read the study online

31
ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PERSPECTIVES ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH PERSPECTIVES National Institutes of Health U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Prenatal Exposure to Airborne Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons and Children’s Intelligence at Age 5 in a Prospective Cohort Study in Poland Susan Claire Edwards, Wieslaw Jedrychowski, Maria Butscher, David Camann, Agnieszka Kieltyka, Elzbieta Mroz, Elzbieta Flak, Zhigang Li, Shuang Wang, Virginia Rauh, and Frederica Perera doi: 10.1289/ehp.0901070 (available at http://dx.doi.org/) Online 20 April 2010 ehponline.org ehp

Upload: nguyenphuc

Post on 11-Jan-2017

237 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Read the study online

ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH PERSPECTIVES

ENVIRONMENTALHEALTH PERSPECTIVES

National Institutes of HealthU.S. Department of Health and Human Services

Prenatal Exposure to Airborne Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons and Children’s Intelligence at Age 5 in a

Prospective Cohort Study in Poland

Susan Claire Edwards, Wieslaw Jedrychowski, Maria Butscher, David Camann, Agnieszka Kieltyka,

Elzbieta Mroz, Elzbieta Flak, Zhigang Li, Shuang Wang, Virginia Rauh, and Frederica Perera

doi: 10.1289/ehp.0901070 (available at http://dx.doi.org/)Online 20 April 2010

ehponline.org

ehp

Page 2: Read the study online

!"#$%&%

%

%

!'$(")"*%+,-./0'$%).%12'3.'($%!.*4545*25%1'.6")25%748'.5"'3.(/%"(8%9:2*8'$(;/%<()$**2#$(5$%")%

1#$%=%2(%"%!'./-$5)2>$%9.:.')%?)084%2(%!.*"(8%

%

?0/"(%9*"2'$%+8@"'8/%&A%B2$/*"@%C$8'45:.@/D2%

EA%F"'2"%G0)/5:$'%

HA%I">28%9"6"((%

JA%1#(2$/KD"%

L2$*)4D"%EA%+*K32$)"%F'.K%

EA%+*K32$)"%M*"D%

EA%N:2#"(#%O2%

&A%=A%?:0"(#%B"(#%

&A%=A%P2'#2(2"%Q"0:

&ARA%

M'$8$'25"%!$'$'"%&S%

%

&%9.*0632"%9$()$'%T.'%9:2*8'$(;/%+(>2'.(6$()"*%7$"*):A%F"2*6"(%?5:..*%.T%!03*25%7$"*):A%

9.*0632"%U(2>$'/2)4A%V$@%W.'DA%VWX%E%I$-"')6$()%.T%+-28$62.*.#4%"(8%!'$>$()2>$%F$8252($A%

C"#2$**.(2"(%U(2>$'/2)4A%L'"D.@A%!.*"(8X%H%!.*2/:Y16$'25"(%<(/)2)0)$%.T%!$82")'25/A%C"#2$**.(2"(%

U(2>$'/2)4A%L'"D.@A%!.*"(8X%J%I$-"')6$()%.T%1("*4)25"*%"(8%+(>2'.(6$()"*%9:$62/)'4A%

?.0):@$/)%Q$/$"'5:%<(/)2)0)$A%?"(%1().(2.A%Z[X%=%I$-"')6$()%.T%G2./)")2/)25/A%F"2*6"(%?5:..*%

.T%!03*25%7$"*):A%9.*0632"%U(2>$'/2)4A%V$@%W.'DA%VWX%R%I$-"')6$()%.T%!.-0*")2.(%"(8%M"62*4%

7$"*):A%F"2*6"(%?5:..*%.T%!03*25%7$"*):%

S%9.''$/-.(82(#%"0):.'%%

9.*0632"%U(2>$'/2)4A%&\\%7">$(%1>$(0$A%Z.@$'%<<<A%/02)$%E=MA%V$@%W.'DA%VW&\\HEA%U?1A%

-:.($]%^E&E_%H\J`aEb\A%T",]%^E&E_%=JJ`&cJH%

!

15D(.@*$8#$6$()/%

B$%#'")$T0**4%"5D(.@*$8#$%C$((2T$'%1'($4%T.'%:$'%"//2/)"(5$%2(%):$%-'$-"'")2.(%.T%):2/%

6"(0/5'2-)d%

Page 1 of 30

Page 3: Read the study online

!"#$%E%

%

!'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%"(8%5:2*8%<e%")%"#$%=%4$"'/%

%

1')25*$%8$/5'2-).'/]%9:2*8'$(;/%:$"*):A%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()%

%

12'%-.**0)2.(A%5:2*8A%8$>$*.-6$()A%$(>2'.(6$()"*A%+Z?A%!"#$%&'(A%2()$**2#$(5$A%-'$(")"*A%!.*"(8A%

Q">$(%%

%

Z:2/%/)084%'$5$2>$8%T0(82(#%T'.6%):$%V<+7?%^&Q\&+?\&\&R=`\&_A%):$%f*"84/%Zd%"(8%Q.*"(8%

7"''26"(%M.0(8")2.(A%"(8%"(.(46.0/%-'2>")$%8.(.'/d%B$%@.0*8%*2D$%).%):"(D%):$%Ud?d%9$()$'/%

T.'%I2/$"/$%9.()'.*%"(8%!'$>$()2.(%2(%1)*"()"A%f1A%T.'%):$2'%"("*4/2/%.T%5.)2(2($A%6$)"*/A%"(8%

!17%6$)"3.*2)$%*$>$*/%2(%/"6-*$/%T'.6%):2/%5.:.')d%

%

Z:$'$%"'$%(.%5.6-$)2(#%2()$'$/)/d%

%

!17% -.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(%

+Z?% $(>2'.(6$()"*%).3"55.%/6.D$%

VW9% V$@%W.'D%92)4%

<e% 2()$**2#$(5$%g0.)2$()%

Q9!F% Q">$(%9.*.0'$8%!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%

B!!?<`Q% B$5:/*$'%!'$/5:..*%"(8%!'26"'4%?5"*$%.T%<()$**2#$(5$YQ$>2/$8%

ZhV<`H% Z$/)%.T%V.(>$'3"*%<()$**2#$(5$`Z:2'8%$82)2.(%

7hF+%<(>$().'4% 7.6$%h3/$'>")2.(%T.'%F$"/0'$6$()%.T%):$%+(>2'.(6$()%<(>$().'4%

Page 2 of 30

Page 4: Read the study online

!"#$%H%

%

13/)'"5)%%

<()'.805)2.(%%

F")$'2"*/%"(8%F$):.8/%%

)'*+(,#-%$./#0(1$2*%!("#

0'&"*%*2#3"%&'4!&,%%

0&'5("*2#6!'#7("!%('!"8%

9!(2(8!:*2#-*;12&#<(22&:%!("#*".#6"*2/5&5%

=&$'(.&4&2(1;&"%*2#>&5%!"8#

7(.&2#*".#:(4*'!*%&5#

Q$/0*)/%%

I2/50//2.(%%

Q$T$'$(5$/%%

Z"3*$/%

%

Page 3 of 30

Page 5: Read the study online

!"#$%J%

%

"#$%&'(%!!

9*:+8'($".?#%Z:2/%-'./-$5)2>$%5.:.')%/)084%.T%9"05"/2"(%6.):$'/%"(8%5:2*8'$(%2(%

L'"D.@A%!.*"(8A%$>"*0")$8%):$%'.*$%.T%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%0'3"(%"2'%-.**0)"()/%2(%):$%

-"):.#$($/2/%.T%($0'.3$:">2.'"*%82/.'8$'/d%%

@AB&:%!4&5?%%Z:$%.3i$5)2>$%.T%):2/%/)084%@"/%).%2(>$/)2#")$%):$%'$*")2.(/:2-%3$)@$$(%

-'$(")"*%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(%^!17_%$,-./0'$%"(8%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%")%"#$%=%4$"'/A%

5.()'.**2(#%T.'%-.)$()2"*%5.(T.0(8$'/%/0/-$5)$8%).%-*"4%"%'.*$%2(%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()d%%

7&%C(.5?#%1%5.:.')%.T%-'$#("()A%:$"*):4A%(.(`/6.D2(#%@.6$(%@"/%$('.**$8%2(%L'"D.@A%

!.*"(8A%3$)@$$(%E\\&%"(8%E\\Rd%I0'2(#%-'$#("(54A%-"')252-"()/%@$'$%2(>2)$8%).%5.6-*$)$%"%

g0$/)2.(("2'$%"(8%0(8$'#.%Jb`:.0'%-$'/.("*%"2'%6.(2).'2(#%).%$/)26")$%):$2'%3"32$/;%$,-./0'$A%

"(8%).%-'.>28$%"%3*..8%/"6-*$%"(8j.'%"%5.'8%3*..8%/"6-*$%")%):$%)26$%.T%8$*2>$'4d%Z@.%:0(8'$8%

"(8%T.0')$$(%5:2*8'$(%@$'$%T.**.@$8%):'.0#:%"#$%=%4$"'/%@:$(%):$2'%(.(>$'3"*%'$"/.(2(#%"32*2)4%

@"/%"//$//$8%0/2(#%):$%Q">$(%9.*.0'$8%!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%^Q9!F_d%#

D&5$2%5?%%B$%T.0(8%):")%:2#:$'%^"3.>$%):$%6$82"(%.T%&adcR%(#j6H_%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%

"2'3.'($%!17/%^'"(#$]%&db`EaEdE%(#j6H_%@"/%"//.52")$8%@2):%8$5'$"/$8%Q9!F%/5.'$/%")%"#$%=%

4$"'/A%"T)$'%"8i0/)2(#%T.'%-.)$()2"*%5.(T.0(82(#%>"'2"3*$/%^VkE&J_d%M0'):$'%"8i0/)2(#%T.'%6")$'("*%

2()$**2#$(5$A%*$"8%.'%82$)"'4%!17/%828%(.)%"*)$'%):2/%"//.52")2.(d%Z:$%'$805)2.(%2(%Q9!F%/5.'$%

"//.52")$8%@2):%:2#:%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%5.''$/-.(8$8%).%"(%$/)26")$8%">$'"#$%8$5'$"/$%.T%

Hdb%<e%-.2()/d%%

<(":2$5!("5?#%Z:$/$%'$/0*)/%/0##$/)%):")%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%!17/%"8>$'/$*4%

"TT$5)/%5:2*8'$(;/%5.#(2)2>$%8$>$*.-6$()%34%=%4$"'/%.T%"#$A%@2):%-.)$()2"*%26-*25")2.(/%T.'%/5:..*%

-$'T.'6"(5$d%Z:$4%"'$%5.(/2/)$()%@2):%"%'$5$()%T2(82(#%2(%"%-"'"**$*%5.:.')%2(%V$@%W.'D%92)4d%%

Page 4 of 30

Page 6: Read the study online

!"#$%=%

%

)*%&+,-(%.+*!

!.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%^!17/_A%/05:%"/%3$(K.l"m-4'$($A%"'$%032g02).0/%"2'%

-.**0)"()/%'$*$"/$8%).%"632$()%"(8%2(8..'%"2'%T'.6%5.630/)2.(%/.0'5$/A%/05:%"/%5."*%30'(2(#%

-.@$'%-*"()/A%82$/$*%"(8%#"/.*2($`-.@$'$8%>$:25*$/A%:.6$%:$")2(#%"(8%5..D2(#A%"(8%"'$%-'$/$()%

2(%).3"55.%/6.D$%"(8%5:"''$8%T..8/%^1Z?IQ%&cc=_d%9."*%30'(2(#%-.@$'%-*"()/A%:.6$%:$")2(#A%

)'"TT25%$62//2.(/A%"(8%/$5.(8%:"(8%/6.D$%"'$%):$%6"2(%5.()'230).'/%).%"2'3.'($%!17%*$>$*/%2(%

!.*"(8%^9:.2%$)%"*d%E\\R_d%

F"(4%/)082$/%2(825")$%):")%):$%T$)0/%"(8%2(T"()%"'$%6.'$%/$(/2)2>$%):"(%"80*)/%).%

$(>2'.(6$()"*%).,25"()/%2(5*082(#%!17/A%*$"8A%-$/)2528$/A%"(8%$(>2'.(6$()"*%).3"55.%/6.D$%

^+Z?_A%3$5"0/$%8$).,2T25")2.(%"(8%IV1%'$-"2'%/4/)$6/%"'$%266")0'$%"(8%'")$/%.T%5$**%

-'.*2T$'")2.(%"'$%2(5'$"/$8%^VQ9%&ccH3X%!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\=X%B:4"))%"(8%!$'$'"%&cc=X%B.'*8%

7$"*):%h'#"(2K")2.(%&cbR_d%%Z:$%5$()'"*%($'>.0/%/4/)$6%2/%-"')250*"'*4%>0*($'"3*$%80'2(#%

-'$(")"*%8$>$*.-6$()%^Q.82$'%E\\J_d%!17/%'$"82*4%5'.//%):$%-*"5$()"%^V$03$')%"(8%Z"-D$(%

&cbbX%!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\H_%%

!17/%:">$%3$$(%/:.@(%).%3$%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()"*%).,25"()/%2(%$,-$'26$()"*%/)082$/%

^?"0(8$'/%$)%"*d%E\\RX%?'"6%"(8%G2(D.>"%E\\\X%B.'6*$4%$)%"*d%E\\J_d%1*):.0#:%):$%-'$52/$%

6$5:"(2/6/%34%@:25:%):$4%62#:)%"TT$5)%):$%8$>$*.-2(#%3'"2(%"'$%(.)%D(.@(A%/0##$/)$8%

6$5:"(2/6/%2(5*08$%$(8.5'2($%82/'0-)2.(%^1'5:23.(#%$)%"*d%E\\EX%G02%$)%"*d%&cbRX%Z"D$8"%$)%"*d%

E\\J_A%32(82(#%).%-*"5$()"*%#'.@):%T"5).'%'$5$-).'/%^I$i6$D%$)%"*d%E\\\_A%32(82(#%).%):$%:06"(%

1:%'$5$-).'%).%2(805$%!J=\%$(K46$/%^F"(5:$/)$'%$)%"*d%&cba_A%IV1%8"6"#$%'$/0*)2(#%2(%

"5)2>")2.(%.T%"-.-).)25%-"):@"4/%^F$)K$'%$)%"*d%&cc=X%V25.*%$)%"*d%&cc=X%B..8%"(8%W.0*$%&cc=_A%

"(8%.,28")2>$%/)'$//%^?"0(8$'/%$)%"*d%E\\R_d%<(%"882)2.(A%-'$(")"*%!17%$,-./0'$/%6"4%"TT$5)%

Page 5 of 30

Page 7: Read the study online

!"#$%R%

%

$-2#$($)25%-'.#'"662(#%@2):%($0'.*.#25"*%5.(/$g0$(5$/%^G"'D$'%E\\JX%!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\c"X%

?5:@"')K%E\\JX%B2*/.(%"(8%C.($/%&cbH_d%%

1%-'./-$5)2>$%5.:.')%/)084%.T%1T'25"(`16$'25"(%"(8%O")2("%6.):$'/%"(8%5:2*8'$(%2(%V$@%

W.'D%92)4%^VW9_%):")%-"'"**$*/%):$%-'$/$()%/)084%:"/%'$-.')$8%):")%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%

!17/%2/%/2#(2T25"()*4%"//.52")$8%@2):%8$>$*.-6$()"*%8$*"4%")%"#$%H%4$"'/%"/%6$"/0'$8%34%):$%

G"4*$4%?5"*$/%.T%<(T"()%I$>$*.-6$()%^VQ9%&ccH"X%!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\R_%"(8%'$805$8%<e%")%"#$%=%

4$"'/%34%):$%B$5:/*$'%!'$/5:..*%"(8%!'26"'4%?5"*$%.T%<()$**2#$(5$YQ$>2/$8%^B!!?<`Q_%^!$'$'"%

$)%"*d%E\\c3_d%<(%*2#:)%.T%):2/%$>28$(5$%.T%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()"*%$TT$5)/%2(%"%60*)2`$):(25%VW9%

-.-0*")2.(A%):$%-'$/$()%"("*4/2/%$>"*0")$8%):$%$TT$5)/%.T%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%.(%"%

6$"/0'$%.T%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%2(%"%9"05"/2"(%-.-0*")2.(d%

%%

/'%0&.'1$!'*,!/0%2+,$!

)'*+(,#-%$./#0(1$2*%!("?##Z:2/%/)084%2/%-"')%.T%"(%.(#.2(#A%*.(#2)082("*%2(>$/)2#")2.(%.T%

):$%:$"*):%$TT$5)/%.T%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%.0)8..'%"(8%2(8..'%"2'%-.**0)2.(%.(%2(T"()/%"(8%5:2*8'$(%

2(%L'"D.@A%!.*"(8d%1/%8$/5'23$8%-'$>2.0/*4%^C$8'45:.@/D2%$)%"*d%E\\J_A%$*2#232*2)4%5'2)$'2"%

2(5*08$8]%n%&b%4$"'/%.T%"#$%(.(`/6.D2(#%@.6$(%@2):%/2(#*$).(%-'$#("(52$/A%(.%50''$()%

.550-")2.("*%$,-./0'$%).%!17/%.'%"(4%.):$'%D(.@(%8$>$*.-6$()"*%).,25"()/A%(.%:2/).'4%.T%2**252)%

8'0#%0/$A%-'$#("(54`'$*")$8%82"3$)$/A%.'%:4-$')$(/2.(A%"(8%'$#2/)$'2(#%")%"%-'$(")"*%:$"*):5"'$%

5*2(25%2(%L'"D.@A%@:$'$%):$4%@2**%:">$%*2>$8%T.'%")%*$"/)%"%4$"'%-'$5$82(#%/5'$$(2(#d%1%).)"*%.T%

=\=%-'$#("()%^b%).%&H%@$$D/_%@.6$(%T0*T2**$8%):$/$%5'2)$'2"d%%

M0**%$('.**6$()%'$g02'$8%-'.>282(#%-'$(")"*%g0$/)2.(("2'$%8")"A%5.6-*$)$%-'$(")"*%"2'%

6.(2).'2(#%8")"A%"(8%"%3*..8%/"6-*$%")%8$*2>$'4%T'.6%):$%6.):$'%"(8j.'%:$'%($@3.'(%5:2*8d%1%

).)"*%.T%H=b%@.6$(%@$'$%T0**4%$('.**$8%34%):$/$%5'2)$'2"A%.T%@:.6%HJJ%:"8%>"*28%"2'3.'($%!17%

Page 6 of 30

Page 8: Read the study online

!"#$%a%

%

8")"%^6$$)2(#%g0"*2)4%5.()'.*%5'2)$'2"_d%B$%$,5*08$8%&\%6.):$'`5:2*8%-"2'/%@:./$%5.'8%.'%

6")$'("*%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*/%'$#2/)$'$8%:2#:$'%):"(%E=%(#j6OA%"3.>$%@:25:%"5)2>$%/6.D2(#%

80'2(#%-'$#("(54%2/%/0/-$5)$8%^P"')2"2($(%$)%"*d%E\\E_d%hT%):$%'$6"2(2(#%HHJ%5:2*8'$(A%E&J%

5:2*8'$(%'$"5:$8%):$%"#$%.T%=%4$"'/%34%10#0/)%E\\c%"(8%:"8%5.6-*$)$%Q">$(%9.*.0'$8%

!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%^Q9!F_%)$/)%'$/0*)/d%B'2))$(%2(T.'6$8%5.(/$()%@"/%.3)"2($8%T'.6%"**%

6.):$'/%.(%3$:"*T%.T%):$6/$*>$/%"(8%):$2'%5:2*8d%Z:$%/)084%@"/%"--'.>$8%34%):$%$):25/%

5.662))$$%.T%C"#2$**.(2"(%U(2>$'/2)4A%"(8%):$%<(/)2)0)2.("*%Q$>2$@%G."'8%.T%):$%V$@%W.'D%

!'$/34)$'2"(%F$825"*%9$()$'d%

0'&"*%*2#3"%&'4!&,]%%1%J=`62(0)$%g0$/)2.(("2'$%@"/%"862(2/)$'$8%34%"%)'"2($8%

2()$'>2$@$'%80'2(#%):$%/$5.(8%.'%):2'8%)'26$/)$'%.T%-'$#("(54%).%.3)"2(%8$6.#'"-:25%2(T.'6")2.(A%

:$"*):%"(8%$(>2'.(6$()"*%8")"%T'.6%):$%6.):$'/d%Z:$%g0$/)2.(("2'$%$*252)$8%2(T.'6")2.(%.(%+Z?%

$,-./0'$%80'2(#%-'$#("(54%^-'$/$(5$j"3/$(5$%.T%/6.D$'/%2(%):$%:.0/$:.*8%80'2(#%-'$#("(54_A%

82$)"'4%!17/%^T'$g0$(54%.T%5.(/06-)2.(%.T%3'.2*$8A%T'2$8A%#'2**$8%.'%/6.D$8%6$")%80'2(#%

-'$#("(54_A%"(8%/.52.`$5.(.625%2(T.'6")2.(%'$*")$8%).%2(5.6$%"(8%$805")2.(d%!./)(")"*%T.**.@`

0-%2()$'>2$@/%@$'$%):$(%"862(2/)$'$8%).%6.):$'/%$>$'4%R%6.():/%"T)$'%32'):%).%8$)$'62($%"(4%

5:"(#$/%2(%'$/28$(5$A%$,-./0'$%).%+Z?A%"(8%.):$'%:$"*):%.'%$(>2'.(6$()"*%5.(82)2.(/d%

0&'5("*2#6!'#7("!%('!"8?##Z.%"//$//%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%!17/A%):$%@.6$(%@$'$%

-$'/.("**4%6.(2).'$8%.>$'%"%Jb`:.0'%-$'2.8%80'2(#%):$%/$5.(8%^VkE=H_%.'%):2'8%^Vk&\\_%

)'26$/)$'%.T%-'$#("(54d%I0'2(#%):$%8"4A%):$4%5"''2$8%%/6"**%3"5D-"5D/%:.*82(#%-$'/.("*%"2'%

6.(2).'/%"(8%D$-)%):$%6.(2).'/%34%):$2'%3$8/%")%(2#:)%^C$8'45:.@/D2%$)%"*d%E\\J_d%1/%-'$>2.0/*4%

8$/5'23$8%^9"6"((%"(8%B:4"))%E\\&X%Z.(($%$)%"*d%E\\J_A%):$%-.*40'$):"($%T."6%5"')'28#$/%@$'$%

"("*4K$8%")%?.0):@$/)%Q$/$"'5:%<(/)2)0)$%2(%?"(%1().(2.A%Z$,"/%T.'%5.(5$()'")2.(/%.T%$2#:)%

5"'52(.#$(25%!17/]%3$(K^"_"():'"5$($A%5:'4/$($j2/.`5:'4/$($A%3$(K.^3_T*0.'"():$($A%

Page 7 of 30

Page 9: Read the study online

!"#$%b%

%

3$(K.^D_T*0.'"():$($A%3$(K.^"_-4'$($A%2(8$(.^&AEAH`58_-4'$($A%823$(K^"A:_"():'"5$($A%"(8%

3$(K.`^#A:A2_-$'4*$($d%M.'%g0"*2)4%5.()'.*A%$"5:%6.(2).'2(#%'$/0*)%@"/%"//$//$8%"/%).%"550'"54%2(%

T*.@%'")$A%)26$A%"(8%5.6-*$)$($//%.T%8.506$()")2.(d%%h(*4%/"6-*$/%6$$)2(#%g0"*2)4%5.()'.*%

5'2)$'2"%@$'$%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%"("*4/2/d%+"5:%!17%6$"/0'$8%34%-$'/.("*%"2'%6.(2).'2(#%@"/%

8$)$5)"3*$%2(%&\\o%.T%-$'/.("*%"2'%/"6-*$/%@2):%"%@28$%'"(#$%.T%5.(5$()'")2.(/d%1/%):$%$2#:)%

"2'3.'($%!17/%@$'$%:2#:*4%2()$'5.''$*")$8%^\dc=p%?-$"'6"(;/%';/%p%\dcc_A%"(8%).%3$%5.(/2/)$()%

@2):%):$%VW9%"(8%.):$'%/)082$/%^!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\H_A%):$/$%!17/%@$'$%/066$8%).%-'.>28$%"%

6$"/0'$%.T%).)"*%"2'3.'($%!17/A%:$'$"T)$'%q!17/rd%

Z:$%0/$%.T%-$'/.("*%6.(2).'2(#%@"/%>"*28")$8%2(%):2/%5.:.')%2(%"%/03/$)%.T%@.6$(%^Vkb\_%

@:.%@$'$%/260*)"($.0/*4%6.(2).'$8%T.'%-$'/.("*A%2(8..'%"(8%.0)8..'%"2'3.'($%!17/d%1**%):'$$%

6$"/0'$6$()/%@$'$%T.0(8%).%3$%:2#:*4%5.''$*")$8%^-"2'`@2/$%?-$"'6"(;/%5.$TT252$()/%n%\dbJA%-p%

\d\&_%^9:.2%$)%"*d%E\\b%_A%@:25:%/0--.')$8%):$%0/$%.T%-$'/.("*%6.(2).'2(#%).%2()$#'")$%2(8..'%"(8%

.0)8..'%$,-./0'$d%%

% 9!(2(8!:*2#-*;12&#<(22&:%!("#*".#6"*2/5&5?%%1T)$'%8$*2>$'4A%"%5.'8%3*..8%/"6-*$%@"/%

5.**$5)$8%T'.6%):$%0632*25"*%5.'8%>$2(A%"(8%"%>$(.0/%3*..8%/"6-*$%.3)"2($8%T'.6%):$%@.6$(d%

!*"/6"%5.)2(2($%"(8%*$"8%*$>$*/%2(%5.'8%"(8%6")$'("*%3*..8%"(8%*$>$*/%.T%EJ%0'2("'4%!17%

6$)"3.*2)$/%2(%5:2*8%0'2($%5.**$5)$8%")%):$%):2'8%4$"'%T.**.@`0-%@$'$%6$"/0'$8%")%):$%Ud?d%9$()$'/%

T.'%I2/$"/$%9.()'.*%"(8%!'$>$()2.(%0/2(#%:2#:`-$'T.'6"(5$%*2g028%5:'.6").#'"-:4%")6./-:$'25`

-'$//0'$%2.(2K")2.(%)"(8$6%6"//%/-$5)'.6$)'4%^5.)2(2($_%^G$'($')%$)%"*d%&cca_A%2(805)2>$*4%

5.0-*$8%-*"/6"%6"//%/-$5)'.6$)'4%^*$"8_%^I")$%"(8%f'"4%&cbc_A%"(8%"%5.632(")2.(%.T%

$(K46")25%8$5.(i0#")2.(A%"0).6")$8%*2g028`*2g028%$,)'"5)2.(A%"(8%#"/%5:'.6").#'"-:4j2/.).-$%

82*0)2.(%:2#:%'$/.*0)2.(%6"//%/-$5)'.6$)'4%^!17%6$)"3.*2)$/_%^O2%$)%"*d%E\\R_A%'$/-$5)2>$*4d%Z:$%

!17%6$)"3.*2)$/%@$'$%5'$")2(2($`"8i0/)$8%).%5.()'.*%T.'%82*0)2.(d%%

Page 8 of 30

Page 10: Read the study online

!"#$%c%

%

=&$'(.&4&2(1;&"%*2#>&5%!"8?%%1)%):$%=%4$"'%T.**.@`0-%-.2()A%"%)'"2($8%'$/$"'5:%@.'D$'%

"862(2/)$'$8%).%$"5:%5:2*8%):$%Q">$(%9.*.0'$8%!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%^Q9!F_A%"%@28$*4`0/$8%

"#$`"8i0/)$8%(.(>$'3"*%)$/)%.T%'$"/.(2(#%"32*2)4%"(8%2()$**2#$(5$%3"/$8%.(%T2#0'"*%6")$'2"*/%.'%

-"))$'(/%^Q">$(%$)%"*d%&ccb_d%Z:2/%2(/)'06$()A%@:25:%2/%*2/)$8%"/%"%5.#(2)2>$%)$/)%34%):$%1#$(54%

T.'%Z.,25%?03/)"(5$/%"(8%I2/$"/$/%Q$#2/)'4A%-'.>28$/%2(T.'6")2.(%.(%T0(5)2.(2(#%2(%"%(063$'%.T%

5.#(2)2>$%8.6"2(/%/05:%"/%>2/0"*`-$'5$-)0"*A%*"(#0"#$A%-'",2/%^-$'T.'6"(5$_A%'$"/.(2(#%"(8%

5.(5$-)%T.'6")2.(d%G$5"0/$%2)%2/%'$-.')$8%).%:">$%62(26"*%50*)0'"*%32"/%"(8%).%3$%5"-"3*$%.T%

$>"*0")2(#%):$%2()$**$5)0"*%/)")0/%.T%5:2*8'$(%$,-./$8%).%).,25%5:$625"*/%^?"))*$'%&cbRX%?2K$6.'$%

"(8%16*$'%&ccR_A%):$%Q9!F%:"/%3$$(%0/$8%2(%"%(063$'%.T%/)082$/%.T%$(>2'.(6$()"*%$,-./0'$/%

2(%5:2*8'$(%2(%!.*"(8%"(8%$*/$@:$'$%^?K0/)'.@"%&ccE_d%G.):%):$%Q9!F%%"(8%):$%B$5:/*$'%

!'$/5:..*%"(8%!'26"'4%?5"*$%.T%<()$**2#$(5$YQ$>2/$8%^B!!?<`Q_s@:25:%@"/%"862(2/)$'$8%).%

):$%VW9%5.:.')s"'$%5.''$*")$8%@2):%):$%/)"(8"'8%)$/)%.T%2()$**2#$(5$%5"**$8%):$%B$5:/*$'%

<()$**2#$(5$%?5"*$%T.'%9:2*8'$(%^Q">$(%$)%"*d%&ccb_d%Q9!F%/)"(8"'8%/5.'$/%5"(%3$%5.(>$')$8%).%

2()$**2#$(5$%g0.)2$()%^<e_%/5.'$/%T.'%$/)26")$/%.T%2()$**2#$(5$%*$>$*/%^9.0()$'%$)%"*d%E\\=X%Q">$(%

$)%"*d%&ccb_A%):.0#:%):$4%/:.0*8%(.)%3$%2()$'-'$)$8%"/%"%6$"/0'$%.T%#*.3"*%2()$**2#$(5$A%30)%.T%

(.(>$'3"*%2()$**2#$(5$%^9.0()$'%$)%"*d%E\\c_d%7$'$A%2(%.'8$'%).%5.6-"'$%):$%L'"D.@%"(8%):$%VW9%

/)084%'$/0*)/A%6$"/0'$8%Q9!F%/5.'$/%@$'$%5.(>$')$8%).%<e%/5.'$%"55.'82(#%).%):$%Q9!F%

6"(0"*%^Q">$(%$)%"*d%&ccb_d%

F")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%@"/%"//$//$8%0/2(#%):$%Z$/)%.T%V.(>$'3"*%<()$**2#$(5$`Z:2'8%$82)2.(%

^ZhV<`H_A%"%*"(#0"#$`T'$$%6$"/0'$%.T%#$($'"*%2()$**2#$(5$%5.(/28$'$8%).%3$%'$*")2>$*4%T'$$%.T%

50*)0'"*%32"/%^I$F"0'.%E\\\_d%

7(.&2#*".#:(4*'!*%&5?%%Z@.%:0(8'$8%"(8%T.0')$$(%-"')252-"()/%@$'$%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%

-'26"'4%"("*4/2/%-'$/$()$8%:$'$d%1%/03/$)%.T%&a&%.T%):$%-"')252-"()/%:"8%">"2*"3*$%8")"%.(%

Page 9 of 30

Page 11: Read the study online

!"#$%&\%

%

6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%^ZhV<`H_%@:25:%@"/%2(5*08$8%"/%"%5.>"'2")$%2(%"%/$-"'")$%6.8$*d%F2//2(#%

5.>"'2")$/%.'%)$/)%2(T.'6")2.(%.550''$8%"/%"%'$/0*)%.T%*.//%).%T.**.@`0-%.'%*"5D%.T%"%32.*.#25"*%

/-$526$(%T.'%32.6"'D$'%"("*4/2/d%

F0*)2-*$%*2($"'%'$#'$//2.(%6.8$*/%@$'$%0/$8%).%$/)26")$%):$%"//.52")2.(%3$)@$$(%-'$(")"*%

"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%"(8%):$%Q9!F%/5.'$%^6.8$*$8%"/%"%5.()2(0.0/%>"'2"3*$_%"/%"%6$"/0'$%.T%

5:2*8%<ed%Z.)"*%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%@"/%6.8$*$8%3.):%"/%"%825:.).6.0/%6$"/0'$%^50)%")%):$%

6$82"(k&adcR%(#j6H%"(8%'$T$''$8%).%"/%q:2#:j*.@r%2(%):$%)"3*$/_%"(8%"/%"%5.()2(0.0/%6$"/0'$d%

Z:$%5.()2(0.0/%!17%8")"%@$'$%*.#%)'"(/T.'6$8%lqO(^!17_r%2(%):$%)"3*$/m%3$5"0/$%):$%

82/)'230)2.(%.T%"2'3.'($%!17%5.(5$()'")2.(/%@"/%6"'D$8*4%/D$@$8%%

1%(063$'%.T%5.>"'2")$/%@$'$%/$*$5)$8%*#1'!('!%T.'%2(5*0/2.(%2(%):$%6.8$*%3"/$8%.(%):$%

*2)$'")0'$%"(8%.0'%.@(%-'2.'%8")"d%Z:$/$%2(5*08$8%6")$'("*%'$-.')%.T%+Z?%$,-./0'$%2(%):$%

:.0/$:.*8%80'2(#%-'$#("(54A%/$,%.T%):$%5:2*8A%"(8%6")$'("*%$805")2.(%^5.6-*$)$8j828%(.)%

5.6-*$)$%&E%4$"'/%.T%/5:..*2(#_d%Z:$%*"))$'%@"/%0/$8%"/%"%-'.,4%T.'%/.52.`$5.(.625%/)")0/%

^C$8'45:.@/D2%$)%"*d%E\\c3_d%G$5"0/$%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%^5.()2(0.0/%ZhV<`H_%2/%"%D(.@(%

5.''$*")$%.T%5:2*8%5.#(2)2>$%8$>$*.-6$()%^L"#"(%"(8%F.//%&c=cX%V.3*$%"(8%F59"(8*2//%E\\=_%

30)%@"/%.(*4%">"2*"3*$%2(%"%/03/$)%.T%):$%5:2*8'$(%^Vk&a&_A%2)%@"/%2(5*08$8%@2):%):$%.):$'%

5.>"'2")$/%2(%"%/$5.(8"'4%"("*4/2/d%%

O$"8%"(8%82$)"'4%!17/%@$'$%(.)%/2#(2T25"()%-'$825).'/%.T%Q9!F%^-p\d&%2(%0(2>"'2")$%

'$#'$//2.(%"("*4/2/_%"(8%):0/%@$'$%(.)%2(5*08$8%2(%.0'%T2("*%6.8$*d%G$5"0/$%-'$(")"*%!17%

$,-./0'$%@"/%-'$>2.0/*4%T.0(8%).%3$%"//.52")$8%@2):%'$805$8%32'):%@$2#:)%"(8%:$"8%

52'506T$'$(5$%2(%):2/%5.:.')%^9:.2%$)%"*d%E\\b_A%@$%$>"*0")$8%):$2'%-.)$()2"*%"/%2()$'6$82")$%

>"'2"3*$/%34%2(5*082(#%):$6%2(%/$-"'")$%6.8$*/d%B$%"*/.%"8i0/)$8%T.'%-./)(")"*%!17%$,-./0'$%

0/2(#%2(82>280"*%5'$")2(2($`"8i0/)$8%!17%6$)"3.*2)$/%2(%0'2($%5.**$5)$8%")%"#$%H%4$"'/A%%"(8%"%

Page 10 of 30

Page 12: Read the study online

!"#$%&&%

%

6$"/0'$%.T%-./)(")"*%'$/28$(5$%5:"(#$%"/%"(%2(825").'%.T%-.//23*$%5:"(#$%2(%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%

!17/%"T)$'%32'):d%%B$%T0'):$'%"8i0/)$8%T.'%6")$'("*%'$-.')%.T%-./)(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%+Z?%2(%):$%

:.6$d%%B$%"*/.%5:$5D$8%T.'%$TT$5)%6.82T25")2.(%34%)'26$/)$'%.T%!17%6.(2).'2(#A%!17%6.(2).'2(#%

/$"/.(%.'%/$"/.(%.T%32'):%34%2(5*082(#%)$'6/%T.'%):$%2()$'"5)2.(%3$)@$$(%!17%"(8%)'26$/)$'%.T%!17%

6.(2).'2(#A%3$)@$$(%!17%"(8%!17%6.(2).'2(#%/$"/.(%"(8%3$)@$$(%!17%"(8%/$"/.(%.T%32'):%2(%

/$-"'")$%6.8$*/d%

1**%$TT$5)%$/)26")$/%"(8%-`>"*0$/%^t%/$)%")%\d\=_%@$'$%#$($'")$8%0/2(#%?1?%^>$'/2.(%

cd&d\dHX%?1?%<(/)2)0)$%<(5dA%9"'4A%V9_d%%

%

30$-1%$!

Z:$%">$'"#$%5.(5$()'")2.(%.T%).)"*%"2'3.'($%!17/%^.T%"8$g0")$%6.(2).'2(#%g0"*2)4_%2(%

-$'/.("*%"2'%/"6-*$/%@"/%Hcd=%u%Jbd&%(#j6HA%@2):%"%6$82"(%.T%&adcR%(#j6

H%^VkHJJ_d%16.(#%"**%

):$%5:2*8'$(%)$/)$8%T.'%Q9!F%")%):$%=%4$"'%T.**.@`0-%^VkHEc_A%):$%">$'"#$%Q9!F%/5.'$%@"/%

E&db%u%Jd&d%%

Z"3*$%&%5.6-"'$/%):$%3"/25%8$6.#'"-:25%5:"'"5)$'2/)25/%.T%T0**4%$('.**$8%/03i$5)/%:">2(#%

-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%"(8%Q9!F%8")"%")%"#$%=%4$"'/%>/d%T0**4%$('.**$8%/03i$5)/%

:">2(#%!17%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%30)%(.%Q9!Fd%Z:$%5:"'"5)$'2/)25/%.T%):$%)@.%#'.0-/%828%(.)%82TT$'%

/2#(2T25"()*4A%$,5$-)%T.'%($@3.'(%32'):%@$2#:)%"(8%6.):$';/%"#$d%h(%">$'"#$A%):$%5:2*8'$(%@2):%

Q9!F%8")"%@$'$%&HHdE#%*2#:)$'%")%32'):A%"(8%6.):$'/%@$'$%.*8$'%34%&%4$"'d%Z:$%82TT$'$(5$/%2(%):$%

6$"(/%"'$%6.8$/)A%30)%/)")2/)25"**4%/2#(2T25"()d%%

9.''$*")2.(/%3$)@$$(%"2'3.'($%!17/%"(8%+Z?%$,-./0'$A%3$)@$$(%"2'3.'($%!17/%"(8%

82$)"'4%!17/A%"(8%3$)@$$(%"2'3.'($%!17/%"(8%6")$'("*%.'%5.'8%5.)2(2($%@$'$%$,"62($8%0/2(#%

?-$"'6"(%'"(D`.'8$'%5.''$*")2.(d%V.($%@"/%T.0(8%).%3$%/2#(2T25"()A%$2):$'%2(%):$%L'"D.@%5.:.')%

Page 11 of 30

Page 13: Read the study online

!"#$%&E%

%

"/%"%@:.*$%.'%):$%/03/$)%/)082$8%:$'$%^VkE&J_%^Z"3*$%E_d%1/%$,-$5)$8A%+Z?%$,-./0'$%80'2(#%

-'$#("(54%@"/%/2#(2T25"()*4%5.''$*")$8%@2):%6")$'("*%"(8%5.'8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*/%3.):%2(%):$%$()2'$%

5.:.')%"(8%2(%):$%-'$/$()%/03/$)%A%/0--.')2(#%/$*T`'$-.')$8%+Z?%"/%"%'$*2"3*$%6$"/0'$%.T%+Z?%

$,-./0'$d%+Z?%$,-./0'$%"(8%82$)"'4%!17/%@$'$%5.''$*")$8%2(%):$%-'$/$()%/03/$)%^(kE&J_%30)%(.)%

2(%):$%*"'#$'%5.:.')d%

72#:%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%*$>$*/%@$'$%"//.52")$8%@2):%"%/2#(2T25"()A%"*3$2)%

6.8$/)A%'$805)2.(%2(%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%2(%6.8$*/%@2):%$2):$'%825:.).6.0/%.'%O(`)'"(/T.'6$8%

5.()2(0.0/%>"'2"3*$/%T.'%!17%$,-./0'$%^Z"3*$%H_d%Z:$%$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%.T%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%

@"/%/2#(2T25"()%"T)$'%"8i0/)2(#%T.'%-'$(")"*%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%"(8%.):$'%-.)$()2"*%5.(T.0(8$'/d%Z:$%

2(>$'/$%'$*")2.(/:2-%3$)@$$(%"2'3.'($%!17%*$>$*%"(8%Q9!F%/5.'$%'$6"2($8%"T)$'%"8i0/)2(#%T.'%

)'26$/)$'%.T%6.(2).'2(#%^/$5.(8%.'%):2'8_d%%%

!'$(")"*%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%@"/%"%/2#(2T25"()%-'$825).'%.T%Q9!F%/5.'$%"/%/:.@(%2(%Z"3*$%

Hd%+,5*082(#%-'$(")"*%+Z?%T'.6%):$%6.8$*%828%(.)%6")$'2"**4%"*)$'%):$%$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%/2K$%.'%-`

>"*0$%.T%!17%.(%5:2*8%Q9!F%/5.'$%lvk%`&dHA%-k\d\H%2(%):$%!17%:2#:j*.@%6.8$*A%"(8%vk%`\d=A%

-k\d\H%2(%):$%O(^!17_%6.8$*%"T)$'%$,5*082(#%+Z?%^VkE&J_mA%2(825")2(#%):")%-'$(")"*%+Z?%

$,-./0'$%2/%(.)%"%-.)$()2"*%5.(T.0(8$'%.T%):2/%"//.52")2.(d%

<(%):$%/6"**$'%/03/$)%:">2(#%8")"%T.'%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%^Vk&a&_A%):$%$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%

.T%!17%$,-./0'$%'$6"2($8%5.(/2/)$()%"(8%/2#(2T25"()%l!k%`&dJA%-k\d\J%T.'%!17%:2#:j*.@X%!k%`

\dRA%-k\d\=%T.'%5.()2(0.0/%O(^!17_md%!'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%"(8%6")$'("*%

2()$**2#$(5$%@$'$%/2#(2T25"()%.'%3.'8$'*2($`%/2#(2T25"()%5.>"'2")$/%2(%):2/%6.8$*%^8")"%(.)%/:.@(_d%

V$2):$'%*$"8%(.'%82$)"'4%!17/%@"/%"%/2#(2T25"()%-'$825).'%.T%Q9!F%/5.'$/%^p\d&_%@:$(%

2(5*08$8%2(82>280"**4%2(%):$%6.8$*d%O$"8%^5.6-0)$8%"/%"%O(`)'"(/T.'6$8%>"'2"3*$_%@"/%(.)%"%

/2#(2T25"()%-'$825).'%2(%):$%6.8$*%"T)$'%5.()'.**2(#%T.'%-'$(")"*%+Z?%$,-./0'$%2(%):$%:.6$A%/$,%.T%

Page 12 of 30

Page 14: Read the study online

!"#$%&H%

%

):$%5:2*8A%"(8%6")$'("*%$805")2.(X%"(8%):$%$TT$5)%.T%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%'$6"2($8%

/2#(2T25"()%@2):%*$"8%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%6.8$*d%Z:$%82$)"'4%'.0)$%.T%$,-./0'$%).%!17/%@"/%(.)%"%

/2#(2T25"()%5.()'230).'%).%):$%$TT$5)%.T%"2'3.'($%!17/A%@:25:%'$6"2($8%/2#(2T25"()%"T)$'%2(5*082(#%

82$)"'4%!17%2(%):$%6.8$*d%Z:$%6"#(2)08$%.T%):$%"//.52")2.(%3$)@$$(%!17/%"(8%Q9!F%@"/%

0(5:"(#$8%@:$(%$2):$'%*$"8%.'%82$)"'4%!17%$,-./0'$%@"/%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%6.8$*d%

<(5*082(#%32'):%:$"8%52'506T$'$(5$%.'%32'):%@$2#:)%/$-"'")$*4%2(%):$%6.8$*%828%(.)%"*)$'%

):$%$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%.T%"2'3.'($%!17%l"8i0/)$8%T.'%32'):%:$"8%52'506T$'$(5$]%vk%`&dJA%-k\d\E%T.'%

!17%:2#:j*.@X%vk%`\dRA%-k\d\E%T.'%5.()2(0.0/%O(^!17_A%VkE&JX%"8i0/)$8%T.'%32'):%@$2#:)]%vk%`

&dHA%-k\d\H%T.'%!17%:2#:j*.@X%vk%`\d=A%-k\d\E%T.'%5.()2(0.0/%O(^!17_A%VkE&Jmd%%

B2):%'$/-$5)%).%-./)(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%!17/A%@$%T.0(8%(.%$TT$5)%.T%-./)(")"*%0'2("'4%!17%

6$)"3.*2)$/%.(%):$%6"#(2)08$%.T%):$%$TT$5)%.T%!17/%.(%Q9!Fd%Z@$()4`):'$$%-$'5$()%.T%T"62*2$/%

5:"(#$8%($2#:3.':..8%.T%'$/28$(5$%2(%):$%5:2*8;/%T2'/)%):'$$%4$"'/%.T%*2T$A%@2):%"%*2D$*4%):.0#:%

0(6$"/0'$8%5:"(#$%2(%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$d%18i0/)2(#%T.'%5:"(#$%2(%($2#:3.':..8%.T%

'$/28$(5$%828%(.)%"*)$'%):$%/)'$(#):%.T%):$%2(>$'/$%"//.52")2.(%T.0(8%3$)@$$(%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%

!17/%"(8%Q!9F%/5.'$d%9.()'.**2(#%T.'%-./)(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%^EEo%.T%6.):$'/%

'$-.')$8%$,-./0'$%80'2(#%")%*$"/)%.($%.T%):$%&\%T.**.@`0-%2()$'>2$@/%#2>$(%3$)@$$(%32'):%"(8%

):$%5:2*8;/%T.**.@`0-%")%"#$%=%4$"'/_%828%(.)%"*)$'%):$%$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%.T%!17/d%%

Z:$'$%@"/%(.%$>28$(5$%.T%"(%2()$'"5)2.(%3$)@$$(%)'26$/)$'%.T%!17%6.(2).'2(#A%!17%

6.(2).'2(#%/$"/.(A%.'%/$"/.(%.T%32'):d%%Z:$%-`>"*0$/%.T%2()$'"5)2.(%)$'6/%@$'$%#'$")$'%):"(%\dHb%2(%

):$%6.8$*/%@2):%825:.).62K$8%!17%"(8%#'$")$'%):"(%\dE=%2(%):$%6.8$*/%@2):%*.#%)'"(/T.'6$8%!17d%%

M2("**4A%2(%.'8$'%).%3$))$'%5.6-"'$%):$%L'"D.@%5.:.')%).%):$%VW9%5.:.')A%@$%'$/)'25)$8%

"("*4/2/%).%):$%L'"D.@%-"')252-"()/%@2):2(%):$%5.66.(%!17%$,-./0'$%'"(#$%/$$(%2(%L'"D.@%"(8%

VW9%^\dEa`JJdb&%(#j6H_%"(8%).%):$%/03/$)%.T%@.6$(%T.'%@:.6%8")"%.(%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%

Page 13 of 30

Page 15: Read the study online

!"#$%&J%

%

@$'$%">"2*"3*$%^/.%):")%):$%6.8$*/%@.0*8%3$%82'$5)*4%5.6-"'"3*$_d%<(%):2/%5.6-"'2/.(A%):$%

$/)26")$8%$TT$5)%/2K$/%2(%3.):%):$%825:.).6.0/%"(8%5.()2(0.0/%6.8$*/%@$'$%/262*"'%).%):./$%

.3/$'>$8%2(%):$%$()2'$%!.*2/:%5.:.')%^.>$'%):$%T0**%$,-./0'$%'"(#$]%&db`EaEdE%(#j6H_%^Z"3*$%J_d%

%

4.$(-$$.+*!%

B$%:">$%T.0(8%):")%:2#:$'%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%!17/%2/%"//.52")$8%@2):%"%

6.8$/)%"(8%/)")2/)25"**4%/2#(2T25"()%'$805)2.(%2(%/5.'$/%.(%"%)$/)%.T%(.(`>$'3"*%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%

2(%"%/"6-*$%.T%=%4$"'%.*8%5:2*8'$(%.T%(.(`/6.D2(#%6.):$'/%T'.6%L'"D.@A%!.*"(8A%"T)$'%

5.()'.**2(#%T.'%5.(T.0(82(#%>"'2"3*$/d%9:2*8'$(%2(%):$%:2#:%$,-./0'$%#'.0-%^w&adcR%(#j6H_%:"8%

Q9!F%/5.'$/%):")%@$'$%.(%">$'"#$%&dJ%-.2()/%*.@$'%^-k\d\E_%5.6-"'$8%).%*$//%$,-./$8%5:2*8'$(%

^x&adcR%(#j6H_A%5.''$/-.(82(#%).%"(%$/)26")$8%Hdb%-.2()%">$'"#$%8$5'$"/$%2(%<e%-.2()/d%Z:$%

'$*")2.(/:2-%3$)@$$(%-'$(")"*%"2'3.'($%!17%"(8%2()$**2#$(5$%")%"#$%=%4$"'/%'$6"2($8%/2#(2T25"()%

"T)$'%5.()'.**2(#%T.'%-./)(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%!17/%"(8%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$d%%%

G$5"0/$%):$%7.6$%h3/$'>")2.(%T.'%F$"/0'$6$()%.T%):$%+(>2'.(6$()%^7hF+_%

<(>$().'4A%"%6$"/0'$%.T%):$%5:2*8;/%-'.,26"*%5"'$)"D2(#%$(>2'.(6$()%@:25:%5"(%5.(T.0(8%"%/)084%

.(%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()%^G'"8*$4%$)%"*d%&ccR_A%2/%(.)%@28$*4%0/$8%2(%9$()'"*%+0'.-$A%2)%@"/%(.)%

"862(2/)$'$8%2(%):$%!.*2/:%5.:.')%"/%2(%):$%-"'"**$*%VW9%5.:.')%/)084X%):2/%5.(/)2)0)$/%"%*262)")2.(%

.T%):2/%/)084d%7.@$>$'A%@$%2(5*08$8%6")$'("*%$805")2.(%2(%.0'%6.8$*/%).%-"')2"**4%"55.0()%T.'%):$%

6.):$'/;%26-.')"()%'.*$%2(%/)260*")2(#%):$%5:2*8%^L"#"(%"(8%F.//%&c=cX%F51/D2$%"(8%9*"'D$%

&caRX%V.3*$%"(8%F59"(8*2//%E\\=X%C$8'45:.@/D2%$)%"*d%E\\c"_d%G$5"0/$%.T%):$%5.(5$'(%):")%):2/%

825:.).62K$8%>"'2"3*$%^5.6-*$)$8%>/d%828%(.)%5.6-*$)$%&E%4$"'/%.T%/5:..*2(#_%6"4%2)/$*T%(.)%3$%

/$(/2)2>$%$(.0#:%).%5.()'.*%T.'%82TT$'$(5$/%2(%):$%:.6$%$(>2'.(6$()%"(8%"55.0()%T.'%-.)$()2"*%

5.(T.0(82(#%.T%!17%$TT$5)/%34%6")$'("*%$805")2.(A%@$%"*/.%0/$8%y).)"*%4$"'/%.T%$805")2.(%

Page 14 of 30

Page 16: Read the study online

!"#$%&=%

%

5.6-*$)$8%34%):$%6.):$';%"/%"%5.()2(0.0/%>"'2"3*$A%"(8%T.0(8%(.%82TT$'$(5$/%2(%):$%'$/0*)/d%B$%

"*/.%T.0(8%):")%-$'/.("*%"2'3.'($%!17%*$>$*/%@$'$%(.)%5.''$*")$8%@2):%).)"*%4$"'/%.T%$805")2.(%

5.6-*$)$8%34%):$%6.):$'%^'k%`\d\HbA%-k\dJbbA%VkHHH_A%62)2#")2(#%5.(5$'(%):")%0(6$"/0'$8%

82TT$'$(5$/%2(%/.52.`$5.(.625%/)")0/%6"4%:">$%5.(T.0(8$8%.0'%T2(82(#/%.(%!17%$,-./0'$d%%

F")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%@"/%">"2*"3*$%T.'%"%/03/$)%.T%&a&%@.6$(%"(8%@"/%/2#(2T25"()*4%"//.52")$8%

@2):%5:2*8%<ed%%%1T)$'%"8i0/)6$()%T.'%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$A%):$%$TT$5)%.T%-'$(")"*%!17%$,-./0'$%

@"/%/2#(2T25"()%^-kd\\HR%T.'%:2#:j*.@%!17%"(8%-k\d\Hc%T.'%5.()2(0.0/%!17_d%%%

!'$(")"*%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%@"/%/2#(2T25"()*4%"//.52")$8%@2):%5:2*8%<e%30)%828%(.)%5.(T.0(8%

):$%"//.52")2.(%3$)@$$(%"2'3.'($%!17/%"(8%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$d%Z:$%"//.52")2.(%3$)@$$(%-'$(")"*%

$,-./0'$%).%+Z?%"(8%8$T252)/%2(%$"'*4%5.#(2)2>$%T0(5)2.(2(#%:"/%3$$(%$/)"3*2/:$8%-'$>2.0/*4%

^+/D$("K2%"(8%9"/).'2("%&ccc_d%!'2.'%'$/$"'5:%2(%):$%/"6$%L'"D.@%5.:.')%/:.@$8%):")%5.)2(2($%

*$>$*/%6$"/0'$8%2(%($@3.'(/;%-*"/6"%@$'$%/2#(2T25"()*4%:2#:$'%):"(%6.):$'/;%3*..8A%2(825")2(#%

):")%):$%T$)0/%6"4%3$%*$//%"3*$%).%8$).,2T4%):2/%/03/)"(5$%^C$8'45:.@/D2%$)%"*d%E\\a_d%!'$(")"*%

+Z?%@"/%(.)%5.''$*")$8%@2):%"2'3.'($%!17/%^Z"3*$%E_A%5.(/2/)$()%@2):%):$%"("*4/2/%.T%9:.2%"(8%

5.**$"#0$/%@:25:%/:.@$8%):")%"**%$2#:)%/-$52")$8%!17/%6.(2).'$8%:">$%.0)8..'%/.0'5$/%

28$()2T2$8%@2):%5."*%5.630/)2.(A%):.0#:%/.6$%"'$%"*/.%'$*")$8%).%+Z?%^9:.2%$)%"*d%E\\R_d%%

Z'"(/-*"5$()"*%$,-./0'$/%).%!17/%:">$%3$$(%*2(D$8%).%8$5'$6$()/%2(%:$"8%

52'506T$'$(5$A%32'):%@$2#:)A%"(8%*$(#):%^I$i6$D%$)%"*d%E\\\X%!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\HX%B:4"))%$)%"*d%

&ccb_d%Z:$/$%8$5'$6$()/%:">$%-.)$()2"*%*.(#$'`)$'6%26-*25")2.(/%T.'%-'.8052(#%*.@$'%5.#(2)2>$%

T0(5)2.(2(#%"(8%-..'$'%/5:..*%-$'T.'6"(5$%2(%5:2*8:..8%^7"5D%$)%"*d%&cc&_d%7.@$>$'A%2(%):2/%

"("*4/2/%($2):$'%):$%($@3.'(;/%:$"8%52'506T$'$(5$%(.'%32'):%@$2#:)%-'$825)$8%2()$**2#$(5$%")%=%4$"'/%

.T%"#$d%%

Page 15 of 30

Page 17: Read the study online

!"#$%&R%

%

Q$*42(#%.(%"%/2(#*$%6$"/0'$6$()%.T%-'$(")"*%"2'%T.'%.0'%$,-./0'$%6")'2,%2/%*262)$8d%

7.@$>$'A%3$5"0/$%6$"/0'$6$()/%80'2(#%):$%/$5.(8%"(8%):2'8%)'26$/)$'/%@$'$%5.''$*")$8%^9:.2%$)%

"*d%E\\b%_A%@$%5.(/28$'$8%):$%/2(#*$%6.(2).'2(#%)26$-.2()%).%3$%"%'$"/.("3*$%2(825").'%.T%-'$(")"*%

$,-./0'$%>2"%2(:"*")2.(%.>$'%):$%*"/)%)@.%)'26$/)$'/%.T%-'$#("(54d%I$/-2)$%D(.@(%/$"/.("*%

>"'2")2.(%2(%"2'%-.**0)2.(%*$>$*/%'$*")$8%).%:$")2(#%@2):%5."*%2(%L'"D.@%^9:.2%$)%"*d%E\\b%_A%):$%

-.)$()2"*%$TT$5)%.T%/$"/.(%.(%.0'%'$/0*)/%@"/%62)2#")$8%34%):$%T"5)%):")%6.(2).'2(#%@"/%$>$(*4%

82/)'230)$8%"5'.//%/$"/.(/%^VkbRA%b&A%b=%"(8%cE%6.):$'/%@$'$%6.(2).'$8%2(%/-'2(#A%/066$'A%T"**%

"(8%@2()$'A%'$/-$5)2>$*4_d%B$%"*/.%5.(/28$'$8%):$%*262)")2.(%.T%0/2(#%"%Jb`:.0'%6.(2).'2(#%-$'2.8%

).%'$-'$/$()%"%*.(#$'%5.()2(0.0/%$,-./0'$%-$'2.8d%7.@$>$'A%@$%T.0(8%(.%$TT$5)%6.82T25")2.(%34%

)'26$/)$'%.T%!17%6.(2).'2(#A%!17%6.(2).'2(#%/$"/.(%.'%/$"/.(%.T%32'):%.(%"(4%.T%.0'%T2(82(#/d%B$%

"*/.%828%(.)%6"D$%):$%"//06-)2.(%):")%):$%/$5.(8%"(8j.'%):2'8%)'26$/)$'/%.T%-'$#("(54%"'$%):$%

6./)%>0*($'"3*$%-$'2.8/%@2):%'$/-$5)%).%3'"2(%8$>$*.-6$()d%Z:$%T2'/)%)'26$/)$'%6"4%3$%$g0"**4%.'%

6.'$%26-.')"()d%%

Z.%.0'%D(.@*$8#$A%):$'$%:"/%.(*4%3$$(%.($%-'2.'%$-28$62.*.#25"*%/)084%'$-.')2(#%"(%

2(>$'/$%"//.52")2.(%3$)@$$(%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%!17%"(8%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%")%"#$%=%4$"'/A%"(8%

):")%2/%T'.6%.0'%9$()$';/%.(#.2(#%5.:.')%/)084%2(%VW9%^!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\c3_d%%G4%8$/2#(A%"**%

>"'2"3*$/%@$'$%6$"/0'$8%/262*"'*4%2(%VW9%"(8%L'"D.@A%$,5$-)%T.'%):$%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()%

"//$//6$()%)..*%0/$8%^Q9!F%2(%L'"D.@%>/d%):$%B!!?<`Q%/5.'$%2(%VW9_d%Z:$%VW9%/)084%

2(5*08$8%1T'25"(`16$'25"(/%"(8%I.62(25"(`16$'25"(/X%):$%L'"D.@%/)084A%9"05"/2"(/d%I")"%.(%

):$%:.6$%5"'$)"D2(#%$(>2'.(6$()%@$'$%">"2*"3*$%.(*4%2(%V$@%W.'D%92)4d%%1%T0'):$'%*262)")2.(%.T%

):$%L'"D.@%/)084%2/%):$%T"5)%):")%):$%8")"%.(%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%@$'$%.(*4%">"2*"3*$%T.'%"%

/03/$)%.T%):$%-"')252-"()/d%%%

Page 16 of 30

Page 18: Read the study online

!"#$%&a%

%

%V.($):$*$//A%):$%'$/0*)/%.T%):$%)@.%5.:.')%/)082$/A%.($%2(%1T'25"(`16$'25"(/%"(8%

I.62(25"(/%"(8%):$%.):$'%2(%9"05"/2"(/A%"'$%#$($'"**4%5.(/2/)$()%3.):%"5'.//%):$%T0**%'"(#$%.T%

$,-./0'$%"(8%'$/)'25)2(#%).%):$%5.66.(A%*.@$'%'"(#$d%%Z.%5.6-"'$%):$%)@.%82TT$'$()%/)082$/A%@$%

/)"(8"'82K$8%):$%$,-./0'$%$TT$5)%/2K$/%^vj?+_%"(8%T.0(8%):")%):$4%@$'$%/262*"'%2(%):$%)@.%5.:.')/%

")%"#$%=%4$"'/]%`Ed\R%^c=o%9<]`Jd\EA`\d&_%.(%Q9!F%2(%L'"D.@%^$()2'$%'"(#$_%5.6-"'$8%@2):%`

EdRH%^c=o%9<]%`Jd=cA%`\dRa_%T.'%M0**%?5"*$%<e%2(%):$%VW9%5.:.')%^!$'$'"%$)%"*d%E\\c3_d%Q$/)'25)2(#%

).%):$%5.66.(A%*.@$'%$,-./0'$%'"(#$A%):$%/)"(8"'82K$8%$,-./0'$%$TT$5)%/2K$%^vj?+_%@"/%`Ed=R%

^c=o%9<]%`Jd=EA%`\dR_%.(%Q9!F%2(%L'"D.@A%2(825")2(#%#$($'"*%5.(/2/)$(54%.T%'$/0*)/%"5'.//%):$/$%

)@.%82TT$'$()%5.:.')/%")%"#$%=%4$"'/d%%G$5"0/$%):$%VW9%"(8%L'"D.@%5.:.')/%'$-'$/$()%"%@28$%

'"(#$%.T%$,-./0'$/%$,-$'2$(5$8%2(%6"(4%.):$'%0'3"(%"'$"/A%/)084%'$/0*)/%2(%L'"D.@%"(8%VW9%"'$%

'$*$>"()%).%.):$'%-.-0*")2.(/%@.'*8@28$d%

1/%(.)$8A%):$'$%"'$%"%(063$'%.T%*262)")2.(/%2(%):2/%/)084d%Z:$4%2(5*08$%):$%/2(#*$%Jb`:.0'%

-'$(")"*%6.(2).'2(#A%):$%*"5D%.T%7hF+%<(>$().'4%8")"A%"(8%):$%T"5)%):")A%"*):.0#:%):$%-'$(")"*%

+Z?%g0$/)2.(("2'$%8")"%@$'$%>"*28")$8%34%5.)2(2($A%):$%$/)26")$%.T%-./)(")"*%+Z?%@"/%3"/$8%.(%

2()$'>2$@/%"*.($d%%%

% <(%/066"'4A%):$/$%'$/0*)/%2(825")$%):")%"2'3.'($%!17/%6"4%"8>$'/$*4%"TT$5)%5:2*8'$(;/%

5.#(2)2>$%8$>$*.-6$()%")%=%4$"'/%.T%"#$A%@2):%-.)$()2"*%26-*25")2.(/%T.'%/5:..*%-$'T.'6"(5$d%Z:$%

-'$/$()%T2(82(#/%"'$%.T%5.(5$'(%3$5"0/$%Q9!F%/5.'$/%6$"/0'$8%80'2(#%):$%-'$/5:..*%-$'2.8%

:">$%3$$(%/:.@(%).%5.''$*")$%@2):%"5"8$625%"5:2$>$6$()%*")$'%2(%*2T$%^G"*3.(2%$)%"*d%E\\cX%Q">$(%

E\\\_d%B$%"'$%5.()2(02(#%).%T.**.@%):2/%5.:.')%2(%.'8$'%).%8$)$'62($%*.(#$'`)$'6%$TT$5)/%.T%

-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%.(%3$:">2.'"*%.0)5.6$/%"(8%"5"8$625%'$"82($//d%%

Page 17 of 30

Page 19: Read the study online

!"#$%&b%

%

3050&0*(0$!

1'5:23.(#%1+A%<(4"(#%MA%Q"6$/:%1A%f'$$(@..8%FA%V"44"'%ZA%L.-/.630)%!A%$)%"*d%E\\Ed%

1*)$'")2.(%.T%-'$#("(54%'$*")$8%:.'6.($/%"(8%T$)"*%/0'>2>"*%2(%M`HJJ%'")/%$,-./$8%34%2(:"*")2.(%

).%3$(K.^"_-4'$($d%Q$-'.8%Z.,25.*%&R]b\&`b\bd%

1Z?IQd%&cc=d%Z.,25.*.#25"*%-'.T2*$%T.'%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%^!17/_d%1)*"()"A%f1]%

1#$(54%T.'%Z.,25%?03/)"(5$/%"(8%I2/$"/$%Q$#2/)'4A%Ud?d%I$-"')6$()%.T%7$"*):%"(8%706"(%

?$'>25$/A%!03*25%7$"*):%?$'>25$d%1>"2*"3*$]%:))-]jj@@@d")/8'd585d#.>j).,-'.T2*$/j)-Rcd:)6*%

l"55$//$8md%

G"*3.(2%fA%V"#*2$'2%C1A%903$**2%Qd%E\\cd%9.(50''$()%"(8%!'$825)2>$%P"*282)4%.T%):$%Q">$(%

!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%"(8%):$%V"#*2$'2%V.(>$'3"*%132*2)4%Z$/)d%C.0'("*%.T%!/45:.$805")2.("*%

1//$//6$()%-03*2/:$8%.(%10#0/)%E=A%E\\c%"/%8.2]%&\d&&aaj\aHJEbEc\cHJHaRH]%

G"'D$'%ICd%E\\Jd%Z:$%8$>$*.-6$()"*%.'2#2(/%.T%"80*)%82/$"/$d%C%16%9.**%V0)'%EH]=bb?`=c=?d%

G$**2(#$'%IA%O$>2).(%1A%B")$'("0,%9d%&cbcd%O$"8%<e%"(8%/.52"*%5*"//d%<()$'(")2.("*%i.0'("*%.T%

$-28$62.*.#4%&b]&b\`&b=d%

G$'($')%CZA%Z0'($'%B+A%!2'D*$%COA%?./(.TT%9?A%1D2(/%CQA%B"*8'$-%FLA%$)%"*d%&ccad%

I$>$*.-6$()%"(8%>"*28")2.(%.T%/$(/2)2>$%6$):.8%T.'%8$)$'62(")2.(%.T%/$'06%5.)2(2($%2(%/6.D$'/%

"(8%(.(/6.D$'/%34%*2g028%5:'.6").#'"-:4j")6./-:$'25%-'$//0'$%2.(2K")2.(%)"(8$6%6"//%

/-$5)'.6$)'4d%9*2(25"*%9:$62/)'4%JH]EEb&`EEc&d%

G'"8*$4%Q7A%9.'@4(%QMA%B:2)$/28$`F"(/$**%Od%&ccRd%O2T$%")%:.6$]%/"6$%)26$A%82TT$'$()%-*"5$/`

"(%$,"62(")2.(%.T%):$%7hF+%2(>$().'4%2(%82TT$'$()%50*)0'$/d%+"'*4%I$>$*.-6$()%z%!"'$()2(#%

=]E=&`ERcd%

G02%eeA%Z'"(%FGA%B$/)%BOd%&cbRd%1%5.6-"'")2>$%/)084%.T%):$%'$-'.805)2>$%$TT$5)/%.T%

6$):"8.($%"(8%3$(K.^"_-4'$($%2(%):$%-'$#("()%"(8%-/$08.-'$#("()%'")d%Z.,25.*.#4%JE]&c=`E\Jd%

Page 18 of 30

Page 20: Read the study online

!"#$%&c%

%

9"6"((%I+A%B:4"))%QFd%E\\&d%Q$)$()2.(%"(8%/).'"#$%/)"32*2)4%.T%-$/)2528$/%"(8%!17%2(%!UM%"2'%

/"6-*$/d%<(]%!'.5$$82(#/%.T%):$%&&):%1((0"*%F$$)2(#%.T%<()$'(")2.("*%?.52$)4%.T%+,-./0'$%

1("*4/2/A%{&aEd%9:"'*$/).(A%?9]%<()$'(")2.("*%?.52$)4%.T%+,-./0'$%1("*4/2/d%

9:.2%7A%C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%?-$(#*$'%CA%9"6"((%I+A%B:4"))%QFA%Q"0:%PA%$)%"*d%E\\Rd%

<()$'(")2.("*%/)082$/%.T%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%"(8%T$)"*%#'.@):d%

+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&J]&aJJ`&a=\d%

9:.2%7A%!$'$'"%M!A%!"5%1A%B"(#%OA%M*"D%+A%F'.K%+A%$)%"*d%E\\b%+/)26")2(#%<(82>280"*`O$>$*%

+,-./0'$%).%12'3.'($%!.*4545*25%1'.6")25%748'.5"'3.(/%):'.0#:.0)%):$%f$/)")2.("*%!$'2.8%

G"/$8%.(%!$'/.("*A%<(8..'A%"(8%h0)8..'%F.(2).'2(#%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&R]&=\c`&=&bd%

9.0()$'%?1A%G05:"("(%O7A%h')$#"%Md%E\\=d%V$0'.5.#(2)2>$%26-"2'6$()%2(%*$"8`$,-./$8%

5:2*8'$(%.T%1(8$"(%*$"8`#*"K2(#%@.'D$'/d%C%h550-%+(>2'.(%F$8%Ja]H\R`H&Ed%

9.0()$'%?1A%G05:"("(%O7A%h')$#"%Md%E\\cd%V$0'.5.#(2)2>$%/5'$$(2(#%.T%*$"8`$,-./$8%1(8$"(%

"8.*$/5$()/%"(8%4.0(#%"80*)/d%C.0'("*%.T%Z.,25.*.#4%"(8%+(>2'.(6$()"*%7$"*):A%!"')%1%aE]RE=`

RHEd%

I")$%1QA%f'"4%1Od%&cbcd%1--*25")2.(/%.T%2(805)2>$*4%5.0-*$8%-*"/6"%6"//%/-$5)'.6$)'4d%V$@%

W.'DA%VW]%9:"-6"(%"(8%7"**d%

I$i6$D%CA%?.*"(/D4%<A%G$($/%<A%O$(25$D%CA%?'"6%QCd%E\\\d%Z:$%26-"5)%.T%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%

:48'.5"'3.(/%"(8%T2($%-"')25*$/%.(%-'$#("(54%.0)5.6$d%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&\b]&&=c`&&RJd%

I$F"0'.%f+d%E\\\d%Q$>2$@%.T%):$%).(2`Ed%?$5.(8%$82)2.(d%F$()"*%F$"/0'$6$()/%W$"'3..Dd%

+/D$("K2%GA%9"/).'2("%Qd%&cccd%1//.52")2.(%.T%-'$(")"*%6")$'("*%.'%-./)(")"*%5:2*8%

$(>2'.(6$()"*%).3"55.%/6.D$%$,-./0'$%"(8%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()"*%"(8%3$:">2.'"*%-'.3*$6/%2(%

5:2*8'$(d%+(>2'.(6$()"*%:$"*):%-$'/-$5)2>$/%&\a]cc&`&\\d%

Page 19 of 30

Page 21: Read the study online

!"#$%E\%

%

7"5D%FA%G'$/*"0%VA%B$2//6"(%GA%1'"6%IA%L*$2(%VA%G.'"@/D2%+d%&cc&d%+TT$5)%.T%>$'4%*.@%32'):%

@$2#:)%"(8%/03(.'6"*%:$"8%/2K$%.(%5.#(2)2>$%"32*2)4%")%/5:..*%"#$d%Z:$%V$@%+(#*"(8%i.0'("*%.T%

6$8252($%HE=]EH&`EHad%

C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%G$(8D.@/D"%<A%M*"D%+A%!$("'%1A%C"5$D%QA%L"26%<A%$)%"*d%E\\Jd%+/)26")$8%'2/D%

T.'%"*)$'$8%T$)"*%#'.@):%'$/0*)2(#%T'.6%$,-./0'$%).%T2($%-"')25*$/%80'2(#%-'$#("(54]%"(%

$-28$62.*.#25%-'./-$5)2>$%5.:.')%/)084%2(%!.*"(8d%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&E]&Hcb`&J\Ed%

C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%!"5%1A%9:.2%7A%C"5$D%QA%?.5:"5D"`Z")"'"%+A%I064":(%Z?A%$)%"*d%E\\ad%

!$'/.("*%$,-./0'$%).%T2($%-"')25*$/%"(8%3$(K.l"m-4'$($d%Q$*")2.(%@2):%2(8..'%"(8%.0)8..'%

5.(5$()'")2.(/%.T%):$/$%-.**0)"()/%2(%L'"D.@d%<()%C%h550-%F$8%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%E\]HHc`HJbd%

C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%!$'$'"%MA%C"(D.@/D2%CA%F'.K$D`G08K4(%IA%F'.K%+A%M*"D%+A%$)%"*d%E\\c"d%

f$(8$'%/-$52T25%82TT$'$(5$/%2(%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()"*%$TT$5)/%.T%-'$(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%>$'4%*.@`*$"8%

*$>$*/]%Z:$%-'./-$5)2>$%5.:.')%/)084%2(%):'$$`4$"'%.*8/d%d%+"'*4%706%I$>%b=]=\H`=&\d%

C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%!$'$'"%MA%C"(D.@/D2%CA%F'.K$D`G08K4(%IA%F'.K%+A%M*"D%+A%$)%"*d%E\\c3d%P$'4%

O.@%!'$(")"*%+,-./0'$%).%O$"8%"(8%F$()"*%I$>$*.-6$()%.T%9:2*8'$(%2(%<(T"(54%"(8%+"'*4%

9:2*8:..8d%L'"D.@%!'./-$5)2>$%9.:.')%?)084d%V$0'.$-28$62.*.#4%HE]Ea\`Eabd%

L"#"(%CA%F.//%7d%&c=cd%!"'$()"*%5.''$*")$/%.T%5:2*8|/%<e%"(8%:$2#:)]%"%5'.//`>"*28")2.(%.T%):$%

G$'D$*$4%#'.@):%/)084%'$/0*)/d%9:2*8%8$>$*.-6$()%H\]HE=`HHEd%

O2%NA%Q.6"(.TT%O9A%Z'2(28"8%I1A%70//"2(%VA%C.($/%Q?A%!.')$'%+VA%$)%"*d%E\\Rd%F$"/0'$6$()%.T%

0'2("'4%6.(.:48'.,4%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%0/2(#%"0).6")$8%*2g028`*2g028%$,)'"5)2.(%

"(8%#"/%5:'.6").#'"-:4j2/.).-$%82*0)2.(%:2#:`'$/.*0)2.(%6"//%/-$5)'.6$)'4d%1("*%9:$6%

ab]=aJJ`=a=&d%

F"(5:$/)$'%ILA%f.'8.(%?LA%f.*"/%9OA%Q.3$')/%+1A%hD$4%1Gd%&cbad%1:%'$5$-).'%2(%:06"(%

-*"5$()"]%/)"32*2K")2.(%34%6.*438")$%"(8%5:"'"5)$'2K")2.(%.T%32(82(#%.T%EAHAaAb`

Page 20 of 30

Page 22: Read the study online

!"#$%E&%

%

)$)'"5:*.'.823$(K.`-`82.,2(A%H`6$):4*5:.*"():'$($A%"(8%3$(K.^"_-4'$($d%9"(5$'%Q$/%Ja]JbR&`

JbRbd%

F51/D2$%FA%9*"'D$%1d%&caRd%!"'$()`hTT/-'2(#%'$/$63*"(5$/%2(%2()$**2#$(5$`Z:$.'2$/%"(8%

$>28$(5$d%G'2)2/:%C.0'("*%.T%!/45:.*.#4%Ra]EJH`EaH%%

F$)K$'%QA%I$*#"8.%COA%7$''$**%Qd%&cc=d%+(>2'.(6$()"*%7$"*):%"(8%72/-"(25%9:2*8'$(d%

+(>2'.(6$()"*%:$"*):%-$'/-$5)2>$/%&\H]E=`HEd%

V$03$')%IA%Z"-D$(%?d%&cbbd%Z'"(/T$'%.T%3$(K.^"_-4'$($%2().%6.0/$%$63'4./%"(8%T$)0/$/d%1'5:%

Z.,25.*%RE]EHR`EHcd%

V25.*%9CA%7"''2/.(%FOA%O"-./"%QQA%f26$*/:)$2(%<OA%B$**/%!fd%&cc=d%1%)$'").*.#25%/0--'$//.'%

'.*$%T.'%-=H%2(%3$(K.l"m-4'$($`)'$")$8%)'"(/#$(25%-=H`8$T252$()%625$d%V")%f$($)%&\]&b&`&bad%

V.3*$%LA%F59"(8*2//%Gd%E\\=d%Q$"82(#%8$>$*.-6$()%"(8%26-"2'6$()]%G$:">2.'"*A%/.52"*A%"(8%

($0'.32.*.#25"*%T"5).'/d%C.0'("*%.T%I$>$*.-6$()"*%"(8%G$:">2.'"*%!$82")'25/%ER]Ha\`Habd%

VQ9d%&ccH"d%<//0$/%2(%Q2/D%1//$//6$()d%B"/:2(#).(A%I9]%V")2.("*%15"8$64%!'$//d%

VQ9d%&ccH3d%!$/)2528$/%2(%):$%82$)/%.T%2(T"()/%"(8%5:2*8'$(d%B"/:2(#).(A%I9]%V")2.("*%15"8$64%

!'$//d%

!$'$'"%MA%Z"(#%IA%B:4"))%QA%O$8$'6"(%?1A%C$8'45:.@/D2%Bd%E\\=d%IV1%8"6"#$%T'.6%

-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%6$"/0'$8%34%3$(K.l"m-4'$($`IV1%"8805)/%2(%6.):$'/%"(8%

($@3.'(/%T'.6%V.'):$'(%F"(:"))"(A%):$%B.'*8%Z'"8$%9$()$'%1'$"A%!.*"(8A%"(8%9:2("d%9"(5$'%

+-28$62.*%G2.6"'D$'/%!'$>%&J]a\c`a&Jd%

!$'$'"%MA%Z"(#%BWA%7$'3/)6"(%CA%Z"(#%IA%O$>2(%OA%F2**$'%QA%$)%"*d%E\\c"d%Q$*")2.(%.T%IV1%

6$):4*")2.(%.T%=|`9-f%2/*"(8%.T%19?OH%).%)'"(/-*"5$()"*%$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%-.*4545*25%

"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%"(8%5:2*8:..8%"/):6"d%!O.?%hV+%J]$JJbbd%

Page 21 of 30

Page 23: Read the study online

!"#$%EE%

%

!$'$'"%M!A%O2%NA%B:4"))%QA%7.$-($'%OA%B"(#%?A%9"6"((%IA%$)%"*d%E\\c3d%!'$(")"*%-.*4545*25%

"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(%$,-./0'$%"(8%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%")%"#$%=d%!$82")'25/%&EJ]$&c=`$E\Ed%

!$'$'"%M!A%Q"0:%PA%Z/"2%BWA%L2(($4%!A%9"6"((%IA%G"''%IA%$)%"*d%E\\Hd%+TT$5)/%.T%)'"(/-*"5$()"*%

$,-./0'$%).%$(>2'.(6$()"*%-.**0)"()/%.(%32'):%.0)5.6$/%2(%"%60*)2`$):(25%-.-0*")2.(d%+(>2'.(%

7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&&]E\&`E\=d%

!$'$'"%M!A%Q"0:%PA%B:4"))%QFA%Z/"2%BWA%Z"(#%IA%I2"K%IA%$)%"*d%E\\Rd%+TT$5)%.T%-'$(")"*%

$,-./0'$%).%"2'3.'($%-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(/%.(%($0'.8$>$*.-6$()%2(%):$%T2'/)%H%4$"'/%

.T%*2T$%"6.(#%2(($'`52)4%5:2*8'$(d%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&J]&Eba`&EcEd%

Q"0:%P1A%B:4"))%QFA%f"'T2(D$*%QA%1(8'$@/%7A%7.$-($'%OA%Q$4$/%1A%$)%"*d%E\\Jd%

I$>$*.-6$()"*%$TT$5)/%.T%$,-./0'$%).%$(>2'.(6$()"*%).3"55.%/6.D$%"(8%6")$'2"*%:"'8/:2-%

"6.(#%2(($'`52)4%5:2*8'$(d%V$0'.).,25.*%Z$'").*%ER]HaH`Hb=d%

Q">$(%Cd%E\\\d%F"(0"*%T.'%Q">$(|/%-'.#'$//2>$%6")'25$/%"(8%>.5"30*"'4%/5"*$/]%'$/$"'5:%

/0--*$6$()%(.d%Hd%O.(8.(]%h,T.'8%!/45:.*.#2/)/%!'$//%O)8d%

Q">$(%CA%Q">$(%C9A%9.0')%C7d%&ccbd%F"(0"*%T.'%Q">$(|/%-'.#'$//2>$%6")'25$/%"(8%>.5"30*"'4%

/5"*$/]%/$5)2.(%E%5.*.0'$8%-'.#'$//2>$%6")'25$/d%O.(8.(]%h,T.'8%!/45:.*.#2/)/%!'$//%O)8d%

Q.82$'%!Fd%E\\Jd%+(>2'.(6$()"*%5"0/$/%.T%5$()'"*%($'>.0/%/4/)$6%6"*8$>$*.-6$()d%!$82")'25/%

&&H]&\aR`&\bHd%

?"))*$'%Cd%&cbRd%1//$//6$()%.T%9:2*8'$(d%H'8%$82)2.(%$8d%?"(%I2$#.]%C$'.6$%Fd%?"))*$'A%!03*2/:$'A%

<(5d%

?"0(8$'/%9QA%I"/%?LA%Q"6$/:%1A%?:.5D*$4%I9A%F0D:$'i$$%?d%E\\Rd%G$(K.^"_-4'$($`2(805$8%

"50)$%($0'.).,252)4%2(%):$%M`HJJ%'")]%'.*$%.T%.,28")2>$%/)'$//d%C%1--*%Z.,25.*%ER]JEa`JHbd%

?5:@"')K%Cd%E\\Jd%12'%-.**0)2.(%"(8%5:2*8'$(|/%:$"*):d%!$82")'25/%&&H]&\Ha`&\JHd%

Page 22 of 30

Page 24: Read the study online

!"#$%EH%

%

?2K$6.'$%hA%16*$'%Qd%&ccRd%9:"'"5)$'2/)25/%.T%1Z?IQ|/%"80*)%"(8%-$82")'25%$(>2'.(6$()"*%

($0'.3$:">2.'"*%)$/)%3"))$'2$/d%d%V$0'.).,25.*.#4%&a]EEc`EHRd%

?'"6%QCA%G2(D.>"%Gd%E\\\d%F.*$50*"'%$-28$62.*.#4%/)082$/%.(%.550-")2.("*%"(8%$(>2'.(6$()"*%

$,-./0'$%).%60)"#$(/%"(8%5"'52(.#$(/A%&cca`&cccd%+(>2'.(6$()"*%:$"*):%-$'/-$5)2>$/%&\b%=a`

a\d%

?K0/)'.@"%ZC1d%&ccEd%!.8'$5K(2D%8.%)$/)0%6")'45%Q">$("A%@$'/i"%D.*.'.@"%^&c=R_d%B"'/K"@"]%

!'"5.@(2"%Z$/).@%!/45:.*.#25K4(5:%!.*/D2$#.%Z.@"'K4/)@"%!/545:.*.#25($#.d%

Z"D$8"%LA%Z/0D0$%VA%W./:28"%?d%E\\Jd%+(8.5'2($`82/'0-)2(#%"5)2>2)4%.T%5:$625"*/%2(%82$/$*%

$,:"0/)%"(8%82$/$*%$,:"0/)%-"')25*$/d%+(>2'.(%?52%&&]HH`J=d%

Z.(($%99A%B:4"))%QFA%9"6"((%I+A%!$'$'"%M!A%L2(($4%!Od%E\\Jd%!'$825).'/%.T%-$'/.("*%

-.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(%$,-./0'$/%"6.(#%-'$#("()%62(.'2)4%@.6$(%2(%V$@%W.'D%92)4d%

+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&&E]a=J`a=cd%

P"')2"2($(%+A%?$--"*"%ZA%O2**/0(8$%!A%!0/D"%!d%E\\Ed%P"*28")2.(%.T%/$*T%'$-.')$8%/6.D2(#%34%

/$'06%5.)2(2($%6$"/0'$6$()%2(%"%5.660(2)4`3"/$8%/)084d%C%+-28$62.*%9.660(2)4%7$"*):%

=R]&Ra`&a\d%

B:4"))%QFA%G$**%I1A%?"()$**"%QFA%f"')$%?CA%C$8'45:.@/D2%BA%f*"8$D`W"'3.'.0#:%1A%$)%"*d%

&ccbd%!.*4545*25%"'.6")25%:48'.5"'3.(`IV1%"8805)/%2(%:06"(%-*"5$()"%"(8%6.80*")2.(%34%

9W!&1&%2(805)2.(%"(8%#$(.)4-$d%9"'52(.#$($/2/%&c]&Hbc`&HcEd%

B:4"))%QFA%!$'$'"%M!d%&cc=d%1--*25")2.(%.T%32.*.#25%6"'D$'/%).%/)082$/%.T%$(>2'.(6$()"*%'2/D/%

2(%5:2*8'$(%"(8%):$%8$>$*.-2(#%T$)0/d%+(>2'.(%7$"*):%!$'/-$5)%&\H]&\=`&&\d%

B2*/.(%POA%C.($/%!1d%&cbHd%<(:232)2.(%.T%IV1%6$):4*")2.(%34%5:$625"*%5"'52(.#$(/%2(%>2)'.d%

9$**%HE]EHc`EJRd%

Page 23 of 30

Page 25: Read the study online

!"#$%EJ%

%

B..8%L1A%W.0*$%QCd%&cc=d%Z:$%'.*$%.T%T'$$%'"825"*/%"(8%-=H%2(%($0'.(%"-.-)./2/%2(%>2>.d%C%

V$0'./52$(5$%&=]=b=&`=b=ad%

B.'*8%7$"*):%h'#"(2K")2.(d%&cbRd%!'2(52-*$/%T.'%$>"*0")2(#%:$"*):%'2/D/%T'.6%5:$625"*/%80'2(#%

2(T"(54%"(8%$"'*4%5:2*8:..8]%Z:$%($$8%T.'%"%/-$52"*%"--'."5:d%<(]%+(>2'.(6$()"*%7$"*):%9'2)$'2"%

=cd%f$($>"A%?@2)K$'*"(8]%%B.'*8%7$"*):%h'#"(2K")2.(d%

B.'6*$4%IIA%Q"6$/:%1A%7..8%IGd%E\\Jd%+(>2'.(6$()"*%5.()"62("()`62,)0'$%$TT$5)/%.(%9V?%

8$>$*.-6$()A%-*"/)252)4A%"(8%3$:">2.'d%Z.,25.*%1--*%!:"'6"5.*%&ca]Jc`R=d%

%

Page 24 of 30

Page 26: Read the study online

!"#$%E=%

%

6'#10!78%L'"D.@%9.:.')]%?03/$)%@2):%"2'3.'($%!.*4545*25%1'.6")25%748'.5"'3.(%^!17_%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%"(8%Q">$(%9.*.0'$8%

!'.#'$//2>$%F")'25$/%^Q9!F_%8")"%^E&c_"%>/d%?03/$)%@2):%"2'3.'($%!17%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%30)%62//2(#%Q9!F%8")"%^&Hc_%%

! ! ?03/$)%@2):%"2'3.'($%!17%

6.(2).'2(#%"(8%Q9!F%%

?03/$)%@2):%"2'3.'($%!17%

6.(2).'2(#%30)%62//2(#%Q9!F%%

9.()2(0.0/%P"'2"3*$/% -`>"*0$3% F$"(%u%?I% V

5% F$"(%u%?I%% V8%

Z.)"*%>"*28%"2'3.'($%!17%$,-./0'$%^(#j6H_% \dR=% HcdRE%u%JbdJc% E&c% HcdHc%u%Jada\% &E=%

I2$)"'4%$,-./0'$%).%!17/%80'2(#%-'$#("(54$% \dH&% JEdJc%u%=dR=% E&c% JHd&J%u%RdEa% &Hc%

9.'8%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*%^(#j6O_%% \dJc% Ed\J%u%&&d=E% E&c% HdEc%u%&=d=R% &Hb%

9.'8%3*..8%*$"8%*$>$*%^}#j8*_% \d=c% &dR\%u%&d&c% E&\% &d=&%u%\dab% &Ec%

9.'8%3*..8%6$'50'4%*$>$*%^}#j8*_% \dJH% &d\a%u%\dRJ% &R&% &d&R%u%\dac% &\R%

f$/)")2.("*%"#$%^8"4/_%% \d\a% HcdER%u%&daH% E&c% Hcd=&%u%&dRH% &Hc%

G2'):%@$2#:)%^#_% \d\&% HHRbdJc%u%=\bdHb% E&c% H=\&dR=%u%JaJdEE% &Hc%

G2'):%:$2#:)%^56_% \daR% =JdJJ%u%Hd\R% E&c% =Jd=J%u%Hd&\% &Hc%

7$"8%52'506T$'$(5$%")%32'):%^56_% \dE&% HHdb&%u%&d=J% E&c% HJd\&%u%&dJa% &Hc%

F.):$';/%"#$%^4$"'/_% \d\&% Ebd=\%u%Hd=c% E&c% EadJc%u%HdaH% &Hc%

F")$'("*%:$2#:)%^56_% \d&b% &RJdRc%u%=da&% E&c% &R=d=E%u%=d=c% &Hc%

F")$'("*%-'$`-'$#("(54%@$2#:)%^D#_% \dc=% =bdJJ%u%bdb\% E&c% =bd=\%u%cdHE% &Hc%

F")$'("*%)$/)%.T%(.(`>$'3"*%2()$**2#$(5$%^ZhV<`H_%% \dEH% HHdJb%u%cd\a% &aR% H&dJE%u%cda&% H&%

Page 25 of 30

Page 27: Read the study online

!"#$%ER%

%

F")$'("*%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*%")%32'):%^(#j6O_%% \dca% &dRb%u%&\d\c% E&c% Edcc%u%&JdHJ% &Hb%

F")$'("*%3*..8%*$"8%*$>$*%")%32'):%^}#j8*_% \dac% &dcE%u%\dbH% E\c% &dbR%u%\dRR% &HR%

9")$#.'25"*%P"'2"3*$/% -`>"*0$T% !'.-.')2.(% V% !'.-.')2.(% V%

9"05"/2"(%Q"5$% &d\\% &d\\% E&c% &d\\% &Hc%

F")$'("*%$805")2.(%^-'.-.')2.(%#'"80")$8%:2#:%/5:..*A%

2d$d%&E%4$"'/%.T%/5:..*2(#_%

\dJa% \dc&% E&c% \dbb% &Hc%

+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$%^4$/k&A%(.k\_% \d=E% \dEE% E&c% \dE=% &Hc%

+,-./0'$%).%"*5.:.*%80'2(#%-'$#("(54%^4$/k&A%(.k\_% \d&b% \dR\% E&c% \dRa% &Hc%

?$,%.T%):$%5:2*8%^-'.-.')2.(%T$6"*$_% \d=E% \d=E% E&c% \dJb% &Hc%

"%16.(#%):$/$%E&c%6.):$'`5:2*8%-"2'/%@2):%>"*28%!17%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%"(8%5.6-*$)$%Q9!F%8")"A%=%-"2'/%:"8%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*/%

w%E=(#j6O%"(8%@$'$%(.)%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%/"6-*$%/2K$%.T%E&J%-'$/$()$8%2(%.0'%T2("*%6.8$*%^Z"3*$%H_d%F.):$'`5:2*8%-"2'/%2(5*08$8%2(%

Z"3*$%&%@$'$%(.)%'$/)'25)$8%3"/$8%.(%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*A%"/%@$%):.0#:)%):2/%62#:)%32"/%.0'%5.6-"'2/.(/d%

3%-`>"*0$/%@$'$%#$($'")$8%34%)@.%/"6-*$%)`)$/)/A%$,5$-)%T.'%5.'8%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*A%6")$'("*%)$/)%.T%(.(`>$'3"*%2()$**2#$(5$A%

6")$'("*%3*..8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*%")%32'):A%"(8%#$/)")2.("*%"#$A%@:25:%@$'$%(.)%(.'6"**4%82/)'230)$8A%"(8%T.'%@:25:%(.(`-"'"6$)'25%

B2*5.,.(%)$/)/%@$'$%):$'$T.'$%0/$8d%%%%

5%<T%):$%/"6-*$%/2K$%2/%pE&cA%/.6$%/03i$5)/%"'$%62//2(#%8")"%.(%):$%>"'2"3*$%2(%g0$/)2.(d%

8%<T%):$%/"6-*$%/2K$%2/%p&HcA%/.6$%/03i$5)/%"'$%62//2(#%8")"%.(%):$%>"'2"3*$%2(%g0$/)2.(d%<(%):$%5"/$%.T%!17%$,-./0'$%*$>$*/A%.(*4%

&E=%.T%&Hc%:"8%>"*28%!17%8")"X%2d$dA%6$$)2(#%g0"*2)4%5.()'.*%/)"(8"'8/d%%%%

Page 26 of 30

Page 28: Read the study online

!"#$%Ea%

%

$%$/)26")$8%34%):$%T'$g0$(54%.T%2()"D$%.T%!17`5.()"2(2(#%T..8/%80'2(#%-'$#("(54A%"/%'$-.')$8%2(%):$%-'$(")"*%g0$/)2.(("2'$%34%):$%

6.):$'%

T%-`>"*0$/%@$'$%#$($'")$8%34%M2/:$'%+,"5)%)$/)

Page 27 of 30

Page 29: Read the study online

!"#$%Eb%

%

6'#10!9:%L'"D.@%9.:.')]%?-$"'6"(%9.''$*")2.(/%^5.''$*")2.(%5.$TT252$()%'A%-`>"*0$%^V__%%

% +Z?% F")$'("*%5.)2(2($% 9.'8%5.)2(2($% Z.)"*%"2'3.'($%!17/%

M0**4%$('.**$8%-"')252-"()/%@2):%"8$g0")$%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%%

I2$)"'4%!17% \d\cA%\d&&%^HJJ_% `\d\EA%\da\%^HJH_% \d\HA%\dR\%^HJH_% \d\RA%\dE=%^HJJ_%

+Z?% % \dJbA%p\d\&%^HJH_% \dJaA%p\d\&%^HJH_% `\d\=A%\dHb%^HJJ_%

F")$'("*%5.)2(2($% ``% % \db=A%p\d\&%^HJH_% \d\bA%\d&=%^HJH_%

9.'8%5.)2(2($% ``% ``% % \d\HA%\d=H%^HJH_%

?03/$)%.T%5:2*8'$(%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%-'$/$()%"("*4/2/%^VkE&J_"%%

I2$)"'4%!17% \d&cA%\d\&% `\d\JA%\d=a% `\d\JA%\d=J% \d\=A%\dJR%

+Z?% % \dJbA%p\d\&% \dJRA%p\d\&% `\d\=A%\d=\%

F")$'("*%5.)2(2($% ``% % \dccA%p\d\&% \d\EA%\da=%

9.'8%5.)2(2($% ``% ``% % \d\JA%\dR\%

"%Z:2/%/03/$)%$,5*08$/%/03i$5)/%@2):%6.(2).'2(#%8")"%(.)%6$$)2(#%g0"*2)4%5.()'.*%5'2)$'2"A%@2):%6")$'("*%

.'%5.'8%5.)2(2($%*$>$*/%w%E=%(#j6OA%"(8%2T%"(4%.T%):$%T.**.@2(#%8")"%"'$%62//2(#]%5:2*8%Q9!F%/5.'$A%

-'$(")"*%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$A%/$,%.T%5:2*8A%.'%6")$'("*%$805")2.(d%%

%

%

%

Page 28 of 30

Page 30: Read the study online

!"#$%Ec%

%

6'#10!;:!1//.52")2.(%G$)@$$(%!'$(")"*%+,-./0'$%).%12'3.'($%!17/%"(8%Q9!F%?5.'$%")%1#$%=%

W$"'/%2(%):$%L'"D.@%9.:.')%^VkE&J_%"A%3!!

!"#$%& '& &()*&+,& -./0123& !"#$%& '& &()*&+,& -./0123&

!17%

^:2#:j*.@_% .$456& .#4%7& .84#5& 848#& O(^!17_% .84)6& .$488& .84$$& 848#&

+Z?%2(%):$%

:.6$5% .$475& .545& .8456& 848#&

+Z?%2(%):$%

:.6$% .$476& .545#& .845(& 848#&

/$,%.T%

5:2*88% 84)9& .84)6& $46(& 8455& /$,%.T%5:2*8% 84)%& .84)7& $469& 845)&

6")$'("*%

$805")2.($% 847$& .$45#& #4(5& 84%6& &

6")$'("*%

$805")2.(% 849)& .$457& #479& 84)8&"%Z:2/%)"3*$%-'$/$()/%)@.%6.8$*/%/28$%34%/28$A%.($%@2):%825:.).6.0/%!17%%^q:2#:j*.@r_%"(8%.($%

@2):%5.()2(0.0/%O(`)'"(/T.'6$8%!17%^qO(^!17_r_d%Z:$4%3.):%"8i0/)%T.'%-'$(")"*%+Z?%2(%):$%

:.6$A%/$,%.T%):$%5:2*8A%"(8%6")$'("*%$805")2.(d%

3%1/%(.)$8%2(%):$%)$,)A%"T)$'%T0'):$'%2(5*082(#%6")$'("*%2()$**2#$(5$%^0/2(#%5.()2(0.0/%ZhV<`H%

/5.'$_%@:25:%@"/%/2#(2T25"()*4%"//.52")$8%@2):%5:2*8%2()$**2#$(5$%2(%):$%6.8$*A%):$%3$)"/%"(8%-`

>"*0$/%T.'%!17%3.):%:2#:j*.@%"(8%O(`)'"(/T.'6$8%@$'$%/262*"'%"(8%/2#(2T25"()%^Vk&a&_d%O$"8A%

82$)"'4%!17/A%32'):%@$2#:)A%32'):%:$"8%52'506T$'$(5$A%2(82>280"*%5'$")2(2($`"8i0/)$8%!17%

6$)"3.*2)$/%T'.6%0'2($A%6")$'("*%'$-.')%.T%-./)(")"*%$,-./0'$%).%+Z?%2(%):$%:.6$A%"(8%@:$):$'%

):$%5:2*8%5:"(#$8%'$/28$(5$%-./)(")"**4A%@$'$%(.)%/2#(2T25"()%-'$825).'/%^-p\d&_%"(8%@$'$%

):$'$T.'$%(.)%2(5*08$8%2(%):$%T2("*%6.8$*%-'$/$()$8%:$'$d%

5%6")$'("*%'$-.')%.T%/6.D$%2(%):$%:.6$%80'2(#%-'$#("(54]%4$/k&A(.k\%

8%T$6"*$k&A6"*$k\%

$%#'"80")$8%T'.6%:2#:%/5:..*A%2d$d%5.6-*$)$8%&E%4$"'/%.T%/5:..*2(#]%4$/k&A%(.k\

Page 29 of 30

Page 31: Read the study online

!"#$%H\%

% % %

6'#10!<:!1//.52")2.(%G$)@$$(%!'$(")"*%+,-./0'$%).%12'3.'($%!17/%"(8%Q9!F%?5.'$%")%1#$%=%

W$"'/%2(%):$%L'"D.@%9.:.')%<(5*082(#%.(*4%?03i$5)/%B:./$%!17%+,-./0'$%@"/%B2):2(%):$%

9.66.(%+,-./0'$%Q"(#$%G$)@$$(%):$%VW9%"(8%L'"D.@%9.:.')/%^\dEa`JJdb&%(#j6H_!!

!"$)8& '& ()*&+,& -./0123& & !"$)8& '& ()*&+,& -./0123&

:;<&=>?@>A1BCD& .$46#& .#4(7& .84#6& 848#& & EF=:;<D& .$4#%& .#48)& .84%5& G848$&

HIJ& .#489& .549)& .8457& 848#& & HIJ& .$4($& .54)7& .84#)& 848#&

K3L&BM&N>?1O& 8465& .8495& $4((& 8459& & K3L&BM&N>?1O& 8495& .846$& #489& 84#7&

P0Q3RF01&

3O2N0Q?BF& 8499& .#48#& 54)9& 84)(& &

P0Q3RF01&

3O2N0Q?BF& $488& .$499& 5499& 84%7&

!

!

%

!

!

Page 30 of 30