the mechanism of restructuring in geometry

The Mechanism of Restructuring

in Geometry

Stellan Ohlsson

The Learning Research and Development Center,

University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260

Technical Report No. Kb L-90-04

May, 1990

To appear in the Proceedings of the Twelfth Annual Conference of the Cognitive

Science Society, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. Massachusetts,

July 25-28, 1990.

Preparation of this manuscript was supported, in part, by ONR grant N00014-89-J-1681. Approved for

public release; distribution unlimited. The opinions expressed do not necessarily reflect the positions

of the sponsoring agency, and no endorsement should be inferred. This report is a substantially

rewritten version of an earlier technical report: Ohlsson, S. (1983). Restructuring revisited. IN.

Re-describing the problem situation as a heuristic in geometric problem solving (Technical Report No.

353). Uppsala, Sweden: Department of Psychology, University of Uppsala.

UNCLASSIFIEDSECURITY CLASSIFICATION OF THIS PAGE

Form ApprovedREPORT DOCUMENTATION PAGE OM8No 0704-0188

la REPORT SECURITY CLASSIFICATION Ib RESTRICTIVE MARKINGS

Unclassified I2a. SECURITY CLASSIFICATION AUTHORITY 3 DISTRIBUTION/AVAILABILITY OF REPORT

Approved for public release;2b. DECLASSIFICATION /DOWNGRADING SCHEDULE di stri bu ti on unl imi ted

4. PERFORMING ORGANIZATION REPORT NUMBER(S) S MONITORING ORGANIZATION REPORT %..'ABER(S)

UP ITT/LRDC/ONR/KUL-90-04

6a. NAME OF PERFORMIN ORGANIZATION 6b OFFICE SYMBO 7a. NAME OF MONITORING ORGANIZATIONLearning Research & Developmen (If applicable) Cognitive Science ProgramCenter, University of PittsburI h Office of Naval Research (Code 1142CS)6c. ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code) 7b ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code)

3939 0'Hara Street 800 North Quincy StreetPittsburgh, PA 15260 Arlington, VA 22217-5000

8a. NAME OF FUNDING /SPONSORING Sb OFFICE SYMBOL 9 PROCUREMENT INSTRUMENT 10;.NT:FICAT,Or4 NUMBERORGANIZATION If applicable) N00014-89-J-1681

8c. ADDRESS (City, State, and ZIP Code) 10 SOURCE OF FUNDING NUMBERSPROGRAM PROJECT TASK WORK UNITELEMENT NO NO NO ACCESSION NO.

61153N RR04206 RR04206-01 NR442a-523

11. TITLE (Include Security Classification)

The Mechanism of Restructuring in Geometry

12. PERSONAL AUTHOR(S)

Stellan Ohlsson13a. TYPE OF REPORT 13b TIME COVERED 14 DATE OF REPORT (Year, Month, Day) 15 PAGE COujNT

Technical FROM TO _ May 1990Nh UPPLEMENTARY NOTATIO . .

s report is a substantially rewritten version of an earlier technical report:Ohlsson, S. (1983). "Restructuring revisited. III. Re-describing the problem situation"

17 COSATI CODES 18. SUBJECT TERMS (Continue on reverse if necessary and identify by block number)

FIELD GROUP SUB-GROUP Search; Restructuring; Function; Mechanism; Heuristic;05 02 Operators; Path; Initial state; Goal state; Description

space,19 ABSTRACT (Continue on reverse if necessary and identify by block number)

Restructuring consists of a change in the representation of the current search state, a processwhich breaks an impasse during problem solving by opening up new search paths. A corpus of52 think-aloud protocols from the domain of geometry was scanned for evidence ofrestructuring. The data suggest that restructuring is accomplished by re-parsing the geometricdiagram. / /ram~~~~~ f, ,I ,' ,

20 DISTRIBUTION /AVAILABILITY OF ABSTRACT 21 ABSTRACT SECURIrF CLASSI;cCAT,3,N

U3UNCLASSIFIED/UNLIMITED 0 SAME AS RPT - DTIC USERS Unclassified22a NAME OF RESPONSIBLE INDIVIDUAL 2212TI rW

'Nr (Ir .iude ,Area cde 22( );FICT S'eRoCL

Susan M. Chipm:!n (202) 696-4318 ONR 1142CSDD Form 1473, JUN 86 Previous editions are obsolete SE(:jRIT. f L ASIr CA -_Oq OF T.Hi-j A, .

S/N 0102-LF-014-6603 UNCLASSIFIED

O hisson 2 Restructuring in Geometry

Knowledge and Understanding in Human Learning

Knowledge and Understanding in Human Learning (KUL) is an umbrella term for aloosely connected set of activities lead by Stellan OhIsson at the Learning Researchand Development Center, University of Pittsburgh. The aim of KUL is to clarify therole of world knowledge in human thinking, reasoning, and problem solving. Worldknowledge consists of concepts and principles, and contrasts with facts (episodicknowledge) and with cognitive skills (procedural knowledge). The long term goal is toanswer six questions: How can the concepts and principles of particular domains beidentified? How are concepts and principles acquired? How can the acquisition ofconcepts and principles be assessed? How are concepts and principles encoded in themind? How are concepts and principles utilized in performance and learning? Howcan instruction facilitate the acquisition and utilization of concepts and principles (asopposed to episodic or procedural knowledge)? Different methodologies are used toinvestigate these questions: Psychological experiments, protocol studies, computersimulations, historical studies, semantic, logical, and mathematical analyses,instructional ntervention studies, and so on. A list of KUL reports appear at the backof this report.

r

7. Codes

9r

4-i

May KUL-90-04 1990

Ohisson 3 Restructuring in Geometry

Table of Contents

Abstract 4

Introduction 5

Method 6

Results 7

Case 1: Deliberate restructuring 7

Case 2: Goal-driven restructuring 8

Case 3: Hint-driven restructuring 9

Discussion 10

References 11

List of KUL reports 12

May KUL-90-04 1990

Ohlsson 4 Restructuring in Geometry

Abstract

Restructuring consists of a change in the representation of the current searchstate, a process which breaks an impasse during problem solving by opening up newsearch paths. A corpus of 52 think-aloud protocols from the domain of geometry wasscanned for evidence of restructuring. The data suggest that restructuring isaccomplished by re-parsing the geometric diagram.

May KUL-90-04 1990


Introduction

A wide variety of problem solving processes have been analyzed in terms ofheuristic search (Newell & Simon, 1972). For example, in geometry proofs thegeometric theorems (operators) are applied to the mental representation of thediagram (the knowledge state) until the desired proposition (the goal state) has beenattained (Anderson, 1981). The stepwise character of heuristic search contrasts withthe Gestalt hypothesis that problem solving proceeds through (a) an initial,unsuccessful, attack on the problem, (b) a more or less protracted impasse, and (c) arestructuring of the problem, which is typically, but not necessarily, followed byinsight (Ohlsson, 1984a).

Several attempts have been made to reconcile the information processing andGestalt hypotheses. Simon (1966) proposed that it helps to sleep on a problem,because goal tree information is forgotten faster than problem information. After apause, a new goal tree is built on the basis of more knowledge about the problem.Langley and Jones (1988) interpret an impasse as a failure to retrieve the relevantproblem solving operator. Insight occurs when some external stimulus causes enoughactivation to spread to that operator to allow its retrieval. A related hypothesisclaims that insight occurs when an appropriate analogy is retrieved (Keane, 1988).Both the differential rate of forgetting hypothesis and the spread of activationhypothesis require that the problem solver moves attention away from the problem,and so cannot explain insight during ongoing problem solving. Greeno and Berger(1987) have proposed that insights occur when a problem solver breaks an impasse byconstructing new functional knowledge, i. e., new problem solving operators. A newoperator is constructed by inferring that an object can fulfill a particular function, e.g., that a screwdriver can be used to complete an electric circuit. This follows from thefact that the screwdriver is made of metal, in conjunction with the general principlethat metallic objects conduct electricity. Several researchers have proposed thatproblem representations can be improved by the construction of macro-operators(Amarel, 1968; Korf, 1985). Koedinger and Anderson (in press) have proposed therelated idea that geometry experts combine geometric theorems into larger inferenceschemas, called diagram configuration schemas, which allow them to find a proofwithout step-by-step search of the proof space. The macro-operator and diagramconfiguration hypotheses explain expert performance, but they do not explaininsights by novices. All of these hypotheses locate restructuring in the processes ofproblem solving.

In contrast, I have proposed that restructuring involves a change in the mentalrepresentation of the current search state ,(Ohlsson, 1984b). A change in therepresentation implies that objects, relations, and properties which initially are seenas instances of certain concepts are being re-encoded as instances of other concepts.

May KUL-90-04 1990

OhIsson 7 Restructuring in Geometry

Results

The protocols were scanned for the occurrence of restructuring events. Ten suchevents were found. The three most informative events will be analyzed below. They

illustrate deliberate restructuring, goal driven restructuring, and restructuring in

response to a hint.

Case 1: Deliberate restructuring. Subject S3 was given the problem in Figure 1

after she had studied Theorems 1-5 (see Table 1). She began by proving that trianglesAED and BEC are congruent, and then entered an impasse. In fragments F65-F67

(see Table 2) she deliberately sets out to see the problem from many viewpoints. The

process of restructuring proceeds through three steps. First, she mentally cuts the

figure along the diagonal CA, forming the triangles CDA and CBA (F68-F70). She

then mentally cuts the figure along the other diagonal, forming the triangles DCB

and DBA (F71-F74). Finally, she keeps one triangle from each pair, as it were, and

sets herself the task of proving them congruent (F75-F77). Figure 2 gives a

diagrammatic analysis of the process. The geometric objects perceived by the subject

are drawn in bold lines, while the rest of the diagram is drawn in broken lines.

Restructuring was not followed by insight in this case. The subject worked on theproblem for twelve minutes without solving it.

Table 2. Protocol excerpt from Subject 33.

F65. but perhaps one can see this in some other way alsoF66. one can perhaps see this from many viewpoints hereF67. now we shall seeF68. one can see it asF69. CDA and CBAF70. trianglesF71. one can see it onF72. DCB and DBA insteadF73. yes exactly yesF74. those twoF75. wellF76. now I can see this in another wayF77. CDB and CAD ought to be congruent here in some way

May KUL-90-04 1990


Case 2: Goal-driven restructuring. S1 was given the problem in Figure 1 as hisfirst problem after studying Theorems 1-5 (see Table 1). S1 misunderstood the goal ofthe problem to be to prove that angle ADC is congruent to angle BCD. When theprotocol excerpt in Table 3 begins, he has proved that angles EDA and ECB arecongruent by proving them corresponding parts of the congruent triangles EDA andECB. He then sets himself the goal of proving that the remaining parts, i. e., anglesEDC and ECD, are equal (F43). His plan is to prove that they are equal by provingthat the sides of the triangle EDC are equal (F42-F45).

Table 3. Protocol excerpt from Subject S1.

F42. yes now I am thinking about whether one can prove that these two sides [DE,EC] are equally longF43. because if they are then those two angles [EDC, ECD] which are just theremaining parts of those angles which I want to get [ADE, BCD] must be equally longF44. so then this and that angle [ADE, BCD] must be equally bigF45. and then the problem is solvedF46. so it is now a question of proving that it is isoscelesF47. that triangle [EDC]F48. and that I cannotF49. but perhaps one can do it in some other way(What are you thinking?)F50. well now I am thinkingF51. well it is the same problemF52. but from another angleF53. yes if this oneF54. is those two lines [ED, EC) are equally longF55. I am thinkingF56. yes but they must beF57. since they are parts ofF58. it is congruentF59. these two here are congruent [triangles EDA, ECB]F60. and it is [ED, EC] corresponding sides in the triangles [EDA, ECBIF61. therefore these two sides [ED, ECI are equally long

This goal is reformulated as proving that the triangle EDC is isosceles (F46-F47).This view of the problem leads to an impasse (F48-F49). Prompted by theexperimenter to continue to think-aloud, he states that he is thinking about the same

May KUL-90-04 1990

OhIsson Restructuring in Geometry

D C C

D G

A B A B

Prove angles ECD and CDE congruent. Prove line segments AG and BD congruent.

Figure 1. Problem 1. Figure 4. Problem 2.

C C1%t A

I I i I

I I I

A B A B

Figure 5. Analysis of S2's re-encoding process. Perceived geometric figuresare drawn in bold lines, the rest of the figures in broken lines.

O hlsson 9 Restructuring in Geometry

problem but from another angle (F50-F52): he has re-encoded ED and EC as lines(F54). The goal is still to prove them congruent (F53-F55). He suddenly realizes that

ED and EC are corresponding sides of the two triangles EDA and ECB, which he has

already proved congruent (F56-F61). Figure 3 shows a diagrammatic analysis of the

process with perceived geometric objects in bold lines and the rest of the diagram--the

background--in broken lines. The subject quickly completed the correct solution.

Case 3: Hint-driven restructuring. S2 attempted Problem 2 (see Figure 4) afterhaving learned the five theorems in Table 1, plus four others. She decided to prove

triangles AED and BEG congruent and quickly reached an impasse. The protocol

excerpt in Table 4 begins

Table 4. Protocol exccrpt from Subject S2.

(What other triangles could be congruent?)F109. what othersFl10 could there be others which are congruentF1ll. huh(That could be. You have now been working the hypothesis that the whole point is toprove that those two triangles [AED, BEG] are congruent.)F112. yes

(And just now you reached the conclusion that you cannot do that with theinformation you have. Can you find two other triangles which one can find which one

could believe could be congruent?)F113. congruent exactly alikeF114. no that is impossible there are no othersF115. it cannot beF116. there are only one otherF117. also hypothetically then this line hereFl18. then there are two hereF119. and those two here can surely never be congruentF120. these two here can surely never be congruentF121. no I do not understand thatF122. butF123. now I see itF124. I have forgotten this one here [AGB or BDA]

May KUL-90-04 1990

OhIsson

Restructuring in Geometry

CA)

C03

C1 -S

O a

I -I

I

a

I

%

%%) %

%~a%

L

%

%

%% %

%

I I

I

I

I

4.)

4) %%

0 %

* I%

I

4.4.

% Cl

IC

-

I

4.

%

"I

OhIsson 10 Restructuring in Geometry

when the experimenter gives her the hint that there are other pairs of triangles in thefigure that might be congruent. She first rejects this suggestion (F113-F115). Shethen runs through the triangles in the figure (F113-F121), and concludes that thereare no other congruent triangles in the figure (F121). She then suddenly sees thetriangles AEG and BDA (F123-F124). Figure 5 shows a diagrammatic analysis of theprocess with perceived geometric objects drawn in bold lines and the rest of thediagram drawn in broken lines. In spite of this restructuring, the subject failed tosolve the problem.

Discussion

The restructuring process revealed in these three protocol excerpts consists inre-encoding the given figure. The diagram--the set of lines on the paper--containswithin it a large number of different geometric objects (angles, sides, triangles, etc.).Only some of those geometric objects are perceived at any one time. The others recedeinto the background. In particular, if a line configuration is perceived in one way,then alternative encodings of that same line configuration recede into thebackground. Restructuring consists of switching to one of the alternative encodings.How does the switching mechanism work? The data suggest that re-encoding is doneby re-parsing the diagram. During initial problem perception complex objects (e. g.,triangles) are constructed out of simpler objects (e. g., lines). This process is a searchthrough a description space (OhIsson, 1984b). Alternative interpretations of theperceptual information are possible, so some choices are made, resulting in aparticular encoding of the given diagram. When an impasse forces the problem solverto re-encode the problem, he/she backs up in the description space, dismantles his/herprevious encoding, and traverses another path through the description space. Thisprocess breaks an impasse by allowing other operators (geometric theorems) to applyto the current state. Restructuring is a rare event: There was approximately onerestructuring event per hour of problem solving effort in the present study.Restructuring does not necessarily lead to insight: In two of the three excerptspresented above, the subject failed to solve the problem. This study supports the ideathat diagram parsing is central in geometry (Koedinger & Anderson, in press), butthe validity of the re-parsing mechanism for other domains than geometry remainsan open question. For example, a different mechanism seems to be responsible forre-encoding of the Mutilated Checker Board Problem (Kaplan & Simon, in press).

May KUL-90-04 1990


References

Amarel, S. (1968). On representations of problems of reasoning about actions. In D.Michie (Ed.), Ma.hine intelligence. Vol 3. (pp. 131-171). Edinburgh, UK:Edinburgh University Press.

Anderson, J. R. (1981). Tuning of search of the problem space for geometry proofs.Proceedings of the Seventh International Joint Conference on ArtificialIntelligence (pp. 165-170). Vancouver, Canada: University of British Columbia.

Greeno, J. G., & Berger, D. (1987). A model of functional knowledge and insight(Technical Report No. GK-1). Berkeley, CA: University of California.

Kaplan, C. A. & Simon, H. A. (in press). In search of insight. Cognitive Psychology.

Keane, M. (1988). Analogical problem solving. New York, NY: Wiley.

Koedinger, K. R. & Anderson, J. R. (in press). Abstract planning and perceptualchunks: Elements of expertise in geometry. Cognitive Science.

Korf, R. E. (1985). Learning to solve problems by searching for macro-operators.Marshfield, MA: Pittman.

Langley, P. & Jones, R. (1988). A computational model of scientific insight. In R. J.Sternberg (Ed.), The nature of creativity. Contemporary psychologicalperspectives (pp. 177-201). Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press.

Montgomery, H. (1988). Mental models and problem solving: Three challenges to atheory of restructuring and insight. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 29,85-94.

Newell, A. & Simon, H. A. (1972). Human problem solving. Englewood Cliffs, NJ:Prentice-Hall.

Ohlssonr, S. (1984a). Restructuring revisisted. I. Summary and critique of the Gestalttheory of problem solving. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 25, 65-78.

Ohlsson, S. (1984b). Restructuring revisited. I. An information processing theory ofrestructuring and insight. Scandinavian Journal of Psychology, 25, 117-129.

Simon, H. A. (1966). Scientific discovery and the psychology of problem solving. InMind and cosmos: Essays in contemporary science and philosophy. Vol. III. (pp.22-40). Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh.

May KUL-90-04 1990


KUL Reports

1985

Ohlsson, S., & Langley, P. (April, 1985). Psychological evaluation of path hypothesesin cognitive diagnosis (Technical Report No. 1985/2). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

1986

Ohlsson, S. (January, 1986). Some principles of intelligent tutoring (Technical ReportNo. 1986/2). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center,University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (June, 1986). Computer simulation and its impact on educational researchand practice (Technical Report No. 1986/14). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (October, 1986). Sense and reference in the design of interactiveillustrations for rational numbers (Technical Report No. 1986/18). Pittsburgh,PA: Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

1987

Ohlsson, S. (April, 1987). A semantics for fraction concepts (Technical Report No.KUL-87-01). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center,University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (September, 1987). Trace analysis and spatial reasoning: An example ofintensive cognitive diagnosis and its implications for testing (Technical ReportNo. KUL-87-02). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and DevelopmentCenter, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S., Nicholas, S., & Bee, N. (December, 1987). Interactive illustrations forfractions: A progress report (Technical Report No. KUL-87-03). Pittsburgh,PA: Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S., & Rees, E. (December, 1987). Rational learning: Deriving arithmeticprocedures from state constraints (Technical Report No. KUL-87-04).Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center, University ofPittsburgh.

May KUL-90-04 1990


1988

Ohlsson, S. (February, 1988). Mathematical meaning and applicational meaning inthe semantics for fractions and related concepts (Technical Report No.KUL-88-01). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center,University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (March, 1988). Principled understanding of subtraction with regrouping:A mathematical analysis (Technical Report No. KUL-88-02). Pittsburgh, PA:Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S., & Rees, E. (August, 1988). An information processing analysis ofconceptual understanding in the learning of arithmetic procedures (TechnicalReport No. KUL-88-03). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and DevelopmentCenter, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (December, 1988). Towards intelligent tutoring systems that teachknowledge rather than skills: Five research questions (Technical Report No.KUL-88-04). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center,University of Pittsburgh.

1989

Ohlsson, S. (January, 1989). Knowledge requirements for teaching: The case offractions (Technical Report No. KUL-89-01). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (April, 1989). Cognitive science and instruction: Why the revolution is nothere (yet) (Technical Report No. KUL-89-02). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Robin, S., & Ohlsson, S. (August, 1989). Impetus than and now: A detailedcomparison between Jean Buridan and a single contemporary subject(Technical Report No. KUL-89-03). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research andDevelopment Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (Ed.), (October, 1988). Aspects of cognitive conflict and cognitive change(Technical Report No. KUL-89-04). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research andDevelopment Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Leinhardt, G., & Ohlsson, S. (November, 1989). Tutorials on the structure of tutoringfrom teachers (Technical Report No. KUL-89-05). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

May KUL-90-04 1990


Ernst, A., & OhIsson, S. (December, 1989). The cognitive complexity of the regroupingand augmenting algorithms for subtraction: A theoretical analysis (TechnicalReport No. KUL-89-06). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and DevelopmentCenter, University of Pittsburgh.

1990

Ohisson, S., & Rees, E. (January, 1990). Adaptive search through constraintviolations. (Technical Report No. KUL-90-01). Pittsburgh, PA: LearningResearch and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohisson, S., & Hall, N. (February, 1990). The cognitive function of embodiments inmathematics instruction (Technical Report No. KUL-90-02). Pittsburgh, PA:Learning Research and Development Center, University of Pittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S., & Rees, E. (March, 1990). Comparative evaluation of knowledge-basedsimulation models of procedural learning (Technical Report No. KUL-90-03).Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and Development Center, University ofPittsburgh.

Ohlsson, S. (May, 1990). The mechanism of restructuring in geometry (TechnicalReport No. KUL-90-04). Pittsburgh, PA: Learning Research and DevelopmentCenter, University of Pittsburgh.

May KUL-90-04 1990

Distrbution List

Ms. Lia B. Adele Dr. MerA4 S. Baker Dr. Jaime 0. CarkonelCode 553,0 Navy Personnel R&D Center Comue Science DeparmnNava Reach Lab Son Diego CA 921526800 Carnegie-Mellon Unr--yOverlook Drive Schrde ParkWeshipon. DC 2037-500 prot dott. Brno G. Barm Pittsburgh, PA 15213

Urni. di rica diDr. Edith Ackermars inteligeaz anificiale Dr. Gail CarpnterMed" Laboratory Univeasta di Milano Center for Adaptive SystemsEL1i-311 20122 Milano - via F. Storm 23 111 Cummington St., Room 24420 Ames, Smret MTALY Boston Universey,Cmardge. MA 02139 Boston. MA 02213

Dc. Jonathan BarossMr Beth Adebon 8U Glu Avernue Dr. John I. Carroll

Department of Computer Science Berwyn PA 1912 IBM Watson Reerch CenterTut Uniteraity User Interface IntituteMuford. MA 0215S Dr. Gautam A'- P.O. Box 704

Depertmsent of Computer Science Yorktown Heights, NY 10598Techiclal Document Center Boz 1688 Statiotn BAFHRLJLRS-TtC Vaoderbie Untvrrsty Dr. Ruth W. CbubsyWright.Pattereca APE Nashvlle TN 37235 CDEC, Hamburg HalOH 454360 CarneIe Mellon Unscerty

Dr. John Black Pittsburgh. PA 15213Dr. Robert Ahiera Teachers Collg& eerta 8Cod, N711 cokunhia, Universty, Dr. Fed ChangHuman Factors Laboratoey 525 West 120th Street Pacific BellNaval Training System Center New Yost NY 10027 2600 Camino RamonOrlando. FL 32813 Room 3S-450

Drc Michael Blackburn San Ranson, CA 94S83Dr. Robert M. Aiken Code 943Comiputer Science Deparmn Na"a Occa Systems Center Dr. Devida Charney

038-24 Smn Diepo, CA 92152-5000 English DprmnTemple University Penn State UniversityPlbiladelpbie PA 1912 Dr. Arthur S. Shaiws Univsity Park, PA 16802

Code N712Mr. Tejisanb S. Anand Naa Training Systems Cene Mrsz. Oh ClarkePhilip Laboratories; Orlandlo, FL 32813-7100 818 South George Maon Drive345 Scarborough Road Arlington. VA 22D4Briarcliff Manor Dr. Deborah A Boelim-DaviNow York NY 1020 Deparmn of Psychology Dr. Norman Cliff

Georg Masson University Deparmn of PsychologDr. James Anderson 4400 University Drive Univ. of So. Calioria,Nro" Uraservsry Pairtim; VA 22030 Los Anges CA 900691061Depuien of PayebooProvidence, RI 0291 Dr. Suer Bogner Dr. Stanley Cogy-

Army Reearch Ituttute Office of Naval TechnologDr. John R. Anderson ATIN: PER1-SF Code =Deparmn of Psychology 5001 Eisenhowr Avenue go0 N. Quincy streetCarnegeslon University Alesadria. VA P233-60 Arlington, VA 22217.500Scbenley ParkPittsburgh, PA 15213 Dr. Jeff Boner Dr. Jere Confrey

Guidance Technology. Inc. Cornell UnivesityDr. Thomas, H. Anderaon =vowia Street Dept. of EducationCester (or the Study of Resading Pittsbrgh PA 15212 Roo 490 Roberts174 Children's Research, Center ithaca, NY 1485351 Gery Drive Dr. J. C. SoudresxChampsis. IL 61=2 ene for Maufadecuring Dr. Lynn A. Cooper

Engineering Deparmn of psychologyDr. Stephen J. Aniola, Chairman Na-tIa Bureau of Stwadrd Columbis UniversityDepsartment of hInormation Systems Gaithersburg, MD 2069 New York, NY 10027

and 3ywem EnoineanGeorg maso Univerity Dr. Lyle E. Bourne. Jr. Dr. Meredith P. Crawford4400 University Drive Dep-rmn of Paychology 3563 Hamlet PlaceFuaxa VA P2030 Bcel 345 Che" Chase. MD 20815

Uiniversity of ColoradoProf. John Anneti Boulder CO 8830 Dr. Ham P. CrombagUniversit of Warwick Paity of LawDepartment of Psyholog Dr. Hugh Burns University of LimburgCom"tr CV4 7AL Department of English P.O. Box 616ENGLAND Universit of Tams Mastricht

Austin. TX 7870 Thbe NETHERI.ANDS 6200 MDBosedn AtkinCods 61ZI210 Dr. Robert Caffes Dr. Kenneth & CrossNaval Sea Systems Comamandl S of FAtEucation Anacraps Sciences, Inc.Wubeungtn DC 20368.510 Stanford Unfiversity P.OL Drawer Q

Stanord, CA 9%3M Sanm Barbara, CA "3102Dr. Patld SwnSchool of Educetion Dr. Joseph C Campione, Dr. Cary Caidson610 a. Uaivwmly. REs 10L Center for the Studly of Reading Intelen Imenauanalr SystemsUivesity of Mlihigan Unsiversity of llnois Tems, Instruments Al LabAnn Ador M11 491259 51 Oerty Drive P.O. Box 8(1246

Champaips. IL 61M2 Dues, TX 7526Dr. Jaime D. UaerObarsetof Automation sad Resac Dr. Janne Capper. Diretor Brien DallmanADM. Corporation ot America Centeidr for Research nto Paactic Training Teehnology Brand,29 Maonm Strva 354 Albeemne Stueed. NW I"0 TCHTWfITXCAlmwafra VA 22314 Was1hingon. DC 2M00 Lowry APE, CO 88230-500

ivii of Pittakrghlbtiesm 05/"R9

Mr. John F. DmlpiI Dr. Debra Evans Dr. Cad K. FraderimenCbmi. Computer q inam Depi. Aplied Science Associates. Inc. Depa. of FBwaoal PsapcologTowon SLOW Uiverity P.O0. BOX w07 me"N UniernayBatmmrs, MD 2M4N Busier, PA WW0 3700 MOTIwwwh Suse

Monm" OusacMarpuw Do%. LibAr- Dr. Lasted..s D. 4&d CANADA H3A 1Y2Appie ScienceAoao O00c Of FIXm~ ManmuP.O. Boa 1072 Ofiem at Emmno Deuelapmnt Dr. 3ab, R. FiederabenBudear. PA MW IWO E St, NW DON LAboatinnu

Wambinan.s DC 20415 10 Moulon StreetGamy Delsoote CanbMWg MA 02238Direua do Lialrmastque Dr. JiCamO i Falmapse

Sdciiique at Technique vine Resarch, Unit in Dr. Norman PredwmnCNRS Mihauadcawl A Balimanau Sclence Educadanad Tosung Service15. (3uss Asile France Universty of Ctcauam (as3-R)75700 Paris, FRANCE Wrima CA 92717 Profaeron, NJ 06341

Dr. Denims Delacoma Dr. Besrice I. Farr Departant of Humanides and-wbo De- Army Resarch insMM oca S *.

Bagr KA Yale Sssmom PERI-IC Harvey Mudd CalgYale Unhweit 300 Eseanhoser Aveues Caemm, CA 91711Nea Hame. Cr 06320)67447 Alexmltim VA 2=33

Dr. Alfred IL Fre*lDr. Slan Domy Dr. Meael I. Parr, Caucaa APOSLJNL. Bldg 410Florida So"h Unasa Cognicift a WhunMe Sciences Baling APR. DC 20332.446Dap -lan of Psyclsaloo 2520 Nasib Vernoan SlesTalabassee FL 32306 Arlni VA 2227 Dr. Alinda Fredomn

Depsien af PawchaloaDr. lTbames, 5 DeZmi, Dr. PA Palem. Uniesei of AlbertaProjec Enelnea A) Cade 51 Edmaomn AheraGeneal Dynamnic NPRDC CANADA T6G 229PO Boa 74WPeiI Zone 2646 San Diip~ CA 92152.4M0Fart Wait!,. 7X 76101 Dr. Mical Frien*

Dr. Jurom A Feldmen Paychala DepeamntDr. Roon. Dilan Unirsity of Rndmaer Yark UnuvermyDepartiaot of Guidanc and ComPiLerSia DePucWn- Taro ONT

Educauionel Peydulog Rodbeater. HY 146V7 CANADA M31 IP3Southern Illinois UnimaeeyCarbsondale IL 6M01 Dr. Paid Fekisadi Col. Dr. Ernst Frime

Sourharn Illiois U " meity Hlm -armpacblg Id DiernsDr. I. Stuart Dow, School of Madmn Marial 7umeaie.KmsunFaculty of Educaion Mesd m Edui Depamem I130 WimmUnaummity of British Columbia P.O. Boa 3926 AUSTRIA2W2 Main Mel Springfeld IL 42706VwAncouve 9C CANADA V617 1Z5 Dr. Robert M. Gape

Dr. Eklabak Fenmmm 1456 Mitchell AvenueDetane Teclamical Curriculums and Immcwaa Tagahammee. FL 32303

IaUadM , inwe Ur~mwdq of WiacarwanCamsmo Sawin. Bldg 3 W1 North Mat Sweet Dr. C. Lao Gan.Amdil VA W214 Madlas WA 53706 APOSR/XE, Bldg. 410(2 Copia) Boling APB

CAPT J. FPhe" Wasmingan. DC W32Dr. Platre Dupat Commmandant (G-715)Orgenidn for Economic U.S, Coas Guard Dr. Pbilip GLdb

Caaperasia and Dewelaopmert 2100 SeR n Si. &W. ARI.Fast Gordon7. rne Andre-Pascal Woebington. DC 20393 ATrTN PERI.CD7M06 PARIS Fart Gordon, GA 30903FRANCE PfoL Donald Fitterfld

Univesaity of Now England Mr. LA@ GladwinDr. Ralph Dumal Departmen of Paydbl 305 Davis AvenueV-P Humaen Factors Armidele. Ne. South Wale. 23 Leabur, VA =M07JIL Sitama AUSTRALIAIM Jelereon Davis Hwy. Dr. Robert Glamorsuis an0 Dr. Michae Flaningam Lamming ResarwchAAlnpon, VA moi Code 32 A Developmnt Cenwe

NPRDC Urielity Ot Pkw^uuoDr. Jahn lb Smn DieV. CA 92152.410 3939 Ollm StreetNavy Pamoud R&D Canter Plazbwgk~ PA 1520code 31 Dr. ID. FkuINSmn Dlep, CA 9W2 IsusLut for Defese Aalpam Dr. Marvin U. Glade

w N. Baawegart Si. 101 Homestead Tarrantor. Sam Epugele Akmnria, VA 22311 Ithamca NY 1466144 1 Moumnai AvenueMonami. NI 0704 Dr. Kenneth IN Forbu* Dr. Dinfg J. Goebing

Unierl a o le AR! Fild UnitERIC F tyAuaamDepacummaat Compuar Scq c P.O. Boan S7672440 Resac Bir Sauis 530 1304 Wes Springfield Avenue Prooklio a( Mansere. CA "%94.5011Rockwft M 443063250 Urbane IL 61IS1

Dr. Jampb GaguamDr. L Ande Ealommn Dr. RA - A. Fox Compq e S, inc Lab-"aaUnlmelay of CAloradc Univeft of Calosudo SRI InternationalDepuur of Pqacholoej Depertmun t npaulca 333 Rawwood AvemnueCMAp Ba 35 Bouider. 00 w"0 Menlo, Park CA "MSummder. CO ISmIE

Umeeaity of Pmsugh~lo"O 05/29,

Mr. Richard God Dr. Wayne Harve Mr. Roland JonesPeycolor DeaitaitCente for Lesang Technology Mitre Corp.. X-203

sychordg Diertmedntia eopet ae Burlington Road55rbi nvest Euationl Stenet tCne Bedford, MA 01730

StanfordNeon CA 9402160ap tre

Mir. Herold Golsin owo. A 026 Dr. Monde Just

University of DC Dr. Barbara, Hayms-Roth Caruegie.Mela tUniversity

Dprms WEgneigKnowledge * -a Lboratory Dqwatmwx of Psychology

Bldg, 4Z, Room 12 StnodUwr"Schooley Park

4m Coinetoct Avenue. N.W. 701 Welch Road Ptsug.P 51

Womingon, DC 2000 Palo Alto, CA 94304 D uhKn

Dr. Shierrie Gott Dr. Frederick Ham.Roth University of Minnesota

A IRLMOMJ Teknowledge Department of Pylog

Brooks Ape. TX 7WS3-5601 P.O. Box 10119 Eviou Hal1IM EmbarcaderO RdA 75 E. Rive Road

Dr. T. Oovindmaj Palo Alto, CA 9430 Nlauiiolm. MN 55455

Georgia leecacte ofTedmology Dr. Jamass Handier Dr. Michael Kapla

Sc Ooof Ihutrld Dept. of Coaiputer Off=m0m of Basic Resarch

~adSytem Engineering Univervity of Marylnd U.. m Aesearhnue

A.lna GA 303U20 Coleg Pask. MO 2042 SM__ aoe AeuAlmedra, VA W233-560

Dr. Wayne Gray Dr. Janes H~eer

Artificial Intelignc Laboratory Department of Educaional Dr. A. Karmiloff-Saith

NYNEX D-vlopment MRC-CDIJ

500 Weatcheater Avenue University of Delaware 17 Gordon Straw

White Plina, NY 10604 Newark, DE 19716 LodnENGLAND WClH 0A14

H. Wiim Greenup Dr. Geoffrey HintonDep Amg MS hnuachonal Computer Scionoa Deparmn Dr. Milton S. Kamz

Management (EO3A) Unkveraity of Toronto European Sminc Coordination

Education Center, MCCDC Sandford Flessing Building or"ic

Ouanooo VA 22134-500 10 Kine College Road U.S. Anny Research InstituteToreoo, Ontario MSS LA4 CANADA Box 65

Dr. 131k Gregeq FP0 New York 09510.1500

Adrdraly Research Dr. Jaee E. HoffmxnD.Fank eEaoahloamentAXB Depatomen of Psychology r rakKi

Quart RoadUnivarty of Delaware Department of Psychology

Teddinfon Newark. DE 19711 228 rn HalritMiddloma ENGLAND TWIIOLN DrCet ovs tomu Niverity

Dr. Stephen Geoaaherg Depanuimt of Psycholog

Center for Adapiv System U n diy of Califonia Dr. Wend Kelog

Room 244 Los Ange, CA 50024 IBM T. J. Watson Reaearch Ct.

III Cummangton Street P.O. Box 704

Boston Univerity ML. Julia S. Hough Yorktown Heighata, NY 10598

Boaomn MA 02215 Cambridge University Press40 West 20th Stramt Dr. Dougiss KAY

Michael Habon Now York, NY 10011 Unimmoaiy of North Carolina

DORNIER GMBH Depatmen of Siti

P.aOon 1420 Dr. Willam Howel Grape Hill. NC 2V514

D-7900 Ffrideiufeti I Crid ScientistWE91 GERMANY APHRUXA Dr. David Kiersa

Brooks AFB, IX 7823-560I Technical Communication Program

Dr. Hanry M. HeWf 'TIDAL Bldg. 236 Boniatedl Bivd,

Half Reouresu Inc. Dr. Steve Hunka University of Michigan

4918 33rd Road. North 3.104 Educ. N. Aim Arbor, MI 48109L2108

Aduigtom% VA 2227 Un~vervity of AlbertaEdmonton, Alberta Dr. Thoorns Kolon

Mr. H. Hamoburger CANADA T6G 2fJS AFHRIT

Departmoet of Coomputer Science Wd~m AFB, AZ 8524%6457

George Mason Univity Dr. Jack HunterFairfta VA 2M30 2122 Coolide Street Dr. Jeremy Kk-pirck

ILansing. MI 48M0 Departmen of

Dr. Bruce W. Hamil, Mathematics Education

Research Center Dr. Bonnie B. John 100 Aderhold Hal

The Jobom Hopkins University Wean Hall 8124 Univrsiy of Georgia

Applied Phayui Laboratory Doeament Of Comoputer Science Athena, GA 30602

John Hopkins Road Carnege melow Unientuy

Laurl MD 2M70 Pi-tuburil, PA 15Z13 Dr. J. Powe KimnadArmy Research ~Iostem

Dr. Paurc R. Harrison Dr. Ded B. ]on"s Orlando Field Unit

Comutr chc Deparmn U.S Nudear Regulatory do PM TRADE

U.S. Nava Acmdamy Commamon Otlando, FL. 32803

Annapolis, MD 21402-S00 NRRLABWehigmn DC 20555 Dr. Walter Kiteh

]Swies Hut Department of Psychology

Gl~m of the COdd Mr. Paul L. Jonms University of Coloado

of Naval Opeaeeon Reerch Divison Boulder, CO 80309434

OF-1111 Chidf of Nava Technical TrainingDaptnm of the Navy Building EAAt-1 Dr. Aimx Kirfick

Waduloom D.C. 20M&2=00 Navel AiTaciiMmpisol mto fMiginpon, IN 38054.56 Tcmk

Cantw for Human.-Machine-yemm ResearchAdeotaGA 30332-020

Univesity of iumburAhs NVIkon 05t29/90

Dr. JamaiW L Kood Dr. Marcia C Lim~ Dr. D. MhiuGlem*~ lesgimnitc Tecbimoicog Graduate school The Turin huitteSchool of Inioreaon of Edmcation. EMS!' Gemrg House

a CoptrScence Tolmani Hal 36 North Hanover StreetAtlanta. GA 30332 IUniverary of Callirni Glasgo G1 ZAD

Berteley, CA 94720 UNnwE KINGDOMDr. Stepe KomIYHavard Univeraity Dr. RoberUt Lloyd Dr. Vloon Midore1336 Willia Joane HAN Depi of Geollwlphy CNI-atituto TeonoloWe Dauitcbe33 Kirkland St. Unierasity of South Carolina Via A110pera Pim, 11Cabridge, MA 92136 Columbhia, SC N=20 GENOVA-ITALIA 16143

Dr. Kmathe Kotcavisy, Dr. Jia Laciead Dr. Jaes= R. MilerCOMmdTy Colep Of Unmcesiy ofMC

Allegheny, Counsty Massachusetts 3500 W. Bakhaa Center Dr.90 Ridge Avenue Phyvic Departmenwt AwCA TX 78759Pittsuhs,s PA 13212 Ambervi. MA 010013 D.JsnMls

Dr. Ket Kramer Vern M. Males: Depetesen ci EducationHCI Lehk Cods S330 NPRDC Code 32 Roberts HallNaval Research Laboratory Son Diego, CA 92132-800 Corne Unremmuy4445 Overlook Avenue lIthma, NY 14853Wimbingon.^ DC 7837.300 Dr. Will=m L Malay

code 04 Dr. Claremont M. Mitchel

Dr. Gay IKrn NETPMSA School of Indus. and Sya. En&.6211mpd Avenue Pensacola. Fl. 32509500 Center fcr Menk-MachmnPackl Grove, CA 9395 Symse Research

Dr. Mary Martino Gem*~ Institute of TechnologDr. LoleAnn Kuntz Director. Educational Tedsnolov Atlantim. GA 30532-0783010 SW. 23rd Terrace HO USAJ'A/DFTEApt. N. 0 USAF Academty. CO 80640-SM0 Dr. Andrew It McilaerGaineavwile, Fl. 32608 Appfic. of Advance Tedanlo

DC. Sandra P. Marshall Science and Enp. EducationDr. David R. LAmbert Days. of Ptabcololy National Science FoundationNav" Ocean Syatm Canter San Diego Suate University Washipon. DC 30550Code 772 Son Dieap, CA 92182271 Catalina Boulaward Or WfAmm MontagesSen Diegox CA 92132-300 Dr. John HK Mason NPRDC Code 13

Centr (oC Mita Edation San Diego. CA 921326800Dr. Pat Lmensy Mathematics FacultyNASA Ames Research Ctr. open University Dr. Melvin D. MoemaloMoffet Fe. CA 903S Mlisc Keynes, MVK 6A NASA Hodeadquaom

UNflED KINGDOM Code RtCDr. Robert W. Lawler Waehinpgon. DC 2"4Marthea 118 Dr. Massion M. Matthew,Purdue U navesay Depatment of Compute Science Prot John MortonWest Lait e. IN 47907 Universty of South Carolina MRC Copitivec

Coluambus. SC 2926 Developenmt Unit

Dr. Eugen Lee 17 Gotdo SUiStNa"e Posigraduese School Dr. Richard E. Mayer London WC1H OARMonterey. CA 91943.5026 Deparmn ci Psydiologf UNnTE KINGDOM

University a( CalaimsDr. Yuh.Jeng Lees Sensa Beduce CA 93106 Dr. Almn MurDepartment of Computer Science BeheIor, 'TedinoloffCode 52L.. Dr. David J. MOGeun Laboratories - USCNa"a Pcetuasduale School Galbaudis Univeramy 250 N. Harbor Dr. Suite 309Monterey, CA 9300 800 Floa Avenume, N.E. Redondo Beach. CA 90277

Dr. Jill F. LesoWabno C M Or. William R. MumraSho of Computer Science Dr. Joseph C McLachlan FMC Corporaioncarme"e Mellon University Code 52 Central Bnpnerig LabsPMAburgs, PA 15213-3W9 Navy Personnsel R&D Centeir 12M Colemamn Avenue

San Diego, CA 921324800 Ban S80Dr. Ja Lavin Santa Olem CA 9502Depesment a( Dr. Dou~a L. Medin

Educational Psychologf Deprten of Psycholog Chair. Depasimant of Weapons and210 Educaton Building University of Mihgn System Bnnewrig1310 South Simrh Strests Ann Arbor. MI 48109 U.S. Nava Acadermy,Cbmapeipa [L 61OW4990r tllMmk Anasaolie, MD 21402

Dr. Joam Levine Poravau ente for L.4edumkb Dr. T. NiblettLemeaing R&D Canter CWstiauhavn Voldpide 8 Mae Twmin InstieUiversity 0( Plth%WO 1424 Kohanlmvn K Georg HousePibbmxra. PA 13260 DENMARK 36 North Hanover Street

Glasgo G1 2AD

Maod LeA& Dr. Arthur Mae"e UNnTE KINGDOMD0" -esn of Pmylholog Computer Aria andCermaeie.Meon University Educauion Laboratory Librawy. NPRDCPlumburgh. PA 13213 Nas Yost U Oversity Cods PWIL

719 Broadway. 121h floor Son Dies. CA 92132800Dr. Doris K. Ljdhk New Yort. NY O0U4ctu h odmety Ccm s Librarianno Camps Commssion Drk% North Dr. Jceo Momc Naval C~se for Appie ResrchRolm.. VA ZZM Deparmen of Physics in Artifical Intelligence

Hasebroua Laboratory Naval Resach Laboral"Univeit c i Masettes Cods 5510Amberat, MA 01003 Wabinspon, DC 2075-5000

Unineinty of Piabrohbeon 0129/90

Dr. IHarld P. 0*Nd. if. Dept. of Ackomsreive Sciences Dr. Linda G. RobertsSc Ooof Education - WPH S01 code 54 Science. E3ucon, and

Deparmnt of Educational N"va Pcetyeuuet Sehool Trampotao ProgramPapd~olow A Tahooogy Monway, CA 9393.5M2 Office of Tedmiodogy AmmmeaK

Uuiwucuty of Soutiaerm Califrni Congs of the United Star"Lose Ange. CA 9039.403 Dr. Pewe Pirell Wamingon, DC 2MI0

Sc Oof EducationDr. Piug ORorica University of Caliornia Dr. EritW 7- Rofthopflanforicom a computer somena Berkeley. CA 94720 AT&T Bed LabormtorimUnm*w of California. hL~ Roo 213-456Irice CA W37V Pro(. Torso Pospic 600 Mountain Avenue

Mamadetua Institute Muntu H. WJ 0794Dr. S@lm Olibm of Tedmologf E25-201Larmsi R a D cante Cowte for ffidlocoi Dr. Alen H. Scboeneldunieeuq of I'mhm31 Information procesig Unieity o( CahworiaPlnuhwgi PA 13206 CAmbidp. MA 02139 Depsrmmt of Edlucation

Berkeley. CA 94720Dr. 1acmm B. Obw Dr. PetePlr cWICAT *mmmmm Universty of Colorado Lowa ed ie1875 South So"t Stuea Dep-nni of Puythologr Psycholcopco A OusutaiveOr" Ur 84058 Bouldler. C0 88309.03 Foumdations

College of EducationDr. Gary M. Olson Or. Steow I- Poilrock UniMuit a( IowCognitive Science end Boeing Advanced Technolog Center Iow City, IA 5n,42

Macbiec Intelligence Lab. P0, Box 24346 U/a 71,4U"Verity of Mkichgn Seatle WA 96124 Dr. Janet W. Scbofiedd701 Tappan Stree 816 LRDC BuildingAnn Arbor. Ml 491234 Dr. Joseph Pamirs Univeraty of Pittaburg

ATIN: PERI-4C 3939 O'Herm SuveeDr. Judith Reimun Olsoe Army Rinmrcb Institute Piuaburk PA 15260Gradua Sc Oof Business 5001 Eisenhower Ave.University of Michign Akmdri VA W33-501) Dr. Key SchulueAnn Arbor, MI 469.124 Coputer Sciec Dept

Mr. Paul S. Ram U.S. Na"a AcademyOffice of N"va Remeath. Code U-33 Annapolis. MD 21402-5018

Code 114C Nava Surface Weapons Centergo0 m. Ouinry street Wbite Oak Laboratory Dr. Miriamt SchmtockArlingon. VA 72217-500 Silhu Spring, MD 2090 Code 52(6 COPim) Navy Personnel R A D Center

Dr. Jamm A. Rqea Son Dieg, CA 92152-660Dr. Judith Orema Unieraity of MuyandBook Remwth Office School of Medicine Dr. Judith W. SegalArmy Rmachb huIre Depulen Of Neurcoo OI5001 Eimsnboe Avenue 22 South Grewn Stree 555 Now Jeney7 Ave. NWAbeJ ds VA ZZ3 Baltime MD 21201 Washington, DC MM20

Dr. Jae Odiansity Dr. J. Wese Regian Dr. Robert J. SeidelInstitte (or Defense Analm AFHI4RADI US Army Raescb Institute131 N. ammiaegad St. Brooks AMD TX 78W3 500 Fisenhowe Ave.Alemadria. VA 2Z311 Ajiemndra, VA 22333

Dr. Fred ReifDr. Everett Paime Pbysica Dep-nnn Dr. Colleen ?4. SearMail Stop 23903 univest of Culifni Institute (or Copitive ScienceNASA-Ameas Researcha Center Berkeley, CA 94720 Mai Code C.01SMoffeti Field, CA 9403 Univenity of California, Son Diego

Dr. Coacims M. Raagtluth Lm Jolla, CA 92093Dr. Gitcboon Part 330 Huntt HalAnmy Research Institute Syac- U~niversity Dr. Michael G. ShaftoPERI-2 yrsutee NY 13244 NASA Ames Reawth Ce,.5001 Eimenhower Avenue Mail Stop m39.Alexndria, VA 22333 Dr. Daniel Reisaerg Molleei Feld CA 94835

Reed CdaeDr. Ray Pee Deparmn of Paycholog Mr. Colin SheppwrdInstiut for Riesocha Portland, OR 97202 AXC2 Block 3

on Learning Admeradey Resarch Estabtisliment2550 imoser Streom Dr. Laure Resick Ministy of Defence PortadownPallo Alta. CA 94304 Learning R A D Center Portsmouth Hants P064AA

Universit of Pittsburgh UNITED KINGDOMDrc David N. Perkins 3939 ON" streetPro~ee Zero, Pltzaburglk PA 15213 Dr. Lee S. SbhnHarvard Graduate ScolSchool of Education

of Edmwmio Dr. J. idey Richeeon 307 cerm7 Applan Way Center for Applied A] Stanford UniversityCamabeiclo MA 02138 Cosep of Bisins Stanford. CA 9430-394

Univerty of ColoradoDr. C. Poem. Chir Boulder. CO 800"19 Dr. Randall SbumakerDept. at P~daology Na"a Rm rd LaboratoryMWrgV State University Dr. Edwins L Rimend code 5510Cold Spring L.-Hillu Rd. Dept. of Cocaputer end 455 Ovulomok Avenue. SW.Baltimore. MD ZU39 flooraftion SQinc Wasmiron. DC 20375-300

Uiversity of NMatmemmuDr. Nesiey N. Peat Amherst, MA 01083 Dr. Edwaerd SilverNad Educatioe and Tom"an LRDCPiugau Support Aetet Mr. W41am A. Ricao University 0f PittsburvisCod*447 Code 71 3939 OGumr StreBidding 243S Nava Training Systemns Center Pittsburgh, PA 15260Pueb FL 32109500 Orlando, 1FL 323113

Unjev"t Of piezburnOlKeWo W529m9

Dr. H~hc A Simon Dr. DwAvd E. Ston Dr. Keith T. WascourtDep-na of Psychdrology C-oput Teachring Corporation FMC CorporationCaerneie-Melon Uweererney 1713 South Ndi Street Cealw Bogeat LaOWShA 1e5 Park Urbana. IL 61820 1IM Coam Ave, Bos 380PMttbearo. PA 15213 Dr arc upeSarni O.w CA 9%602

Robert L Sitopson. Jr. Stodord University Dr. Dousla WettelI3ARPA4srO Inmitute for Mathemtcal Code SI1400 Wa Ed. Studies ua the Social Scienoes Navy Personeel R&D CenterArlagooot VA M09.2M0 Stanfrd CA 94305-411S Son Diego. CA 92152-480

Dr. Zita M. Simutis Dr. Perry W. Mwomfe Dr. Bara WhiteOuiuf. Technologies for Skil FMC Coaton Siroo of Educelion

Acqumttion and Retention Cerntral Engineering LAbs Toow Hal. EMS?ARl 120 Colela Avenue. Bog 380 Uniwenhty of California300 Eisenhower Avenue Sant Clara. CA 93002 BerkeWu. CA "M73

Aieorm A2MDr. Shaeron Tkao Dr. Daid WiltionDr. Derek Slam Allen Corporaio Univemy of IlinoisComputing scianc Depar-n 209 Madison Sarea Deperumet of Computer Sciencemmu tialvormy Alexnd'a. VA 2214 1304 West Spnrins AvenueAberdesn A92FX Urbna IL 61801Scotiand Dr. Douglas TowneUNflED KINGDOM Behavira Tsenoloff Leaw Dr. Mmli. It. William

University of Southern Caeifonma Appfic. of Adanced TedrnnologiesMe. Gai K. Swem 230 N. Harbor Dr. Suite 309 National Science FoundatbonLOGICON. Inc Redondo Beach, CA 9027 SEJMDOJSEP.O. BOe 85158 WO0 G Street. NW. Room 633-ASmn Diesp. CA 92138.315 Major D. D. Tucker Washingon. DC 20330

HOMO. Code MA. Room 4023Mr EFArwd E. Smith Washington. DC 20380 5. H. WionDeprten of Puycbolou Code 3300Univnit of Michigarn Dr. Paul T. Tsvohig Na"a Research Laboratoy330 Packad Road ArM Research Iustitute Washington. DC 207-5=0Aim Arbor. MI 46103 ATTN: PERI-RL

501 Eisenhowrer Avenue Dr. Robert A. WaherDr. A"fe F. Smode Alexandia, VA 2233-30 U.S1 Army Inuiee for theCode 7A Bebavioral and Social SciencesReserch and Development Dept. Dr. TM I- Tyue 5001 Eisenhower AvenueNava Training 9stetin Canter Deprten of Psycholog Aicmndria. VA 2233-5600Orlando. Fl 32813-7100 Gecr maon Univaiaey

4w0 Uniniaait Dive Dr. Marli C. Watrock

Dr. Eliot Solaway Fairfae, VA 22030 Graduate Schrool of EduatioYale Uniueeei UCLAComputer Scienc Depal-n Dr. Harol P. Van Cotu Los Angea. CA 9004P.O. BOX 2158 Committee On HUum FaCLoreNew Hm~n Cr 00230 National Academy of Sciences Mr. Paul T. Wohig

2101 Conatitutio Avenue Army Research InstituteLinda Ba Sorilio, Washington, DC 20418 3001 Eimenhower Ave.IBM-Los Angel Scianuific Center ATTN: PERJ.RLHis Wilobire Bled. 'eli Floor Dr. Kurt Van Laina Akmndkia VA 22133-360Lms Ansela., CA 900M Deparmn of Psychology

Carnegie-Mellon iiaUnt" Mr. Joseph WobiN. S. Seiliaa Selienly Put Alplatede. IncFMC Corportion Pittsburgh, PA 1S213 2 Burlington Executive CenterBox so III Mwodias Thropik10 C41leen Avenue Dr. Frank L. Vmasno Burfington, MA 01803Sant Cam CA 93052 Navy Personnel R&D Cancer

San Diego. CA 921S2.U0 Dr. Wallace Wuseck. IDr. Motian Stearns Nay Persnnel R&D CenterSRI Internstional Dr. Jerr Volt Code 31333 Ravenusood Ave. Navy Personne R&D Center Smn Mapo CA 921526800Rom. 1-517A Code 51Manio Paut. CA 94025 Smn Diego, CA 92152.UM Dr. Mmmoud Yazd=n

Dept. of Computer ScienceDr. Friedrich W. Steem Dr. Thomau A Warm University of Eate

Bmmdufilim FAA Academy AAC934D Prince of Wales Roadda Vaegrna P.O. Boz 230=Eae EX44PT

Posefda 132 Oklahoma City. OK 73125 ENGLANDD-3306 Dom. IVIMT GERMANY Dr. Bairn Warren Or. Joseph L. Yourng

SBN LAboratoeia. Inc National Scin- Foundiation

Dr. Frederick Steginbseer 10 Moulton Surea Room 320CIA.ORD Cambridige, MA 0323 8W0 G StrK N.W.

Ammm BiliingWashington DC W550Washapon DC 2M0 Dr. Diana oWea

Department of Edulna Dr. Ui ZermDr. Swul Sternberg Development: Geneald Electric:tielvrell of Paurnelan Unlewei of Dame Reearch & DevVlopm C~neDepama of pvyehwog Nowarb. DE 19711 Artifical Intealgnce PrograU wall Steet PO Bolt 8

Pblde~iso PA 191044196 Dr. Shibuag Wan Schaeartay, NY 12301Depursen of Psychology

Dr. Ronald Slav"e Jacbao state UniveriteyOak Ridg Asne. Univ. 1400 J. R. Lyenchn StweetP.O. ams 117 Jackano, MS 3917

OkRidge. TN 37131.0117

the mechanism of restructuring in geometry

Documents