overview of fmc soil and groundwater remediation technologies · soil and groundwater remediation...
TRANSCRIPT
Health and Safety
• Always review and refer to appropriate MSDS
• Material compatibility for delivery systems / design
– for oxidants use stainless steel or plastics
• Appropriate PPE for site and any other hazards
should be worn (e.g. overalls, gloves, boots, safety
glasses etc.)
• Injecting any liquid under pressure creates a
hazard to be risk assessed and controlled
FMC Soil and Groundwater Remediation
Webinar Series
• Series of free webinars for the soil and
groundwater remediation market
• The educational webinars focus on the
underlying science and application of chemical
and biological remedial technologies
• Highlight successful case studies
• Demonstrate how our experienced team of
technical professionals can assist with remedial
design
September 12, 2013
Agenda
• Overview of FMC Soil and Groundwater Remediation and our comprehensive portfolio
• cost effective, proven products that address a wide range of contaminants and site conditions
• Chemical Oxidation Technologies
• Aerobic Bioremediation Technologies
• Chemical Reduction Technologies
• Anaerobic Bioremediation Technologies
• Summary
September 12, 2013
September 12, 2013
• FMC is a global chemical company
• FMC is a supplier of reagents to cause the destruction of organic
contaminants and immobilisation of metals.
• Success of remediation projects requires design expertise based on
a technical understanding of:
• contaminant chemistry
• site geology and hydrogeology
• the mechanisms by which the technology works
• experience of successful applications of the techniques
• FMC backs up its products with an experienced team, including 8
with Ph.D.’s, who also have decades of industry experience
designing and implementing remediation projects
• Our business model enables implementation of in situ / on site
remediation technologies by provision of reagents and expertise.
FMC Soil & Groundwater Remediation
Chemical Oxidation
Soil and Groundwater
Remediation
Technologies
Klozur® Persulfate Technologies for
Chemical Oxidation
What is Chemical Oxidation?
• Addition of Oxidants into the subsurface to facilitate the
conversion of recalcitrant and toxic compounds to CO2
and H2O or less toxic / more biodegradable
intermediates
• Chemical Oxidation reduces contaminant mass through
the oxidation process
• Suitable for saturated and/or vadose zone source and
plume treatment
• Chemical Oxidation maybe combined with other
techniques (e.g. enhanced or monitored natural
attenuation)
• Permanganate (MnO4) – low solubility of K salt
– not strong enough to destroy benzene (no radical mechanism)
– can oxidise TCE
– forms solid residues “crust” on DNAPL
• Hydrogen Peroxide (H2O2) (Fenton’s Reagent) – very reactive (creates heat and off
gas) so potential safety issues
– short half life so limited distribution
– radical mechanism
• Ozone (O3) – low solubility gas must be sparged
– short half life thus limited distribution
– Radical mechanism
– often an addition to AS/SVE so
unclear if oxidation mechanism is
responsible for contaminant removal
• Persulfate (S2O8) – high solubility
– radical mechanism
– variable half live hence longevity can
be adjusted from hours to months
– Safe to handle and inject
Common Chemical Oxidants used for Remediation
Klozur ® Persulfate
• Oxidation mechanisms via direct oxidation (relatively strong) and production of radicals (sulphate SO4˙ and hydroxyl OH˙)
• Thermodynamically very strong –can oxidise multiple organic compounds
• Does not produce gaseous breakdown products or significant heat
• High aqueous solubility (>40%) for diffusion and advection –large ROI
• Can be activated over a wide range of geochemical conditions
• Can be mixed into unsaturated soils to destroy a wide range of target organics
• Ease of handling as oxidant is supplied as a granular solid
• Leaves residual sulfate in formation to stimulation biodegradation
Purchase of FMC’s Klozur® Persulfate includes rights to practice
the inventions covered by the patents in the purchase price of the
product
Granular Persulfate
• Persulfate can produce radicals which are powerful and kinetically fast but activation is required
• Engineered activation methods are designed based on:
• specific contaminant(s) –their nature and distribution
• site lithology hydrogeology
• Activation is simple, as usually two liquids are mixed together –like adding milk to tea!
Klozur Persulfate Chemistry – Activation
S2O8-2 + activator SO4•- + (SO4•- or SO4
-2)
Heat Iron H2O2 High pH
Sustainable Solution: FMC Manufactures Utilizing Hydroelectric Power
Klozur Activated Persulfate
Examples of contaminants destroyed
Chlorinated Solvents
PCE, TCE, DCE
TCA, DCA
Vinyl chloride
Carbon tetrachloride
Chloroform
Chloroethane
Chloromethane
Dichloropropane
Trichloropropane
Methylene chloride
TPH
BTEX
GRO
DRO
ORO
creosote
Oxygenates
MTBE
TBA
Chlorobenzenes
Chlorobenzene
Dichlorobenzene
trichlorobenzene
Phenols
phenol
Pentachlorophenol
nitrophenol
Freons
Pesticides
DDT
Chlordane
Heptachlor
Lindane
Toxaphene
MCPA
Bromoxynil
PAHs
Anthracene
Benzopyrene
Styrene
Naphthalene
Pyrene
Chrysene
trimethylbenzene
Others
Carbon disulfide
PFOS / PFOA
Aniline
PVA
TNT / DNT
1,4 Dioxane
Klozur® Activated Persulfate Application Methods
• Direct push
• Fixed well
• In situ soil mixing
• Ex situ soil mixing
Forming a persulfate solution
Fixed wells
Direct push rig
In situ mixing
Site: Leaking UST at Former Chemical Plant
Contaminant: Dichloromethane Lowest Conc. 910 ppb
Highest Conc. 12,000 ppb
Treatment: Six Years - Pump Treat System
Two Years - Soil Vapor Extraction System
Soil & GW Did Not Meet LA RWQCB Closure Level
Injected Hydrogen Peroxide Activated Klozur®
Target GW Zone 40-48 ft bgs
1,600 ft2 Under Bldg & 800 ft2 Outside Bldg
Geology: Silty Clays/Narrow Silty Sand Layers
23 Application Wells (16 inside the bldg)
ROI = 8-12 ft
Results: 1. Levels Reduced 94 - 97% within 61 Days
of Monitoring Following Treatment
2. Site Closure Accepted by LA RWQCB
after Two Years of Monitoring
Klozur Persulfate Case Study
Fixed Wells - H2O2 Activation
• 5,000 tons Treated in 2 days
• Depth to Groundwater – 1 foot
• Treatment Interval – 1 to 11 feet bgs
• 10 gram Klozur / 1 gram Hydrated Lime Applied per Kilogram of Soil
• Concentrations Dropped from 100 – 200 ppm Total VOCs in Groundwater to Less than 0.1 ppm in One Week
Klozur Persulfate Case Study
Soil Mixing - Alkaline Activation
In Situ Chemical Oxidation of Chlorobenzene using Klozur Activated Persulfate
• Design objective; maximize in situ destruction of COC in a
single round of intensive treatment
• 7,317 m2 (all 5 Hotspots) treated Sept 07 – Feb 08
• Most impacted areas in Hotspots were treated twice
• Persulfate injection concentrations; 20 and 40% wt/wt (mostly
40% wt/wt)
• Lime activation resulted in enhanced mobilization of COC from
sorbed and NAPL phases
• Estimated that 11,304 kg of COC’s were oxidized in the soil
phase
• Calculated that 189 kg of COC was oxidized in dissolved
phase
• Concentrations of chlorobenzene and dichlorobenzene reduced
at least ten fold since completion of the ISCO treatment
• Latest samples; all COC’s are significantly below EQS (Envl
Quality Std’s)
• June 2008; Site “closed” acceptance letter by
The Environment Agency
continuous
flight auger rigs
Area A Area C Area E
Area B Area D
2008 Brownfield Briefing Remediation Innovative Award -“Best Conceptual Design”
Thornton, England
Aerobic
Bioremediation
Soil and Groundwater
Remediation
Technologies
Aerobic Bioremediation Using
PermeOx® Plus,
Calcium Peroxide and
Terramend®
What is Aerobic Bioremediation?
• Addition of oxygen and nutrients to allow microbial
biodegradation of organic contaminants
• Facilitate the conversion of biodegradable
compounds to CO2 and H2O
• Aerobic bioremediation reduces contaminant mass
through natural biological processes, which are often
limited by the availability of oxygen or nutrients
• The solubility of oxygen in water in very low (10
mg/L) so a continuing source of oxygen can promote
aerobic biodegradation in groundwater
• For unsaturated soils oxygen can be provided from
air (21% oxygen), and the moisture content
managed, so a source of nutrients containing N & P
will stimulate biodegradation
PermeOx® Plus and Calcium Peroxide
CaO2 + 2H2O → Ca(OH)2 + H2O2
2H2O2 → O2 + 2H2O
• PermeOx Plus is Engineered calcium peroxide for very slow release of oxygen
• Calcium Peroxide is a standard (food) grade with a faster oxygen release profile
Both products provide oxygen for enhanced aerobic bioremediation
• For the treatment of readily biodegradable organic compounds such as petroleum hydrocarbons
• 18% Active Oxygen
• Applied as a slurry
• PermeOx Plus provides long-term oxygen release up to one year
• Calcium Peroxide gives oxygen release over multiple months
• Priced very competitively
September 12, 2013
Active Petrol Retail Station - Germany
• Groundwater remediation via stimulation of aerobic bioremediation
via slow release of oxygen from modified calcium peroxide
• Two Direct Push slurry injections
• Two and a half years of site monitoring
Aerobic Bioremediation Case Study
Terramend®
• Terramend comprises nutrients containing N and P sources to
allow microbial growth on biodegradable organic compounds
in soils
• Specific Terramend formulations may also allow co-metabolic
induction of PAH degrading enzymes via addition of plant
fibres
September 12, 2013
Chemical Reduction
Soil and Groundwater
Remediation
Technologies
Chemical Reduction Using
Daramend® and EHC®
(Carbohydrate & ZVI)
September 12, 2013
What is chemical reduction?
• Chemical reduction involves transfer of electrons to
contaminants from reduced metals (ZVI, ferrous iron)
or reduced minerals (magnetite, pyrite)
• The major dechlorination pathway promoted by ISCR
technology is β-elimination, which supports complete
dechlorination of TCE and PCE with less
accumulation of metabolites such as cis-DCE and VC
than pure enzymatic systems
• Permeable reactive barriers, known as PRBs,
constructed using ZVI are probably the most well-
know and broadly applied example of ISCR.
ß–Elimination: Main Pathway
Biogenolysis/Hydrogenolysis: Minor Pathway
• Reaction is abiotic reductive dehalogenation; minimizes/eliminates DCE/VC
• Requires direct contact with ZVI surface
• β-elimination is the dominant pathway (~90%); ZVI generates hydrogen so some
biotic reductive reactions are supported
Direct Chemical Reduction
cVOC Dechlorination Pathways with ZVI
Contaminants Treated via Chemical Reduction
EHC® / Daramend®
• Chlorinated Solvents
o PCE, TCE, cDCE, 11DCE, VC
o 1122TeCA, 111TCA, 12DCA
o CT, CF, DCM, CM
• Pesticides
o Toxaphene, Chlordane, Dieldrin, Pentachlorophenol
• Energetics
o TNT, DNT, RDX, HMX, Perchlorate
EHC® Metals ISCR Reagent
• Heavy Metals including As, Cr, Pb, Zn, Cd
EHC In Situ Chemical Reduction (ISCR)
Reagent Composition
EHC is for application to groundwater
EHC is delivered as a dry powder and
includes the following:
• Micro-scale zero valent iron (standard ~40%)
• Controlled-release, food grade, complex carbohydrate
(plant fibres) (standard ~60%)
• Major, minor, and micronutrients
• Food grade organic binding agent
• Sustainable Solution
o scrap metal
o food production by-products
EHC® ISCR Installation Methods
Injection Methods
• Direct injection
• Hydraulic fracturing
• Pneumatic fracturing
• Well injections (EHC-L)
Direct Placement
• Trenching
• Excavations
• Deep soil mixing
59-01-EIT-DL
Chemical Reduction of
Contaminants in Soil – Daramend
• Patented combination of slow-release
carbohydrate and nutrients with micro-
scale ZVI (20% to 50% w/w)
• Stimulates indigenous bacteria by
providing carbon and nutrients
• Generate very strong reducing conditions
that promote reductive dehalogenation
reactions
• 2% to 5% by weight required to treat most
soils to remedial goals
• More than 10,000,000 tons of soil,
sediment, and other wastes have been
successfully treated to date.
Carbon Fermentation + ZVI Corrosion:
Multiple Dechlorination Mechanisms
Production of organic acids (VFAs):
• Serves as electron donor for microbial
reduction of CVOCs and other oxidized
species such as O2, NO3, SO4
• The release of acids keeps the pH down and
thereby serve to reduce precipitate formation
on ZVI surfaces to increase reactivity
• Increase rate of iron corrosion/H2 generation
Favorable thermodynamic conditions for
dechlorination:
• Combined oxygen consumption from carbon
fermentation and iron oxidation Strongly
reduced environment (-250 to -500 mV)
• High electron/H+ pressure
ZVI Reactions:
Fe0 Fe2+ + 2e-
2H2O 2H+ + 2OH-
2H+ + 2e- H2(g)
R-Cl + H+ + 2e- R-H + Cl-
Fe+2 generation
Material
Solid
Organic
Carbon
Iron
Metal
Oxide Film
Ferm
enta
tion
H+
VFA H2 generation
59-01-EIT-DL
Downtown Urban Setting Former Dry Cleaner –
Site Remediation Using Direct Injection of EHC
• Site: Waterfront Medieval Town Center, The Netherlands
• Solution Provider: Groundwater Technology B.V., Rotterdam, The
Netherlands
• Geotechnically sensitive subsoil
(some peat / clay)
• P&T virtually impossible
(low permeability)
• Busy street –
services, sewers etc
• Recreational shopping –
boutiques, café. bars
• Plume extends 2,600 ft / 800 m from
grain elevators.
• Discharges into small creek.
• The bedrock rises to an elevation of ca
9 ft / 3 m above the present day water
table at the presumed source area.
• PRZ installed down-gradient of
suspected source area in April 2005.
• The PRZ is installed as a line of
injection points spaced approximately
10 ft / 3 m apart.
• The PRZ extends across the width of
the plume and measures ca 270 ft / 90
m long.
EHC Permeable Reactive Zone (PRZ)
Case Study
Plume Treatment CCl4
-50
-45
-40
-35
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
0 27 54 81 108 135 162 189 216 243 270
Distance from SBE [ft]
Inje
cti
on
de
pth
[ft
]
EHC PRZ – Plume
Treatment Injection Layout
44<1
<1
120067
25<1 <1
19
1575
16
72<1
5.825
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
May 2010
60<1
<1
57062
31<1 <1
21
1635
21
120<1
1334
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
October 2009
70<1
<1
1400130
29<1 <1
21
2117
62
260<1
1589
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
April 2009
150<1
<1
620170
49<1 <1
37
1254
110
490<1
28170
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
October 2008
82<1
<1
1400300
57<1 <1
13
1946
380
650<1
25280
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
April 2008
98<1
<1
1600170
27<1 <1
14
94140
610
540<1
82190
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
August 2007
36<1
<1
2700620
33<1 <1
17
150380
610
410<1
2.485
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
February 2007
47<1
<1
770140
100011 <1
140
49067
280
4606.4
3798
<1
EHC Treatment Zone
Monitoring well andCT concentration (ug/L)
N
Property Line
0 300 600
SCALE IN FEET
March 2005
EHC PRZ - Plume Treatment Results
EHC® Permeable Reactive Zone
Plume Treatment Economics
• A total of 21,800 kg of EHC was used
to create the 90 m long PRB at a
product cost of less than € 80,000
€330/m2 of PRB cross-section.
• The installation was completed in 12
days using direct injection.
• So far, the PRB has treated a total of
73,000 m3 of groundwater during its
life-time at a product cost of (€1/m3).
Treatment of Pesticides in Soils with Daramend
• Former agricultural chemical manufacturing facility
• Approximately 4,500 tons of soil and sediment from drainage ditch
contaminated with DDT, DDE, DDD, and Toxaphene
• Applied and incorporated 2% (w/w) DARAMEND amendments
• Irrigate amended soil to 90% of soil water holding capacity and
leave for 7 days
• Aerate by tilling for 2 or 3 days
• Repeat process if required
Treatment of Pesticides
0
50
100
150
200
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14
Time (cycles)
Co
nc
en
tra
tio
n (
mg
/kg
)
Toxaphene
DDT
DDE
DDD
EHC Metals ISCR Treated and Mechanisms
Contaminant Treatment Mechanisms in the ZVI-
Carbohydrate zone
As (III, V) Reductive precipitation with oxidized iron
minerals. Precipitation as As sulfide and mixed Fe-As sulfide
Cr(VI), Mo(VI), Se(IV,VI),
U(VI)
Reductive precipitation with oxidized iron minerals and adsorption to iron oxides.
Me2+ (Cu, Zn, Pb, Cd, Ni)
Metal cations precipitate as sulfides, following stimulated heterotrophic
microbial sulfate reduction to sulfide. Adsorption to iron corrosion products (e.g.;
iron oxides and oxyhydroxides).
• Puls and Su, EPA Research Lab, OK:, Reductive precipitation of chromium and arsenic treatment
with ZVI PRBs.
• Blowes et al., University of Waterloo: Organic substrate PRBs for sulfate reduction and trace
metals treatment in acid mine drainage.
EHC Metal is controlled-release carbohydrate with sulfide, nutrients &
micro-scale ZVI
EHC Metals Case Study – Pb Treatment
Battery Recycling Facility
Contaminants
•Lead – 360 - 86 μg/L
Approach
• Create sulfate reducing conditions
• Conditions by Injecting EHC-M
• 0.05% EHC-M by wt. application rate
• 0.25% by wt. Dolomite
• Direct push, Direct Placement
59-01-EIT-DL
-200
-100
0
100
200
300
400
0
3
6
9
12
15
11/7/07 11/9/07 11/11/07 11/1/08 11/3/08 11/5/08
Po
ten
cia
l R
ed
ox
(m
V)
pH
Gráfico 2 - Potencial Redox e pH no poço PB-01
pH
ORP (mV)
Results
• Pb concentration
reduced to <10 ppb in
six months
• Full-scale remediation
in progress
EHC Metals injection 11/11/07 59-01-EIT-DL
EHC Metals Case Study – Pb Treatment
Battery Recycling Facility
Anaerobic
Bioremediation
Soil an Groundwater
Remediation
Technologies
ELS™ for in situ Bioremediation
via Enhanced Reductive
Dechlorination
September 12, 2013
What is Anaerobic Bioremediation? • Anaerobic bioremediation of chlorinated solvents
involves the use of the contaminants as the terminal
electron acceptor (respiratory substrate) i.e. instead
of oxygen, nitrate, sulfate etc.
• This process may also be termed dehalorespiration or
enhanced reductive dechlorination.
• The process involves sequential dechlorination of
chlorinated solvents where cis-DCE and VC are
common daughter products, before ethene / ethane is
formed.
• The process is mediated by Dehalococoides sp.
which are relatively ubiquitous but need to increase in
population density (grow) to allow rapid sequential
biotransformations
ELS™ emulsified lecithin substrate
• Applications:
• Enhanced reductive dechlorination
including both biostimulation and
bioaugmentation
• Composition:
• Food-grade lecithin, including: • Phospholipids for long-term release
of organic carbohydrate • Slow-release nitrogen & phosphorus • Polysaccharides and sugars to support
rapid creation of reducing conditions
• Availability:
• 25% emulsion and 100% concentrate
• Packaging:
• 5-gal. pail, 55-gal. drum, 275-gal.
tote (25% emulsion only)
ELS Advantages • Easy to use:
• Stable emulsion
• No chase water needed
• Slow release nutrients:
• Provides both organic
nitrogen and phosphorus
• Good distribution:
• Hydrophilic for enhanced
distribution
• Small droplet size (60%
<1µm and 85% <2μm)
• Efficient source of hydrogen:
• High yield of H2
produced/gram substrate
• Long lasting:
• Extended release profile of
2 to 3 years
Superior transport in the subsurface
(hydrophilic nature of phospholipids
eliminates need for chase water)
Hydrogen Yield from Organic Electron Donors
Product
Product Concentration
(%)
Theoretical Hydrogen yield * (g H2/g substrate, estimate,
as delivered)
ELS™ Concentrate 100 0.324
Emulsified Vegetable Oil 100 0.359
HRC® 100 0.141
Sodium Lactate Solution 100 0.075
* Source ESTCP Project ER-0627, 2010
• Hydrogen utilization by bacteria is influenced by other factors including:
• Biodegradation rate (longevity)
• Substrate distribution
• Availability of nutrients
• pH
ELS Longevity (Column effluent TOC at 20 °C)
15cm/day gw flow TOC remained above the 20 mg/L threshold needed to support ERD for more than 365 days. Column
test run at RT (20±2 °C); Given the Q10 for carbohydrate fermentation is 2.0 we estimate ELS longevity in groundwater at a
typical temperature of 10±2 °C will be between 2 and 3 years
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
0 100 200 300 400 500
To
tal O
rgan
ic C
arb
on
(m
g/L
)
Time (Days)
Feed
EHC-L
20 mg/L TOC
ELS – Applicability
Target Compounds: • Chlorinated ethenes • Chlorinated methanes • Chlorinated ethanes • Some heavy metals • Some pesticides & herbicides • Some organic explosives
Suitable Site Conditions & Objectives:
• Wide range of permeability • Moderate to slow groundwater flow • Plume treatment • Diffuse source zone treatment
Contaminant Levels: • Wide range subject to target
compound identity and site conditions
Longevity: • Typically 2 to 3 years
Application Methods: • Direct push • Gravity feed through existing wells or
well points • Low or high pressure injection; subject
to site conditions • Recirculation systems
FMC Soil & Groundwater Remediation
• A comprehensive portfolio of cost effective proven products to address a
wide range of contaminants and site conditions
• Unsurpassed technical support
• An experienced team of environmental professionals focused on
remedial strategies; including 8 Ph.D. level remediation specialists
• Remedial design and field support
• Other Services
• Laboratories focused on research and treatability studies
• Support services including site test kits
• Upcoming Events
• Technical webinars
• The application of In Situ Chemical Reduction (ISCR)
Groundwater Remediation Technologies
• Destruction organic contaminants in soil and groundwater using
Chemical Oxidation
• November conferences in London, Paris and Milan
September 12, 2013
©2013 FMC Corporation. FMC, DARAMEND, EHC, ELS, PermeOx and Teramend are trademarks of FMC Corporation or its
subsidiaries. HRC is a trademark of Regenesis. All rights reserved
FMC Soil and Groundwater Remediation - Europe
Technical Support
Dr. Ian Ross (UK) [email protected]
+44 7855 745531
General Enquiries
Mike Mueller (Austria) [email protected]
+43 664 1803060