immune responses to parasites: the art of distinguishing the good from the bad
TRANSCRIPT
IMMUNOLOGY TOD.AY
ost parasites pass through
complicated life cycles
with different stages,
frequently colonizing
various tissues of the host, and conse-
quently ccz+sin a great variety of antigens.
Over millions of years, parasites have de-
veloped sophisticated strategies to adapt to
their hosts and to evade attacks by the im-
mune system. As a result, parasite infec-
tions tend to be chronic and the quality of
the immunological responses varies consid-
erably in the different phases of infection.
The studies of the host-defense mechanisms
against parasites are aimed at the develop-
ment of prophylactic and curative means
but, at the same time, they provide important
insights into general principles of the regu-
lation of immunity.
Cells and cytokines involved in
protection and immunopathology
Infections with parasites are often charac-
terized by polarized T-cell responses that
control the development of either immunity
or pathology. Cytokines Froduced by the
T helper 2 (Th2) subset ol CD4+ cells are
thought to be involved in granuloma for-
mation and pathagenesis resulting from
infection with the helminth Skistosorrzn
mnsoni. However, hepatic granuloma for-
mation in mice in which the interleukin 4
(IL-41 gene has been knocked out (IL-4-/-I
was found to be similar to that in infected
wild-type mice (E. Pearce, Ithaca, NY). Tumor
necrosis factor IY (TNF-a) contributes to dis-
ease and death in IL-K- mice. These data
show that IL-4-independent pathways are
involved in the generation of Th2-like re-
sponses during acute disease. In the chronic
phase of S. rrmrtsarri infection, the down-
modulation of granulomatous inf!am-
mation may be a result of the regulation of
Th2 responses by CDS’ T cells. Pearce
reported on his studies to elucidate the
cytokine cascade involved in granuloma
modulation and demonstrated that IL-4
promotes interferon y (IFN-y) production
by type 1 CDS’ T cells.
The differentiation of uncommitted T cells
towards a Thl phenotype is driven by IL-12.
In a wide range of models of infectious dis-
ease, IL-12 has been shown to confer pro-
tection when administered at the time of
infection. The combination of IL-12 and
Pe:ltostam (sodium siboqluconate), an
antimony-based drug commonly used for
the treatment of human leishmaniasis, in-
duces healing in Lrishmn~rin rr@tr--infected
mice even during progressive disease
13’. Scott, Philadelphia, PA). This finding
shows that IL-12 can switch an established
Th2 response to a protective Thl pattern
when the parasite ‘burden is reduced. It
should be noted, however, that the switch
occurs at the level of the T-cell population
and is probably based on a fraction of naive
cells or Thl cells rather than a change of
clonal phenotype.
Early after infection, L. mnjtlr stimulates
IL-12 production in genetically resistant and
in susceptible mice. By contrast, a strong
upregulation of IL-12-receptor expression is
only detected in resistant and not in suscep-
tible mice (Scott). The resulting limitation of
IL-12 responsiveness, which presumably
contributes to the lack of ThI development
in susceptible mice, can be overcome by ad-
ministration of exogenous IL-12, which in-
duces the upregulation of IL-12-receptor
expression.
An additional group of cytokines - the
chemokincs - has recently been shown to be
involved in microbial infections. Most of the
01 chemokines attr I- neutrophils, whereas
/3 chemokines ;_t o monocytes, lympho-
cyte subpopulations ,,nd naturai killer cells.
It was observed that in patients with Iocal-
ized cutaneous leishmaniasis, skin lesions
are characterized by high lewls of mono-
cyte chemoattractant protein 1 (MCP-1). By
contrast, expression of macrophage inflam-
matory protein la (MlP-la) predominates
in the non-healing lesions of diffuse cuta-
neous Ieishmaniasis (H. Moll, Wiirzburg).
This suggests that, in addition to the lym-
phokinc profile, the pattern of chemokine
expression correlates with the type of dis-
ease, extending the scope of candidates for
cytokine-based interventions.
Effector mechanisms
Cytokines such as IFN-y and TNF-ru. are
critical for the induction of effector mecha-
nisms that mediate the antimicrobial defense.
The bulk of evidence indicates that this ac-
tivity can be assigned to nitric oxide (NO) or
its reaction products. Notably, recent evi-
dence strongly suggests that NO-dependent
killing of infectious agents is also used by
human macrophages. NO is not only in-
volved in the elimination of microbes for
overcoming acute infections, but also re-
stricts the growth of organisms that per&l
in latently infected hosts. C. Bogdan
(Eriangcn) reported that FerGtpnce of L.
r~mjor in clinically cured mice is accompanied
by the sustained expression of cytokine-
inducible NO synthase CiNOS), and inhibition
of iNOS activity results in reactiv&iion <if CU-
taneous leishmaniasis. The majority of per-
sisting L&lJnln/?in is associated With iNOS
cells, some of which are possibly fibroblasts.
Studies in elihn showed that fibroblasts can
take up L. ~nnjor, but fail to kill the parasites.
IMMUNOLOGY TODAY
Genetic regulation of the host response to infections Natural resistance or susceptibility to infec-
tions with intracellular pathogens tmyco-
bacteria, Snlrrturzclln t!jpIz~i,nzrrizzrzz and L.
slozzowai) is determined by the gene Be‘s/
It!///_s/z, now designated Nmrrr/rl (natural-
resistance-associated macrophage protein 1).
This has been confirmed recently by experi-
ments with transgenic mice showing that a
Nrnzzrjrl construct derived from a resistant
strain confers the resistance phenotype to
an otherwise susceptible genetic back-
ground (E. Skamene, Montreal). Members
of the Nrnzrr/~ gene family have been iden-
tified in most species, uncovering an ancient
group of related Nramp proteins that are
presumed to be involved in membrane
transport or signal transduction. It has been
postulated that the Nrampl protein is local-
ized in the phagosome membrane of
macrophages, where it may transport a
charged substrate, possibly nitrate or nitrite,
to create an antimicrobial milieu.
The linkage between human NRAMPI
and susceptibi!ity to mycobacterial disease
is currently being analyzed. There is some
evidence for an association of NRAMPZ and
tuberculosis in epidemic outbreaks of the
disease, whereas no significant link was
found in endemic areas (Skamcnc). This
may reflect an involvement of NRAMPI in
early, natural susceptibility to tuberculosis.
Vaccination strategies For the development of an effective vaccine
against an infectious agent, it is necessary to
chara, :erize the type of immune response(s)
mediating protection, to identify the rel-
evant microbial antigens and to establish an
appropriate mode of delivery. All these
aspects were addressed at the meeting.
M.M. Simon (Freiburg) described the
mechanisms of immunity to Lyme disease,
which is caused by infection with the spiro-
chete B~rlrlin bzzr~&r~ri. The humoral im-
munity is essential for clearance of the bac-
teria, but T cells are critically involved in the
generation of an optimal antibody response.
B. bzrr@r@i may evade complete elimi-
nation by modulating its ?oat of outer
surface proteins (0s~) and binding host-
derived plasmin. This causes persistence
even in the presence of an ongoing immune
response.
invasion and tissue destruction by the
enteric parasite Ezztnt1zoeI7~ histd~tim is the
result of parasite adherence to and subse-
quent killing of host cells. Adherence is me-
diated by a surface lectin of the amoeba.
Vaccination trials in gerbils have shown that
a 125 amino acid fragment of the 170 kDa
subunit of this lectin confers protection
against amoebic liver abscesses (E. Tannich,
Hamburg). It is intriguing that this frag-
ment was recognized by about 80% of sera
from hsymptomatic E. Izi.~fol_~/ticn carriers but
only by 15% of sera from patients with
amoebic liver abscesses.
Over recent years, the development of
novel delivery systems has led to advanced
strategies for vaccination. These include
using IL-12 as an ndjuvant (Scott) and im-
munization with DNA such as a plasmid
encoding OspA of 6. btzr~~dorfcri (Simon). In
addition, specialized antigen-presenting
cells may be used for the generation of
immunity against parasite infections.
Dendritic cells are attractive candidates be-
.cause they have the unique capacity tcr in-
duce primary immune responses and retain
antigen in an immunogenic form for pro-
longed periods. The biological relevance of
this was shown in experimental cutaneous
leishmaniasis: treatment of mice with
dendritic cells that had been pulsed with
L. znzjclr antigen irz zlit~o induced resistance
against a subsequent challenge with virulent
parasites (Mall).
Future prospects Significant achievements have been made
with respect to the identification and mol-
ecular characterization of protective para-
site antigens and the dissection of immune
responses that mediate resistance or pathol-
ogy. However, parasite immunologists and
molecular biologists continue to face great
challenges. Many details of the mechanisms
that underlie antigenic variations remain
to be clarified, and the paradigm of lym-
phocyte subsets mediating detachable func-
tions with beneficial or detrimental effects
still needs critical evaluation. In the future,
the field of parasite immunology is ex-
pected to contribute further to our general
understanding of immunologically driven
disorders, since the features of parasite
infections closely resemble the general av-
enue taken by other, non-infectious chronic
diseases
Trends
The Trends section of Immunology Today covers up-to-date
developments and reports on recent immunologically relevant
meetings. If you would like your meeting to be reported by
lmmunofogy Today then please contact our Editorial Office at:
68 Hills Road
Cambridge
UK c52 IlA
Tel +44 I223 3 15962, Fax +44 I223 464430
e-maii [email protected]
D,ECEMBER 1996