spinning wheel apartments - la city planning · 1/19/2017 · the 1936 spinning wheel apartments...

SPINNING WHEEL APARTMENTS 423-427 North Hayworth Avenue

CHC-2017-4770-HCM ENV-2017-4771-CE

Agenda packet includes:

1. Under Consideration Staff Recommendation Report

2. Nomination

3. Letters of Support Please click on each document to be directly taken to the corresponding page of the PDF.

Los Angeles Department of City Planning RECOMMENDATION REPORT

PROJECT: Historic-Cultural Monument Application for the

SPINNING WHEEL APARTMENTS REQUEST: Declare the property a Historic-Cultural Monument OWNER(S): Hayworth Abbey LLC c/o Isaac Cohanzad 11601 Santa Monica Blvd. Los Angeles, CA 90025 APPLICANT: Dee Ann Newkirk 427 ½ N. Hayworth Avenue Los Angeles, CA 90048 PREPARER: Charles J. Fisher 140 S. Avenue 57 Highland Park, CA 90042

RECOMMENDATION That the Cultural Heritage Commission:

1. Take the property under consideration as a Historic-Cultural Monument per Los Angeles Administrative Code Chapter 9, Division 22, Article 1, Section 22.171.10 because the application and accompanying photo documentation suggest the submittal warrants further investigation.

2. Adopt the report findings.

VINCENT P. BERTONI, AICP Director of PlanningN1907 [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] Ken Bernstein, AICP, Manager Lambert M. Giessinger, Preservation Architect Office of Historic Resources Office of Historic Resources [SIGNED ORIGINAL IN FILE] Melissa Jones, Planning Assistant Office of Historic Resources Attachment: Historic-Cultural Monument Application

CULTURAL HERITAGE COMMISSION HEARING DATE: January 19, 2017 TIME: 10:00 AM PLACE: City Hall, Room 1010 200 N. Spring Street Los Angeles, CA 90012

CASE NO.: CHC-2017-4770-HCM ENV-2017-4771-CE Location: 423-427 North Hayworth Avenue Council District: 5 Community Plan Area: Wilshire Area Planning Commission: Central Neighborhood Council: Mid City West Legal Description: Tract TR 6790, Lot 273

CHC-2017-4770-HCM 423-427 N. Hayworth Avenue Page 2 of 2 SUMMARY The 1936 Spinning Wheel Apartments is a multi-family residential building located at 423-427 North Hayworth Avenue in the Fairfax District of Los Angeles, one block west of Fairfax Avenue. The subject property was designed in the French Norman Revival style by architect David C. Coleman for the Spinning Wheel Corporation. Originally, the Spinning Wheel Apartments was constructed as one of two mirror-image structures that, together, framed a garden court; the second structure was demolished in 2015. The Spinning Wheel Apartments consists of an asymmetrical, two-story structure with four units in a U-shaped plan and a cross gabled four car garage located at the rear of the property. The exterior of the primary structure features two corbelled towers on the front façade with a small, gabled decorative pediment; a tall, slightly sloped hipped roof; vertical arched vents along each façade; wood casement windows; regency style bay windows; leaded glass fixed pane windows with colored inserts; decorative arch reliefs; and quoins. The interiors of the individual units showcase hardwood floors; detailed crown moldings; gambrel doorways; plastered mantels; original lighting fixtures; and original tiled kitchens and bathrooms. Based on permit records there appear to have been only minor alterations to the subject property that include the addition of security bars to the windows of the first floor units in 1991. CRITERIA The criterion is the Cultural Heritage Ordinance which defines a historical or cultural monument as any site (including significant trees or other plant life located thereon) building or structure of particular historic or cultural significance to the City of Los Angeles, such as historic structures or sites in which the broad cultural, economic, or social history of the nation, State or community is reflected or exemplified, or which are identified with historic personages or with important events in the main currents of national, State or local history or which embody the distinguishing characteristics of an architectural type specimen, inherently valuable for a study of a period style or method of construction, or a notable work of a master builder, designer or architect whose individual genius influenced his age. FINDINGS Based on the facts set forth in the summary and application, the Commission determines that the application is complete and that the property may be significant enough to warrant further investigation as a potential Historic-Cultural Monument.

!" #$%#&$'()*+&,'*-*./'*%,

!"#$#%&'()#*+,&*-(./,&0

1-"&&-(2''"&%%0 34$0 5#+*647(84%-"46-0

9/*:&(#;(2''"&%%&%(#*(!"#$&"-<0 5#,,+*4-<(./,&0

2%%&%%#"(!/"6&7(.+,=&"0 >"/6-0 ?7!"@0 A#-0

!"#$#%&'()#*+,&*-(

!"#$&"-.(/.$&01+23'2*4 5-"+6-+"& 789&6-

52-&:

7$&*(5$;6&

<;-+";3

=&;-+"&!

0. .%,1'$2.'*%,)3*1'%$()4).%,+*'*%,

>&;"(1+23-0 !=;6!";3! ?%-2,;-&' /!"#$%#&#'("!

@#$%&'($')A(*&+,(#"! B-,'#.$'-#"!

7#&+&,./!C*("! !#(*(,'!C*("!

D%(-E&(!"#$#%&'()#*+,&*-(#*(2-%(7"242*;3(52-&F0 >(*! !<-! !C!0,-G,!

5. 3*1'%$*.6.27'2$/7)8%,28&,').$*'&$*/

!"#$!%&'&(#)$"&*+,#*-$#.#,'/#01#($-"#$0&//$%1*2$3+/-+%4/$5#%1-42#$6%)1*4*7#$3%1-#%14$89#7-1&*$:!"#$#"$%&

&(1/($'*!'%(!2#-.3!$4/'4#./5!($-,-"&$5!-#!*-$&./!%&*'-#6!-1!'%(!,.'&-,5!*'.'(!-#!$-""4,&'6!

!"#$%&'($)$&%#%$(*#*$"(+,$-#.&,"+'/0&1"2!"#!%$%&!$"'"#%()%!*+*)%,!$)!%&*!"($)!-.##*)%,!"/!)(%$")(01!,%(%*1!"#!0"-(0!&$,%"#2!

'"2-3&(*!'%(!3&*'&,+4&*%&,+!$%.#.$'(#&*'&$*!-1!.,!.#$%&'($'4#./7'68(!*8($&"(,!"#$%&'&$()*"+,)-,.)&"/0'"1(-2*"0/"

,"3&'#02!"1(*)&"0'""&(%02"0/"40$1('-4(#0$

!"#$%&'%(&)%*+,-(-)

&../01%2.%3/4526/0%7142860149!8:586;:%316/5;<1%!2==/44/2>

BC1>D9C5E5FA>F92A()D.F)G.>+&?"+*#"&+%'&7?

()$0(,.)&"%0'5"0/","",1(&'".-#)2&'!"2&1#6$&'!"0'",'4%#(&4("%%01&"#$2#+#2-,)"6&$#-1"#$/)-&$4&2"%#1"0'"%&'",6&

!"(H<!!"#

$%&'&()

!. "#$%&'(')*#&+,*%"

!!"#$%!&'$()*!+,-'./)-/0,$#!&/1#)* !!!!!!&/2,.)3*/2,.)3*!!!!!!!

41():

5#$66.%7!8$/),.$#*!

9::; 8$/),.$#*!

<=>?:<&

41():

8$/),.$#*!

@>49A!

&/1#):

8$/),.$#*

41():

!"#$%&'!%("#

41():

5#$66.%7!8$/),.$#*!

8$/),.$#*!

41():

8$/),.$#*!

&/1#):

8$/),.$#*

41():

!"#$%"& '()*+,%"&!!""##!

1 UPDATED MARCH 20141 UPDATED MARCH 2014

Spinning Wheel Apartments Former name of property

423-27 N. Hayworth Avenue 90048 5

423-27 N. Hayworth Avenue Fairfax District

5527-032-022 Tract No. 6790 N/A 273

1936 Private Development

David C. Coleman Owner Build

Apartment Building Apartment Building

French Normandy with Chateauesque influence 2 U-shaped

Frame

Stucco

Gable

Composition Shingle

Fixed Select

Stained glass and lead Select

Off-center Off-center

Wood Glass

✔

✔

!. "#$%&"$'()*+,--"&.

!"#$%!"#$%&'(%)*"$+%&%%&'$()!$*+&',#'-.%,-%),*.%(,'+%-,*%/&0,*%&1$+*&$",'#!%23"#%#+4$",'%/&5%&1#,%6+%4,/71+$+(%,'%&%

#+7&*&$+%(,48/+'$9%%:+%#8*+%$,%"'418(+%4,7"+#%,-%68"1("';%7+*/"$#%"'%$3+%',/"'&$",'%7&4.+$%<#++%!"#$%&'()*(=>:?@22A!B9"

C9%

D9%

E9%

F9%

G9%

H9%

I9%

J9%

/0 %1'+$')2*3'+$(&'4*&%+(,&4%*'5%)$'6'4"$'()*<@-%!',)'B

!"#$+(%"'%$3+%K&$",'&1%L+;"#$+*%,-%M"#$,*"4%N1&4+#%

!"#$+(%"'%$3+%O&1"-,*'"&%L+;"#$+*%,-%M"#$,*"4&1%L+#,8*4+#%

P,*/&115%(+$+*/"'+(%+1";"61+%-,*%$3+%K&$",'&1%&'("#$%O&1"-,*'"&%L+;"#$+*#%

!,4&$+(%"'%&%M"#$,*"4%N*+#+*Q&$",'%RQ+*1&5%S,'+%<MNRSB%!"#$%&'($&#)*+,-$(%,*

."#/0"#$%&'($&#)*+,-$(%,"

T+$+*/"'+(%+1";"61+%-,*%'&$",'&1U%#$&$+U%,*%1,4&1%1&'(/&*.%

#$&$8#%65%&%3"#$,*"4%*+#,8*4+#%#8*Q+5<#B%Survey Name(s):

R$3+*%3"#$,*"4%&'#$'481$8*&1%*+#,8*4+%(+#";'&$",'<#BV%

70 8&'$$%)*+$"$%-%)$+

#$%&"&'()%*+",--*.&"/*0")*"!"#$%##&'(&)*+,(-")$'"&%1+%2%(,+('"*2")$'"34*3*&'5"6*+06'+)",+5".$/"%)"&$*0-5"7'"+*6%+,)'5"

,&","8%&)*4%(9:0-)04,-";*+06'+)!""#/3'"/*04"4'&3*+&'&"*+","&'3,4,)'"5*(06'+)",+5",)),($"&$'')&")*")$'"7,(<"*2")$%&"

2*46!"

"0% 9:;<;=>?*-;@AB>@C*5>=D:E<CE;@*F*T+#4*"6+%$3+%7*,7,#+(%/,'8/+'$W#%735#"4&1%43&*&4$+*"#$"4#%&'(

*+1&$",'#3"7%$,%"$#%#8**,8'("';%+'Q"*,'/+'$9%%@(+'$"-5%&'(%(+#4*"6+%&'5%43&*&4$+*X(+-"'"';%+1+/+'$#U%

#$*84$8*+#U%"'$+*",*%#7&4+#U%,*%1&'(#4&7+%-+&$8*+#9

G0% +CHC>B>@C*;I*+EJ@EIEDH@D>*F*A((*+##%$3+%7*,7,#+(%/,'8/+'$W#%3"#$,*"4U%481$8*&1U%&'(Y,*%&*43"$+4$8*&1

#";'"-"4&'4+%65%("#48##"';%3,)%"$%#&$"#-"+#%$3+%MO?%4*"$+*"&%#+1+4$+(%"'%=+4$",'%F'(#)'*+,'-$,./#01'-%2,39%%

Z,8%/8#$%#877,*$%5,8*%&*;8/+'$%)"$3%#86#$&'$"&&'+Q"(+'4+!"#$!"#"%&'('9

!"#$%&'%(&)%*+,-(-)

&../01%2.%3/4526/0%7142860149!8:586;:%316/5;<1%!2==/44/2>

M@=2RL@OXO>!2>LA!%?RK>?[K2+&?"+*#"&+%'&7?

2 UPDATED MARCH 20142 UPDATED MARCH 2014

1991 Security bars added to windows.

2015 Second building that was built a twin to subject building demolished.

!" !"#"$%"

!" #$%&'()*+,*" -.#-"#))"+'$/0*&-1" 1/203--*+"(3))"2*$'0*"4/2)3$" 5*$'5+1"/&+*5" -.*"6#)37'5&3#"8/2)3$"9*$'5+1":$-;"

#&+"/&+*51-#&+"-.#-"-.*"+'$/0*&-1"!"##$2*"0#+*"#<#3)#2)*"/4'&"5*=/*1-"-'"0*02*51"'7"-.*"4/2)3$"7'5"3&14*$-3'&"

#&+"$'4>3&,?

!" !"#$%!$&'#(")*%$'"#

!"#$%! &'#(")*%+

!"#$$"%&''#$(()% *+",)% !"-"$:

.+/: 0123$%4567$#)% 86-+9)%

./01*/(2&34+*/&

4-6$: *26/-3,)%

!"#$$"%&''#$(()% *+",)% !"-"$)%

.+/)% 0123$%4567$#)%

506"+'("0+&./*1'/*/7811)"$'+(9#&:*1/*#*+('(";*&

4-6$)! *26/-3,)%

!"#$$"%&''#$(()% *+",)% !"-"$)%

.+/)% 0123$%4567$#)%

86-+9)%

86-+9)%

!"#$%&'%(&)%*+,-(-)

&../01%2.%3/4526/0%7142860149!8:586;:%316/5;<1%!2==/44/2>

,-./01-&2&34/3154+60!367!/+&?"+*#"&+%'&7?

3 UPDATED MARCH 2014

!"#$%&#'()&*#+)#",--'*$#'.#$%&#)'/+)0$+')1 !"#$% !"#"$%"

811)"$'+(

!"#$%&'()*+,*"-.#-"#))"4.'-',5#4.1"#&+"30#,*1"1/203--*+"#1"4#5-"'7"-.31"#44)3$#-3'&"(3))"2*$'0*"-.*"45'4*5->"'7"

-.*"63->"'7"@'1":&,*)*1;"#&+"/&+*51-#&+"-.#-"4*503113'&"31",5#&-*+"7'5"/1*"'7"-.*"4.'-',5#4.1"#&+"30#,*1"2>"-.*"

63->"(3-.'/-"#&>"*A4*$-#-3'&"'7"$'04*&1#-3'&?

!"#$%&'()*+,*"-.#-"!".#<*"-.*"53,.-"-'"1/203-"'5".#<*"!"#$%&'("-.*"#445'453#-*"4*503113'&"-'"1/203-"#))"

3&7'50#-3'&"$'&-#3&*+"3&"-.31"#44)3$#-3'&?

B3,&#-/5*CD#0*C E#-*C


!"#$%#&'#$(&#$)*&%+$+#,#-+&$-(&)*#).&+*#&)/''#%0/-(1-2&3/4#%&+/&1-(1)$+#&+*$+&5/6&$2'##&71+*&+*#&%+$+#,#-+8&

9*#-:&#"#)+'/-1)$""5&/'&0*5%1)$""5&%12-&+*#&3/++/,&0/'+1/-8&;1+*#'&+*#&$00"1)$-+&!"#+*#&0'#0$'#'&,$5&%12-8"

Dee Ann Newkirk

427! N. Hayworth Avenue Los Angeles CA

90048 323-326-6240 [email protected]

Hayworth Abbey, LLC Attn: Issac Cohanzad Wiseman Residential

11601 S. Santa Monica Boulevard Los Angeles CA

90025-2907 310-473-3000 & 310-914-5555 [email protected]

Charles J. Fisher

140 S. Avenue 57 Highland Park CA

90042 323-256-3593 [email protected]

✔

✔

✔

Charles J.

Fisher

Digitally signed by Charles J. Fisher

DN: cn=Charles J. Fisher, o, ou,

[email protected], c=US

Date: 2016.06.30 00:08:05 -07'00'Charles J. Fisher 6-29-2016

&'" #$%&'(()*

:1$3%,25%1-;$%<26/9$"$'%/#$/-#+3=%,25#%326+3-"+23>%<26/+9$%-99%6-"$#+-9(%+3%"1$%2#'$#%(/$<+?+$'%7$92@A%%&9"125=1%"1$%$3"+#$

/-<B$"%65("%32"%$C<$$'%DEE%/-=$(>%,25%6-,%($3'%-''+"+23-9%6-"$#+-9%23%-%*F%2#%?9-(1%'#+;$A

"#$%!!"#$!%&'"()&*+,-."-)/.!0(1-2$1"!3-42&""/.!&'!&()!*++$,)!'+!

-$.&'/$,!0).'1/,).!'/!)2#$%!345!&'!%#26)/&78$)..$98)/:%#,$&;7'/8!

G??+<$%2?%H+("2#+<%I$(25#<$!%

F$/-#"6$3"%2?%*+",%09-33+3=%

JEE%4A%!/#+3=%!"#$$">%I226%KJE%

L2(%&3=$9$(>%*&%MEEDJ%

0123$)%JDNAMOPADJEE%

:$7(+"$)%/#$($#;-"+23A9-<+",A2#=%

&00LQ*&RQG4%*H8*SLQ!R%

DA 426+3-"+23%T2#6

JA :#+""$3%!"-"$6$3"(%&%-3'%U

NA U+79+2=#-/1,

VA R@2%0#+6-#,%012"2(%2?%8C"$#+2#WX-+3%T-Y-'$

ZA *2/+$(%2?%0#+6-#,W!$<23'-#,%F2<56$3"(

PA

MA

*2/+$(%2?%U5+9'+3=%0$#6+"(%?2#%X-[2#%&9"$#-"+23(%

\+3<95'$%?+#("%<23("#5<"+23%/$#6+"]%

*23"$6/2#-#,%012"2(

H+("2#+<-9%012"2(

.QX&!%0-#<$9%I$/2#"

KA%

OA

!"#$%&'%(&)%*+,-(-)

&../01%2.%3/4526/0%7142860149!8:586;:%316/5;<1%!2==/44/2>

,-./01-&2&34/3154+60!367!/+&?"+*#"&+%'&7?


✔ ✔

✔

✔

✔

✔ ✔

Spinning Wheel Apartments

Architectural Description

This 2-story 4-unit apartment building is designed asymmetrically in the French-

Normandy style with Chateauesque influence with two corbelled towers on the

front facade, the first at the Southeast corner and the other at a bump-out to the

right center of the facade. The roof is a tall slightly sloped parapet with a small

gabled decorative pediment between the two towers and vertical arched vents

spread along each facade. The shallow U-Shaped building is more symmetrical on

the South facade, where it originally faced a twin that was demolished in 2015.

The two second-story units are serviced by two-flight staircases along the inside of

each U with delicate steel railings.

Architectural details include wood casement windows, a first-story regency style

bay on the left plane of the front facade, with the right plane being slightly

forward. Quoins decorate the three front corners. Leaded glass fixed pane

windows with colored inserts are at the second floor level above the bay. Two

bays are on the South facade. Reliefs of vertical rectangles are found on the sides

of that bay, below the windows, with a circle in the center plane. The bays flank

an enclosed decorative arch relief, which is between two square pilasters with

Egyptian Papyrus-covered capitals under a freeze with simple "Sun disks" above

the capitals. The freeze is topped with a small oval shield surrounded by flowers.

A small balcony is near the center of the North facade, as are two enclosed sets of

secondary stairs serving to the two upper units.

The one alteration is the addition of burglar bars to the windows on the first floor

units.

A cross gabled four car garage is set at the rear of the property.

Interior features include hardwood floors, detailed crown moldings, gambrel

doorways, plastered mantles with a central shield, original lighting fixtures and

original tiled kitchens and bathrooms.

Spinning Wheel Apartments

423-7 N. Hayworth Avenue

Significance Statement

Built in 1936 by the Spinning Wheel Corporation, this four-unit apartment building was one of

several built by this owner in different parts of Los Angeles. The buildings each followed their

own design scheme, this project using the French Normandy style with a Chateauesque

influence. The building is indicative of the type of quality development being done in the

Fairfax area in the immediate years prior to the second World War, when it was rapidly

becoming the new Jewish section in Los Angeles, quickly eclipsing and eventually replacing the

historic Boyle Heights as the home of the Los Angeles Jewish community.

It was the Northern building with a mirror image twin immediately to the South. Together the

two buildings framed a garden area. An announcement in the Los Angeles Times on September

16, 1936 stated: “Plans have been completed for two apartment structures at 419-21½ and 425-

27½ North Hayworth avenue for the Spinning Wheel Corporation. David C. Coleman is the

architect. Each building will be two stories in height and will contain sixteen rooms divided into

four apartments. The cost will be $20,000.”

The apartment building is located one block to the West of Fairfax Avenue, directly to the West

of Canter’s Deli. The subdivision, Tract No. 6790, was laid out in 1923 by the A. F. Gilmore

Company, the creators of the Farmers Market (HCM #543), in partnership with the Security

Trust and Savings Bank. The land was a part of the Gilmore holdings in the Salt Lake Oil Field,

on land that Gilmore had previously operated as a dairy farm. By the 1920s the real estate values

had reached such a point that the land was worth more for housing than oil.

G. Allen Hancock had already subdivided his mother’s holdings into Hancock Park and the

pressure for development to go West was heavy. By the mid-1920s the Fairfax district was hot.

However, most of the construction was to the East of Fairfax Boulevard, leaving Tract No. 6790

almost devoid of housing by the end of the decade. Then came the Great Depression, which

slowed down the development of single-family homes in the area. The lots on Hayworth Avenue

were to remain relatively vacant until the mid-1930s. The Spinning Wheel project was one of

the first to come in during that period. The street eventually became almost entirely multi-family

housing as the Jewish influx to the area grew. The context statement for survey LA reviews this

history and the section dealing with the Beverly-Fairfax area is attached as an addendum to this

document.

The statement specifically calls out the Beverly Square (Tract No. 7944) neighborhood located

just South of Beverly Boulevard from Tract No. 6790. Both tracts were subdivided by the

Gilmore Company in the mid 1920s and experienced the same development patterns. The

survey did not review the subject building, but the Hollywood survey picked up a similar one at

825 N Edinburgh Avenue, giving it a 3S,3CS,5S3 rating, referring to it as an "excellent example

of French Norman Revival multi-family residential architecture in Hollywood." An email from

Kari Fowler of Historic Resources Group, which did the Hollywood survey, notes the similarities

and high rate of historic integrity between the two buildings. She also states that "an HCM

nomination is worth pursuing, particularly due to the intact interior features that could contribute

to a local designation."

Many of the new residents came from Europe, especially people who chose to leave those areas

that were rapidly coming under the heel of Hitler’s National Socialism. By 1936, there was a

need for housing and new projects, such as the Spinning Wheel Apartments began to meet that

need. The Lots, 273 and 274 had first been sold to Raymond J. Eliot in the mid-1920s. Not

much has been found on Eliot, but he then deeded the property to James Joseph Anton, who was

a long term resident of the Los Angeles area. Born in 1890, he had married his wife, Lillian

Stein, at the old sandstone courthouse in Santa Ana, on March 29, 1909. It appears that they

were thwarted from building on the lots by the stock market crash in October 1929.

The Antons sold the lots to Raymond D. Currier, but the new owner passed away suddenly on

December 1, 1931, leaving it to his wife, Augusta. She retained the properties through the

depths of the Great Depression, eventually selling them to the Spinning Wheel Corporation on

September 16, 1936. The building permits for the construction of the two buildings were taken

out the same day. The design by Architect David C. Coleman, did four large units in each

building. The buildings had spacious well-appointed units the size of many houses with the two

bedroom units at 1,700 square feet and one bedrooms at 1,500 square feet. The French

Normandy design was also unique, with the Chateauesque turrets on the front of each building.

The buildings were quickly filled and then sold to owners who lived in each of the buildings,

renting out the remaining units. The building at 423-27½ was sold to Harry and Esther Jenkins

on December 6, 1939. Jenkins and wife ran a drug store in Boyle Heights, while living nearby at

2020 Pennsylvania Avenue. They were part of an influx of Yiddish-speaking Russian Jewish

immigrants that had come to that community at the turn of the 20th

Century. By the late 1930s,

they saw the exodus to Fairfax and bought the apartment as an investment and a place to live

when they retired. By the late 1940’s they had relocated to the apartment, living in it until

Harry’s death in July 1963. The 1956 reverse phone directory shows the owner living at 427 N.

Hayworth. The other units were occupied by Jewish immigrants, as well:

Ike Bennie Fingerett was born in Romanou, Russia on February 24, 1891, arriving in the United

States on July 14, 1910 in Philadelphia and settling in Pittsburgh, where he worked as a baker.

He and his wife, Ethel (also from Russia) were living on Matthews Street in Boyle Heights by

1935 and moved to the Spinning Wheel Apartments sometime after 1940. In 1956 they were

living at 423 N. Hayworth Avenue.

Edna Eisner was living at 425 (now 423½) N. Hayworth Avenue. Records show that she and her

husband, Samuel, a tailor, were living at 435½ N. Orange Grove in 1942. Records note that

Samuel was born in "other country" on his death notification in 1950. Edna probably relocated

to the Spinning Wheel Apartment sometime after Samuel's death. The records are very sketchy

on the Eisner's background, but it appears that they arrived in the Fairfax District sometime

around 1940. It is very possible that they came here after the annexation of Austria the German

Reich in 1938.

The background of Pauline Weiner, who lived at 427½ N. Hayworth, is not readily deciphered,

as her name is fairly common and she has not left enough of a historic footprint to be

distinguished from other women with the same name from the Los Angeles area.

The building was deeded to Irving and Margit Ecker on January 3, 1964. The Eckers had been

refugees who fled from Budapest, Hungary after the collapse of the 1956 revolution against the

Communist regime there. After first arriving in New York on January 16, 1957, the family came

to Los Angeles to live near their married daughter, Eva. Irving, whose birth name was Ignacz

Ecker, was born in Sataralyachyhely, Hungary on November 27, 1910 and took up his

occupation as a tailor once settled in the United States. His wife, the former Margit Neumann,

was born in Bihar, Hungary on September 29, 1905. The couple were naturalized on January 25,

1963.

After Irving’s death on September 20, 1996, Margit continued to live in her apartment until her

passing on March 10, 2007 (at 101 years of age). The building then went to Eva and her

husband, Abraham Leopold Langer. Abraham was also a refugee, arriving in New York from

his native Czechoslovakia on August 3, 1948. During World War II. he and his family were

imprisoned at the Auschwitz death camp in Poland. Abraham was the only survivor, being

liberated by the Russians in 1945. The couple were married in Brooklyn, NY on March 9, 1958.

They came to Los Angeles around 1960. The Langer’s retained the building until they felt

pressured to sell as the street was rapidly changing with large new buildings crowding out many

of the historic ones, including the other Spinning Wheel building immediately to the South.

The Spinning Wheel Apartments are an important architectural type specimen of the French

Normandy design, as well as one of the earliest apartments to be built as the area became the

new Los Angeles Jewish community. From 1938 until 2015, the building was always owned by

Jewish immigrants who had come to the United States in search of a better life.

Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.

Ten New Apartment Projects to Be Built in Los AngelesLos Angeles Times (1923-Current File); Sep 13, 1936; ProQuest Historical Newspapers: Los Angeles Timespg. E1

� � � � � � � ��

� � � � � � ! " # $ � % # &' ( $ ) * + � , # ) - . - / 0 # � / ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 4 5 6 - + . % * + � � # ) 3 * + # * $ ( ) . 7 8 # � * . % * + � " # $ � % # & # ) 3� � � � � � 9 � . � � ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( : 5 . ( * - . 5 5 . ) � � � % � � � � 3 * . # ( � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & ; 7 # ( . � $ 1 $ ) # � � 8 # � * . % * + � 5 # ( ( $ � � < # ) - + . = # � � � # > ? . ( * . % * + � @ # � * = # / � A $ � " $ � � 3 6 ) 3 � � � $ � ( * + � ( �) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( $ ) * + � ) . � * + 7 � ( * � � ) 8 . � * $ . ) . % * + � B $ � ( + $ � � C 0 ' 4 # ) 3 % . � 5 # ) � # � ( * + $ ( # � � #7 # ( - . � � � � 3 7 $ * + . $ � 3 � � � $ - / ( > D + � = # � � � # D # � 0 $ * ( # � � # ) 3 7 � � � * + � 5 . ( * � $ ( $ 2 � � ( 6 � % # - �5 # ) $ % � ( * # * $ . ) . % * + � � # ( * 2 � � . 7 ! 1 � . 6 ) 3 � � ( . 6 � - � > D + � , # ) - . - / % # 5 $ � � 5 2 # � / � 3 . ) * + � % $ � ( * . $ �� & 8 � . � # * $ . ) $ ) * + $ ( # � � # 4 # ) 3 $ ) � E F F � # ) - + � � ' > " > 9 $ � 5 . � � 2 � 1 # ) 3 . $ ) 1 * + � ( # 5 � . ) * + � 8 $ � - � . %* + � � # ) - + . + � + # 3 # - G 6 $ � � 3 >9 $ � 5 . � � . 7 ) � 3 # � � � # * $ � � � ( 5 # � � 8 � � - � ) * # 1 � . % * + � � # ) - + . � # ) 3 4 2 6 * + � 3 � � � � . 8 � 3 $ ** + . � . 6 1 + � H � $ / � 9 > ' � � # ) , # ) - . - / $ ) , # ) - . - / 0 # � / 4 2 * + � � E � F ( 9 $ � 5 . � � ( # 7 * + � � # � 6 � . %( 6 2 3 $ � $ 3 $ ) 1 # ) 3 ( � � � $ ) 1 . % % * + � � � ( ( 8 � . 3 6 - * $ � � 8 . � * $ . ) ( . % + $ ( � # ) 3 > I * ( . . ) 2 � - # 5 � - � � # � * .9 $ � 5 . � � # ) 3 + $ ( ( . ) J > � > 9 $ � 5 . � � * + # * + . 6 ( $ ) 1 # ) 3 - . 5 5 � � - $ # � 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * 2 � . 6 1 + * $ ) 5 . � �5 . ) � * + # ) . $ � 8 � . 3 6 - * $ . ) > � � * 7 � � ) * + � , # ) - . - / ( # ) 3 * + � ' > " > 9 $ � 5 . � � C . 5 8 # ) 4 2 * + � � # � � � E K F ( 5 . ( * . % * + � � # ) 3 $ ) * + � " # $ � % # & ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 4 ) . � * + . % B $ � ( + $ � � � . 6 � � � # � 3 4 + # 3 2 � � )( 6 2 3 $ � $ 3 � 3 # ) 3 3 � � � � . 8 � 3 >I ) � E K L 4 * + � " # � 5 � � ( 0 6 2 � $ - ? # � / � * 4 . 8 � � # * � 3 2 " � � 3 � � - / # ) 3 < . 1 � � M # + � + N � � 5 # * B � ( * D + $ � 3@ * � � � * # ) 3 " # $ � % # & ' � � ) 6 � : . ) � # ) 3 . 7 ) � 3 2 J > � > 9 $ � 5 . � � ; . 8 � ) � 3 4 $ ) � $ * $ ) 1 � . - # � % # � 5 � � ( * . ( � � �* + � $ � 8 � . 3 6 - � . 6 * . % * + � 2 # - / ( . % * + � $ � * � 6 - / ( > @ . . ) 4 * + � " # � 5 � � ( 0 6 2 � $ - ? # � / � * 2 � - # 5 � #8 � � 5 # ) � ) * � � ) 6 � H � � ( * # 6 � # ) * ( 4 $ - � - � � # 5 ( * # ) 3 ( 4 % � . 7 � � ( + . 8 ( 4 # ) 3 . * + � � � � * # $ � ( * . � � ( 2 � 1 # )( � � � $ ) 1 # * * + � 5 # � / � * > D + � " # � 5 � � ( ? # � / � * ( * $ � � � & $ ( * ( $ ) $ * ( . � $ 1 $ ) # � � . - # * $ . ) : # � * + . 6 1 + $ * + # (1 � . 7 ) ; 4 7 $ * + # ) # � � # . % % . . 3 ( * # ) 3 ( # ) 3 � � * # $ � ( + . 8 ( # ( � * + ) $ - # � � # ) 3 - 6 � * 6 � # � � 3 $ � � � ( � # ( * + �@ 6 � � � ' � � # $ ) 7 + $ - + $ * ( $ * ( > I * $ ( * + � � # ( * � � 5 ) # ) * . % 9 $ � 5 . � � - . 5 5 � � - $ # � # ) 3 � � - � � # * $ . ) # �3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * ( * + # * . ) - � $ ) - � 6 3 � 3 # 3 � $ � � ! $ ) 5 . � $ � * + � # * � � 4 # � # - � * � # - / 4 # ) 3 # ( * # 3 $ 6 5 >= $ / � * + � ( $ ) 1 � � ! % # 5 $ � # ) 3 5 6 � * $ ! % # 5 $ � 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * ( $ ) * + � ? $ 3 ! B $ � ( + $ � � # ) 3 , # ) - . - / 0 # � /) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( 4 * + � ) � 7 ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( . % * + � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & # � � # 7 � � � 3 � � � � . 8 � 3 # ) 3 + � # � $ � 5 # � / � * � 3 # ( 3 $ ( - � � * � ( 6 2 3 $ � $ ( $ . ) ( > D + � $ ) - � 6 3 � 3 # + $ 1 + ) 6 5 2 � � . % 5 6 � * $ ! % # 5 $ � � � ( $ 3 � ) - � ( 4$ ) - � 6 3 $ ) 1 ) 6 5 � � . 6 ( * 7 . ! ( * . � 3 6 8 � � & � ( # ) 3 % . 6 � 8 � � & � ( 4 $ ) # � # � $ � * . % 0 � � $ . 3 < � � $ � # � ( * � � ( >? . ( * 7 � � � - . ) ( * � 6 - * � 3 % � . 5 * + � 5 $ 3 ! � E O F ( * . * + � � # � � � E K F ( 4 * + . 6 1 + � # * � � � & # 5 8 � � ( � & $ ( * H #8 � . 5 $ ) � ) * 4 6 ) 6 ( 6 # � � $ ) * # - * 4 # ) 3 ( . 5 � 7 + # * � # * � � & # 5 8 � � . % # ) # 8 # � * 5 � ) * + . 6 ( � 3 $ ( * � $ - * $ (P Q R Q S T U V W X Y S Q Z [ \ ] ^ _ S X [ _ Q ` a ] _ b Q c d e f ^ Y ] ` c d g f ^ Y ^ Y ] h X T _ S Y ! i \ ` Q S ] j S Q ^ a ` Q ] _ a Y T3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * > D + � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * ( 7 � � � � � � ) 5 . � � # 6 * . 5 . 2 $ � � ! % . - 6 ( � 3 * + # ) * + �# 6 * . 5 . 2 $ � � ( 6 2 6 � 2 ( % 6 � * + � � � # ( * $ ) * + � B $ � ( + $ � � C 0 ' 4 ( $ ) - � * + � 7 � � � 8 # ( * * + � . 6 * � � � $ 5 $ * . % * + �k \ ^ l ] m Q T Q ^ n Y a T o Y U p ^ ^ _ S Q Q _ [ Y S ^ U ^ _ Q i qB + � � � 5 6 - + . % 7 � ( * ! - � ) * � # � = . ( ' ) 1 � � � ( 3 $ 3 ) . * + # � � # � # � 1 � r � 7 $ ( + ' 5 � � $ - # ) 8 . 8 6 � # * $ . ) 6 ) * $ �# % * � � B . � � 3 B # � I I 4 * + � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 + # 3 # ( $ 1 ) $ % $ - # ) * r � 7 $ ( + ' 5 � � $ - # )8 � � ( � ) - � % � . 5 $ * ( � # � � $ � ( * 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * $ ) * + � � E O F ( > " . � � & # 5 8 � � 4 � � ( � # � - + . ) * + � � � ( $ 3 � ) * ( . %* + � A � # ) 1 � 9 � . � � ' � � ) 6 � ! 9 # � 3 ) � � @ * � � � * # � � # 4 + $ ( * . � $ - # � � # r � 7 $ ( + � ) - � # � � 4 % . 6 ) 3 # 3 $ � � � ( �

� � � � � � � �� E

r � 7 $ ( + - . 5 5 6 ) $ * � � 8 � � ( � ) * # * $ � � . % * + � . � � � # � � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & # � � # # * * + # * * $ 5 � > D + $ () � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 4 8 # � * . % # ( 6 2 3 $ � $ ( $ . ) 3 � � � � . 8 � 3 2 9 > ' � � # ) , # ) - . - / 4 $ ) - � 6 3 � 3 � � - � ) * $ 5 5 $ 1 � # ) * (% � . 5 . 6 * ( $ 3 � * + � s > @ > 4 8 � . 8 � � 7 + . + # 3 5 . � � 3 % � . 5 * + � J # ( * C . # ( * 4 # ) 3 ' ) 1 � � � ) . ( 7 + . + # 35 . � � 3 * . * + � # � � # % � . 5 . * + � � 8 # � * ( . % * + � - $ * : 8 � $ 5 # � $ � � . � � , � $ 1 + * ( ; > I * 5 # 2 � * + # * * + $ () � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 # ) 3 . * + � � / ) . 7 ) � # � � r � 7 $ ( + � � ( $ 3 � ) * $ # � � ) - � # � � ( $ ) * + � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & # � � # 3 $ 3) . * ( � � � & - � 6 ( $ . ) . % r � 7 $ ( + + . 5 � . 7 ) � � ( # ) 3 � � ) * � � ( 2 # ( � 3 . ) � � ( * � $ - * $ � � + . 6 ( $ ) 1 - . � � ) # ) * ( . �� # � * . � $ ) % � 6 � ) - � # ( ( � � ) $ ) ( . 5 � . * + � � 8 # � * ( . % = . ( ' ) 1 � � � ( > 0 � � 5 $ * # ) 3 - � ) ( 6 ( � � ( � # � - +$ ) 3 $ - # * � ( * + # * # ( 6 2 ( * # ) * $ # � ) 6 5 2 � � . % 8 � . 8 � � * $ � ( $ ) * + � ( � � ) - � # � � ( 7 � � � 2 6 $ � * # ) 3 . 7 ) � 3 2 r � 7 $ ( + $ ) 3 $ � $ 3 6 # � ( 4 2 . * + � $ � $ ) 1 . ) ( $ * � # ) 3 � � ) * $ ) 1 * . * � ) # ) * ( > M 6 � $ ) 1 * + � 8 . ( * 7 # � 8 � � $ . 3 4 * + �r � 7 $ ( + 8 . 8 6 � # * $ . ) . % � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & $ ) - � � # ( � 3 ( 6 2 ( * # ) * $ # � � 4 # ) 3 - . ) * $ ) 6 � 3 * . 5 . � � 7 � ( * 7 # � 3$ ) * . ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( � $ / � 0 $ - . ! < . 2 � � * ( . ) > D + � � � � � � � ! " # $ � % # & ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 $ ( ( * $ � � # 8 . 8 6 � # �� ( $ 3 � ) * $ # � # � � # % . � r � 7 $ ( + % # 5 $ � $ � ( 4 $ ) - � 6 3 $ ) 1 5 � 5 2 � � ( . % * + � A � * + . 3 . & - . 5 5 6 ) $ * 7 + . 7 � � �8 # � * . % # 5 # N . � 5 . � � 5 � ) * * . * + � B $ � ( + $ � � C 0 ' ( * # � * $ ) 1 $ ) * + � � E � F ( >< � ( $ 3 � ) * $ # � ( 6 2 3 $ � $ ( $ . ) ( $ ) * + � " # $ � % # & ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 7 � � � ( � � � $ - � 3 2 - . 5 5 � � - $ # � 3 $ ( * � $ - * ($ ) - � 6 3 $ ) 1 * + . ( � # � . ) 1 K t u @ * � � � * 4 � � � � � � � . 6 � � � # � 3 # ) 3 " # $ � % # & ' � � ) 6 � > ' 8 # � * $ - 6 � # � � 8 � . 5 $ ) � ) *r � 7 $ ( + 2 6 ( $ ) � ( ( 3 $ ( * � $ - * � 5 � � 1 � 3 Y T \ ] m v \ S _ b w Y a S x Y y l R Q ] X Q z ^ \ i Q _ a i Q ^ S Q x Q S S Q ` _ \ Y ^ h { \ ^ b Q S| Y ] U \ ] j } q P X ^ a ] Q ^ ^ Q ^ [ Y _ Q S a ] m _ \ _ b Q Y S Q Y p ^ ~ Q o a ^ b 8 . 8 6 � # * $ . ) 2 � 1 # ) # 8 8 � # � $ ) 1 . ) " # $ � % # &( * # � * $ ) 1 $ ) * + � � E K F ( 4 # - - � � � � # * $ ) 1 1 � � # * � # % * � � B . � � 3 B # � I I > I ) * + � 8 . ( * 7 # � � # � ( 4 - . 5 5 6 ) $ * - � ) * � � ( 4 ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( ) # 1 . 1 6 � ( 4 / . ( + � � 3 � � $ ( 4 � � ( * # 6 � # ) * ( 4 # ) 3 r � 7 $ ( + 2 # / � � $ � ( 7 � � �) 6 5 � � . 6 ( . ) * + � ( * � � � * > @ � � � � # � � . ) 1 ! _ a i Q � X ^ a ] Q ^ ^ Q ^ Z a ] [ T X ` a ] m | Y ] _ Q S p ^ � Q T a [ Y _ Q ^ ^ Q ] Z@ - + 7 # � * � � # / � � 4 # ) 3 M $ # 5 . ) 3 � # / � � 4 # � � ( * $ � � $ ) . 8 � � # * $ . ) > � � � � � � � . 6 � � � # � 3 # � ( . ( # 7 #( $ 1 ) $ % $ - # ) * $ ) - � � # ( � $ ) * + � � ( * # 2 � $ ( + 5 � ) * . % r � 7 $ ( + - . 5 5 � � - $ # � # ) 3 $ ) ( * $ * 6 * $ . ) # � 8 � . 8 � � * $ � (3 6 � $ ) 1 * + � 8 . ( * 7 # � 8 � � $ . 3 4 5 # ) . % 7 + $ - + - . ) * $ ) 6 � * . ( � � � � * + � - . 5 5 6 ) $ * * . 3 # >C # � * + # D + � C # � * + # ) � $ 1 + 2 . � + . . 3 ( � � 8 � � ( � ) * # 3 $ ( * $ ) - * $ � � 8 # * * � � ) . % 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * * + # * 3 $ % % � � � 3( . 5 � 7 + # * % � . 5 * + # * . % * + � ( 6 � � . 6 ) 3 $ ) 1 # � � # ( . % 0 $ - . ! < . 2 � � * ( . ) 4 ? $ 3 ! B $ � ( + $ � � 4 # ) 3 � � � � � � !" # $ � % # & > ' ( 5 . ( * . % * + � C # � * + # # � � # � $ � ( 7 $ * + $ ) * 7 . , 0 A � ( 4 C # � * + # C $ � - � � # ) 3 @ . 6 * + C # � * + # 4# ) 3 . ) � 8 � . 8 . ( � 3 , 0 A � 4 C # � * + # @ G 6 # � � 4 $ * 7 # ( � # � 1 � � ) . * ( 6 � � � � 3 # ( 8 # � * . % @ 6 � � � = ' >M � � � � . 8 � � r > , # � � � ? - C # � * + 8 � # ) ) � 3 C # � * + # C � ) * � � : � # * � � C # � * + # C $ � - � � ; # ( # 3 � ( $ � # 2 � �( 6 2 3 $ � $ ( $ . ) . % . ) � ! ( * . � 4 0 � � $ . 3 < � � $ � # � 4 ( $ ) 1 � � ! % # 5 $ � � � ( $ 3 � ) - � ( # ) 3 ( 5 # � � � � # 5 . 6 ) * ( . % 5 6 � * $ !% # 5 $ � + . 6 ( $ ) 1 ( * # � * $ ) 1 $ ) � E O O > ? - C # � * + � ) � $ ( $ . ) � 3 * + � 3 � � � � . 8 5 � ) * # ( # - . 5 8 � � * �- . 5 5 6 ) $ * 7 $ * + - . 5 5 � � - $ # � # ) 3 $ ) ( * $ * 6 * $ . ) # � � � � 5 � ) * ( 4 7 + $ - + - # 5 � * . $ ) - � 6 3 � * + � % # 5 . 6 (C # � * + # C $ � - � � D + � # * � � > ' � * + . 6 1 + * + # * 8 � # ) 7 # ( ) . * % 6 � � - # � � $ � 3 . 6 * 4 * + � ( 6 2 3 $ � $ ( $ . ) p ^ T Y U \ X _ 3 $ 3- � � # * � # 3 $ ( * $ ) - * $ � � ( � ) ( � . % 8 � # - � � $ * 2 � . / � 7 $ * + * + � ( 6 � � . 6 ) 3 $ ) 1 ( * � � � * 1 � $ 3 * . % � # * 6 � � # )$ � � � 1 6 � # � ( * � � � * 8 # * * � � ) # � . 6 ) 3 @ # ) � $ - � ) * � � . 6 � � � # � 3 4 # ) 3 + # 3 # ) � 5 8 + # ( $ ( . ) 8 � 3 � ( * � $ # )# - - � ( ( > | Y S _ b Y U | a S [ T Q p ^ 3 � � 3 � � ( * � $ - * $ . ) ( � & - � 6 3 � 3 ) . ) ! 7 + $ * � ( 4 % . � 2 # 3 � % � # * � . . % ( 4 # ) 3 � � G 6 $ � � 33 � ( $ 1 ) � � � $ � 7 . % # � � ) � 7 - . ) ( * � 6 - * $ . ) 2 # + . 5 � . 7 ) � � ( # ( ( . - $ # * $ . ) > � �� ¡ ¢ £ ¤ ¢ � ¥ � ¦ � � � § ¨ ¢ � � ¨ © ª « � ¬ � � « � ® � ¯ ° � ± ² � ³ ´ µ ´ ¶ � µ · ¸ µ ¹ º

Dee Ann Newkirk 6/30/16 Photos

To: Charley Fisher

This is Kari Flowler email saying our building looks worthy to be on SURVEY LA!

Dee Ann

Begin forwarded message:

From: Kari Fowler <[email protected]>

Date: February 2, 2016 at 11:12:44 AM PST

To: "[email protected]" <[email protected]>

Subject: 423 N. Hayworth

Hello, Dee Ann:

It was nice speaking with you yesterday. I took a closer look at your building and the building on

Edinburgh, and I concur that the two buildings are quite similar and appear to have a similarly high

level of historic integrity. The Edinburgh building is located in the Hollywood Community Plan Area,

which we surveyed, and we did indeed evaluate it as locally eligible as an “excellent example of French

Norman Revival multi‐family residential architecture in Hollywood.” Interestingly, the building at 423

N. Hayworth is located in the Wilshire Community Plan Area, which was surveyed by Katie Horak’s

1irm (whom you spoke with). So I can’t speak directly to why it wasn’t picked up; they may have had a

higher threshold in their area versus ours.

In any case, I agree that an HCM nomination is worth pursuing, particularly due to the intact interior

features that could contribute to a local designation. Ordinarily, this is something we could help you

with. Although, due to our current workload it’s not something we would be able to get to right away.

And given your current circumstance you probably need to get this going sooner than later. .

Hope this helpful and best of luck to you!

‐Kari

© 2016 Microsoft Terms Privacy & cookies Developers English (United States)

Inbox 66159

Junk 399

TA Links

Drafts 6

Sent

Deleted

Buy a Timeshare.com 4

eBay 1896

Facebook 2461

Ancestry

LA City Lobbying 7

Masonic 59

Millard 2

ModCom 78

Nash Club 3260

Phone Messages 22

Political newsletters 19165

Welk 16

Xerox Copier 62

eorge Washington Masoni

Folders

New folder

Categories

…

New category

Fwd: 423 N. Hayworth

New Reply Delete Archive Junk Sweep Move to Categories Charles Fisher

Outlook.com - [email protected] https://blu181.mail.live.com/?tid=cmTjyjHTI_5hGvUQAiZMIImg2&fid...

1 of 1 7/1/2016 12:05 AM

Building Permit History

423-27 N. Hayworth Avenue

Los Angeles

September 16, 1936: Building Permit No. 24828 to construct a 2-story, 38’ X 74’ 16-

room 4-family apartment at 425, 425½, 427 and 427½ N.

Hayworth Avenue, on Lot 273 of Tract No. 6790.

Owner: Spinning Wheel Corp.

Architect: David C. Coleman

Engineer: None

Contractor: Spinning Wheel Corp.

Cost: $10,000.00

September 16, 1936: Building Permit No. 24829 to construct a 1-story, 18’ X 33’ 4-

room garage at 425, 425½, 427 and 427½ N. Hayworth

Avenue, on Lot 273 of Tract No. 6790.


Architect: David C. Coleman

Engineer: None

Contractor: Spinning Wheel Corp.

Cost: $300.00

January 14, 1937: Building Permit No. 524 for interior tile work at 425-27 N.

Hayworth Avenue.


Architect: None

Engineer: None

Contractor: Selectile Contractors

Cost: Not Shown

June 2, 1960: Building Permit No. LA61988 for wet sandblasting.

Owner: Harry Jenkins

Architect: None

Engineer: None

Contractor: I. Reblee

Cost: $440.00

June 29, 1991: Building Permit No. HO13978 to install security bars.

Owner: Irving and Margaret Ecker

Architect: None

Engineer: None

Contractor: Owner

Cost: $300.00

May 31, 2007 Electrical Permit No. WO74113135 for electrical panel upgrade

Owner: Eva Langer, Trustee, I. and M. Ecker Trust

Architect: None

Engineer: None

Contractor: Owner

Cost: Not Shown

Spinning Wheel Apartments Photographs

Spinning Wheel Apartments, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)



Spinning Wheel Apartments, satellite view, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, c 2015 (photograph by Google Earth)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, front bay, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, North facade, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, January 16, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, rear facade, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, garage, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, March 11, 2016 (photograph by Dee Ann Newkirk)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, South side bay, 423-27½ N. Hayworth, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, South facade, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, railing, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, typical living room, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, typical mantel, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, leaded glass, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, crown molding, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, original bathroom, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Ave, April 12, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

Spinning Wheel Apartments, 423-27½ N. Hayworth Avenue, January26, 2016 (photograph by Charles J. Fisher)

City of Los AngelesDepartment of City Planning

12/13/2016

PARCEL PROFILE REPORT Address/Legal Information

PIN Number 141B177 1388

Lot/Parcel Area (Calculated) 6,611.9 (sq ft)

Thomas Brothers Grid PAGE 593 - GRID B7

Assessor Parcel No. (APN) 5527032022

Tract TR 6790

Map Reference M B 74-32

Block None

Lot 273

Arb (Lot Cut Reference) None

Map Sheet 141B177

Jurisdictional Information

Community Plan Area Wilshire

Area Planning Commission Central

Neighborhood Council Mid City West

Council District CD 5 - Paul Koretz

Census Tract # 1945.00

LADBS District Office Los Angeles Metro

Planning and Zoning Information

Special Notes None

Zoning R3-1

Zoning Information (ZI) ZI-2452 Transit Priority Area in the City of Los Angeles

ZI-2443 Neighborhood Conservation ICO - Lower Council Dist. 5

General Plan Land Use Medium Residential

General Plan Footnote(s) Yes

Hillside Area (Zoning Code) No

Baseline Hillside Ordinance No

Baseline Mansionization Ordinance No

Specific Plan Area None

Special Land Use / Zoning None

Design Review Board No

Historic Preservation Review No

Historic Preservation Overlay Zone None

Other Historic Designations None

Other Historic Survey Information None

Mills Act Contract None

POD - Pedestrian Oriented Districts None

CDO - Community Design Overlay None

NSO - Neighborhood Stabilization Overlay No

Sign District No

Streetscape No

Adaptive Reuse Incentive Area None

Ellis Act Property No

Rent Stabilization Ordinance (RSO) Yes

CRA - Community Redevelopment Agency None

Central City Parking No

Downtown Parking No

PROPERTY ADDRESSES

427 N HAYWORTH AVE

425 N HAYWORTH AVE

423 N HAYWORTH AVE

427 1/2 N HAYWORTH AVE



ZIP CODES

90048

RECENT ACTIVITY

CHC-2017-4770-HCM

ENV-2017-4771-CE

CASE NUMBERS

CPC-1986-823-GPC

ORD-183497

ORD-165331-SA80

This report is subject to the terms and conditions as set forth on the website. For more details, please refer to the terms and conditions at zimas.lacity.org(*) - APN Area is provided "as is" from the Los Angeles County's Public Works, Flood Control, Benefit Assessment.

zimas.lacity.org | planning.lacity.org

Building Line None

500 Ft School Zone No

500 Ft Park Zone No

Assessor Information

Assessor Parcel No. (APN) 5527032022

Ownership (Assessor)

Owner1 HAYWORTH ABBEY LLC C/O C/O ISSAC COHANZAD

Address 11601 SANTA MONICA BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90025

Ownership (Bureau of Engineering, LandRecords)

Owner HAYWORTH ABBEY LLC C/O ISAAC COHANZAD

Address 11601 SANTA MONICA BLVD LOS ANGELES CA 90025

APN Area (Co. Public Works)* 0.152 (ac)

Use Code 0400 - 4 units (4 stories or less)

Assessed Land Val. $1,223,796

Assessed Improvement Val. $714,204

Last Owner Change 07/31/15

Last Sale Amount $1,900,019

Tax Rate Area 67

Deed Ref No. (City Clerk) 933266

2043220

1916427

1861576

1656888

Building 1

Year Built 1936

Building Class D65

Number of Units 4

Number of Bedrooms 8

Number of Bathrooms 4

Building Square Footage 4,668.0 (sq ft)

Building 2 No data for building 2




Additional Information

Airport Hazard None

Coastal Zone None

Farmland Area Not Mapped

Very High Fire Hazard Severity Zone No

Fire District No. 1 No

Flood Zone None

Watercourse No

Hazardous Waste / Border Zone Properties No

Methane Hazard Site Methane Zone

High Wind Velocity Areas No

Special Grading Area (BOE Basic Grid Map A-13372)

No

Oil Wells None

Seismic Hazards

Active Fault Near-Source Zone

Nearest Fault (Distance in km) 2.35278168

Nearest Fault (Name) Hollywood Fault

Region Transverse Ranges and Los Angeles Basin



Fault Type B

Slip Rate (mm/year) 1.00000000

Slip Geometry Left Lateral - Reverse - Oblique

Slip Type Poorly Constrained

Down Dip Width (km) 14.00000000

Rupture Top 0.00000000

Rupture Bottom 13.00000000

Dip Angle (degrees) 70.00000000

Maximum Magnitude 6.40000000

Alquist-Priolo Fault Zone No

Landslide No

Liquefaction Yes

Preliminary Fault Rupture Study Area No

Tsunami Inundation Zone No

Economic Development Areas

Business Improvement District None

Promise Zone No

Renewal Community No

Revitalization Zone None

State Enterprise Zone None

Targeted Neighborhood Initiative None

Public Safety

Police Information

Bureau West

Division / Station Wilshire

Reporting District 711

Fire Information

Bureau South

Batallion 18

District / Fire Station 61

Red Flag Restricted Parking No



CASE SUMMARIESNote: Information for case summaries is retrieved from the Planning Department's Plan Case Tracking System (PCTS) database.

Case Number: CPC-1986-823-GPC

Required Action(s): GPC-GENERAL PLAN/ZONING CONSISTENCY (AB283)

Project Descriptions(s): AB-283 PROGRAM - GENERAL PLAN/ZONE CONSISTENCY - WILSHIRE AREA- COMMUNITY WIDE ZONE CHANGES ANDCOMMUNITY PLAN CHANGES TO BRING THE ZONING INTO CONSISTENCY WITH THE COMMUNITY PLAN. INCLUDESCHANGES OF HEIGHT AS NEEDED. REQUIRED BY COURT AS PART OF SETTLEMENT IN THE HILLSIDE FEDERATIONLAWSUIT

DATA NOT AVAILABLEORD-183497

ORD-165331-SA80



ZIMAS INTRANET 2014 Digital Color-Ortho 12/13/2016City of Los Angeles

Department of City Planning

Address: 423 N HAYWORTH AVE Tract: TR 6790 Zoning: R3-1

APN: 5527032022 Block: None General Plan: Medium Residential

PIN #: 141B177 1388 Lot: 273

Arb: None

Streets Copyright (c) Thomas Brothers Maps, Inc.

spinning wheel apartments - la city planning · 1/19/2017 · the 1936 spinning wheel apartments...

Documents