indian buddhist theories - buddhist thougt of persons... · indian buddhist theories of persons...

Download INDIAN BUDDHIST THEORIES - Buddhist Thougt of Persons... · INDIAN BUDDHIST THEORIES OF PERSONS In…

Post on 25-Aug-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents

1 download

Embed Size (px)

TRANSCRIPT

  • INDIAN BUDDHIST THEORIES OF PERSONS

    In this book, Vasubandhus classic work Refutation of the Theory of aSelf is translated and provided with an introduction and commentary. Thetranslation, the first into a modern Western language from the Sanskrittext, is intended for use by those who wish to begin a careful philo-sophical study of Indian Buddhist theories of persons. Special features of the introduction and commentary are their extensive explanations of the arguments for the theories of persons of Vasubandhu and thePudgalavdins, the Buddhist philosophers whose theory is the central targetof Vasubandhus refutation of the theory of a self.

    James Duerlinger has taught in the Philosophy Department at the Univer-sity of Iowa since 1971. He has published on topics in Greek philosophy,philosophy of religion, and Buddhist philosophy, which are also his currentteaching and research interests.

    111111

    111

    011

    111

    0111

    0111

    0111

    4111

    R U N N I N G H E A D

    i

  • RoutledgeCurzon Critical Studies in BuddhismGeneral Editors:

    Charles S. Prebish and Damien Keown

    RoutledgeCurzon Critical Studies in Buddhism is a comprehensive study of theBuddhist tradition. The series explores this complex and extensive tradition froma variety of perspectives, using a range of different methodologies.

    The Series is diverse in its focus, including historical studies, textual translationsand commentaries, sociological investigations, bibliographic studies, and consider-ations of religious practice as an expression of Buddhisms integral religiosity. Italso presents materials on modern intellectual historical studies, including the roleof Buddhist thought and scholarship in a contemporary, critical context and in thelight of current social issues. The series is expansive and imaginative in scope, span-ning more than two and a half millennia of Buddhist history. It is receptive to allresearch works that inform and advance our knowledge and understanding of theBuddhist tradition.

    1

    1

    11

    11

    11

    11

    THE REFLEXIVE NATURE OF AWARENESS

    Paul Williams

    BUDDHISM AND HUMAN RIGHTS

    Edited by Damien Keown, Charles Prebish and Wayne Husted

    ALTRUISM AND REALITYPaul Williams

    WOMEN IN THE FOOTSTEPS OF THE BUDDHA

    Kathryn R. Blackstone

    THE RESONANCE OF EMPTINESS

    Gay Watson

    IMAGING WISDOMJacob N. Kinnard

    AMERICAN BUDDHISMEdited by Duncan Ryuken Williams

    and Christopher Queen

    PAIN AND ITS ENDINGCarol S. Anderson

    THE SOUND OF LIBERATINGTRUTH

    Edited by Sallie B. King and Paul O. Ingram

    BUDDHIST THEOLOGYEdited by Roger R. Jackson and

    John J. Makransky

    EMPTINESS APPRAISEDDavid F. Burton

    THE GLORIOUS DEEDS OF PURNAJoel Tatelman

    CONTEMPORARY BUDDHISTETHICS

    Edited by Damien Keown

    INNOVATIVE BUDDHIST WOMENEdited by Karma Lekshe Tsomo

    TEACHING BUDDHISM IN THE WEST

    Edited by V. S. Hori, R. P. Hayes and J. M. Shields

    EMPTY VISIONDavid L. McMahan

    SELF, REALITY AND REASON INTIBETAN PHILOSOPHY

    Thupten Jinpa

    BUDDHIST PHENOMENOLOGYDan Lusthaus

    ZEN WAR STORIESBrian Victoria

    IN DEFENSE OF DHARMATessa J. Bartholomeusz

    RELIGIOUS MOTIVATION AND THE ORIGINS OF BUDDHISM

    Torkel Brekke

    DEVELOPMENTS IN AUSTRALIAN BUDDHISM

    Michelle Spuler

    THE BUDDHIST UNCONSCIOUSWilliam S. Waldron

    ACTION DHARMAEdited by Christopher Queen,

    Charles Prebish and Damien Keown

    INDIAN BUDDHIST THEORIES OF PERSONS

    James Duerlinger

  • INDIAN BUDDHISTTHEORIES OF

    PERSONS

    Vasubandhus Refutation of the Theory of a Self

    James Duerlinger

    111

    011

    111

    0111

    0111

    0111

    4111

  • First published 2003by RoutledgeCurzon

    11 New Fetter Lane, London EC4P 4EE

    Simultaneously published in the USA and Canadaby RoutledgeCurzon

    29 West 35th Street, New York, NY 10001

    RoutledgeCurzon is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group

    2003 James Duerlinger

    All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted orreproduced or utilized in any form or by any electronic,

    mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any

    information storage or retrieval system, without permission inwriting from the publishers.

    British Library Cataloguing in Publication DataA catalogue record for this book is available

    from the British Library

    Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication DataDuerlinger, James.

    Indian Buddhist theories of persons/James Duerlinger.p. cm. (RoutledgeCurzon critical studies in Buddhism)

    Includes bibliographical references and index.

    3. Man (Buddhism) I. Title. II. SeriesBQ2682.E5D84 2003

    126dc21 2002037127

    ISBN 0415318351

    1

    1

    11

    11

    11

    11

    1. Vasubandhu. Abhidharmakoabhya. atmavadapratioeda.2. Anatman.

    This edition published in the Taylor and Francis e-Library, 2005.

    To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledgescollection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.

    (Print Edition)

    ISBN 0-203-60764-3 Master e-book ISBN

    ISBN 0-203-34205-4 (Adobe eReader Format)

  • CONTENTS

    Preface viiAcknowledgments xi

    1 Introduction to the Translation 1

    2 Translation of Vasubandhus Refutation of the Theory of a Self 71

    Section 1: Vasubandhus theory of persons 71

    Section 2: Vasubandhus objections to the Pudgalavdins theory of persons 73

    Section 3: Vasubandhus replies to the objections of the Pudgalavdins 86

    Section 4: Vasubandhus replies to the objections of theTrthikas and objections to their arguments 96

    Section 5: Concluding verses 111

    3 Commentary on Section 1: Vasubandhus theory of persons 122

    4 Commentary on Section 2: Vasubandhus objections to the Pudgalavdins theory of persons 131

    5 Commentary on Section 3: Vasubandhus replies to objections by the Pudgalavdins 206

    111

    011

    111

    0111

    0111

    0111

    4111

    v

  • 6 Commentary on Section 4: Vasubandhus replies to the objections of the Trthikas 238

    Bibliography 299Index 303

    1

    1

    11

    11

    11

    11

    C O N T E N T S

    vi

  • PREFACE

    The Refutation of the Theory of a Self is an Indian treatise (fourth orfifth century CE) on the selflessness of persons that was composed by aBuddhist philosopher known as Vasubandhu. The Refutation, as I willcall it, is basically an attempt to refute the view that persons are selves. In this book I offer a Translation of the Refutation, along with anIntroduction and Commentary, for the use of readers who wish to begindetailed research on Indian Buddhist theories of persons by making acareful philosophical study of this classic of Indian Buddhist philosophy.The Translation is the first into a modern Western language to be madefrom the Sanskrit text and avoids errors I believe to be contained in earliertranslations, which were based on a Sanskrit commentary (sixth centuryCE) by Yaomitra, and either the Tibetan translation by Jinamitra and dPalbrtsegs (twelfth century CE) or the Chinese translations by Paramrtha(sixth century), and by Xanzng (seventh century CE).

    In the Introduction I provide readers with information and explanationsthat will introduce them to the main three kinds of Indian Buddhist theoriesof persons and enable them to do a careful philosophical study of theRefutation. In the Translation an attempt is made both to translate termsin a way that will promote a better understanding of the theses and argu-ments it contains and to help readers through its more difficult passagesby indicating in brackets key unexpressed parts of the theses and argu-ments it contains. The notes to the Translation explain the translation andcall attention to problems I believe to exist with previous modern transla-tions. In the Commentary, the theses and arguments contained in theRefutation are explained and assessed.

    In the Refutation Vasubandhu first argues that we are not selves, whichare persons who can be identified without reference to the collections ofaggregates that comprise their bodies and minds, and that, nonetheless, wedo ultimately exist, since we are the same in existence as the collections ofthese aggregates. Then he presents a series of objections to the theory of the Pudgalavdins, who belong to the Indian Buddhist schools in whichit is claimed that, even though we are not independently identifiable, we

    111

    011

    111

    0111

    0111

    0111

    4111

    vii

  • ultimately exist without being the same in existence as collections of suchaggregates. Then Vasubandhu replies to their objections to his own theoryof persons. Finally, he replies to objections raised by the Nyya-Vaieikas,non-Buddhist Indian philosophers who claim that we are selves in the sense that we are substances that exist independently of our bodies andmomentary mental states.

    Vasubandhu not only discusses and rejects the theories of persons putforward by the Pudgalavdins and Nyya-Vaieikas, but also dismisses, ina single sentence, the thesis of Ngrjuna, the founder of the Mdhyamikaschool of Indian Buddhism, that no phenomena ultimately exist, as anadequate basis for a theory of persons. In Ngrjunas extant works (secondcentury CE) a Buddhist theory of persons is not presented in any greatdetail. But in the seventh century CE Candrakrti worked out the implica-tions of Ngrjunas thesis for the interpretation of the Buddhas theory of persons. This interpretation became the basis of t