NOVEMBER 2009 1

SHIPBUILDING AND SHIP PROCUREMENTFOR THE SPANISH NAVY

BRIEFING FOR: SCHOOL OF POLICY STUDIES

QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY

BRIEFING FOR: SCHOOL OF POLICY STUDIES

QUEEN'S UNIVERSITY

NOVEMBER 2009 2

SHIPBUILDING PROGRAMSHIPBUILDING PROGRAM

ENTERING THE FINAL STAGE OF ONE OF THE MOST AMBITIOUS SHIPBUILDING PROGRAM OF THE SPANISH NAVY HISTORY

NOVEMBER 2009 3

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

THE SHIPBUILDING STRATEGY IS AT THE

CORE OF OUR CAPABILITY TO DESIGN, BUILD,

SUPPORT AND EVOLVE, THROUGH THE LIFE

CYCLE, THE FLEET

NOVEMBER 2009 4

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

• THE PILLARS

• A LONG-TERM SHIPBUILDING

STRATEGY

• RULES OF ENGAGEMENT

• THE CHALLENGES

• THE DELIVER RESULTS

NOVEMBER 2009 5

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

THE PILLARSTHE PILLARS

NOVEMBER 2009 6

THE PILLARS OF THE MODEL

THEORY

OF NICHES

THEORY

OF NICHES

THE NAVY

A PROACTIVE ROLE

THE NAVY

A PROACTIVE ROLE

NAVANTIA

SOLE SOURCE

SHIPYARD

NAVANTIA

SOLE SOURCE

SHIPYARD

THE INDUSTRIALMODEL

THE INDUSTRIALMODEL

FABA

COMBAT SYSTEMS

FABA

COMBAT SYSTEMS

THE BEST

TECHNOLOGICAL

PARTNER

WE CAN AFFORD

THE BEST

TECHNOLOGICAL

PARTNER

WE CAN AFFORD

NOVEMBER 2009 7

WHY SOLE SOURCE SHIPYARD?

• WE CAN'T AFFORD COMPETITION

• LIMITED NUMBER OF CONTRACTS,

MANY DIFFERENT TYPES OF SHIPS

AND SMALL NUMBER OF SHIPS BY

CLASS ( SOME PROTOTYPES) MAKES

UNREALISTIC DIFFERENT SHIPYARDS

IN COMPETITION

• NAVANTIA IS OUR SOLE SOURCE

SHIPYARD AND A STRATEGIC ASSET

FOR THE NAVY

SOLE SOURCE SHIPYARD

NOVEMBER 2009 9

ENGINEERING & PRODUCTIONCRITICAL MASS

ALFLOT HQ

FERROL

ROTACARTAGENA

FERROL SHIPYARD

SAN FERNANDO

PUERTO REALFABA

ENGINES

NOVEMBER 2009 12

THE ROLE OF THE NAVY

• CLEAR DEFINITION OF OP REQS

• MAINTAIN THE TECHNICAL SPECS CODE

• CONTROL THE SHIPBUILDING PROCESS

• COMPETENCY IN THE :

– DESIGN

– BUILDING

– RISK ASSESSMENT

– COST ESTIMATE & NEGOTIATION

– SYSTEM ENGINEERING

– SHIPYARD BUSINESS

• DRIVER OF TECHNOLOGY

IMPROVEMENTS

THE NAVY IN CONTROL OF

THE ENTIRE

BUILDING PROCESS

NOVEMBER 2009 13

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

A LONG-TERMSHIPBUILDING STRATEGY

A LONG-TERMSHIPBUILDING STRATEGY

NOVEMBER 2009 14

A LONG-TERM SHIPBUILDING STRATEGY

XXI CENTURYXXI CENTURYXXXX

OWN DESIGN PHASE

LE

VE

L O

F N

AT

ION

AL

DE

SIG

N

70’s decade 80’s decade 90’s decade

OWN CONSTRUCTION

IMPORTED DESIGN

PHASE

S-70

S-80

F310

F-100

LHD

FFG

LPD

PDA

S-60

DEG

S-70

FUTURE FRIGATE

AUSTRALIAN LHDs

AAW DESTROYER

Corvettes

F-100

NOVEMBER 2009 15

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

THE CHALLENGESTHE CHALLENGES

NOVEMBER 2009 16

THE CHALLENGES

THEORY

OF NICHES

THEORY

OF NICHES

THE NAVY IN

CONTROL OF THE

ACQUISITION PROCESS

THE NAVY IN

CONTROL OF THE

ACQUISITION PROCESS

THE BEST

TECHNOLOGICAL

PARTNER

WE CAN AFFORD

THE BEST

TECHNOLOGICAL

PARTNER

WE CAN AFFORD

SOLE SOURCE

SHIPYARD

SOLE SOURCE

SHIPYARD

CONTAIN COST IN ASOLE SOURCE SCENARIO

CONTAIN COST IN ASOLE SOURCE SCENARIO

RELEASABILITY ISSUESRELEASABILITY ISSUES

KEEP KNOW-HOWWITHIN THE NAVY

KEEP KNOW-HOWWITHIN THE NAVY

COMMERCIAL Vs MIL SPCSCOMMERCIAL Vs MIL SPCS

CONTINUOUS&COMPETITIVELONG TERM IMPROVEMENT

CONTINUOUS&COMPETITIVELONG TERM IMPROVEMENT

NOVEMBER 2009 17

THE MODEL

RULES OF ENGAGEMENTRULES OF ENGAGEMENT

NOVEMBER 2009 18

“RULES OF ENGAGEMENT”

• RESTRAIN CHANGES DURING CONSTRUCTION• EMPLOY SAME SYSTEM ENGINEERING AND

MANAGEMENT PROCEDURES ACROSS THE PROGRAM

• DO NOT START CONSTRUCTION UNTIL DESIGN IS MATURE

• SATISFY PERFORMANCE AND SCHEDULE AT ACCEPTABLE RISK AND AFFORDABLE COST

• ALLOW FUTURE GROWTH FOR EMERGING OPERATIONAL REQUIREMENTS

NOVEMBER 2009 19

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL

THE DELIVER RESULTSTHE DELIVER RESULTS

NOVEMBER 2009 20

F-100 FRIGATE

CONCEPT: FRIGATE FOR AAW SUPERIORITY. A FULL AEGIS IN A 6000 TONS SHIP

ACQUISITION STRATEGY:• NAVANTIA PRIME CONTRACTOR• NATIVE DESIGN FOR THE

PLATFORM• AEGIS FMS & NATIONAL DESIGN

FOR COMBAT SYSTEM• USN SUPPORT KEY FOR

INTEGRATION AND CSSQT

NOVEMBER 2009 21

S-80 A SUBMARINE OF THE NEXT GENERATIOM

THE COMBINATION OF AN AIP SYSTEM AND STRIKE CAPABILITY MAKES THE S-80 A SUBMARINE OF THE NEXT GENERATION

NOVEMBER 2009 22

SUBMARINE S-80

CONCEPT: CONVENTIONAL SUBMARINE COMBINING AIR INDEPENDENT PROPULSION AND STRIKE (TACTOM)

ACQUISITION STRATEGY:• NATIVE DESIGN• PRIME CONTRACTOR NAVANTIA• LOCKHEED MARTIN TECHNOLOGICAL

PARTNER FOR THE COMBAT SYSTEM• UTC TECHNOLOGICAL PARTNER FOR

POWER CELLS

USN KEY FOR ESTABLISHING THE SUBSAFE PROGRAM AND TACTOM INTEGRATION

NOVEMBER 2009 23

S-80 PROGRAM

NOVEMBER 2009 24

S-80 PROGRAM

NOVEMBER 2009 25

LHD

CONCEPT : A FORCE PROJECTION UNIT THAT COMBINES AMPHIBIOUS, HELO & VSTOL CAPABILITIES

ACQUISITION STRATEGY:• NAVANTIA PRIME CONTRACTOR• NATIVE DEVELOPMENT OF

COMBAT SYSTEM AND SENSORS• USN SUPPORT KEY FOR FLIGHT

CERTIFICATION AND JSF INTEGRATION

NOVEMBER 2009 26

PROJECTION CAPABILITY

NOVEMBER 2009 27

PROJECTION CAPABILITY

NOVEMBER 2009 28

BAC

CONCEPT : A FORCE SUPPORT UNIT

ACQUISITION STRATEGY:• NAVANTIA PRIME CONTRACTOR• NATIVE DEVELOPMENT OF

COMBAT SYSTEM AND SENSORS

NOVEMBER 2009 29

CONCLUSIONSCONCLUSIONS

THE SHIPBUILDING MODEL IS OPTIMIZED TO OUR CONSTRAINS AND NEEDS AND HAS PROVEN VERY SUCCESSFUL IN FULFILLING THE MAIN OBJECTIVE OF BUILDING A BALANCED AND MODERN FLEET