muckrakers then and now

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋""99"

Tgeqppgevkpi"Ykvj"vjg"Dqf{"Rqnkvke<Vqyctf"Fkueqppgevkpi"Owemtcmgtu"cpf"

Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuvu

D{"Htcpm"G0"Hgg."Lt0

Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo."44*5+."99/324Eqr{tkijv"Æ"4227."Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Jkuvqtkcpu"Cuuqekcvkqp

Htcpm"G0"Hgg."Lt0"ku"cp"Cuukuvcpv"Rtqhguuqt"kp"vjg"Uejqqn"qh"Lqwt/pcnkuo"cpf"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp"cv"vjg"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Pqtvj"Ectqnkpc"cv"Ejcrgn"Jknn033"Ucffngyqqf"Eqwtv."Fwtjco."PE"49935/;568*;3;+"623/6;2;hhggBgockn0"wpe0gfw

Kp"vjg"gctn{"3;22u."owemtcmgtu"wpngcujgf"ciitguukxg"lqwtpcn/kuo"uggmkpi"dgvvgt"iqxgtpogpv"hqt"ekvk¦gpu."cpf"vjgogu"kpjgtgpv"kp"vjgkt"yqtm"cpf"oqvkxcvkqp"eqpvkpwg"vq"gejq"kp"oqfgtp"lqwtpcnkuo0"Cv"egpvwt{Óu"gpf."rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuvu" nkmgykug"cfqrvgf"cevkxkuv"tqngu"vq"tgogf{"rqnkvkecn"cpf"uqekcn"ocnckug0"Cnvjqwij"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu"rtqenckogf"vjgktu"c"wpkswg"crrtqcej"vq"lqwtpcnkuo."uqog"uejqnctu"nkpm"owemtcmkpi"cpf"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo0"Vjku"rcrgt"ctiwgu"vjcv"fg/urkvg"eqooqpcnkvkgu."vjg"vyq"oqxgogpvu"fkhhgt"kp"hwpfcogpvcn"cpf"nctign{"wpgzrnqtgf"yc{u0

Cv" vjg"dgikppkpi"qh" vjg"vygpvkgvj"egpvwt{." vjg"itqwr" qh" ocic¦kpg" lqwtpcnkuvu" yjq" dgecog"mpqyp" cu" vjg" owemtcmgtu" rtcevkegf" cp" ci/

itguukxg" hqto" qh" lqwtpcnkuo" vjcv" cvvcemgf" wpdtkfngf" dki"dwukpguu" cpf" iqxgtpogpv" eqttwrvkqp0" Kfc" O0" Vctdgnn."Fcxkf"Itcjco"Rjknnkru."cpf"Nkpeqnp"Uvghhgpu"jgnrgf"fg/Ýpg"cpf"ugv"vjg"gctn{"vqpg"qh"vjg"owemtcmkpi"fgecfg."cpf"vjgogu"kpjgtgpv"kp"vjgkt"yqtm"cpf"oqvkxcvkqp"eqpvkpwg"vq""tguqpcvg" kp"oqfgtp" lqwtpcnkuo0"Vjgug" vjtgg"ytkvgtu" cnuq"fgoqpuvtcvgf"uqog"qh"vjg"tcpig"qh"dgjcxkqtu"cpf"rgturge/vkxgu"vjcv"ugrctcvgf"tcfkecn"cpf"eqpugtxcvkxg"crrtqcejgu"vq"vjg"owemtcmkpi"igptg0

Cv"egpvwt{Óu"gpf."c"pwodgt"qh"uq/ecnngf"rwdnke"qt"ekxke"lqwtpcn/kuvu" nkmgykug" cfqrvgf" cevkxkuv" tqngu" vq" tgogf{" rqnkvkecn" cpf" uqekcn"

Vjg"cwvjqt"ykujgu"vq"vjcpm"Ft0"Fqpcnf"N0"Ujcy"qh"vjg"Uejqqn"qh"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp" cv" vjg"Wpkxgtukv{" qh"Pqtvj"Ectqnkpc" cv"Ejcrgn"Jknn"cpf"vjg"CL"ocpwuetkrv"tgxkgygtu"hqt"cfxkeg"kp"vjg"rtgrctcvkqp"qh"vjku"ctvkeng0

9:""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

ocnckug" vjcv"ocp{"qdugtxgtu" ucy"cv" nctig" kp" vjg"pcvkqp0"Vjg"rwd/nke" lqwtpcnkuvu."yjqug"oqxgogpv" ku" pqy"oqtg" vjcp" c" fgecfg" qnf."enckogf"vjgktu"ycu"c"pgy"crrtqcej"vq"lqwtpcnkuo03"Jqygxgt."yjkng"vjg"eqpvtqxgtukcn"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"oqxgogpv"jcu"{gv" vq"igpgtcvg"owej" jkuvqtkecn" cpcn{uku.4" uejqnctu" kpenwfkpi" Okejcgn" Uejwfuqp"jcxg"uckf"vjcv"vjgtg"ku"c"eqppgevkqp"dgvyggp"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"owemtcmkpi0" 5"Vjku" rcrgt" gzcokpgu" vjcv" encko" htqo" vjg" jkuvqtkecn"rgturgevkxg"cpf"uwiiguvu"vjcv"fgurkvg"egtvckp"eqooqpcnkvkgu."vjg"vyq"oqxgogpvu"fkhhgt"kp"hwpfcogpvcn"cpf"nctign{"wpgzrnqtgf"yc{u0

ÐNkvgtcvwtg"qh"GzrquwtgÑ

Oquv"ogfkc"jkuvqtkcpu"Ýz"vjg"owemtcmkpi"gtc"cv"dgvyggp"3;24"cpf" 3;346" cpf" ukvwcvg" kv" kp" vjg" eqpvgzv" qh" vjg" Rtqitguukxg" tghqto"oqxgogpv"qh"3;23/3;3907"Ceeqtfkpi" vq"jkuvqtkcpu"Igqtig"Oqyt{"cpf"Lwfuqp"Itgpkgt."ÐVjg"Ògtc"qh" vjg"owemtcmgtuÓ" ku"igpgtcnn{"cu/uwogf"vq"jcxg"dgiwp"ykvj"vjg"rwdnkecvkqp"d{"OeEnwtgÓu"Ocic¦kpg"qh"Nkpeqnp"UvghhgpuÓ" ÒVyggf"Fc{u" kp"Uv0"NqwkuÓ" kp"Qevqdgt." 3;24."cpf" vq" jcxg" gpfgf" kp" vjg" Rtqitguukxg" rctv{Óu" I…vvgtf“oogtwpi"ykvj" vjg"gngevkqp"qh"Yqqftqy"Yknuqp" kp"3;340Ñ8"Vjg"owemtcmkpi"ocic¦kpguÏ"ÐOeEnwtgÓu."EqnnkgtÓu."Gxgt{dqf{Óu."vjg"Cogtkecp."cpf"Equoqrqnkvcp"Ï"cejkgxgf"ektewncvkqpu"kp"vjg"jwpftgfu"qh"vjqwucpfu"cpf"yqp"wprtgegfgpvgf"ocuu"tgcfgtujkr"cetquu"Cogtkec"hqt"vjg"Ònkv/gtcvwtg"qh"gzrquwtg0ÓÑ9

Vjg"owemtcmgtu"cnuq"nckf"itqwpfyqtm"hqt"qvjgt"fgrctvwtgu"htqo"vjg"ockpuvtgco"kp" vygpvkgvj/egpvwt{"Cogtkecp" lqwtpcnkuo0"Hqt" kp/uvcpeg." uqog" ogfkc" jkuvqtkcpu." kpenwfkpi" Uejwfuqp" cpf" Tqdgtv"Oktcnfk."Ýpf"kpxguvkicvkxg"tgrqtvkpiÓu"tqqvu"kp"vjg"owemtcmkpi"gtc0:

Rwdnke"LqwtpcnkuoÓu"Ckou

Kp" vjg" itqykpi" nkvgtcvwtg" qh" rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo." vyq" cwvjqtu"jcxg"jcf"rctvkewnct"korqtvcpeg<"Fcxku"Ogttkvv."hqtogt"gfkvqt"qh"vjg"Ykejkvc" *Mcpucu+"Gcing."cpf"Lc{"Tqugp."c" lqwtpcnkuo"rtqhguuqt"cv"Pgy"[qtm"Wpkxgtukv{"cpf"fktgevqt"qh"vjg"hqtogt"Rtqlgev"qp"Rwdnke"Nkhg"cpf" vjg"Rtguu0;"Rgtjcru" vjg"mg{"rqkpv"wpfgtueqtgf"d{"Tqugp."Ogttkvv."cpf"qvjgtu."ku"Ðeqoowpkv{"eqppgevgfpguu0Ñ"Cpf"Ðyjcv"fku/vkpiwkujgu"eqoowpkv{"eqppgevgfpguu"htqo"ukorng"etwucfkpi"ku"vjg"gorjcuku" qp" rwdnke" fkuewuukqp" cpf" ekxke" kortqxgogpv0Ñ32" Tqugp"cffu<"ÐEqoowpkv{"eqppgevgfpguu"rqkpvu"ykvj"cncto"vq"qwt"itqykpi"

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋""9;"

ugpug"qh"fkunqecvkqp"htqo"vjg"eqoowpkvkgu"yjgtg"yg"nkxg."cpf"htqo"vjg"ykfgt"rqnkvkecn"eqoowpkv{"yg"kpjcdkv"cu"ekvk¦gpu"qh"vjg"yqtnfÓu"qnfguv"fgoqetce{0"Kv"cnuq"vcmgu"yjcv"jcf"gctnkgt"dggp"c"rtgokug"qh"vjg"fckn{"pgyurcrgt"Ï"vjg"gzkuvgpeg"qh"c"rwdnke"cvvwpgf"vq"rwdnke"chhcktu"Ï"cpf"ocmgu" vjcv" vjg"pgyurcrgtÓu"rtqlgev0"Vjwu."eqoow/pkv{"eqppgevgfpguu"ku"cdqwv"jgnrkpi"vq"hqto"cu"ygnn"cu"kphqto"Òvjg"rwdnke0ÓÑ33

Cu"Ogttkvv"jcu"ockpvckpgf"kp"uvtguukpi"rjknquqrj{"qxgt"fgÝpk/vkqp"cpf"rtcevkegu<"ÐRwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ku"pqv"ckogf"cv"uqnxkpi"rtqd/ngou="kv"ku"ckogf"cv"tg/gpicikpi"ekvk¦gpu"kp"uqnxkpi"rtqdngou0"Kv"fqgu"pqv"uggm"vq"lqkp"ykvj"qt"uwduvkvwvg"kvugnh"hqt"iqxgtpogpv"000"kv"uggmu"vq"mggr"ekvk¦gpu"kp"ghhgevkxg"eqpvcev"ykvj"vjg"iqxgtpkpi"rtqeguu0"Kvu"iqcn"ku"pqv"vq"dgvvgt"eqppgev"lqwtpcnkuvu"ykvj"vjgkt"eqoowpkvkgu."dwv"vq"dgvvgt"eqppgev"vjg"rgqrng"kp"eqoowpkvkgu"ykvj"qpg"cpqvjgt0Ñ34

OWEMTCMKPI"CPF"RWDNKE"LQWTPCNKUO

Owemtcmkpi"cpf"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"jcxg"kp"eqooqp"c"pwodgt"qh"swcnkvkgu."kpenwfkpi"*3+"lqwtpcnkuvke"cevkxkuo."*4+"iqcnu"qh"tgeqp/pgevkpi"ekvk¦gpu"cpf"vjgkt"iqxgtpogpv."*5+"cp"cuuworvkqp"vjcv"lqwt/pcnkuo"eqwnf"ceeqornkuj"vjg"tgeqppgevkqp."*6+"uvtqpin{"jgnf"rjknqu/qrjkgu"dwv"pq"ugv"twngu"hqt"cejkgxkpi"vjgkt"gpfu."jgpeg"c"ykfg"tcpig"qh"dgjcxkqtu."*7+"etkvkekuo"htqo"eqpvgorqtctkgu"kp"ockpuvtgco"lqwt/pcnkuo."cpf"*8+"etkvkekuo"htqo"rgtuqpu"kp"vjg"rqygt"uvtwevwtgu0"Vjg{"gxgp"jcxg" kp" eqooqp" vjg" uwurkekqp"d{" uqog" vjcv"rwdnkujgtu" go/dtcekpi"vjgug"pqxgn"hqtou"jcxg"dggp"oqvkxcvgf"ukorn{"d{"vjg"rtqÝvu"vjg{"ctg"rtqokugf"htqo"kpetgcugf"tgcfgtujkr035"Ugxgtcn"cwvjqtu"jcxg"ocfg" eqpxkpekpi" ctiwogpvu" vjcv" vjku" ycu" vtwg" hqt" vjg" rwdnkujgtu"qh"owemtcmkpi" rwdnkecvkqpu.36" cpf" ukoknct" eqpegtpu" ctg" gzrtguugf"cdqwv" ikcpv"ogfkc" eqtrqtcvkqpuÓ" urqpuqtujkr" qh" rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"kp"cp"gtc"qh"fgenkpkpi"ektewncvkqp"vq"kpetgcug"ektewncvkqp.37"cnvjqwij"jgtg"vjg"lwt{"ku"uvknn"qwv038

Vyq"Xkgyu"qh"Iqxgtpogpv"cpf"Ekvk¦gpu

Vjku"tgugctej"gzcokpgu"vjg"eqpegrvwcn"htcogyqtm"qh"vjtgg"ngcf/kpi"owemtcmgtÏVctdgnn."Rjknnkru."cpf"UvghhgpuÏvqyctf"iqxgtpogpv"cpf"ekvk¦gp"rctvkekrcvkqp"dgvyggp"3;24"cpf"3;34"cu"gzrtguugf"kp"rctv"d{" vjgkt"cwvqdkqitcrjkgu"cpf" ngvvgtu0"Vjgug"Ýpfkpiu"ctg"eqorctgf"ykvj"vjg"uvcvgf"oqvkxgu"cpf"qdlgevkxgu"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuoÓu"ngcf/

:2""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

kpi"rtqoqvgtu."Ogttkvv."Tqugp."cpf"Ctvjwt"Ejctkv{."cpqvjgt"ogodgt"qh" vjg"Rtqlgev" hqt"Rwdnke"Nkhg" cpf" vjg"Rtguu0"Vjg"iqcn" jgtg" ku" pqv"vq"etkvkswg"gkvjgt"oqxgogpv"qt" vq"gzcokpg"yjcv" vjgug"owemtcmgtu"ytqvg"kp"vjgkt"ctvkengu"dwv"vq"fgvgtokpg"yj{"vjg{"ytqvg"yjcv"vjg{"fkf"fwtkpi"vjcv"rgtkqf"cpf"yjcv"xkukqp"qh"vjg"tgncvkqpujkr"qh"ekvk¦gpu"cpf"iqxgtpogpv"kphqtogf"vjgkt"tjgvqtke0"Ukoknct"kpswkt{"yknn"dg"fktgevgf"cv"vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu0

VJG"CEVKXKUV"VWTP<"NKPEQNP"UVGHHGPU

Nkpeqnp" UvghhgpuÓ" ÐUjcog" qh" vjg" EkvkguÑ" ugtkgu" kp"OeEnwtgÓu"Ocic¦kpg" oc{" jcxg" ncwpejgf" vjg" owemtcmkpi" gtc39" dwv" kvu" cw/vjqt"enckogf"c" nqpi" nkpg"qh"rgqrng."gxgp"Ðvjg"rtqrjgvu"qh" vjg"Qnf"Vguvcogpv"ygtg" cjgcf"qh"og" 000" Ýpfkpi" hcwnv"ykvj" Òvjkpiu" cu" vjg{"ctg0ÓÑ3:"Kp"hcev."jg"ytqvg."ÐK"fkf"pqv"kpvgpf"vq"dg"c"owemtcmgt="K"fkf"pqv"mpqy"vjcv"K"ycu"qpg"vknn"Rtgukfgpv"Tqqugxgnv"rkemgf"vjg"pcog"qwv"qh"Dwp{cpÓu"RknitkoÓu"Rtqitguu"cpf"rkppgf"kv"qp"wu="cpf"gxgp"vjgp"jg"uckf"vjcv"jg"fkf"pqv"ogcp"og0Ñ3;

Dwv"dghqtg"nqpi"vjg"etwucfkpi"lqwtpcnkuv"ycu"ujqykpi"c"rtghgt/gpeg"hqt"etwucfkpi"qxgt"lqwtpcnkuo0"Vctdgnn"uckf"vjcv"cu"gctn{"cu"3;2:"ujg" ugpugf" ÐUvghhgpuÓ" itqykpi"fkuucvkuhcevkqp"ykvj" vjg" tguvtkevkqpu"qh"lqwtpcnkuo0"Jg"ycpvgf"c"ykfgt"Ýgnf."qpg"kp"yjkej"jg"eqwnf"oqtg"fktgevn{"kpÞwgpeg"rqnkvkecn"cpf"uqekcn"ngcfgtu."rtgcej"oqtg"fktgevn{"jku"pqvkqpu"qh"vjg"Iqnfgp"Twng."yjkej"cv"vjcv"vkog"ycu"jku"ejqugp"iwkfg042"Jku" cwfkgpeg." ujg" uckf."ycu"Ðrqnkvkecn"dquugu" 000" *cpf+" vjg"v{eqqpu"qh"Ycnn"Uvtggv."vjg"Dtcjokpu"qh"Dquvqp0Ñ43

Kp"jku"cwvqdkqitcrj{"cpf"kp"ocp{"qh"jku"ngvvgtu."Uvghhgpu"gxkpegf"eqpvkpwkpi"kpvgtguv" kp"dtkpikpi"eqttwrv"qhÝekcnu" vq"jggn0"Ytkvkpi"vq"jku"hcvjgt"kp"3;25"qh"c"ocic¦kpg"ugtkgu"jg"ycu"fgxgnqrkpi."Uvghhgpu"tgoctmgf."ÐK"vjkpm"vjg{"yknn"ocmg"vtqwdng"hqt"uqog"fcopgf"dki"tcu/ecnu"yjq"vjkpm"vjg{"ctg"cdqxg"vjg"fcpigt"octm0Ñ44

ÐUqogvjkpi"Ecp"Dg"FqpgÑ

Kp"3;26."Uvghhgpu"cuuwtgf"jku"hcvjgt"jku"owemtcmkpi"fkf"pqv"tg/Þgev"rguukokuo<"ÐK"uc{"vjgtg"ku"vjg"cuuworvkqp"vjcv"uqogvjkpi"ecp"dg"fqpg"cpf"vjcv"ogp"ctg"yknnkpi"vq"fq"kv0Ñ45"Rctv"qh"jku"qrvkokuo"ycu"kp"vjg"dcuke"iqqfpguu"cpf"tgurqpukdknkv{"qh"vjg"rtkxcvg"ekvk¦gp0"Kp"c"ngvvgt"vq"Tqqugxgnv"kp"Ugrvgodgt"3;27."Uvghhgpu"wtigf"vjg"rtgukfgpv"vq"uggm"ecorckip"hwpfu"pqv"htqo"Ðvjg"kpuwtcpeg"cpf"qvjgt"eqtrqtc/

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"":3"

vkqpu"uggmkpi"pcvkqpcn"ngikuncvkqpÑ"dwv"htqo"Ðvjg"rgqrng"yjq"fkfpÓv"ycpv"cp{vjkpi"qwv"qh" vjg"Iqxgtpogpv"gzegrv"igpgtcn" ncyu"cpf"cp"cfokpkuvtcvkqp"qh"lwuvkeg"cpf"hckt"rnc{0Ñ46"Jg"cffgf<"ÐK"dgnkgxg"yg"yqwnf"pqv"qpn{"tgurqpf"ykvj"qwt"fqnnctu"dwv"ykvj"c"vtgogpfqwu"eqp/vtkdwvkqp"qh"nq{cnv{"vq"{qw"cpf"vq"vjg"iqxgtpogpv0"000"][_qw"yqwnf"ocmg"vjg"oknnkqpu"hggn"vjcv"kv"ycu"vjgkt"Iqxgtpogpv."cu"kv"ku."cpf"vjcv"{qw"cpf"{qwt"cfokpkuvtcvkqp"ygtg"dgjqnfgp"vq"vjg"ocp{."pqv"vq"vjg"hgy0Ñ47

Hqwt"{gctu"ncvgt."kp"c"ngvvgt"eqpuqnkpi"Engxgncpf."Qjkq."tghqto/gt"Vqo"N0" Lqjpuqp"qp"cp"gngevkqp" ugvdcem."Uvghhgpu"ytqvg." ÐVjg{"]Engxgncpf"xqvgtu_"jcxg"pqv"fkuvwtdgf"o{"eqpÝfgpeg"vjcv"kp"vjg"nqpi"twp"vjg"rgqrng"yknn"iq"tkijv"oqtg"uwtgn{"vjcp"cp{"kpfkxkfwcnu"qt"ugv"qh"kpfkxkfwcnu0Ñ48

ÐFgoqetce{"c"HcknwtgAÑ

Kp"jku"cwvqdkqitcrj{."Uvghhgpu"eqoogpvgf."ÐVjg"ngcfkpi"swgu/vkqp" tckugf" kp"o{" ugeqpf" ctvkeng" qp"Uv0"Nqwku"ycu." ÒKu" fgoqetce{"c"hcknwtgAÓ"C"vtkem."c"rqnkvkecn"vtkem#"K"jcf"pq"fqwdv"vjcv"vjg"rgqrng"eqwnf"cpf"yqwnf"iqxgtp"vjgougnxgu0Ñ49

UvghhgpuÓ"cuuguuogpv"qh" vjg"tghqto"xkevqtkgu" kp" vjg"3;27"gnge/vkqpu"ycu"vjcv"Ðyg."vjg"Cogtkecp"rgqrng."ecttkgf"qwtugnxgu"cv"ncuv."cpf"vjg"dgikppkpi"jcu"dggp"ocfg"vqyctf"vjg"tguvqtcvkqp"qh"tgrtgugp/vcvkxg"fgoqetce{"cnn"qxgt"vjg"ncpf0Ñ4:"Jku"xkukqp"ycu"vjcv"iqqf"ogp"yqwnf"rtqxkfg"ngcfgtujkr"kp"dtkpikpi"iqxgtpogpv"vq"vjg"rgqrng0"Kp"c" 3;28" ngvvgt" vq"Dtcpf"Yjkvnqem." tghqto"oc{qt" qh"Vqngfq."Qjkq."Uvghhgpu" u{pvjguk¦gf"jku" xkgy"qh" vjg" tgncvkqpujkr" dgvyggp" ngcfgtu"cpf"ekvk¦gpu0"Ð[qw"ygtgpÓv"gngevgf"oc{qt.Ñ"jg"vqnf"Yjkvnqem0"Ð[qw"ygtg"ejqugp"ngcfgt0"[qw"ygtgpÓv"vjgtg"vq"ikxg"iqqf"iqxgtpogpv"qt"uqnxg"rtqdngou." dwv" vq" ngv" vjgo"iqxgtp" vjgougnxgu" uqogjqy"cpf"vcemng" vjgkt"rtqdngou"ykvj" vjgo"cpf"hqt" vjgo=" kipqtcpv." kp"fqwdv."ykvj"pq"Òrqnke{Ó"cpf"pqv"ocp{"fgÝpkvg"rncpu."dwvÏc"engct"kfgc."cpf"c"yknnkpipguu" vq"ugtxg." vq"ugtxg"qvjgtu" vqyctf" vjg"fgxgnqrogpv"qh"vjgkt"ejctcevgt"cv"cp{"rgtuqpcn"ucetkÝeg"gzegrv"vjcv"qh"vjg"fgxgnqr/ogpv"qh"{qwt"ejctcevgt0Ñ4;

Gzrquwtg."Pqv"Eqpxkevkqpu

Kp"c"3;29"ngvvgt"vq"Tqqugxgnv."Uvghhgpu"uwiiguvgf"c"xkgy"qh"vjg"xcnwg"cpf"ckou"qh"owemtcmkpi." vgnnkpi" vjg"rtgukfgpv."Ðoquv"qh" vjg"


iqqf" fqpg" kp" vjg" ncuv" hgy" {gctu" jcu" dggp" fqpg" d{" vjg" gzrquwtg."pqv" vjg" eqpxkevkqp" qh" vjg" tcuecnu0" Jcttkocp" ]tckntqcf" dctqp" G0J0"Jcttkocp_" vcnmkpi"qp"vjg"uvcpf"ku"qh"oqtg"wug" vq" vjg"eqwpvt{" vjcp"Jcttkocp"dgjkpf"dctu0Ñ52"Kp"vjcv"ngvvgt"jg"ocfg"qpg"qh"jku"engctguv"uvcvgogpvu"cdqwv"jku"oqvkxgu"kp"owemtcmkpi<

Yjcv"K"co"chvgt"ku"vjg"ecwug"cpf"vjg"rwtrqug"cpf"vjg"ogvjqfu"d{"yjkej"qwt"iqxgtpogpv."ekv{."uvcvg"cpf"hgfgtcn."ku"ocfg"vq"tgrtgugpv"pqv"vjg"eqooqp."dwv"vjg"urgekcn"kpvgtguvu="vjg"tgcuqp"yj{"kv"ku"uq"jctf"vq"fq"tkijv"kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"UvcvguÈ"Hkijvkpi"fkujqpguv{"cu"{qw"ctg."{qw"ctg"fqkpi"oqtg"vjcp"cnn"vjg"tguv"qh"wu"uq/ecnngf"owemtcmgtu"rwv"vqigvjgt"vq"ujqy"vjg"Cogtkecp"rgqrng"vjcv"vjg"ecwug"qh"itchv."cpf"vjg"tguwnv"qh"cnn"qwt"eqttwrvkqp."ku"ukorn{"okutgrtgugpvcvkqp"kp"iqxgtpogpv"cpf"vjcv"vjg"ewtg"ku"vq"tgiwncvg."vq"eqpvtqn."qt."kh"vjgug"hckn."vq"qyp"vjqug"dwukpguugu"yjkej"Ýpf"kv"pgeguuct{"vq"vjgkt"uwe/eguu"vq"eqttwrv"ogp"cpf"ekvk¦gpu"cpf"uvcvgu"cpf"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu053

Uvghhgpu"oc{"jcxg"dgnkgxgf"kp"vjg"gzrqufi"vq"jgnr"tguvqtg"iqqf"iqxgtpogpv"vq"vjg"rgqrng"dwv"jg"dcemgf"wr"jku"ycvejfqi"tqng"ykvj"rqnkvkecn"cevkxkuo"vjcv" ku"gejqgf"d{"uqog"qh" vjg"oqtg"gzvtgog"gh/hqtvu" vcmgp" kp" vjg" pcog" qh" rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo0" Kp" c" ngpivj{" 3;2:"ngvvgt"vq"Yknnkco"E0"Dqddu."yjq"ycu"kpxqnxgf"kp"tghqto"ghhqtvu"kp"Kpfkcpcrqnku."Uvghhgpu"eqodkpgf"c"rgr"vcnm"*Ð[qwt"rncvhqto"ku"iqqf"cu"hct"cu"kv"iqguÑ+."oknf"ueqnfkpi"*Ðo{"fgct"Ot0"Dqddu."{qw"fkf"pqv"hqnnqy"o{"cfxkegÑ+."cpf"rncp"qh"cvvcem"*ÐIq"vq"vjg"rgqrng"ykvj"{qwt"rtqitco0Ñ+054"Crtkn"3;32"hqwpf"jko"cumkpi"Lwfig"Lcogu"D0"Fknn"vq"Ðugpf"og" cu" dki" c" ejgem" cu" {qw" ecp" d{"yc{" qh" c" eqpvtkdwvkqp" vq"]Rtqitguukxg"ngcfgt"Tqdgtv"O0_"Nc"HqnngvvgÓu"Ýijv"kp"Ykueqpukp0"Vjg"kpvgtguvu"ctg"rtgrctkpi"c"dki"qticpk¦cvkqp"cickpuv"jko"vjgtg."cpf"kv"ku"qwt"dwukpguu."cnn"qh"wu0Ñ55"

UvghhgpuÓ" cevkxkuo"oqxgf" jko" vqyctf" uqekcnkuo" fwtkpi" vjgug"{gctu" cpf" qhhgtgf" vjg" gzvtgog" uqnwvkqp" vq" dtkpikpi" iqxgtpogpv"vq" vjg" rgqrng<" Ocmkpi" vjg" rgqrng" qypgtu" qh" vjqug" qticpk¦cvkqpu"vjcv" Uvghhgpu" ucy" cu" vjg" eqttwrvkpi" kpÞwgpegu" qp" iqxgtpogpv056"Tgictfnguu"yjgvjgt"pcvkqpcnk¦cvkqp"ycu"tgcnn{"vjg"cpuygt."jqygxgt."Uvghhgpu"ycu"rtgrctgf"vq"ngcxg"lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"uvgr"fktgevn{"kpvq"vjg"tghqto"ghhqtvu."iqkpi"dg{qpf"gzrquwtg"vq"rncppkpi"cpf"ngcfkpi"vjg"Ýijv"kp"ekv{"chvgt"ekv{057

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"":5"

VJG"RQYGT"QH"HCEV<"KFC"O0"VCTDGNN

Vjg"rctcfqz"qh"Kfc"O0"Vctdgnn"ku"vjcv"cnvjqwij"qpg"qh"vjg"dguv/mpqyp"qh"vjg"igptg."ujg"ycu"c"tgnwevcpv"owemtcmgt0"Cntgcf{"c"ygnn/mpqyp"lqwtpcnkuv"yjgp"jgt"kpxguvkicvkqp"qh"Uvcpfctf"Qkn"cpf"Lqjp"F0" Tqemghgnngt" ycu" ugtkcnk¦gf" kp"OeEnwtgÓu" ocic¦kpg" kp" 3;24.58"Vctdgnn"eqpvkpwgf"vq"vjkpm"qh"jgtugnh"cu"c"lqwtpcnkuv."qt"c"jkuvqtkcp.59"tcvjgt"vjcp"c"owemtcmgt"fwtkpi"owej"qh"vjg"owemtcmkpi"rgtkqf0"Ujg"dgicp"ytkvkpi"hqt"OeEnwtgÓu"kp"3:;5"cu"Ðc"uvtc{"lqwtpcnkuv"kp"RctkuÑ5:"cpf"tgockpgf"ykvj" vjg"ocic¦kpg"wpvkn"ujg"cpf"ugxgtcn"eqnngciwgu."tglgevkpi"c"dwukpguu"uejgog"qh"rwdnkujgt"U0U0"OeEnwtg."nghv"vq"lqkp"Vjg"Cogtkecp"Ocic¦kpg"kp"Octej"3;2805;"Qh"jgt"fc{u"cv"OeEnwtgÓu."Vctdgnn"ytqvg."ÐYg"ygtg"pgkvjgt"crqnqikuvu"pqt"etkvkeu."qpn{"lqwtpcn/kuvu"kpvgpv"qp"fkueqxgtkpi"yjcv"jcf"iqpg"kpvq"vjg"ocmkpi"qh"vjku"oquv"rgthgev"qh"cnn"oqpqrqnkgu"*Uvcpfctf"Qkn+0Ñ62"Vjg"Cogtkecp."vqq."ycu"fgxqvgf" vq" lqwtpcnkuo."pqv"owemtcmkpi." ujg" uckf<"ÐCu"c"ocvvgt"qh"hcev."Vjg"Cogtkecp"Ocic¦kpg"jcf"nkvvng"igpwkpg"owemtcmkpi"urktkv0"Kv"fkf"jcxg"c"nctig"cpf"Ýijvkpi"kpvgtguv"kp"hckt"rnc{="kv"uqwijv"vq"rtgu/gpv"vjkpiu"cu"vjg{"ygtg."pqv"cu"uqogdqf{"vjqwijv"vjg{"qwijv"vq"dg0"Yg"ygtg"lqwtpcnkuvu."pqv"rtqrcicpfkuvu="cpf"cu"lqwtpcnkuvu"yg"uqwijv"pgy"cpingu"qp"qnf"uwdlgevu0Ñ63

Vjg"CogtkecpÓu"tgrqtvkpi."ujg"uckf."ycu"iwkfgf"d{"Ðqwt"ctfgpv"fguktg"vq"kortqxg"vjkpiu"d{"fgoqpuvtcvkpi"vjgkt"wpuqwpfpguu"cpf"000"qwt"wpyknnkpipguu"vq"wug"cp{"qvjgt"vqqnu"vjcp"vjqug"yjkej"dgnqpigf"ngikvkocvgn{"vq"qwt"rtqhguukqp0Ñ64

ÐEqoogtekcn"Ocejkcxgnnkcpkuo"cpf"vjg"Ejtkuvkcp"EqfgÑ

Dgukfgu"rwdnkujgt"U0U0"OeEnwtgÓu"swguv"hqt"oqtg"tgcfgtu.65"vjg"oqvkxcvkqp"hqt"VctdgnnÓu"Vjg"Jkuvqt{"qh"vjg"Uvcpfctf"Qkn"Eqorcp{"ycu" jgt" eqpxkevkqp" vjcv" Ðdwukpguu" ku" korqtvcpv." ecp"dg" rtqÝvcdng."cpf" ku"pqv" kpjgtgpvn{" gxkn.Ñ" cpf" vjcv" Ðdwukpguu"jcu" egtvckp"qdnkic/vkqpu"vq"kvu"yqtmgtu."ykvj"tgictf"vq"vjgkt"jwocp"pggfu."vjcv"kp"ocp{"kpuvcpegu"kv"fqgu"pqv"hwnÝnn0Ñ66"Kv"ycu."ujg"uckf."Ðvjg"uvtwiingÈ"dg/vyggp" Eqoogtekcn" Ocejkcxgnnkcpkuo" cpf" vjg" Ejtkuvkcp" Eqfg0Ñ67"Ukpeg"vjg"vgto"ÐowemtcmgtÑ"ycu"crrnkgf"tgvtqcevkxgn{"kp"3;28"d{"c"tgrtqxkpi"Rtgukfgpv"Vjgqfqtg"Tqqugxgnv.68"Vctdgnn"kp"3;24"fkf"pqv"ugg"jgtugnh"cu"c"owemtcmgtÏÐvjku"encuukÝecvkqpÈ"yjkej"K"fkf"pqv"nkmgÑ69Ïyjgp"OeEnwtgÓu"rwdnkujgf"vjg"jkuvqt{"kp"kpuvcnnogpvu."pqt"yjgp"vjg"eqnngevkqp"ycu"rwdnkujgf"kp"Ðvyq"hcv"xqnwogu"ykvj"igpgt/qwu"crrgpfkegu"qh"yjcv"K"eqpukfgtgf"guugpvkcn"fqewogpvuÑ6:"kp"hcnn"


3;260"ÐK"jcf"jqrgf"vjcv"vjg"dqqm"okijv"dg"tgegkxgf"cu"c"ngikvkocvg"jkuvqtkecn" uvwf{.Ñ" ujg" uckf." Ðdwv" vq"o{"ejcitkp" K" hqwpf"o{ugnh" kp/enwfgf"kp"c"pgy"uejqqn."vjcv"qh"vjg"owemtcmgtu0Ñ6;

Cnvjqwij"ujg"fkf"pqv"gzrnkekvn{"fkuewuu"jgt"fkunkmg"qh"vjg"owem/tcmgtu"cpf"vjgkt"ogvjqfu."Vctdgnn"jkpvgf"vjcv"qdlgevkxkv{"cpf"dcncpeg"ygtg"coqpi"vjg"eqpvguvgf"rtcevkegu0"Ujg"htgswgpvn{"ctiwgf"hqt"hckt/pguu" cpf" tgrqtvkpi" dqvj" ukfgu" qh" cp" kuuwg.72" cnvjqwij" vjg" Ðtcfkecn"tghqtokpi"gngogpv"000"jcf"nkvvng"kpvgtguv"kp"dcncpegf"Ýpfkpiu0Ñ73

Kpfkxkfwcnu"xu0"vjg"Ocuugu

VctdgnnÓu"eqpegrv"qh"vjg"qtfkpct{"ekvk¦gp"cpf"jku"qt"jgt"tqng"kp"tghqto"ku"uqogyjcv"rtqdngocvke"dgecwug"ujg"ugnfqo"tghgttgf"vq"qt/fkpct{"rgqrng"kp"cp{"ogcpkpihwn"yc{"kp"jgt"cwvqdkqitcrj{0"Oquvn{."vjg"rgqrng"Vctdgnn"vcnmgf"cdqwv"ygtg"eqnngciwgu."ngcfkpi"dwukpguu/ogp." qt" rqnkvkecn" ngcfgtu0"Pqp/gnkvgu"ygtg" tghgttgf" vq" eqnngevkxgn{."cpf" vjg"yqtmkpi"ocp" cpf"yqocp" vgpfgf" vq" dg" fkuewuugf" qpn{" kp"vgtou"qh"rqnkvkecn"cuuqekcvkqpu"*g0i0."Uqekcnkuvu+.74"wpkqp"ogodgtu.75"qt"igpgtke"eqnngevkxgu"*g0i0."yqogp.76"vjg"rqqt77+0"Kp"VctdgnnÓu"vjkpm/kpi."vjgkt"curktcvkqpu"crrgctgf"uwduwogf"d{"vjqug"qh"vjg"tghqtokuv"gnkvg0"Etkvkek¦kpi"vjg"tcfkecn"tghqtogtuÓ"qpg/ukfgf"cvvcemu."ujg"ytqvg."ÐPqy"K"ycu"eqpxkpegf"vjcv"kp"vjg"nqpi"twp"vjg"rwdnke"vjg{"ygtg"vt{/kpi"vq"uvkt"yqwnf"ygct{"qh"xkvwrgtcvkqp."vjcv"kh"{qw"ygtg"vq"ugewtg"rgtocpgpv"tguwnvu"vjg"okpf"owuv"dg"eqpxkpegf0Ñ78

Ujg"vcnmgf"dtkgÞ{"qh"qticpk¦gf"ncdqtÓu"Ðdqf{"qh"xqvgu"vjcv"pq"rqnkvkecn" rctv{"fctgf"fgh{.Ñ79" cpf" uckf" ujg" hqwpf" Ðocp{"yqtmogp"ygtg"ocic¦kpg"tgcfgtuÑ7:"hcoknkct"ykvj"jgt"yqtm0"Jqygxgt."pqyjgtg"kp"vjg"owemtcmkpi"rgtkqf"qh"VctdgnnÓu"cwvqdkqitcrj{"ku"vjgtg"c"engct"uvcvgogpv"qh"oqdknk¦kpi"qtfkpct{"ekvk¦gpu"vq"vcmg"qp"vjg"cdwugu"qh"vjg"vtwuvu"qt"qh"iqxgtpogpv."qt"qh"yjcv"vjg"rgqrngÓu"cigpfc"okijv"dg0"Qpn{"ugnfqo"ku"vjgtg"gxgp"tghgtgpeg"vq"tghqto"eqpegtpu"gocpcvkpi"htqo"vjg"yqtmkpi"encuu0"Nkmg"Uvghhgpu."Vctdgnn"uckf"ujg"dgnkgxgf"vjcv"vjg"uqnwvkqpu"yqwnf"eqog"htqo"gvjkecn"dwukpguu"cpf"iqxgtpogpv"cf/okpkuvtcvkqp0"Ujg"ytqvg"qh"vgnnkpi"rgqrng"kp"Mcpucu."ÐWpnguu"{qw"ecp"dg"cu"ghÝekgpv"cpf"cu"rcvkgpv."cu"hctuggkpi"cu"{qwt"itgcv"eqorgvkvqt"Ï"ncyu"qt"pq"ncyu."{qw"yknn"pqv"uweeggf0"[qw"owuv"ocmg"{qwtugnxgu"cu"iqqf"tgÝpgtu."cu"iqqf"vtcpurqtvgtu."cu"iqqf"octmgvgtu."cu"kpig/pkqwu."cu"kphqtogf."cu"kocikpcvkxg"kp"{qwt"ngikvkocvg"wpfgtvcmkpiu"cu"vjg{"ctg"kp"dqvj"vjgkt"ngikvkocvg"cpf"knngikvkocvg0Ñ7;"Vjg"vcumu"ujg"gpwogtcvgf"engctn{" kfgpvkh{"jgt"cwfkgpeg"cu"dwukpguu"cpf"rqnkvkecn"ngcfgtu."pqv"qtfkpct{"ekvk¦gpu0

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"":7"

Vqyctf"Dgvvgt"Ngcfgtu

Vjg"mg{"vq"cejkgxkpi"vjg"tghqtou"Vctdgnn"cpf"Uvghhgpu"uqwijv"ycu" dgvvgt" ngcfgtu" oqtg" vjcp" dgvvgt" hqnnqygtu0" Vjgkt" cwvqdkqitc/rjkgu" tgeqwpv" htgswgpv" rgtuqpcn" eqpvcev" cpf" eqttgurqpfgpeg"ykvj"rtgukfgpvu."ecrvckpu"qh"kpfwuvt{."rqnkvkecn"ngcfgtu."cpf"ejcorkqpu"qh"tghqto."cpf"cnyc{u"qp"cp"cfxkuqt{." uqogvkogu"eqnncdqtcvkxg." ngx/gn0"Vjgqfqtg"Tqqugxgnv" tgegkxgf"owej" cfxkeg" htqo"dqvj"Uvghhgpu"cpf"Vctdgnn." cu" fkf"Rtgukfgpvu"Engxgncpf" cpf"Yknuqp." coqpi"qvj/gtu0"Vctdgnn"gxgp"vgnnu"qh"qhhgtkpi"vq"ijquv/ytkvg"ctvkengu"hqt"Itqxgt"Engxgncpf"fwtkpi"jgt"ncuv"vyq"{gctu"cv"OeEnwtgÓu"ocic¦kpg082"Yjgp"c"ugtkgu"qh"ngevwtgu"kp"Mcpucu"cpf"Qmncjqoc"qkn"Ýgnfu"wrugv"uqog"yjq"hgnv"ujg"jcf"dggp"eq/qrvgf"d{"Uvcpfctf"Qkn."Ðvjgtg"ygtg"jctf/jgcfgf"kpfgrgpfgpv"ngikuncvqtu"cpf"dwukpguu"ogp"kp"vjg"uvcvg"yjq"eqpuqngf"og0Ñ83"Pqyjgtg"ctg"qtfkpct{"ekvk¦gpu"ogpvkqpgf0

Tgugctejkpi"ctvkengu"vjcv"ygtg"kp"fkuvkpev"eqpvtcuv"vq"vjg"tcfkecn"lqwtpcnkuo"vjcv"qvjgt"owemtcmgtu"tgxgtgf."Vctdgnn"hqwpf"c"ogvcrjqt"vjcv"knnwokpcvgu"jgt"xkukqp"qh"uqekgv{"cpf"tghqto0"Cdqwv"3;34."yjkng"fqkpi"c"ugtkgu"qp"kpfwuvt{"vjcv"ujg"kpukuvgf"ycu"pqv"owemtcmkpi.84"Vctdgnn"dgecog"hcuekpcvgf"ykvj"Htgfgtkem"Vc{nqtÓu"vjgqtkgu"qh"uekgp/vkÝe"ocpcigogpv085

Wpfgt"Vc{nqtkuo."cu"Vctdgnn"fkueqxgtgf."Ðvjg"dwukpguu"qh"ocp/cigogpv" ycu" pqv" qpn{" rncppkpi" dwv" eqpvtqnnkpi" yjcv" kv" rncppgf0"Ocpcigogpv"nckf"qwv"cjgcf"vjg"fc{Óu"yqtm"hqt"gcej"ocp"cv"jku"oc/ejkpg=" vq" jko" vjg{"ygpv"ykvj" vjgkt" kpuvtwevkqpu." vq" vjgo" jg"ygpv"hqt"gzrncpcvkqpu"cpf"uwiiguvkqpu0Ñ86"Vjg"kfgcn"ycu"eqqrgtcvkqp"cpf"tgeqipkvkqp"qh"kpvgtfgrgpfgpeg"dgvyggp"yqtmgtu"cpf"ocpcigtu."dwv"Vc{nqtkuo"cnuq"rtguetkdgf"c"tkikf."jkgtctejkecn"u{uvgo"kp"yjkej"eqo/owpkecvkqp"okijv"Þqy"wr"cpf"fqyp."dwv"fgekukqpu"eqwnf"dg"ocfg"qpn{"cv"vjg"vqr087"Jkffgp"kp"VctdgnnÓu"godtceg"qh"Vc{nqtÓu"uekgpvkÝe"ocpcigogpv"rtkpekrngu." vjgp." ku" cp"ctiwcdng"chÝtocvkqp"qh" uvtqpi"cpf"cdng"ngcfgtu."eqorcuukqpcvg."cpf"yknnkpi"vq"nkuvgp."dwv"wpswgu/vkqpcdn{"kp"ejctig0

ÐVTWVJÑ"WPHGVVGTGF"D["HCEVU<"FCXKF"ITCJCO"RJKNNKRU

Kh"Vctdgnn"icxg"uwrrqtv"vq"Egegnkc"VkejkÓu"encko"vjcv"Ðhcev"ycu"vjg"owemtcmgtuÓ"cpvkfqvg"vq"twoqt"cpf"vq"ugpucvkqpcnkuv"{gnnqy"lqwt/pcnkuo.Ñ88"Fcxkf"Itcjco"Rjknnkru" fkf" pqv0"Cnvjqwij" nguu"ygnn" tg/ogodgtgf"vjcp"Vctdgnn"cpf"Uvghhgpu."Rjknnkru"ku"c"ukipkÝecpv"Ýiwtg"


yjqug"yqtm"jgnrgf"fgÝpg"owemtcmkpi"cpf"ickpgf"vjg"igptg"kvu"pkem/pcog"cpf"pqvqtkgv{0"Igqtig"Oqyt{"cpf"Lwfuqp"Itgpkgt"jgnf"vjcv"vjg"3;28"ugtkgu"ÐVjg"Vtgcuqp"qh"vjg"UgpcvgÑ"kp"Equoqrqnkvcp"Ocic¦kpg"Ðycu."kp"ocp{"tgurgevu."vjg"enkocz"qh"vjg"owemtcmkpi"oqxgogpv"kp"Cogtkecp"lqwtpcnkuo0"Vjg"dqnf."qwvurqmgp."qhvgp"kpvgorgtcvg"ncp/iwcig"qh"cp"cwvjqt"fgfkecvgf"vq"Òvjg"ugctej"hqt" vtwvjÓ"ecrvwtgu" vjg"guugpeg"qh"dqvj"vjg"dguv"cpf"yqtuv"curgevu"qh"owemtcmkpi0Ñ89"

Hwgnkpi"RjknnkruÓ"¦gcn."dkqitcrjgt"Nqwku"Hknngt"uckf."ycu"vjcv"kp"eqooqp"ykvj"qvjgt"owemtcmgtu"Rjknnkru

jcf"uggp"kp"jku"nkhgvkog"vjg"dtgcmfqyp"qh"vjg"qnf"oqtcnk/vkgu." vjg"qnf"oqfgu"qh" nkhg." vjcv"jcf"eqpuvkvwvgf" vjg"dcugu"qh"c"rcuv"fgoqetce{0"Kh"fgoqetce{"ygtg"vq"dg"tgecrvwtgf."pgy"oqtcnkvkgu" cpf"oqfgu" yqwnf" jcxg" vq" dg" fgxgnqrgf0"Cpf"pqv"qpn{"vjcv<"vjg"qnfgt"qpgu"yqwnf"jcxg"vq"dg"dtqmgp"fqyp"eqorngvgn{."fkuetgfkvgf"cpf"cppkjkncvgf=" vjg{"eqwnf"pqv"dg"tgxkxgf."hqt"vjg{"ygtg"c"fgcf"jcpf"qp"vjg"rtgugpv."vjg"ogcpu"d{"yjkej"vjg"vtwuvu"cpf"vjgkt"cnnkgu"eqpvkpwgf"vq"itqy"vqyctf"vjcv"nqikecn"gpf"qh"kpfkxkfwcnkuo<"qnkictej{08:

RjknnkruÓ"owemtcmkpi"dgicp"yjgp"jg"nghv"pgyurcrgt"lqwtpcnkuo"kp"3;23"vq"gpvgt"ocic¦kpg"lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"vq"ytkvg"pqxgnu.8;"cpf"jku"rtqnkÝe" ectggt" gpfgf" kp" 3;33"yjgp" jg"ycu" ujqv" d{" c" ÐfgtcpigfÑ"tgcfgt92" qp" Lcpwct{" 45" cpf" fkgf" vjg" pgzv" fc{093" Rjknnkru" jcu" dggp"etgfkvgf"ykvj"nc{kpi"Ðc"ukipkÝecpv"rctv"qh"vjg"itqwpfyqtmÑ"hqt"vjtgg"cogpfogpvu" vq" vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"Eqpuvkvwvkqp094"Qh" vjg" Ukzvggpvj"CogpfogpvÓu" kpeqog" vcz" cpf" tgfkuvtkdwvkqp" qh" pcvkqpcn" ygcnvj."jkuvqtkcp"Ktxkpi"Fknnctf"uckf."ÐRjknnkru"pqvcdn{"jgnrgf"vq"etgcvg"vjg"pgeguuct{"rwdnke"qrkpkqp"kp"uwrrqtv"qh"vjku"cogpfogpv"vjtqwij"jku"pgyurcrgt" cpf"ocic¦kpg" ctvkengu" vjcv" nckf" qrgp" vjg" Ýpcpekcn"oc/pkrwncvkqpu"rtgxkqwun{"uq"nctign{"jkffgp"htqo"vjg"g{gu"qh"qtfkpct{"ogp"cpf"yqogp0Ñ95"Hknngt"eqpvgpfgf"RjknnkruÓ"Ugpcvg"gzrqufiu"Ðicxg"hqto"vq"vjg"rqrwnct"rtqvguv"yjkej"Ýpcnn{"dtqwijv"cdqwv"rcuucig"qh"vjg"Ugxgpvggpvj"Cogpfogpv"vq"vjg"Eqpuvkvwvkqp"rtqxkfkpi"hqt"fktgev"gngevkqp"qh"ugpcvqtu0Ñ96"Cpf"Fknnctf"uckf."ÐVjgtg"ecp"dg"pq"swguvkqp"vjcv"RjknnkruÓ"rgtukuvgpv"ytkvkpi"hqt"c"nctig"rqrwnct"cwfkgpeg"qp"vjg"uwdlgev"qh"vjg"rqnkvkecn."geqpqoke"cpf"uqekcn"okuvtgcvogpv"qh"yqogp"kp"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu"jgnrgf"vq"dtkpi"cdqwv"vjku"oclqt"eqpuvkvwvkqpcn"ejcpig.Ñ97"vjg"Pkpgvggpvj"Cogpfogpv0

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"":9"

Vtwvj"xu0"Hcevu

Rjknnkru"dgnqpigf"vq"vjg"uejqqn"qh"owemtcmgtu"hqt"yjqo"gpfu"lwuvkÝgf" ogcpu0" Vq" jko." vjg" rqygt" qh" nkvgtcvwtg" cpf" tjgvqtke" kp"ikxkpi"cwfkgpegu"c" vtwg"rkevwtg"qh" nkhg"ycu"c"itgcvgt"iqcn" vjcp"vjg"lqwtpcnkuvke" qdlgevkxkv{" gurqwugf" d{"Vctdgnn0"Ceeqtfkpi" vq" jkuvqtk/cp"Tqdgtv"Oktcnfk."Rjknnkru"Ðqhvgp"dngpfgf"hcevu"cpf"Ýevkqp."wukpi"eqorqukvg"ejctcevgtu."Ýevkqpcn"fkcnqiwg"cpf"wpkfgpvkÝgf"uqwtegu"vq"ocmg"jku"rqkpvu"qp"uqekcn"kuuwgu0Ñ98"Dgecwug"qh"vjku."ÐVjg"Vtgcuqp"qh"vjg"UgpcvgÑ"rtqorvgf"Tqqugxgnv"vq"eqkp"vjg"vgto"owemtcmgt"vq"fg/uetkdg"vjg"igptg099"Oktcnfk"rqkpvgf"qwv."jqygxgt."vjcv"Ðwpnkmg"owej"qh" vjg"owemtcmkpi"ghhqtvu."yjkej"ygtg"ygnn"fqewogpvgf"gzrqufiu."vjg" ÒVtgcuqpÓ" ctvkengu" nghv"owej" vq"dg"fguktgf" cu" lqwtpcnkuo." gxgp"vjqwij" vjg" guugpeg" qh" RjknnkruÓ" ejctigu"ycu" rtqdcdn{" ceewtcvg0Ñ9:"Dgukfgu"Tqqugxgnv"cpf"ogodgtu"qh"vjg"Ugpcvg.9;"RjknnkruÓ"yqtm"gxgp"ftgy"etkvkekuo"htqo"qvjgt"lqwtpcnkuvu0:2

ÐRtgqeewrcvkqp"Ykvj"vjg"RtqokpgpvÑ

RjknnkruÓ"ngvvgtu"ygtg"fguvtq{gf"d{"jku"Ýtuv"dkqitcrjgt:3"cpf"vjg"ncem"qh"rtkoct{"uqwteg"ocvgtkcn"qp"RjknnkruÓ"vjqwijvu"cpf"oqvkxcvkqp"cu"c"owemtcmgt"ocmgu"fktgev"cuugtvkqp"qh"jku"xkgy"qh"vjg"qtfkpct{"ekvk¦gp"rtqdngocvke0"Jqygxgt." jku" ugxgtcn" dkqitcrjgtu"jcxg"pqvgf"c"eqpukfgtcdng"cwfkgpeg"hqt"jku"pqxgnu"cpf"hqt"vjg"ocic¦kpgu"eqp/vckpkpi"jku"owemtcmkpi"ctvkengu0"Hknngt"ogpvkqpgf"Ðc"jcnh"c"oknnkqpÑ"Equoqrqnkvcp"tgcfgtu:4"qh"ÐVjg"Vtgcuqp"qh"vjg"Ugpcvg0Ñ

Ceeqtfkpi" vq"Hknngt." RjknnkruÓ" ekteng" qh" htkgpfu" cpf" eqnngciwgu"ycu"ftcyp"htqo"vjg"gnkvgu"qh"Pgy"[qtm"uqekgv{0:5"Oqtgqxgt."dkqitc/rjgt"Cdg"Tcxkv¦"uckf"vjcv"kp"owej"qh"jku"ytkvkpi."ÐRjknnkru"ujqygf"jku"rtgqeewrcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"rtqokpgpv"cpf"hcujkqpcdng"000"jku"kpxqnxg/ogpv"ykvj"vjg"ocvgtkcnu"qh"jku"Ýevkqp"fkf"pqv"gzvgpf"vq"c"rcuukqpcvg"eqpegtp"hqt"cp"kpfkxkfwcn0Ñ:6"Vjwu."gurgekcnn{"kp"vjg"ÐVtgcuqpÑ"ug/tkgu."RjknnkruÓ"vctigvu"cpf"jku"vctigv"cwfkgpegu"crrgct"vq"jcxg"dggp"vjg" wrrgt" uvtcvc" qh"ygcnvj" cpf"rqygt0"Vjku"oc{"jcxg" umgygf"jku"eqpegrvwcnk¦cvkqp"qh" vjg"qtfkpct{" ekvk¦gp0"Cu"Hknngt" uckf<" ÐRjknnkru"kfgcnk¦gf"c"okffng"encuu"yjkej"gctpgf"kvu"dtgcf"kh"pqv"swkvg"d{"vjg"uygcv"qh"kvu"hceg."kp"NkpeqnpÓu"rjtcug."cv"ngcuv"d{"uvgcf{."rtqfwevkxg"ncdqt0"Rjknnkru"fkf"pqv"jcxg" vq" eqrg"ykvj" vjg"rgtrngzkvkgu"qh"ocuu"rtqfwevkqp."vjg"cuugodn{"nkpg."ÒugtxkegÓ"kpfwuvtkgu"yjkej"vqq"qhvgp"rtqxkfgf"nkvvng"ugtxkeg0Ñ:7

::""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

RWDNKE"LQWTPCNKUO<"VJGQT["KPVQ"RTCEVKEG

Nkmg"owemtcmkpi."rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"jcu"rtqxgp" vq"dg"cp"wo/dtgnnc" vgto" hqt" c"ykfg" tcpig" qh" lqwtpcnkuvke" cevkxkvkgu" cpf" tguwnvu0"Rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"jcu"dggp"wugf"vq"fguetkdg"qt"ucpevkqp"lqwtpcnku/vke"dgjcxkqtu"tcpikpi"htqo"ukorn{"uggmkpi"qwv"tgcfgtu"vq"cum"vjgo"vjgkt"eqpegtpu.:8"vq"tgqtkgpvkpi"rqnkvkecn"eqxgtcig"vq"hqewu"qp"rqnke{"kuuwgu"qxgt"ecpfkfcvg"rgtuqpcnkvkgu"cpf"uqwpf"dkvg"crrtqcejgu.:9"vq"kfgpvkh{kpi"cpf"uqnkekvkpi"urgekÝe"pggfu" vq"jgnr"jkij/etkog"pgkij/dqtjqqfu.::" vq" tgfgukipkpi" nc{qwv" cpf" itcrjkeu" vq" gpjcpeg" vjgkt"xcnwg" vq" tgcfgtu0:;" Rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo" cnuq" jcu" ngf" vq" eqxgtcig" kp"yjkej"lqwtpcnkuvu"cfqrv"vjg"tqng"qh"gzrgtv"kp"urgekh{kpi"uqnwvkqpu;2"cpf"ghhqtvu"vq"cevkxgn{"qticpk¦g"cpf"ngcf"eqoowpkv{"itqwru"kp"vjg"uqnwvkqp"qh"rtqdngou"rncegf"qp"vjg"cigpfc"d{"rtguu"cpf"ekvk¦gpu"cev/kpi"vqigvjgt0;3"Kp"ugxgtcn"gzcorngu"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo."vtcfkvkqpcn"kpvgt/ogfkc" eqorgvkvkqp"jcu" dggp" guejgygf" hqt" lqkpv." eqqtfkpcvgf"cevkxkvkgu"kpxqnxkpi"qpg"qt"oqtg"pgyurcrgtu"cpf"qpg"qt"oqtg"dtqcf/ecuv"uvcvkqpu0;4"Vgejpqnqi{"jcu"gxgp"cnnqygf"ekvk¦gpu"vq"wpfgtuvcpf"ngikuncvkxg"tgfkuvtkevkpi"vjtqwij"kpvgtcevkxg"icokpi.;5""jgnr"rncp"ow/pkekrcn"rtqlgevu;6"cpf"fgvgtokpg"jqy"fkhhgtgpv"nqecn/rqnke{"qrvkqpu"yqwnf"chhgev"vjgkt"vczgu0;7

Ctiwkpi"vjcv"yjcv"ku"korqtvcpv"kp"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ku"kvu"rjknqu/qrj{."pqv"c"fgÝpkvkqp."oqxgogpv"eq/hqwpfgt"Fcxku"ÐDw¦¦Ñ"Ogttkvv"kpkvkcnn{"yctpgf"cickpuv"uggkpi"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ogtgn{"cu"c"ugv"qh"dgjcxkqtu0"ÐVjg"{gctpkpi"hqt"c"hcekng"fgÝpkvkqp" 000" kpxkvgf"lqwtpcn/kuvu" vq" tgictf" kv" cu" c" ugv" qh" rtcevkegu" tcvjgt" vjcp" cu" c" rjknquqrj{0"Rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"dgecog"Òhqewu"itqwruÓ"cpf"ÒrqnnkpiÓ"cpf"Òjqnfkpi"hqtwouÓ"cpf"Òugvvkpi"cigpfcuÓ"cpf"Òigvvkpi"kpxqnxgf"kp"vjg"pgyuÓ"cpf"Òcumkpi" tgcfgtuÓ" 000"Vjg" vqqnu" jcxg" dgeqog" kfgpvkÝgf" cu" vjg" vjkpi"kvugnh0Ñ;8

Kh"fgÝpkvkqp"jcu"dggp"c"fgrgpfgpv"xctkcdng."uqog"qh"rwdnke"lqwt/pcnkuoÓu"rtkoct{"cvvtkdwvgu"pgxgtvjgnguu"jcxg"jgnrgf"ujcrg"yjcv"kv"okijv"ogcp"vq"ekvk¦gpu"cpf"vq"lqwtpcnkuvu0"Chvgt"{gctu"qh"fgenkpkpi"vq"fgÝpg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo."Tqugp"oqtg"tgegpvn{"jcu"uckf"Ðkv"okijv"iq"uqogvjkpi"nkmg"vjku<"Cp"crrtqcej"vq"vjg"fckn{"dwukpguu"qh"vjg"etchv"vjcv"ecnnu"qp"lqwtpcnkuvu"vq"*3+"cfftguu"rgqrng"cu"ekvk¦gpu."rqvgpvkcn"rctvkekrcpvu" kp"rwdnke"chhcktu."tcvjgt" vjcp"xkevkou"qt"urgevcvqtu="*4+"jgnr"vjg"rqnkvkecn"eqoowpkv{"cev"wrqp."tcvjgt"vjcp"lwuv"ngctp"cdqwv."kvu" rtqdngou=" *5+" kortqxg" vjg" enkocvg"qh" rwdnke" fkuewuukqp." tcvjgt"vjcp"ukorn{"ycvej" kv"fgvgtkqtcvg="cpf"*6+"jgnr"ocmg"rwdnke" nkhg"iq"ygnn."uq"vjcv"kv"gctpu"kvu"encko"qp"qwt"cvvgpvkqp0Ñ;9

Coqpi"jwpftgfu"qh"rtkpv."dtqcfecuv."lqkpv"ogfkc"cpf"ownvkog/

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"":;"

fkc"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"rtqlgevu.;:" vyq"cv"Ejctnqvvg."Pqtvj"Ectqnkpc."knnwuvtcvg"mg{"eqpegrvu"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"kp"pgyuyqtm0"Cu"kvu"Ýtuv"hqtc{"kpvq"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo."vjg"Ejctnqvvg"Qdugtxgt"kp"3;;4"fgekfgf"vq"hqtiq"eqxgtkpi"gngevkqpu"d{"vjg"vtcfkvkqpcn."uq/ecnngf"Ðjqtug/tcegÑ"crrtqcej"vjcv"hqewugu"qp"yjq"ku"ngcfkpi"yjqo"kp"vjg"tceg0"Kpuvgcf."d{"Ýtuv"uggmkpi"kfgcu"htqo"vjg"eqoowpkv{."vjg"pgyurcrgt"etgcvgf"c"ekvk¦gpÓu"cigpfc"qh"yjcv"kuuwgu"ygtg"korqtvcpv"vjcv"vjg"uvchh"wugf"cu"vjg"dcuku"hqt"swguvkqpkpi"cpf"gxcnwcvkpi"ecpfkfcvgu0"ÐYjgp"ecpfk/fcvgu"icxg"cp"korqtvcpv"urggej"fwtkpi"vjg"ecorckip."vjg"eqpvgpvu"ygtg"ÒocrrgfÓ"cickpuv" vjg"ekvk¦gpÓu"cigpfc."uq" vjcv" kv"ycu"gcu{"vq"vgnn"yjcv"ycu" uckf" cdqwv" vjqug" eqpegtpu" vjcv" tcpmgf" jkijguv"ykvj"ekvk¦gpu0Ñ;;"Vjg"QdugtxgtÓu"3;;4"eqxgtcig"dgicp"ykvj"kuuwgu"rqnnkpi"qh"ekvk¦gpu"vq"fgvgtokpg"yjcv"ycu"korqtvcpv"vq"vjgo."hqnnqygf"d{"kp/fgrvj"eqxgtcig"Ðvq"jgnr" vjgo"wpfgtuvcpf" vjgug"eqorngz" kuuwgu"cpf"vjg"rqvgpvkcn"uqnwvkqpu0Ñ322"Vjg"pgzv"uvgr"ycu"vq"kpxqnxg"ekvk¦gpu"cv"gxgt{"uvcig0"Ceeqtfkpi"vq"Qdugtxgt"gfkvqt"Tkem"Vjcogu<

Qwt"kuuwgu"rqnn"ycu"vjg"Ýtuv"uvgr"vqyctf"tgvwtpkpi"ekvk¦gpu"vq"vjgkt"rtqrgt"rnceg"kp"qwt"eqxgtcig"qh"vjg"rqnkvkecn"rtq/eguu0"Pqy"yg"yqtmgf"vq"mggr"vjgo"vjgtg" vjtqwijqwv" vjg"ecorckip0"Yg"rgrrgtgf"qwt" kuuwgu" uvqtkgu" cpf" ecorckip"vtckn" tgrqtvu"ykvj"ekvk¦gp"rgturgevkxgu0"Yg"eqnngevgf"tgcf/gtuÓ" swguvkqpu" kp" cfxcpeg"qh" ecpfkfcvguÓ" xkukvu" cpf" cumgf"vjqug"swguvkqpu"cnqpi"ykvj"qwt"qyp0"Yjgp"Rcv"Dwejcpcp"xkukvgf"qwt"pgyutqqo."yg"rwv"jko"dghqtg"c"itqwr"qh"xqv/gtu"kpuvgcf"qh"qwt"gfkvqtkcn"dqctf0"Yg"urqpuqtgf"c"fgdcvg"coqpi"ecpfkfcvgu"hqt"iqxgtpqt"cpf"kpxkvgf"ekvk¦gpu"vq"cum"uqog" qh" vjg" swguvkqpu0" Yg" tgiwnctn{" rwdnkujgf" tgcfgtuÓ"vgngrjqpgf"eqoogpvu"cdqwv"ecorckip"fgxgnqrogpvu0323

Yjkng"ecpfkfcvgu"eqwnf"vcnm"cdqwv"cp{vjkpi"vjg{"ycpvgf"vq"dtkpi"wr."Qdugtxgt" lqwtpcnkuvu"kpukuvgf"vjcv"vjg{"cnuq"urgcm"vq"vjg"kuuwgu"qp"vjg"ekvk¦gpu"cigpfc0"Kh"c"ecpfkfcvg"tghwugf."jg"qt"ujg"okijv"dg"kfgpvkÝgf"cu"fgenkpkpi"vq"cpuygt"vjg"ekvk¦gpuÓ"swguvkqpu."qt"d{"dncpm"urcegu"kp"itkfu"yjgtg"qvjgtuÓ"cpuygtu"vq"vjg"swguvkqpu"crrgctgf0

Ceeqtfkpi" vq"Vjcogu." vjg" ecorckip" eqwnf" encko" uweeguu" d{"uwej" ogcuwtgu" cu" xqvgt" tgurqpug" vq" vjg" pgyurcrgtÓu" crrgcnu" hqt"fkcnqiwg." xqvgt" vwtpqwv." cpf" xqvgt" ecnnu" vq" iqxgtpogpv" qhÝekcnu"hqt"kphqtocvkqp0"ÐEqorctgf"vq"tgcfgtu"qh"qvjgt"ctgc"pgyurcrgtu.Ñ"Vjcogu"uc{u."Ejctnqvvg"tgcfgtu"gxkpegf"Ðc"fkurtqrqtvkqpcvg"kpetgcug"kp"kpvgtguv"kp"rqnkvkeu"fwtkpi"vjg"ecorckip."ygtg"oqtg"rqukvkxg"cdqwv"vjg"pgyurcrgtÓu"jgnrhwnpguu"kp"ocmkpi"vjgo"hggn"c"rctv"qh"vjg"rqnkvk/

;2""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

ecn"rtqeguu.Ñ"cpf"Ðhgnv"oqtg"qh"c"eqppgevkqp"dgvyggp"eqxgtcig"qh"vjg"ecpfkfcvgu"cpf"vjg"kuuwgu"chhgevkpi"vjgo"rgtuqpcnn{0Ñ324

Kp" c" oqtg" codkvkqwu." pqp/gngevkqp" rtqlgev." vjg" Qdugtxgt" kp"3;;6" vgcogf"ykvj" vgngxkukqp" cpf" tcfkq" lqwtpcnkuvu" kp" ÐVcmg" Dcem"Qwt"Pgkijdqtjqqfu1Ectqnkpc"Etkog"Uqnwvkqpu.Ñ"c"rtqlgev"vq"tgencko"etkog/tkffgp."korqxgtkujgf"pgkijdqtjqqfu"vjtqwij"ekvk¦gp"cevkqp0325"Dgukfgu"gzvgpukxg"wug"qh" vtcfkvkqpcn" tgrqtvkpi"ogvjqfu."eqorwvgt/cuukuvgf" tgrqtvkpi" cpf" etquu/ogfkc" eqxgtcig." vjg" rtqlgev" kpenwfgf"eqpfwevkpi"vqyp"oggvkpiu."dtkpikpi"qhÝekcnu"vq"nkuvgp"vq"rgqrng"qh"vjg"pgkijdqtjqqfu."cpf"uwuvckpgf"eqxgtcig"Î"qxgt"ugxgtcn"{gctu"Î"qh"vjg"ghhqtvu0"Vjg"pgyurcrgt"cnuq"ugtxgf"cu"c"engctkpi"jqwug"hqt"rgqrng"ykvj"kfgcu."iqqfu"cpf"owueng"vq"eqpvtkdwvg"vqyctf"uqnxkpi"rtqdngou"eqxgtgf"kp"pgyu"uvqtkgu"cpf"gxgp"vqqm"vjg"tcfkecn"uvgr"qh"jktkpi."ykvj"Rgy"oqpg{."c"eqoowpkv{"eqqtfkpcvqt"Ðyjq"ycu"kpuvtwogpvcn"kp"qt/icpk¦kpi"vqyp"oggvkpiu"cpf"hqewu"itqwru"cpf"eqqtfkpcvkpi"tgcfgt"tgurqpug0Ñ326

CPCN[UKU

Vctdgnn." Rjknnkru." cpf" Uvghhgpu" tgrtgugpv" vjtgg" vjgogu" qh" vjg"owemtcmkpi"oqxgogpv0"Vctdgnn" uvqqf" hqt" vjg" lqwtpcnkuvke" iqcnu" qh"qdlgevkxkv{."cocuukpi"eqrkqwu"hcevu"cpf"ngvvkpi"vjg"hcevu"vgnn"vjg"uvq/t{0"Rjknnkru."qp"vjg"qvjgt"jcpf."dgnkgxgf"vjcv"vq"vgnn"vjg"vtwvj"okijv"tgswktg"guejgykpi"ogtg"qdlgevkxg"hcevu."c"pqvkqp"gejqgf"d{"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuoÓu"eq/hqwpfgt" Lc{"Tqugp" kp" vjg"gctn{"3;;2u0327"UvghhgpuÓ"owemtcmkpi"ngf"jko"cyc{"htqo"vjg"dcvvngu"qh"hcevu"cpf"qdlgevkxkv{."cpf"htqo"lqwtpcnkuo"kvugnh."cu"jg"cvvgorvgf"vq"dgeqog"cp"cevkxg"rctv/pgt"kp"tghqto"oqxgogpvu"ctqwpf"vjg"eqwpvt{0

Vjku" tgugctej" uwiiguvu" vjcv" vjg" owemtcmgtu." nkmg" vjg" rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu."uqwijv"vq"wug"vjg"ogfkc"vq"tgeqppgev"ekvk¦gpu"ykvj"vjgkt"iqxgtpogpv0"Jqygxgt."vjg{"crrtqcejgf"vjg"vcum"htqo"fkhhgtgpv"gpfu"qh"vjg"urgevtwo"cpf"ykvj"fkhhgtgpv"eqpegrvkqpu"qh"vjg"vgtou"qh"vjcv"tgeqppgevkqp0

Kpfggf." egtvckp" wpfgtn{kpi" cuuworvkqpu" cpf" dgnkghu" crrgct"vq" nkpm" vjg" vyq"oqxgogpvu0"Gcej" ku"itqwpfgf" kp" hckvj" vjcv" cp"gp/icigf" cpf" eqookvvgf" rwdnke" ecp" cpf" fqgu"ocmg" iqqf" ejqkegu0328"Ceeqtfkpi"vq"jkuvqtkcp"Rcvtkem"Rcngtoq."ÐUvghhgpu"dgnkgxgf"vjcv"ocp"jcf"c"pcvwtcn."goqvkqpcn"fkurqukvkqp"vq"fq"iqqf0"Yjgp"ÒkpvgnnkigpegÓ"uygrv"cyc{"vjg"kipqtcpeg"qh"rgtuqpcn"cpf"uqekcn"gxkn."vjku"igpgtqwu"korwnug"vjgp"oqxgf"vjgug"ngcfgtu"vq"godtceg"vjgkt"hgnnqy"ocp"cpf"tghqto0Ñ329

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"";3"

Vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu."vqq."tguv"vjgkt"oqxgogpv"qp"cp"kornkekv"dgnkgh" vjcv" ekvk¦gpu." kh" dtqwijv" kpvq" eqoowpkv{" fkueqwtug."yknn" dg"gpvjwukcuvke"hqt"cevkqp0"Ogttkvv."hqt"kpuvcpeg."uckf<

CogtkecpuÓ"igpgtcn"fkuiwuv"ykvj"cpf"ykvjftcycn"htqo"rwdnke"nkhg"pgxgtvjgnguu"kpenwfgu"uqog"gctn{"ukipu"qh"ocvwtkpi"kpvq"c"fgvgtokpcvkqp" vq"ejcpig" vjg"yc{" vjkpiu"rtgugpvn{"yqtm0"Vjg" gogtikpi" eqoowpkvctkcp"oqxgogpv." ejcpigu" kp" eqt/rqtcvg"rtqeguugu" vq"gorqygt"yqtmgtu." gzrgtkogpvcvkqp" kp"pgy"yc{u"vq"qrgtcvg"rwdnke"uejqqnu."itqykpi"fkuewuukqp"qh"pgy"yc{u"qh"qticpk¦kpi"nkxkpi"urcegu"cpf"eqoowpkvkgu."kp/etgcugf"rtguuwtg"hqt"eqoowpkv{"rqnkekpi."cpf"vjg"hqwpfkpi"qh"uwrrqtv"itqwru"ctg"cnn"ukipu"qh"cp"cycmgpkpi."cnvjqwij"kv"uggou"gxgt"uq"unkijv."qh"CogtkecÓu"ekxke"gvjke032:

Cu"Ejctkv{"rwv"kv."ÐRwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"fqgupÓv"qpn{"cko"vq"vtgcv"tgcf/gtu"cu"ekvk¦gpu."kv"cuuwogu"vjcv"tgcfgtu"ycpv"vq"dg"ekvk¦gpu0Ñ32;

Kv" ku" cv" vjku" rqkpv." jqygxgt." vjcv" c" pcvwtcn" fgnkpgcvkqp" qh" vjg"oqxgogpvu"gogtigu0"Vjg"owemtcmgtu."cu"gzgornkÝgf"d{"Uvghhgpu."Vctdgnn."cpf"Rjknnkru"dwv"fgoqpuvtcvgf"cu"ygnn" kp"vjg"yqtm"qh"Tc{"Uvcppctf"Dcmgt."Wrvqp"Ukpenckt."cpf"Ejctngu"Gfyctf"Twuugnn."ygtg"vjg" qpgu" vq" ugngev" vjg" rtqdngou" qh" uqekgv{" qp" yjkej" vjg{" yqwnf"ytkvg0"Vjg"ejqkegu."jqygxgt"pcvwtcn."ygtg"pqv"jkgtctejkecnn{"qtfgtgf"htqo"oquv"ugxgtg"vq"pgzv"ugxgtg."cpf"cu"jkuvqtkcp"Lcogu"Y0"Ectg{"jcu" rqkpvgf" qwv."owemtcmkpi" gctn{" qp" Ðfktgevgf" kvu" cvvcem" cickpuv"vjg" Òrnwvqetce{Ó" cpf" vjg" dwukpguu" encuu0Ñ332"Vjg"owemtcmgtu" cnqpg"rwv"vjg"knnu"vjg{"rgtegkxgf"kp"uqekgv{"qp"vjgkt"ogfkc"cigpfc0"Vjgktu"ygtg" fkevcvgf" fkcipqugu" cpf" rtguetkrvkqpu." cpf" yjkng" ektewncvkqp"gzrnqukqpu"qp"vjg"owemtcmkpi"ocic¦kpgu"cvvguv"vq"vjg"ceewtce{"qh"vjgkt"lwfiogpv"cdqwv"yjcv"vjg"rwdnke"ycpvgf."kv"ku"yqtvj"pqvkpi"vjcv"vjg"owemtcmgtuÓ"xktvwcnn{"wpkxgtucn"vjgog"qh"dtkpikpi"rqygt"vq"jggn"oc{" jcxg" dnkpfgf" vjgo" vq" qvjgt" uqekgvcn" rtqdngou0" Hqt" kpuvcpeg."fgurkvg"VctdgnnÓu"eqpegtpu"hqt"gswcn"yqtmkpi"tkijvu"hqt"yqogp"cpf"ykvj"Rjknnkru"c"ukpiwnct"gzegrvkqp."uecpv"cvvgpvkqp"ycu"rckf" kp" vjg"owemtcmkpi"lqwtpcnu"vq"vjg"yqogpÓu"uwhhtcig"kuuwg"vjcv"ycu"dqknkpi"vqyctf"ewnokpcvkqp"ykvj"vjg"Pkpgvggpvj"Cogpfogpv"kp"3;420

Rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuoÓu" rtqrqpgpvu." qp" vjg" qvjgt" jcpf." jcxg" ct/iwgf"vjcv"vjg"crrtqrtkcvg"cigpfc"dgikpu"ykvj"ekvk¦gpu0"Ceeqtfkpi"vq"Ejctkv{<"ÐEkvk¦gpu"ctg"htwuvtcvgf"d{"vjg"uncvgu"qh"Òkorqtvcpv"kuuwguÓ"vjcv"gfkvqtu"cpf"rqnkvkecn"ngcfgtu"rcuu"fqyp"vq"vjgo"d{"Ýcv="vjg{Ótg"nqqmkpi"hqt"cp"cigpfc"vjcv"eqttgurqpfu"vq"vjg"rtqdngou"vjg{"vjgo/ugnxgu"ugg0"Uq"yjkng"pgyurcrgtu"ecp"iq"qp"vt{kpi"vq"rgtuwcfg"rgqrng"


vjcv" vjku"qt" vjcv"wprqrwnct" kuuwg"ycttcpvu"cvvgpvkqp." vjg{Ónn"gpicig"ekvk¦gpu"oqtg"kh"vjg{"ngctp"vq"tgurgev"vjg"rtkqtkvkgu"vjqug"ekvk¦gpu"ugv"hqt"vjgougnxgu."cpf"hqewu"pgyu"eqxgtcig"vkijvn{"ctqwpf"vjgo0Ñ333

Vjg"tgugctej"uwiiguvu"vjg"j{rqvjguku"vjcv"fgurkvg"ukoknctkvkgu"kp"vjg"oqvkxgu"cpf"ogvjqfu"qh"vjg"owemtcmgtu"cpf"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu."vjg"vyq"rgturgevkxgu"fkhhgt"kp"vjgkt"hwpfcogpvcn"eqpegrvwcnk¦cvkqp"qh"vjg"tgncvkqpujkr"qh"rtguu."rwdnke"cpf"iqxgtpogpv0"

Ngcfgt/Egpvgtgf"Owemtcmgtu

Vq"Vctdgnn."Rjknnkru."cpf"Uvghhgpu."vjg"vcum"ycu"gzrqukpi"eqttwr/vkqp"cpf"ocnhgcucpeg"kp"rwdnke"nkhg."cpf"vjg"iqcn"ycu"gpnkuvkpi"cdng."wpeqttwrvgf" kpfkxkfwcnu" vq" dg" ngcfgtu" qh" iqxgtpogpv0" Ceeqtfkpi"vq"Mcrncp." vjg"owemtcmgtu" Ðtgeqipk¦gf" vjcv" fgoqetce{"ycu" unqy"vq"rwtig"qt"tgxgtug"kvugnh."cpf"eqpugswgpvn{"vjg{"qhvgp"nqqmgf"ykvj"hcxqt"qp"uvtqpi"ogp"yjq"ugv" vjgougnxgu"cdqxg" vjg" ncy0Ñ334"Vjgug"ngcfgtuÓ" vcumu"yqwnf"dg" vq"qhhgt"rtqitcou"cpf"c"xkukqp"tgurqpukxg"vq"vjg"ekvk¦gpt{"kp"c"vqr/fqyp"eqoowpkecvkqp"Þqy0"UnqcpÓu"cpcn{/uku"ku"vjcv"vjg"Rtqitguukxg"oqxgogpv"ycu"dtqwijv"qp"d{"hgct"qh"dki"dwukpguu"cpf"kvu"eqpvtqn"qh"iqxgtpogpv"cpf"ycu"Ðckogf"rtkoctkn{"cv"cvvgorvkpi"vq"vcmg"eqpvtqn"htqo"dwukpguu"cpf"tgvwtp"kv"vq"vjg"okffng"encuu0Ñ335"Hqt"vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu."jqygxgt."vjg"iqcn"ku"c"dqvvqo/wr"

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"";5"

tgeqppgevkqp"kp"yjkej"vjg"ekvk¦gpu"ctg"tg/gpgtik¦gf"cpf"tg/gpicigf"kp"iqxgtpogpv"cpf"ekxke"nkhg"vjtqwij"lqwtpcnkuvuÓ"iwkfcpeg"cpf"go/rqygtogpv0

Ekvk¦gp/Dcugf"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo

Cnvjqwij" cv" vjg" qwvugv" vjg" tghqto" uqwijv" d{" vjg"owemtcmgtu"ku"oqtg"gcukn{"tgeqipk¦gf" kp" vjg" vtcfkvkqp"qh"cejkgxkpi"jqpguv." tg/urqpukxg"iqxgtpogpv." vjg" tghqto"uqwijv"d{" vjg"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"oqxgogpv"iqgu"dg{qpf"vjcv"vq"qpg"qh"dgvvgt"dcncpeg"dgvyggp"ekvk/¦gpu"cpf"vjg"kpuvkvwvkqpu"qh"vjgkt"rqnkvkecn"cpf"ekxke"nkhg0"Yjgtg"vjg"owemtcmgtu"gpxkukqpgf" tgcn"eqttwrvkqp"cpf" tgcn"gpgokgu" kp"rwdnke"nkhg."vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuvu"ugnfqo"encko"vjcv"vjg"iqxgtpogpv"ngcfgtu"ctg"eqttwrv"qt"vjcv"vjgkt"rqnkekgu"ctg"tgrtguukxg0"Vjgkt"encko."kpuvgcf."ku"vjcv"vjg"iqxgtpogpv"ku"tgpfgtgf"wptgrtgugpvcvkxg"cpf"wptgurqp/ukxg"yjgp"ekvk¦gpu"nqug"hckvj"kp"vjgkt"kpuvkvwvkqpu"cpf"ykvjftcy"htqo"rctvkekrcvkqp0336"

Kornkekv"kp"vjg"nkvgtcvwtg"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo."vqq."jcu"dggp"vjcv"iqxgtpogpv"ecppqv"qt"yknn"pqv"cfftguu"rtqdngou"qh"ekvk¦gp"eqpegtp"wpnguu"ekvk¦gpu"ctg"jgctf"cpf"ctg"cevkxg"kp"rtqoqvkpi"uqnwvkqpu."cpf"jgtg" nkgu"cpqvjgt"eqpegrvwcn"fgrctvwtg0"Vjg" vyq"oqxgogpvuÓ" tgnc/vkqp"vq"ekvk¦gpu"cpf"iqxgtpogpv"ecp"dg"nkmgpgf"vq"c"ngxgt"cpf"hwn/


etwo0"Kp"vjg"Rtqitguukxg"oqfgn."vjg"xqvgtu"ygtg"vjg"hwnetwo"cpf"vjg"lqwtpcnkuvu"ygtg"cv"vjg"ngxgt."yjkng"kp"vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"oqfgn"lqwtpcnkuvu"ctg"vjg"hwnetwo"cpf"kv"ku"vjg"ekvk¦gpuÓ"jcpfu"qp"vjg"ngxgt0"Dqvj"okijv"oqxg"iqxgtpogpv"vq"cev."dwv"vjg"eqpegrvwcn"f{pcokeu"ctg"xgt{"fkhhgtgpv."kp"rctv"dgecwug"qh"vjg"fkhhgtkpi"uvcvwu"qh"vjg"rtguu"cv"vjg"dgikppkpi"cpf"gpf"qh"vjg"vygpvkgvj"egpvwt{0

Vjg"owemtcmgtu"yqtmgf" htqo"c"rqygthwn/ogfkc"oqfgn0" ÐVjg"rqygt"qh"vjg"rtguu"ku"itgcvgt"vjcp"gxgt"dghqtg.Ñ"ytqvg"Yknn"Ktykp"kp"3;33"cv"vjg"dgikppkpi"qh"c"Eqnnkgtu"ugtkgu"owemtcmkpi"vjg"Cogtkecp"rtguu0337"Rwdnkujkpi"Ðvjg"tcy"ocvgtkcn"hqt"rwdnke"qrkpkqp.Ñ338"jg"fg/enctgf."Ðvjg"Cogtkecp"rtguu"jcu"oqtg"kpÞwgpeg"vjcp"kv"gxgt"jcf"kp"cp{"qvjgt" vkog." kp"cp{"qvjgt"eqwpvt{0"Pq"qvjgt"gzvtclwfkekcn"hqteg."gzegrv" tgnkikqp." ku" jcnh" uq" rqygthwn0Ñ339" Hgct" qh" dcf" rtguu" cpf" cp"ctqwugf"cpf"kphqtogf"ekvk¦gpt{"ycu"c"rqygthwn"kpegpvkxg"hqt"tghqto."cpf"owemtcmgtu"cejkgxgf"eqpukfgtcdng"uweeguu" kp" kortqxkpi"uqek/gv{0"Xkgygf" kp" vjqug" vgtou." vjg"owemtcmgtu."yjqug" Ðhqtownc"ycu"ukorng<"Fkcipqug."rtguetkdg."vjgp"ycvej"uqnwvkqpu"wphqnf.Ñ33:"eqwnf"tgn{"qp"vjg"nkvgtcvwtg"qh"gzrquwtg"vq"cejkgxg"vjgkt"gpfu033;

Cv"egpvwt{Óu"gpf."jqygxgt."vjgtg"ycu"eqpukfgtcdng"fqwdv"cdqwv"vjg"rqygt"qh"vjg"rtguu"gxgp"vq"ucxg"kvugnh"cokf"etkvkecn"nquugu"kp"og/fkc"etgfkdknkv{"coqpi"tgcfgtu.342"fgenkpkpi"ektewncvkqp.343"cpf"c"eqp/vkpwcn"tgfwevkqp"kp"vjg"pwodgt"qh"pgyurcrgtu0"Rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ycu"dqtp."Tqugp"uc{u."Ðcv"c"vkog"qh"itcxg"fqwdvu"cdqwv"vjg"hwvwtg"qh"vjg"rtguu0Ñ344"Vjg"rqygt"qh"vjg"rtguu."eqpvguvgf"gxgp"kp"KtykpÓu"fc{.345"okijv"dg"uggp"dgvvgt"kp"uqog"ghhqtv"vq"tgeqppgev"ekvk¦gpu."rtqoqvg"ekxke"fkcnqi."cpf"hceknkvcvg"ekvk¦gp"uqnwvkqpu"vq"uqekgvcn"rtqdngou"vjcp"kp"c"Swkzqvke"cvvgorv"vq"owemtcmg"kp"vjg"vtcfkvkqp"qh"Uvghhgpu"qt"Rjknnkru0

UWOOCT["CPF"EQPENWUKQP

Vjg"jkuvqtkgu"qh" vjg"owemtcmgtu"cpf"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuvu" kpfggf"uwrrqtv"vjcv"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ku"Ðtgokpkuegpv"qh"rtqitguukxg"kfgcu"cdqwv"vjg"pggf"hqt"ejcpig"kp"cp"ghhqtv"vq"kortqxg"vjg"eqpfkvkqpu"hqt"fgoqetce{0Ñ346" "Wrqp"kpkvkcn" kpurgevkqp." vjg{"uggo"ukoknctn{"oqvk/xcvgf"cpf"ukoknctn{"ukvwcvgf"cu"cevkxkuv"lqwtpcnkuvu"uggmkpi"vq"tgeqp/pgev"ekvk¦gpu"vq"vjgkt"iqxgtpogpv"hqt"vjg"dgvvgtogpv"qh"fgoqetce{0"Yjgtg"fkhhgtgpegu"uggo"vq"crrgct."uwej"cu"kp"¦gcn"hqt"gzrqufiu"cpf"kpxguvkicvkxg"lqwtpcnkuo."kv"ecp"gxgp"dg"ctiwgf"vjcv"uqog"qh"vjgug"ctg"nctign{"ocvvgtu"qh"fgitgg0347"Jqygxgt."vjg"yc{"gcej"oqxgogpv"eqp/egrvwcnk¦gf" vjg" tgncvkqpujkru"coqpi"ekvk¦gpu."iqxgtpogpv."cpf" vjg"rtguu"tgxgcnu"c"ukipkÝecpv."wpcrrtgekcvgf"fkhhgtgpeg"dgvyggp"vjgo0

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"";7"

Gzcokpkpi"vjg"rgtuqpcn"uvcvgogpvu"qh"hqwpfgtu"qh"owemtcmkpi"cpf"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ujqyu"vjcv"vjg"vyq"oqxgogpvu"fkhhgt"rjknq/uqrjkecnn{"kp"jqy"vjg{"ucy"vjg"tqng"qh"vjg"cxgtcig"ekvk¦gp."kpfggf."jqy"vjg{"ucy"vjg"ekvk¦gp0"Kv"ku"c"hwpfcogpvcn"cpf"ukipkÝecpv"fkhhgt/gpeg0"Yjgtg"gcej"uqwijv" vq"oqdknk¦g"nctig"pwodgtu"qh"ekvk¦gpu"vq"tguqnxg"rwdnke"kuuwgu."vjg"owemtcmgtu."cu"gxkfgpegf"d{"vjg"ngcfgtu"uvwfkgf"jgtg."uggo"nctign{"vq"jcxg"uggp"vjg"rwdnke"cu"etkvkecn"ocuu"d{"yjkej"vq"ngxgtcig"gnkvgu"kpvq"dgjcxkpi"kp"vjg"rwdnkeÓu"dguv"kpvgt/guvu0"Vjg"owemtcmgtuÓ"ekvk¦gp."cu"vjg{"ucy"jko."jcf"vq"dg"kphqtogf"d{"vjg"rtguuÏvqnf"yjcv"pggfgf"fqkpi."kp"qvjgt"yqtfuÏuq"vjcv"jg"eqwnf"Ðxqvg"vjg"tcuecnu"qwv0Ñ"Vjcv"jcxkpi"dggp"fqpg."vjg"gnkvgu"eqwnf"vcmg" kv" htqo"vjgtg"cpf" vjg"ekvk¦gp"eqwnf"iq"dcem" vq"dgkpi"cp"qtfk/pct{"rtqfwegt0"Vjg"rwdnke"cigpfcu"ygtg"pqv"vjg"rwdnkeÓu."cpf"vjgtg"ku"nkvvng"ugpug"kp"vjgkt"rgtuqpcn"uvcvgogpvu"vjcv"vjg"owemtcmgtu"ucy"ekvk¦gpu"cu"eqpvtkdwvkpi"kfgcu"qt"ngcfgtujkr"kp"dtkpikpi"cdqwv"ejcpig"kp"rwdnke"chhcktu0

Vjg"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuvu." qp" vjg"qvjgt"jcpf." uqwijv" vq"oqdknk¦g"ekvk¦gpu" vjtqwij" kphqtocvkqp." iwkfcpeg." gpeqwtcigogpv." cpf." cv"vkogu."nqikuvkecn"uwrrqtv0"LqwtpcnkuoÓu"tqng"ycu"vq"rtqxkfg"ekvk¦gpu"vjg"ogcpu"vq"kfgpvkh{"vjgkt"qyp"pggfu"cpf"uqnwvkqpu."cpf"vq"wug"iqx/gtpogpv"cu"qpg"qh"vjgkt"rtqdngo/uqnxkpi"vqqnu0"Kp"vjku"xkukqp."vjg"ekv/k¦gp"ku"owej"oqtg"vjqtqwijn{"gpicigf"kp"ekxke"chhcktu0"Kv"ku"c"oqtg"gorcvjke"cpf"gorqygtkpi"xkukqp"vjcp"vjg"owemtcmgtÓu"eqpegrvkqp"qh"Ðvjg"rgqrng.Ñ"cpf"tgrtgugpvu"c"dqvvqo/wr"oqfgn"kp"eqpvtcuv"vq"vjg"owemtcmgtuÓ"vqr/fqyp"oqfgn0

Vjku"tgugctej"eqpvtkdwvgu"vq"c"dgvvgt"wpfgtuvcpfkpi"qh"gcej"qh"vjgug"oqxgogpvu"vjcv"ujctg"qpg"qvjgt"hgcvwtg<"gcej"ncuvgf"cu"c"hqt/ocn"oqxgogpv"hqt"vgp"vq"vygnxg"{gctu0"Cu"pqvgf"cdqxg."vjg"owem/tcmkpi"rgtkqf"ycu"igpgtcnn{"uggp"cu"3;24"vq"3;340"Rwvvkpi"c"rtgekug"vkognkpg"qp"vjg"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"oqxgogpv"ku"rtqdngocvke"kp"vjcv"ocp{"lqwtpcnkuvu"uvknn"rtcevkeg"kv0"Jqygxgt."vjg"Rgy"Egpvgt"hqt"Ekxke"Lqwtpcnkuo." etgcvgf" kp" 3;;5" cu" cp" Ðkpewdcvqt" qh" ekxke" lqwtpcnkuo"rtqlgevu.Ñ"enqugf"kp"4224."cpf"ocp{"qh"vjg"oqxgogpvÓu"gctn{"Ýiwtgu"jcxg"rwtuwgf"qvjgt"rtqlgevu0"Kp"4224."Tqugp."yjkng"enckokpi"uweeguu"cpf" fgp{kpi" vjcv" vjg"oqxgogpv"ycu" qxgt." icxg" jku" kfgc" qh"yjcv"uejqnctu"yqwnf"ugg"cu"vjg"Ðjkuvqt{"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo0Ñ348"

D{"gzcokpkpi"vjg"rgtuqpcn"uvcvgogpvu"qh"hqwpfgtu"qh"owemtcm/kpi"cpf"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo."uejqnctu"cnuq"jcxg"c" lworkpi"qhh"rqkpv"hqt"gzcokpkpi"yjgvjgt"gkvjgt"fgrctvwtg"htqo"ockpuvtgco."vtcfkvkqp/cn" lqwtpcnkuo." kh" htggf"qh" vjg"geqpqoke"tgcnkvkgu" vjcv" kp"dqvj"ecugu"uggogf"vq"dtkpi"vjgkt"twpu"vq"cp"gpf."eqwnf"jcxg"hwnÝnngf"vjg"codk/vkqpu"qh"vjgkt"rtkpekrcn"urqpuqtu0


Gpfpqvgu

3"Ugg." hqt" kpuvcpeg."Ctvjwt"Ejctkv{."Fqkpi"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo" *Pgy"[qtm<"Iwknhqtf"Rtguu."3;;7+."3="Fcxku"Ogttkvv."Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Rwdnke"Nkhg<"Yj{"Vgnnkpi" vjg"Pgyu" Ku"Pqv"Gpqwij" *Jknnufcng."PL<"Ncytgpeg"Gtndcwo."3;;7+."8="Lc{"Tqugp."Igvvkpi"vjg"Eqppgevkqpu"Tkijv<"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"vjg"Vtqwdngu" kp" vjg"Rtguu" *Pgy"[qtm<"Vygpvkgvj"Egpvwt{"Hwpf."3;;8+."3="Lc{"Tqugp"cpf"Rcwn"Vc{nqt."Vjg"Pgy"Pgyu"x0"Vjg"Qnf"Pgyu" *Pgy"[qtm<"Vygpvkgvj"Egpvwt{"Hwpf."3;;4+04"Fcxku"Ogttkvv"fguetkdgu"uqog"qh" vjg"jkuvqt{"qh"jku"oqxgogpv" kp"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Rwdnke"Nkhg<"Yj{"Vgnnkpi"vjg"Pgyu"Ku"Pqv"Gpqwij"4pf"gf0"*Ocjycj."PL<"Ncytgpeg"Gtndcwo."3;;:+0"Hqt"c"eqpvgorqtcpgqwu"jkuvqt{"qh"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo."ugg"Ectqn"Tggug"F{mgtu."ÐCuuguukpi"Fcxku"OgttkvvÓu"ÒRwdnke" LqwtpcnkuoÓ" Vjtqwij" Jku" Ncpiwcig.Ñ" kp" gf0" Gfowpf" Ncodgvj."Rjknkr"Og{gt."cpf"Guvjgt"Vjqtuqp."Cuuguukpi"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"*Eqnwodkc<"Wpkxgtukv{" qh" Okuuqwtk" Rtguu." 3;;:+." 79/:40" Cnuq." F{mgtu." Ocmkpi"Lqwtpcnkuo"Rwdnke<"C"Ecug"Uvwf{"qh"Ejcpig"cv"vjg"Ykejkvc"Gcing."*Rj0F0"fkuu0."Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Pqtvj"Ectqnkpc"cv"Ejcrgn"Jknn."3;;7+05"Okejcgn" Uejwfuqp." ÐYjcv" Rwdnke" Lqwtpcnkuo"Mpqyu" cdqwv" Lqwtpcnkuo"dwv"FqgupÓv"Mpqy"cdqwv" ÒRwdnke.ÓÑ" kp"gf0"Vjgqfqtg"N0"Incuugt."Vjg"Kfgc"qh" Rwdnke" Lqwtpcnkuo" *Pgy" [qtm<" Iwknhqtf" Rtguu." 3;;;+." 33:/3550" Ugg"cnuq."Cpvjqp{" L0" Gmuvgtqyke¦." ÐVjg"Jkuvqt{" cpf"Fgxgnqrogpv" qh" Rwdnke"LqwtpcnkuoÑ"kp"gf0"cpf"Tqdgtv"P0"Tqdgtvu."Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Rqnkvkecn"Mpqyngfig" *Ncpjco."OF<"Tqyocp" cpf"NkvvngÝgnf." 4222+." 5/42="Tqdgtv"Oktcnfk."Vjg"Owemtcmgtu<"Gxcpignkecn"Etwucfgtu"*Yguvrqtv."EV<"Rtcgigt."4222+." zxk/zxkk=" Dctdkg" ¥gnk¦gt." ÐOcmkpi" vjg" Pgkijdqtjqqf"Yqtm<" Vjg"Kortqdcdknkvkgu"qh"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"kp"Incuugt."374/39406" Ugg." hqt" kpuvcpeg." Tqdgtv" E0" Mqejgtudgtigt." Lt0." gf0." Oqtg" Vjcp" c"Owemtcmgt<"Kfc"VctdgnnÓu"Nkhgvkog"kp"Lqwtpcnkuo"*Mpqzxknng<"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Vgppguugg"Rtguu."3;;6+="Tqdgtv"Oktcnfk."ÐVjg"Lqwtpcnkuo"qh"Fcxkf"Itcjco"Rjknnkru.Ñ" Lqwtpcnkuo" Swctvgtn{" 85" *Urtkpi" 3;:8+<" :50" Jqygxgt." uqog"qvjgtu"Ýpf"owemtcmkpi"iqkpi"qp"cv"ngcuv"c"fgecfg"gctnkgt0"Lqjp"O0"Jcttkuqp"cpf"Jctt{"J0"Uvgkp."gf0"Owemtcmkpi<"Rcuv."Rtgugpv"cpf"Hwvwtg"*Wpkxgtukv{"Rctm<"Rgppu{nxcpkc"Uvcvg"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;92+."40"Nkpeqnp"Uvghhgpu."Vjg"Cwvqdkqitcrj{" qh" Nkpeqnp" Uvghhgpu" *Pgy"[qtm<" Jcteqwtv." Dtceg" (" Eq0."3;53+."5790"7" Yknnkco" Fcxkf" Unqcp." Rgturgevkxgu" qp" Ocuu" Eqoowpkecvkqp" Jkuvqt{"*Jknnufcng."PL<"Ncytgpeg"Gtndcwo"Cuuqekcvgu."3;;3+."49408" Igqtig" G0" Oqyt{" cpf" Lwfuqp"C0" Itgpkgt" kp" Fcxkf" Itcjco" Rjknnkru."Vjg"Vtgcuqp"qh" vjg"Ugpcvg."Igqtig"G0"Oqyt{"cpf"Lwfuqp"C0"Itgpkgt."gf0"*Ejkeciq<"Swcftcping"Dqqmu."3;86+.";09" Kdkf0." 320" Hqt" c" fkuewuukqp" qh" vjg" owemtcmkpi" lqwtpcnkuvu" rtghgtgpeg"hqt" ocic¦kpgu" qxgt" pgyurcrgtu" hqt" vjgkt" yqtm." cpf" yj{" vjg{" dgnkgxgf"ocic¦kpgu" uwuvckpgf" vjg" oqxgogpv" yjgtg" pgyurcrgtu" eqwnf" pqv." ugg"Egegnkc" Vkejk."Gzrqufiu" cpf" Gzeguu<"Owemtcmkpi" kp" Cogtkec." 3;22/4222"*Rjkncfgnrjkc<"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Rgppu{nxcpkc"Rtguu."4226+0"Yjkng"kv"jcu"dggp"ctiwgf"vjcv"pgyurcrgtu."vqq."gpicigf"kp"owemtcmkpi"Î"wpfgt"vjg"pcog"qh"

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"";9"

kpxguvkicvkxg"tgrqtvkpi"qt"Pgy"Lqwtpcnkuo"*ektec"3::2+"Î"vjg"hcev"tgockpu"vjcv"vjg"vgto"ÐowemtcmkpiÑ"ku"cuuqekcvgf"cnoquv"gzenwukxgn{"ykvj"ocic¦kpg"lqwtpcnkuo"kp"vjg"nkvgtcvwtg0:" Ugg." hqt" kpuvcpeg."Okejcgn" Uejwfuqp."Fkueqxgtkpi" vjg" Pgyu<" C" Uqekcn"Jkuvqt{" qh" Cogtkecp" Pgyurcrgtu" *Pgy"[qtm<" Dcuke" Dqqmu." 3;9:+." 3::="Oktcnfk."Owemtcmgtu."zkk="Octkc"D0"Octtqp."ÐVjg"Hqwpfkpi"qh"Kpxguvkicvkxg"Tgrqtvgtu"cpf"Gfkvqtu."Kpe0"cpf"vjg"Ctk¦qpc"Rtqlgev<"Vjg"Oquv"UkipkÝecpv"Rquv/Ycvgticvg"Fgxgnqrogpv"kp"W0U0"Kpxguvkicvkxg"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo" 36." Ykpvgt" 3;;9." 78/790" Hqt" c" fkuewuukqp" qh" kpxguvkicvkxg"tgrqtvkpi"cu"c"ukipkÝecpv"ejcpig"kp"vygpvkgvj/egpvwt{"lqwtpcnkuo."ugg"Dknn"Mqxcej"cpf"Vqo"Tqugpuvgkn."Vjg"Gngogpvu"qh"Lqwtpcnkuo"*Pgy"[qtm<"Etqyp"Rwdnkujgtu."4223+."334/3360"Ugg"cnuq."Ngg"Ukignocp."ÐVjgtg"[qw"Iq"Cickp<"Vjg"Ogfkc" cpf" vjg"Fgxgnqrogpv" qh"Cogtkecp"Rqnkvkeu.Ñ"Eqoowpkecvkqp"Oqpqitcrju"72."Fgegodgt"3;;4."629/632="Dctdkg"¥gnk¦gt."ÐLqwtpcnkuvu"cu"Kpvgtrtgvkxg"Eqoowpkvkgu.Ñ"Etkvkecn" Uvwfkgu" kp"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp" 32."Ugrvgodgt" 3;;5." 43;/459=" Fcxkf"Ygcxgt" cpf" NgCppg" Fcpkgnu." ÐRwdnke"Qrkpkqp" qp" Kpxguvkicvkxg"Tgrqtvkpi" kp" vjg" 3;:2u.Ñ"Lqwtpcnkuo"Swctvgtn{"8;."Urtkpi"3;;4."368/3770;"Ogttkvv"cpf"Tqugp"ctg"eqpukfgtgf" vjg"hqwpfgtu"qh" vjg"rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuo"oqxgogpv0"Fcxku"Ogttkvv"cpf"Lc{"Tqugp."Kocikpkpi"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo<"Cp"Gfkvqt"cpf"Uejqnct"TgÞgev"qp"vjg"Dktvj"qh"cp"Kfgc0"Tq{"Jqyctf"Enctm"Rwdnke"Ngevwtg"kp"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp"Tgugctej"*Dnqqokpivqp."KP<"Kpfkcpc"Wpkxgtukv{"Uejqqn"qh"Lqwtpcnkuo."3;;7+."43032"Lc{"Tqugp."Eqoowpkv{"Eqppgevgfpguu<"Rcuuyqtfu"hqt"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"*Uv0"Rgvgtudwti."HN<"Vjg"Rq{pvgt"Kpuvkvwvg."3;;5+.";033"Kdkf0."7034"Fcxku"Ogttkvv."ÐOkuukpi"vjg"Rqkpv.Ñ"Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Tgxkgy"*Lwn{1Cwiwuv"3;;8+."52035"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Tqugp."Eqppgevkqpu036"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Unqcp."494037"Vjg"geqpqoke"rnkijv"qh" vjg"oqfgtp"rtguu" ku"ygnn/fqewogpvgf0"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Tqugp."Eqppgevkqpu."3;038" Yjgp" vjg" ikcpv" Icppgvv" Eq0" Kpe0" enckogf" vq" dg" rtcevkekpi" rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo" cv" kvu" oqtg" vjcp" ;2" fckn{" pgyurcrgtu." uqog" lqwtpcnkuvu" cpf"cecfgokekcpu" tglgevgf" vjg" kfgc."uggkpi"eqtrqtcvg"ugnh/kpvgtguv"cu"rqnnwvkpi"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuoÓu"jkijgt"ckou039"Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt.";03:"Uvghhgpu."Cwvqdkqitcrj{."57903;"Kdkf0."579042" Kfc"O0"Vctdgnn."Cnn" kp" vjg"Fc{Óu"Yqtm<"Cp"Cwvqdkqitcrj{" *Pgy"[qtm<"Oceoknncp."3;5;+."4;9043"Kdkf0."4;9/;:044"Nkpeqnp"Uvghhgpu."Vjg"Ngvvgtu"qh"Nkpeqnp"Uvghhgpu."Xqn0"3."gf0"Gnnc"Ykpvgt"cpf"Itcpxknng"Jkemu"*Pgy"[qtm<"Jcteqwtv."Dtceg."3;5:+."384045"Kdkf0."387046"Kdkf0."392047"Kdkf0."3930

;:""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

48"Kdkf0."445049"Uvghhgpu."Cwvqdkqitcrj{."5:704:"Uvghhgpu."Ngvvgtu."39304;"Kdkf0."3:2052"Kdkf0."3:4/:5053"Kdkf0."3:5054"Kdkf0."42;055"Kdkf0."463056"Kdkf0."444057"C"oclqt"hqewu"hqt"Uvghhgpu"ycu"Dquvqp."yjgtg"jg"urgpv"c"{gct"vt{kpi"vq"ceeqornkuj"tghqto0"Cwvqdkqitcrj{."834058"Nqwku"Hknngt."Vjg"Owemtcmgtu"*Uvcphqtf."EC<"Uvcphqtf"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;;5+."327059"Vctdgnn."45;05:"Kdkf0."36305;"Kdkf0."478/47;062"Kdkf0."428063"Kdkf0."4:3064"Kdkf0."4820"65"Hknngt."Owemtcmgtu."324066"Mqejgtudgtigt."87067"Vctdgnn."462068" Lwuvkp" Mcrncp."Nkpeqnp" Uvghhgpu<" C" Dkqitcrj{" *Pgy"[qtm<" Ukoqp" cpf"Uejwuvgt."3;96+."82."36:/75="Vctdgnn."463/64069"Vctdgnn."46406:"Kdkf0."45;06;"Kdkf0."463072"Kdkf0."4:2073"Kdkf0."464074"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Vctdgnn."529075"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Vctdgnn."49:076"Kdkf0."57."49;077"Kdkf0."495="4:2078"Kdkf0."4640"Gorjcuku"cffgf079"Kdkf0."49:07:"Kdkf0."4:407;"Kdkf0."472082"Kdkf0."48;083"Kdkf0."4720"Vctdgnn"uqwpfu"cnoquv"pc•xg"kp"ceegrvkpi"vjgug"tgcuuwtcpegu0"Qpg"okijv"yqpfgt"cv"vjg"vtwg"ÐkpfgrgpfgpegÑ"qh"vjgug"eqwpugnqtu"cpf"vjg"nkmgnkjqqf"qh"dwukpguuogp"cpf"ngikuncvqtu"uwiiguvkpi"cp{vjkpi"gnug"yjgp"kv"ecog"vq"chÝtokpi"vjg"rtgtqicvkxgu"qh"dki"dwukpguu084"Kdkf0."4;80"85"Kdkf0."4;4086"Kdkf0."4;6087"Gtke"O0"Gkugpdgti"cpf"J0N0"Iqqfcnn."Lt0"Qticpk¦cvkqpcn"Eqoowpkecvkqp<"Dcncpekpi"Etgcvkxkv{"cpf"Eqpuvtckpv"*Pgy"[qtm<"Uv0"OctvkpÓu"Rtguu."3;;5+0"""""""

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋"";;"

" " Gkugpdgti" cpf" Iqqfcnn" encko" vjcv" Vc{nqtÓu" uekgpvkÝe" rtkpekrngu" tguvgf"qp" vjg" cuuworvkqp" qh" Ðc" hwpfcogpvcn" fkuvkpevkqp" dgvyggp"ocpcigtu" cpf"gornq{ggu<"ocpcigtu"vjkpm."yqtmgtu"yqtm0Ñ88"Vkejk."8;089"Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt.";0"8:"Hknngt."46:08;"Oktcnfk."ÐRjknnkru.Ñ":5092"Jcttkuqp"cpf"Uvgkp.";093"Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt" *67+" kfgpvkh{" vjg"iwpocp"cu"Ðc"ogodgt"qh"cp"qnf"Ycujkpivqp" hcokn{."Hkv¦jwij"E0"Iqnfudqtqwij."yjq"okuvcmgpn{"dgnkgxgf"vjcv"Rjknnkru"jcf"dggp"rgtugewvkpi"IqnfudqtqwijÓu"ukuvgt"kp"jku"pqxgnu0Ñ94"Kp"Jcttkuqp"cpf"Uvgkp.":095"Kdkf096"Nqwku"Hknngt."Xqkeg"qh"vjg"Fgoqetce{"*Wpkxgtukv{"Rctm<"Rgppu{nxcpkc"Uvcvg"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;9:+."8097"Jcttkuqp"cpf"Uvgkp.":098"Oktcnfk."ÐRjknnkru.Ñ":9099"Hknngt."Vjg"Owemtcmgtu."475="Mcrncp."82."36:/375="Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt."438/44709:"Mcrncp."::09;"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt."580:2"Hknngt."Owemtcmgtu."475="Oqyt{"cpf"Itgpkgt."5:0"Unqcp"*494+"enckou"vjcv"owemtcmgtu"dtqwijv"vjgkt"qyp"fqyphcnn"dgecwug"Ðocp{"rqqtn{"tgugctejgf"ctvkengu" jcf" ocfg" tgcfgtu" swguvkqp" vjg" etgfkdknkv{" qh" vjg" owemtcmgtu0Ñ"Vjqtpvqp" cnuq" Ýpfu" gxkfgpeg" qh" Ðcp" kpvgpukÝecvkqp" qh" vjg" fkhhgtgpegu"kp" lqwtpcnkuvke" uvcpfctfu" dgvyggp" lqwtpcnkuvu" cpf" pqp/lqwtpcnkuvuÑ" kp" vjg"owemtcmkpi" fgecfg0" Dtkcp"Vjqtpvqp." ÐOwemtcmkpi" Lqwtpcnkuvu" cpf"Vjgkt"Tgcfgtu<"Rgtegrvkqpu"qh"Rtqhguukqpcnkuo.Ñ"Lqwtpcnkuo"Jkuvqt{"43"*Urtkpi"3;;7+<"5:0:3"Oktcnfk."ÐRjknnkru.Ñ":60:4"Hknngt."Xqkeg."80:5"Kdkf0."3490:6"Cdg"E0"Tcxkv¦."Fcxkf"Itcjco"Rjknnkru"*Pgy"[qtm<"Vyc{pg"Rwdnkujgtu."3;88+."750:7"Hknngt."Xqkeg."3:80:8" Vqo" Hkgnf." ÐKp" Rtckug" qh" Rwdnke" Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"Gfkvqt" (" Rwdnkujgt." 3:"Octej"3;;7."780:9"Pgkn"Rgkteg."ÐEkxke"Lqwtpcnkuo<"C"Pgy"Igptg.Ñ"Pcvkqpcn"Lqwtpcn."4"Lwn{"3;;6."37:70::"Gf"Hqwj{"cpf"Lcp"Uejchhgt."ÐEkxke"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï"Itqykpi"cpf"Gxqnxkpi.Ñ"Pkgocp"Tgrqtvu"6;"*Urtkpi"3;;7+<"38/3:0:;"Rjknkr"G0"Og{gt."ÐVjg"Ogfkc"Tghqtocvkqp<"Ikxkpi"vjg"Cigpfc"Dcem"vq"vjg"Rgqrng0Ñ"Vjg"Gngevkqpu"qh"3;;4."gf0"O0"Pgnuqp"*Ycujkpivqp."F0E0<"ES"Rtguu."3;;5+<"328/32:.";80;2"Nqw"Wtgpgem."ÐGzrgtv"Lqwtpcnkuo0"Rqtvncpf."Ockpg."Pgyurcrgt"Tghtcogu"vjg" Kfgc" qh" Qdlgevkxkv{" vq" Dtkpi" Tgcfgtu" Oqtg" Hqteghwn" Kpvgtrtgvkxg"Tgrqtvkpi.Ñ"Pkgocp"Tgrqtvu"6;"*Urtkpi"3;;7+<"8/330

87

322""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

;3" Ugg." hqt" kpuvcpeg." Gfyctf" F0" Oknngt." Vjg" Ejctnqvvg" Rtqlgev<" Jgnrkpi"Ekvk¦gpu"Vcmg"Dcem"Fgoqetce{"*Uv0"Rgvgtudwti."HN<"Vjg"Rq{pvgt"Kpuvkvwvg."3;;6+0" Kp" Pqtvj" Ectqnkpc" kp" 3;;8." c" eqpuqtvkwo" qh" pgyurcrgtu" cpf"dtqcfecuv" uvcvkqpu"ycu" hqtogf" wpfgt" Rq{pvgt" Kpuvkvwvg" iwkfcpeg" vq" gnkekv"ekvk¦gpuÓ" eqpegtpu" cpf" ikxg" vjgo" rtkoce{" kp" ecorckip" eqxgtcig0" Uvgxg"Tkng{."ÐRqnkvkecn"Eqxgtcig"vq"Hqewu"qp"Xqvgtu0"P(Q"Lqkpu"Vgco"Ghhqtv"hqt"Ò;8"Tcegu.Ñ"Pgyu"("Qdugtxgt."Tcngkij."PE."49"Fgegodgt"3;;7.""r0"3*C+="Lcogu"Dgppgvv."ÐPqtvj"Ectqnkpc"Ogfkc"Vt{"vq"Ngcf"Rqnkvkeu"vq"Kuuwgu.Ñ"Pgy"[qtm"Vkogu."46"Ugrvgodgt"3;;8."r0"3*C+0;4"Ugg."hqt"kpuvcpeg."Htcpm"Fgpvqp"cpf"Guvjgt"Vjqtuqp."Ekxke"Lqwtpcnkuo<"Fqgu"Kv"YqtmA"*Ycujkpivqp."FE<"Rgy"Egpvgt"hqt"Ekxke"Lqwtpcnkuo."3;;7+="Oknngt."Ejctnqvvg"Rtqlgev0;5"Rgy"Rtqlgevu." ÐTgfkuvtkevkpi"Icog."Tqejguvgt."P["4223.Ñ"jvvr<11yyy0rgyegpvgt0qti1rtqlgev1igvRtqlgev0rjrA{gct?42240" Ceeguugf" qp" 36" Lwn{"42260;6"Ingpp"Vjqocu."ÐYjcv"Ecp"Eqorwvgt"Icogu"Vgcej"LqwtpcnkuvuAÑ"*Ngevwtg."Cuuqekcvkqp"hqt"Gfwecvkqp"kp"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp"cppwcn"eqpxgpvkqp." Okcok." HN." Cwiwuv" :." 4224+." jvvr<11yyy0rgyegpvgt0qti1fqkpiel1urggejgu1uacgloeingppvjqocu0jvon0"Ceeguugf"qp"36"Lwn{"42260;7"Lcogu"M0"Dcvvgp"Cyctfu."ÐPgy"Jcorujktg"Rwdnke"Tcfkq"ÒVcz"Ejcnngpig.ÓÑ"jvvr<11yyy0rgyegpvgt0qti1dcvvgp1PJRT0jvon0"Ceeguugf"qp"36"Lwn{"42260;8"Fcxku"Ogttkvv."ÐOkuukpi"vjg"Rqkpv.Ñ"Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Tgxkgy."Lwn{/Cwiwuv"3;;8."520;9"Lc{"Tqugp."ÐVjg"Cevkqp"qh"vjg"Kfgc<"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"Kp"Dwknv"Hqto.Ñ"kp"Incuugt."43/6:."430;:"Lcp"Uejchhgt."ÐEkxke"Lqwtpcnkuo<"C"Fgecfg"qh"Ekxke"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"*Ngevwtg."Uqekgv{" qh" Rtqhguukqpcn" Lqwtpcnkuvu" Pcvkqpcn" Eqpxgpvkqp." Hqtvj" Yqtvj."VZ." Ugrvgodgt" 35." 4224+." jvvr<11yyy0rgyegpvgt0qti1fqkpiel1urggejgu1uaurljgcfnkpg0jvon0"Ceeguugf"36"Lwn{"42260;;"Lc{"Tqugp."kp"Fcxku"Ogttkvv"cpf"Lc{"Tqugp."ÐKocikpkpi"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"kp"Ncodgvj."Og{gt."cpf"Vjqtuqp."58/78."680322"Tkem"Vjcogu."ÐRwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"vjg"3;;4"Gngevkqpu.Ñ"kp"Ncodgvj."Og{gt."cpf"Vjqtuqp."333/44323"Vjcogu."3380324"Vjcogu."3430325" Rgy" Rtqlgevu." ÐVcmg" Dcem" Qwt" Pgkijdqtjqqfu1Ectqnkpc" Etkog"Uqnwvkqpu.Ñ" Rgy" Egpvgt" hqt" Ekxke" Lqwtpcnkuo." jvvr<11yyy0rgyegpvgt0qti1rtqlgev1igvRtqlgev0rjrAuvcvg?PE"Ceeguugf"qp"35"Lwn{"35."42260326"Kdkf0327"Lc{"Tqugp."ÐDg{qpf"Qdlgevkxkv{.Ñ"Pkgocp"Tgrqtvu."69."Ykpvgt"3;;5."6:/750328"Lcogu"Y0"Ectg{."ÐKp"Fghgpug"qh"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"kp"Incuugt."770329"Rcvtkem"H0"Rcngtoq."Nkpeqnp"Uvghhgpu"*Dquvqp<"Vyc{pg"Rwdnkujgtu."3;9:+."96032:"Ogttkvv."Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo."8032;"Ejctkv{."3;0"Gorjcuku"kp"qtkikpcn0332"Ectg{."770

Ï"Uwoogt"4227""̋""323"

333"Ejctkv{."70334"Mcrncp."33;0335"Unqcp."4930336" Ktqpkecnn{." kv" jcu" dggp" uwiiguvgf" vjcv" vjg" owemtcmgtuÓ" jctf/jkvvkpi"gzrquwtg" qh" uqekgvcn" knnu" rtqoqvgf" ekvk¦gp" fkuknnwukqp" cpf" fkugpicigogpv"htqo" vjg" rqnkvkecn" rtqeguu0" Ugg" Vjqocu" Ngqpctf." ÐFkf" vjg" Owemtcmgtu"Owem"Wr"RtqitguuA.Ñ" kp"Oktcnfk."Owemtcmgtu." 353/770"Rwdnke" lqwtpcnkuvu"jcxg" ngxgngf" c" ukoknct" ejctig" cv" vtcfkvkqpcn" lqwtpcnkuvu" qh" vjg" vygpvkgvj"egpvwt{0337" Yknn" Ktykp." ÐVjg" Cogtkecp" Pgyurcrgt.Ñ" tgrtkpvgf" kp" Vjg" Cogtkecp"Pgyurcrgt"*Cogu<"Kqyc"Uvcvg"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."3;8;+."90338"Kdkf0.":0339"Kdkf033:"Oktcnfk."Owemtcmgtu."zkkk033;" Hqt" cp" qrrqukpi" xkgy." ugg" Tqdgtv" Y0" OeEjgupg{" cpf" Dgp" Ueqvv."kpvtqfwevkqp"vq"Vjg"Dtcuu"Ejgem<"C"Uvwf{"qh"Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo."d{"Wrvqp"Ukpenckt" *Nqpi"Dgcej."EC<"Ukpenckt."3;49.";vj"gf0.="Wtdcpc<"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Knnkpqku"Rtguu+0"Ecnnkpi"vjg"vwtp/qh/vjg/egpvwt{"rgtkqf"Ðvjg"Iqnfgp"Cig"qh"rtguu"etkvkekuo.Ñ" vjg{"ctiwg" vjcv" Ðpgxgt"dghqtg"cpf"pgxgt" ukpeg"jcu"rtguu"etkvkekuo" dggp" uwej" c" ukipkÝecpv" rncpm" kp" vjg" rncvhqto" qh" vjg" gpvktg" nghv"ykpi"qh"vjg"rqnkvkecn"urgevtwo0"È"Dgvyggp"3;22"cpf"3;42."jwpftgfu"wrqp"jwpftgfu"qh"etkvkecn"ctvkengu"ygtg"rtkpvgf"kp"vjg"rqrwnct"rtguu."htqo"uqekcnkuv"pgyurcrgtu"vq"ocuu"ektewncvkqp"ocic¦kpgu.Ñ"zz0342"Kp"3;;9."vjg"Cogtkecp"Uqekgv{"qh"Pgyurcrgt"Gfkvqtu"dgicp"c"eqpvkpwkpi"gzcokpcvkqp"qh"vjg"nqy"uvcvg"qh"pgyurcrgt"etgfkdknkv{"cpf"jqy"pgyurcrgtu"eqwnf" kpetgcug" vjgkt" uvcpfkpi" coqpi" tgcfgtu0" Ugg" Ejtkuvkpg" Fwtdcp."Gzcokpkpi" Qwt" Etgfkdknkv{<" Rgturgevkxgu" qh" vjg" Rwdnke" cpf" vjg" Rtguu"*Tguvqp."XC<"Cogtkecp"Uqekgv{"qh"Pgyurcrgt"Gfkvqtu."3;;;+0"Fgurkvg"owej"ghhqtv" ukpeg"3;;9."pgyurcrgt"etgfkdknkv{" tgockpu"fgekfgfn{" nqy0"Ugg"Rgy"Tgugctej"Egpvgt" hqt" vjg"Rgqrng" cpf" vjg"Rtguu." ÐPgyu"OgfkcÓu" Kortqxgf"Kocig" Rtqxgu" Ujqtv/Nkxgf.Ñ" jvvr<11rgqrng/rtguu0qti1tgrqtvu1fkurnc{0rjr5ATgrqtvKF?37;"Ceeguugf"qp"34"Lwn{"42260343"Pcvkqpcn"fcvc"ujqy"vjg"cxgtcig"yggmfc{"tgcfgtujkr"qh"fckn{"pgyurcrgtu"fgenkpgf" htqo" 7:08" rgtegpv" qh" vjg" Wpkvgf" Uvcvgu" rqrwncvkqp" kp" 3;;:" vq"7706"rgtegpv"kp"42240"Pcvkqpcn"Pgyurcrgt"Cuuqekcvkqp"ÐFckn{"Pgyurcrgt"Tgcfgtujkr"Vtgpfu.Ñ"jvvr<11yyy0pcc0qti1ctvrcig0ehoACKF?3836(UKF?97"ceeguugf"qp"34"Lwn{"42260"Vjku"fgenkpg"eqpvkpwgu"c"vtgpf"vjcv"jcu"gzkuvgf"Ðhqt"cv"ngcuv"vyq"igpgtcvkqpu0Ñ"Rtqlgev"hqt"Gzegnngpeg"kp"Lqwtpcnkuo."ÐVjg"Uvcvg"qh"vjg"Pgyu"Ogfkc"4226.Ñ"jvvr<11yyy0uvcvgqhvjgogfkc0qti1pcttcvkxgapgyurcrgtuakpvtq0curAogfkc?4"ceeguugf"qp"34"Lwn{"42260344"Tqugp."Eqppgevkqpu."30345" Gxgp" cu" ektewncvkqp" uggogf" vq" dg" dqqokpi" dwv" cp" gzwdgtcpv" gtc" qh"eqtrqtcvg"itqyvj."vjgtg"ycu"itqykpi"rtguuwtg"qp"uocnn."eqoowpkv{"rcrgtu."cpf" lqwtpcnkuvuÓ" ogoqktu" qh" vjg" fc{" uqogvkogu" ogpvkqpgf" vjku" cpf" vjg"fgenkpg"kp"vjg"vqvcn"pwodgt"qh"pgyurcrgtu0"Ugxgtcn"ctvkengu"kp"vjg"Cvncpvke"Oqpvjn{"kp"vjg"Ýtuv"vyq"fgecfgu"qh"vjg"vygpvkgvj"egpvwt{"rqkpvgf"vq"eqpegtpu"qh"fgenkpkpi"rtguu"kpÞwgpeg0"Htcpeku"G0"Ngwrr."ÐVjg"Ycpkpi"Rqygt"qh"vjg"

324""̋""Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"Ï

Rtguu.Ñ" kp"Yknnctf" Itquxgpqt" Dng{gt." gf0." Vjg" Rtqhguukqp" qh" Lqwtpcnkuo"*Dquvqp<"Cvncpvke"Oqpvjn{" Rtguu." 3;3:+." 52/730" Kp" jku" ctvkeng." rwdnkujgf"kp" vjg"ocic¦kpg" kp"Hgdtwct{"3;32."Ngwrr"pqvgf"c" nquu"qh"rtguu" kpÞwgpeg"dgecwug"qh"vjg"korgtuqpcn"pcvwtg"qh"pgyurcrgtu"vjcv"uqwijv"nctig"cwfkgpegu"kp"nctig"octmgvu"cpf"lqwtpcnkuo"vjcv"ucetkÝegf"nqecn"fgvckn"hqt"eqxgtcig"qh"uq/ecnngf"nctigt."igpgtcn"kuuwgu0"Kp"cpqvjgt"Cvncpvke"ctvkeng."Quycnf"Icttkuqp"Xknnctf" pqvgf" kp" Lcpwct{" 3;3:" c" fgenkpg" kp" vjg" pwodgt" qh" pgyurcrgtu"dgecwug" qh" vjg" geqpqokeu" qh" rwdnkujkpi" qt" uvctvkpi" qpg." rctvkewnctn{" kp"wtdcp" ctgcu." cpf" dgecwug" qh" vjg" dgikppkpi" qh" rtguu" eqpuqnkfcvkqp" wpfgt"nctig" pgyurcrgt" eqtrqtcvkqpu0" Xknnctf." ÐRtguu" Vgpfgpekgu" cpf" Fcpigtu.Ñ"*kdkf0."42/4;+0"Vjg"Cogtkecp"Pgyurcrgt"Rwdnkujgtu"Cuuqekcvkqp."hqtogf"kp"3::9."hqwpf"kvu"ogodgtu"wpfgt"rtguuwtg"htqo"oqtg/rqygthwn"iqxgtpogpv"wpfgt" vjg" cfokpkuvtcvkqpu" qh" Vjgqfqtg" Tqqugxgnv" cpf"Yqqftqy"Yknuqp"Ðcpf"pggfgf"c"xqkeg"yjkej"eqwnf"urgcm" kp"eqorgvkvkqp"ykvj"qvjgt"xqkegu"kp"rqnkvkecn"cpf"geqpqoke"eqpvguvu0Ñ"Gfykp"Gogt{."Jkuvqt{"qh"vjg"Cogtkecp"Pgyurcrgt"Rwdnkujgtu"Cuuqekcvkqp"*Okppgcrqnku<"Wpkxgtukv{"qh"Okppgcrqnku"Rtguu." 3;72=" Yguvrqtv." EV<" Itggpyqqf" Rtguu." 3;92+." 760" Ekvcvkqp" ku" vq"vjg"Itggpyqqf"gfkvkqp0"Jkuvqtkcp"Fqwincu"Dktmjgcf"pqvgu" vjcv"Ðvjg"rtguu"gpvgtgf"vjg"vygpvkgvj"egpvwt{"qp"vjg"xgtig"qh"eqtrqtcvg"qnkiqrqn{."ocnkipgf"cu"owej"cu"cp{"qvjgt"kpfwuvt{"kp"vjg"eqwpvt{0"Eqorgvkvkqp"hqt"pgyurcrgt"ektewncvkqp"urcypgf"vjg"ugpucvkqpcnkuvke"Ò{gnnqy"lqwtpcnkuoÓ"qh"vjg"3:;2u."gxqmkpi" xktwngpv" rwdnke" etkvkekuo0" È" Rtqitguukxg" ngikuncvkqp" tgiwncvkpi"dwukpguu"rtcevkegu"ycu"fktgevgf"cv"vjg"rtguu"kvugnh"kp"3;34."rtqjkdkvkpi"jkffgp"qypgtujkr."fkuiwkugf"cfxgtvkukpi."cpf"hcnukÝgf"ektewncvkqp"enckou0Ñ"Dktmjgcf"ÐVjg"Rtqitguukxg"Tghqto"qh"Lqwtpcnkuo<"Vjg"Tkug"qh"Rtqhguukqpcnkuo"kp"vjg"Rtguu.Ñ" kp"gf0"L0"Okejcgn"Jqicp."Tjgvqtke"cpf"Tghqto"kp" vjg"Rtqitguukxg"Gtc."xqn0"8"qh"C"Tjgvqtkecn"Jkuvqt{"qh"vjg"Wpkvgf"Uvcvgu<"UkipkÝecpv"Oqogpvu"kp"Cogtkecp"Rwdnke"Fkueqwtug" *Gcuv" Ncpukpi<"Okejkicp" Uvcvg"Wpkxgtukv{"Rtguu."4225+."3350"Dng{gt"cnuq"rqkpvu"vq"Ðc"itgcv"kpetgcugÑ"kp"eqpvgpv"vjcv"ycu"Ðrwdnkekv{"cpf"rtqrcicpfc"kp"vjg"iwkug"qh"pgyuÑ"uwrrnkgf"d{"vjg"godt{qpke"rwdnke"tgncvkqpu"kpfwuvt{"cpf"vjg"fknwvkqp"qh"c"pgwvtcn"gfkvqtkcn"xqkeg0"Dng{gt."Ockp"Ewttgpvu"kp"vjg"Jkuvqt{"qh"Cogtkecp"Lqwtpcnkuo"*Dquvqp<"Jqwijvqp"OkhÞkp."3;49+."642."6430346"Jcppq"Jctfv."ÐTgkpxgpvkpi"vjg"Rtguu"hqt"vjg"Cig"qh"Eqoogtekcn"Crrgcnu<"Ytkvkpiu"qp"cpf"cdqwv"Rwdnke"Lqwtpcnkuo.Ñ"kp"Incuugt."4240347"Yjgp"cumgf."Ogttkvv"cpf"Tqugp"jcxg"kpukuvgf"vjcv"rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuo"ku"pqv"cp"cnvgtpcvkxg"vq"kpxguvkicvkxg"lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"vjcv"dqvj"hqtou"qh"eqxgtcig"ecp"dg"wpfgtvcmgp"cv"vjg"ucog"pgyurcrgt0"Rwdnke"lqwtpcnkuoÓu"hqewu."jqygxgt."vq"dtkpi"rgqrng"vqigvjgt"kp"tcvkqpcn"fkueqwtug"vq"gzejcpig"kfgcu"cpf"tgcej"kphqtogf"fgekukqpu"cpf"yqtm"vqigvjgt"qp"ekxke"kuuwgu0348"Tqugp"urqmg"cv"vjg"Rgy"EgpvgtÓu"Lcogu"M0"Dcvvgp"Cyctfu"cpf"U{orqukwo"hqt"Gzegnngpeg"kp"Ekxke"Lqwtpcnkuo"cv"vjg"Uejqqn"qh"Lqwtpcnkuo"cpf"Ocuu"Eqoowpkecvkqp." Wpkxgtukv{" qh" Pqtvj" Ectqnkpc" cv" Ejcrgn" Jknn." 44"Crtkn"42240

muckrakers then and now

Documents