the evil quartet - birkbeck, university of london · steven gaines dove sax. 6 sax & gaines...
TRANSCRIPT
1
The evil quartet
If we know what causes biodiversity
loss, we should also know the solutions
Dave Dawson February 2011
Jared Diamond
THE EVIL QUARTET
In the 80s Diamond investigated
recent extinctions
and found that their agents of
decline, where known, could be
classed under four headings:
1. Overkill.
2. Habitat destruction and
fragmentation.
3. Impact of introduced species.
4. Chains of extinction.
From Caughley (1994)
The evil sextet
If we know what causes biodiversity loss, we
should also know the solutions
• Over-exploitation
• Invasive alien species
• Loss and degradation of habitat
• Pollution and intensive management
• Climate change
• Us
Dave Dawson February 2011
2
David Raup
Jack Sepkoski
Prof. Norman
MacLeod Natural
History Museum
McLeod (2003)
1 2 3 4 5
Stages in geological time
McLeod 2003
The evil quartet
• Over-exploitation
Dave Dawson February 2011
If we know what causes biodiversity
loss, we should also know the solutions
3
Paul Martin
Prehistoric overkill
• Rapid extinction of
megafauna shortly
after arrival of people
•People in small
numbers, but they
were
•Sophisticated, group
hunters
•with advanced tools
Martin (1989)
4
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment
Vitousek et al. (1997a)
World fisheries
Garratt Hardin 1968
The tragedy of the commons
The evil quartet
• Invasive alien species
Dave Dawson February 2011
If we know what causes biodiversity loss,
we should also know the solutions
•Over-exploitation
5
Grass flora of New Zealand
157
31
226
46
Endemic Indigenous Naturalised Transient
Edgar & Connor (2000)
Dove SaxSteven Gaines
6
Sax &
Gaines
(2008)
Plant species on islands
Sax & Gaines (2008)Plant species on well-studied islands
The increase of alien species over time
Species invasions and extinction: The future
of native biodiversity on islands
• Predation by exotic species has caused
the extinction of many native animal
species on islands, whereas competition
from exotic plants has caused few native
plant extinctions
• But, could there be a surplus of species,
and so an extinction debt of island plants?
• Probably not, at least not yet
Sax & Gaines (2008)
7
Mainland invasive non-native species
• Most non-native species don’t
harm native biodiversity (Didham et
al. 2005, Hamilton 2011, but see Vitoųsek
et al. 1997, Burton et al. 2010)
• And concern here is rather with the cost to the GB economy (estimated
to be 1.7 billion (Williams et al. 2010), and
• So this is a real issue, but perhaps not a very significant one for our local biodiversity?
The evil quartet
• Loss and degradation of habitat
Dave Dawson February 2011
If we know what causes biodiversity loss, we
should also know the solutions
•Over-exploitation
•Invasive alien species
Darlington (1957)
West Indies.
The number of species, S,
relates to the area of the
island, A
D = cAz Preston (1962)
Number of
amphibian and
reptile species,
log scale
Island size, log scale
8
E.O. Wilson, studied ants on New Guinea islands MacArthur & Wilson
(1967) The theory of
island biogeography
Jared DiamondDiamond (1975)
Oceanic islands
in equilibrium
Land bridge islands(connected to New Guinea
10,000 years ago)
Carry an “extinction
debt”
New Guinea satellite islands
9
New Guinea satellite islands
Diamond (1975)
Fraction of
near island
number, log
scale
Diamond (1975)
•Bigger better
•Single large better than several
small
•Close spacing better
•Grouping better
•Better linked with corridors = B
•Better compact than thin
1980
Lenore Fahrig
10
Habitat
Habitat fragmentation (Fahrig 2003)
Habitat
Habitat fragmentation (Fahrig 2003)
Matrix
Habitat
Habitat fragmentation (Fahrig 2003)
Matrix
Correlated effects of Habitat loss, after Forman (1997) & Fahrig (2003)
Landscape multicollinearity
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
0 20 40 60 80 100
Percentage of Habitat Lost
Do
min
an
ce
of
ea
ch
pro
ce
ss
, a
rea
s
an
d n
um
be
rs
Perforation
Fragmentati
onShrinkage
Attrition
Patch size
Core
Isolation
# of patches
11
An apparent effect of patch size on biodiversity
could actually be an effect of:
• the total amount of habitat left in the landscape (Fahrig 2003)
• isolation from other patches (Diamond 1975)
• a change in edge to core ratio of patches (Ewers & Didham 2007)
• extinction debt (Diamond 1975)
• historical factors (e.g. time since fragmentation, differing invasive
aliens)
• a coincidental correlation with some other cause (Didham et al. 2005)
• “habitat heterogeneity” within the landscape and a selective loss of this:
Báldi (2008), Boakes et al. (2010)……
12
Studies are needed at the landscape,
not the patch level
• “Habitat patches” are never homogeneous
• Work is needed at a scale appropriate to the
movement of the species
• To distinguish the effects of habitat loss and
fragmentation
• To take proper account of the matrix
• Difficult to study, as replicate landscapes are
needed
McGarigal & Cushman (2002), Fahrig (2003), Ewers & Didham (2005), Kupfer et al.(2006)
Meg Game
George Peterken
Incidence of Dog's mercury in recent woods with distance
from older woods (Game & Peterken 1981)
0
50
100
< 0.2 0.2 - 0.4 0.4 - 0.8 0.8 - 1.6 1.6 - 3.2 3.2 - 6.4
Distance from source (Km, log scale)
Perc
en
tag
e w
ith
Do
g's
merc
ury
(95%
co
nfi
den
ce l
imit
s)
Woodland herbs in central Lincolnshire (after Game & Peterken
1984)
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
1 10 100
Number of ancient woods (log scale)
Nu
mb
er
of
sp
ec
ies 5ha
15ha
40ha
70ha
150ha
250ha
350ha
600ha
Increasing fragmentation
13
Alessio Mortelliti
80% forest coverIncidence of Hazel
Dormouse in 41
landscape blocks
in central Italy
Mortelliti et al. (2011)
Under 10% forest cover
Increasing amount of hedgerows (length in a 4x4 km landscape block)
100%
Proportion
of
landscape
blocks with
Hazel
Dormice
0%
Dr Robert Ewers
Dr Raphael Didham
14
Distance from edge
between forest (left) and
grassland matrix right
(logarithmic scale)
Beetle species’
responses to the
edge between
temperate
rainforest (left) and
grassland matrix
(right).
45% showed little
or no edge effect.
5% of the species preferred
the grassland matrix
Ewers & Didham 2008
Beetle
population
abundance
Distance from edge
between forest (left) and
grassland matrix right
(logarithmic scale)
Beetle species’
responses to the
edge between
temperate
rainforest (left) and
grassland matrix
(right).
38% of the species were affected
up to 50m into the forest
Ewers & Didham 2008
Beetle
population
abundance
Distance (m) from edge
between forest (left) and
grassland matrix right
(logarithmic scale)
Beetle species’
responses to the
edge between
temperate
rainforest (left) and
grassland matrix
(right).
12% of the species were affected
1000m, or more, into the forest!
Ewers & Didham 2008
Beetle
population
abundance
Edge effects reducing
and fragmenting the
core
Ewers & Didham (2007)
15
Extinction debt
Kakamega Forest, Kenya
Brooks et al. (1999)
Extinction debt
Kakamega Forest, Kenya
Brooks et al. (1999)
Extinction debt is difficult both to study and to apply
• An initial equilibrium is assumed: Whittaker et al. (2005)
• We assume the slopes of the two species-area curves (z) and often ignore the matrix: Whittaker et al. (2005), Wright & Muller-Landau (2006), Ladle (2009), Smith (2010) but see Koh & Ghazoul (2010)
• It’s difficult to obtain comparable species lists (Ladle 2009)
• The timing of fragmentation is not firm
• We should study replicate landscapes, not patches
• What of other taxa (e.g. beetles)?
• And of other habitats and geographic areas?
• How much confidence have we here, let alone extrapolation to other (e.g. northern temperate) regions?
• A persuasive case for some species (Marsh fritilliary, Bulman et
al. 2007)
• We should be cautious over simple predictions of future extinctions
World biodiversity “Hotspots”Myers (1988)
16
Combined
Priority afforded
by schemes that
focus on:
A (Red), where
most has been
lost or
B (Green), where
most remains,
and so which are
vulnerable in
future
The evil quartet
• Pollution and intensive management
Dave Dawson February 2011
If we know what causes biodiversity loss, we
should also know the solutions
•Over-exploitation
•Invasive alien species
•Loss and degradation of habitat
Fritz Haber Paul Müller
Published 1962, DDT banned in US 1972
17
Ratcliffe (1970)
Year
Eggshell
thickness
Peregrine Falcon eggshell thinning
and organochlorine pesticide use
Anon 2010, see also Gregory et al. (2004)
The second silent spring? Krebs et al. 1999
The second silent spring (Krebs et al. 1999).
What is needed in the agricultural matrix?
• “Extensification”
• “Agri-environment” enhancements?
• Organic farming?
• Most agree that the solutions need to be
focussed on individual farms, but
• Don’t forget the habitat patches, and
• Big re-wilding schemes?
18
(2007)
The evil quartet
• Climate change
Dave Dawson February 2011
If we know what causes biodiversity loss, we
should also know the solutions
•Over-exploitation
•Invasive alien species
•Loss and degradation of habitat
•Pollution and intensive management
Climate change and habitat loss
Species’ distribution
Climate envelope
Climate change and habitat loss
Species’ distribution
Climate envelope
Lost habitat
19
Climate change and habitat loss
Species’ distribution
Climate envelope
Lost habitat
Climate change and habitat loss
Species’ distribution
Climate envelope
Lost habitat
R.J. Whittaker et al. (2005)
Whittaker et al. (2005)
20
Jared Diamond
Diamond (1975)
•Bigger better
•Single large better than several
small
•Close spacing better
•Grouping better
•Better linked with corridors = B
•Better compact than thin
What should the principles be?
1. First, increase the total area of high quality habitats
2. Go for high environmental heterogeneity
3. Control other threats from human activity
• Where it’s readily accommodated, also go for some big
reserves, and only then for….
• connectivity, mainly from improvements to the matrix
• Realise that fragmentation per se has little to do with it
After Harrison & Bruna (1999), Dawson (2006), Laurance (2008) & Hodgeson et al. (2009)
Are extinctions the sole concern?
• We expect many more extinctions as a result of our impact on the environment
• But mainly on islands and other little-modified ecosystems (e.g. the Amazon, Kakamega)
• GB has lost only some 12 species of higher plants in
the last 200 years, and all but one of these survives
on the continent (Kevin Walker in prep.)• The values of common species have been ignored
(Gaston & Fuller 2008)
• Is it because of this that we have enthusiastically embraced “ecosystem services”?
21
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment Biodiversity Synthesis
See also Diaz et al. (2006)
The evil quartet
• Us
Dave Dawson February 2011
•If we know what causes biodiversity
loss, we should also know the solutions
•Over-exploitation
•Invasive alien species
•Pollution and intensive management
•Loss and degradation of habitat
•Climate change
Dr Paul Ehrlich1978
22
Lord (Robert) May of Oxford, President
of the Royal Society 2000-2005
Government Chief Scientific adviser
1995-2000
May 2010
Ecological footprint and biocapacity
23
May recommends
• Educate women and afford women control over
their lives
• Decarbonize energy supplies
• Produce more food, whilst preserving habitats
and species
• Realise that ritual, authority and faith will trump
the evidence and so can prevent a sensible
response
May 2010
Intergovernmental Platform on Biodiversity and
Ecosystem Services (IPBES)
Announced December 2010. To be set up this
year
– Will mirror the IPCC
Simon Levin (2010)
The challenge is to
find ways to maintain
cooperation in the
common good even
without the
mechanism of
competition and
conflict with other
groups.
We need social norms
that meet this
challenge and find
leaders to take us
down that path.
Mark Van Vugt
24
Averting the Tragedy of the CommonsUsing Social Psychological Science to Protect the Environment
Mark Van Vugt
Four necessary components:
• Information
• Identity
• Institutions
• Incentives
Edward O. Wilson
Biophilia: “…the
connections that human
beings subconsciously
seek with the rest of life.” E.O
Wilson, Biophilia Harvard University Press 1984.
He proposed the possibility
that the deep affiliations
humans have with nature are
rooted in our biology.