TN TTItr SUF'REI'IE COURT OF INDIACIVIIJ EXTRAORDIIIATI.Y .J'UIIILiDIC'I'ION

CIVIL WRIT PE'IITIO}I NO. I .Z OF 206.In the matter of tCOMMON CAUSE( a negist,ered Society)

UNION OF INDIA.Versus

... PEBITIONER.

. . . RBSPONDntrT

INDEX

SR. t'IR PARTICULARS PAGES

L. Lj.st of Dat,es and Synopsls A, B & C.2. i.'{rit tretj.tj.on alongi.rj.th

Affidavit in support. 1 73. AI'Ii.tD(LlRE uRr 3/4,th page Advertisement,

appeared on 11-l- L-})OZ j.n Indian Express Barrd Hindustan Tjmesr arid again L3th &19th November, 2002(in colour) j.nHindust an Tirnes.

4. AI{\iEXURE trBrr FUII-page Advertlsement,appeared on L2-Lt-200 j-n HJ.ndust,an Tjrnes.

5. ANNEXURE rrcrr FulI page Advertisemen'b, 10appeared on 14-l-L-2OO2 in Hj-ndustan Tjrnesand TiJses of Indla.

6. AI{!.IEXLJRE trDr Half-page Advert,lsernen! LLappeared on 14-1L-20O2 ln Hindustan-Titnes.

7. AltrNEy.tmE rrE[ Half-page Advertisement, Lzappeared on 1-4-1L-2OQ2 in HindustanTimes (in colour).

8. ANNBXTIRE rrFrr l{alf-page Advertisement,, ]-3appearrd on L4-11-2OO2 in I-lindust,anT.lmes.

9, ANNEICInE IGrr t/Ath-aage Advert j-sernent, L4appeared on 19-11-2002 ln FtindustanTimes.

10. Alii'tBI('URE rrHrr t/4tfr-paqe Advertlsement- 15appeared on L9-1 I-2OOZ in l{industan 'Times and Indlan Express.

l-1. AIINB)CLJRB ttItt L/ ttr-paEe Advertiscnent , 16appeared on L9-i-L-2002 j"n Flj.nciustanIirnes and Ti-rnes of India.

!2. ANNBXURE rJ-[ l/4th-page Advertisement, L7appeared on 19-11-200 j.n HindustanTlmes and Tirnes of Indla.

13. r${l.IEXuF.E,rl(.r full-page Jrdvertisenrent" 18appeared on 19-l_1-2002 In l.J-mes ofIndia and also appeared in (suppternentof B par;es) of Incliern Express.

contd.......

SR. NR. PTRTICIILARS PAGES

14. AI{NE}CUREappearedof Delhl

rLn Copy of the ArtlcLeJ,n tbe OIJTLOOK magazlne( dabed L8*1L-2002)T9

Pet ibloner

FI ace: NewDat,ed:

IleIhl..

e,-\;*hourle )Director, COMMON CAUSE

I,IST OF DATBS AI'TD SYITOPSIS

Honrble Court wl.ll have observed that, l.n recent,years there has been a spate of big-slzed, fulL-page and half-page advertJ,sements praced ln newspapersby different, Mlnistrles of the Central Governmentas well by t,he $t ate Government,sr ost,enslbly forproJecting the Smage of polj-ticlans, utJ.lJ.slngoccasions of varlous types such as comrnemorationof a depart,ed leader, encouxaging rural handlcraft s,openlng of a new bridge or road or rallwayconnet:tlon, or I ay.lng foundatlon-stone of bul.ldlng,et'c. These big-slzed advertlsements are quJ.tefrequentry belng placed in neurspapers,ln dlfferentlanguages, all over the country.

Petit,ioner f eels that pro ject,irrg the Lmage oft,he pollticlans, whose photographs are alsopromlnent'ry dlsplayed in these advertlsements, andof thelr polit,lcal partJ.es, J.s obvlously thesole purpose of these blg-sized advertLsement. If,for lnstance, people have Lo be lnvit,ed t,o thef unct,lon of a foundatlon-laylng ceremony or abrldge openlng ceremony thls purpose can wellbe served by sendlng J-nvlt,at,ions or even throughbeat of drums ln t,he area where the ceremonyhas to be performed, lnstead of pracing advertlse-ment, rerated to the event,, dlspr.ryed in newspapersln other parts of the country. Governmentalfunct,ioning and achlevements can, where necessary,be proJected through medium of radlo and TV.Peti-tloner has secured i-nformation t,haL eachfull-page advertlsement (black anrl white) iJt

a widely clrculated newspaper costs aboutlis 6. O0 I akh to lts 8. OO I akh ( advertlsement printedJ.n colour cost s upt,o about fts L5 . 00 I akh ) , andhalf

-page advertisement cost s about lb 4. O0 I alctrto I{s 5. U0 } akh. on cert, aj-n days 2 t,o 3such fuII-page half-page advertisement,s appearln newspapf,s r Tot aI nurnber of advert lsement s ofvarious slzes whlctr appeared ln t,hree newspapersof Delhi J-n, one rnreek, were i.8 ( det,ails furnlshedon top of each of the A t,o K). These lgadvert.lsements of varlous sizes t,ot,aI upto LZ fulI-page advertlsement s. Taking t,he tot al of LZ full-page advertlsements appearing in one week, ln threenewspapers, t,he average comes to f our f uII

-pageadvertisement,s in one newspaper j.n a week.Assuning that there are only 5O0 newspapers andmagazines ln the country, printed in varlouslanguages, which is obviously a conservative figure,the average total of fulI-page advertisements ofthis nature appearing l-n one year will be 4 x 500 x50 ( approxirnate number of weeks ln a fear) = 200 x500 = L,00,000. Cost of full-page advertisement lnnewspaper of wlde clrculatlon ranging from Rs 6.00 1akht'o I?s 8'00 rakh, even if we take the average cost ofRs 2.00 }akh, the totar expenditure on r.,00,000 f ull-page a.dvertlsements will be Rs 2r00r000 x Lr00,000= Rs 2000 crores. This much cost, is lncurred bythe centre and states with t,he prtmary purpose apparentlyto project the lmage of porlticians and t,helr partles.Petlt'ioner feels that such actj-on on the part of centrarGovernment and St ate covernments arnount,s 1nf act mlsutilLsat,ion of publlc funds whlch canbe more gaj.nfully utillsed for betterment, of

nnexuresAtoK

I5.f e of t,he people.

The attacfied Annexures A to K are photo-coplesof such adverElsement,s whlctr appeared Ln aboutone week jJr November, 2OO2, some of t,hem lncolour. Relevant, det all s lncluding t,he numberof tlmes part,lcular advertisement,s appearedr havebeen typed on the op of each Annexures.

Pet, j-tloner tras f elt that 5-n deal ing wit,h thlsmatter there is no alternative exceptj.ng toapproach the Honr ble Court wit,h the prayer thatdlrections may be lssued t,o the Cent,ral Governmentto lnitlat,e steps to determine as to how thJ.stype of expendlture can best be minimlsed 1nrelation to t,he Cent,ral Government as well asthe state Governments, and that initlatlve shouldbe t alcen by the Cent,ral Government, to aI sopersuade tl:e $tabe Governments to Lake approprlatestepso Petitioner has named only one Respondentin the Petltion, namely, the Secretary of theunion Ministry of rnformatlon and Broadcasting, underwhictr Dlrectorate of Audio visuar pubriclt,y funct,ions,lnsLead of burdenlng the fire also wj-th Respondent sof st, ate Government s along wlth any ot,her I'tlnlstrlesof the Central Government.Hence t,his t{rit pet itlon.

XXXXXXXX

tIN. THE S-UBRtrME COURT OF INDIAcrvrrJ E4TR4o,RprlLAIr.Y_,JURr.$pr qi' roN.

WRIT PETITION (CIVIL) NO. OF 20Q2,

In the matter of ICO}4MON CAUSE( a negisLered Society)A-3L, West End,New Dethi 1L0021through j.ts DJ-rector$hrl H. D. Shourl.ei ... PHI'ITIONER.

VersusUnlon of Indla,Ml-nj.stry of Informatlon and Broadcasting,Shastri Bhawan,New DelhL Ll00lthrough its Secretary.

PETITION IJT{DER ARTICLE 32 OF THECONSfITUIIO}T OF II'{DIA FOR ISSUANCE OFA WRIT IN THE NATURE OF CERTIORARIAND/OR MAIIDAT"TUS N{D/OR ANV OTHERDIRECTION, DIRECTING THE IJNION OF INDIAIN THE MINISTRY OF II.dFORMATION ANDBROADCASTING TO DE.f BRI"IINE THE STBPSTHAS CAN BE TAKEN TO CHECK PROFLIGACYIN THE PLACEIVIEI'IT OF BIG-SIZgD ADVERTISEIVIENTSIN Ti"iE NEV'ISPAPERS TCIR PRO.TECTING THEIMAGE OF POLITICIA}{S AND OT POIJITICAIJPARTIE-S, WHICF{ IS BEING $(TEI{SIVELY rcNEBY DIFFERSIT I"III.JISTRI,ES OT THE GOVERNMENTOF INDIA AND ALSO BY TIIE STATE GOVERNME}ITS IINVOI,1rJNG HUGE AI'IOUNTS OF GOVERNMEh{TAIJEDCPM{SES Otr' THE CM{TRAIJ GOVERNMEIIIT AI'ID THESTATE GOVERNI\TENTS I !{FIIC}I CAI.I tsE I.ITIIJISEDTO GREATER ADVASITAGE FOR IMPROVE${ENT OFLI\ENG CONDITIONS OF THE PEOPIJE, IN THECONTE)(I OF THEIR FT]I{DN,1EI{TAL RIGHTSGUARAT'ITEED I-INDER ARTICXJE 2J, oF THECONSTITUfION OF INDIA.

To

Honrble The Chlef .Tustlce of IndJ-a and HJ-s LordshipsCornpanicn rfustJ.ces of the Honrble Suprerne Courb of Indla.

The Humble Petltion of t,he Pet,itloner abovenamed,MOST RESPECf FUIJLY S}{EVTEIIH tL. That the PetLt,ioner J.s a []oclet,y du]y reglsteredunder the Socleties Reglstrat,ion Act, 1860, and J.s

Contd.. o o.2o

r'Fl?tffi{.F\ ;l-ffi'' '' I

2

eng aged J.n t aldng up v arious common problems of thepeopLe f or securlng redressal t,hereof . The PetltlonerSoclety has also brought t,o Court varlous constltutlonalproblems. The Petitloner has an establlshed locus st,andlJ.n J.be capaclty as a bonaflde pubLlc lnterest organlsatlonfor talcing up matters of general publle lmportance. ThePetltloner J.s subrnlttlng the present publJ.c J.nterestPet,i.tj.on for conslderation of the Hon'ble Court.z. that, the Petlt,ioner strongly f eels thatlncreaslngly durlng the recent years t,he tendencyhas grown anong polJ-tlc1ans, at the Cent.re as wellas j-n the States, to proJecE through large-scaleadvertLsenents j.n newspapers various tasks undertakenby Lhelr lrJ.nistrj.es and theJ.r governmental functJ'onJ.ng1n general, obvlously for proJecElng the image ofpolJ.ticJ.ans and polJ't,j.cal partJ'es. This tendency hasgrown t,o sueh an e;cEent that almost every few dayst,here are such Iarge-sca1e ( full-page, half-page andquarter-page ) advergisernents ln various importantnewSpapXSr The petltJ.oner has ascertalned that costof these bJ.g advertisements ranges upto about, Rs 6 laltlrst,o Rs I laldrs for eachr full-page advert,lsement ( lnblack and wtrlte ) tn newspapers of wlde clrculatlon,and coruespondlng cost, f or half -page and quarter-pageadvertlsements.

3. Annexures A t,o K are photo-coples of thef ull-pdgee three quarter-page, half-page and quart,er-page advertisements whlch appeared durlng one weekof NovernJcer, ZOO2, J-n three English newspapers of Delhl,namely, Hlndustan firnes, Tjroes of India and Indian Express. Orrthe top sf each of these Annexures Petj.t, j.oner has

3furnls}ed det ail s of number of t jrnes the a

46. That t,he PeLit,loner does recognise that, polltlcalleaders have t,o resort to such pro jections for ralsJ-ngthelr image as well as the funqe of their partles.The problem that emerges from consideration of th1smatter J.s whettrer the concerned pol1.tlcians can devisesuitable alternatives through which the objectlve ofpro jecti":ag t,heir lrnage may be satisf acborily fulfllledand yet t,he expendlture of present hlgh-level may nothave to be incurred. The Petltloner does not conslderit, necessary to emphaslze that in the conditlons oflnadequacy prevaillng j.n the country J.t would be desirable thatevery effort should be made to utilise government funds t,o themaximum exLent J.n the j.nterest, of rneeting t,he multlfariousessentj-al requlrements of the people.7. That t,he Petitioner conslders that it, would beunavalli-ng for h1m t,o communlcate these views to any governmentalauthorltyr at the Centre or In t,he Stateso They are not, likelyt,o be thus persuaded t,o abstaj.n from plac.ing such costly advertise-ments .in newspapers, Therefore, the Petlt,ioner has consldered1t, approprlat,e t,o bring t,his matter before the Honrble Courb withthe prayer that in the int,erest of the people the Hon'ble Courtmay kindly consj.der what directions can be glven t,o the CentralGovernment through the RespondenL for examj-nlrrg thJ-s problem andto also communicate j't to the $tate Governrnenbs, for det,erminingthe measures that need to be taken to utllise alternatlve rneans,includj-ng Doordarshan and TV and approprlate smal.ler-sizedgovernment notices, for project.ing ttre jmportant events instead ofdoing thJ.s through such large-slzed expensive adverLisernentsr sothat Government funds may not geL urj.sutil.iseci and frittered awaywlren these are very muchr requirecl for rneeting the ottrer urgent.requirements of the people ancl of goverrunental functlonj-ng.8. That, the above grounds are beirrg sukrnitted wlthoutprejudice to one another and bhe Petltj-oner craves leave to addCo or to amend the above. .

o That the present Pet,ition is bei-ng submittedbonaflcle and j.n general publlc .int'eresL.10. That no other Writ Pet'ltion or Proceeding has beeninitiated by the Petitioner j-n any lllgh Court or t,he SupremeCourt of Indla on the subject matter of the present, Petition.Ll-, That the Petitioner has no alternatlve equallyef f icaclous remedy in I aw f or t,he cause of asbj.onbeing agit,ated herein.

PRAYBRs

In the above premises, J-t, J-s prayed thatthis Honrble Court may be pleased :

(j.) to lssueorder or

a wrj.t, direct,ion ori.n the nature of mandamus

and/or a.ny othrer writ,,

6J.nvJ.tatlons to them for seeuringthreir presence at, the proJected eventsuch as foundation-laylng ceremony,opening of a new road or brldge orrallway IJ.ne or ottrer 1-tnport ant'f acil-Ity for the beneflt of thepeople, thereby avoidlng the heavYexpendit,r.rre whj.ch 1s being presentl-yincurred by placement of advertisements1n newspapf,sc

(11) to pas6 such other and further ordersas may be deemed necessary and properon the f acts and ln t,he clrcumstancesof the cdseo

PSTITIONER SHAIL,FOR WHrCH Agf OF KINDI{ESS, THEAS IN DUTY BOUND. EVER PRAY.

Pet,Itioner

( H, D. shourle )DlrecAor, COI4MON CAUSE.

PIaceDated

a

tNew Delhl.

Versus

U\]ION OF INDIA. ... RESPONDEI{TATFIDAVIT

I, H. D. ShourLe son of late Shri S. L. sihouri.e,aged 90 years, Director, colJl}{ol'{ cAusE, }r-31, ltest,End, I{ew Delhi L10021, do hereby solemnly affirma.nd state as follows /

In t,he matt er of !COM}ION CAUSE( a negtstered Society )

1o

Pet it,loner Socletyam aware of thet,o depose t,hereono

IN ?HE SUPREI,IE COURT OF INDIACIVJL EXTRAORDTI.IARYJUR.ISgICTION

CI \ruL WRIT PtrTI'TIO}i NO. ot' 2002

. .. PETITIONER

That I am the Director of Col"il'toN CAU:jE, thel.n the above vlrlt, Petition, that I

f act s of the c ase and arn eompet ent

2o That, the i"{rj-t, Petit,lon aforegoing has been preparedby me ano r say that the contents thereof are true andcorrect to the best of my knowledge and belief.3" That theare true coples

L, the Deponent, abovenamed doat New De1hi on this day of

the l"{rit Pet itlon aforegolnge orlg

DEPONNdT

irereby verlfy2aO2 that the

are t,rue and correctart of l.C is

coneea therefrom.

Annexuresof thelr

t,o

res

Verificatlon z

contentst,o thefalse andof the Affidavit, aforegoing

nothj.ng materj-al

DEPONEbiT

Thi q 3l4.th-pace a ove J,l,._i 1_.20 02 in

It.

Yfrlh EMPI 9usln$s School, Nrw D.lhl

Smt. Sheila DikshitHonblo Chiel Minislet,

Delhl

ffiLffiil,itI 3TH

-

I 9TH NOVEMBER

lnauguration of Kalyan Week:by

Shrimati Sheila DikshitHon'ble Chief Minister, Delhi.

Presided byShri Raj Kumar Chauhan

. Hon'ble Social Welfare Minister, Delhi.Followed Ot

" "1ldlo Light Cerernony.

Date : 13,,N,,o,yember, 2002Place : lndia,:Gate Lawn

Time l 05,00 P,Ml::..::...,.,..

.1.::: :, .,.,,, i,, .,

Be a proud Delhi citizen.' ; Join us

andmake the

,Over f Q00 nureitnlizcd cltil{r(t1t lyqnrcn ntti tlisthlail will rts:st:trthlc ttnil beioined by sclrool chiklren n:14.,i.,.,er:W,lt'tf utl walk.roitrfe st Indiu Gute Ltwttthis evening and ligltt u.,.,[i.,y,tlle'1iraiiilt to lcindle,,,tl!i,ll;,':,'-Lyo7,e; and strertgthentheir aspirat.ions. Yon LfrS'yrfrLlf.,::,ar1d i,oin,tltis ll{tr!!rl;.r,i!! rolitiotr, volitiott to

c t t i t tt tt o o tl, w o rt ru t t t t o o,r'rt tL;i!: t!,, y tl ttis ab i tittt,'', r

Sh. Raj Kumar ChauhanHon'bls Selal Wellare Ministet,

Delhl

DATE13.11 20A214.11 .200215.11,200215,11 :200216.11.:200217 .11.200218.1I.?002

a success.

PITOGRAMMElnaugural function & lighllng the candlesCultural evening at Dilli Haat, 'Parntrng competllion for destrtute and menlally challcrrgeC clrrldren.Seminaronprobletnsofseniorcitizensandthelr9olUtions'Sp'rds ComprtLtron for destitute and rnentally challerrged ciridren.Chrldrcrl's theatte.

'

Workshop on beggal laws and anli-begginrJ carilpaign.Photo Exhibition lollowed by cultrlral evenlng )q''of

Bepartrnerlt off $meia$ Welfaru

my delhi

Heq. I Clre

WE CAEAffiYOT' SMJTERE

Kalyam WWeeH{

'q**_:,-

Govt. of hlCT of Delhi.

This fuI r- p g r g* a .clyg!lqg'le_l!_ll. i ltin tlre HIIJtiUST/\N III'lLS

i\,lj

[]9 rr: tJ t.ltl l7.ll.'.)lt{,')

4*,uexaRE $ -:

MESSAGE,'/,lh th0 commissioning of Ihe Easrcrn-Norlhern lnicrReqional ttvoc itxsoo MW) back ro-ba.kI rnnsmission Syslcm at Pusauli (District Kaimur), t,ihar, tho nation has taken a vilal slcl) in tlro''legrarion or rho powe. lransmission network oI rhe country. Tho HVDc syslem would ailow thoi:rslern Rcaion to expo'1 its surprus power to the tJorthrn Rogion which will benefit by gnliinq',acoss to lo d @sl pov/ar. This evcnl marks tho comt)lotion of lhe llrsl phase ot the National powci"ild,

tho natjon-v/ido oxorcisc u,rdertaken by PowEltGI-{rD to enablo oxchangs ol power witll'; nproved reliability and quality bets een ail the r6gions ot tho counlry.I congralr.ilalo PowERGRID lor this achievement and wish them success in their fulure.'ndcavours.

O+rgt+...,o(A. B. V8lpayoo)

& rorr.g, trrrali:,ot, {PffiWERGRHffins

Ecrslerrr-Northern !nler Regionol500 MW I'IVDC Bucl< lo Bqck Trqnsnrission Syst

ot Pusquli (Dist. Koimgr), Bilrorot 5.30 pm, Todoy, tlre 12' November, 2OO2

by

Shri /\lcrl Bilrcrri VoipoyeeHon'ble Prime Minisler of lndio

Shrl Anrnl G. GooteHon blo Union Mini:lcr trl Poworwlll ptoslds ovor llto lunction

MESSAGEr hrtltr ol 0r.sl pl?^!uro lhit Powrr 6rid Cortrcrallon ol Indlr Llnrilod hnr i.l'lnvod y.l dnollror nrll.llo,ro lr lr{,

..\'4^,rn\olttutnt36!lorlohgirdlr,ilthr./,.nn,,r.,,ori,'qolfr'.!,'rrl',rlrr.,,1lil!rlr,,rl.',,nlllVl)C(lx!rrrJM'Nlll:r,:k'.'.'ile^rh,r!bnSrltomrtPvrrun{O':t'ctXn(nur).8'ha.,ni,i!ll,eco,,rr.r('toflhol,rlllil'i.t.illl:'ro,,olC,nlwr,Ll,lr.,.'n!Mrtlot!dt lhr!prolrcllneol!nr!h,.Jlrlcrol.)lloch.ol.qyirs6lottrr!slonolorFOWIRLillll)lOi'rnlycoollrrclllro'r'r.rlCrEUE'rbylndblng6rchnngeol'el.lbl6andqunllypowerbalwonnlllh6livoroglonsolll'ft,jourlry Wilrll16'{,rr!($ing ol ur! HVOC nrojocl. bolh !l!6 llorlhorn and lho Eoslo.n rsoionr will bo bona0lod by lmpaovo(l plnril load soclof'rOy rdJooe gDnoralon lrrin !nd btlo. @nlrolol troqurncy.

.

',!ldilela.inu16.do.goncy6!rlsbnalo.ilhirrD0lonrundor6dvrr!oopo.atln0condlllonlondwouldlmprovolhoovor,,.J'alul!t6 Pov/ERGRlo s hlr ecaslon. [:... -t r-

(Anont C. G6oto)

'1, V. Shrhl.,abry. lt'nrry d Pffi MESSAGE{ elimil utilira16 ot go.r.rlion 6picilos ond btlnncod powFr flow. lr!or.connocliong ol, ,wt reqbn.lg6d3 rt en rmrcdanl inilrrliyo o' lhc Covarnmonlol ln,Jii\ Today ls nn hrpoilint

'!/ 6 lhc F o, 3ccld when lho .slcm.Nodhern lnler Rogional HVOC (1r5U0 f,lw) Llnck lo'rl Irinemi!!ion Sy3lem al PusauI {Dierid Xaimur), Brhnr ls bfioq dorllcilod lo lho nilion by

'.ibro Pdmc $inrstcr lh6 rchenro @nrplclca tho firrl phase ol llatlonal t'owor crld bolno''ncmenlcd by POWERCRIO. Th,s HVDC achcmo I proicct wlll bo!\ctil bollr Enslcrn ondr.4r,a.nR.gimondlncililalobl.dioclionrjorchi.Q0olpowor!plo500l/!Y llwillslionroko

.rgy 6xd6q.3 Ftrrblo $U obor rogione horcby onrudng qu0l,ly and roliobllly ol powar|'t4(t1 V Shoht)

''pxqlt(L6telltq urs, i :''''l'.1 "1

Srnt. Jayawintl MolrtaHon blo Union [linlslor ot

Slalo lor Powor

MESSAGEI r,il hil)ty to not0 llrnt nOW{:fl(illlD llr0 Cilrl,rl Tr0namlsrk)n lJlllily unrJtt Mlnltiry ol Pdvol hn! onrml.ilon&J trfr..l,rnt!,rtl,.rrn[,lorltf(tio,,ilIIVOC(1x5r]0MW)ll^ckk't1a(kTrsr'!rrisslonSysltrr6lP!t.ul,[lilrnt.Ih'ar3onlmfErlrnt,0 l('wr",,r .il.,tnl,Jilr\t ol lli! llrll pl'nro ol Nrlio,nl Po*n. Gdd. Tho lmpl.monloton o( Urit HVOC Prcid frn lq1J'ol)li,,rl ulilirnlior (il rnsLnrco6 botwoon Enrlorn E Nodhorn Ro0lont.lconqrrrularoPOWEnclllOonicconrplishinotlri3mornorablolonl Onlho@c43lonolconrmir:iminqolb\l5Pftirss'nl,,,rllol!ielrrdriln lrrrlliri'lrrybolioflhrllhoPOWEttclllDwoulddchiovomonymolobonclhmarklnltu,tandholptolrll q Nilllon lownrJ! 1,0 rund ol !rospo,lly.

:J-1.-.-F.*(Jryrw.ntj tr.hl

R, P. SlnohChsIir]En 6 Mann0Llg Olroclor. POWERCIIIO

I hnvo lho plonixa ol [rlo(rilnfl nll ol y,'u thrl pOWERCRID t IIVDC bsci to bacl rrqd rl Sa3a'irl,r' cofiloclirq Norllr0(r l{(J!or xrd lir!loill Ro0lon ln a3yrlcltrooou! nrcde i! gdl!.4 ln^ugur'lir,ry by llon bla l,rinro Mlfllrlo. ol l,rd s Tlrle prulccl conslsl ol E rlollo blet of 500 Mrl f{Vtlc i!st)cl:il'!d B(10 cficull ktrrr ol 400 kv fuC lnnsnils.ion liro ln Bihar (En!l6m Rmh ) ond UrPrndo3h(NoilhomRo0iof)nlo{rgwl') orlcnsionrolBihotShantndAll*ab!dtubabbsCornrni33lnrl\0 ol llils proln.t il]irlc complollon o{ nrrl pha!6 ol Nnlisral Pmr Grtt erd wnh ih,r'courlry wl(lo i,lor.ogurrl orcha'rqo cntnrity ha! ri3c^ to 5000 LlW. Ihrr

''Cid har U

corrtlolod by POWIli(;llL{] wilrin llrn cooIndUar schcdul6 dnd 6t s @rl ol Rr 590 sdca igi'G.)vt otlilovcd cosl ol lls 0/2 croros Ihi3 lngh lcchnobgy preiod l! @hO lo plsy ! hhl Dt"l0odl,rq 500 M!ry ol powor k) t.)wrr dolicll Noilllorn Rogion 6 q!n!@t bi313 il EBsl.m Rogio.tLLriy tu'snlii^ t,o$or !u,t,ru.. lv a ro'g rinro.tIVOC krclrroloq/ {n.jillil^! l,il6rconnec!,on ol l*o r.0lonr havln! llwrpstiHe rl6i,,t'rrnoiolor r. I lrir lnr l,r,ri,,gy o!ro 1in.il,lrlos i,rl^r 'rrfllininl ordrnrrgn ol 6nor0y drl6 hling ilvr' 'ol(lr!r!rrrycl[!nd 0'rtrr'ln!j.r!xlilIirtlrllr.lworrgln'r h(qlrotlloll{rdrhnlhnl.lt.nri'f rrf r{ t,.rnlrrli0lil ayllonra, po*Dr llow col b. rloulnlod lh a prdrr ruM ulrclg|1 ll\'n,'..rnly tra Ilrv| rilro .{nmiir'onF4 firsl polo ol til.sliqiou! IIVOC H prlo ll,t mrrrclin T.L(l

^1lr,rr lir,t,)rj ) l,J l\i,l | (:i{r llx,r, ll(,(l (xr ) () rrorll,! nlrond ol .(l,filuln n'xj al i rcrl ol li!(:,.r'1 hr! ll,iln lrrn rt,lrovnrl r,nl nrir tr(racl 1r 6l!0 lo{rlrhll,9 rrtrll ol !dtlur Fn, I

lir':r.'il1{rqitvrloll,,,,llinrjrtl,(l!rr A,lvnrLoc{ilnilrlrrlriltqolllilrtr',l0rthdrirl'otrda,o!,'ll"rlrxr Ir l[[!qriU Jr)rri0 (l,rt, Ir-Uxilr Dgw0r ruqulr0(io|lr lnd hsr h0\pd Estt6m Rt9o'

. Ono ol lho worid'r lo.gell trotumi$ior\ ,o) .Iroh.nlitr'c.Srlr.m: " ':lvr,l,tict,,,,. .- . :' l.-!r5o0rnw$/DCboc!robockrrotionl

. Cqrrier ovcr 4096 ot rorot po*cr: : ir. ,l,i,l,liil""li.r","-.,.oo,uoo,u,o Ige.crolcd;n tho Notion, i ,i". r,." rl

. Oivcrrifying inlo letccom burinerr ' iii, 5otoo,^.Allohobod400lvOoubb iti'ough ortoblirhmcnl o{ brmd.bood ,.

-

Circvx l;n. -

'1

Op:iciF,b,o Tclccom Notwork ouo. itl b) trlimorcdl\oloclCott : Rr 6/?Crorcs lcxrdn!ivcly sprood lron:misr;on c) Fundrng

. .

I \Yorld-llrrl I;-;;;;;" -':'': 1 r --' d) ommrr:-:fi'::'j' i

sAf IENI-f-EAT-URE5-Q-F-IHE IRoJECI; *-l

I

' T ir F.qod invohog @nslruction ol aboul 760 Clt. km! 100 KV AC lines and a 500 MW IIVOC ILJ,-l.lo-Lrcl rlrbn al Srrr!;,m

I. Tt.rj 9.:rram !ub-rLrlon would bq lho 5rh juberrilon ol f)O'tERCRIO in tlo rrira r/ n ,,ir Itt\d r,!/ta g!tt: a @st ro tho F4ra supply n tho arca ol 3Jsa'Jnt. Mohanla, Kirantnasa. I

Ucr.',. Cr-.1J5 RorC ctc I

. Th.3 lik an:d Lro|lalo br

This f uII-perrlcr advrlrtisorrL birirr:t.rJd on 14.1 I .ztrltztn t,he HINL,USTAN flt'rLS irNU T.il,LS L'f: INDIA

OnChildren's Doy

We affu'nl our conrrnilnrcnttowards Universalisation of

Elenrentary liduc:rtion

. . .- .r', r{.} nFF)ft}vtr,,'

Shri Arrl Ilihnri Vajpnycellon'ble Pnme Minister

, especiir.ily belo,1#Sbnity anrl nrinoliry Eio$lt

cornplete B yearsby 2010;

Universal retenlion by 2010.

:ir 28 States ';

3900 cr-oles approved foidrrring 2002-0:l .so l'ar, to

goal oI Universalisation ofEclucatiorr

t;2L,2I9 new sclrool l;uilrlings. 28,.190aclclitional classroonrs appror.ecl.

7 Urrion'I'errilories ,i. 600 llistr.icts ,:. 5,16I .l'orr.ns6.4 lalJr Villages ,t Crorcs o{ Children

... oue solution h;. 'sli ir-._.r l-. : \-l la

Depadment of Elementary EcJucation and LiteracyMinistry of Human Resource Development, Government ofJnclia

ffib

ffifern"&TF{ild.g

This hr

#mswef,$beir

Meet i

The,

Hon'ble fc0mmem0t

" Our children are thefuture oi our nation. We arecommitted to nurture themthrough their chiidhood andtheir most impressionabieand formative years. so thatthey can realize their fullpotentiai and contribute richlyto the develooment of theirmotherland'.

Shri Atal Bihari VaioaveeHon ble Pnme [{rnriter

-fl$wo '\v' r tQ -

SARAS ' )f Indirr2ooz he tte$t't o,-,i,nfts clirect fi'ow t ;iuufts clir

The fich leguteY gf rt'wsl hmtl

cEM-# sAR'\s 2002 - 'cruniinoug* ution TodaY

by

":#;:;,:,1,i',,,",1'ln""ll"'nradinond ffi ffi "*Prrlffiii*l':l"m:*

"i',rrr,,'*""*nlentsof*',ol ffiffiffi ffi ^,:J:::J:X,:;:,",,';;:,;,|,,,i,,atItough--:.xlnfffiffirr^n,h1eJH::l?#ill}:'ts;Shrl snat"o,ili b"u.topr.otHon'ble Minister

for Kr)faJ*ttrc"' "" ^tide

vaneU ofgerteratiorts *offt" I v^.^nrl'::',:;:,,:;',:'T::,";,';,||o*:^.,.,'."%w**'"""ffi*ru:"elopmentGu9stsofhunour"::;':::" ;',l,,,lnui r'o'vonn ,ic"sits tltrun:'::l':rm:ln

rii '""'r'

ofhandicraft Products for"*r^

o"'^'onrent and social

tryliftntent' ,ah ,-!- ,'!--'i+i\''l1

V-.*.tv"ioir',r,"

'or' 'o" Pi'k f'o^ *:*':t:,Lonte t"''- "

cts from ruralposstble range ofprod

. n to tl pavill" i o'u"r -1,

"

o'ai L'{ a i d an' N ew D elhi'

**,,.*:l:?f lf."l''i*?'o,"*'PRoGRI\1'\1E i

'

Inausuration : lifftilT;;"''t to9? -Drte : il"if "'1, Ptetti lu11'*t'venue U."o.*i

.

""""*r*ffiry:u,",.,n,g*i?"i',1,"0'*

ii:iti:l::lii

l::l:::

ff,

This 1 /4th-?ei{g advgltisggreint a_ppeareo_on 1 9. I 1 .'zLriz.rn the UinOustan-iT.nlry

A^/^/Extl*E'G'

ifi: lQn National Parft : i:Si*fi:r,.'"'- :' i,,,''. 1'.. ;.'','1,,:,';1ifi,i :- :'',,,i,i.

'l- |il.,i..i

.

lilrI

i.i; l *'*1*tlt ig$ffirtq6 ii..... : i,,',,r .,i,,,. i. .ii ,ii${l,iffi

iif:frfitiffititti{lti}tit$il,ji i,,', ;i,liriii"i,ij,,-: 1,4t,,,**$lliiiilitiritili:lt$ilj$ffi::' ..i. t:.r:. :i\iil:\:ii!ii:r,,:jjii iiil il: . :i.]\:it :)i' -i $i1"ffi'l;r1fillirfiffiillir{$lilniri u$tiiii';iritilinril $i$iliii:iiiii ,:,:r,1i,,,ii:,,,iiliirlr u:. *ii l ii itffi lii lj.ll ii{i:lti. l.:1iit ii; i ; :;ilrtiii+iit':Li:i*i,ll\',ir: '

N,t,ii

:.:: j::i:l:.i: il' i'..,!!,?i "J :

iriliil'6[t.* ffi$$ffi ii'r";''::,iHffi.,1.,\ jr +1. l$Hffi?ffi

ii:..i';i i''."; :r.,',-'.', .,'ii;r;.,:i.f-'',iljil;ij,{1,' ;,.''',,-.t,.i' r1,' i;ii? r'i l'':: ti;;i 5:i ;t!';iL:1:'i;"lilt;.': ' i: , ,'1,'l* t.t;lilli'ii;itli:i'i:,',',..i,,1",ir,i,r,i'- i.i,Iiiiiili'.,.iill

i\:yr#{#g+ifi|ffi{#*iffi ffi ;;d;,,.;;*l*'-ffi{+!tiitiitlitiirffi,ilffjl:ffi:',il::i:i::::T"iy:::::l':T::to,:'','i' -1' +"-,"iffii'#i;iiiiiiii!ffi;ffi"lfrgtribute totharormerPrimo Minisrer, rnoirabanoi'.t'iitli =i:'"t'r'''gffiiffi I

iitrJiilfiii;ffillfi$'f;,tfl'1"93, *u' 1^oired renowned wrilor Rudyard Krprinsio pen' ",'t,'i,1;iiffiiffi |iffiiitt;,iitii!,tlffile Bookl'The wildlrre sancluaryadjoinins rho Nationarparrworr]#ltii '''ffiffii;ifiI

4##ff +rg+r'ili,,*:]?:idfr ffi i'ir:fff ff :ffi *T,;:*rnl#'-ffi ffi |fti+1"rii{iffifffffit.le'!ivore density, isgoultgo amons the bosf risor resu"ui.',fi;,,r*fiiiilffilffi t

!1*3\11iiiiiffi,X,:,.ti.flitltulclign.onNovemberls,tnuninnoayotndiracu;oiilti'fl;;"]ilii.' ffi r#ffiitiiiit ffil|,;,' '^ ; oistinguishedGuests ,-"'- ,:.'i ,,',,,',,.-i''r'+ulffiiiffiffi I "Hitlltll*#i*1ffirl,viras Rao Deshmukh,'o.'rtmnl..lirinu"rn,"' , -t"''l'i*;nu;iffif!r# ii' ,jti,,'?ffiif"Plgvijav sinsh, chief Minisrer of Madhya praossh , '''' i.1't1:l'j,'::'ffi) \,rri+r,Uj;r1lgXlr;tlii iffi;h.'i Ut'va,nsh sinsh, Minister ror Forest, gadhlaprad;rni,',1i,:.ffii{rfffitl";Hllffi#;ril.s,, 'L'u,tlrmila

singh, MinisterforTrioit wutru,,rj Madhva pradrll, '',,."-'"i'r'ii;iil'ilj,il'$iri;1ii1:i4i;6"i1rsrrriswaroop sinsh Naitt, tvtinisterfor Foresr, t.nuiurnui - ,';.,fi ii lffill,,fttiiffiffiilitilgr'tlswaroop sinsh Naik, Ministerfor Foresr, tuarraiasntra',i '',,;;jt'i;,iiffi##l\+r\t$*,:+ii'X. urem,9n $ingh Nagpure, Minister, Backward'ctasser *, til,,t.;t.'r;lfti'':!' :;ffi#i.llffi1*ffj.f;:"'r'; venue:Ghatkghka,seoni .',:'',', ffi'lfft'

*ffi,ffi ffi i\- V--1Ir -t+ I t/!_+-S4-.'^--*

6 tt1lI

1jIII_u__l / 4th-paQe acvertisenretnt a a&re d onn Hindustan Times and tnOian xDre s s

1 9.1 I .2AU2

Aru,uex a(E id '

ir[ri'#

iI

Thi s 1 / 4Lh-paoe advertissrrreni. erared crn 19.1i.2Ut)2

.Ln HINI]USTAhJ TItilL S nno-TlTr5 ilT INDJ A

otilffi rr-ffi\H

.,:l g ;lErrcN, 2AA2

i t-6s

/64rvvgXuR6.t7r

1,. '':

srn{tad,{ i}r* !ql. ffi gg*rt "r"* oir{ "Imy

' gw-q-* tsrnq qt r,oryr * ;ffisiqrrf, a+ Eqn gqftqi or ftqf"r% gqftqior qqftg-*mqT{eqrRf,r'1T,.-B*,fl$awnquGoft,

erhsrorqLcn,s{Hiqin.rcn

[reiircd "']-1 9' II''2tJNzin bhe Hinou@i,re;-or ln =: l7

)n!1,i-1t!1 If

ttl

I

I

I

I.'

ffi#

I

I

t,

I

Inf,ia will never beI

4,, "{t- ..tlY.-

t6Ihf--S_l11lf1ri:Je irdvertiserrrurrL r,trijrri,r-ed or) i:).II.Ztjt,'Z -

------:;.'.'...'-#_ _i_.__.:__;_=---=1n.llge-g-of , tnd*a ?r'u.gI.sCI,_.a_;.rlrtarcu in\Suirplurrrrrlrl, of,,"g,,SAtJOs)111'8tF:q,Uo='-=.'':""-q fl'=I nrtIbn' f xFlEsG-- on-ETiffia \, I4**6xul?t -11

" Derrutcrucy I)ocs Not, fiIcurr. Elect,ians...... lYc lIwuc'Ib'I{.cc1t'I'|rc Coult lt'y Ali,u

lrtrlira Candlrlt (iu*,ulrlrti AICC Scssion, l)cccrrrtrcr' l9l

lJrttle r thc tlynunric Icatlership olSmt. Sonia Ganclhi

thc nble guitllncc oICapt. Aurarintlcr SinghI lorr'l:lc ('lricl lvliristcr, I'rrrrjrb

I Iltt tttutrlIrrrlrll'llo(urr'lltr'll{Irrclrtrrtl,rlisilrlr:csscrtlilrllyrlrrr(iorl's rlceisitrl lo provirlc lr rnirrinrrrru l{) llouts prrrvcr srrpplr.tr.scetor' (lcst)itc ircrrtc tlr orrglrt rclirtcrl grorrcr slror llrgcs. lior tlrc lir,rin rl tlcr lo srrrc tlrr'lirr trrcrs ct()l) tllc (i()\,1. rrlrrlc tlorvrrriglrt prrr.t.l'rtltliliorrlrl l)o\\,ct \\'r)t llr ll,s. (r.I00 elor c li orrr olltcr sllrlcs.

a l)iruelrllric ol l)isirn,e:rlrrrctr{ llrs lrtcrt scl lll) lo cnsltrc trilltsplt,ctlrrily rtrrtl lirir rrcss rvlrilc c:rr r yirrg orrl govl. tlisirrvcslnrcrrt.

a \\irr kl-cl;rss irrliir:;(ruc(rrrc lo lrir;c sllrrrrllrrtls ol'livirrg in lhu Slrrlc.rsrr1rPlr,,1 qr;1111,! Itr ir|:cs. cilic rnrcrritics, hcrrltlr &ctlucltiorr lltcrlitr,

a ( lvlclllllclltltcsl0cclllpclcclllollrtcf[)l)tllxll()ll1\'lllltllllrcIlc,atnYt- srrlr'rlr ink irrg rvrtlcr ltttrl lttlvitttcctl scrvct lt11c ltrcilitics to all.

o lrrlrotlrrc{iorr ol lltcs( tr'tltttololy {irr scrvct';tgc llsiltrllclll nlrlllts ;solitl wrrslc nrrrrl'.cllull irt lltc Ilrlrlrrr rttc;ts ttl lltc Sllrlc. Nl()lI srlrlirr scttirrrr rrp lirsl scrvcrit;lc lrciltnlcnl pllrttt irt l.trtllri;rrut ulticlt'lrr otlrrce r'lct:lr icity li otrt s'rrslc.

c 'lir nrret tlrc lllorrirrli rlcrrnntl ol pou'cr irt tlrc Stulc. lrigh lrcrrrporlrrctl corrrrrrillcc lrrrs bccn sct rrp lirt cortslrttction ol tlrrr'ycc(s lilt(ill l l'l-clrrl Nlohlbrt, Slrrrlrprrrkarttli I'nrjcct, ctc.

I Utt-irrtt'rrrrlrlctl 24 lrurrls Puucr srrIgrly lrrr tlrc lrrtrl lrrclts ul l'rrlplrurrrctl.

a SPccirrl slr inllertt rlcirsut cs lo clrcek llrc rttetrtcc ol'lctttltlc li,cticirlc.o liliicicrrl syslcrrr rritltorrl lIIlr.rsnrr.ill r.orrr;'rrlr'riscrl issrr:rilr'c

tlr ivittll lit t'rtt lr, l{eliislrrrliotr,t l(r'rlc ptt ntil:;, t'lt. itttrl prrrrltlllrrrl reliislr:rlirrn ol tttolor velriclcs lo piivtrtc dcltlcts ptoposctl. 'tltt spol surrrrrrrr y tlisptrsirl ol lr ll lic r:lr:tllrrrts.

o 5,1 sccortrl;rr v clrrc lro,;pil;tls l( rlis(r re{. srrll tlivisiortul lrrrtl lrlrrck lrInrvcbccrrplrysit:rrllyrrpgrlrtlcrl llrrotrglrtlrcstrpl)oltol \\brldllirll

"n'prftied'- Facilitr r\ll1_slorIrt_rtlrtoirtprcricclcostol lls. l().4 lcr0rcirrlstlllrlscrrrrrl l{s. l0lcrorciil2Dtl 1rlrrrsr:,. ,\l'.1.lirr llrtsrrlrti licc ltl l)toicct crr:;t ol'l{s. 42.J2 clorc.r Stock poirrts;rt vlr iorrs I)or I lo\\,ll:j irr lrrtlitr to lircilitlrlc srrrootlr cxl)otts.r \\'hcntrvorthlls.TT5crcrrsitlrcltl'lcxl)()r'tc(l outol'lls. l000crorcortlcrsirrlrrrrtl.r I:xport irousc s(lrtrrs clLrc to stcrlinlt cxllor.t Pgy{i;y1111111(.c.a l{icc cxporls u,or tlr I(s.SJ cltrlc con(nrclctl.r Ncrv nlrr kcts tbl oltl lirl I)urrjlb lirrrrrcr.s.

n

a

a

a

a

l':tsscrl rrrt I er I il izcl lrcrrt'l rl.r rr or t lr lls.(,I lirilicst plrtlrll, procrrrcrrrcrrt ltgcrrcy irrwortll l{s, 1400 ct'olc lllocurcrl.Ovcr 99.29i' rrrillinr: ol' prtltil, clopclorc.Spcc il l rlc:; igrrir (crl n rir rrrlis lil t lir ccl ptrtk ll, grr ot r rr c rr r,:rr ( in 2{)02

Pnlmjab Marches Ahead .o..ouR ACHIriVliN{tlN't's

llelicl't. tlrc irrrrrrcrs rdr lls J{)/- lJcr ([r;.rirl lirr rlrcir t,rr,l,ly Ir.r.rrr,,lrlrrrirrllKlrrrril-2{)01,1(s.l()l)cr(tlrirrr;rlrrsirlirstirrsr;rlrrrcrrrollroilils.ll(s.-1{l/- ylcr

qArtj"cle r,rhich appeared J.noon 18th Novenber

'

'zuu /.. : 4*ru&uRtL

^'-',-/

'f

. RD you'aware that you just gave away half a' crore of your rupees to Shri Anant G. Geete,minister for power? You also gave it away to Dr

. Murli Manohar Joshi, minister for human res-,ources development; Uma Bharati, minister forcoal and mines; Sukhdev Singh Dhindsa, min-

, ::'; ister for chemicals and fertilisers; M. Kannappan, minister of], tstat. for non-conventional energy sources; and tR. laatu,:. . 'tninister for environment and forests. The people of Hary-:' ..: 'ana/ Maharashtra, Chhattisgarh and Punlab gave it to their '.

' . chief ministers. On Indira Gandhi's death anniversary you '

.: . 'gav it to the Delhi government. You must be angry, Why 'r,. .. wouldn't you be? Because you know you did not give it .

.1 r ; .. ar{a/. So was it stolen? Weil, you can say, as good as. If some ''' geedy person takes half a'crore rupees to enhance his per-'

.

sonal image without so much as asking you, you have everyright to be livid. Just look at the rlcwspapers, I arn not ask-

' ing you to read them. People have possibly not reacted .'.

because they turn a natural blind eye to it.'l'he stuff is notnormally read except by those who put it in and beguile

' . themsclves into thinking that the whole world ls not only

OADSHOWSf. l"rjf,4i ;r l'. 1:i 'il'ltt'' I

even says in it that "the Samras Village scheme has rnade it*' ,Gu jarat villages dispute-free and vibrint". With Gujgrat

, .',,.

t l i

now an international tenn for cortinturtal violence and ' ' :seriously affecting investnlent antli,commerce, the people

"

of Gujarat have paid not only in tlieir sufferlng but also i':'u . :

paid for the mau's self-aggrandiserneut, , i"' '.r:':', ; II would tell these self-advertising ninisters to take a page f : i' ,

out of Arun Shourie's book, llelca-oguered as he is, Shourie took the timef to write and give real inforrrration irr$a series of articles,in 'fhe ItdianfiExpress about the problenrs he facesitin his rninistrv and what needs to betdone. I'hat tinA of stuff is not only

read, it has credibility. lf all whattltese ads claim is true, how corne rveas citizcns have not seeu the clrange?And, couldn't this moncy be put to

, bctter use? lior exarnple, wouldn't itbe better to put the nroney intoimproving tlre horrendous working/living conditlons of

I coal lnincrs rathcr than paying lralf a crore to announce "3i;TllARS Ol' GROUNDTI!{IiAKING t'[RIOI{NfANCti l}Y COAIJ AND NflNI, MlN.rrts'r'i{y". Or fixing the tollets ht a felv schools instead of tak.r ing out a full-page colour ad announcing again, "cloRlousI

,3 veans o[ ACnlrv[,M[Nls" in the rruu nrinistry.

A ND how nruclr'il !.q!!S qjqqQgt af Jo.ulpocket?ff ' f f t U r a t e s b e I o rv_ a r e e p!t_c!!-1,q&Lco10-u-!y.ef kda y sL "l.arlcfl,xl'ieJiii rrrrly. llind!t\tdtr 'firrrcs: Iull I'ate: Ils

. 1.11 o, o@ r llilr-sri* i;" Frtl'ag,c: lts 13,72,00u. Llaif I'agc: l{s tr,6(},!!!,_tl1c_!1!ljgrr

.

fip?R.-IiilfP, ttlns TZ0,IOU I I l I f I'lxe : I{s 2, I 0,000.-lloeyirevcfiicG

r a-to tlGl]u il i s t r rs tha t tliffi n.yi tltcy spend is not their persolral inconre to clo with as they 'plcrse? Why rre tlrcy not accountable for such wasteful

:,F+l-jk:, exltglt_t]itiLe/ lror every tlucstiorTtric-.rski, you gct only twoiinswers: 1. lt's all very well for you to talk and criticise. ''You live in air-conditi