The things that keep me awake at night III

&What we can do about it

Richard CaulfieldChief Exec

VSNW

Current issues • Cuts• Office for Civil Society• Growth• Payments by Results• Welfare reform• Future of Infrastructure• Our National Voice• Young people• Debt• Big Lottery• The ‘F’ Word• NHS Reform• Choice• Quasi-Quangos• Talking to Government• Work Programme• London Centricism• Big Society• Accountability• Local Enterprise partnerships• Environment

CUTS

• Still the prevailing wisdom

• What did Transition Fund achieve?

• Looking worse than expected for Local Gov

• ‘Graph of Doom’

The Barnet Graph of Doom

Office for Civil Society *new*

• What impact do they have across departments?

• What have they done for the sector?– National Citizen Service– Community First– Community Organisers

Forget Full cost recovery!

Growth *new*

• Economic– ‘Economic equivalent of war today’– ‘forget about crossing every ‘t’ and dotting every

‘i’

• Within VCS– Is growth always good?

Payments by Results *new*

• Another prevailing logic… but:

• What is the true impact?

• Can the diverse range of the sector engage?

• Will naturally create certain behaviours– (see ‘The Junior Apprentice’)

Welfare Reform *new*

• Should probably be first?• Universal Credit trialled in NW first…– Oldham, Tameside, Warrington & Wigan

• Impact on vulnerable people• Growth in homelessness• Deserving & undeserving poor in policy• Redefining words: ‘homeless’ & ‘poverty’• Impact on VCS Services

Future of Infrastructure *update*

• Transforming Local Infrastructure hardly transformational: set up to fail

• BIG setting policy direction with approach• What will impact of Assist be?• The end of free services?• What is the role of the private sector?

‘Our’ National Voice ? *new*

NCVO on SERCO and National Citizen Service:

• "We are pleased to see our draft guidance being used as the basis for this tender. It’s vitally important that we get the relationship right between the voluntary sector and the private sector."

• What other voice? ACEVO & NAVCA?

Young People *updated*

• Youth Unemployment• Is youth contract delivering?• Still seeing reduction in services• Do we understand impact of loss of EMA &

rise in tuition fees? • Impact of benefit changes

Debt *no change*

• Cut government debt but increase:– Personal debt• Student loans in Fe & HE• Removal of EMA

– Private Sector debt• Payments by results will lead to huge borrowing

– Local Authority debt• General power of competence

– Voluntary sector debt• Loans, Loans, Loans• Social Impact Bonds

Big Lottery *updated*

• Government’s puppy? – some blurring of lines

between OCS and BIG

• ‘Building Capabilities…’ paper – dangerous

• They are not simply ‘another funder’

• ‘programme’ methods have been divisive

• Still key to future of VCS!

‘The F word’ *updated*

• Public Sector working more towards ‘compliance’ rather than tackling issues

• Is there any point to Equality Impact Assessments

• ‘The Act’ seemingly more and more irrelevant– Virgin/Devon Health contract

NHS Reform *updated*

• Changing Geographies

• Checks and balances on clinicians

– Do they ‘get’ the sector?

• Financial allocations – ACRA impact on NW

Local Area Teams ‘LATs’

NHS North Commissioning Support Units

Public Health England

4 Regions + 15 Centres

Healthwatch *update*

• Doing more than LINks for less or same £

• Fluctuating advice – little consistency

• Variety of approaches to ‘tendering’

• Different answers in different place!

• Too little guidance or unclear guidance?

What about Public Health? *update*

• How long will ring fence last?

• Problem of ACRA formula

• Novating contracts - Why not put everyone on

notice?

• Communication & Engagement

• Role in shaping the market

Health & Wellbeing Boards *no change*

• The place where it all comes together?

• Majority in NW lack VCS engagement

• Healthwatch has statutory place

• Range of interpretation of role

Choice *new*

• Choice of user or choice of commissioner?

• Do we really want choice?

• Is it a misnomer?

Quasi – Quangos? *new*

• 9 RDAs to 39 LEPs• 0 to 152 Healthwatch• 9 regions + Centre to 4 regions, 27 LATs + NCB• 152 PCTs to 212 CCGs• 0 to 12 clinical senates• 0 to 1 National Citizen Service• 1 DH to DoH + Public Health England + 4

Regions + 15 centres

Talking to Govt *update*

• ‘Nonsultation’

• Increasingly unproductive?

• Who should we talk to anyway?

Work Programme *update*

• Any evidence it is working?

• Lack of transparency

• Lack of choice

• No real sector engagement in delivery at Tier 2

• Sector still too quiet about issues

‘London Centricism’ *update*

• Is Centricism a word?• Cost of events!• Lack of willingness to engage with regions• Nationals starting to play local• One size fits all view of sector

Accountability *updated*

• ‘The Market decides’

• The Prime contractor model

• Police Commissioners

• Elected Mayors

• Is there really any accountability?

Local Enterprise Partnerships *update*

• What have they achieved thus far?

• Still not inclusive

• Regional Growth Fund – any use?

• Recognition of need for ‘pan LEP’ working!

• May be useful tool for keeping ERDF Regional

The Environment *update*

• Will Local Nature Partnerships have an impact?

• Impact of changes in planning?

• Windfarms!!

So what can we (VCS) do?

Start with some myths

• Sustainability is key• Merger – that’s the way forward• Big is Better• Diversify your income• We need to be a ‘Social Enterprise’/have a

trading arm• we are too dependent on public sector• Consortia – that’s the answer!

What can we do?

• Community Budgets• Collaboration• Co-production• Create locally• Do what we do best• Campaign!

Community Budgets

• Keep an eye on the pilots– Whole place• Greater Manchester and Cheshire West & Chester

– Neighbourhood

• Chance to pool budgets• Opportunity to invest ‘upstream’

Collaboration

• Find collaborators

• May not be usual suspects

• Look to private sector as well as VCS/Public S

• Get someone to support collaboration

Co-production

Need to• Push for changing in commissioning processes• See public sector colleagues as part of the

solution• Work collaboratively within the sector with

mutual trust• Celebrate those commissioners who truly

engage

Create Locally

• Give local businesses a route to connect• Be creative about opportunities in the

community• Be focused upon what you want to achieve• Keep grants on the agenda!

Do what we do best…

• Respond to need– Fill the gaps

• Focus energy on the people and places that need it

• Provide a platform for the voice of those who need support

• Don’t let anyone fall below the radar

Campaign

"Now is not the time to hold your tongue just because you need that government grant or

contract. Now is the time to speak out openly and truthfully about how these

changes affect your beneficiaries."

Debra Allcock TylerChief Executive Directory of Social Change