mkultra research on human subjects

Upload: mary-eng

Post on 03-Apr-2018

232 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    1/49

    !"#$%%&'(

    )*+!'

    ,*+

    #$%%&!"

    -

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    2/49

    .

    /

    01234

    )524

    *64

    34

    342

    344

    34

    24

    346

    3

    $

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    3/49

    .','"'7'0

    5#5!'**''*.

    #*('#--*8"

    +7'*'1'

    4

    *'0

    '

    6666

    629!"

    4'

    /'/5

    6-:;&*'

    *2*/.?@

    78

    8'

    '.

    2

    4!=1.4'

    A

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    4/49

    582

    4'

    .

    2'*/.B

    44

    '

    4

    5

    '5665

    '5

    '5

    4

    '2

    26

    '64B

    54'.2

    452

    '.-::C?

    .25@

    '/4

    '/62

    ''4'!

    '2

    2'

    C

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    5/49

    24'.

    5

    '024

    46

    '*/.4

    -:&%6-:D%64

    42'

    !44

    4

    2',4242

    4

    5'4

    '

    442

    4'

    24'

    4

    '-44

    ',44

    5

    42'

    &

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    6/49

    #445++//

    2)*/.45

    E6E4

    E

    4'

    4

    E

    '

    52

    44

    2

    '.)4

    E4

    2E6*

    2E

    E

    '*/.4

    44'

    242

    5

    '.

    E5

    '

    2

    4'44

    F

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    7/49

    *62

    '424

    4

    2-::%6$%%&

    4'

    45

    '

    '

    !

    "#

    */.44

    -:D%'*4

    */.G!=1.4'.-:DD

    !"#$%#&'$(!

    7/?

    '@$-:D;&

    )*+!,((

    $-:;-'A#

    44

    2-:DF70

    3+703+(1C&*#1CF(02

    2*/.'C.

    !$F-:DD*/.-.+$

    )?-%$.-:CD34H--:%&

    */7

    D

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    8/49

    2*

    /.'@

    34)

    III45I

    5

    5'#*

    4

    '&

    4'+

    '34

    )

    8'*

    4

    4G'.

    24

    '/

    45

    '1

    4

    82G'F

    -:DD!"#$44*

    2'=)

    /

    58

    '42

    *02,,

    ;

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    9/49

    12'

    203+

    7H7*/.''''*/.-:D&

    '/

    44'D

    =B#B4

    =B

    5'?/4

    8

    5

    '@;

    *4!=1.

    6*/.5

    */.'34

    2''*)

    #.88

    B(#.B

    3.B

    ':.-:FA*/.B!=1.

    5'?

    '''''.82'@-%.

    4*/.?8

    */.5''''/

    */.*.

    HH+0'@--

    :

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    10/49

    .4*/.

    4$%%$!)

    *7+0

    #5HB'

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    11/49

    '''

    224'/

    2

    2'@-C

    .$*

    4)

    /2

    ''''

    .*2

    2

    '.*

    2

    '/4

    2'34

    '

    2

    2

    '-&

    .-::&.$*'

    #4'.

    -::D*!.+

    --

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    12/49

    $

    4'-F77

    '-D)?.

    '''2''

    ''.-'''

    '@-;')?,

    '''

    '''@-:.4

    '/5'

    ..$*4

    4

    2'8863+

    -::C$#'.

    .3*.3*(.

    2-:C&-:CD4'$%0

    44-::%'$-/-:::5

    )&!*/0+

    .$*?5

    '@$$+44

    5'.4+B5

    )

    !B

    '2

    442

    -$

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    13/49

    '''

    ''''.4

    '''

    '

    ""*-:C&

    '?.@6'''

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    14/49

    ?4

    255

    ''(',

    2

    '$C

    !

    4'

    +

    2'64B

    542

    4'

    *1-::C

    0.+*/4

    5

    4'6

    E

    2)

    /4.

    J+/5

    -:C%-:C&-:C&

    2'/

    4

    25''''/

    '+

    4J05

    J+BJ+

    -C

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    15/49

    4J+

    4J'''.5

    /55'$&

    64

    +'04

    ?@

    '*

    4B'

    .$%%$$#124)

    I/G

    I7'

    !*,3

    K''''!7,

    '!77

    */.5400'$F

    /-:::34#5$4,*/

    .!2)

    ++//

    4

    '454

    '.

    4'/

    -&

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    16/49

    '$D

    7'!B

    4)

    /4

    2'

    ,

    5

    '.4

    )

    '3G

    8'$;

    /$%%&40'+.5

    )?./'''

    ''''L."5)

    +55'@.5

    ?@I

    4'@$:

    !)4

    24'

    4+B

    85'4

    2

    2'.$%%&0'4

    '

    -F

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    17/49

    #"

    46

    ',4

    GGGG'

    G'A%

    .$%%&34#54

    )

    1*7

    7

    *

    ''''5

    56

    '

    I6

    2

    'II/I

    'A-

    .44

    2

    '*4J

    -D

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    18/49

    !.#.

    258'A$

    6'B

    5

    4'

    "$"%"#

    &

    *?

    4'@AA/?

    '@AC,"+

    *'4

    4".4)

    ?3*5

    '+

    '

    4

    ''''5

    554'A&

    *B7B-:CD'

    "

    48

    ++//'24

    *'2

    'AF

    *

    4'I*1I

    -;

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    19/49

    4

    42'AD+

    *?

    '@A;

    *

    '.D/**

    1?2

    4'@A:!4*

    '!'*,

    4?

    '@C%C-,

    *',

    4'C$,

    .

    */-:;%'CA02

    .*/-:::

    5'CC

    ,

    4'

    /56*8

    1M

    4'B

    *01'/

    5'C&

    ,4

    ',B

    -:

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    20/49

    654

    'CF

    .4*

    -:&%F%)

    4*/..27

    4.244

    28

    '15*

    -:&%'CD

    *?+!@

    7*3'+#$F-:&A'C;.#!

    *4

    ?'@C:,

    !54

    -:F%4

    '&%/-:D;*

    02,,1

    '&-!?

    '@&$

    ##

    4'

    701*

    4'.6

    44

    /**1/**1('

    $%

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    21/49

    4'-::C

    .D/**1

    )?.D4

    MB

    #39#.*

    '@&A)

    !34'4

    '#.

    88B(

    #.B

    3.B

    '@&C

    -::C

    4/**1*.

    *.(4'&&

    54

    ''4'

    4-::;#

    +H8.'4

    4/**1*.'

    .D/**1?

    24'@

    *..-

    '05

    4

    5

    $-

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    22/49

    *.?

    @*.'

    48++//

    25

    62

    '

    *.52

    6

    '

    2

    '/5

    4(

    *.'/**1

    54

    22

    .-*.'@&F

    #

    "2

    44'

    ?5

    4'@&D.'0

    24

    *4

    '&;/

    $$

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    23/49

    '&:

    ./*'4

    22

    4'

    '

    'F%

    *

    4'

    B

    *'!'F-

    04'

    4

    )'

    H-:;D*'F$

    4'

    '?

    24*'@FA

    7B

    7'?

    '@FC0'?2

    #*.

    6'@F&

    *'&6CB

    '

    $A

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    24/49

    2

    2?@

    )'FF

    /HB**E

    ??

    @?

    '@'''2

    54

    ''''2'''

    'FD

    HB*B48

    +

    +//*'

    38,0,?

    2

    .**-:&%'@F;.,

    ND%$%CC2!-:;D'/-:;;*/.

    4*ND&%%%%*/.

    'F:

    $'-::&

    -:F%4

    *77',5B

    *?*?

    @?'@D%,5-:&A+

    !4?*'@D-

    $C

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    25/49

    B?

    @B

    '.

    'D$

    4'/6!=1.*/.

    4'?/

    5*/.'''4

    2!=1.6

    N-&%%%'@DA?4@?2

    45@

    4'DC

    '54

    ?'''

    '15

    E

    '@D&

    1#*.$;''*'$FDC(

    '"

    ?B

    2'@DF#

    4B?

    884'@DD

    24

    )7'.

    52*

    '

    $&

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    26/49

    E4'D;

    24522

    4

    '

    #%

    )?

    G

    44

    '@D:44

    44

    */.!=1.4-:&%6D%

    11G-:;-43H(-$AAA';%4

    4'3H-$AAA*

    #1*#1(C&*#1CF

    24'/-::-

    */.4

    4'3H-$AAA?$'-%034'

    /*

    24700

    '2G

    '@;-

    /

    2

    -:DC';$*#1CFCF'-%-('

    *#14

    'CF'-%-()?

    $F

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    27/49

    7.

    '''@

    52

    7.'

    #48

    *E4

    4'/-::A4'

    42'I

    +'I;A*

    .*0135'.*013

    -:&%*'#

    4.*013?.3*.3

    *(

    2'@;C

    -:&%*4

    77'5*

    ?2

    '@;&.*013

    7+B-:&A2'

    *

    ';F

    .$*)$I

    E

    2'I;D*

    .*013-::D

    77'70

    000(*/.

    $D

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    28/49

    004

    34H-$AAA';;

    4

    5'56

    65'5

    '5

    +

    22

    .22

    '

    54?2

    '@;:.$%%A

    0$"')#('+&

    (5+*.&.104)

    ,G.*8

    A%%,*'

    '*IGG

    'I:%

    *B4

    '.44

    4'A%-:::*'..*013

    '

    .48II

    '*4

    $;

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    29/49

    77

    ':-

    .'**,

    )

    ?5

    (

    ''''

    B5

    B'?'''

    B4

    4':$

    '*B

    45

    4)

    24

    'H4

    ''''4

    II

    '

    5

    ':A

    $:

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    30/49

    .54)

    2'.-::C(

    4)

    !

    ',4

    5''

    =4

    +L5'*'3!5

    !

    4-:;F'.!5

    37

    ',5

    08HGG'/

    ':C

    1

    4-:;F*

    4-::%8

    4':&,*B

    424

    44

    '*

    -::D.+$

    54

    2'

    #"#

    A%

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    31/49

    .

    44

    '

    **86-:D%

    *

    5

    ''''/

    '*

    5

    '/4

    8

    5

    ':F

    94

    24'

    !=1.-:D%4'

    *2

    '

    *

    54

    '#6&2/$7899?

    44

    05':DH-C%-

    -&%%%$%%%%%4'

    #)?-:;F

    !4

    A-

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    32/49

    FD4-:FD-:&;':;$*/

    788:?

    '@::,

    ?'@-%%

    .-::C(45

    5

    2)

    $*/788:;

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    33/49

    7'"?

    44'@-%A

    "54',

    74K

    .?2@'-%C

    77,?@

    '-%&4'

    *

    4'

    42'

    4'?4

    *G

    '@-%F

    ?.3-:&%#

    15*(4'''I

    4I#5I

    'I*'@-%D

    .2

    4'*/.

    4

    /6*)

    /

    /6*''''

    AA

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    34/49

    (''''

    +4

    ''''*4

    8

    '-%;

    .*0135

    ',

    .*013'.*013@

    4'@-%:.*013'.*013

    4'?+

    24

    27H7*/.'@--%,

    */.7H7B5

    '

    4*B-::D4

    *

    '4B

    4

    4'/

    44

    '

    18

    82'.

    '/$%%$(-+.4)

    I+/H!/!(8'

    AC

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    35/49

    '.2

    'I---(-+I/H!(

    *

    4'I--$

    .$%%&*1*1(?)

    .$+?*5*

    1B6

    62''''*

    *-::D'--A,.*

    -::&*

    $'.'--C?

    *

    -::&.*0134

    '@--&

    ,$%%-,.*$%%&*14'.

    $%%-,.*?.*013111@

    .*013B'--F

    .*013

    .*013'

    9

    5)

    *'

    8

    4)$%%-,.**E,.*5

    ?@

    4E,.*

    E,.**B-::D

    A&

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    36/49

    0027H7E.*013B

    E,.*

    .*013E,.*-::%

    4

    '

    #"HB-::D.$+

    788=G

    4'--D/

    ")

    2

    24'4

    ''''//

    '''

    '--;

    -%&")?.5

    N-%%%%A'

    7'@--:

    ?@'-$%.-::D34#

    4)

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    37/49

    I!5"G5',

    '-$-

    *77*4

    $%%%$%%$$%%A$%%C'-$$

    $%%%2B$%%%

    '

    .7"

    .!**81*1

    .7.I.$+

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    38/49

    $%%C!=B4

    $$>

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    39/49

    42

    )*2

    4'.4

    '**14

    22'-$F.54

    4'-$D.

    *

    1'4

    '.-::;(-+

    4)

    'IL

    26652I

    ".'''

    '7'=8L

    !

    )I/G'I-$;

    54

    4'

    '!=1.

    45

    '344

    '.24

    '

    2

    4

    A:

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    40/49

    2'.24

    44

    4'

    .

    '

    #$%

    *24

    4'

    !5*

    '

    H5

    2'.)4

    ''*

    /**1*.'

    5'

    44

    4'

    34B

    '

    24

    4

    '.

    '8'

    */.!=1.48

    4'

    ++//4',

    C%

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    41/49

    '/

    J'5

    '

    $%%C5*

    '0)

    066

    24

    '

    5

    6''''75

    2'.

    686'-$:

    ,'.

    4

    4'.6

    24

    4'-A%+

    4

    4'

    46

    '.4

    $%%-50),,+&$'

    "'.11,I

    4'@-A-

    C-

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    42/49

    4'

    2'.8

    =C'&'

    !)

    -'62

    '

    $''

    A''

    C'5

    ('-A$

    .54

    42

    '5

    464

    '-AA

    24

    4

    4',

    '

    :6--

    *',

    4

    5'

    C$

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    43/49

    -'=1'!04%*/$A6$C($%%-('?H

    5?

    @84'

    /3

    5''''6

    52

    *5'@

    $'!4,&'$(!(

    '+.$

    .$:&*'--:DD('

    A'.*0134.*013()$FDF-::&('

    C'34'H'--:%'1'K'C-'AC#-:-:DF'

    &'!A&'

    F'&:'

    D'*/C

    ;'!-F$'

    :'52$'

    $.$'

    $'?$@DA-::C('

    -%'.)!.$'01

    K'A'-6C&:-:;$('

    --''&:F-'

    -$'#'5&2.)!.;$%%$

    .-'

    -A'.*01334"#1.*

    0134--'

    -C'.*013;$;'

    -&'.*013;$:'

    -F'!.+$F$#'1'$FAF:

    -::D('

    -D'22$*,222.+

    *2521$A$-F'$!$&$%%$'

    -;'!'

    CA

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    44/49

    -:'!'

    $%'$#'.(+*'

    *'.$-%A*'$F-::C('

    $-'10$&'

    $$'3+#)%&!*/0C;D-:::('

    $A'C;C6C;&'

    $C'.*0134.*013($*

    !%$.$*/

    .!..!.(C%A.D-::FK'$DF'&'

    $&'0*.+*/.'('

    +5-5.$

    -%A*'--A6--C-::C('

    $F'0#**/%)4@167!A$%%$.-C'

    $D'7'!$4%*/.&-:::('

    $;'$;:'

    $:'+!'.5%2'!,',

    58A770-C$%%&('

    A%'+!'.5B,+$-$%%&'

    A-'7$+'#'*'5'L5

    $:$%%&'

    A$'*#*'%!$;-::D('.

    48

    8'46*/.

    +'/+

    55.'1'+*/.

    *.01.'A-::D)

    /5''

    .8

    *

    '''*

    )(#.(

    4(

    '

    AA'"'.!.'"#>2+'%

    .$'.*/$-::$('

    CC

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    45/49

    AC'"'.!'&(4%#+'

    *0KD)-D'$--::-('

    A&'CC'

    AF'+'%/>2,A$%%C('

    AD'37'+'$?$@$'%).$+%$

    )2$'.$,'#,$#

    %#+-

    '#5,2''#:;-::;('

    &F'5:A6C'

    &D'7,,5160-%$%%$(

    &;'7-%'

    &:'!-A;'

    F%'7$6A'

    F-'7F--CD'

    C&

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    46/49

    F$'C;A''FF:'*'-:;D('

    FA'."$-$'

    FC'.A;'

    F&'.A;'

    FF'C;A''FD;6F;CF;F'FD'.A:'

    F;'0*.+*/%.'('

    +-5.

    $-%A*'&C-::C('

    F:'.*013;C&'

    D%'!##%##02$

    #$&%$%%$('

    D-'$&-'

    D$'$;D6;;'DA',533'""#0*/''

    +1$C-::CA$'

    DC''

    D&'#.#!%*/',

    ,"HA%-:;;DD'

    DF',.'"(42CD:-:::('

    DD'0)+%2'>

    ,>''

    .,.!-::C&D'

    D;'7-CD'

    D:'!-F$'

    ;%'.*013F;:6F:%'

    ;-'34'H'-$AAA'$'-%.*/'

    ;$'.*013FDF'

    ;A'.2!52,6**'*-,.

    K'&%/$!-::C'

    ;C'"$20,($+7-&

    -::C-;.'

    ;&'!-FF6D'

    ;F'!$&D'

    ;D'.*013F;D'

    CF

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    47/49

    ;;'FF#1F-F%D6%A

    --A%'#*1(#02

    .)&*A%-EC$*$;:*#1*)C&*#1CF.)/

    G!!$D-::D

    #(02

    2'

    #)-(4

    2

    #E$(

    4

    2EA(

    EC(/1,(/1,

    '

    /#1%$9%%9%$

    ;:'!-;-'

    :%'*0'3'"')#(

    '+&++.&1,+

    17$$$%%A'-;'

    :-'046'+2'50

    $--:::.-'

    :$')%'''2'

    !+).$,+,

    6,$,-$C8?7888@

    :A!A&'

    :C'!52'

    :&'+CF:6D%'

    :F'!-F$'

    :D'5:D'

    :;':D'

    ::':D'

    -%%':D'

    -%-'0&D'

    -%$',5A$'

    -%A',5A$'

    -%C',5A$'

    CD

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    48/49

    -%&',5A$'

    -%F'!-DC'

    -%D'!-D$'

    -%;'!-D&6F'

    -%:'.*0134$.$*/H$--::C4.34H

    '-$;:-.$*/,-;-::C$

    (C('

    --%'.*013F;&'

    ---'!=.7''$.%

    !0#+##+2,"HC$%%$'

    --$'

    --A'37'+'$?$@$'%)

    .$+%$)2$'.$,

  • 7/29/2019 mkultra research on human subjects

    49/49

    -$&'385'3.+.#,5'.

    $%'+#*$./!

    K'-C-E/C.-D$%%C'

    -$F'.'.0&0'0'B$'*$

    *+*'*1K'-%A:%:'-$D'!-;-'

    -$;'='

    -$:'-D'

    -A%'!-&;6-F$'

    -A-'!'!0%,,+&'

    4,-:D$%%-('

    -A$''-:D'

    -AA'-:;'