kek activities on clic x-band accelerating structures tsinghua univ., march 24 t. higo (kek)

96
KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Upload: archibald-warren

Post on 20-Jan-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating

StructuresTsinghua Univ., March 24

T. Higo (KEK)

Page 2: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Contents • Basic idea behind KEK X-band R&D• History of X-band developments at KEK• Preparation of test structures• Test facilities• Test results of accelerating structures• Expansion of Nextef facility• Basic studies related to breakdown• Expansion of our collaboration

20100324 2CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 3: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Areas of concern for KEK X-band R&D

• LC before ITRP and extension to LC-related study with CLIC

• X-band Application• Basic technology for high energy

accelerator• Scientific understanding of processing

and breakdowns

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 3

Page 4: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

History of X-band developments at KEK

• Early 1990: High precision machining + diffusion bonding– Establishment of fabrication technology1.3m DS

• Late 1990: realized discharge problem– Reduce group velocity, shorter str.

• By 2004 ITRP: 60cm HDDS– Eacc established 50 ~ 65MV/m– HOM suppression:   HDDS   weak damping +

detuning• 2007~: CLICX-band & higher gradient

– collaboration   CERN+SLAC+KEK– 30 ㎝ TW acc structure

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 4

Page 5: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Relevant accelerator structures

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 5

Stage Unit JLC-X GLC CLIC-C CLIC-G

Year 1996 2004 2007 2010

ECM TeV 1 1 3 3

Structure Type DS HDDS CG / HDS HDS

Length m 1.3 0.6 0.2 0.3

Eacc MV/m 73 / 60 65 / 50 120 / 100 120 /100

PIN MW 130 57 65 64

<a / > 0.2~0.14 0.2 ~ 0.15 0.15~0.08 0.12~0.09

Vg/c % 10 ~ 2 4.5~0.8 2.4~0.7 1.7~0.8

T ℃ < 19 71 53

Page 6: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Some typical experiments in mind

• High gradient characteristics only reflects the material choice!?– After processing – After number of breakdowns– After saturation

• Is this true?– Not electric field but magnetic field is the key?– Surface treatment is not the issue?– Hard/soft may or may not be the issue?

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 6

Page 7: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Single-cell SW high gradient test at SLAC

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)7

The near perfect surface processing affected only the processing time. The second structure processed to maximum gradient in few minutes vs few hours for the normally processed structure.

ultra clean condition vs normal surface processing conditions.

But we are curious how the processing proceeds and how high we can obtain without serious damage.

Surface treatment is

not the issue??

Page 8: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Surface fields for 5 different single cell structures, shaped pulse (flat part: A5.65-T4.6-KEK-#1- 150 ns, A5.65-T4.6-Frascati-#2- 150 ns, A3.75-T2.6-Cu-SLAC-#1: 150 ns, A3.75-T1.66-Cu-KEK-

#1 200 ns, A2.75-T2.0-Cu-SLAC-#1 200 ns)

Maximum surface electric fields [MV/m]

Maximum surface magnetic fields [kA/m]V.A. Dolgashev, 16 December 2008

High vg

Low vg

Ts~Hs2

EaccFor the same BDR

Different shapeDifferent Eacc

butVery similar Hs

Mag

netic

fiel

d??

20100324 8CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 9: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

BDR Pulse Heating Dependence

20 40 60 80 10010

-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

Peak Pulse Heating at Last Cell (K)

BD

R (

1/p

uls

e/m

)

T18, 900 hrsTD18, 100MV/m@100ns, 870 hrsTD18, 100MV/m@150ns, 960 hrsTD18, 100MV/m@200ns, 750 hrsTD18, 115MV/m@150ns, 550 hrsTD18, 120MV/m@150ns, 570 hrsTD18,100MV/m@230ns, 700 hrs

100310, TD18_Disk_#3 Faya Wang, SLAC

Magnetic field??

20100324 9CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 10: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 10

Walter Wuensch, CLIC09

After saturation, or after

number of breakdowns,

surface property is lost

and totally determined by

the material?

Page 11: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

General idea behind our study• Take these experimental results in mind.• Before reaching this saturated regime, there should be a

place to play with the surface condition or crystal structure.

• Can we stay in this regime for high gradient?• How to proceed through this regime to saturation?• Inevitable to go beyond this regime for high gradient?• Want to study the performance from this view point.• Then we understand and conclude in which regime we

play for the linear collider.• One of the key issues for our studies is devoted to this

point, in addition to pursuing higher and higher gradient.

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 11

Page 12: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Preparation of accelerator structures

• Technology established as of GLC/NLC era– KEK precision machining of parts– SLAC assembly– Now further study is ongoing with SLAC and CERN to

improve in future

• Fabrication flow– Precision machining– Chemical polish– Diffusion bonding and brazing in hydrogen furnace– Baking in vacuum at 650C

20100324 12CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 13: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Fabrication of damped structures

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)13

KEK fabricated all parts. SLAC made assembly.

Page 14: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Vacuum Baking of T18_vg2.4_DISC

650° C

10 days

at SLAC

From Sami, Mar. 120100324 14CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U.

(Higo)

Page 15: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18 first pair #2(KEK) & #3(SLAC)

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)15

#3 being tested at SLAC NLCTA

#2 being tested at KEKNextef

Design = CLIC-C

Page 16: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Structure test philosophy• Evaluate at more than one laboratory

– Independent evaluation– Equivalent to “S0” idea for ILC– Obtain statistical info and cross checking

• Requirement for facility– Long-term operation – 100MW or more power for over 100MV/m level

• Actual facilities– SLAC NLCTA with pulse compression– KEK Nextef with two klystrons– CERN 12GHz being developed– The comparison of three independent studies is a healthy

condition, which should be kept.

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 16

Page 17: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 17

KT-1

Nextef

Now located at the J-Arc of the KEKB Injector

Test facilities of KEK

Page 18: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

KEK test facilities

• Nextef– Shield-A being used for structure tests– Shield-B being prepared for basic studies, taking

power from KT-1• KT-1

– One PPM klystron– High gradient study with narrow waveguide– High power study on components– Feed shield B

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 18

Page 19: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

KEK:   Nextef Configuration

KT-1X-band

KT-2

NextefX-band

A

B

20100324 19CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 20: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Nextef operation since 2007

20100324 20CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 21: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Nextef inside shield room

20100324 21CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 22: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Monitors and components in shield-A

20100324

GVGVPM PMAM

Sl i t

FC

E

E

I P

Louni nel oad

Otsukal oad

DC

I PH

VAC

I nsulVAC

I PDC H

H

Vari an  I P

187

KX03 425

FC

I P

Load

Vari anI P

Q-mass

WC WCFC

FC

VAC DC

230

FC-MidFC-UPFC-DN

Qmass

PMMirror + camera PM

AM

Quad

Camera

22CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 23: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

High gradient test of three structures

• Disk-based un-damped– T18_Disk    Oct. 2008~June 2009– 4000hr, 9 months

• Quad-based heavily damped– TD18_Quad_#5    Sep. 2009~Nov. 2009– 1000hr, 3 months

• Disk-based heavily damped– TD18_Disk_#2    Dec. 2009~– 1200hr, 4 month+

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 23

Page 24: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

T18_Disk_#2• Aim

– Electric gradient: possibility to realize 100MV/m within tolerable breakdown rate

• Design geometry– No damping slots– Big increase of gradient toward downstream– No big pulse heating temperature rise

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 24

Page 25: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

CLIC   Nominal: CLIC_G ( T24 being tested in

2010)

Grudiev, 2nd X-band structure WS at KEK, 2008

CLIC   Test: CLIC_C                    ( T18 tested)

Pulse temperature rise

20100324 25CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Pulse temperature rise

Accelerating field Accelerating field

Surface E fieldSurface E field

Page 26: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

T18_Disk #2(KEK)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000 3500 4000

MasterTable_Eacc_Trend till_090610

<Eacc> 51nsec Ushi<Eacc> 113ns Ushi<Eacc> 173n ushi<Eacc> 213n Ushi<Eacc> 253ns UshimotoEacc keep 253ns UshiEacc 51ns UshiEacc 113ns UshiEacc 173ns UshiEacc 213ns UshiEacc 253ns UshiEacc Usahimoto 2/21-3/23Eacc 252ns Usahi 4/1-4/7Eacc 252ns 4/7-14Eacc 312ns 4/14-16Eacc 412ns 4/23-27Eacc 331ns 4/28-5/1Eacc 252ns 5/1-11Eacc 412ns 5/11-6/10

Total BD<Eacc> MV/m Total# BD

RF-ON integrated (hr)

090610

20100324 26CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 27: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Establishment of experiments to quantitatively compare

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

80 85 90 95 100 105 110 115 120

Breakdown rate for 252ns and 412ns

BDR(ACC) 412nsBDR(ACC) 252nsBDR(ACC) 252ns

y = 2.3888e-18 * e (0.28603x) R= 0.97016

y = 1.815e-17 * e (0.24289x) R= 0.94792 BDR(ACC) [1/pulse/m]

Eacc [MV/m]

Roughly the same breakdown rates were observed for a pair of structures.Will pursue the same comparison again for the second pair.

95 100 105 110 11510

-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

Unloaded Gradient: MV/m

BK

D P

oss

ibili

ty: 1

/pu

lse

/m

BKD Possibility for 230ns

250hrs

500hrs

1400hrs

1200hrs

900hrs

C. Adolphsen, US-HG@ANL, 2009

27

# 2   KEK で試験#1  SLAC で試験

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 28: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Red real cell timing, blue linear cell timing, 205 ns data

5 10 150

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

Breakdown position

No

. of

sho

ts

Breakdown position for 205 ns dataSteffen 090227

Page 29: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Dark current evolution 252nsec

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

0.008 0.01 0.012 0.014 0.016 0.018

T18_#2 Dark Current evolution081128-081224-090224-090414-090515

I_UP/Eacc 2.5 (081128)

I_UP/Eacc 2.5 (081224)

FN FC-UP (253ns, 090225)

FN FC-UP (253ns, 090414)

I_UP/E^2.5 253ns 090515

y = 0.14557 * e (-653.42x) R= 0.99838

y = 0.074674 * e (-672.19x) R= 0.99772

FC-UP microA/(MV/m)

2.5

Eacc [MV/m]

beta=37

beta=36

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

0.008 0.01 0.012 0.014 0.016 0.018

T18_#2 Dark Current evolution081128-081224-090224-090414-090515

I_Mid/Eacc 2.5 (081128)

I_Mid/Eacc 2.5 (081224)

FN FC-Mid (253ns, 090225)

FN FC-Mid (253ns, 090414)

I_Mid/E^2.5 253ns 090515

y = 0.22345 * e (-596.01x) R= 0.99982

y = 0.1351 * e (-607.18x) R= 0.99854

FC-Mid microA/(MV/m)2.5

Eacc [MV/m]

beta=40

beta=39

Measured at RF ON 700 – 1200 – 2100 – 3000 – 3400 hoursDecreasing amount, no big change in shape nor slope (beta).

20100324 29CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 30: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Dark current spectra in June

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

0 5 10 15

T18_VG2.4_Disk #2Spectrum_vs_Width at 64MW

I_slit_peak [microA] 64MW, 252ns

I_slit_peak [microA] 113ns, 64MW

I_slit_peak [microA] 64MW, 331ns

I_slit peak [microA]

pc (MeV/c)

090618

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

1.4

0 5 10 15

T18_VG2.4_Disk #2Spectrum_vs_power at 252ns

I_slit_peak [microA] 64MW, 252ns

I_slit_peak [microA] 55MW, 252ns

I_slit_peak [microA] 70MW, 252ns

I_slit peak [microA]

pc (MeV/c)

090618Dependence on power Dependence on width

Actual field of analyzer magnet was checked. The formula used up to now pc[MeV/m] = 1.646 x I [A] = 8.23xRef. Volt. [V] was confirmed.

Two peaks appear and higher for higher momentum one. Less than ½ of full acceleration.Little exists below 2.5MeV/m.

20100324 30CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 31: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

View direction 45deg

View area 60deg

4.1mm

Focus within 5mm to infinity

20100324 31CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 32: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Optical inspection upstream and downstream

Insertion 82.7mmIris #1 at match cell

Insertion 98.0mmIris #2 at first regular cell

20100324 32CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

252.2mm Iris #19Down side iris of last regular cell

261.3mmLast regular cell iris #20

Page 33: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Optical inspection result and future

• No significant variation as cell position was observed– Though more breakdowns happened downstream

end estimated from RF pulse shape

• Need to inspect with better spacial resolution– Change to better bore scope or adjust focal plane?– Should be inspected by SEM

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 33

Page 34: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

As of completion, meas. By J. Lewandowski

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 34

[email protected]/cell at 22.3degC 11.4233MHz at 30C in VAC -0.7MHz than nominal

Page 35: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Bead pull amplitude plot 11422MHz after high gradient test

Input side Output side3520100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U.

(Higo)

Page 36: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Phase and frequency after high gradient test

Result at 11424MHz 120.5deg/cell

3620100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 37: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

RF change due to high gradient test

• RF evaluated after high gradient test for 4000 hours with 2500 breakdowns in 800M pulses.– Input matching was kept.– Output matching changed by =0.05 level.– Average frequency increased by 1.1+0.7=+1.8MHz.– Field ripple±4.4% appeared near output end.

• Above change in RF performance was observed.– Need to confirm carefully with SLAC data. – If this is due to the actual structure change, not

tolerable. Need the number of breakdowns be limited until reaching operation.

3720100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 38: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

T18_Disk summary• 100MV/m was proven to be feasible• Similar breakdown rate between SLAC and KEK• Breakdown rate decreased as processing proceed• Breakdown probability is higher in downstream cells• Dark current can be fit with modified FN formula• Dark current decreases as processing proceeds• No big change in field enhancement value• Dark current dominates in low energy region, from a

few down-stream cells• RF property seems changed due to the processing• Long-term operational stability should be proven

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 38

Page 39: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Quad_#5

• Aim– Study the structure split in longitudinal plane– Taste the one with 50 micron radius at the edge

• Design geometry– Large damping aperture– Big increase of gradient toward downstream– Big pulse heating temperature rise at the damping

port opening

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 39

Page 40: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

KEK’s version: 50 micron chamfer

Made of CuZr without heat treatment.

50 micron rounding: shape with angles and bumps.

Reference planes were formed by milling in a few micron level without re-chucking for shaping cells.

Assembly was done within ten micron level.

40CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 41: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Possible cause of high dark currentField enhancement due to round chamfer

• Simulation of field enhancement– 1.4 ~ 1.6 at radius– with gap<radius/5, step<radius/2.5

• Only a few tool passes – to shape 50 micron radius– with radius tool of 2mm

• If three passed tangential discontinuity by about 30 degree

• Can be relaxed by such as EP in future

20100324 41CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 42: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Detailed shape at R0.05 chamfer

Cell #9

Cell #10

Cell #11

Only 2~3 tool passes over R0.05 90deg rounding.

Not tangential connection from smooth surface.30-40 degree edge emerges.

Sharp edges or bumps exist at the rim.

42CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 43: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Electric field enhancement in a shallow channel with round chamfer

Gap (micron) Bump (micron) Emax / Enominal

0 0 1.39

0 20 1.57

10 20 1.58

Calculation done by T. Abe by CST MS. Waveguide field.

20100324 43CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 44: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Production of quadrant Q1-1

44CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Green lines are ±2.5 microns.Followings shows worst part out of four measured areas along the axis.

Local shape is smoothly connected.

Page 45: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Surface: No etchingNo high-temperature heat treatment

• Alcohol bath – with ultra-sonic vibration for 5 minutes.

• Acetone bath twice – with ultra-sonic vibration for 5 minutes.

• Nitrogen blow• Storage in a deccicator

– Initially filled with nitrogen gas.– Storage for more than a month.

45CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 46: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Carry and storage

Edge inspection

First hanging

Check ball diameter

Prepare next quad approach

Second hanging

Assembly

46CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 47: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Fine adjustment

Fixing by bolt

Completion of stack

Alignment checking

RF setupManual adjustment before final pressing, without ball and groove

mechanism. Misalignment: within ten microns.Reproducibility: a few microns.

47CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 48: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Final alignment

X

Y

Z

C-plane

IN OUTMisalignment of each quadrantw.r.t. the average of four quadrants (units are in micron)

48CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 49: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Elastic tuning with a ball being kept push

4mm stainless ball pushed by minus watch driver.Pushing by turning with Higo’s hand full force.Elastic deformation kept, meaning that the tuning pins are kept pushing the balls.

49CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 50: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Notice: Deformed cavity wall

Cell 3(×35 )

Cell 3(×100 )

Cell3 deformation : 0.053mm

Cell 8(×35 )

Cell 8(×100 )

Cell8 deformation : 0.167mm

Cell 10(×35 )

Cell 10(×100 )

Cell10 no tuning

50CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 51: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Field smoothness after tuning good.

3

3.5

4

4.5

5

0 5 10 15 20

Raw amplitude of bead pull measurementbead pull # 14-20-28-32

Amp 14

amp 20

Amp 28

Amp 32

Amplitude

LabVIEW Cell #51CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U.

(Higo)20100324

Page 52: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Vacuum chamber design

U-tight seal (round metal gasket)VCR connector for cooling water connectionThin H-bend being vac sealed with bellowsVac evacuation from CF114 mounted on chamber with IP 70l/s and from WR90 at just 0.5m from structure

52CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 53: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Installation into chamber

53CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 54: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Installed into Nextef

Nextef setup

3dB phase check

Input connection

54CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)20100324

Page 55: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 55

Page 56: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Gradient limited at 50~60MV/m50nsec

20100324 56CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 57: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

ACC-IN pulse at hard limit

Tp(ns)51 113

Power (MW)19 14

Ea (MV/m)59 50

Sqrt(Tp)*Power135 147

5720100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 58: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Vacuum characteristics• Vacuum total pressure

– Base pressure at <10-6Pa– Typically processing <10-5Pa– Increases every time at few to 5MW range if after RF-OFF

for more than several hours• Mass spectrum

– M=2, 28 and 44 increase with RF-ON, but not M=18• Especially when reaching power limit

– M=2 becomes dominant residual gas after an hour or so run

– M=27 and 28 change in a similar manner as time, indicating hydrocarbon-origin surface contamination

20100324 58CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 59: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Breakdown pulse analysis

20100324 59CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 60: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Timing distribution for change>2000

20100324 60CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 61: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

T18 structure Function F[z]time difference for the BD info to reach both ends

20100324 61CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Use time difference Rs(rise)-Tr(fall) to calculate BD position.Function F(z) is calculated from design vg(z).

Page 62: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Breakdown cell distribution >2000

534 events were analyzed out of 1919 INTLK.

20100324 62CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

50ns higher target run

Mostly downstream half.

Simply increasing toward output end.

Indication of BD following some field gradient.

Page 63: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Quad dark current much larger than T18

(Note: Power is just the value in the control program panel. Read 12MW as 19MW, though relative comparison between quad and T18_disk is OK without this.)

T18

Quad

20100324 63CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 64: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Spectrum peak at very low energy

20100324 64CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

T18_DiskPeaks at 8MeV/c and 4MeV/c with 108MV/m

Present quadPeak at 1.2MeV/c (=0.8MeV)with 19MW 59MV/m

It seems only the last cell or +1 contributes mostly.

Page 65: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Inspection with long-distance microscope after finishing high gradient test

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 65

Page 66: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

No.18 Q2-2 to match Q1-1

20100324 66CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 67: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Cell No.18

~100m

20100324 67CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 68: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Surface inspection summary

• Optical inspection with long-distance focus microscope

• Still not easy to see the arcing spots• Will go to SEM

– though only the center of the rod can be observed in a Japanese company in April

• Will go to CERN SEM for full inspection

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 68

Page 69: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Quad summary  • Very slow processing• Hard ceiling in processing gradient

– 60MV/m @ 50ns, 50MV/m @ 113ns• No further progress with EP (SLAC)• Gas trapping at mating surfaces?• Discharge due to edge?arc is not only at the edge• We do not understand why these longitudinal split ones

are not well in high gradient performance• Still worthwhile to study because of the estimated

cheapness in mass production• Probably reasonable to test with CD10-type setup

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 69

Page 70: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Disk_#2• Aim: Prove heavily damped structure

– Electric gradient: possibility to realize 100MV/m• Design geometry

– Heavy damping slots with wide opening– Big increase of gradient toward downstream– Big pulse heating temperature rise at the damping

port opening– No longitudinal cut but disk-based as T18 structures

• Fabrication in practice– Milling surface in many places– CP and VAC baking are the same as T18

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 70

Page 71: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 71

Diff

eren

t fre

quen

cy

Page 72: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 72CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

51ns 112ns 91ns 112ns 152ns

Power calibration should be reflected.Actually is continuously progressing.

Page 73: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 73

Disk-based: un-damp vs heavy damp

Page 74: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Breakdowns localized at downstream

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)74

加速管

Page 75: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

=42

=57 =72=70

TD18_Disk_#2

Processing:  Dark current decreased β-value decreased   only processing is slow?    why so slow?

20100324 75CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 76: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

20100324 76CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)

MidDN

UP

Still

goin

g up

Page 77: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Disk_#2 test in practice• Replacing load(L)

– Acc str BD originated from the BD from the load line disappeared.

• Processing at 50 nsec– Reached 100MV/m after 1200hrs with 6000 breakdowns.– Still slow processing speed

• Pulse width increased up to 152nsec– Roughly the same power level as that of 51ns was reached

without difficulty– It means 100MV/m level was achieved at longer pulse.

• Power was calibrated with the present setup– Peak power meter was used as a reference– Kly comb. (S+N) and ACC-IN power were calibrated.

20100324 77CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 78: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Disk summary• The processing speed is very slow comparing to that of

T18_Disk_#2 or SLAC for TD18_#3.– Difference in trip criteria?– Difference in acc structure itself?– Difference in processing protocol?– Need quantitative comparison in detail

• Dark current level reached the similar level to that of T18_Disk_#2.

• Even though the processing seems still proceeding, it may be stopped sometime not very far away but after trying some experimental important studies.

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 78

Page 79: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Possible tests with RF shaping

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 79

More breakdown in the second pulse?Same dark current for both?

Almost independent?Twice processing speed?

RF p

ulse

Tem

pera

tur

e

Page 80: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

TD18_Disk test idea in near future

• Evaluate performance with a longer pulse width

• Study with such as two-pulse operation• Check dark current evolution to the final

saturation• Finish and go next test

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 80

Page 81: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Improvement in Nextef studies

• Much room for anyone to help us

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 81

Page 82: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Evaluation of missing energy to be implemented

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 82

Pulse analysis, such as missing energy evaluation is still to be established. Good manpower is needed.

Page 83: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Rs Phase measurement to be establishedBD pulse with IQ

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 83

Pulse analysis is still to be established. Good manpower is needed.

Page 84: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

FC-UP and FC-Mid

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 84

Relation to RF can be better analyzed?

Page 85: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

KEK operation plan Nextef & KT1 7 10 1 4 7 10 1 4 7 10 1 4 7 10 1 4 7 10

2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

T18_Disk_#2

TD18_Quad_#5

TD18_Disk_#2

T18_Disk_Disk #3

T24_Disk_#3

TD24_Disk_#

Narrow waveguide test

High power components test

Narrow waveguide test

Basic studies at shield-B

RF delivery from KT1 to shield-B

KT1

NextefPulse compression

20100324 85CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 86: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Nextef expansion plan

KT-1X-band

KT-2C-band

NextefX-band

A

B

20100324 86CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Pulse compressor

Nextef PC AKT-1 B

B will be used for C-band also.

Page 87: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Configuration of the Power Line from KT-1 to shield-B

H.Matsushita20100324 87CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 88: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

01020304050607080

0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600

ns

MW

PPM4 2003)(PPM4G2A(2006)

25MW,1.5us (PC use)

50MW,0.25us structure test at present  

PPM klystron output power limit

20100324 88CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 89: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Example of RF Pulse Waveforms:Normal(Left) and Pulse Shortening (Right).

The availability of ppm klystron depends on the required RF quality.Empirically we have known that RF pulses were often broken when the product of the pulse width and peak power is large.

PPM クライストロンの運転限界

20100324 89CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 90: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

25 MW×2 Klystons×gain=3→ 150MW

Klys

tron

Acce

lera

tor

TE11R

TE11L

750ns → 150nsGain = 3.6 @ 3dB

22m - One ChannelKl

ystr

onAc

cele

rato

r

1500ns → 300nsGain = 3.3 @ 3dB

TE11R

TE11L

TE12LTE12R

TE11 ModeConverter

TE11-TE12

Reflector

Upgrade using higher mode

Starting in 2010 version

Pulse Compressor (circular TE11 / TE21) proposed by M. Yoshida.

final versionIn 2010 or later

20100324 90CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 91: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

パルス圧縮器の構成(Traveling Wave Delay Line Pulse Compressor )

Klys

tron

Acce

lera

tor

TE11R

TE11L

TE12LTE12R

TE11-TE12

ReflectorTE11 ModeConverter

モード変換器

by Kazakov

20100324 91CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo)

Page 92: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Some area on basic high gradient studies with KT-1

• Narrow waveguide• FE microscope and/or DC-HV breakdown• C10/CD10 TW small setup• Single-cell setup as SLAC

• These themes are to be prioritized through discussion among us

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 92

Page 93: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

High gradient study with narrow waveguide at KEK

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)93

Materials are compared with breakdown rates.Copper BDR >> Stainless-steel BDR

We may try molybdenum next.

Page 94: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Establish a shield-B for basic studies

• We keep collaborating with SLAC single-cell SW activities

• But also we establish Shield-B connecting to KT-1 in 2010

• Shield-B is originally used for C-band but we can use it for X-band. X-band can coexist with C-band or it may be used for multi-frequency experiment in future.

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 94

Page 95: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

X-band collaboration

20100324CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua

U. (Higo)95

KEKStructure fabrication

Infrastructure & test @ Nextef

CERN financially supports for Structure fabrication High power test System expansion

SLAC conductsStructure fabrication

High power testBasic research

US-Japan CERN/KEK

collaboration

CLICUS-HG

TsinghuaStructure design

Structure test and analysis @ Nextef

and others

Asian collab.

Page 96: KEK activities on CLIC X-band Accelerating Structures Tsinghua Univ., March 24 T. Higo (KEK)

Conclusion • Nextef will run fully dedicated for the feasibility

study of CLIC 100MV/m• Nextef will boost peak power and high power

stability by introducing pulse compression system in 2010

• We try to construct a test area in addition for key studies in a simpler configuration

• From these tests and design efforts, we want to confirm the feasible design as of NOW.

• Let us effectively collaborate among us, especially expanding in Asian collaboration for KEK to contribute

20100324 CLIC collaboration meeting at Tsinghua U. (Higo) 96