Making Learning Realwith Problem-Based Case Learning

www.makinglearningreal.org

Scoring Rubric for Presentations

Scoring Rubric for Presentations – Instructions

Instructions–1

Traits 5–Excellent 4–VeryGood 3–Adequate 2–Limited 1–PoorInform

ationQuality

andOrganization • Mainpointsareveryclear

andverydetailed

• Informationisdirectlylinkedtopresentationtopic

• Informationisveryorganized

• Mainpointsareclearanddetailed

• Informationislinkedtopresentationtopic

• Informationiswellorganized

• Mainpointsaresomewhatclearbutcouldusemoredetail

• Mostinformationislinkedtothepresentationtopic

• Informationisorganized

• Mainpointsarenotclearandlacksignificantdetail

• Someinformationislinkedtothepresentationtopic

• Informationislooselyorganized

• Presentationlacksmainpointsandrelateddetails

• Informationlacksconnectiontothepresentationtopic

• Informationisnotorganized

Non

verbalCom

mun

ication

• Speakerappearsverycomfortableandconfident

• Speakerconsistentlyfacestheaudienceandmaintainsgoodeyecontact

• Speakerconsistentlyappearstobeengagingwiththeaudience

• Speakerusesbodymotionsandgesturesveryeffectively

• Speakerutilizestheroomveryeffectivelyviamovement

• Speakerappearsfairlycomfortableandconfident

• Speakergenerallyfacestheaudienceandmaintainsgoodeyecontact

• Speakergenerallyappearstobeengagingwiththeaudience

• Speakerusesbodymotionsandgestureswell

• Speakerutilizesmuchoftheroomviamovement

• Speakerappearsgenerallyateaseandconfident

• Speakersometimesfacestheaudienceandmaintainseyecontact

• Speakersometimesappearstobeengagingwiththeaudience

• Speaker'sbodymotionsandgesturesneithersupportnordetractfrompresentation

• Speakermovesaboutsomeoftheroom

• Speakerappearsuneasyandsomewhatinsecure

• Speakerrarelyfacestheaudienceormakeseyecontact

• Speakerrarelyappearstobeengagingwiththeaudience

• Speakerusesfewbodymotionsorgesturesorhasgesturesormovementsthatdistracttheaudience

• Speakerismostlystationary

• Speakerappearsveryuneasyandinsecure

• Speakerfacesawayfromtheaudienceormakesnoeyecontact

• Speakerappearsdisengagedfromtheaudience

• Speakerlacksanybodymotionsorgesturesordemonstratesconsistentlydistractionbodymotionsorgestures

• Speakeriscompletelystationary

QualityofVerbalCom

mun

ication • Speaker’svoiceisvery

confident,steady,strong,andclear

• Speakerconsistentlyusesinflectionstoemphasizekeypointsortocreateinterest

• Speaker'stalkingpaceisconsistentlyappropriate

• Speaker’svoiceissteady,strongandclear

• Speakeroftenusesinflectionstoemphasizekeypointsandcreateinterest

• Speaker'stalkingpaceismostlyappropriate

• Speaker’svoiceisgenerallysteady,strongandclear

• Speakersometimesusesinflectionstoemphasizekeypointsandcreateinterest

• Speaker'stalkingpaceisappropriate

• Speaker’svoiceisfrequentlytooweakortoostrong

• Speakerrarelyusesinflectionstoemphasizekeypointsandcreateinterestorspeakersometimesusesinflectionsinappropriately

• Speaker'stalkingpaceisoftentooslowortoofast

• Speaker’svoiceisconsistentlytooweakortoostrong

• Speakerfailstouseinflectionstoemphasizekeypointsandcreateinterestorspeakeroftenusesinflectionsinappropriately

• Speaker'stalkingpaceisconsistentlytooslowortoofast

Scoring Rubric for Presentations – Instructions

Instructions–2

Traits 5–Excellent 4–VeryGood 3–Adequate 2–Limited 1–PoorVisualToo

ls

• Visualaidsareverycreative,clear,andeasytoread

• Presentationisconsistentlyenhancedbythevisualtools

• Visualaidsareusuallycreative,clear,andeasytoread

• Presentationisoftenenhancedbythevisualtools

• Visualaidsarereasonablycreative,clear,andeasytoread

• Presentationissometimesenhancedbythevisualtools

• Visualaidshavelimitedcreativityorclarityoraresometimesdifficulttoread

• Presentationisnotenhancedbythevisualtools

• Visualaidsdemonstratenocreativityorclarityandareoftendifficulttoread

• Presentationisweakenedbythevisualtools

App

ropriateUse

ofVocabulary • Alltermsareincludedin

thepresentation

• Usedinuniqueandcreativeways

• Usedincontext

• Alltermsareincludedinthepresentation

• Usedeffectively• Usedincontext

• Mosttermsareincludedinthepresentation

• Generallyusedappropriately

• Generallyusedinappropriatecontext

• Severaltermsareincludedinthepresentation

• Mayormaynotbeusedappropriately

• Maylackcontext

• Fewornotermsareincludedinthepresentation

• Mayormaynotbeusedappropriately

• Lackscontext

PrecisionandDetailin

Docum

entsProdu

ced • Documentsareclear,well

constructed,accurateandshowattentiontodetail

• Extracarehasbeentakenintheproduction

• Clearlyevidentthatdocumentsarecorrect,detailedandaccurate

• Carehasbeentakenintheproduction

• Evidentthatdocumentsarecorrectandshowageneralattentiontodetailandaccuracy

• Generalcarehasbeentakeninproduction

• Documentsmayhavesomeerrorsandshowsomedetail

• Somecarehasbeentakeninproduction

• Documentshavenumerouserrorsandlackdetail

• Littlecaretakenintheproduction

Overall

Presen

tatio

nEffectiven

ess • Thiswasanexceptional

presentationandextremelyeffective

• I’dgiveyoua10

• Thiswasaverygoodpresentationandveryeffective

• I’dgiveyouan8or9

• Thispresentationwasgoodandeffective

• I’dgiveyoua6or7

• Thispresentationwasaverageandsomewhateffective

• I’dgiveyoua3,4or5

• Thispresentationwasweakandnoteffective

• I’dgiveyoua0,1,or2

©2009NashvilleStateTechnicalCommunityCollegeandWGBHEducationalFoundation.AllRightsReserved.