FEET

raxsuavEvrrRS MS£»g

SESTBICTOKS AS, PER- RLAT EASEWENTO A y EASEMENT'ON EACH SIDE LOT LINE IS RESERVED FDR .UTILITIES

"REPARIAN RIGHTS* FULL .RIPARIAN RIGHTS SO WITH EACH LDT^'-BUT IT IS -EXPRESSLY UNDERSTOOD -THAT NO USE SHALL BE HADE OF SUCH . RIPARIAN

• RIGHTS 'EXCEPT THE DOCK HEREIN PERMITTED

LOT 24

THESE RESTRICTIONS' SHALL RUN TO THE YAER 1975 UNLESS .SOCNER .AMENDED AS HEREON PERM! LI tit.

BGB= BASIS CF BEARING FXC= FOUND CROSS CUT

MEASURED DIMENSION P=? PLAT DIMENSION AC-' AIR CONDITIONER. VPP= WOOD POWER POLE UGP- UNDER GROUND - POWER

CONCRETE

2 FENCE

WOOD -DECX.

10.54-'

70X10' S43*34'00'ECP&m

v-n> ro<=> <5 CO

r v?' I'-as ;.z: ̂

m<r»

^rn V

LOT CEKNEfc FALLS ON VPP VXW PHOK£ SISER

l5t37'«M0L3yViPJf^g :KI

8TH STREET E. SC RB3HTH3F--VAY

26' ASPHALT V/ 2T C0NC, OJRS

LEGAL .DESCRIPTION : LOT ,23, BLOCK 6, SECOND -VSOBIFiaN ISLE DF PALMS, ACCORDING TO THE.PLAT THEREOF ON :FIL£ 'IN -THE rOFFICE OF THE CLERK OF THE-CIRCUIT COURT IN AND FOR:PINELLAS COUNTY, FLDREDA RECORDED IN PLAT BOOK:: 39, PAGES- -28 & S9, SAID LANDS SITUATE, LYING AWS 3E3NG Bf PINELLAS CCUTY, FLORIDA

CERTIFIED' TO r

FLOOD ZONE : AE COMMUNITY PANEL: 121 DATED: 9/03/2003 (FLOOD ZuNE : "BTC'.'D' IN DESIGNATED FLOOD H

"X" ARE NOT ZONE AREA.)

KEVIN .P. -MABDODCS AND SARA A.- .HADDOCKS STUART B; TABM AN AND MELODY M..TA3MAN VERITAS TITLE, INC. ATTORNEYS' TITLE INSURANCE FUND

Page 58: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

11120 8th St E PZ 2015-09 V

Pinellas County GIS Plat

11125

11200

11180

11160

11140

11120

11055

11085

11105

11145

11105

11100

11080

11000

11005

11125

210

105119.3

85.3

73.9 110

36.9

120 112.5

5050.4

105

36.9119.4

70

50.4

12070

70

85.3

70 70

70

70

70

708TH

ST E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

site

Page 59: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

11120 8th St E PZ 2015-09 V

Pinellas County 2009 Aerial

11125

11200

11180

11160

11140

11120

11055

11085

11105

11145

11105

11100

11080

11000

11005

11125

210

105119.3

85.3

73.9 110

36.9

120 112.5

5050.4

105

36.9

119.4

70

50.4

12070

70

85.3

70 70

70

70

70

708TH

ST E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

8TH S

T E

site

Page 60: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 61: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 62: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 63: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA

PUBLIC NOTICE

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD PUBLIC HEARING

CASE NO. PZ 2015-09 VARIANCE

DATE: THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 at 2:00 P.M. TREASURE ISLAND CITY HALL AUDITORIUM LOCATED AT 120 108TH AVENUE

PROPERTY PETER AND PAMELA DELANEY OWNER: 11120 8TH STREET, EAST TREASURE ISLAND, FL 33706 AGENT: DAVID GREINER 6775 102TH AVENUE, NORTH PINELLAS PARK, FL PROPERTY ADDRESS: 11120 8TH STREET, EAST The Planning and Zoning Board will consider a variance to reduce the southeastern side yard setback from 10 feet to 8.6 inches to install a pergola. PLANS FOR THE APPLICATION MAY BE REVIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT, 120 108

th

AVENUE, TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA, BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 8:00 AM AND 4:30 PM, MONDAY TO FRIDAY.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CALL THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT AT 547-4575 EXT. 239.

Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-

judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108

th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by

phone at 727-547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed.

NOTE: THE STAFF COMMENTS AND OTHER CORRESPONDENCE MAY ALSO BE VIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT OFFICE.

_________________________________________

Paulette E. Cohen Community Improvement Director

Page 64: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1

CITY OF

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

120 - 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706

Telephone (727) 547-4575; Fax (727) 547-4584

CASE NO. PZ-2015-10-V STAFF REPORT

February 19, 2015; 2:00 p.m.; Planning and Zoning Board

PROPERTY Navneet and Neerja Anand OWNER: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706 AGENTS: Andrew Dohmen, AIA and Scott Livernois Design Styles Inc. 1708 East Columbus Drive Tampa, FL 33605 REQUEST: (Measuring from the waterside edge of the proposed landscape feature) A variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1

foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth.

GENERAL INFORMATION:

Location: 8490 West Gulf Boulevard Land Use: Residential Medium Zoning: RM-15

Adjacent Property (Use):

North: 8540 West Gulf Blvd – Sunset Beach Dunes Condo (Multi-Family) South: 8484 West Gulf Boulevard – Single Family Dwelling Unit

East: 8485 W Gulf Blvd. – duplex 85th Avenue right-of-way and 8547 and 8549 Blind Pass Drive - 2 Dwelling Units on a lot

West: Gulf of Mexico

Page 65: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2

Site Area: 7,177 +/- square feet Flood Zone: VE 14 and VE 15, Flood Insurance Rate Map Community Panel No. 12103C0257G, September 3, 2003. Site Legal: Lot 5 and the Southeasterly one half of Lot 4, Block 1, Sunset Beach Subdivision, Unit No. 2, according to the map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 23, Page 1, of the Public Records of Pinellas County, Florida

Parcel #: 36-31-15-87408-001-0050 BACKGROUND: There is a new single family house on the site, close to being completed. The property borders the Gulf of Mexico. On October 15, 2012, the Planning and Zoning Board approved a variance to reduce the side yard setback back from 7.5 to 5.5 feet on the south side of the property to construct a new home and the accompanying site plan for this house on the Gulf of Mexico. STAFF ANALYSIS – VARIANCE REQUEST:

1. The variance is in fact a variance as set forth within the Land Development Regulations and within the province of the Planning and Zoning Board based upon the opinion of the City Manager or his designee.

The variance being requested is set forth within the Land Development Regulations and under the purview of the Planning and Zoning Board.

2. Special conditions or circumstances exist which are peculiar to the building, structure, or land for which the variance is sought and do not apply generally to buildings, structures, or lands in the same district.

Section 68-431, Schedule of lot and bulk regulations describes the dimensional requirements of the RM-15, Residential Medium District.

District/Use

Minimum Lot Width (Feet)

Minimum Lot Depth (Feet)

Minimum Lot Area (Square Feet)

Maximum Density Dwelling Units (Per Acre)

Maximum Building Height (Above BFE)

RFH – 15 Residential Medium

Single Family 40 90 4,500 9 35

Maximum Lot Coverage in all districts: 50 %

Impervious Surface Ratio – RM-15: 70%

The subject site meets the requirements for the development of a single family structure.

Page 66: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3

3. Strict application of the provisions of the land development regulations would not permit the applicant reasonable use of the building; structure, or land.

A literal interpretation of the Land Development Regulations continues to provide the property owners’ full use of the subject site with a new single family home and a swimming pool. The variance is being requested on the north side of the property to provide for a water feature approximately 12 inches deep, 12 feet – 8 inches wide with stepping stones. The City's Land Development Regulations do not address fountains, water features, or any other structure which is built to hold water. The Land Development Regulations describe swimming pool setbacks and setbacks for accessory structures.

Swimming pool setbacks are measured from the waterside edge of the pool to the property line. (minimum 10 feet from the water side edge to the property line)

Accessory structures are required to maintain the same setbacks as the principal structure. (The minimum side setback for this property is 7.5 feet)

4. The peculiar conditions and circumstances existing are not the result of the actions of the applicant, the applicant’s agents, or the applicant’s predecessors in title.

All of the improvements on this site were established by the applicant. There were no

actions by predecessors in title that influenced the layout of the house and/or the design of the swimming pool on the site.

5. The variance proposed to be granted is the minimum variance that will make possible the reasonable use of the building, structure, or land.

The variance is being requested for a new landscape water feature. The original water feature was included on the approved site plan. The water feature was positioned close to the swimming pool in the rear – waterfront yard.

6. Owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement would result in unnecessary hardship. Special conditions to be considered pursuant to this section of the land development regulations shall include, but not be limited to, the following circumstances:

Redevelopment. If the proposed project involves the redevelopment or utilization of an existing developed or partially developed site.

Substandard Lot(s). If the proposed project involves the utilization of an existing legal nonconforming lot(s).

Neighborhood Character. If the proposed project promotes the established development pattern of a block face, including setbacks, building height, and other dimensional requirements.

Public Facilities. If the proposed project involves the development of public parks, public facilities or public utilities.

Architectural and/or engineering considerations. If the proposed project utilizes architectural and/or engineering features that would render the project more disaster-resistant.

Page 67: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4

Comments:

Redevelopment – not applicable

Substandard Lot(s) - This is not a substandard lot size in the RM-15 district.

Neighborhood Character– not applicable

Public Facilities – not applicable

Architectural and/or engineering considerations – The proposed water feature project will not provide for a more disaster-resistant dwelling unit.

7. The granting of the variance will be in harmony with the general purpose and intent of this chapter.

The granting of the north side yard setback variance allows for a unique use at a single family home. The water feature will not be visible from the street. It will be located behind the front wall and side perimeter wall.

8. The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the neighborhood or otherwise

detrimental to the public welfare.

The granting of this north side variance may be injurious to the neighboring property. The Sunset Beach neighborhood has some of the lowest elevations in the City. Even in a sudden summer storm of “short-duration”, there may be flooding. This water feature is designed to hold 12 inches of water. The concern of staff is that the water feature will overflow often. The overflow of water against the side perimeter block wall may ultimately lead to mold and mildew for the neighboring property. Staff continues to regulate impervious driveway surfaces and parking areas to be 3 feet away from the neighboring property line to avoid storm-water shedding on to a neighboring property. Walls, however, can still be built on the side property line.

STAFF RECOMMENDATION:

Staff recommends DENIAL of the variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from

10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches; based on the following:

This is a self-imposed hardship for a decorative water landscape feature.

This request is not a minor variance. The requested variance is greater than one-half of

the required side yard setback.

Due to the proximity of the water feature to the property line and the depth of the water

feature; it may be problematic for the neighboring property to the north.

The approved site plan provided for this landscape water feature without the need for a variance. It is unclear why this decorative water feature must be relocated to this specific location.

Page 68: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5

Should the Planning and Zoning Board wish to APPROVE this request for a variance to reduce the required north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches; the Planning and Zoning Board would find:

The proposed encroachment will not block anyone's view.

This is a landscape water feature. It is not a swimming pool or an accessory structure.

The minimum setback should not apply to this improvement.

The 2010 Florida Building Code does not regulate this structure as a pool, because it is

not 24 inches in depth. Since this is not a swimming pool; the minimum setback should

not apply to this water feature.

CASE PZ 2015-10V

REQUEST: Variance to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches

to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch

in length with a 12-inch water depth.

Planning and Zoning Board Action:

[ ] Approved [ ] Denied [ ] Deferred [ ] Approved with Conditions

Page 69: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Case Number: -4$ v

owners' Navneet.Anand «.st

City of Treasure Island Development Review Application

Please use blue or black ink only. Failure to complete this form in its entirety will result in this application being returned without review. Note: A separate application is required for each request.

•SocrH la 5?

Address 8490 GulfBlvd Treasure Island, FL 33706

Phone 248-561-5117

Agent

Address

Design Styles Architecture 1708 East Columbus Dr.

Tampa, FL 33605

Phone 813-241-6700

Fax

Email

Fax

Email [email protected]

List all Legal Owner(s) of Property: . Navneet Anand, Neerja Anand Navneet Anand, Neerja Anand

_ . . . . . . . u , . M t . Lot: 5 and southeasterly one half Complete legal description (may be placed on attached separate page):

of lot 4, Block: 1, Subdivision: sunset beach, Flood Zone: ve

Development Name:

Site Location/Address: 8490 gulf blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706

Area of Development (Acreage or Square Feet) 104 square feet

Parcel Identification Number (list all): 36-31-15-87408-001-0050 VAKMW Application Request

allow for a concrete 6'-0" high privacy wall on the south side of the property that turns to the north as it reaches

the east of the property. We would also like to allow for a landscape water feature on the north side of the property behind the privacy wall.

c t n . 4. residential medium _ ._4 , ,.. residential medium Future Land Use Designation Proposed Future Land Use

Current Zoning RM-15 Proposed Zoning RM-15

I certify that I have revieyvedihe LancTDevelopment Regulations and that my submission meets all requirements. The only exceptions are those items to which I am/equestirfg-^ariances to or waivers from certaip^plions of the code and understand that they must be listed on the plans individually and on the attagfed/transmittaI. I understand that if^afTiterri does need a variance, it will be necessary to file through the appropriate review entity. / /yf / /

Signature musjt be original (No copies, scans, faxes or e-mails)

Owner/Agent Date

Page 70: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

January 28, 2015 Paula Cohen Michelle Orton City of Treasure Island 120-108th Avenue Treasure Island, FL 33706 Site Plan Application – Variance Request Project #12021 – Anand Residence To whom it may concern: Our design team would like to request a variance to the City of Treasure Island for a detached single family home located in 8490 West Gulf Blvd, Treasure Island, FL 33706. Variance Requested: We are asking for the approval to allow for a side walk on the north side of the home to travel across a water feature that is approximately 8” deep. The architectural feature is located within the 10’ side yard setback behind a privacy wall, out of site of the public on the north side of the property. There will be lighting placed at the rim of feature as well to light up at night. According to the Municode of Treasure Island there is no mention of any restrictions to Fountains or water features besides swimming pools and the required side yard setback. Our architectural feature consist of 8”deep of water and will not function as a swimming pool and does not meet the requirements of one. Our request is to allow for the architectural feature to occur where located on the site plan behind the privacy wall that is meant to keep the public out of the pool area at the rear of the home. Should you have any questions, please feel free to contact me by phone at 813-241-6700 or by e-mail at [email protected] Sincerely, Andrew J. Dohmen, AR #15805 Design Styles Architecture Inc.

Page 71: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 72: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

POOL

SPA

COVERED PATIO

PATIO

GARAGE

STORAGE ROOM

POOL STORAGE

F

R

E

E

Z

E

R

LANDSCAPE

FEATURE

+ ELEV. @ 0'-0"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-12"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-16"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-12"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-0"

LOT 5

BLOCK 1

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND

MEAN HIGH WATER LINE

(1968) BULKHEAD P.B. 2, PGS

24-26

APPROXIMATE EDGE OF

SEA OATES 8/29/2012

99

.1

5' (M

)

N 63°33'" E(P)

N 63°27'55" E(M)

93

.9

9'(M

)

S 63°33' W(P)

S 63°31'07" W(M)

7'-6

" S

ID

E S

ET

BA

CK

N 29°02'59" W(M)

N 26°11'23" W(R)

74.56'(M)

20'-0" FRONT SETBACK

10'-0" B

ACK S

ETBACK F

RO

M 1

968 MEAN

HIG

H W

ATER L

INE

ROOFLINE BELOW

ROOFLINE

BELOW

2

A9.1

12'-8"

14'-0"

4'-2"4'-6"4'-0"

14

'-1

"

15

'-5

"

16

'-9

"

21

'-1

"

3"

3'-6

"

3"

3'-6

"3

'-6

"3

'-6

"

3"

3"

3"

2'-3

"

3

"

3'-3

"

1'-0"

1

4

'-3

"

32'-1"

6

'-3

"

3

1

'-0

"

23'-1"

5'-2

"

5"

19

'-5

"

10'-9"

10

"

4'-6

"

4'-6"

3"

3"

3

A9.1

5'-0"

2'-0"

3'-0"

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

48" HIGH

SECURITY FENCE

W/ 8" CMU

FOOTING BELOW,

CMU TO BE 4"

ABOVE GRADE.

48" SECURITY

FENCE TO BE

MEASURED OFF

OF THE POOL

DECK IN ORDER

TO CONFRIM

WITH LOCAL

CODE

REQUIREMENTS.

5'-0"

2'-0"

3'-0"

48" HIGH SECURITY FENCE

TO BE MEASURED OFF THE

POOL DECK TO CONFORM

WITH LOCAL CODES.

48" HIGH

SECURITY

FENCE W/ 8"

CMU FOOTING

BELOW, CMU

TO BE 4" ABOVE

GRADE

EXISTING PALM

TREE

EXISTING PALM

TREE

4" THICK

CONCRETE SLAB

CONCRETE

WALKING

PAD

GRADE

ELEV. @ 6'-0"

ABV TOP OF

POOL

ELEV. @ 0'-0"

TOP OF POOL

ELEV. @ -1'-0"

POOL SLAB

1'-4

"

1'-0

"4

"

6"

6"

EXTERIOR

GROUND

FLOOR

COLUMN

10"

2'-6"

(4) #5 BARS CONT.

90° HOOK

8"X12" CONC.

CURB W/ (2) #5

HORIZ. BARS

3/4" = 1'-0"

MASONRY LOW WALL DETAIL

10"

1'-4" M

IN

.

2'-6"

6'-0"

4" X 4" INSPECTION

PORT AT EACH

FILLED CELL (TYP.)

(1) #5 BAR VERTICAL

FILLED CELL AT 32"

O.C. TYP.

8" X 16" C.M.U. TYP.

30" MIN LAP

1" GRAVEL

(4) #5 BARS CONT.

90° HOOK

NOTE:

ALL CELLS FILLED SOLID

W/ 3000 PSI GROUT.

3

COMP. SOIL. (95%

MODIFIED PROCTOR

PER ASTM D1557)

DOUBLE COURSE OF 8"

X 8" X 16" KNOCK OUT

CMU W/ (1) #5 HOR

CONT BAR IN EACH

COURSE ALL GROUT

FILLED

SLOPE TOP

PAINT

5/8" THICK STUCCO

FINISH IN TWO COATS.

TYP. U.N.O. AT EXT.

MASONRY WALLS.

EXTEND PARGE COAT

4" BELOW GRADE TYP.

2"

NOTE:

ALL JOINTS TO BE

TOOLED.

PAINT

1/4" = 1'-0"

POOL PLAN

1

ANDREW J. DOHMEN, AR #15805 10/30/12

Project number

Drawn by Checked by

No. Issue Description Date

Sheet Number

Sheet Title

Professional Seal

Key Plan

Original drawing is 24 x 36 Do not scale contents of drawing

Consultant

Address

Phone

Fax

In Association with

Project

Prepared for

Contract No

No. Revision Description Date

All reproduction & intellectual property rights reserved 2012

12021

DC PF

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

A9.1

REVISED SITE PLAN

09/26/12

ANAND RESIDENCE

Navneet & Neerja Anand

8490 GULF BLVD.

TREASURE ISLAND, FL

33706

1/2" = 1'-0"

LANDSCAPE FEATURE SECTION

1

---- ---- ----

P:\P

ro

je

cts\2

01

2 P

ro

je

cts\1

20

21

- A

na

nd

R

esid

en

ce

\A

na

nd

R

esid

en

ce

\S

he

ets\In

te

rio

r D

esig

n\A

9.1

R

evise

d P

oo

l P

la

ns.d

wg

, 1

/2

3/2

01

5 5

:0

7:3

9 P

M, slive

rn

ois, 1

2:1

2

Page 73: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 74: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Case PZ 2015-10V Case PZ 2015-11SM

8490 West Gulf Blvd Anand

8490

8540854085408540854085408540

8547

8484

8478

60152(S) 1

0

50

60

50

50

50

90

75

178(S) 30

78(S

)

60 10550

104.9180(S)

75

101(S

)

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

Subject site

Page 75: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA PUBLIC NOTICE

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

PUBLIC HEARING CASE NO. PZ 2015-10 VARIANCE

CASE NO. 2015-11 SITE PLAN MODIFICATION

DATE: THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 at 2:00 P.M. TREASURE ISLAND CITY HALL AUDITORIUM LOCATED AT 120 108TH AVENUE

PROPERTY Navneet and Neerja Anand OWNERS: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706 AGENTS: Andrew Dohmen, AIA and Scott Livernois Design Styles Inc. 1708 East Columbus Drive, Tampa, FL 33605 LOCATION: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. The Planning and Zoning Board will consider

a variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth

the site plan modification for this property

PLANS FOR THE APPLICATION MAY BE REVIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT, 120 108

th

AVENUE, TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA, BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 8:00 AM AND 4:30 PM, MONDAY TO FRIDAY.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CALL THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT AT 547- 4575 EXT. 239.

Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-

judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108

th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by

phone at 727-547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed. NOTE: THE STAFF COMMENTS AND OTHER CORRESPONDENCE MAY ALSO BE VIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT OFFICE.

_________________________________________ Paulette E. Cohen, Community Improvement Director

Page 76: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

1

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND

PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

120 - 108th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706

Telephone (727) 547-4575; Fax (727) 547-4584

CASE NO. PZ-2015-11 SITE PLAN MODIFICATION STAFF REPORT

FEBRUARY 19, 2015 AT 2:00 P.M. PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

PROPERTY Navneet and Neerja Anand OWNERS: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706 AGENTS: Andrew Dohmen, AIA and Scott Livernois Design Styles Inc. 1708 East Columbus Drive Tampa, FL 33605 DESCRIPTION: A site plan modification to a single family property located at 8490 West

Gulf Blvd., along the Gulf of Mexico. The applicant proposes to build a 6 foot wall on the south side of the property and relocate the landscape water feature on the site.

GENERAL INFORMATION:

Location: 8490 West Gulf Boulevard Land Use: Residential Medium Zoning: RM-15

Adjacent Property (Use):

North: 8540 West Gulf Blvd. Sunset Beach Dunes Condo (Multi-Family) South: 8484 West Gulf Blvd. Single family dwelling unit

East: 8485 West Gulf Blvd. – duplex 85th Avenue right-of-way 8547 and 8549 Blind Pass Dr. - 2 dwelling units on a lot

Page 77: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

2

West: Gulf of Mexico Site Area: 7,177 +/- square feet Flood Zone: VE 14 and VE 15, Flood Insurance Rate Map Community Panel No. 12103C0257G, September 3, 2003. Site Legal: Lot 5 and the Southeasterly one half of Lot 4, Block 1, Sunset Beach

Subdivision, Unit No. 2, according to the map or plat thereof as recorded in Plat Book 23, Page 1, of the Public Records of Pinellas County, Florida

Parcel #: 36-31-15-87408-001-0050 Background: There is a new single family house on the site, close to being completed. This property borders the Gulf of Mexico. On October 15, 2012, the Planning and Zoning Board approved a variance to reduce the side yard setback back from 7.5 to 5.5 feet on the south side of the property to construct a new home and the accompanying site plan for this house on the Gulf of Mexico.

Prior to making a decision on this proposed site plan modification, the Planning and

Zoning Board will take action on Case No. PZ-2015-10V:

To reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth.

Staff Analysis: The review criteria for a site plan modification case are contained in the Land Development Regulations Section 70-92: (1) In what respects the plan is or is not consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the

purpose and intent of the land use district in which it is located.

The site plan modification is consistent with the Comprehensive Plan and the purpose and intent of the district in which it is located. The use of the property will remain a single family home with a swimming pool. The site plan modification is needed because the applicant proposes to extend the perimeter 6 foot high wall on the south side of the property and relocate the landscape water feature. The new wall will begin west of the front building setback line and extend westerly for a distance of approximately 49 feet. As proposed, the new wall meets the requirements of the Land Development Regulations.

Page 78: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

3

(2) In what respects the plan is or is not in conformance with all the applicable regulations of the land use district in which it is located.

Category Land Development

Regulations Proposed Site Plan

Modification

Impervious Surface Ratio 70% Maximum 54%

Lot Width 40 feet 75 +/- feet

Lot Depth 90 feet 96 +/- feet

Lot Area 4,500 square feet 7,154 square feet

Building Setbacks

Street 20 feet 20 feet

Side - North 7.5 feet 15 feet

Side - South 7.5 feet 5.5 feet approved by variance (10/15/12)

Total Side Setback 15 feet 20.5 feet

Rear 10 feet 10 feet

Parking 2 parking spaces 2 parking spaces

(3) In what respects the plan is or is not in conformance with the City’s subdivision

regulations and all other applicable City requirements including the design and construction of streets, utility facilities and other essential services.

The extension of perimeter wall and relocation of the landscape water feature will have no impact on the City’s current level of service of any component of the City’s public infrastructure.

In what respects the plan is or is not consistent with good design standards in respect to all internal or external relationships including but not limited to:

Relationship to adjoining properties; (a) Internal or external circulations, both vehicular and pedestrian; (b) Disposition of open space, use of screening or buffering and preservation of

existing natural features including trees; (c) Building arrangements both between buildings in the proposed development and

those adjoining sites. (d) Provisions to ensure continued public use of existing public beach or waterfront

access-ways, if any. Also, proposed new or enhanced public beach or waterfront access-ways, if identified as a requirement during the conference(s) between the applicant and city staff.

(e) Protection of historically / architecturally significant structures or archeological sites, if any, on or near the proposed development site from any adverse effects of the proposed development.

(f) Suitability and design of proposed on-site recreation areas and improvements, or of other lands to be dedicated for public recreational purposes.

(a) There will be no internal or external changes to vehicular and pedestrian circulation.

(b) There will be no disposition of open space. The proposed site plan modification addresses buffering / screening with the new wall on the

Page 79: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

4

south side of the property. The property owner / contractor must take all appropriate measures during construction / installation of the wall in compliance with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection rules for protected vegetative species.

(c) The Land Development Regulations permit the construction of a wall on the property line. The landscape water feature is a structure that is proposed to be placed adjacent to the perimeter wall, possibly impacting an adjoining site. (See case PZ 2015-10V)

(d) There will be no change to the use of the public beach or access to the

waterfront as a result of the proposed improvement.

(e) There are no known historically/architecturally significant structures or archeological sites adversely impacted by the improvements shown on the proposed site plan.

(f) No lands are proposed to be dedicated for public recreational purposes.

(4) In what respects the plan is or is not in conformance with the city policy in respect to

sufficiency of ownership guarantees for completion of all required improvements and the guarantees for continued maintenance.

There are no newly required or upgraded public improvements associated with this development proposal.

(5) Where applicable, in what respects the plan is or is not in conformance with the

regulations of the Southwest Florida Water Management District, the Tampa Bay Regional Planning Council and state and federal agencies. The issuance of permits or letters of intent-to-approve by these agencies may be considered evidence of such conformance.

The Southwest Florida Water Management District does not need to review or approve the development area. The Tampa Bay Regional Planning Council will not need to review or approve any aspects of this site plan.

(6) In the case of rehabilitation or redevelopment of an existing nonconforming use, per

section 68-512(3), whether the overall degree of nonconformity on the site is significantly reduced and additional adverse impacts are not created, and whether an exemption from variance requirements for any or all remaining nonconformities should be granted.

This is the site of a newly constructed single family home. Nonconforming use provisions and redevelopment issues are not applicable to this site plan modification case.

Page 80: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

5

STAFF RECOMMENDATION: Staff recommends APPROVAL of this proposed Site Plan modification for only the extension of the perimeter wall with the following conditions:

Where necessary to accommodate proposed development, the property owner shall be responsible for the removal and/or relocation of any and all public utilities located on the subject site. This is regardless of whether the public utilities are known at the time of site plan approval or discovered subsequent to such approval. Any required relocation will require approval of the City's Public Works Dept.

All construction associated with this project shall be subject to the current requirements of the Florida Building Code and the City’s Land Development Regulations.

All appropriate measures shall be taken during construction/installation of the wall to be in compliance with the Florida Department of Environmental Protection rules for protected vegetative species.

In accordance with Section 68-458. - Garden walls, fences and hedges, (d) Waterfront yards. The waterfront yard fences that a chain link or an open fence with openings not less than 3 5/8 inches between intermediate uprights which are not greater than 1½-inch cross sections may extend up to four feet in height. Decorative post caps may be installed on structural posts of the fence, but shall not extend more than ten inches above the top rail.

Pursuant to Section 70-92(f), if within 12 months of the date of approval of an application for site plan review, a building permit has not been applied for, the approved site plan becomes null and void; provided, however, that the City Commission and applicant may jointly agree to extend such period of approval.

Staff recommends DENIAL of the relocation of the landscape water feature on the proposed Site Plan for the reasons described in PZ 2015-10V case, including the following concern:

The relocation of the landscape water feature may be injurious to the neighboring property. In a sudden summer storm of “short-duration” and a storm event, the landscape water feature will overflow because it is only designed to hold 12 inches of water. The overflow of water against the side perimeter block wall may ultimately lead to mold and mildew for the neighboring property owner’s side of the wall or greater runoff of storm-water into the yard of the neighboring property owner.

Page 81: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

6

CASE PZ-2015-11 SM

Planning and Zoning Board Action:

A site plan modification for a single family property at 8490 West Gulf Blvd. along the Gulf of Mexico where the applicant proposes to extend a 6 foot wall along the south side of the property and relocate the landscape water feature.

[ ] Approved [ ] Denied [ ] Deferred [ ] Approved with conditions

Page 82: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Case Number: 401S-U swi

City of Treasure Island Development Review Application

Please use blue or black ink only. Failure to complete this form in its entirety will result in this application being returned without review. Note: A separate application is required for each request.

owners' Navneet Anand

Address 8490 Gulf Blvd Treasure Island, FL 33706

Phone 248-561-5117

Agent

Address

Andy Dohmen, Scott Livernois Design Styles Architecture

1708 East Columbus Dr. Tampa, FL 33605

Phone 813-241-6700

Fax

Email

Fax

Email [email protected], [email protected]

List all Legal Owner(s) of Property: Navneet Anand, Neerja Anand Navneet Anand, Neerja Anand

Complete legal description (may be placed on attached separate page): L°t- 5 and southeasterly one half

of lot 4, Block: 1, Subdivision: sunset beach, Flood Zone: ve

Development Name:

Site Location/Address: 8490 gulf blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706

Area of Development (Acreage or Square Feet) 104 square feet

Parcel Identification Number (list all): 36-31-15-87408-001-0050

Application Request allow for a concrete 6'-0" high privacy wall on the south side of the property that is 1-0" off of the south property line. The wall will start 1'-0" off of the

front setback and connect to the front corner of the house. The wall will run parallel to the south property line for 49'-0" towards the Gulf of Mexico but still 14-0" from the rear setback.

c . . ... n . .. residential medium _ ._4 , ,.. residential medium Future Land Use Designation Proposed Future Land Use

Current Zoning RM-15 Proposed Zoning RM-15

I certify that I have reviewed the Land Development Regulations and that my submission meets all requirements. The only exceptions are those items to which I am requesting variances to or waivers from certain sections of the code and understand that they must be listed on the plans individually and on the attached transmittal. I understand that if an item does need a variance, it will be necessary to file through the appropriate review entity.

Signature must be original (No copies, scans, faxes or e-mails)

Owner/Agent Date

Page 83: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 84: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

POOL

SPA

COVERED PATIO

PATIO

GARAGE

STORAGE ROOM

POOL STORAGE

F

R

E

E

Z

E

R

LANDSCAPE

FEATURE

+ ELEV. @ 0'-0"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-12"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-16"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-12"

+ ELEV. @ 0'-0"

LOT 5

BLOCK 1

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND

MEAN HIGH WATER LINE

(1968) BULKHEAD P.B. 2, PGS

24-26

APPROXIMATE EDGE OF

SEA OATES 8/29/2012

99

.1

5' (M

)

N 63°33'" E(P)

N 63°27'55" E(M)

93

.9

9'(M

)

S 63°33' W(P)

S 63°31'07" W(M)

7'-6

" S

ID

E S

ET

BA

CK

N 29°02'59" W(M)

N 26°11'23" W(R)

74.56'(M)

20'-0" FRONT SETBACK

10'-0" B

ACK S

ETBACK F

RO

M 1

968 MEAN

HIG

H W

ATER L

INE

ROOFLINE BELOW

ROOFLINE

BELOW

2

A9.1

12'-8"

14'-0"

4'-2"4'-6"4'-0"

14

'-1

"

15

'-5

"

16

'-9

"

21

'-1

"

3"

3'-6

"

3"

3'-6

"3

'-6

"3

'-6

"

3"

3"

3"

2'-3

"

3

"

3'-3

"

1'-0"

1

4

'-3

"

32'-1"

6

'-3

"

3

1

'-0

"

23'-1"

5'-2

"

5"

19

'-5

"

10'-9"

10

"

4'-6

"

4'-6"

3"

3"

3

A9.1

5'-0"

2'-0"

3'-0"

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

6'-0" HIGH CMU

PRIVACY WALL

48" HIGH

SECURITY FENCE

W/ 8" CMU

FOOTING BELOW,

CMU TO BE 4"

ABOVE GRADE.

48" SECURITY

FENCE TO BE

MEASURED OFF

OF THE POOL

DECK IN ORDER

TO CONFRIM

WITH LOCAL

CODE

REQUIREMENTS.

5'-0"

2'-0"

3'-0"

48" HIGH SECURITY FENCE

TO BE MEASURED OFF THE

POOL DECK TO CONFORM

WITH LOCAL CODES.

48" HIGH

SECURITY

FENCE W/ 8"

CMU FOOTING

BELOW, CMU

TO BE 4" ABOVE

GRADE

EXISTING PALM

TREE

EXISTING PALM

TREE

4" THICK

CONCRETE SLAB

CONCRETE

WALKING

PAD

GRADE

ELEV. @ 6'-0"

ABV TOP OF

POOL

ELEV. @ 0'-0"

TOP OF POOL

ELEV. @ -1'-0"

POOL SLAB

1'-4

"

1'-0

"4

"

6"

6"

EXTERIOR

GROUND

FLOOR

COLUMN

10"

2'-6"

(4) #5 BARS CONT.

90° HOOK

8"X12" CONC.

CURB W/ (2) #5

HORIZ. BARS

3/4" = 1'-0"

MASONRY LOW WALL DETAIL

10"

1'-4" M

IN

.

2'-6"

6'-0"

4" X 4" INSPECTION

PORT AT EACH

FILLED CELL (TYP.)

(1) #5 BAR VERTICAL

FILLED CELL AT 32"

O.C. TYP.

8" X 16" C.M.U. TYP.

30" MIN LAP

1" GRAVEL

(4) #5 BARS CONT.

90° HOOK

NOTE:

ALL CELLS FILLED SOLID

W/ 3000 PSI GROUT.

3

COMP. SOIL. (95%

MODIFIED PROCTOR

PER ASTM D1557)

DOUBLE COURSE OF 8"

X 8" X 16" KNOCK OUT

CMU W/ (1) #5 HOR

CONT BAR IN EACH

COURSE ALL GROUT

FILLED

SLOPE TOP

PAINT

5/8" THICK STUCCO

FINISH IN TWO COATS.

TYP. U.N.O. AT EXT.

MASONRY WALLS.

EXTEND PARGE COAT

4" BELOW GRADE TYP.

2"

NOTE:

ALL JOINTS TO BE

TOOLED.

PAINT

1/4" = 1'-0"

POOL PLAN

1

ANDREW J. DOHMEN, AR #15805 10/30/12

Project number

Drawn by Checked by

No. Issue Description Date

Sheet Number

Sheet Title

Professional Seal

Key Plan

Original drawing is 24 x 36 Do not scale contents of drawing

Consultant

Address

Phone

Fax

In Association with

Project

Prepared for

Contract No

No. Revision Description Date

All reproduction & intellectual property rights reserved 2012

12021

DC PF

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---- ---- ----

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

---

A9.1

REVISED SITE PLAN

09/26/12

ANAND RESIDENCE

Navneet & Neerja Anand

8490 GULF BLVD.

TREASURE ISLAND, FL

33706

1/2" = 1'-0"

LANDSCAPE FEATURE SECTION

1

---- ---- ----

P:\P

ro

je

cts\2

01

2 P

ro

je

cts\1

20

21

- A

na

nd

R

esid

en

ce

\A

na

nd

R

esid

en

ce

\S

he

ets\In

te

rio

r D

esig

n\A

9.1

R

evise

d P

oo

l P

la

ns.d

wg

, 1

/2

3/2

01

5 5

:0

7:3

9 P

M, slive

rn

ois, 1

2:1

2

Page 85: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL
Page 86: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

Case PZ 2015-10V Case PZ 2015-11SM

8490 West Gulf Blvd Anand

8490

8540854085408540854085408540

8547

8484

8478

60152(S) 1

0

50

60

50

50

50

90

75

178(S) 30

78(S

)

60 10550

104.9180(S)

75

101(S

)

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

BLIND PASS DR

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

W G

ULF

BLV

D

Subject site

Page 87: TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD CITY HALL

CITY OF TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA PUBLIC NOTICE

TREASURE ISLAND PLANNING AND ZONING BOARD

PUBLIC HEARING CASE NO. PZ 2015-10 VARIANCE

CASE NO. 2015-11 SITE PLAN MODIFICATION

DATE: THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 19, 2015 at 2:00 P.M. TREASURE ISLAND CITY HALL AUDITORIUM LOCATED AT 120 108TH AVENUE

PROPERTY Navneet and Neerja Anand OWNERS: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. Treasure Island, FL 33706 AGENTS: Andrew Dohmen, AIA and Scott Livernois Design Styles Inc. 1708 East Columbus Drive, Tampa, FL 33605 LOCATION: 8490 West Gulf Blvd. The Planning and Zoning Board will consider

a variance request to reduce the north side yard setback from 10 feet to 1 foot 8 inches to install a landscape water feature approximately 12 feet 8 inches in width, 14 feet 1 inch in length with a 12-inch water depth

the site plan modification for this property

PLANS FOR THE APPLICATION MAY BE REVIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT, 120 108

th

AVENUE, TREASURE ISLAND, FLORIDA, BETWEEN THE HOURS OF 8:00 AM AND 4:30 PM, MONDAY TO FRIDAY.

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION CALL THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT AT 547- 4575 EXT. 239.

Ex parte communication - The substance of any ex parte communication with a board member which relates to quasi-

judicial action pending before the Board is not presumed prejudicial to the action if the subject of the communication and the identity of the person, group, or entity with whom the communication took place is disclosed and part of the record before final action on the matter. The board member may read a written communication from any person. However, a written communication that relates to quasi-judicial action pending before a board member shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action, and such written communication shall be made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Board members may conduct investigations and site visits and may receive expert opinions regarding quasi-judicial action pending before them. Such activities shall not be presumed prejudicial to the action if the existence of the investigation, site visit or expert opinion is made a part of the record before final action on the matter. Disclosure must be made before or during the public meeting at which a vote is taken on such matters, so that persons who have opinions contrary to those expressed in the ex parte communication are given a reasonable opportunity to refute or respond to the communication. (For more information see Florida Statutes 286.0115) Any person desiring to file an appeal to any action taken by the Board at this meeting will need a record of the proceedings and for such purpose may be required to insure that a verbatim transcript is made. Said transcript shall be made by the appellant at his or her expense. The City maintains a tape recording of all public hearings. In the event that you wish to appeal a decision, the tape may or may not adequately insure a verbatim record of the proceedings. Therefore, you may wish to provide a court reporter at your expense. Any person with a disability who needs any accommodation in order to participate in this proceeding is entitled to assistance at no cost. Please contact the office of the City Clerk in writing at 120 108

th Avenue, Treasure Island, Florida 33706, or by

phone at 727-547-4575, at least two working days prior to the meeting to advise what assistance is needed. NOTE: THE STAFF COMMENTS AND OTHER CORRESPONDENCE MAY ALSO BE VIEWED AT THE COMMUNITY IMPROVEMENT DEPARTMENT OFFICE.

_________________________________________ Paulette E. Cohen, Community Improvement Director