Metal and NonmetalMetal and NonmetalFatal Accident ReviewFatal Accident Review

CY - 2009CY - 2009

Contractor Employees, 6

Mine Employees, 10

MNM Fatalities

Crushed Stone, 12%

Other*, 57%

Sand & Gravel, 31%

MNM Fatalities by Commodity

* Alumina, Cement, Clay, Gold, Lead/Zinc, Salt, Dimension Stone, Lime, Copper

Machinery, 25%

Fall of Roof, 6%

Electrical, 6%Falling

Material, 19%

Powered Haulage, 31%

Fall of Person, 13%

MNM Fatalities by Classification

1-5 Employees,

25%

6-10 Employees,

25%11-20

Employees, 6%

21-50 Employees,

6%

51-100 Employees,

6%

100+ Employees,

32%

MNM Fatalities by Mine Size

MNM Fatalities by Occupation

Delivery Person, 6%

Supervisor, 13%

Machinery/Plant

Operator, 6%

Repairman/Technician,

30%

Mobile Equipment Operator,

25%

Laborer/Utility, 20%

Other, 13%Production,

31%

Maintenance, 56%

MNM Fatalities by Activity

MNM Fatalities by Total ExperienceMNM Fatalities by Total Experience

30+ Years, 19%

0-1 Year, 19%

11-15 Years, 19%

2-5 Years, 25%

6-10 Years, 6%

16-30 Years, 12%

MNM Fatalities by Job ExperienceMNM Fatalities by Job Experience

2-5 Years, 25%

0-1 Years, 44%

10-15 Years, 6%

16-30 Years, 25%

51-60, 56%

25-40, 25%

41-50, 13%

60+, 6%

MNM Fatalities by Age

MNM Fatalities by Day of WeekMNM Fatalities by Day of Week

Friday , 6%

Thursday, 25%

Tuesday, 32%

Sunday, 6%Saturday,

31%

6-8 a.m, 6%8-10 a.m., 25%

12-3 p.m., 38%

3-4 p.m., 25%

9-10 p.m., 6%

MNM Fatalities by Hour of Day

Root CausesRoot Causes

No Risk Assessment ConductedNo Risk Assessment Conducted

Inadequate Policies, Procedures, ControlsInadequate Policies, Procedures, Controls

Did not use Personal Protective EquipmentDid not use Personal Protective Equipment

Lack of Pre-operation ChecksLack of Pre-operation Checks

Equipment not MaintainedEquipment not Maintained

Failure to Conduct ExaminationsFailure to Conduct Examinations

Training InadequateTraining Inadequate

55

47

30

42

26 27

35

26

33

23

16

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

MNM Fatalities – 1999-2009

ElectricalElectrical

YearYear ‘05 ‘05 ‘06 ‘06 ‘07 ‘07 ’08 ’08 ’09 ’09

FatalitiesFatalities 2 2 5 5 1 1 22 1 1

MCC fires / explosionsMCC fires / explosions

DeenergizeDeenergize

Lockout/TagoutLockout/Tagout

Power line clearancePower line clearance

Monitor ContractorsMonitor Contractors

Fall of Material Fall of Material

YearYear ‘05 ‘05 ‘06 ‘06 ‘07 ‘07 ‘08 ‘08 ’09 ’09 FatalitiesFatalities 33 6 6 2 2 3 3 3 3

Block equipment against motionBlock equipment against motionCover or secure openingsCover or secure openingsBarricade area below work Barricade area below work Avoid suspended loadsAvoid suspended loads

Fall of Roof or BackFall of Roof or Back

YearYear ‘05 ‘06 ‘05 ‘06 ‘07 ‘07 ‘08 ‘08 ’09 ’09

FatalitiesFatalities 0 0 0 0 3 3 3 3 1 1

Examine and test for loose groundExamine and test for loose ground

Design, install, and maintain a support Design, install, and maintain a support system to control the ground in places system to control the ground in places where persons work or travel in performing where persons work or travel in performing their assigned taskstheir assigned tasks

Slip / Fall of PersonSlip / Fall of Person

YearYear ‘05 ‘05 ‘06 ‘06 ‘07 ‘07 ‘08 ‘08 ’09 ’09

FatalitiesFatalities 33 3 3 6 6 4 4 2 2

Many serious fall injuriesMany serious fall injuries

Eliminate Hazards and use PPEEliminate Hazards and use PPE– Inadequate walkwaysInadequate walkways

and scaffoldsand scaffolds– Fall protection not usedFall protection not used

– Persons not anchoredPersons not anchored – Holes not covered or protectedHoles not covered or protected

Human ElementHuman Element

Safe Work Practices Safe Work Practices notnot Established or Followed– Established or Followed–

Hazards not eliminated Hazards not eliminated Fall protection not attachedFall protection not attachedSeat belt not wornSeat belt not wornNo barricades while working belowNo barricades while working belowWorking near an open hole Working near an open hole Circumvented a guardCircumvented a guard

SLAM Risks