judge parkes decision 2011

Download Judge Parkes Decision 2011

Post on 18-Oct-2015

37 views

Category:

Documents

0 download

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Another unfunded Litigation to save PMT employee jobs.

TRANSCRIPT

  • !

    !""

    #$%&"

    "#$%&!'$()#*'+),('- %%.+,#"/#%%+-()

    $01#'("#$%&+#'-'%,

    '-'-'%$%0"0-$2'/.

    3$#"++0#'()+#"$01#'(#/()4#"+($01#'("#$%&&($20'23($%.,

    ,%(%'%#"%&(+

    35-0'0+%$(%06(7*-2,3*$+*('%%#/&($2+"0)-8.'-'-'%$%0"0-$2'/.3$#"++0#'()+#"$01#'(#/()4%&'0#'%&20#'()0$/%#$"#$20#'9:#"%&(%0#'()(8#$)(%0#'+#($-%($-0++*-$-$*$%&$#'+#)0-(%0'2(++/#'-#'+#)0-(%-#)(0'%('-#%0/#"($0'2%&/#)(0'%#'%8$;9()#"'#')0"%&$(%'0'2!+$60/+0+($A*+%%#/&/C#'%&7))80'2#"('0'-060-*(),

  • /#%%+-()+%(%0#'E

  • '#%"$##0'0'+%$*/%0'2%&(%%*%8#>'--%#$(0'0'+0-%&+%(%0#'('-())(%0'%/($$#$%+)(/-0'(''6)#,

    *$0'2($0#-$0#$%#9

  • (2(0'+%3%&"0$+%/#)(0'%,'%&$+*)%0'2&($0'2 &)-0'*).9

  • )#'%+'#$($$$+#'---0$/%).%#.F+(//*+(%0#', %%&/#'/)*+0#'#"%&%0'2("%$.7(+ 0++*-(-0+/0)0'($. #%#"0)($$%#)-.G!$27('%.#*%#C'#7(+%#%&/#'/$'+.#*8$#*2&%*($)0$0'%&%0'2.#*($80'27(%/&-('-.#*($+*8L/%%#%$0'(%0#'0'%&"*%*$,H=

    ;, 0#)(%0#'++%0'2"$#7$0%%'+%(%'%+0'-0+/0)0'($.+*+'+0#'#"($C).

    '*2*+%E#-$('-(0++*-($C).(-0+/0)0'($.+*+'+0#'%&/0$/*+%('/+('--%(0)+#"7&0/&($+%"#$%&8)#7,'$%0''%($%%&-0+/0)0'($./%-$08*$+'%(%I9$*$"#$+##'%#(++8)%&=-#/*'%+$A*+%-0'0%+#'('-%7#,

    )0

  • # 60-'/7(+$+'%-%&(%('.)#. 7(+/#*'+)-#$ -0+/0)0'-"#$#6

    *%0+2$(%$%&('90'*%+,

    =)+# )

    &+%%)'%(2$'%$#60--0'$%0''%($%?

    JJ$#60-%&'0#'3$+0-'%#$&0+-+02'E

  • '/#'+0-$0'2%&)(7"*)'++#"/#*'0/(%0#'+"$#(')#.$%#)#.+%($-()0+%&G#8L/%06+%('-($-#"7&%&$%&$($C%'-+%#0'%$"$70%&%&"$>$/0+#")#.$02&%+,H($--#+'#%/#'+0-$0%&$%%06(%0#'8&0'-%&$($C#$0%+(/%*()""/%,3 "= );;:991;=#,(%+)0#,;9%'-+%#0'"#$(%0#'%&(%7#*)-())#7%&*'0#'%#-/0-7&%&$%#$#/++(2$06('/,2!'1;:=,,(%;E@++& 9EE:;:=:;,&*'0#'0+'#%$A*0$-%#+%(8)0+&0'(-6('/>(/%).%&0'"#$(%0#'+#*2&%7#*)-8&)"*)0'*$+*0'2=%&2$06('/,,&9=

  • ')#.$()+#60#)(%+/%0#':(=0"0%(C+(%$0()*'0)(%$()/&('2+-*$0'2%&/#*$+#"(/#))/%068($2(0'0'2$)(%0#'+&0#'(%%$+%&(%($('-(%#$.+*8L/%+#"8($2(0'0'2G"#$,,,(/0$/*6'%0#'#"%&-*%.%#'2#%0(%,,,"$*+%$(%+%L/%06+#"=/%0#':(=*/&(+-#+(")(%$"*+(),H2!'@;E,,D;ED; DDE9@%& +2?A&;DE

  • ;, //*+0'2(')#.#""0)0'2*'+*8+%('%0(%- *'"(0$)(8#$$(/%0//&($2+70%&%($-

    '*2*+%E#-$('-(0++*-($C).(-0+/0)0'($.+*+'+0#'%&(%0'=$%0''%($% $(-?

    30+7))(7($#"$,($C).F+$#'+0%."#$"0)0'2*'+*8+%('%0(%-'"(0$(8#$3$(/%0/3/#)(0'%+70%&'#8(+0+0'"(/%('-#"%&F+%'-'/.%#206*'L*+%0"0-/$-'/%#%+/#)(0'%+,$,($C).&(+$)0-*#'%&+%(/%0/+%#)=%*()$(-0'2#"%&G$#'+0%.H+%(%'%/('$+*)%0'('.%&0'2#%&$%&('(/#'/)*+0#'%&(%%&+#'-'%&($8#$-/#'+0-$(8)#'2#0'2('0*+%#7($- ($C).F+(/%060%0+(+(*'0#'#""0/$('-8.>%'+0#'%#%&(/%060%0+#"#%&$*'0#'#""0/$+,

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

    ((

    "(0)#$$"*+%#$#60-%&'0#' 70%&0'"#$(%0#'$A*+%-8.%&'0#'%&(%0+$)6('%%#0%+$"#$0'20%+-*%.%#$$+'%)#.+,

    ((

    (C/&('2+0'%&)#.'%%$+('-/#'-0%0#'+#"*'0%)#.+70%*%"0$+%'#%0".0'2('-8($2(0'0'270%&%&'0#',

    ((

    -0+/0)0')#.+"#$'2(20'20'*'0#'(/%060%0+('-K#$"#$*%0)010'2%&$#/+++#"%($-8.+*/&(/%0#'+(+"0)0'2*'"(0$)(8#$$(/%0//&($2+('-2060'2%+%0#'.,

    ((

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