suitability of mouse embryos for human ivf qc: zygotes vs. 2-cell embryos

1
can be used routinely for long-term storage of human spermatozoa. Rapid freezing of sperm in cryopreservation gives better survival rates compared to gradual freezing, although one may assume that gradual acclimatization to very low temperatures would maintain the functional integrity of the sperm to a greater extent. This as ascertained by morphology is the similar by both protocols thus refuting common belief. Supported by: This project was supported by a grant from the Cleveland Clinic Foundation. P-357 Suitability of mouse embryos for human IVF QC: zygotes vs. 2-cell embryos. M. Li, K. C. Drury, R. S. Williams. Univ of Florida, Gainesville, FL. Objective: Mouse embryos are widely used for quality control (QC) and media formulation in human IVF laboratories. The present study evaluated two different stages of mouse embryo culture to test the suitability of new media. Design: In-vivo fertilized mouse zygotes and 2 cell stage embryos de- rived from the same strain (B6C3F-1XB6D2F-1) were purchased frozen from Embryotech. Embryos were cultured in different media and endpoints compared using Chi square (p , 0.05). Materials/Methods: Frozen–thawed zygotes and 2 cell stage mouse em- bryos were cultured (avg. 5 20/droplet) in 100 ul droplets of media supplemented with 10% SSS (Irvine) under washed Squibb mineral oil. Two cell embryos were scored for # blastocyst on day 3 (D3) and # hatched on day 4 (D4) of culture. Zygotes were scored for # blastocyst on D4 and # hatched on day 5 (D5) of culture. When sequential media were employed, embryos were washed in 3 ml prior to next step culture. During period of testing, human IVF was performed using P-1 1 10% SSS for embryo culture with day 3 (8 cell) transfer. Results: The implantation rate of human embryos transferred on D3 during year 2000 using P-1 1 10% SSS was 22.4% (N 5 126). In accordance, mouse 2 cell embryo development in the same medium resulted in 91.8% blastocyst (B) on D3 and 51.1% hatched (H) on D4 (N 5 233) with good cell architecture. However, zygote culture in P-1 1 10% SSS gave only 29.1% B on D4 and just 1.2% H on D5 (N 5 86) (p 5,0.01) with the majority undergoing degeneration at the morula stage. These results are contrasted with the following more complex sequential media using mouse zygote stage: (1) P-1 for 48 hrs then Blastocyst medium (Irvine) 81.8% B, 18.2% H (N 5 22); (2) Quinn’s Sequential (Q-Fert, Q- Cleave, Q-Blast-Biopharma) 78.0% B, 2.6% H (N 5 38); (3) Quinn’s Sequential with Insulin, Transferrin, Selenium (ITS- Sigma) added to Q- Blast. 95.5% B, 4.5% H (N 5 22); (4) Quinn’s Q-Fert only. 98.4% B, 4.8% H (N 5 63) (p 0.05). Conclusions: It has long been appreciated that although mouse embryos constitute a biological test system for culture conditions, they are notori- ously permissive and resistant to levels of toxicity that can negatively impact human embryos. Cell cycle blocks, common in certain strains of mouse embryos, may also not reflect specific conditions found in humans, although they have played a role in the understanding of glucose and phosphates in early human embryo culture. It is with interest then that mouse zygotes did not respond well to P-1 1 10% SSS under the same conditions where 2 cell embryos progressed to the blastocyst and hatched stage at high rates (91.8% B, 51.1% H). At the same time, P-1 supports reasonable human embryo implantation rates (22.4%) when embryos are transferred at the 8 cell stage. In contrast to P-1, new media from Quinn (Q-Fert) supported blastocyst development from mouse zygotes at high levels (98.4%) but lacked corresponding hatch rates (4.8%). We are con- tinuing to test prospective complex sequential media with a mouse zygote system in order to examine their suitability for human IVF laboratory use. Mouse zygotes are able to distinguish between culture media, but are deficient in their ability to accurately reflect conditions relevant to use in the IVF laboratory. Supported by: Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shands Hos- pital at University of Florida. P-358 Coculture with buffalo rat liver (BRL) cells enhanced day-3 embryo development in poor prognosis patients. S. Shen, K. Ho, D. Jaffe, E. Pritts, M. Cedars, V. Y. Fujimoto. Dept of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Science, Univ of CA, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA. Objective: Methods to improve embryo quality are needed to enhance IVF outcome. Coculture systems have been suggested to minimize embryo fragmentation and improve blastomere development. A randomized con- trolled study showed BRL cell coculture significantly improved implanta- tion rates in patients undergoing conventional IVF (Hum. Reprod, Vol. 13, no.1, pp. 165–168, 1998). In our lab, we have been using a BRL cell coculture system for patients who had failed previous cycles with poor embryo quality. For this study we examined day-3 embryo quality and pregnancy rates from coculture compared to regular culture system. Design: A retrospective analysis of patients who had BRL cell coculture at UCSF In Vitro Fertilization program. Materials/Methods: IVF outcome and embryo quality were assessed in cycles from 1999 and 2000 where the patients who had at least one cycle without coculture and one cycle with coculture. A total of 34 patients included 38 cycles without coculture vs. 35 cycles with coculture. Day-3 embryo quality was compared between two culture systems. Embryo quality was based on cleavage on day-3 and morphological “grade” relating to fragmentation. Grade 1 and 2 are considered good or fair embryos; Grade 3 and 4 are poor quality. Clinical pregnancy was defined as the presence of a gestational sac on ultrasound examination. Fisher exact and unpaired t testing were used. Results: Clinical pregnancy rates were 5/38 (13%) in regular culture cycles and 14/35 (40%) in coculture cycles (p 5 0.015). However, ongoing pregnancy rates were not significantly different (8% in regular culture cycles vs. 20% in coculture cycles, p 5 0.179). The effect of BRL cell coculture on embryo development at 72 hour post retrieval. Culture system No. of embryos cultured No. of blastomeres/ embryo % of 6-cell Grade/embryo Regular Culture 437 5.29 6 2.11 44% 2.30 6 1.03 Coculture with BRL 342 6.46 6 2.05 69% 2.12 6 0.91 P value ,0.0001 ,0.0001 50.011 Conclusions: These data provide evidence that, with BRL cell coculture, day-3 embryo development is significantly improved. Although randomized studies are needed to assess the impact of BRL cell coculture on pregnancy outcome, these results support the theory of using BRL cell coculture to improve embryo development and subsequent pregnancy rates for patients with poor embryo quality during in vitro fertilization treatment. P-359 Intracytoplasmic sperm injection using non-motile testicular sperma- tozoa selected by modified hypo-osmotic swelling test. H. Sallam, A. Rahaman, A. Eid, A. Sallam, A. A. Agameya. Alexandria Univ, Alexan- dria, Egypt; Alexandria Fertility Ctr, Alexandria, Egypt. Objective: The aim of this work was to explore the fertilizing capacity of totally non-motile testicular spermatozoa selected by a modified hypo- osmotic swelling test (consisting of 50% culture medium and 50% milli-Q water), compared to motile testicular spermatozoa in patients with infertility due to non-obstructive azoospermia. Design: A comparison of fertilization, clinical pregnancy and on-going pregnancy rates in azoospermic patients with non-motile testicular sperma- tozoa selected by a modified hypo-osmotic swelling test versus azoospermic patients with motile testicular spermatozoa. Materials/Methods: Fifty five cycles in infertile couples due to non- obstructive azoospermia treated with intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), consisting of 16 cycles where ICSI was performed using non-motile spermatozoa and 39 cycles where ICSI was performed with motile testicular spermatozoa. In the 16 cycles with total absence of motility, the spermato- zoa used for injection were selected by a modified hypo-osmotic swelling test (a solution consisting of 50% culture medium and 50% milli-Q water), while in the 39 cycles with motile spermatozoa, these were randomly selected. Results: The fertilization rate was 32.4% in the non-motile sperm group S230 Abstracts Vol. 76, No. 3, Suppl. 1, September 2001

Upload: m-li

Post on 02-Dec-2016

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Suitability of mouse embryos for human IVF QC: zygotes vs. 2-cell embryos

can be used routinely for long-term storage of human spermatozoa. Rapidfreezing of sperm in cryopreservation gives better survival rates comparedto gradual freezing, although one may assume that gradual acclimatizationto very low temperatures would maintain the functional integrity of thesperm to a greater extent. This as ascertained by morphology is the similarby both protocols thus refuting common belief.

Supported by: This project was supported by a grant from the ClevelandClinic Foundation.

P-357

Suitability of mouse embryos for human IVF QC: zygotes vs. 2-cellembryos. M. Li, K. C. Drury, R. S. Williams. Univ of Florida, Gainesville,FL.

Objective: Mouse embryos are widely used for quality control (QC) andmedia formulation in human IVF laboratories. The present study evaluatedtwo different stages of mouse embryo culture to test the suitability of newmedia.

Design: In-vivo fertilized mouse zygotes and 2 cell stage embryos de-rived from the same strain (B6C3F-1XB6D2F-1) were purchased frozenfrom Embryotech. Embryos were cultured in different media and endpointscompared using Chi square (p, 0.05).

Materials/Methods: Frozen–thawed zygotes and 2 cell stage mouse em-bryos were cultured (avg.5 20/droplet) in 100 ul droplets of mediasupplemented with 10% SSS (Irvine) under washed Squibb mineral oil.Two cell embryos were scored for # blastocyst on day 3 (D3) and # hatchedon day 4 (D4) of culture. Zygotes were scored for # blastocyst on D4 and# hatched on day 5 (D5) of culture. When sequential media were employed,embryos were washed in 3 ml prior to next step culture. During period oftesting, human IVF was performed using P-11 10% SSS for embryoculture with day 3 (8 cell) transfer.

Results: The implantation rate of human embryos transferred on D3during year 2000 using P-11 10% SSS was 22.4% (N5 126). Inaccordance, mouse 2 cell embryo development in the same medium resultedin 91.8% blastocyst (B) on D3 and 51.1% hatched (H) on D4 (N5 233)with good cell architecture. However, zygote culture in P-11 10% SSSgave only 29.1% B on D4 and just 1.2% H on D5 (N5 86) (p 5 ,0.01)with the majority undergoing degeneration at the morula stage. Theseresults are contrasted with the following more complex sequential mediausing mouse zygote stage: (1) P-1 for 48 hrs then Blastocyst medium(Irvine) 81.8% B, 18.2% H (N5 22); (2) Quinn’s Sequential (Q-Fert, Q-Cleave, Q-Blast-Biopharma) 78.0% B, 2.6% H (N5 38); (3) Quinn’sSequential with Insulin, Transferrin, Selenium (ITS- Sigma) added to Q-Blast. 95.5% B, 4.5% H (N5 22); (4) Quinn’s Q-Fert only. 98.4% B, 4.8%H (N 5 63) (p 0.05).

Conclusions: It has long been appreciated that although mouse embryosconstitute a biological test system for culture conditions, they are notori-ously permissive and resistant to levels of toxicity that can negativelyimpact human embryos. Cell cycle blocks, common in certain strains ofmouse embryos, may also not reflect specific conditions found in humans,although they have played a role in the understanding of glucose andphosphates in early human embryo culture. It is with interest then thatmouse zygotes did not respond well to P-11 10% SSS under the sameconditions where 2 cell embryos progressed to the blastocyst and hatchedstage at high rates (91.8% B, 51.1% H). At the same time, P-1 supportsreasonable human embryo implantation rates (22.4%) when embryos aretransferred at the 8 cell stage. In contrast to P-1, new media from Quinn(Q-Fert) supported blastocyst development from mouse zygotes at highlevels (98.4%) but lacked corresponding hatch rates (4.8%). We are con-tinuing to test prospective complex sequential media with a mouse zygotesystem in order to examine their suitability for human IVF laboratory use.Mouse zygotes are able to distinguish between culture media, but aredeficient in their ability to accurately reflect conditions relevant to use in theIVF laboratory.

Supported by: Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Shands Hos-pital at University of Florida.

P-358

Coculture with buffalo rat liver (BRL) cells enhanced day-3 embryodevelopment in poor prognosis patients.S. Shen, K. Ho, D. Jaffe, E.

Pritts, M. Cedars, V. Y. Fujimoto. Dept of Obstetrics, Gynecology andReproductive Science, Univ of CA, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA.

Objective: Methods to improve embryo quality are needed to enhanceIVF outcome. Coculture systems have been suggested to minimize embryofragmentation and improve blastomere development. A randomized con-trolled study showed BRL cell coculture significantly improved implanta-tion rates in patients undergoing conventional IVF (Hum. Reprod, Vol. 13,no.1, pp. 165–168, 1998). In our lab, we have been using a BRL cellcoculture system for patients who had failed previous cycles with poorembryo quality. For this study we examined day-3 embryo quality andpregnancy rates from coculture compared to regular culture system.

Design: A retrospective analysis of patients who had BRL cell cocultureat UCSF In Vitro Fertilization program.

Materials/Methods: IVF outcome and embryo quality were assessed incycles from 1999 and 2000 where the patients who had at least one cyclewithout coculture and one cycle with coculture. A total of 34 patientsincluded 38 cycles without coculture vs. 35 cycles with coculture. Day-3embryo quality was compared between two culture systems. Embryo qualitywas based on cleavage on day-3 and morphological “grade” relating tofragmentation. Grade 1 and 2 are considered good or fair embryos; Grade 3and 4 are poor quality. Clinical pregnancy was defined as the presence of agestational sac on ultrasound examination. Fisher exact and unpaired ttesting were used.

Results: Clinical pregnancy rates were 5/38 (13%) in regular culturecycles and 14/35 (40%) in coculture cycles (p5 0.015). However, ongoingpregnancy rates were not significantly different (8% in regular culturecycles vs. 20% in coculture cycles, p5 0.179).

The effect of BRL cell coculture on embryo development at 72 hour postretrieval.

Culture system

No. ofembryoscultured

No. ofblastomeres/

embryo% of6-cell Grade/embryo

Regular Culture 437 5.296 2.11 44% 2.306 1.03Coculture with BRL 342 6.466 2.05 69% 2.126 0.91P value ,0.0001 ,0.0001 50.011

Conclusions: These data provide evidence that, with BRL cell coculture,day-3 embryo development is significantly improved. Although randomizedstudies are needed to assess the impact of BRL cell coculture on pregnancyoutcome, these results support the theory of using BRL cell coculture toimprove embryo development and subsequent pregnancy rates for patientswith poor embryo quality during in vitro fertilization treatment.

P-359

Intracytoplasmic sperm injection using non-motile testicular sperma-tozoa selected by modified hypo-osmotic swelling test.H. Sallam, A.Rahaman, A. Eid, A. Sallam, A. A. Agameya. Alexandria Univ, Alexan-dria, Egypt; Alexandria Fertility Ctr, Alexandria, Egypt.

Objective: The aim of this work was to explore the fertilizing capacity oftotally non-motile testicular spermatozoa selected by a modified hypo-osmotic swelling test (consisting of 50% culture medium and 50% milli-Qwater), compared to motile testicular spermatozoa in patients with infertilitydue to non-obstructive azoospermia.

Design: A comparison of fertilization, clinical pregnancy and on-goingpregnancy rates in azoospermic patients with non-motile testicular sperma-tozoa selected by a modified hypo-osmotic swelling test versus azoospermicpatients with motile testicular spermatozoa.

Materials/Methods: Fifty five cycles in infertile couples due to non-obstructive azoospermia treated with intracytoplasmic sperm injection(ICSI), consisting of 16 cycles where ICSI was performed using non-motilespermatozoa and 39 cycles where ICSI was performed with motile testicularspermatozoa. In the 16 cycles with total absence of motility, the spermato-zoa used for injection were selected by a modified hypo-osmotic swellingtest (a solution consisting of 50% culture medium and 50% milli-Q water),while in the 39 cycles with motile spermatozoa, these were randomlyselected.

Results: The fertilization rate was 32.4% in the non-motile sperm group

S230 Abstracts Vol. 76, No. 3, Suppl. 1, September 2001