informal fallacies - yola - cinnamonphilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/informal...

29
INFORMAL FALLACIES Engel, S. Morris. 2000. “With Good Reason: An introduction to Informal Fallacies.” 6 th ed. Bedford. http://www.iep.utm.edu/f/fallacy.htm http://onegoodmove.org/fallacy/toc.htm http://www.fallacyfiles.org/glossary.html

Upload: vuongnhu

Post on 24-Mar-2018

247 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

INFORMAL

FALLACIESEngel, S. Morris. 2000. “With Good Reason: An

introduction to Informal Fallacies.” 6th ed. Bedford.

http://www.iep.utm.edu/f/fallacy.htm

http://onegoodmove.org/fallacy/toc.htm

http://www.fallacyfiles.org/glossary.html

Page 2: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacy of Presumption:

• "Justice requires higher wages because it is right that people should earn more."

• This amounts to: "justice requires higher wages because justice requires higher wages.”

– God exists!– How do you know?– The Bible says so.– How do you know that what the Bible says is true?– Because the Bible is the word of God!

--Begging the question: (petitio principii)

The argument uses the conclusion that it seeks to establish. It

assumes the conclusion in its premises.

Page 3: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of presumption:

• "Since I'm not lying, it follows that I'm telling the

truth.“

– Bill: “I enjoy only good books.”

– Tom: “How do you know when they’re good?”

– Bill: “If they’re not good, I don’t enjoy them.”

-- Circular definition:

The definition includes the term being defined

as a part of the definition; Using the concluding claim

as evidence to support the conclusion.

Page 4: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "If we lower the drinking age from 21 to 18,

then what next? 16 year olds being allowed to

drink? 14 year olds?"

• "If we allow the French to influence us, we'll

soon be eating nothing but snails and garlic."

--Slippery slope:

Supposing that a single step

in a particular direction

must lead to the extreme position.

Page 5: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

Fallacies of presumption:

• "After Ketchup was considered a serving of vegetables in school meals, math scores dropped nation-wide. Therefore, ketchup causes math scores to drop."

-- Post hoc ergo propter hoc: (Post hoc for short.

Latin: "after this, therefore because of this.")

Because one thing follows another,

it is held to cause the other.FORM:

Event C happened immediately prior to event E.

Therefore, C caused E.

.

Page 6: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of presumption:

• "In K-12 children, neater handwriting causes

larger feet.“

• “The number of cases of drowning increases

as the sale of ice cream increases. So eating

ice cream must cause drowning.”

-- Cum hoc ergo propter hoc:

Assumes events which occur together are causally connected,

and there is no room for coincidence or for other causal

factors. FORM: Events C and E both happened at the same time.

Therefore, C caused E.

Page 7: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "If you are not with us, you are against

us." -W

--Bifurcation:

Presenting only two alternatives

where others exist;

black and white thinking.

ALSO: FALSE DILEMMA

Page 8: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "How can you condone usury? You're a

Christian, and Christ drove the money-lenders

from the temple."

• ”As an opera-lover, you will be the first to agree

that we need more subsidy for the arts."

-- Argumentum ad Hominem:

Attacking the arguer

rather than the argument itself.

It also includes invoking the proponents position.

ALSO: TU QUOQUE

Page 9: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "Since you based your theory of Bigfoot

on stories from The National Enquirer,

the theory must be false.”

• “The war on drugs started from strict

Puritanical heritage. So we don’t have

to encourage drug control.”

-- The genetic fallacy: (p. 89)

Attacking the source of the argument

rather than the argument itself. It is a fallacy,

because how an idea originated is irrelevant to its validity.

Page 10: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "You can't tell me smoking is bad when

you've been smoking for thirty years."

-- Tu Quoque: ("you also")

Undermining a case by claiming

that its proponent is himself guilty of what he talks of.

Page 11: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

Anecdotal evidence

• Anecdotes and stories

• These are events that happen to someone, or

that are told to them, with no attempt at any

scientific analysis. Some are simply stories,

events that did not really happen or that have

been significantly altered (for example urban

legends). They are useful for adding interest, and

in illustrating points, but they should not be used

to make generalizations.

• "This is third day in a row that we've had a record

high temperature. Global warming must be real." 12

Page 12: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "The credit card company will take my

late fee off. Otherwise I'll be so broke I

can't pay them anything."

--Wishful thinking:

Rejecting a claim solely because

we do not wish it to be true.

Page 13: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• “We should liberalize the laws on

marijuana.”

• “No. Any Society with unrestricted

access to drugs loses its work ethic and

goes only for immediate gratification.”

-- Straw Man:

A deliberate over-statement of an opponent's position.

Stating a position that no one holds.

Page 14: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "It cleans your teeth white! Yes, that's

right-- whiter than white!"

-- Argumentum ad Nauseum:

Repetition of a point,

often by exaggerating or slightly changing the point.

Page 15: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of language:

• "Hitler summons war lords!”

• "Scotland stole a goal in the first half, but

England's efforts were rewarded. . ."

--Loaded words: (also emotive argument)

The deliberate use of prejudiced terms

to conjure a more favorable

or hostile response.

Page 16: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• "This must be a good orchestra

because each member is a talented

musician."

Composition:Claiming that what is true for individual

members of a class

is also true for the class as a whole.

Page 17: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• "Germany is a militant country. Thus, each

German is militant.”

• "Because the brain is capable of

consciousness, each neural cell in the brain

must be capable of consciousness."

Division:Attributing to the individuals in a group

something that is only true of the group as a unit.

Page 18: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• "All child-murderers are inhuman, thus, no child-murderer is human.”

• "My dog's got no nose/ How does he smell?/ Terrible!"

•Equivocation:Using words ambiguously;

equivocal words have more than one meaning.

Page 19: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• “You are not entitled to your opinion.”

•Equivocation:Using words ambiguously;

equivocal words have more than one meaning.

Page 20: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• 1. If someone is entitled to an opinion

then her opinion is well-supported by

the evidence. (This is precisely what it

means to be entitled to an opinion).

• 2. I am entitled to my opinion (as is

everyone in a democratic society).

• 3. Therefore, my opinion is well

supported by the evidence.

Page 21: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

FORMAL FALLACIES

• Consider the true premise: If there is

fire, oxygen is present.

"Oxygen is present, therefore there is fire.”

"If I drop an egg, it breaks. This egg is broken,

so I must have dropped it."

•--Affirming the consequent: (Remember: biconditional)

• Believing that the consequent (the second phrase)

necessarily entails the antecedent.

Page 22: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

FORMAL FALLACIES

• Consider the premise: If there is fire, oxygen is

present.

• There is no fire, therefore there is no oxygen.

• Consider the premise: If I am hungry in the

morning, I will eat breakfast.

• I am not hungry in the morning, therefore I will

not eat breakfast.

--Denying the antecedent:

Believing that when the antecedent is false,

the consequent must be false also.

Page 23: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*INDUCTIVE FALLACIES:

• The apples on the top of the box look

good. The entire box of apples must be

good.

--Unrepresentative sample:

The sample used relevantly different

from the population as a whole.

Page 24: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

• "I'm backing Hillary Clinton on this one.

She can't be wrong all the time.”

• “I’m betting red on the Roulette table.

The last five times was black, so it’s

bound to be red soon.”

--Gambler's Fallacy:

Believing the next outcome

will somehow be influenced by the last outcome.

This only applies to cases of independent trials,

like rolling the dice.

*INDUCTIVE FALLACIES:

Page 25: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Fallacies of relevance:

• "We don't know what caused the door

to slam, therefore it was a ghost.“

• We don’t have proof that God exists,

therefore he does not exist.

-- Argument from ignorance:

Using the lack of knowledge

of any alternatives to

justify the truth of a claim.

Page 26: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

LINGUISTIC FALLACIES

• "I met the ambassador riding his horse. He was snorting and steaming, so I gave him a lump of sugar"

• "Helicopter powered by human flies"• "The anthropologists went to a remote area and

took photographs of some native women, but they weren't developed."

• "One morning I shot an elephant in my pajamas. How he got into my pajamas I'll never know." --Groucho Marx

-- Amphiboly:

Sentence constructions are ambiguous; the whole meaning of a

statement can be taken in more than one way.

Page 27: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

*Inductive Fallacy

• Since I saw two people with the same birthday,

then I think that this classroom has an unusual

number of people with the same birthday.

• So, the next time I see two people with the same

birthday, then it will confirm my hypothesis.

• ---------------------------------

• Confirmation Bias: Using future instances to

confirm one’s hypotheses, without appeal to

independent evidence.

• Also, a tendency to search for or interpret new information

in a way that confirms one's preconceptions.

• Avoiding information and interpretations which contradict

prior beliefs. 28

Page 28: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

TWO CRITICAL THINKING ASSIGNMENTS. 3-5 PAGES each. Double spaced.

• For each assignment, find one fallacious argument in the media. Your job is to catch people

making mistakes in reasoning. Media includes television, newspaper editorials, talk radio

shows, etc. A good place to look is the “letters to the editor” or “public forum.”

1. In your SHORT introduction, indicate the source of the argument. Name the author of the

article and the article title, and then in parentheses list the newspaper with date and page

of article. If you are using a hard copy, then clip out the article and attach it to your paper.

If you are citing a website, then be sure to give the full URL in your bibliography.

2. Give a thesis statement (i.e. “Joe blow made a Slippery Slope Fallacy.’)

3. Write out a one-paragraph summary of the author’s argument as it appears in your source.

You may use quotes. The summary should outline the author’s argument by indicating

premises and conclusions. Remember, the conclusion is what the author wants you to

believe and the premises are the reasons the author gives for why he wants you to believe

his position. For example, if an author says, “Sam Wellers should not move his bookstore

from downtown,” then that is the conclusion, and a premise might be “Sam Weller’s

Bookstore will only be successful in downtown Salt Lake City.” To make the argument a

deductive argument, you might have to fill in an inference. In the example above, the

inference will be: “If Sam Wellers wants to be successful, he should not move his bookstore.”

If the author relies on unstated assumptions or unwanted consequences, then state these.

Include everything relevant to your case.

Page 29: INFORMAL FALLACIES - Yola - CinnamonPhilosophycinnamonphilosophy.yolasite.com/resources/Informal Fallacies PPT...-- Amphiboly: Sentence constructions are ambiguous; ... For example,

4. Identify and define the fallacy made. Fallacies can include affirming the consequent

or denying the antecedent; or informal fallacies such as ad hominem, slippery

slope, begging the question etc. A list of fallacies is given in Arthur’s paper on E-

reserves, and online, such as: http://www.fallacyfiles.org/inforfal.html

http://www.drury.edu/ess/Logic/Informal/Overview.html

5. In the longest section of your paper, you need to explain how the argument from

your source fits the definition of the fallacy. This requires that you examine details

of the author’s argument and persuade me that the author really is making that

fallacy. Pretend like I agree with the author and that I do not see anything wrong

with the argument. Give examples or analogies to really show me that the

argument is no good. Part of your job in defending your position is to persuade

your reader that the fallacy you’ve chosen really is a fallacy, using your target

article as an example. You should feel like you are over-explaining the obvious.

6. A short conclusion will summarize your thesis. I.e. “Joe Blow has made a slippery

slope fallacy.”

7. Include a bibliography.