prof. vittorio de pedys for discussion how business angel and venture capital evaluate investments...

40
Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

Upload: alban-lyons

Post on 27-Dec-2015

229 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

Prof. Vittorio de Pedys

FOR DISCUSSION

How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments

LESSON 6

Page 2: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

WOULD YOU HAVE INVESTED?

MICROSOFT CORPORATION, 1978

2

Page 3: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

START SMALL AND THINK BIG

3

Page 4: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

START SMALL AND THINK BIG

4

Page 5: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

GRANDFATHER OF SILICON VALLEY

5

Page 6: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

GRANDFATHER OF SILICON VALLEY

6

Page 7: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

PRIVATE EQUITY AND VENTURE CAPITAL

7

Page 8: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

VENTURE CAPITAL INVESTMENT PROCESS

8

Page 9: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

99

U.S. VENTURE CAPITAL IN 2010

• 26 B$ into 2800 deals; up 11%

• 800 firms have 6.000 partners

• Average partner manages 223 M$ of investments, sits on 6 company boards

• 72 IPO’s vs 12 in 2009 & 160 average 1990-1994

• 1° California ; 2° Massachusettsss ; 3° NY

Source: UCLA

Page 10: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1010

ITALIAN VENTURE CAPITAL IN 2010

• 90 M€ investments in 30 companies (early stage)

• 13 players

• 2-3 disinvestments

• Exit generally through selling to other companies

• Italian venture capital & private equity association www.aifi.it

Source: AIFI

Page 11: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1111

Introduction to raising capital

Page 12: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1212

Capital raising sequence

1. Personal savings & credit card debt

2. Friends, families and “fools”

3. Business Angels

4. Venture capital

5. IPO or acquisition

Page 13: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1313

Stages

• Seed = product developed & launched, CEO in place, some early sales, not profitable

• Early stage = paying customers, proven business model, management team in place, break even revenue

• Expansion = needs investment for sales & marketing investments to sell more

Page 14: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1414

Business Angels

• Typically retired or semi-retired, successful professionals who have investment cash

• Many want to mentor CEO’s• To be considered “accredited investors” need

> 500.000 € net worth• Typical angel investment 40-60k per year• Like Venture Capitals, do not sign NDA

agreements• Normally invest locally & for themselves

Page 15: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1515

Angels groups

• Angel groups in almost every city• Most are non-profit organizations• Each member invests individually• Use standard deal term sheets• All investors sign same term sheet• Investors may invest different amounts

Page 16: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1616

The Italian Business Angels organization is called IBAN (Italian Business Angels Network)

http://www.iban.it/

Page 17: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1717

Typical angel deal in U.S. (2010)

• 1.7 B$ total investment*

• 400 K$ investment

• 1.5 M$ pre-money valuation

• 20-25% equity

• One seat on the board of directors

Source: ACA 2010

Page 18: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1818

Typical angel deal in Italy (2010)

• 33 M€ total investment

• 145 K€ average investment in each company

• 40-60 K€ average investment per Business Angel

• Consider 1-5 investment opportunities during the year

• One seat on the board of directors

Source: IBAN

Page 19: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

1919

Venture Capital vs Business Angels

Venture Capital’s have:

• Expensive offices & high overhead costs (vs. angel’s home office)

• High labour costs (vs. angels work solo)

• Investors who expect high profits (vs. angels have lower profit expectations)

• VC board of directors (vs. no board)

Page 20: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

2020

Club degli investitori

• Group of entrepreneurs of the Piemonte region that invests in new or recent constitution companies that are innovative, with highly growth potential

• Investments realized: Arenaways – Authix – Caspertech - Lachesi – Microcinema – Microwine – Skuola.net – Nicanti

• The club is formed by 40 members

Source: clubdeglinvestitori.it

Page 21: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

21

Evaluation process 1/2

• Entrepreneur sends Business Plan to the club

• Every member can examine the Business Plan

Source: clubdeglinvestitori.it

Selection is based on : • Innovation level of the product or the service proposed

• Credibility of the entrepreneur and the management

team

• Target market and selling strategy

• Headquarters in the Piemonte region

Page 22: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

22

• Club reviews plan & decides if appropriate to present to all members

• Entrepreneur makes 15 minute presentation & 20 minute Q&A

• If 4-6 Angels investors express interest, due-diligence team formed & meets with entrepreneur for 2-3 hours to learn more

• Typical pre-money valuation = 500K€ - 1M€

Evaluation process 2/2

Page 23: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

Y1

Competitor 1

Competitor 2Competitor 3

Competitor 4Competitor 5

Competitor 6

Competitor 7

Competitor 8

Competitor 9

Competitor 10

Competitor 11

Y2

X1 X2

New Co

VCs AND ANGELS LOOKS FOR CREDIBLE DIFFERENTIATION…

23

Page 24: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

3.PRODUCT&TECHNOLOGY

TECHNOLOGY

PARTNERSHIPS

SIMPLICITY

BUSINESS PROCESS

DOMAIN KNOWLEDGE

NETWORK

…AND DEFENSIBLE BARRIERS

24

Page 25: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL

It is important to know the meaning of post-money and pre-money valuation in Venture Capital or

Private Equity

25

Page 26: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

PRE MONEY VALUATION

A pre-money valuation refers to the valuation of a company 

26

Page 27: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

POST MONEY VALUATION

Post-money valuation is the value of a company after an investment has been made. This value is equal to the sum of

the pre-money valuation and the amount of new equity

If a company is worth $100 million (pre-money) and an investor makes an

investment of $25 million, the new, post-money valuation of the company will be $125 million. The investor will now own

20% of the company. 27

Page 28: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL IF THE COMPANY IS A START UP

¶ ANGEL VALUATION

¶ VENTURE CAPITAL METHOD

28

Page 29: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL IF THE COMPANY IS A START UP

¶ ANGEL VALUATION

¶ VENTURE CAPITAL METHOD

29

Page 30: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

TIPICAL ANGEL VALUATION (1/2)

NO REVENUES?

500K-1M€ STANTARD PRE-MONEY VALUATION

30

Page 31: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

TIPICAL ANGEL VALUATION (2/2)

….or bridge loan to A round Venture capital investment:

Angels can buy A round shares at 75% share price

31

Page 32: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL IF THE COMPANY IS A START UP

¶ ANGEL VALUATION

¶ VENTURE CAPITAL METHOD

32

Page 33: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

VC METHOD

POST = V/ (1+r)t

V= EBITDA x multiple exit

R= required annual return of the fund

t= time to exit

33

Page 34: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

EXAMPLE

POST = 25/ (1+50%) 4

= 4.9 M€

EBITDA Year 4 = 5M€

Value in 4 years= 5 M€ x 5 = 25M€

Required annual return: 50%

Time to exit = 4 years

Investment = 3 M€

PRE = 4.9 - 3 = 1.9 M€

VC QUOTA = 3/ 4.9 = 60% 34

Page 35: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

Single period NPV method Base Model Variatio 1 Variation 2Exit value V 25.000.000,00$ 22.500.000,00$ 25.000.000,00$ Time to exit t 4 4 4Discount rate r 50,00% 50,00% 60,00%Investment amount I 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ Numeber of existing shares x 1.000.000 1.000.000 1.000.000 Post-Money POST 4.938.272$ 4.444.444$ 3.814.697$ Pre-Money PRE 1.938.272$ 1.444.444$ 814.697$ Ownnership fraction of investors F 60,75% 67,50% 78,64%Ownnership fraction of entrepreneurs 1-F 39,25% 32,50% 21,36%Number of new shares y 1.547.771 2.076.923 3.682.349Price per share p 1,94$ 1,44$ 0,81$ Final wealth of investors 15.187.500,00$ 15.187.500,00$ 19.660.800,00$ Final wealth of entrepreneurs 9.812.500,00$ 7.312.500,00$ 5.339.200,00$ NPV of investors` wealth 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ NPV of entrepreneurs` wealth 1.938.272$ 1.444.444$ 814.697$

Single period NPV method Variation 3 Variation 4 Variation 5Exit value V 25.000.000,00$ 25.000.000,00$ 25.000.000,00$ Time to exit t 4 4,4 4Discount rate r 50,00% 50,00% 50,00%Investment amount I 3.300.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ Numeber of existing shares x 1.000.000 1.000.000 2.000.000 Post-Money POST 4.938.272$ 4.198.928$ 4.938.272$ Pre-Money PRE 1.638.272$ 1.198.928$ 1.938.272$ Ownnership fraction of investors F 66,83% 71,45% 60,75%Ownnership fraction of entrepreneurs 1-F 33,18% 28,55% 39,25%Number of new shares y 2.014.318 2.502.235 3.095.541Price per share p 1,64$ 1,20$ 0,97$ Final wealth of investors 16.706.250,00$ 17.861.700,15$ 15.187.500,00$ Final wealth of entrepreneurs 8.293.750,00$ 7.138.299,85$ 9.812.500,00$ NPV of investors` wealth 3.300.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ 3.000.000,00$ NPV of entrepreneurs` wealth 1.638.272$ 1.198.928$ 1.938.272$

35

Page 36: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL IF THE COMPANY EXISTS

¶ DCF

¶ MULTIPLES

36

Page 37: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

DCF MODEL

Sum of all future cash flows that are estimated and discounted to give their present values

WACC: Kd (no debt) + ke (35%-50%)

Used by VC to check

37

Page 38: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

METHODS TO EVALUATE A VC DEAL IF THE COMPANY EXISTS

¶ DCF

¶ MULTIPLES

38

Page 39: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

MULTIPLESEV/EBIDTA

EV/REVENUES

EV/CASH FLOW

EV/EBIT

P/E

Private comparable companies + AIM companies

Very simple but easy to make mistakes

39

Page 40: Prof. Vittorio de Pedys FOR DISCUSSION How Business Angel and Venture Capital evaluate investments LESSON 6

AVERAGE EBITDA MULTIPLE = 5 X EBITDA

40