rda: thinking globally, acting globally gordon dunsire presented at international developments in...
DESCRIPTION
BibO: Bibliographic Ontology Confusing tongues? BIBFRAME: Bibliographic Framework Say what we mean CRM: Conceptual Reference Model DC: Dublin Core FR: Functional Requirements ISBD: International Standard Bibliographic Description MARC21 RDA: Resource Description and Access schema.org UNIMARC KOS++ Universal Bibliographic Control RDF Thinking globally Acting locallyTRANSCRIPT
RDA: thinking globally, acting globallyGordon Dunsire
Presented at International Developments in Library Linked Data: Think Globally, Act Globally – Part Two: an ALCTS
Program,ALA Annual, Las Vegas, USA, 28 Jun 2014
Overview
Failure of top-down approachRDA toolsCase: intended audienceMapping the focus of descriptionTop-down, bottom-up issues
BibO:BibliographicOntology
Confusingtongues?
BIBFRAME:BibliographicFramework Say what
we meanCRM: ConceptualReference Model
DC: Dublin Core
FR: FunctionalRequirements
ISBD: International StandardBibliographic Description
MARC21RDA: ResourceDescriptionand Access
schema.orgUNIMARC
KOS++
UniversalBibliographicControl
RDF
Thinking globally
Acting locally
For unFRBRizedapplications
30 million (partial) examples
Links to othervocabularies
Element set +Relationshipdesignators
Globalizing RDA linked data
Language-neutralURIs
(immutable)
Language-specificURIs
(for developers)
Language-specificlabels and definitions
(for humans)
Unconstrainedversions
Map of“Audience”
umarc:m “adult, general”
“adult, serious”
pbcore:adult “adult”
m21:e “adult”
MPAA:NC-17?
BBFC:18?
Element sets (schema)
Value vocabularies (KOS)Broader/narrower/same?
m21:“Target audience of …”
m21:“Target audience” schema:
“audience”
dct:“audience”
rdau:“Intended audience”
isbd:“has note on use or audience”
isbdu:“has note on use or audience”
rdfs:subPropertyOf
umarc:k
bf:“Intended audience”
frbrer:“has intended audience”
rdaw:“Intended audience”
isbd:Resource
bf:Work
bf:Instance
rda:Work
rda:Expression
rda:Manifestation
rda:Item
isbd:P1193 (has work aspect )
isbd:P1190(has expression aspect )
isbd:P1192(has manifestation aspect )
isbd:P1191 (has item aspect )
rdae:P20231 (has work expressed)
rdai:P40049 (has manifestation exemplified)
rdam:P30139(has expressionmanifested)
bf:instanceOf
bf:expressionOf
marc21:Resource
?
Mappingentities
Top-downExamine local schema Identify the common elementsCreate a common/global element set (RDF)Refine the global element set to connect down (map) to
specific local elements Issues
Common elements may not cover the same space as local elementsRefinement not possibleCommon elements have to be augmented
Favours the global over the localEncourages a good-enough approach
Bottom-up
Publish the local schema(s) in RDFMap local elements from different schema to
lowest common (dumber) elements – add new elements if necessary
Continue until all local schema have been mappedIssues
Multiplicity of RDF element setsFrequent overlap and redundancy
Local management resources
Thank you!
Published RDA element setsrdvocab.info
Published RDA value vocabularieshttps://
github.com/RDARegistry/RDA-VocabulariesProject: versions, issues, feedback