the hampshire avon management catchment - … · the hampshire avon management catchment ... you...

29
The Hampshire Avon Management Catchment Figure 1 - Photograph of Salisbury cathedral with the Hampshire Avon river in the foreground A summary of information about the water environment in the Hampshire Avon management catchment

Upload: buituong

Post on 27-Jul-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

The Hampshire Avon Management Catchment

Figure 1 - Photograph of Salisbury cathedral with the Hampshire Avon river in the foreground

A summary of information about the water environment in the Hampshire Avon management catchment

2

We are the Environment Agency. We protect and improve the environment and make it a better place for people and wildlife. We operate at the place where environmental change has its greatest impact on people’s lives. We reduce the risks to people and properties from flooding; make sure there is enough water for people and wildlife; protect and improve air, land and water quality and apply the environmental standards within which industry can operate. Acting to reduce climate change and helping people and wildlife adapt to its consequences are at the heart of all that we do. We cannot do this alone. We work closely with a wide range of partners including government, business, local councils, other agencies, civil society groups and the communities we serve. Front cover photo: from Wessex Chalk Streams and Rivers Trust

Published by:

Environment Agency Horizon House, Deanery Road, Bristol BS1 5AH Email: [email protected] www.gov.uk/environment-agency © Environment Agency 2014 All rights reserved. This document may be reproduced with prior permission of the Environment Agency.

Further copies of this report are available on the e-consultation tool: www.gov.uk/government/consultations/update-to-the-draft-river-basin-management-plans and via our National Customer Contact Centre: T: 03708 506506 Email: [email protected].

3

Contents The Hampshire Avon Management Catchment ......................................................... 1

Contents ..................................................................................................................... 3

1 Your views count ................................................................................................. 4

2 The Hampshire Avon Management Catchment ................................................... 6

2.1 Protected areas ............................................................................................. 7

2.2 Status of waters ............................................................................................ 8

2.3 Improvements to how water bodies are assessed ...................................... 11

2.4 Investigating the water environment in the Hampshire Avon management catchment ............................................................................................................. 11

2.5 Challenges and choices consultation 2013 ................................................. 12

2.6 Taking action in partnership ........................................................................ 13

2.7 Measures that could improve the water environment .................................. 15

2.8 Economic appraisal and environmental assessment of measures to improve the water environment .......................................................................................... 16

2.9 Proposed long term objectives .................................................................... 17

2.10 Links to other management plans ............................................................ 18

3 Operational catchments ..................................................................................... 19

3.1 Hampshire Avon Operational Catchment .................................................... 19

4 What do you think? ............................................................................................ 26

4.1 How to respond ........................................................................................... 27

4.2 What the Environment Agency will use the responses for .......................... 27

4.3 How the Environment Agency will use your information .............................. 28

Figure 1 - Photograph of Salisbury cathedral with the Hampshire Avon river in the foreground 1 Figure 2 - Map of the South West river basin district and the management catchments within it .................................................................................................... 5 Figure 3 - Map of the Hampshire Avon management catchment and the operational catchments within it .................................................................................................... 6 Figure 4 - Chart showing the classification of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 1 ................................................................................................... 9 Figure 5 - Chart showing the confirmed reasons for not achieving good status of water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment by type and source sector ............ 12 Figure 6 - Photograph of the Hampshire Avon river ................................................ 19 Figure 7 - Map of the Hampshire Avon operational catchment ............................... 20 Figure 8 - Chart showing the classification of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 1 ................................................................................................. 21 Figure 9 - Chart showing the classification and long term objectives of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 2 (revised boundaries and classification/standards) ........................................................................................... 21 Figure 10 - Chart showing the confirmed reasons for not achieving good status of water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment by type and source sector ............ 22

4

1 Your views count Water is essential for life. It allows the natural environment to flourish, and businesses, agriculture and the economy to grow and prosper. The water environment provides many different benefits to society - from supplying drinking water and supporting fisheries to providing an essential resource for business and agriculture, transport routes and a source of recreation that promotes wellbeing. It is critical that this precious resource is managed properly to ensure that the needs of society, the economy and wildlife can be met and maintained in the long-term. Building on years of progress, the Environment Agency has worked with a range of partners over the past two years to agree what the main problems are, that are stopping there being a healthy water environment in the Hampshire Avon, and how it should work with others to address them. The consultations, Working Together and Challenges and choices, have helped inform this final step in updating the river basin management plan for the South West River Basin District. The ‘Challenges and choices’ consultation set out what the Environment Agency had identified as the significant issues facing the water environment. The significant issues were identified using a broad range of information, including the results of investigations, the agreed “reasons for not achieving good status” (previously called “reasons for failure”) across each catchment and more. We asked if you agreed with these significant issues. The majority of you did but you also raised additional local issues, which will take time to work through with catchment partnerships, to help shape the final river basin management plan. This catchment summary is a support document for the consultation on the draft update to the river basin management plan and for the Catchment Partnerships. It will help you to understand progress with the river basin management planning process so far, at a more local scale. This includes some initial economic appraisal to identify what actions are most cost beneficial. By understanding this information and letting the Environment Agency know what you think, you have an opportunity to influence the decisions about what actions will be taken over the next six years, to improve the health of your water environment. The Catchment Based Approach (CaBA) is a Government policy framework that empowers local action to improve the water environment through community partnerships. A renewed focus on the catchment based approach has led to new Catchment Partnerships being set up to drive local delivery. More information is available in the “Taking action in partnership” section or you can contact the CaBA National Support Group:

• www.catchmentbasedapproach.org • Email: [email protected]

The partnerships are working on a wide range of issues, including the water environment but also address other concerns that are not directly related to river basin management planning. The information in this document will inform the work of

5

the Hampshire Avon Catchment Partnership in developing their vision, aims and priorities; it is not intended to duplicate or overarch the important local work. To view the consultation on the update to the South West River Basin Management Plan, please visit http://ea.objective.co.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405418011983#section-s1405418011983 This is a public consultation and we, the Environment Agency, welcome everyone's views. Figure 2 shows the location of the Hampshire Avon management catchment within the South West River Basin District. To help you get the most out of the information provided within this catchment summary, we have provided a glossary to explain some of the terms that are used. The glossary can be found on the e-consultation web pages. There are many ways to respond to this consultation (see How to respond for more details), but if you have any difficulties please call our National Customer Contact Centre on 03708 506 506 or email [email protected]. This consultation runs from October 2014 to April 2015. We will issue a response document in summer 2015. This will summarise the comments we received and what will happen as a result. The updated South West River Basin Management Plan will be published in December 2015, following approval by the Secretary of State.

Figure 2 - Map of the South West river basin district and the management catchments within it

6

2 The Hampshire Avon Management Catchment

Figure 3 - Map of the Hampshire Avon management catchment and the operational catchments within it

The Hampshire Avon river system flows through a region of outstanding natural and cultural heritage, with the main Wiltshire tributaries converging in Salisbury, and meeting the sea at Christchurch. The catchment support habitats and species of national and international importance, with Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI),

7

Special Area of Conservation, Special Protection Area and Ramsar designations. The overall catchment area is about 1,750 square kilometres and 205 kilometres of the river are designated as SSSI. Although predominantly a chalk river, some of the headwaters are fed by the Upper Greensand (UGS), with clay in its western headwaters, grading to sand and gravels at the lower end. Land use is predominantly rural (98%) comprising of arable, improved pasture grasslands and woodland. The Avon is considered to be one of the most bio diverse river systems in lowland Britain, supporting a very rich flora, fish and invertebrate fauna. The river is well known for its salmon and trout fisheries, although salmon numbers have been under pressure in recent years. Water resources within the Avon catchment are utilised for a number of purposes, the biggest use is public and private water supply. Other activities include general agriculture, spray irrigation, fish farming and mineral activities. In some parts of the catchment, rising phosphate and nitrate levels in the groundwater are a cause for concern. Christchurch Harbour is an important tourist and recreational hub and is internationally important for nature conservation. There are three designated bathing beaches in this area attracting large numbers of visitors. There are some issues with the numbers of water bodies shown in the classification graphs. We are in the process of migrating to an improved water body network and classification which will include more accurate water body boundaries and improved tools. During this period you will notice some differences between cycle 1 and cycle 2 data. The Hampshire Avon management catchment has only one 1 operational catchment. The operational catchment has distinct characteristics and pressures, and requires a mix of measures to achieve long-term objectives for the water environment and reduce the risks of flooding.

2.1 Protected areas There are areas in the catchment where the water environment is recognised as being of particular importance because of the benefits they provide to society. These benefits include rare wildlife habitats, bathing waters or areas around drinking water sources. These areas are known collectively as ‘Protected areas’. Protected areas are a priority for action and protection to make sure we can all continue to enjoy the benefits they provide into the future, and that the investment that has already been made in protecting them is not wasted. Whether a particular part of the water environment is protected or not, we still assess its status every year to understand whether it is healthy or not and whether it’s getting better or worse. Some areas require special protection under European legislation. These designations are designed to manage water, nutrients, chemicals, economically significant species, and wildlife. The management of these areas has been integrated into the overall framework of river basin planning.

8

The table below shows the number of the different types of protected areas in the Hampshire Avon catchment.. Protected area type

Numbers

Bathing Waters 3 Drinking Waters 5 Shellfish Waters 0 Urban Wastewater Treatment 2 More information can be found about protected areas, including how compliance is assessed, in the river basin management planning annex: http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078877. This consultation is concerned with the health of all the water in the Hampshire Avon catchment, both surface water and groundwater. The principal aquifers in the Hampshire Avon catchment are the Cretaceous Chalk and Upper Greensand (UGS). They provide a large proportion of our drinking water supply and provide baseflow to rivers (c85% of all river flow) so their protection is very important. The rivers that are fed by groundwater have unique and important habits such as the Chalk streams.

These aquifers are impacted both in quality and quantity by human activity. The quality is impacted by high levels of nitrate (predominately arising from agricultural activities) and elevated phosphorus levels. Work undertaken as part of a Nutrient Management Plan (NMP) has identified that a significant proportion of phosphorus load entering the Avon is from natural phosphatic minerals in the Upper Greensand Aquifer (further details in NMP).

Where large groundwater supplies have deteriorating trends in water quality, Safeguard Zone action plans have been implemented to help reverse these trends. The aim is reducing point and diffuse pollution by working closely with land owners and by farmers implementing all reasonable measures to manage nutrients efficiently.

Transitional and Coastal Waters (TraC): The river discharges into Christchurch Harbour SSSI which borders the Dorset/Hampshire coastal water body. Protected areas: 9 Special Areas of Conservation (SAC), 1 Special Protection Area (SPA), 6 National Nature Reserves and 71 Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI), Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty and Environmentally Sensitive Areas.

2.2 Status of waters In 2009 this catchment was divided up into 39 river water bodies, 11 lakes, no surface water transfers, 1 estuaries & coastal waters and 3 groundwater bodies. We are proposing some changes to the way the catchment is divided up, which are described in more detail below. In 2009 30% of water bodies were classified at Good

9

Ecological Status (GES) or better. Additional classification information by water body type can be found here: http://environment.data.gov.uk/catchment-planning/. Figure 4 shows the classification for the catchment’s surface waters in 2009, when the first river basin management plan was published, and the most recent (2013) status.

Figure 4 - Chart showing the classification of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 1

Since 2009 during cycle 1, the Environment Agency and our Partners have been actively working to both confirm the causes of less than good status and to take necessary interventions to improve these water bodies which we felt were a priority. Some of the improvements are not yet reflected in the data. There has been some improvement to several of the water bodies in the 2013 classification. Deane Water, Nine Mile River, Dockens Water and Linford Brook, have been reclassified from Poor Status in 2009 to Moderate Status in 2013. However, there has also been some drop in status, for example, some of the Nadder tributaries, have declined from Moderate Ecological Status in 2009 to Poor Ecological Status in 2013 . Some of the reported drop in status in 2013 has been ascribed to improvements in assessment methodology and the addition of new elements, while other drops in status are under investigation. The ‘bad’ status result shown in the 2013 classification in Figure 4 is due to a ‘bad’ phytobenthos result in the Chitterne Brook. We have low confidence in this result; it is inconsistent with the status of other elements in the water body and we are investigating.

The majority of water bodies not meeting Good Ecological Status are failing for elements such as phosphate and fish.

10

The Hampshire Avon Catchment Partnership has concerns about some classification results. Proposed phosphorus standards may not be met in the river and the partnership recommends that sediment and phosphorus be treated as separate issues as they have different impacts on the river. Many of the SAC water bodies are classified as ‘good’ but they do not meet favourable condition targets1 for phosphorus. The partnership also considers that additional issues not covered are:

• Fine Sediments • Impacts of fish farms • Turbid water during spring and early summer • Algal blooms • Impacts of multiple stressors acting together • Effects of climate change

Additional evidence that could be used:

• Fish catch records from anglers • Invertebrate data from The Riverfly Partnership • Invasive species records

The Wessex Chalk Streams and Rivers Trust are undertaking a Catchment Invertebrate Fingerprinting (CIF) investigation to provide a greater level of evidence of the impact of stressors such as fine sediment on the ecology. Pollution 'hot spots' are appearing in the catchment which combine substantial sediment, phosphate, organic pollution and low-flow impacts. The main reasons for not achieving good status are diffuse pollution from agricultural sources, point source pollution from the water industry and physical modification.

Pollution from agricultural land contributes to high phosphorus which has adverse effects on water uses and ecology. Fine solids running off land can carry an excess of nutrients causing an imbalance in the river leading to algal blooms and water quality problems. Too much sediment can settle in the gravel stopping fish eggs from hatching by preventing a good flow of oxygen.

Rising nitrates and phosphates in groundwater impacts on drinking water sources and conservation interests. The headwaters of some parts of the catchment are underlain by UGS (a source of phosphate). The Avon is a Catchment Sensitive Farming target catchment and there are groundwater Nitrate Vulnerable Zones; improvements have been made through this and work by the water companies who have removed 80% of phosphate from their sewage treatment works, although point source pollution remains an issue. 1 Conservation objectives define the desired state for protected areas in terms of features for which they have been designated. When these features are being managed in a way which maintains their conservation value, then they are said to be in ‘favourable condition’. Favourable condition targets for individual elements can be more stringent than Water Framework Directive targets for meeting GES.

11

Modification to river form and structures are an issue; a quarter of the water bodies in the catchment are modified with over 110 river obstructions. Several alien species are widely present and are part of a multispecies eradication project.

2.3 Improvements to how water bodies are assessed Improvements have been made to the way water bodies are defined and classified since the plans were published in 2009. Subject to consultation, the changes will be adopted when the updated plans are published in 2015. You can find more information about these improvements in the ‘River Basin Management Planning Annex’ at http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078877 The table below shows the status of the different kinds of water bodies in the management catchment based on these new approaches. Management Catchment

Numbers of water bodies at each status or potential in 2013 (using new building blocks)

Water body type

High Good Moderate Poor Bad

Rivers & Canals (including Surface Water Transfers)

0 15 18 6 1

Lakes

0 4 6 1 0

Estuaries and Coastal waters

0 0 1 0 0

Ground waters

- 1 - 2 -

For more information on the changes since cycle 1, please see section 4.3 ‘Changes since first cycle (new building blocks)’ within Part 2 (technical annex) of the RBMPs. (http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078877).

2.4 Investigating the water environment in the Hampshire Avon management catchment

Since the initial assessment of status was made, the Environment Agency and its partners have been working to understand the reasons for not achieving good status. Since 2009, the Environment Agency has carried out 208 investigations in the Hampshire Avon catchment. These have helped to determine the reasons why water bodies are failing and the likely causes.

12

Figure 5 - Chart showing the confirmed reasons for not achieving good status of water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment by type and source sector

All reasons for not achieving good status data are available on the catchment data explorer.

2.5 Challenges and choices consultation 2013 In 2013, through the ‘Challenges and choices’ consultation, the Environment Agency asked for your views on:

• The significant issues that are limiting the benefits society obtains from the water environment (the challenges) and

• The best way to address these issues and what should be done first (the choices)

We had 115 responses to the South West River Basin District Challenges and choices consultation and 22 were specific to the Hampshire Avon catchment. Responses were received from a mixture of individuals and organisations including Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty (AONBs), Wildlife Trusts, River Trusts, Angling Clubs & Organisations, Utility Companies, Local Councils, industry groups, energy industry, conservation charities & local businesses. The general consensus was that the catchment would benefit from improved communication, linked up delivery and a shared vision between key stakeholders. Community & catchment groups must be more inclusive and much wider than just

13

fishing; it must include farmers, local authorities and other water users. There is a feeling that many of the problems on the river are well known and frequently discussed. Over abstraction was considered to be the biggest challenge facing the Avon, other popular responses included the loss of riverine habitat including gravel removal, pollution and sedimentation from fields, roads, and fish farms and flashy quick response run off events from heavy rainfall transporting sediment into rivers. Additional monitoring was also viewed as a requirement, and questions were raised over our knowledge of the species that are present in our water bodies, both native and invasive. For further information on the responses submitted during the ‘Challenges and choices’ consultation, please see the consultation response document here: https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/water/choices.

2.6 Taking action in partnership In June 2013, the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs (Defra) published a policy framework to encourage the wider adoption of an integrated Catchment Based Approach to improving the quality of the water environment, which incorporated findings from the pilot phase. The objectives for the Catchment Based Approach are:

• To deliver positive and sustained outcomes for the water environment by promoting a better understanding of the environment at a local level; and

• To encourage local collaboration and more transparent decision-making when both planning and delivering activities to improve the water environment.

Adopting the approach will promote the development of more appropriate river basin management plans (which underpin the delivery of the objectives of the Water Framework Directive) but will also provide a platform for engagement, discussion and decisions of much wider benefits including tackling diffuse agricultural and urban pollution, and widespread, historical alterations to the natural form of channels. The Environment Agency is a member of the Hampshire Avon Catchment Partnership, who are developing a plan to enhance the catchment. This summary has been informed by the Partnership, both formally through the ‘Challenges and choices’ consultation and through the ongoing work to develop measures to protect and improve the water environment. As well as shaping the updates to the river basin management plan, the results of this consultation will be used to inform the work of the Partnership. There is a strong history of collaborative action in the Hampshire Avon catchment to improve the rivers and the wider habitats it supports. Many of the organisations active in the catchment have been involved in extensive programmes of habitat management, restoration and awareness campaigns and the partnership intends to use and build upon these existing relationships and projects.

14

The partnership was formed in early 2014 and the organisations/individuals involved are committed to working together to achieve better outcomes for the water environment in line with a vision for high water quality and sustainable flows, abundant wildlife, and fully functioning and resilient ecosystems. A Catchment Action Plan is being produced to guide this process, bringing together issues identified by existing plans and strategies, stakeholder input and data and evidence gathering. The plan will prioritise actions for the key issues affecting the Hampshire Avon. The Wessex Chalk Streams and Rivers Trust are hosting the catchment partnership. More details on the Catchment Partnership can be found at www.wcsrt.org.uk/catchment-partnerships. During the first cycle of the river basin management plan, a range of partners have been working to improve and protect the water environment. There have been many projects and works undertaken and, projects may cover multiple water bodies. Numerous partnership programmes since 2009 have been delivering environmental enhancements across the catchment, including the following:

• Life Project: http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/regions/south_west/ourwork/stream-livingriver.aspx

• River Avon Restoration Project (RARP): http://www.wiltshirewildlife.org/what-we-do/Directory

• Demonstration Test catchment: http://www.avondtc.org.uk/ • Avon Roach Project: http://www.avonroachproject.co.uk/ • Source to sea Invasives: http://www.wiltshirewildlife.org/what-we-

do/The+Source+to+Sea+Project • Wessex Chalkstream Project (WCSP): http://www.wiltshirewildlife.org/what-

we-do/wessexchalksstreams • Catchment Sensitive farming:

http://www.naturalengland.org.uk/ourwork/farming/csf/default.aspx • Wessex Bess: http://www.brc.ac.uk/wessexbess/home

There have been numerous partnership projects delivered within the catchment, for example:

• Butts Road – WCSP – River restoration project incorporating habitat enhancement, flood plain connectivity, reed bed restoration and improved disabled access with information boards describing the works and benefits.

• The Severals – Wessex Chalkstream & Rivers Trust – River restoration project with habitat enhancement for young fish, installation of flow deflectors and the opening of culverts to improve flow across the floodplain.

For more information about projects delivered in the Hampshire Avon: http://riverwiki.restorerivers.eu/wiki/index.php?title=Main_Page http://www.therrc.co.uk/rrc_map.php

15

Additional partnership projects are planned for the future. The key objective moving forwards will be to link projects together, expanding not only the size and scale of the projects but also increase the number partners involved. With the prospect of greater collaboration on projects by undertaking a Catchment Based Approach there is opportunity to work across issues and deliver multiple benefits into the future. Additional Schemes not included within the Environment Agency projects list include:

• Wessex Water- Catchment Management Work in Source Protection Zones http://www.wessexwater.co.uk/sustainability/customersandcommunities/default.aspx?id=3428

• Nutrient Management Plan – Collaborative project looking at reducing nutrients released into the catchment

• Wessex Water – Low Flow impact studies http://www.wessexwater.co.uk/sustainability/environment/default.aspx?id=3456

• Forestry Commission – New Forest Stream Restoration Projects http://www.hlsnewforest.org.uk/info/50/wetlandrestoration

• Barbel Society – Funding and research into habitat restoration • Cranborne Chase ANOB – Farmland Birds Project

http://www.ccwwdaonb.org.uk/projects/farmland.htm • Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust –Farmer-led initiatives to restore

breeding wader birds numbers on the Lower Avon • Salisbury Greenspaces group- looking into the management of the green

spaces and their importance to the community https://salisburygreenspace.wordpress.com/

• MORE Woods – Riparian tree and hedgerow planting scheme www.woodlandtrust.org.uk/morewoods

• New Forest National Park - Better Boundaries project www. Newforestnpa.gov.uk/better-boundaries

2.7 Measures that could improve the water environment Where a failure has been identified, a range of measures have been assessed that would be needed to improve the status of water bodies. The Environment Agency has made an assessment of the measures needed to achieve positive benefits for the water environment and society. The measures have been grouped together to ensure the cummulative ‘catchment’ effect is considered. Where possible, climate resilient measures have been chosen. However it is considered unlikely that the measures will be sufficient to address all impacts of climate change and we will be assessing the likely gaps before the publication of the final South West River Basin Management Plan: https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405417915018#section-s1405417915018 As well as the measures needed to improve the status of water bodies, other measures are needed to:

• Protect or improve ‘protected areas’ within the operational catchment

16

• Prevent water bodies deteriorating from their current status. Some of these measures will benefit more than one water body or catchment and some are very specific. The cumulative effect and benefits of measures for the operational catchment have been considered. The measures proposed for this catchment are:

Improve modified physical habitats • Removal or easement of barriers to fish migration

• Improvement to condition of channel/bed and/or banks/shoreline

• Improvement to condition of riparian zone and /or wetland habitats

Managing pollution from waste water • Mitigate/remediate point source impacts on receptor

Manage pollution from towns, cities and transport • Reduce diffuse pollution pathways (i.e. control entry to the water environment)

Manage pollution from rural areas • Mitigate/remediate diffuse pollution impacts on the receptor

Improve the natural flow and level of water • Water demand management

• Improvement to condition of channel/bed and/or banks/shoreline

National Approach to managing Invasive non native species (INNS): INNS are likely to cause deterioration in the ecological status of many of water bodies. Their ability to spread rapidly means that prevention is the most cost-effective solution. It is critical that all partners follow the principles of good biosecurity as outlined in the Check, Clean, Dry campaign, and work with partners to promote this message. All actions to control and manage INNS should follow the national measures in the river basin management plans and fit within the GB Invasive Non-Native Species Strategy.

2.8 Economic appraisal and environmental assessment of measures to improve the water environment

The benefits that measures will bring to society, along with the cost and any disbenefits (negative impacts) of implementing them, have been assessed in economic appraisals. The appraisals aim to identify whether the measures needed to improve the water environment are cost beneficial, in other words, the benefits are greater than the costs. The effects of the measures on the wider environment are also considered, which helps to inform the environmental assessment. The results of the appraisals will help to decide if it is economically, environmentally and socially worthwhile to implement the measures. Environmental and socio-economic benefits and disbenefits (negative impacts) are considered in the economic appraisals. A monetary value has been assigned to

17

some benefits. For surface waters, this is based on society’s willingness to pay for improvements in the water environment2. For ground waters, values used have been ‘transferred’ from other detailed economic studies3. Other benefits and disbenefits which have not been monetised have been identified and form part of the overall appraisal results. The majority of the costs of measures, assessed in the economic appraisals carried out, are estimates. Costs are from local and national sources, and are based on previous experience of implementing similar measures. Where more accurate, local cost information is available, this has been used in place of national estimates. The economic appraisals have been carried out at the operational catchment scale. If the group of measures to improve all water bodies in the catchment to good status is not considered to be cost beneficial (so the cost outweighs the benefits), or would have significant adverse effects on the wider environment, an alternative group of measures to achieve the most for the water environment has been appraised. Assessing the costs and benefits of improving our water environment is an ongoing process and economic appraisals will need to be updated as new and better information becomes available. Your responses to this consultation will help us gather more and better information about the costs and benefits of the measures needed. The economic appraisals we’ve carried out will be refined before the updated South West River Basin Management Plan is published. For more information on the approach taken for catchment economic appraisals and environmental assessment, please see the draft update to the South West River Basin Management Plan : https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405417915018#section-s1405417915018

2.9 Proposed long term objectives In the consultation, we ask for your views on the proposed long term objectives for the water environment, based on preventing a drop in status and delivering all improvements which are technically feasible and worthwhile, based on economic appraisal. This will allow resources to be targeted where they will deliver the most benefits and provide you with a degree of certainty over the long-term quality of your local water environment. This means that in certain circumstances we will be proposing less stringent objectives. Exemptions (if they apply) will result in a less stringent objective or an objective with an extended deadline being proposed. In the following operational catchment sections, we look at the possible scale of improvement which could happen in the second cycle, based on current knowledge of plans and actions. 2Willingness to pay values used are from The Environment Agency’s National Water Environment Benefits Survey (2007, updated 2012). 3 ‘Benefits transfer’ is a recognised way of using benefit values from existing academic studies and surveys. Other benefits which have not been monetised have been identified and form part of the overall economic appraisal results.

18

2.10 Links to other management plans Achieving the long term objectives for the water environment will require a coordinated approach to making improvements across a number of different planning processes. The Strategic Environmental Assessment Environment Report considers the full range of plans that are relevant to the South West River Basin District and it’s catchments. To see this report go to: http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078976 One of the most important links relates to the way flood risks are managed in the catchment. Over the next two years, the Environment Agency will be undertaking considerable planning work, culminating in the publication of the updated river basin management plans and the flood risk management plans. Together, these plans will shape important decisions, direct considerable investment and action, and deliver significant benefits to society and the environment. The two planning processes are working to common river basin district boundaries and many key stakeholders have an interest in both. As the plans themselves and the supporting documents/data-sets are complex, we have decided not to integrate them into a single set of consultation documents. Instead we will coordinate the engagement around the planning processes, promoting them together, cross-referencing, and explaining how they relate to each other. We believe this is the best way to make it easy for you to participate in either, or both, consultations. The flood risk management plan consultation coincides with the launch of this consultation. It includes the measures proposed to manage flood risk, and can be found at: www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-flood-risk-management-plans Flood risk management plans give an overview of flood risk and indentify measures to reduce these risks. Environmental objectives are: to work with natural processes to achieve Water Framework Directive objectives; to improve the water environment, hydromorphology and create habitat through flood risk management; to minimise impacts of flooding on areas of environmental importance. Measures identified which give the best opportunity to deliver river basin management plan aims are: influencing local planning authorities to avoid inappropriate floodplain development; improving existing flood defences; reducing flood risk in Salisbury and Wilton; replacing Tisbury Flood Gate and reducing flood risk to properties around Christchurch Harbour without impacting the SSSI.

19

3 Operational catchments The following section gives an overview of the current state of the water environment in the operational catchment; the reasons for not achieving good status; and the measures being proposed to protect and improve the health of the water.

3.1 Hampshire Avon Operational Catchment

Figure 6 - Photograph of the Hampshire Avon river (courtesy of Wessex Chalk Streams and Rivers Trust)

The Hampshire Avon river system rises in the vale of Pewsey and flows through a region of outstanding natural and cultural heritage, with the Wiltshire tributaries converging in Salisbury, and meeting the sea at Christchurch. They support habitats and species of national and international importance, with Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI), Special Area of Conservation and Special Protection Area designations. The total catchment area is approximately 1,750 square kilometres, with 205 kilometres of river designated as SSSI. Christchurch Harbour is internationally important for nature conservation. There are three designated bathing beaches in this area attracting large numbers of visitors.

We are in the process of migrating to an improved water body network and classification which will include more accurate water body boundaries and improved tools. During this period you will notice some differences between cycle 1 and cycle 2 data.

20

Figure 7 - Map of the Hampshire Avon operational catchment

There are 39 rivers, 11 lakes, 1 estuarine & coastal waters and 3 groundwater bodies in this catchment (cycle 2 network). The status (health) of the water environment in 2009 was assessed as being generally moderate. In 2014, the status of the water environment had not deteriorated and was showing encouraging signs of improvement. It can take five to ten years for the positive benefits of actions to be reflected in the ecological status. Our current analysis suggests that 63% of the water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment should have a long term objective of achieving good status, as shown in Figure 9.

21

Figure 8 - Chart showing the classification of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 1

For more information on the changes since cycle 1, please see section 4.3 ‘Changes since first cycle (new building blocks)’ within Part 2 (technical annex) of the RBMPs. (http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078877)

Figure 9 - Chart showing the classification and long term objectives of all water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment in cycle 2 (revised boundaries and classification/standards)

22

The ‘bad’ status result shown in the 2013 classification in Figures 8 and 9 is due to a ‘bad’ phytobenthos result in the Chitterne Brook. We have low confidence in this result, it is inconsistent with the status of other elements in the water body and we are investigating. Since 2009, investigations in this catchment have helped to determine the reasons why water bodies are not achieving good status, and the likely causes. These are shown in Figure 10 below.

Figure 10 - Chart showing the confirmed reasons for not achieving good status of water bodies in the Hampshire Avon catchment by type and source sector

Measures to improve the water environment have been assessed. Some of these measures will benefit more than one water body or catchment and some are very specific. The cumulative effect and benefits of measures for the operational catchment have been considered. The measures proposed for this catchment are shown in the table below

Improve modified physical habitats • Removal or easement of barriers to fish migration

• Improvement to condition of channel/bed and/or banks/shoreline

• Improvement to condition of riparian zone and /or wetland habitats

Managing pollution from waste water • Mitigate/remediate point source impacts on receptor

Manage pollution from towns, cities and transport • Reduce diffuse pollution pathways (i.e. control entry to the water environment)

23

Manage pollution from rural areas • Mitigate/remediate diffuse pollution impacts on the receptor

Improve the natural flow and level of water • Water demand management

• Improvement to condition of channel/bed and/or banks/shoreline

National Approach to managing Invasive non native species (INNS): INNS are likely to cause deterioration in the ecological status of many of water bodies. Their ability to spread rapidly means that prevention is the most cost-effective solution. It is critical that all partners follow the principles of good biosecurity as outlined in the Check, Clean, Dry campaign, and work with partners to promote this message. All actions to control and manage INNS should follow the national measures in the river basin management plans and fit within the GB Invasive Non-Native Species Strategy. In the Hampshire Avon catchment there are a range of measures proposed. These include tackling agricultural and urban diffuse pollution, point source pollution aimed to reduce nutrients in waste water impacting on surface and groundwater bodies, improving modified watercourses to be more natural through river restoration and habitat creation as part of several partnership projects such as the River Avon Restoration Project (RARP). Measures include reducing the impacts of urbanisation, abstractions and improving fish passage. These measures will contribute to programmes of work to investigate and protect important protected areas SSSIs/SPA/SAC sites, EU Bathing waters, and groundwater drinking water supply sources. All of these measures are considered to be needed to improve the water environment to as near to good status as practicable. The costs and benefits of the measures have been considered in the catchment economic appraisal, results of which are shown below. You can find out more detail on the status and long term objectives by using the Catchment Data Explorer tool at: http://environment.data.gov.uk/catchment-planning/.

3.1.1 Hampshire Avon catchment economic appraisal and environmental assessment

3.1.2 Results and recommendation Measures proposed to improve the water environment to good status (where it is considered to be potentially achievable) in this catchment are cost beneficial; the benefits are greater than the costs. The results of the economic appraisal are shown below.

24

Net present value

£196.43 million

Benefit cost ratio

19

Present value benefits

£192.6 million

Present value costs

£10.4 million

3.1.3 Monetised costs and benefits of implementing the measures proposed for this catchment4

This means that for every pound that is spent towards improving the water environment in this catchment, you could expect to receive £19 of benefits.

3.1.4 Benefits and costs of implementing the measures proposed for this catchment5

Ecosystem service

Benefits and disbenefits to society

Positive or negative impact ˄˄: very positive ˄: positive 0: neutral ˅: negative ˅˅: very negative

Fresh water ˄ Water for non-consumptive use ˄ Water regulation (timing and scale of run-off, flooding, etc.) ˄ Erosion regulation ˄˄ Water purification and waste treatment ˄ Cultural heritage ˅ Aesthetic value ˄ Intellectual and scientific, educational ˄ Social relations (e.g. fishing, grazing or cropping communities) Damage to the Avon Valley SSSIs. ˄ Soil formation ˄ Primary production (in river) ˄ Provision of habitat ˄˄ Impacts on the erosion regulation and provision of habitat ecosystem services are particularly important in the results of this economic appraisal. The impacts will

4 The benefits and costs are shown in ‘Present Value’ terms, which is a way of expressing the value of costs and benefits that will happen in the future in today’s money. We apply a ‘discount’ rate and benefits to reflect people’s preference for receiving goods and services now rather than later.

5Improving the water environment has wider benefits than those we have been able to monetise in the appraisals. We have

identified these using ecosystem services. An ecosystem service is a ‘service’ that the natural environment provides that improves our quality of life.

25

significantly benefit society and although they have not been valued and monetised as part of this economic appraisal, further support the proposed measures for this catchment. The Final Appraisal Report provides a more detailed summary of this economic appraisal. This and other associated appraisal documents can be requested at [email protected] The economic appraisal for the Hampshire Avon catchment is high level and strategic. A more detailed assessment would be needed to assess the impacts of individual projects. The economic appraisal does not include costs to improve the SSSI and SAC protected areas due to the requirement under EU legislation to return them to good ecological status. As the majority of the rivers and catchment area is designated as a protected area, the overall value costs within the catchment are reduced but the benefits increase; less money is required outside of statutory work to return the river to good ecological status, though achieving good status upstream of the protected areas is complementary as it will often influence the status of the designated area downstream (e.g. water quality, siltation, flow, threat of invasive species).

3.1.5 Possible scale of improvement for the Hampshire Avon operational catchment

The information presented so far has focused on the proposed long term objectives for the water environment, based on preventing deterioration and delivering all improvements which are technically feasible and worthwhile. This section focuses on the possible scale of improvement which could happen in the period to 2021, based on current knowledge of plans and actions. The table below indicates what is currently known about the availability of some key mechanisms to deliver improvements by 2021. In this operational catchment: Yes or No Have measures been implemented (or are secured for 2014-15) that will deliver improvements that have not yet been reflected in classification results? E.g. Catchment Sensitive Farming, Catchment Restoration Fund Projects

Yes

Are there measures planned to deliver Protected Area objectives that will also contribute to improvements in water body status?

Yes

Has this operational catchment been identified in water company draft business plans as an area for improvement?

Yes

Has this operational catchment been identified as a priority for action under the new environmental land management schemes (NELMS)?

Yes

Have the local catchment partnership identified measures they are likely to secure funding for, which will bring about improvement within the 2nd cycle?

Yes

Are any additional improvement measures included in Environment Agency or other statutory plans?

Yes

Based on our understanding of the information above, and our catchment

26

knowledge, we have medium confidence that this operational catchment will see an improvement towards the proposed long term objectives by 2021.

4 What do you think? In order to produce a river basin management plan and a flood risk management plan, it is important that the people who understand the local area are able to contribute to these plans. The draft update to the river basin management plan provides information on the river basin district and then asks you to consider a number of questions. To help you provide feedback at the level that is most relevant to you, the catchment summaries summarise the river basin planning information at a more local scale.

• To see the full set of consultation questions, please go to : https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405418011983#section-s1405418011983

• To see the flood risk management plan questions, please go to http://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/draft-flood-risk-management-plans

Your answers to the questions above will help inform the final plans and ensure that the objectives they contain will help drive the protection, enhancement and improvement of the water environment for all its users. For further information on how to provide your answers to these questions, please go to the “How to respond” section below.

27

4.1 How to respond The Environment Agency would prefer you to respond online at: https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405418011983#section-s1405418011983. This will allow you to manage your comments more effectively, while helping us to gather and summarise responses quickly and accurately. Alternatively, there is a Word response form available for each river basin district which you can download and use to write your response before you submit it online, or you can email it to [email protected] . You can view the consultation documents and consultation questions online. But, if you would prefer a printed version of the document, please contact the Environment Agency’s National Customer Contact Centre on 03708 506 506 (local rate). Please return written responses by 10 April 2015.

4.2 What the Environment Agency will use the responses for The Environment Agency will use the responses from this consultation to update the South West River Basin Management Plan. Environment Agency staff dealing with this consultation will see all responses in full. Other Environment Agency staff may also see the responses to help them plan future consultations. A full summary of the responses will be published on the Environment Agency website.

Finding out more

• Strategic Environmental Assessment report http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078976

• Proposed update to South West River Basin Management Plan https://consult.environment-agency.gov.uk/portal/ho/wfd/draft_plans/consult?pointId=s1405418011983#section-s1405418011983

• River Basin Management Plan Technical Annex http://ea.objective.co.uk/file/3078877

• Hampshire Avon Catchment partnership http://hampshireavoncatchmentpartnership.org.uk

• Wessex Chalk Streams and Rivers Trust http://www.wcsrt.org.uk/catchment-partnerships

• Joint Nature Conservation Committee http://jncc.defra.gov.uk/

• Natural England

28

4.3 How the Environment Agency will use your information The Environment Agency will make all comments (apart from personal information) publicly available on the Environment Agency website. This includes comments received online, by email, post and by fax, unless you have specifically requested that your response be kept confidential. Only names of organisations that respond and not individuals will be published. If you respond online or provide an email address, you will receive an acknowledgement of your response. After the consultation has closed a summary of the responses will be published on the Environment Agency website. You will be contacted to let you know when this is available. You will also be notified of any forthcoming river basin consultations unless you request otherwise. Under the Freedom of Information Act 2000, the Environment Agency may be required to publish your response to this consultation, but will not include any personal information. If you have requested your response be kept confidential, it may still be required to provide a summary. If you have any questions or complaints about the way this consultation has been carried out, please contact: Cath Beaver, Consultation Co-ordinator Environment Agency, Horizon House, Deanery Road, Bristol, BS1 5AH [email protected]

29