Integrated Nutrient Management, Soil Fertility, and Sustainable ...
Post on 13-Jan-2017
Embed Size (px)
Food, Agriculture, and the Environment Discussion Paper 32
Integrated Nutrient Management, Soil Fertility,
and Sustainable Agriculture:Current Issues and Future Challenges
by Peter Gruhn, Francesco Goletti, and Montague Yudelman
International Food Policy Research Institute2033 K Street, N.W.
Washington, D.C. 20006 U.S.A.September 2000
Copyright 2000 International Food PolicyResearch Institute
All rights reserved. Sections of this report may bereproduced without the express permission of butwith acknowledgment to the International FoodPolicy Research Institute.
1. Introduction 1
2. Plant Nutrients and Soil Fertility 3
3. Some Issues in Plant Nutrient Use and Soil Fertility 6
4. Soil Fertility Problems: Focus on Sub-Saharan Africa 9
5. Challenges and Responses at the Farmers Level 15
6. Challenges and Responses at the Institutional Level 19
7. Conclusions and Recommendations 22
Appendix: IFPRI/FAO Workshop Conclusions and Recommendations 24
1. Annual cereal crop yield growth rates, 1970s-1990s 7
2. Annual growth rates in fertilizer use per hectare, 1960s-1990s 13
1. The plant nutrient balance system 5
2. Fertilizer consumption in Sub-Saharan Africa and the world, 1961-96 12
3. Long-term effect of balanced fertilization on wheat yield, 1970-88 16
1. Soil Quality Affects Agricultural Productivity 3
2. Reclaiming Acidic and Saline Soils 4
3. Nitrogenous Fertilizer Production 5
4. Extent and Causes of Human-Induced Soil Degradation 10
5. Benefits of Integrated Nutrient Management 19
6. Plant Symptom Analysis, Tissue Analysis, and Soil Testing 20
The challenge for agriculture over the coming decades will be to meet the worlds increas-ing demand for food in a sustainable way. Declining soil fertility and mismanagement ofplant nutrients have made this task more difficult. In their 2020 Vision discussion paper,Integrated Nutrient Management, Soil Fertility, and Sustainable Agriculture: Current Issuesand Future Challenges, Peter Gruhn, Francesco Goletti, and Montague Yudelman point outthat as long as agriculture remains a soil-based industry, major increases in productivity areunlikely to be attained without ensuring that plants have an adequate and balanced supplyof nutrients. They call for an Integrated Nutrient Management approach to the manage-ment of plant nutrients for maintaning and enhancing soil, where both natural and man-made sources of plant nutrients are used. The key components of this approach aredescribed; the roles and responsibilities of various actors, including farmers and institutions,are delineated; and recommendations for improving the management of plant nutrientsand soil fertility are presented.
The genesis for this paper was a joint International Food Policy Research Institute/Foodand Agriculture Organization of the United Nations workshop on Plant NutrientManagement, Food Security, and Sustainable Agriculture: The Future to 2020 held inViterbo, Italy, in 1995. It brought together experts from various fields and institutions includ-ing fertilizer industry groups, universities, nongovernmental organizations, and governmen-tal agencies to examine the contributions fertilizers and other sources of plant nutrients canmake to the food security of developing countries. The workshops main conclusions andrecommendations are reported in the Appendix.
Per Pinstrup-AndersenDirector General
This paper has benefited greatly from the discussion, conclusions, and recommendations that cameout of the IFPRI/FAO workshop mentioned in the foreword, as well as from the helpful commentsand suggestions of Per Pinstrup-Andersen, Bert Janssen, Eric Smaling, Rajul Pandya-Lorch, DavidNygaard, Mylne Kherallah, and Craig Drury. All remaining errors and omissions are the respon-sibility of the authors. The authors would also like to thank Lisa Grover for her excellent word pro-cessing and Uday Mohan for helping to turn our collectively authored and hedged prose into areadable final document.
Can agriculture provide for the food needs of aworld population projected to exceed 7.5 billion bythe year 2020? Concern is growing that it may not.There are indications that the highly productivefertilizer and seed technologies introduced over thepast three decades may be reaching a point ofdiminishing returns (Bouis 1993; Cassman et al.1995; Flinn and De Datta 1984). Prospects forexpanding low-cost irrigation, one of the drivingforces behind yield increases, are also becomingmore limited (Rosegrant and Svendsen 1993;Rosegrant 1997; Carruthers, Rosegrant, and Seckler1997), as are the prospects for converting marginallands into productive arable land (Bockman et al.1990; Crosson and Anderson 1992). Furthermore,new technologies such as genetically engineered,yield-increasing plants are not expected to be majorfactors in food production increases in developingcountries during the next two decades (Hazell 1995;Peng, Khush, and Cassman 1994). Consequently,keeping pace with population growth and increas-ing land scarcity will be more difficult than in therecent past.
Concerns also are growing about the long-termsustainability of agriculture. Both the over- andunderapplication of fertilizer and the poor manage-ment of resources have damaged the environment.In developed countries, for example, overapplica-tion of inorganic and organic fertilizer1 has led toenvironmental contamination of water supplies andsoils (Conway and Pretty 1991; Bumb and Baanante1996; NRC 1989). In developing countries, harshclimatic conditions, population pressure, land
constraints, and the decline of traditional soil man-agement practices have often reduced soil fertility(Stoorvogel and Smaling 1990; Tandon 1998;Henao and Baanante 1999; Bumb and Baanante1996). Because agriculture is a soil-based industrythat extracts nutrients from the soil, effective andefficient approaches to slowing that removal andreturning nutrients to the soil will be required inorder to maintain and increase crop productivityand sustain agriculture for the long term.
The overall strategy for increasing crop yieldsand sustaining them at a high level must include anintegrated approach to the management of soilnutrients, along with other complementary meas-ures. An integrated approach recognizes that soilsare the storehouse of most of the plant nutrientsessential for plant growth and that the way in whichnutrients are managed will have a major impact onplant growth, soil fertility, and agricultural sustain-ability. Farmers, researchers, institutions, and gov-ernment all have an important role to play in sus-taining agricultural productivity.
To better understand the processes at work inretaining soil fertility, the next chapter discusses therole of nutrients in creating an enabling environ-ment for plants to grow. Chapter 3 reviews somecurrent issues in plant nutrient use. Chapter 4examines the decline in soil fertility, particularly inSub-Saharan Africa, where pressures on agricul-ture are particularly severe. Chapter 5 discussesmany of the challenges and possible responses tothe decline in soil fertility at the farm level, with par-ticular reference to the role that an integrated
1In this paper plant nutrients refer to all types of nutrients, whether organic or inorganic, that combine with energy fromthe sun to result in plant growth. The word fertilizer will usually refer to chemical or inorganic fertilizer unless it isexplicitly qualified with the adjective organic. Therefore, plant nutrients include both organic and inorganic fertilizers.
approach to the management of plant nutrientscan play in maintaining and enhancing soil fertili-ty. The sixth chapter looks at the contributions thatinstitutions can make to ensure that agriculture willremain sustainable. The last chapter presents somerecommendations for improving the manage-ment of plant nutrients and soil fertility in the years
ahead. Several of these recommendations arebased on a joint International Food Policy ResearchInstitute/Food and Agriculture Organization of theUnited Nations workshop held in 1995 (Gruhn,Goletti, and Roy 1998). The workshops main con-clusions and recommendations are reported in theAppendix.
Plant growth is the result of a complex processwhereby the plant synthesizes solar energy, carbondioxide, water, and nutrients from the soil. In all,between 21 and 24 elements are necessary forplant growth. The primary nutrients for plant growthare nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium (knowncollectively as NPK). When insufficient, these pri-mary nutrients are most often responsible for lim-iting crop growth. Nitrogen, the most intensivelyused element, is available in virtually unlimitedquantities in the atmosphere and is continuallyrecycled among plants, soil, water, and air. However,it is often unavailable in the correct form for properabsorption and synthesis by the plant.
In addition to the primary nutrients, less inten-sively used secondary nutrients (sulfur, calcium,and magnesium) are necessary as well. A numberof micronutrients such as chlorine, iron, man-ganese, zinc, copper, boron, and molybdenum alsoinfluence plant growth. These micronutrients are
required in small amounts (ranging from a fewgrams to a few hundred grams per hectare) for theproper functioning of plant metabolism. The absoluteor relative absence of any of these nutrients canhamper plant growth; alternatively, too high a con-centration can be toxic to the plant or to humans.
The capacity of soils to be productive depends onmore than just plant nutrients. The physical, bio-logical, and chemical characteristics of a soilforexample its organic matter content, acidity, texture,depth, and water-retention capacityall influencefertility. Because these attributes differ among soils,soils differ in their quality. Some soils, because oftheir texture or depth, for example, are inherentlyproductive because they can store and make avail-able large amounts of water and nutrients toplants ( Box 1). Conversely, other soils have suchpoor nutrient and organic matter content that theyare virtually infertile.
2. Plant Nutrients and Soil Fertility
A soils potential for producing crops is largely deter-mined by the environment that the soil provides for rootgrowth. Roots need air, water, nutrients, and adequatespace in which to develop. Soil attributes, such as thecapacity to store water, acidity, depth, and density deter-mine how well roots develop. Changes in these soilattributes directly affect the health of the plant. Forexample, bulk density, a measure of the compactnessof a soil, affects agricultural productivity. When the bulkdensity of soil increases to a critical level, it becomes
more difficult for roots to penetrate the soil, therebyimpeding root growth. When bulk density has increasedbeyond the critical level, the soil becomes so dense thatroots cannot penetrate the soil and root growth is pre-vented. Heavy farm equipment, erosion, and the lossof soil organic matter can lead to increases in bulkdensity. These changes in soil quality affect the healthand producticity of the plant, and can lead to loweryields and/or higher costs of production.Source: NRC 1993.
Soil Quality Affects Agricultural Productivity
The way soils are managed can improve ordegrade the natural quality of soils. Mismanagementhas led to the degradation of millions of acres ofland through erosion, compaction, salinization,acidification, and pollution by heavy metals. Theprocess of reversing soil degradation is expensiveand time consuming (Box 2); some heavily degrad-ed soils may not be recoverable. On the otherhand, good management can limit physical loss-es. Good management includes use of covercrops and soil conservation measures; addition oforganic matter to the soil; and judicious use ofchemical fertilizers, pesticides, and farm machinery.
Organic matter content is important for theproper management of soil fertility. Organic matterin soil helps plants grow by improving water-hold-ing capacity and drought-resistance. Moreover,organic matter permits better aeration, enhancesthe absorption and release of nutrients, and makesthe soil less susceptible to leaching and erosion(see Sekhon and Meelu 1994; Reijntjes, Haverkort,and Waters-Bayer 1992).
Plants need a given quantity and mix of nutrientsto flourish. The higher the yield, the greater thenutrient requirement. A shortage of one or morenutrients can inhibit or stunt plant growth. Butexcess nutrients, especially those provided by
inorganic fertilizers, can be wasteful,2 costly, and,in some instances, harmful to the environment.Effective and efficient management of the soilstorehouse by the farmer is thus essential formaintaining soil fertility and sustaining highyields. To achieve healthy growth and optimalyield levels, nutrients must be available not only inthe correct quantity and proportion, but in ausable form and at the right time. For the farmer,an economic optimum may differ from a physicaloptimum, depending on the added cost of inputsand the value of benefits derived from anyincreased output.
Soil nutrient availability changes over time. Thecontinuous recycling of nutrients into and out ofthe soil is known as the nutrient cycle (NRC 1993).The cycle involves complex biological and chemi-cal interactions, some of which are not yet fullyunderstood. A simplified version of this cycle ofplant growth, based on Smaling (1993), is shownin Figure 1. The simplified cycle has two parts:inputs that add plant nutrients to the soil andoutputs that export them from the soil largely inthe form of agricultural products. Important inputsources include inorganic fertilizers; organic fer-tilizers such as manure, plant residues, and covercrops; nitrogen generated by leguminous plants;
Two common features of degraded land are acidic andsaline soils. Soils become acidic (low pH) through theleaching of bases by percolating water. Over time,application of most ammonia-based fertilizers will alsolower pH. Lime, from limestone and dolomite, is fre-quently applied to raise soil pH. By improving the con-ditions for plant growth, liming increases nutrientremoval and enhances organic matter decomposition.Concurrent application of lime and balanced nutrientreplenishment is usually necessary to ensure continuedlong-term soil fertility.
Saline soils (high soluble salt content), sodic soils(high sodium content), saline-sodic soils (high solu-ble salt, high sodium), and high-lime soils are alltypes of alkaline soils. Drainage and nutrient applica-tion are usually sufficient to mitigate the effect ofhigh-lime soils. Saline, sodic, and saline-sodic soilscan usually be reclaimed over time through leaching.Low soil permeability and large amendmentrequirements make sodic soil reclamation a slowand expensive process.Source: Thompson an...