running head: let’s get physical!: adlerian body … ashley mp 2014.pdflet’s get physical!:...

38
Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 1 Let’s Get Physical!: Using Physical Movement to Enhance Adlerian Principles in Therapy Sessions A Master’s Project Presented to The Faculty of Adler Graduate School ________________________________ In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Arts in Adlerian Counseling and Psychotherapy ________________________ By: Danáe M. Ashley December 2014

Upload: others

Post on 19-Mar-2020

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 1

Let’s Get Physical!:

Using Physical Movement to Enhance Adlerian Principles in Therapy Sessions

A Master’s Project

Presented to

The Faculty of Adler Graduate School

________________________________

In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for

the Degree of Master of Arts in

Adlerian Counseling and Psychotherapy

________________________

By:

Danáe M. Ashley

December 2014

Page 2: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 2

Abstract

This paper is part of a two hour, interactive workshop that explores the theoretic foundation of

Alfred Adler’s holism of body and psyche, as well as a brief historical background in overlooked

Adlerians Blanche Evan and Liljan Espenak, who used their Adlerian training and dance

background in their therapeutic process to pioneer what would become Dance/Movement

Therapy. Additionally, the workshop will give the participants some basic physical movement

techniques to utilize in their practice with individuals, couples, and groups to enhance Adlerian

principles such as trust, encouragement, and social interest. The target community for this

presentation is mental health students and practicing counselors, psychotherapists, and others in

the mental health field. The fundamental goals of this workshop and paper are to address an

aspect of Adler's holistic approach to therapy—using the body—with which psychotherapists

may not be familiar and to teach participants a unique piece of Adlerian history.

Keywords: Alfred Adler, Adlerian theory, Adlerian technique, body movement,

Dance/Movement therapy, Blanche Evan, Liljan Espenak, women in Adlerian history

Page 3: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 3

Table of Contents

Abstract…………………………………………………………………………….....................2

Introduction……………………………………………………………………………………...5

Alfred Adler, Individual Psychology, and Body Movement……………………………………6

Organ Inferiority and Organ Dialect……………………………………………….........8

Blanche Evan and Liljan Espenak: Adlerian Psychotherapy and Dance/Movement Therapy…10

Blanche Evan…………………………………………………………………………...10

Evan’s modes of intervention…………………………………………………..12

Liljan Espenak…………………………………………………………………….........14

Espenak’s application of Adlerian theory……………………………………...15

Espenak’s Movement Diagnostic Test…………………………………………17

Liljan Espenak’s legacy………………………………………………………..18

Using Movement in Therapy Sessions………………………………………………………...19

Individual Techniques…………………………………………………………….........20

“The Try On”…………………………………………………………………..20

Amy Cuddy’s “Power Poses”………………………………………………….21

Couple Techniques…………………………………………………………………….22

“The Living Teeter-Totter”………………………………………………........22

“Follow Me”…………………………………………………………………...23

Group Technique………………………………………………………………………25

“Remember Me”………………………………………………………….........25

Implementation and Summary of Outcome for the Project……………………………………26

Description of Project Implemented…………………………………………………...26

Page 4: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 4

Summary of Outcome………………………………………………………………….27

Personal evaluation………………………………………………………….....27

Participants’ evaluation……………………………………………………..…28

Improvements based on outcome……………………………………………...29

Future Plans for Use of Project……………………………………………………..…30

Conclusion………………………………………………………………………………….…30

References…………………………………………………………………………………..…31

Page 5: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 5

Let’s Get Physical!:

Using Physical Movement to Enhance Adlerian Principles in Therapy Sessions

Human beings are on the move from the moment of conception. The zygote tumbles

through the fallopian tubes and into the uterus where it creates a home in the uterine lining and

begins multiplying cells that eventually become a human being. While in the womb, we move to

the rhythm of our mother’s movement—her heart beating, blood pumping, walking, jumping,

and resting. Our bodies are given information about the wider world through our mothers—what

they eat, what they fear, voices and music they hear, their stressors, what they smell, and what

they feel. We receive this information and continue to process it in our bodies when we are

outside the womb (Paul, 2011).

We are born into a culture where body movement becomes both expressive and practical

(Blom & Chaplin, 1988; Boris, 2001). We use “reflexes, gestures, accommodating maneuvers,

posturings, precise complex articulations, random actions, and practical and aesthetic patterns”

(Blom & Chaplin, 1988, p. 3) to live, move, and have our being. Some movements are utilitarian,

while others express an emotion or idea without words. External movements can be seen by the

world, whereas internal movements are felt only by an individual and not seen. We do individual

movements in our posture and our walking gait that reveal how we may be feeling at the

moment. We do group movements to express worship in religious rites as well as when we dance

to celebrate a wedding. We even refer to therapeutic interactions as a form of dance at times

(Mosak & Rasmussen, 2002).

All movement carries some type of meaning. In the field of psychotherapy, where the

focus is on mental and sometimes spiritual process, the body is often not attended to unless there

is a medical issue that affects the client’s mood. Expressive therapies that glean clues from the

Page 6: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 6

body in order to heal, such as Dance/Movement Therapy (DMT), are viewed as a specialist niche

and not something for the everyday practitioner (Capen, 2006). DMT “differs from most verbal

therapies, in that at the outset it places the person in direct contact with her implicit bodily-felt

experiencing rather than in verbalization” (Aplerson, 1979, p. 211). While DMT therapists are

rigorously trained in their skill set, the average therapist can certainly observe a client’s body

movements to gain additional information to help the client (Panhofer, 2011; Parviainen, 2003;

Sommer-Flanagan, 2007). This application of observation would be considered part of Alfred

Adler’s understanding of empathy, which he defined as being “‘able to see with his [the client’s]

eyes and listen with his [the client’s] ears’ (1931a, p.72)” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 14).

Alfred Adler, Individual Psychology, and Body Movement

Early in the twentieth century, Alfred Adler developed what came to be called Individual

Psychology or Adlerian Psychotherapy. Adler was born in 1870 in a village that is now

encompassed by Vienna, to a middle-class Jewish family, and suffered from rickets and

pneumonia as a child. He became a doctor and later a psychotherapist, breaking from Sigmund

Freud, and founding the Individual Psychology therapeutic approach and child guidance

psychoeducation (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1979; Ansbacher, 1992).

Adler’s medical studies brought him into contact with Hermann Nothnagel, a famous

internist, who emphasized to his students that a physician must always look at the whole

patient—not just isolated symptoms or organs—and remember the emotional influence that a

doctor had on his patients (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1979). He told his students, “‘If you want to

be a good doctor, you have to be a kind person’” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1979, p. 332).

Those elements from Nothnagel describe Alfred Adler’s Individual Psychology

approach: use of empathy, authentic regard for others in the form of social interest,

Page 7: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7

encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose, and holism. Holism is defined

as looking at the whole person—body, mind, and spirit—and the understanding that human

beings’ thoughts, feelings, and actions are affected by being socially embedded (Ansbacher &

Ansbacher, 1964; Kopp, 1989; Overholser, 2010; Vande Kemp, 2000).

Modern practitioners of Adlerian psychotherapy hold to this approach. However, in the

focus of easing a person’s psychological pain and encouraging his or her spirit, it is sometimes

forgotten that Adler was a physician of the body, before he became a psychotherapist. The basis

of his psychological theories comes from his observations of the human body—its ailments,

conditions, and tie to the psyche (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964; Gyllensten, Skär, Miller &

Gard, 2010). This is highlighted by Ansbacher (1982) quoting Adler: “‘Very early in my work I

found man to be a unity. The foremost task of Individual Psychology is to prove this unity in

each individual—in his thinking, feeling, acting, in his so-called conscious and unconscious, in

every expression of his personality’ (p. 175)” (p. 32).

Adler trusted movement in a person’s life to reveal the distinctive fictional, final goal he

or she was striving for, as he wrote, “Each individual always manifests himself as unique, be it in

thinking, feeling, speaking, or acting. We are always dealing with individual nuances and

variations…Everything can also be different” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 194). This is

what Adler called the “law of movement” that underpinned a person’s style of life or lifestyle

(Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964; Clark & Butler, 2012). Thus, an adherent of Adlerian

psychotherapy would assign, as Adler himself did, “only limited value to general rules and

instead lay strong emphasis on flexibility and on empathy into nuances” (Ansbacher &

Ansbacher, 1964). If an individual shows his or her lifestyle through “thinking, feeling, speaking,

or acting” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 194), then clearly, the body is a main player in this

Page 8: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 8

unfolding drama of life and should not be neglected in the therapeutic setting (Fennel & Segal,

2011; Guttenberg & Gordon-Rosen, 2013; Leseho & Maxwell, 2010; Lichtman, 2010; Tremain,

2013).

Organ Inferiority and Organ Dialect

The study of psychosomatic issues—the interaction between the body and mind as one

unit—was the concern for Adler in his work Study of Organ Inferiority (Adler, 1917; Ansbacher

& Ansbacher, 1964; Obuchowski,, 1988; Sperry, 2011). Ansbacher and Ansbacher (1964) note

of his later work:

In his subsequent shift of emphasis from the primacy of bodily processes to the primacy

of psychological processes, the organ inferiority lost its causal position and assumed two

new functions. First, it became one of the important objective factors which provide

certain probabilities for the individual’s development (see pp. 368-369), such factors

being ultimately subject to the individual’s own interpretation. Second, the inferior organ,

as the point of least resistance, became the preferred means by which the psyche

expressed itself through the body (p. 223).

Adler acknowledges that the “body is also subject to the law of movement” and that “[t]o

a certain degree, every emotion finds some bodily expression” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964,

p. 223). He reflects that

[t]he emotions and their physical expressions tell us how the mind is acting and reacting

in a situation which it interprets as favorable or unfavorable… [Furthermore,] [t]he body,

through the autonomic nervous system, the vagus nerve, and endocrine variations, is set

into movement which can manifest itself in alterations of the blood circulation, of the

secretions, the muscle tonus, and of almost all the organs. As temporary phenomena the

Page 9: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 9

changes are natural and only show themselves differently according to the style of life or

the person concerned (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, pp. 223-224).

Organ inferiority becomes part of a person’s conceptual world and each person’s body

speaks a language of its own (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964; Coleman & Croake, 1987; Nash &

Nash, 2010; Stone, 2014). Adler studied neuroses effect on the body (Adler, 1932/1996; Kradin,

2011) and believed that “[in] the neurotic symptoms this relationship becomes concretized”

(Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 224). For example, a person suffering from constipation, may

be expressing their desire to hold things in or a person with stooped shoulders may be expressing

discouragement and lack of self-esteem (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964; Bagby, 1923;

Mozdzierz, 1996; Sperry, 1996). As therapists, we must look for the “inner slogan” also known

as “organ jargon” that the body is expressing (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 225).

Adler took the observation of the body-psyche connection further in suggesting that

certain types of body responses to emotion could be inherited. He surmised that “[p]hysical

expressions of this kind will often give us hints of the weaknesses and peculiarities of the family

tree. Other members of the family may make a very similar body response” (Ansbacher &

Ansbacher, 1964, p. 225). This idea may be useful in the therapeutic process when doing a

genogram to understand the family constellation, especially if a client has developed

psychosomatic issues (Chvála, Trapková, & Skorunka, 2012).

The body’s physical development as a form of psychic expression continued Adler’s

thoughts on the body being subjected to the law of movement. He hypothesized that “[a]

courageous individual will show the effects of his attitude in his physique. His body will be

differently build up” and “[w]e can often observe bodily expressions which are plainly the end

results of mental failings, where the right way to compensate for a difficulty has not been

Page 10: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 10

discovered” (Ansbacher & Ansbacher, 1964, p. 226). In Individual Psychology, “[i]t is always

necessary to look for these reciprocal actions of the mind on the body, and of the body on the

mind, for both of them are parts of the whole with which we are concerned” (Ansbacher &

Ansbacher, 1964, p. 225).

Movements of the body, as well as psychological movement were clearly observed

together by Adler to treat the whole person. As a physician, Adler possessed specialized

knowledge of the human body, but encouraged the powers of physical observation when with a

client, whether a therapist had medical knowledge or not. If a therapist aligns his or her self

within an Adlerian theoretical orientation, then this tenet of holism should be practiced.

After Adler’s death in 1937, Individual Psychology continued to spread worldwide and

became the springboard for others to integrate their own theories into Adler’s foundation. The

use of expressive arts fits well within the Adlerian approach (Degges-White & Davis, 2011;

Dushman & Sutherland, 1997; Ernst, Rand & Stevinson, 1998; L’Abate, 2013). Blanche Evan

and Liljan Espenak, two pioneers of the Dance/Movement Therapy (DMT) movement,

successfully integrated their Adlerian training with dance. Both brought the understanding of

holism in mind and body that continues to flourish in the continually developing field of DMT.

Blanche Evan and Liljan Espenak: Adlerian Psychotherapy and

Dance/Movement Therapy

Blanche Evan

Blanche Evan (1909-1982) was a dancer, choreographer, and performer who began using

dance as a “creative, educational emphasis [and later] to a psychotherapeutic emphasis” (Levy,

2005, p. 29) with her approach integrating her original teachings in later years. She was

influenced in her study of dance by Bird Larson, who was one of the early adapters of what was

Page 11: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 11

called natural dance and expressive improvisational dance, as well as the work of Dalcroze,

Noverre, Stanislovski, Mesnsendieck, and Veola and La Meri (Levy, 2005).

Evan’s “major interest was dance improvisation as a medium through which one’s

creative and emotional potential could be drawn out and actualized (Evan, personal

communication, 1980)” (Levy, 2005, p. 29). By the late 1940s and early 50s, she was

specializing in creative dance with children (Evan, 1964). However, by the late 1950s until her

death in 1982, Evan focused on the population of adults that she labeled the “normal, functioning

neurotic” (Levy, 2005, p. 29). She was concerned that the use of dance as therapy was being

emphasized for helping the psychotic individual, overlooking its helpfulness for the neurotic

person and dedicated herself to this cause (Levy, 2005; Benov, 1991). In response to Adler’s

connection of the movement of the psyche and the body, especially regarding neurosis, Evan

adds, “Yes, ‘the life of man is the life of a moving being’ but the typical urban body in the

United States has ceased moving…The no-outlet energy for some becomes active-destructive

violence, outwardly to the world and/or inwardly to one’s self” (Benov, 1991, p. 142).

By 1956, Evan was calling her pioneering work “creative dance as therapy” and in 1958,

after studying at the Alfred Adler Institute of Individual Psychology and the New School for

Social Research, she began to train professionals and students in her approach (Levy, 2005). As

the field of dance therapy expanded, Evan never accepted the word

“movement” as an accurate substitute for the word “dance” (personal communication,

1980). She saw too much of dance therapy as being “antidance” and aspiring either to the

verbal therapies, hence losing the inherent power of dance or to the “body/mind”

therapies, which too often ignored the individual’s emotions and diagnoses (Levy, 2005,

p. 30).

Page 12: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 12

Evan’s Adlerian influence is clear in her emphasis of working with the whole person.

Specifically, she “emphasized the person in his or her world” (Levy, 2005, p. 32). In her work

with the neurotic urban adult, she interpreted issues of fatigue as “manifestations of inner drives

toward repression, fear, and dependency, causing clients to resist using their full physical

potential” (Levy, 2005, p. 32). Furthermore, “[i]n accordance with Adlerian psychology, Evan

believed that repressed aggression and anger were the major maladies of the neurotic. Because

the neurotic’s anger was repressed, so was his or her assertiveness and commitment to growing

up. This was reflected clearly in the body musculature” (Levy, 2005, p. 32). Her commitment in

creative dance therapy was to “re-educate individuals to accept their bodily responses and needs

which, she believed, existed prior to the repressive influences of family and society” (Levy,

2005, p. 32).

Evan’s modes of intervention. Evan developed four major modes of intervention: the

warm-up, the Evan System of Functional Technique, improvisation/enactment, and verbalization

of thoughts and feelings (Levy, 2005; Bernstein, 2005; Najarian, 2008). While there is much to

describe in each form of intervention, the Adlerian influences are clear in the following places:

1. Physical Warm-up: The basis of the warm-up was to bring individuals “into contact with

the reality of their psychophysical selves” (Levy, 2005, p. 33) with the therapist

addressing the whole person. When in a group, social interest and encouragement were

practiced by having members take turns at leading the warm-up also giving the chance

for psychosomatic issues to be affected positively by group interaction (Levy, 2005;

Ávila, 2010).

2. The Evan System of Functional Technique: This technique “included postural work,

coordination, placement of body parts and rhythmicity. This style of work was

Page 13: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 13

individualized, varied, adapting to the individual’s unique anatomical needs. In Evan’s

words, functional techniques ‘…respects nature’s plan of the body in action…Changing

the body tonus from destructive tension to resilience is vital’ (Rifkin-Gainer, et al., 1984,

p. 14)” (Levy, 2005, p. 34). This exemplifies the psychological theory of the law of

movement in the most holistic and fundamental way, remembering Adler’s approach to

each person being unique and that “Everything can also be different” (Ansbacher &

Ansbacher, 1964, p. 194).

3. Improvisation/Enactment: Evan’s definition of improvisation was “…the spontaneous

creation of form” (Levy, 2005, p. 34). She used three types of approaches: projective

techniques (having clients take on the form of an animal, color, or texture), sensitization

to and mobilization of potential body action (use of props, words in opposition—

gather/scatter/, morning/night, etc.), and in-depth and/or complex improvisation

(expressing the client’s own thoughts and feelings in structured movement) (Levy, 2005;

Nemetz, 1995). These approaches echo Adler’s creativity in the use of hunches,

metaphor, humor, and empathy in understanding the client where he or she is to bring the

client’s mistaken beliefs to awareness (Mosak & Maniacci, 1999).

4. Verbalization of thoughts and feelings: This is the process of traditional psychotherapy

during and after the dance sessions—talk therapy integrated with the body. “Evan

emphasized the importance of knowing why the therapist was asking an individual to do

a specific movement exploration” (Levy, 2005, p. 37). Like Adler, she also would assign

homework and encourage the process of putting “‘insight into action’ between sessions”

(Bernstein, 2005, p. 3).

Page 14: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 14

Evan was known for interrupting clients when they were discussing their issues by

saying, “‘Stop talking and move’ (1945-1978, n.p.)…This later became a theme in Evan’s

training of dance therapists…bringing the expression back to its somatic reality (or source in the

body) as opposed to encouraging verbal exploration and intellectualization” (Levy, 2005, p. 40).

Like Adler, she trusted only movement—both psychologically and physically.

Evan trained in psychotherapy at the Alfred Adler Institute of Individual Psychology, was

also a member of its faculty, and was clearly influenced by Adler, she regarded herself as a

dancer and choreographer first, not Adlerian. Her contemporary, Liljan Espenak, however, was

known for her integration of Adlerian psychological concepts into dance therapy.

Liljan Espenak

Born in Bergen, Norway, Liljan Espenak (1905-1988) studied dance in Dresden,

Germany with Mary Wigman at the Wigman Conservatory and was a dance teacher there until

1934. Espenak also studied physiology, Dalcroze eurhythmics—a system of training through

physical movement to music to develop grace and musical understanding—gymnastic

techniques, and developed her own school of movement that was accredited by the Prussian

Board of Education (Levy, 2005).

Espenak fled Germany during World War II, first to England and finally immigrating to

the United States in 1941. She taught dance in the 1940s at the YWCA and the Wright Oral

School for the Deaf and studied psychotherapy for three years in the 1950s at the Alfred Adler

Institute. During this time, she purposefully integrated her psychotherapy training with her

understanding of the therapeutic nature of dance (Levy, 2005).

Eventually, she became the Director of the Division of Creative Therapies, Institute for

Mental Retardation at New York Medical College in 1961, and later a “dance therapist at the

Page 15: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 15

Alfred Adler Mental Hygiene Clinic (Espenak, personal communication, 1980)” (Levy, 2005).

She influenced second-generation dance therapists through her course—the first of its kind for

postgraduates—in dance therapy at New York Medical College from 1961-1981.

As a pioneer, she never intended to become a dance therapist and “[h]er original goal was

to be an ‘ideal teacher,’ but she said, ‘…when groups became emotional later on…the process

became dance therapy and I, a dance therapist’ (1981, p. 10)” (Levy, 2005). Her work was

influenced by Marian Chace (another pioneering dance therapist) and Rudolf Laban’s Movement

Analysis. She applied “Laban’s holistic view that movement is a process that is always part of

behavior involving body…In therapy, sudden critical changes, as well as gradual changes, can be

understood at their various levels as part of the reintegration process of the patient, even while

there may be no verbal acknowledgement by the patient” (Bartenieff, 1983, p. 148).

Espenak developed what she called “psychomotor therapy” which was a combination of

the psychoanalytic theory of Alfred Adler with the mind/body theories (bioenergetic analysis) of

Alexander Lowen (Levy, 2005). Her definition of psychomotor therapy was “an ‘extension of

dance therapy through application of diagnostic tools for treatment on the medical model of

observation, diagnosis, treatment’ (Espenak, personal communication, 1985)” (Levy, 2005, p.

43).

Espenak’s application of Adlerian theory. Espenak highlighted that Adler began his

career as a medical doctor and that this training informed his holistic approach to psychology.

She describes the Adlerian influence in her psychomotor therapy as follows:

We have indicated how certain psychological constructs, such as those of body image

development and its effect upon physical behaviors, have provided a formal basis for one

aspect of psychomotor therapy; we have also indicated how the organization of the

Page 16: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 16

expressive and communicative aspects of movement, in terms of its universality of

applications in time and space form another aspect of this therapy…The salient concepts

derived from Adlerian theory are the following: (1) aggression drive, (2) social feeling,

(3) inferiority feelings (and related organ inferiority), (4) life-style (early recollections,

first memory). This theory offers itself, almost naturally in its linking of organic

functioning to mind and body, as a useful point of departure for relating psychological

thinking with bodily function and especially expressive movement, i.e. dance (Espenak,

1981, p. 38).

Integration of Freud’s pleasure principle and Adler’s aggression and inferiority theories

became key in Espenak’s work. As she stated,

Without the biological aggression drive and the pleasure principle, the inferiority feelings

would not result in striving for superiority, but be accepted as unchangeable…Inferiority

feelings then remain together with the developing recognition of the powerful

surroundings and acceptance of their interaction. The aggressive drive, however, will lead

to nonacceptance of this position and result in striving for superiority as a means of

obtaining the pleasure principle (Espenak, 1979, p. 76) (Levy, 2005, p. 44).

The results of “working directly on the body, developing physical strength, grounding and an

expressive movement vocabulary could counteract the original feelings of inferiority and

dependency” (Levy, 2005, p. 44). For Espenak, the “conceptualization of dance therapy was

formalized by the Adlerian view that emotions motivate, the mind organizes, and the body

performs the action” (Rossberg-Gempton & Poole, 1992, p. 43).

Espenak agreed with Adler’s encouraging social feeling (social interest) and integrated it

in her work. “She noted that Adler began using verbal groups for their therapeutic value with

Page 17: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 17

children in Europe in the early 1900s [and] [i]t was Espenak’s belief that ‘dancing together and

interrelating singly with a group, is an ideal form for discovering and developing social feeling’

(Espenak, 1979, p. 77)” (Levy, 2005, p. 44).

Espenak’s approach to dance therapy had common characteristics to Lowen’s

bioenergetic work and also her fellow Adlerian-influenced dance therapist Blanche Evan’s

functional technique. She created her own movement diagnostic tests that were given at the start

of treatment and at three-month intervals in order to identify strengths and weaknesses in a

patient’s psychophysical integration, and based a treatment plan on these diagnostic findings

(Levy, 2005).

Espenak’s movement diagnostic tests. The Movement Diagnostic Tests as applied are

similar to an Adlerian life style assessment through observation of the mind and body. There are

six categories that present information regarding “‘the positive and negative components of the

patient’s personality’ (1970, p. 10)” (Levy, 2005, p. 46), briefly described as follows:

1. Test 1A—Body Image: “is a muscular test in which the patient is asked to walk on his or

her toes. The patient’s posture during this activity reveals information about his or her

ego strength and self-assertion” (Levy, 2005, p. 46).

Test 1B—Emotional Response (Spatial Relationships): “involves improvisation…[and]

provides information about ‘the life style and emotional climate of the patient’ (1970, p.

10)” (Levy, 2005, pgs. 46-47).

2. Test II—Degree of Dynamic Drive (Force Adjustment): “demonstrates ‘the physical and

motivational energy applied in performance of a task’ (1970, p. 10)…Espenak found that

the degree of energy displayed by the patient could indicate the degree to which he can be

challenged by the therapist” (Levy, 2005, p. 47).

Page 18: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 18

3. Test III—Control of Dynamic Drive (Rhythm, Time Concepts): observes the patient’s

sense of time as Espenak relates, “ ‘Control and organization of time reveals both the

individual’s inherent personal rhythm (as a sum total of his personality) as well as his

ability to adjust to any given organization from the outside (i.e. to cooperate). (Espenak,

1970, p. 11)” (Levy, 2005, p. 47). Interestingly, this test focuses on breathing as the

natural rhythm of a person’s life and an indication of inner feelings being entwined with

both physiological and emotional changes in the body (Levy, 2005).

4. Test IV—Coordination (Body-Awareness and Locomotion): tests “the patient’s

movement-flow as indicated in walking…Espenak saw coordination as the physical

expression of the individual’s mental and emotional control. ‘The movement of walking

is…the best natural demonstration of…the interaction of body and mind’ (1970, p. 12)”

(Levy, 2005, p. 47).

5. Test V—Endurance (Constancy): measured the “‘kinesthetic drive combined with mind

control, endurance’ (1970, p. 12). It utilizes various tolerance tests, including the use of

repetitions of movement to determine the patient’s attention span, ability to concentrate

and tolerance for frustration and stress” (Levy, 2005, p. 47).

6. Test VI—Physical Courage (Anxiety States): “measures the patient’s ability to perform

movements that may seem somewhat threatening” (Levy, 2005, p. 47) such as walking

backwards, floor exercises, changing the center of gravity, and rocking backwards.

“Anxieties relating to movement, such as fear of falling or running downstairs, are

closely linked to the fears the patient experiences in everyday life” (Levy, 2005, p. 47).

Liljan Espenak’s legacy. Espenak’s work continues to influence new generations of

therapists. She connected her modern work of therapeutic healing through dance experience and

Page 19: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 19

Adlerian theory integration with the ancient practices of human society “stating that, historically,

it was common to heal the body, mind, and spirit through dance in religious or tribal ceremonies”

(Rossberg-Gempton & Poole, 1992, p. 43). Therapists need to recognize the long-understood

connection of body, mind, and spirit in order to help their clients in the therapeutic process and it

is to this integration that we now turn.

Using Movement in Therapy Sessions

Current research has proven that what we do with our bodies changes our psychological

perception as well as our chemistry (Jun, Roh & Kim, 2013; Kluge, 2014; Lopez, Falconer &

Mast, 2013; Milliken, 2008; Morgan, Irwin, Chung & Wang, 2014; Strassel, 2011; Waller,

Carlson & Englar-Carlson, 2006). Social scientists Amy Cuddy (Harvard Business School) and

Dana Carney (University of California, Berkeley) studied the questions “Do our nonverbals

govern how we think and feel about ourselves?” and “Do our bodies change our minds?” In her

TED Talk (2012), Cuddy reveals the answer is yes to both. Specifically looking at confidence,

Cuddy and Carney had participants do a high-power posture or a low-power posture for two

minutes before doing various tasks. They compared testosterone and cortisol (stress hormone)

levels, as well as risk taking and the participant’s and others’ perception of his or her confidence.

The results were as follows:

Risk tolerance, which is the gambling, what we find is that when you're in the high-power

pose condition, 86 percent of you will gamble. When you're in the low-power pose

condition, only 60 percent, and that's a pretty whopping significant difference. Here's

what we find on testosterone. From their baseline when they come in, high-power people

experience about a 20-percent increase, and low-power people experience about a 10-

percent decrease. So again, two minutes, and you get these changes. Here's what you get

Page 20: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 20

on cortisol. High-power people experience about a 25-percent decrease, and the low-

power people experience about a 15-percent increase. So two minutes lead to these

hormonal changes that configure your brain to basically be either assertive, confident and

comfortable, or really stress-reactive, and, you know, feeling sort of shut down (Cuddy,

2012).

This research and other studies (Cuddy, 2012; Jeong, Hong, Lee, Park, Kim & Sue, 2005;

Johnson & Råheim, 2010; Van Dyck, Vansteenkiste, Lenoir, Lesaffre, & Leman, 2014; Wilkins,

1995) prove what Adler and others like Evan and Espenak already knew: we must look at the

body as well as the mind if we are to be able to heal the whole person. If this is important, the

next question is: How can a therapist who is not trained in DMT be able to connect the mind and

body of his/her clients safely and with relative comfort? Adler believed in baby steps and herein

lies the answer to our question. A commonality between therapist and client is that we all have

bodies and can practice with them. The techniques that I am suggesting are simple and can be

done during a regular therapy session. They techniques are not equivalent to DMT, although

there are some elements akin to it. The techniques are to give the therapist and the client more

information and awareness about healing the whole self.

I strongly encourage therapists who are going to try the techniques to be especially

discerning with whom you want to try the techniques. There are some clients, like those with

whom you do not have an established relationship or one who has been through severe trauma

and needs an expert DMT therapist, which may not respond well to these techniques. Please use

discretion and ethical judgment when trying them out. A client’s well-being is always the

priority.

Page 21: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 21

Individual Techniques

“The try on”: Empathy breathing and body patterns. Empathy is one of Adler’s core

tenets. Espenak noted how important breathing is in understanding a person’s inner state of being

through the Movement Diagnostic Test III: Control of Dynamic Drive (Rhythm, Time Concepts)

(Levy, 2005). Sometimes a client will come to a therapy session in an agitated state with

shallow, rapid breathing and fidgeting indicating a turbulent psyche. A therapist’s inclination

may be to have the client take slow, deep breaths in order to slow down the fight, flight or freeze

response and restore equilibrium so that he/she can verbalize what is going on.

An alternative to this would be to join with the client in his or her breath and movement

pattern in order to really enter into his or her world. Trying on the client’s breathing and body

patterns aids in understanding more deeply what it is like to be in his or her body in the situation

he or she is in (B. Nordstrom-Loeb & P. Sevett, personal communication, March 28, 2014). Janet

Adler’s (no relation to Alfred) work with autistic children in her video “Follow Me” (Expressive

Media, Inc., 2010) especially demonstrates how effective this technique can be in establishing

empathy, unconditional positive regard, and acceptance of a client where he or she is.

Amy Cuddy’s “power poses” (2012): Confidence in self. This technique is what Ms.

Cuddy described in her TED Talk (2012). It is especially useful for clients who are struggling

with self-confidence or are anxious about an upcoming situation such as a job interview or social

event.

In order for the client to feel the connection of body and psyche, observe his or her

current posture as he or she describes the anxiety-producing scenario to you. If he or she is

holding a low-power posture such as shoulders stooped inward, slouching, legs crossed, hand

holding or stroking the neck, gently point out this posture to them. Then, ask he or she to try on a

Page 22: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 22

high-power posture such as both feet on the ground, straightened spine, relaxed arms—with one

draped over another chair or back of couch. Have the client talk about the upcoming situation

from this position for at least two minutes and observe if there is a change in his or her attitude.

Encourage the client to enlist this posture for two minutes in private before he or she enters the

event and then continue the posture while the event happens.

To aid in encouragement and unconditional positive regard for self, an Adlerian twist on

this technique would be to ask the client, “What is a pose that expresses the feelings of

significance, safety, and belonging for you?” (S. Brokaw, personal communication, October 29,

2014).

Doing Power Poses aids not only in bolstering the Adlerian tenet of honoring the intrinsic

value of a person, but also influences a person’s inclination for social interest. Even if a person

feels at first like he or she is “faking it”, eventually, the conditioned confidence can turn into true

confidence and “acting as if” shifts from inferiority or overcompensation in appearing superior to

a healthy balance (Cuddy, 2012; Mosak & Maniacci, 1999). Furthermore, a person with healthier

self-confidence is more inclined to contribute socially.

A variation of this could be used with Early Recollections (ERs). The therapist could

examine the feeling of the most vivid moment through using an action. If the therapist would like

to work with the ER therapeutically, then the therapist can ask the client to change the action into

the feeling he or she would like to have had (Disque & Bitter, 2004).

Couple Techniques

“Living teeter-totter”: Understanding power differentials. This technique helps

couples to understand what power differentials feel like in the body. It could be done in

conjunction with the explanation of the “Teeter-Totter” of a relationship, a visual technique

Page 23: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 23

taught to me by Susan Pye Brokaw (personal communication, October 29, 2014): draw a picture

of a teeter-totter, explaining that the person on the higher end of the teeter-totter acts superior

through criticism and other means to the person on the lower end, resulting in the partnership

being unequal. The goal is to have an equal partnership in the relationship.

For the “Living Teeter-Totter” technique, have one person sit in a chair while the other

person sits on the floor. Then have them switch. Next, have them sit side-by-side and then switch

to sitting across from each other. The final step is to have the couple reflect on what it felt like in

each position, examining what felt the most like a partnership for them. Have them talk about

ways they can bring that into their everyday life together.

The Adlerian tenets of empathy and inferiority/superiority feelings are addressed in a

tangible way through this technique.

“Follow me”: Understanding the other. Couples in crisis often come to therapy in pain

because each partner feels that the other misunderstands them and talking seems to get nowhere.

This technique is about empathy—embodying the others’ feeling. This should be done carefully

and should not be used at all if domestic violence or self-harm is suspected or anticipated by

either partner.

In this technique, the therapist observes and directs nearby, much like Blanche Evan,

Liljan Espenak, or an authentic movement witness would (Wyman-McGinty, 1998). Ask the

couple to sit or stand and face one another about three or four feet apart—so they cannot touch if

they reach toward the other—as if they are on either side of a mirror. Ask each partner what

emotion they are feeling when they are in conflict. When that is clear, have the first partner

create a movement that represents how that emotion feels in their body. Have them do it several

times and as they do so, have the other partner mirror them.

Page 24: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 24

Next, have them pause for a moment and verbalize how that felt. Then, have the second

partner respond with a movement that represents how he or she feels when the first partner did

the initial movement. Again, have the second partner do this several times and have the other

partner mirror them. Pause and reflect verbally. Take a break or stop at any point if the intensity

gets too high.

The next step is to aid in shifting the stagnant dance the couple has been doing around the

issue. Ask the first partner to create a movement of what he or she would like to feel when

talking about the conflict issue. Again, have the second partner mirror this movement as they do

it together several times. Have them pause for a moment to verbalize how it felt. Then repeat the

process with the second partner taking the lead.

After reflection, ask the couple to create a movement that would express finding a joint

solution. It could be a movement that had elements of the previous movements or a brand new

one. The couple needs to do this while mirroring each other with minimum verbal

communication and no physical contact.

If the couple does not find a rhythm or movement that the therapist can tell is working

after a few minutes, it is fine to stop and reflect on what was not working. This will give the

therapist insight into the root of the conflict. If the couple does find a rhythm or movement that

works, the therapist may ask how that movement could be translated into resolution of the

conflict.

The couple benefits from embodying each other’s emotions to develop empathy.

Mirroring, as used in this technique, connects the couple in overt and covert ways, building new

channels of communication that get the couple physically and emotionally turning toward each

other instead of away (Gottman, 2000).

Page 25: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 25

Group Technique

“Remember me”: Movement and naming. This technique is reminiscent of camp and

youth group icebreakers, but it has a therapeutic twist. It is simple and promotes the Adlerian

tenets of self-expression, social interest, encouragement, humor, and empathy, as well as gives

insight for the therapist into the group he or she is working with.

As the group gathers, have people stand and form a large circle facing inward. Use a

small, soft ball or other object as a talking stick, and if you do not have one then you can

pantomime throwing a ball to the next person. Whoever holds the ball (real or imagined), holds

the floor. It is most helpful if the therapist demonstrates what he or she wants done.

This is an introduction game. The therapist starts by saying his or her own name (or what

he or she would like to be called in this setting), creating a movement that represents him or her

and then answers any other introductory questions he or she wants others to answer before

closing with repeating his or her name and doing his or her movement again. When the therapist

is done, he or she gently tosses (or pretend to toss) the ball to a person at random (no need to go

to the right or the left unless one wishes to) to go next.

The next person says the previous person’s name and does his or her movement. Then he

or she repeats the process the previous person did by saying his or her own name with a

movement, answering questions, repeating the name and movement, and then closing with the

previous person’s name and movement. He or she gently tosses the ball to the next person and

the process repeats itself.

The expectation is to only name the person previous to you and try on his or her

movement. There is no need to name every person and movement who has gone before, although

it could be a fun quiz when everyone is finished. Keeping it to one person does two things: it

Page 26: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 26

makes an immediate connection with at least two people in the group (the one previous and after)

and it allows for a person to succeed in remembering at least one name.

The therapist observes the type of group he or she is working with. The verbal answers

give cues, but the movement a person chooses also gives something away about their lifestyle.

For example, X says her name and puts her hands on her head like ears while saying, “Meow”; Y

says his name and beats his chest like Tarzan; and Z says her name and merely raises an ironic

eyebrow. What might each of these movements say about his or her lifestyle? There could be

several hunches for each. Movement never lies and can give a therapist an immediate clue to

what might be in store for the session.

A final benefit to this technique is the humor that it brings. Everyone is in the same

awkward position and there will no doubt be at least one or two people who create an amusing

movement. This adds levity to the group, releases nervous energy, and begins to build trust for

the rest of the session.

Implementation and Summary of Outcome for the Project

Description of Project Implemented

A two-hour, interactive workshop was implemented on Friday, November 7, 2014, 7:30-

9:30 pm, for the Puget Sound Adlerian Society’s First Friday Forum, held at St. Stephen’s

Episcopal Church, Seattle, Washington. It was filmed for educational purposes and open to the

community, although the target population was for others going to school for or working in a

mental health field. All participants signed a waiver giving permission to be recorded.

The workshop explored the historic background of overlooked Adlerians, Blanche Evan

and Liljan Espenak, who used their Adlerian training and dance background in their therapeutic

Page 27: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 27

processes that pioneered what became Dance/Movement Therapy. The presentation also

explained Adler’s thoughts on how the body affected the psyche as well as psychosomatic issues.

Additionally, the workshop gave participants some basic physical movement techniques

to utilize in their practice with individuals, couples, and groups to enhance Adlerian principles

such as trust, encouragement, holism, and social interest. The participants had ample opportunity

to try these techniques out with a partner and discuss them.

The workshop included a PowerPoint presentation, handouts, and a reference list. The

film of the presentation is one hour, thirty-eight minutes long, as we did not film all of the time

where participants were trying out the techniques.

Summary of Outcome

Personal evaluation. I felt supported by the local Adlerian community in agreeing to

host my Master’s Project presentation as one of their educational First Friday Forums. I spent

almost every minute of free time for over a month researching, writing, organizing, advertising

for, and creating this two-hour presentation. As a result, I felt that I knew the material well and

felt confident in my presentation.

I was fortunate to have a group that was eager to learn and wanted to participate. I was

aware that a few people were out of their comfort zone and I made efforts to put them at ease.

The opening group introduction exercise helped everyone relax some and feel connected as a

group, including myself.

The atmosphere of the First Friday Forums is typically informal, relaxed, conversational,

as well as educational, so I was aiming to hold that space. My pacing through the slides felt

good. I do not normally read slides when I present, but in this case I read some of them because a

few participants could not see them clearly from where they were sitting.

Page 28: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 28

I tend to be bubbly and energetic and know that sometimes if I laugh too much or am too

casual, that this can be perceived that I should not be taken seriously. There were a few times

when I slipped up in holding that tension, but I went right back into the space I was trying to

attain. It was useful to watch the video afterward to become more aware of when this happened

and remember what I was feeling or thinking in that moment. I discovered that those were the

times I was trying too hard to connect and make the information more interesting delivery-wise

or I was starting to get tired.

The times when I felt most comfortable and engaged were when I was teaching the

techniques. I really enjoyed sharing the techniques, coaching the participants as they tried them,

and hearing their reflections on how they felt doing them as well as how they saw themselves

applying them to their own practices. The interactive teaching was the most rewarding part of the

whole project—sharing my knowledge and knowing it was helping others was energizing. I felt

my personal outcomes were achieved.

Participants’ evaluation. There were eleven participants, in addition to my husband who

was filming. Ten out of the eleven filled out the “Adler Graduate School Evaluation of Master’s

Project Presentation” form anonymously and I received an email from one of the participants

later with further reflection. The general results of the evaluation were extremely positive.

Specifically, the feedback for each of the seven elements evaluated were as follows:

1. Was well prepared for the presentation: eight marked “Strongly Agree” and two marked

one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

2. Presented information in a clear and organized manner: six marked “Strongly Agree” and

four marked one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

Page 29: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 29

3. Demonstrated a thorough knowledge and understanding of content: eight marked

“Strongly Agree” and two marked one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

4. Encouraged discussions and questions: nine marked “Strongly Agree” and one marked

one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

5. Brought new knowledge useful in work and personal life: eight marked “Strongly Agree”

and two marked one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

6. Shared/demonstrated skills that can be used with a target population or target issue: seven

marked “strongly agree,” two marked one box to the right of “strongly agree,” and one

marked two boxes to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

7. Overall, demonstrated master’s level quality of work: eight marked “Strongly Agree” and

two marked one box to the right of “Strongly Agree.”

8. Additional Comments: “Well done and interesting.” “So wonderful—thank you!” “Very

illuminating! I had no idea there even was dance therapy, movement therapy or that these

were associated with Adler Studies. Wow! Excellent presentation with very comfortable

exercises to get us out of our comfort zones! Opened my eyes to some new ways to get

clients out of their heads and into their hearts!” “Amazing work. You are clearly

dedicated to movement/Adlerian therapy.” “Loved the enthusiasm!”

Improvements based on outcome. The energy from the participants was positive, open,

and engaged. It was energizing presenting to them and practicing the techniques with them.

Based on the feedback, the learning objectives for this workshop were realized by the

participants. However, there is always room for improvement. Now that I have been through

presenting a couple of times, there are places where I could relax and not try as hard to be

Page 30: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 30

engaging, trusting the process of teaching and the participant’s willingness to learn. I could also

add a few slides to highlight some of the verbal information I was teaching.

Future Plans for Use of the Project

This Master’s Project has a little something for everyone: intellectual information

presented verbally, visually, and interactively, as well as concrete techniques that can be used in

every day practice. I would like to share this at a North American Society of Adlerian

Psychology (NASAP) gathering, as well as any regional Adlerian societies or schools that are

interested in learning about the Adlerian connections to DMT.

Conclusion

Adler’s law of movement has been at work throughout this Project. Delving deeply into

the subject matter engaged me on both personal and professional levels—challenging me and

moving me to grow as a person and a therapist. The unique legacies of Blanche Evan and Liljan

Espenak and their contributions to Adlerian theory and DMT continue to intrigue me and I look

forward to learning more about the importance of movement in therapy in the future. Alfred

Adler’s legacy continues on into the 21st century and I am glad to be part of it.

Page 31: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 31

References

Adler, A. (1917). Study of organ inferiority and its psychical compensation: A contribution to

clinical medicine. New York, NY: Nervous & Mental Diseases Publishing Company.

Adler, A. (1964). The individual psychology of Alfred Adler: A systematic presentation in

selections from his writings (H. L. Ansbacher & R. R. Ansbacher, Eds.). New York, NY:

HarperPerennial.

Adler, A. (1996). The structure of neurosis. Individual Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian

Theory, Research & Practice, 52(4), 351-362.

Alperson, E. D. (1974). Carrying experiencing forward through authentic body movement.

Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, 11(3), 211-214. doi:10.1037/h0086341

Ansbacher, H. L. (1982). Alfred Adler's views on the unconscious. Individual Psychology: The

Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice, 38(1), 32.

Ansbacher, H. L. (1992). Alfred Adler, pioneer in prevention of mental disorders. Individual

Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice, 48(1), 3-34.

Ansbacher, H. & Ansbacher, R. (1979). Superiority and social interest (Rev. ed.). New York,

NY: Norton.

Ávila, L. A. (2010). Psychosomatic symptoms and the 'group mind'. Psychology &

Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice, 83(3), 255-271.

doi:10.1348/147608309X481126

Bagby, E. (1923). The inferiority reaction. The Journal of Abnormal Psychology and Social

Psychology, 18(3), 269-273. doi:10.1037/h0066946

Bartenieff, I. (1983). Body movement: Coping with the environment. New York, NY: Gordon

and Breach Science Publishers.

Page 32: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 32

Benov, R. G. (Ed.). (1991). Collected works by and about Blanche Evan, Unedited. New York,

NY: Blanche Evan Dance Foundation.

Bernstein, B. (2005, October). Dance/movement/word therapy: Blanche Evan and the language

of self discovery. Presentation at the 40th Annual American Dance Therapy Association

Conference: American Rhythms/International Rhythms: Dance/Movement Therapy

Practice and Research, Nashville, TN. doi:10.1037/e501682014-001

Blom, L. A. & Chaplin, L. T. (1988). The moment of movement dance improvisation. London,

UK: Dance Books Ltd.

Boris, R. (2001). The root of dance therapy: A consideration of movement, dancing, and

verbalization vis-à-vis dance/movement therapy. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 21(3), 356-367.

doi:10.1080/07351692109348940

Capen, K. (2006). Review of expressive therapies. Clinical Social Work Journal, 34(3), 397-399.

doi:10.1007/s10615-006-0047-3

Chvála, V., Trapková, L., & Skorunka, D. (2012). Social uterus: A developmental concept in

family therapy for psychosomatic disorders. Contemporary Family Therapy: An

International Journal, 34(2), 293-312. doi:10.1007/s10591-012-9197-3

Ciotola, L. (2006). The body dialogue: An action intervention to build body empathy. Journal

of Group Psychotherapy, Psychodrama & Sociometry (15453855), 59(1), 35-38.

Clark, A. J., & Butler, C. M. (2012). Degree of activity: Relationship to early recollections and

safeguarding tendencies. Journal Of Individual Psychology, 68(2), 136-147.

Coleman, R. L., & Croake, J. W. (1987). Organ inferiority and measured overcompensation.

Individual Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice, 43(3),

364-369.

Page 33: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 33

Cuddy, A. J. C. (2012, June). Amy J. Cuddy: Your body language shapes who you are

[Video file]. Retrieved from

http://www.ted.com/talks/amy_cuddy_your_body_language_shapes_who_you_ar

e/transcript?language=en

Degges-White, S. & Davis, N. L. (2011). Integrating the expressive arts into counseling

practice: Theory-based interventions. New York, NY: Springer Publishing Company.

Disque, J., & Bitter, J. (2004). Emotion, experience, and early recollections: Exploring

restorative reorientation processes in Adlerian therapy. The Journal of Individual

Psychology, 60(2), 115-131.

Dushman, R. D. & Sutherland, J. (1997). An Adlerian perspective on dreamwork and creative

therapies. Individual Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research, & Practice,

53(4), 461-475.

Ernst, E., Rand, J. I., & Stevinson, C. (1998). Complementary therapies for depression: An

overview. Archives of General Psychiatry, 55(11), 1026-1032.

doi:10.1001/archpsyc.55.11.1026

Espenak, L. (1981). Dance therapy: Theory and application. Springfield, IL: Charles C. Thomas,

Publisher.

Evan, B. (1964). The child’s world: Its relation to dance pedagogy. New York, NY: St. Mark’s

Editions.

Expressive Media, Inc. (2010 July 4). Looking for me (Janet Adler) [Video file]. Retrieved from

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FsRfMm7DCww

Fennell, M., & Segal, Z. (2011). Mindfulness-based cognitive therapy: Culture clash or creative

fusion? Contemporary Buddhism, 12(1), 125-142. doi:10.1080/14639947.2011.564828

Page 34: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 34

Gottman, J. (2000). The seven principles for making marriage work. New York, NY: Harmony.

Guttenberg, R. & Gordon-Rosen, M. (2013). “So, where does it hurt?”: An Adlerian dialogue

on pain. Journal of Individual Psychology, 69(2), 133-142.

Gyllensten, A. L., Skär, L., Miller, M., & Gard, G. (2010). Embodied identity—A deeper

understanding of body awareness. Physiotherapy Theory & Practice, 26(7), 439-446.

doi:10.3109/09593980903422956

Jeong, Y-J., Hong, S-C., Lee, M. S., Park, M-C., Kim, Y-K., Suh, C-M. (2005). Dance

movement therapy improves emotional responses and modulates neurohormones in

adolescents with mild depression. International Journal of Neuroscience, 115(12),

1711-1720. doi: 10.1080/00207450590958574

Johnsen, R. W., & Råheim, M. (2010). Feeling more in balance and grounded in one's own body

and life. Focus group interviews on experiences with basic body awareness therapy in

psychiatric healthcare. Advances In Physiotherapy, 12(3), 166-174.

doi:10.3109/14038196.2010.501383

Jun, E., Roh, Y. H., & Kim, M. J. (2013). The effect of music-movement therapy on physical and

psychological states of stroke patients. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 22(1/2), 22-31.

doi:10.1111/j.1365-2702.2012.04243.x

Kluge, M. A. (2014). Music, movement, and mood: Health promotion classes boost well-being

and create social bonds. Generations – Journal of the American Society on Aging,

38(1), 31-34.

Kopp, R. R. (1989). Holistic-metaphorical therapy and Adlerian brief psychotherapy. Individual

Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice, 45(1/2),

57-61.

Page 35: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 35

Kradin, R. L. (2011). Psychosomatic disorders: The canalization of mind into matter. Journal of

Analytical Psychology, 56(1), 37-55. doi:10.1111/j.1468-5922.2010.01889.x

L’Abate, L. (2013). Review of creative family therapy techniques: Play, art, and expressive

activities to engage children in family sessions. American Journal of Family Therapy,

41(3), 275-276. doi:10.1080/01926187.2012.688008

Leseho, J. & Maxwell, L. R. (2010). Coming alive: Creative movement as a personal coping

strategy on the path to healing and growth. British Journal of Guidance & Counselling,

38(1), 17-30. doi: 10.1080/03069880903411301

Levy, F. J. (Ed.) (2005). Dance movement therapy: A healing art. Reston, VA: National Dance

Association.

Lichtman, C. (2010). Psychosomatic medicine: A psychoanalyst's journey through a somatic

world. Psychoanalytic Inquiry, 30(5), 380-389. doi:10.1080/07351690.2010.482386

Lopez, C., Falconer, C. J., & Mast, F. W. (2013). Being moved by the self and others: Influence

of empathy on self-motion perception. Plos ONE, 8(1), 1-9.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0048293

Milliken, R. (2008). Intervening in the cycle of addiction, violence, and shame: A

dance/movement therapy group approach in a jail addictions program. Journal of Groups

In Addiction & Recovery, 3(1-2), 5-22. doi:10.1080/15560350802157346

Morgan, N., Irwin, M. R., Chung, M., & Wang, C. (2014). The effects of mind-body therapies

on the Immune System: Meta-Analysis. Plos ONE, 9(7), 1-14.

doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0100903

Mosak, H. & Maniacci, M. (1999). A primer of Adlerian psychology. New York, NY: Routledge.

Page 36: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 36

Mosak, H. H., & Rasmussen, P. R. (2002). Dance as metaphor of the psychotherapeutic

encounter. The Journal of Individual Psychology, 58(2), 109-121.

Mozdzierz, G. J. (1996). Adler's `what is neurosis?': Clinical and predictive revelations from the

past. Individual Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice,

52(4), 342-350.

Najarian, C. (2008, October). Creative dance for children: Utilizing the methods of Blanche

Evan. Presentation at the 43rd Annual American Dance Therapy Association Conference:

Dance/Movement Therapy for a Diverse Society: Evidence and Ideas, Austin, Texas.

doi:10.1037/e511322014-001

Nash, E. M., & Nash, J. K. (2010). Individual psychology and individual differences in

psychophysiology. Journal of Individual Psychology, 66(3), 253-269.

Nemetz, L. D. (1995). Dance/movement therapy: Speaking the language of self. International

Journal of Arts Medicine, 4(2), 26-31.

Obuchowski, K. (1988). Alfred Adler: Precursor of humanistic psychology. Individual

Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice, 44(3), 263-269.

Overholser, J. C. (2010). Psychotherapy that strives to encourage social interest: A simulated

interview with Alfred Adler. Journal of Psychotherapy Integration, 20(4), 347-363.

doi:10.1037/a0022033

Panhofer, H. (2011). Language and non-languaged ways of knowing in counselling and

psychotherapy. British Journal of Guidance & Counselling, 39(5), 455-470.

Parviainen, J. (2003). Kinaesthetic empathy. Dialogue & Universalism, 13(11/12), 151-162.

Paul, A. M. (2011, July). Annie Murphy Paul: What we learn before we’re born [Video file].

Retrieved from

Page 37: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 37

http://www.ted.com/talks/annie_murphy_paul_what_we_learn_before_we_re_born/trans

cript?language=en

Rossberg-Gempton, I. & Poole, G. (1992). The relationship between body movement and affect:

From historical and current perspectives. The Arts in Psychotherapy, 19, 39-46.

Sommers-Flanagan, J. (2007). The development and evolution of person-centered expressive art

therapy: A conversation with Natalie Rogers. Journal of Counseling & Development,

85(1), 120-125. doi:10.1002/j.1556-6678.2007.tb00454.x

Sperry, L. (1996). Adler's conception of neurosis in the contemporary treatment of personality

disorders. Individual Psychology: The Journal of Adlerian Theory, Research & Practice,

52(4), 372-377.

Sperry, L. (2011). Psychosomatic medicine today: Adlerian contributions. Journal of Individual

Psychology, 67(1), 73-82.

Stone, M. H. (2014). The golden complex. Journal of Individual Psychology, 70(1), 76-85.

Strassel, J. M. (2011). A systematic review of the evidence for the effectiveness of dance

therapy. Alternative Therapies in Health & Medicine, 17(3), 50-59.

Tremain, H. (2013). The mind-body nexus. Journal of the Australian Traditional-Medicine

Society, 19(1), 38.

Van Dyck, E., Vansteenkiste, P., Lenoir, M., Lesaffre, M., Leman, M. (2014) Recognizing

induced emotions of happiness and sadness from dance movement. Plos ONE 9(2):

e89773. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0089773

Vande Kemp, H. (2000). Wholeness, holiness, and the care of souls: The Adler-Jahn debate in

historical perspective. Journal of Individual Psychology, 56(3), 242.

Waller, B., Carlson, J., & Englar-Carlson, M. (2006). Treatment and relapse prevention of

Page 38: Running head: LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY … Ashley MP 2014.pdfLET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 7 encouragement, understanding that each behavior has a purpose,

LET’S GET PHYSICAL!: ADLERIAN BODY MOVEMENT 38

depression using mindfulness-based cognitive therapy and Adlerian concepts. Journal

of Individual Psychology, 62(4), 443-454.

Wilkins, P. (1995). A creative therapies model for the group supervision of counsellors. British

Journal of Guidance & Counselling, 23(2), 245-257. doi:10.1080/03069889500760251

Wyman-McGinty, W. (1998). The body in analysis: Authentic movement and witnessing in

analytic practice. The Journal of Analytical Psychology, 43(2), 239-260.

doi:10.1111/1465-5922.00023