nasrin soltankhah department of mathematical sciencesdepartment of mathematical sciences alzahra...

46
A GENERALIZATION OF TRADES Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. Iran

Upload: frederica-heather-riley

Post on 19-Jan-2016

218 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

A GENERALIZATION OF TRADES

Nasrin Soltankhah

Department of Mathematical Sciences

Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. Iran

Page 2: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Given a set of v treatments V. Let k and t be two positive integers such that t<k<v.

 

Page 3: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

•    

Page 4: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

In a (v,k,t) trade both collections of blocks must cover the same set of elements. This set of elements is called the foundation of the trade and is denoted by found(T).

Page 5: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

ExampleA (6,4,1) trade of volume 2

   

xy12xy34

xy13xy24

   

x12x34y13y24z14z23

x13x24y14y23z12z34

A (7,3,2) trade of volume 6

Page 6: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

1. Hedayat introduced the concept of trade [1] in the 1960s.

2. Hedayat and Li applied the method of trade-off and trades for building BIBDs by repeated blocks (1979-1980).

3. Milici and Quattrocchi introduced the steiner trade named it DMB (1984).

4. Hwang (1986), Mahmoodian and Soltankhah [1992 ] and Asgari and Soltankhah [ 2009] deal with the existence and non-existence of (v,k,t) trades.

Page 7: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Some Known results

 

 

Page 8: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

   

   

  

x

x

x

x

 

 

 

Page 9: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

 

 

Page 10: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

minimal

Mimimal (v,k,t) trade has unique structure

 

If found(T)=k+t+1

 

Page 11: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

There exists (v,k,t) trade of volume m for

 

 

 

Page 12: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Combinatorial trade1. Trade in other block designs2. Trade in Latin squares (Latin trade)3. G-trade in graphs (Decomposition H)

Page 13: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

trade

Latin trade

-(v,k,t) Latin trade

-(v,k,t) trade

A Generalization of combinatorial trade

Page 14: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

1 2 3 4

3 4 2 1

4 3 1 2

2 1

4 3

Page 15: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

Definition:

Page 16: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

 

Example:

Page 17: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

 

Page 18: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Definition

 

 

Page 19: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Example:

x12 x34 y13 y24 z14 z23

x14 x23 y12 y34 z13 z24

x13 x24 y14 y23 z12 z34

     

3-way (7,3,2) trade

xy12

xy34

xy13

xy24

xy14

xy23

     

3-way (6,4,1) trade

Page 20: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

123 147 158 248 267 357368456

124 138 157 237 268 467458356

127 135 148 246 238 367457568

     

3-way (8,3,2) trade

Page 21: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Application of Trade

1. Intersection problem2. Defining set

Page 22: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Trade off

Page 23: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

BIBD

Balanced incomplete block designsLet v, k, and λ be positive integers such that v > k ≥ 2. A (v, k, λ)-balanced incomplete block design ((v, k, λ)-BIBD) is a pair (X,A) such that the following properties are satisfied:

1. |X| = v,

2. each block contains exactly k points, and

3. every pair of distinct points is contained in exactly λ blocks.

Page 24: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

A Steiner triple system of order v, or STS(v), is a (v, 3, 1)-BIBD.

x12 x34 y13 y24 z14 z23

x14 x23 y12 y34 z13 z24

x13 x24Y14y23z12 z34

STS(7):

3-(7,3,2)TRADE

     

x12 x34 y13 y24 z14 z23 xyz

Page 25: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

INTERSECTION

Page 26: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

x12 x34 y13 y24 z14 z23 xyz

x14 x23 y12 y34 z13 z24 xyz

x13 x24 y14 y23 z12 z34 xyz

3-(7,3,2) trade     

Page 27: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Defining Set

Page 28: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

• Given parameters k, t. For which volume

does there exist a µ – way (v, k, t) trade ?

What is the volume spectrum ?

Page 29: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

µ = 3 

 

Page 30: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

Page 31: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

     

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

of volume m

Construction 1

Page 32: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

     

1234

1324

1423

3-way (4,2,1) trade

Example:

x12x34y13y24z14z23

x13x24y14y23z12z34

x14x23y12y34z13z24

3-way (7,3,2) trade

     

Unique structure

Page 33: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

     

     

Construction 2

Page 34: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Example:

     

1234

1324

1423

3-way (4,2,1) tradeof volume 2

 

     

3-way (8,4,3) trade of volume 12

   

Page 35: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

     

     

 

 

 

   

   

 

Page 36: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

     

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Construction 2

Page 37: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

 

t m Construction

1 2

2 6 1

3 12 2

4 36 1

5 72 2⁞ ⁞ ⁞

Page 38: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

Question 1

Does there exist a 3-way (v,k,t) trade of volume less than  

Conjecture:The minimum volume is  

For t=2

For t=3

 

Page 39: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

For t=2 and k=3

For t=3 and k=4

Question 2

 

Page 40: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

•  

Page 41: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

•  

k = t+1

Page 42: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran

•  

Page 43: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran
Page 44: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran
Page 45: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran
Page 46: Nasrin Soltankhah Department of Mathematical SciencesDepartment of Mathematical Sciences Alzahra University Tehran, I.R. IranTehran, I.R. Iran