jurisdiction -- challenging jurisdiction (5 pgs)

8/12/2019 Jurisdiction -- Challenging Jurisdiction (5 Pgs)

1/5

!!""##$$$$%%&&''%%))**++,,--..,,!!//,,00&&

!"#$$%&'(&' *+,(-.(/0(1& (- 1&% 12 0"% 3%-0 .%2%&-%- 41+ /#& 5#6%7 3%/#+-% (2 41+ +-%

0"% ,('"0 #,'+5%&0 (0 (- #$51-0 (581--(3$% 21, 41+ 01 $11-%9

:2 0"%4 #00%580 01 0%$$ 41+ 0"#0 41+ /#&;0


2/5

># 2;56: 2=11;: 2;1G36 45678972:7;1 B79? :0 (- /$%#, #&. =%$$ %-0#3$(-"%. $#= 0"#0 # B1(. 1,.%, /#&

3% /"#$$%&'%. (& #&4 /1+,0@ [M^ eYfZg ACK? M? YDD[!? B? A/^[Z[ChL7 HFN

C? D? `7 H_ D? !0? HOJ WIdF_X?

>/=2D ;G 45678972:7;1?@ i14/% B? C?D? N_N H^

HIE?

>!;56: E58: A6;I3 ;1 :> 45678972:7;1 G=2:8 63>=:39 :; :)5678972:7;1 2=1 F3 2>31?39 =: =1C :7E3?@ #&. >i+,(-.(/0(1&7 1&/%

/"#$$%&'%.7 /#&&10 3% #--+5%. #&. 5+-0 3% .%/(.%.?@ ]#--1 B? C0#" c1=%, k M('"0

!1? NdE G H. dFJ7 dIF?

>^%2%&-% 12 $#/6 12 *+,(-.(/0(1& 1B%, 0"% -+3*%/0 5#00%, 5#4 3% ,#(-%. #0 #&4 0(5%7

%B%& 1& #88%#$?@ L($$ K18 ^%B%$18%,- B? L1$(.#4 c(&%- D%,B(/% !1,8? N_` D1? H.? OJ`

WG$# H&. ^!Y Id`EX

>[&/% /"#$$%&'%.7 *+,(-.(/0(1& /#&&10 3% #--+5%.7 (0 5+-0 3% 8,1B%. 01 %U(-0?@ D0+/6

B? A%.(/#$ gU#5(&%,- dN !# H. _EI? HII cH. O`d?

>//


3/5

>Y +&(B%,-#$ 8,(&/(8$% #- 1$. #- 0"% $#= (- 0"#0 # 8,1/%%.(&'- 12 # /1+,0 =(0"1+0

*+,(-.(/0(1& #,% # &+$$(04 #&. (0- *+.'5%&0 0"%,%(& =(0"1+0 %22%/0 %(0"%, 1& 8%,-1& 1,

8,18%,04?@ Z1,=11. B? P%&2(%$.7 ON ! OHdj gU 8#,0% h(#531&(&(7 Nd c? _OH?

>i+,(-.(/0(1& (- 2+&.#5%&0#$ #&. # *+.'5%&0 ,%&.%,%. 34 # /1+,0 0"#0 .1%- &10 "#B%

*+,(-.(/0(1& 01 "%#, (- B1(. #3 (&(0(1?@ :& P% Y88$(/#0(1& 12 e4#007 OFF c? IOHj P%

!#B(007 II` cH. `NJ?

>/ 38: 83183 ;G :# 2;56:


4/5

M33N/6=GG72

>Y& #/0(1& 34 ^%8#,05%&0 12 A101, l%"(/$%-7 ="%0"%, .(,%/0$4 1, 0",1+'" # /1+,0

-(00(&' #.5(&(-0,#0(B%$4 #- 0"% "%#,(&' 122(/%,7 5+-0 3% /$%#,$4 .%2(&%. (& 0"% -0#0+0%3%21,% (0 "#- -+3*%/0 5#00%, *+,(-.(/0(1&7 =(0"1+0 -+/" *+,(-.(/0(1& 12 0"% $(/%&-%%7 #$$

#/0- 12 0"% #'%&/47 34 (0- %58$14%%-7 #'%&0-7 "%#,(&' 122(/%,-7 #,% &+$$ #&. B1(.?@

^11$#& B? !#,,7 IHE CD JI`j !(04 B c%#,-1&7 I`I !#$? JNF?

>Y'%&/47 1, 8#,04 -(00(&' 21, 0"% #'%&/47 W="(/" =1+$. 3% 0"% 5#'(-0,#0% 12 #

5+&(/(8#$ /1+,0X "#- &1 #+0"1,(04 01 %&21,/% #- 01 #&4 $(/%&-%% +&$%-- "% (- #/0(&'

21, /158%&-#0(1&? D+/" #& #/0 (- "('"$4 8%$ (& +,%7 #&. -"1+$. &10 3%

/1&-0,+%. 01 (&/$+.% #&40"(&' ="(/" (- &10 %53,#/%. =(0"(& (0- 0%,5-? We"%,%X

0"%,% (- &1 /"#,'% =(0"(& # /158$#(&0 0"#0 0"% #//+-%. =#- %58$14%. 21,

/158%&-#0(1& 01 .1 0"% #/0 /158$#(&%. 127 1, 0"#0 0"% #/0 /1&-0(0+0%. 8#,0 12 #

/1&0,#/0?@ D/"15(' B? a#(-%,7 I`d !#$ EdJ?

>e"%& #/0(&' 01 %&21,/% # -0#0+0% #&. (0- -+3-%Y *+.'% /%#-%- 01 -(0 #- # *+.(/(#$ 122(/%, 3%/#+-% 0"% '1B%,&(&' 8,(&/(8$% 12

#.5(&(-0,#0(B% $#= 8,1B(.%- 0"#0 /1+,0- #,% 8,1"(3(0%. 2,15 -+3-0(0+0(&' 0"%(,

%B(.%&/%7 0%-0(51&47 ,%/1,.7 #,'+5%&0-7 #&. ,#0(1$% 21, 0"#0 12 0"% #'%&/4?

Y..(0(1$$47 /1+,0- #,% 8,1"(3(0%. 2,15 -+3-0(0+0(&' 0"%(, *+.'5%&0 21, 0"#0 12 0"%

#'%&/4? !1+,0- (& #.5(&(-0,#0(B% (--+%- #,% 8,1"(3(0%. 2,15 %B%& $(-0%&(&' 01 1,

"%#,(&' #,'+5%&0-7 8,%-%&0#0(1&7 1, ,#0(1$?@ YD:D B? CD7 EJ` GH. H`N?

>O7178:367=> ;GG72368 =63 712;EA3:31: :; 63237I3 ?6=1:8 ;G 459727=> A;B36

G6;E :3?78>=:563@ :C 15>>7:738?@ ]+,&- B? D+8?7 !0?7 DG7 INF !#$? I?

Chal lenging jur isdict ion 4 / 5


5/5

K"% %$%5%&0#,4 .1/0,(&% 0"#0 0"% /1&-0(0+0(1$(04 12 # $%'(-$#0(B% #/0 (- 18%& 01

#00#/6 1&$4 34 8%,-1&- ="1-% ,('"0- #,% #22%/0%. 0"%,%347 #88$(%- 01 -0#0+0% ,%$#0(&'

01 #.5(&(-0,#0(B% #'%&/(%-7 0"% B#$(.(04 12 ="(/" 5#4 &10 3% /#$$%. (&01 > GG88::5599CC

h%0 6&1= 0"% =1,. >45678972:7;1@

^1 # h11'$%m-%#,/"? f1+ =($$ 2(&. -%B%,#$ 51,% /1+,0 /(0%- 41+ 5#4 /"11-% 01 +-%?

l(-(0 41+, $1/#$ $#= $(3,#,4 #&. .(-/1B%, 0"% B#,(1+- ,%-1+,/%- #B#($#3$%?

[30#(& # /184 12 ]$#/6;- M#= ^(/0(1,47 8,%2%,#3$4 #&4 1&% 2,15 0"% G(,-0 0",1+'"

0"% G(20" g.(0(1&-? K"% D(U0" (- &10 #- /158$%0%7 #&. R(& 0"(- %.(01,;- "+53$% 18(&(1&S0"%

D%B%&0" #&. g('"0 #,% *+-0 &10 =1,0" 41+, 0(5% 1, 51&%4? gU#58$%7 $116 +8 0"%

0%,5 >C&(0%. D0#0%-@ #&. &10(/% 0"#0 (0 (- (& 0"% G(,-0 0",1+'" 0"% G(20" g.(0(1&-

#&. &10 (& -+3-%

jurisdiction -- challenging jurisdiction (5 pgs)

Documents