ilsi blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

14
!"# %&’#(&)’*+&), -*.# /0*#&0#1 %&1’*’2’# 3%-/%45 ) 0+(6+()’# ,+778 9(+26 :2(+6#)& ;)(,*)<#&’ (#6+(’ +& :=/> 72?9#’ (*9"’.2,,8 @2?9#1 ,*&A1 ’+ %-/% )1 0+&B*0’1 +. *&’#(#1’ !"#$"#%&’ )*#"$’ +,-’#.%&"#/ 0 1%/ 2342 %&’(+?20’*+& 56’ &*#7"89 -*##"*:;8:< =":>8=&- "? 8:&’#’-& %& &6’ )*#"$’%: @""; A%?’&/ B*&6"#8&/ C)A@BD 6%- 8:=#’%-8:<9/ $*& &6’ -$"&98<6& ": &6’ #"9’ $9%/’; ,/ &6’ E:&’#:%&8":%9 F8?’ A=8’:=’- E:-&8&*&’ CEFAEDG ).’: &6"*<6 ?’H $’"$9’ 7%/ 6%.’ 6’%#; "? EFAEI 8& 6%- ,’’: % #’<*9%# $9%/’# 8: J#*--’9- -8:=’ 8& "$’:’; % )*#"$’%: "K=’ 8: 4LMNG EFAE H%- ?"*:;’; 8: &6’ O:8&’; A&%&’- 8: 4LPMI %:; 8& :"H %9-" 6%- "K=’- 8: B-8% %:; A"*&6QB7’#8=% %- H’99 %- )*#"$’G O:&89 #’=’:&9/I EFAE *-’; &" ;’-=#8,’ 8&-’9? %- !" $%& ’"()*%( +,( -.(,’%"* /*0.1)(&2 H6"-’ %87 8- &" !3./40 15/%*5% /* (%6.4"),(& "(%"12G 4 EFAE -%/- &6%&I ,/ ,#8:<8:< -=8’:&8-&- ?#"7 %=%;’78%I <".’#:7’:& %:; 8:;*-&#/ &"<’&6’#I 8& =#’%&’- !*%.)("4 +,("2 C&/$8=%99/ H"#R-6"$- %:; =":?’#’:=’-D H6’#’ &6’ ’S$’#&- =%: TU"8:&9/ $#".8;’ &6’ ,’-& %.%89%,9’ ?%=&Q,%-’;I ",U’=&8.’ -=8’:=’ ": R’/ $*,98= 6’%9&6 8--*’-VG 2 W"H’.’#I % #’=’:& #’$"#& X ,/ !"#$"#%&’ )*#"$’ +,-’#.%&"#/ C!)+D %:; )%#&6 +$’: A"*#=’ C)+AD 6%- -6"H: &6%& EFAEY- %=&8.8&8’- "?&’: %=& %- % .’68=9’ &" $#"7"&’ ,*-8:’--Q?#8’:;9/ Z-=8’:&8[=Y =":=’$&- %:; 7’&6";"9"<8’- &" ,’ 8:&#";*=’; 8:&" :’H ?""; %:; 6’%9&6 $"98=8’-G EFAE )*#"$’ 8- $#87%#89/ ?*:;’; ,/ 8&- 7’7,’# ="#$"#%&8":- 8:=9*;8:< JBA@I !"=%Q!"9%I \%:":’I ]#%?&I 1=\":%9;Y-I 1":-%:&"I ^’-&9_I A/:<’:&%I BU8:"7"&" C&6’ H"#9;Y- 9’%;8:< $#";*=’# "? %-$%#&%7’DI %:; O:89’.’#G B -7%99 $%#& "? 8&- 8:="7’ %9-" ="7’- ?#"7 )OQ?*:;’; #’-’%#=6 $#"U’=&-G B:; 8:;’’;I EFAEY- %#’%- "? H"#R 6%.’ &" ,’ %$$#".’; ,/ 8&- ="#$"#%&’ 7’7,’#-I %:; %#’ *-*%99/ =9"-’9/ #’9%&’; &" &6’ )O %<’:;%G ^"& -*#$#8-8:<9/I 6’#’ 8- H6’#’ )@AB ="7’- 8:G @#"7 )@ABY- 8:=’$&8": 8: 2332I &6’#’ 6%.’ ,’’: -&#":< 98:R- ,’&H’’: &6’ ?""; -%?’&/ %<’:=/ %:; EFAEG 1%:/ )@AB $%:’9 ’S$’#&-I 7’7,’#- "? &6’ -=8’:&8[= ="778&&’’ %:; &6’ 7%:%<’7’:& ,"%#; %#’ %=&8.’9/ 8:."9.’; 8: EFAEY- H"#RG !"# %&’#(&)’*+&), -*.# /0*#&0#1 %&1’*’2’# 3%-/%45 ) 0+(6+()’# ,+778 9(+26 C

Upload: dangminh

Post on 11-Feb-2017

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$

)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26

:2(+6#)&$;)(,*)<#&'$(#6+('$+&$:=/>$72?9#'$(*9"'.2,,8$@2?9#1$,*&A1$'+$

%-/%$)1$0+&B*0'1$+.$*&'#(#1'

!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(+,-'#.%&"#/(0(1%/(2342

%&'(+?20'*+&

56'(&*#7"89(-*##"*:;8:<(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&(%&(&6'()*#"$'%:(@"";(A%?'&/(B*&6"#8&/(C)A@BD(6%-(

8:=#'%-8:<9/($*&(&6'(-$"&98<6&(":(&6'(#"9'($9%/';(,/(&6'(E:&'#:%&8":%9(F8?'(A=8':='-(E:-&8&*&'(

CEFAEDG().':(&6"*<6(?'H($'"$9'(7%/(6%.'(6'%#;("?(EFAEI(8&(6%-(,'':(%(#'<*9%#($9%/'#(8:(J#*--'9-(

-8:='(8&("$':';(%()*#"$'%:("K='(8:(4LMNG(EFAE(H%-(?"*:;';(8:(&6'(O:8&';(A&%&'-(8:(4LPMI(%:;(8&(

:"H(%9-"(6%-("K='-(8:(B-8%(%:;(A"*&6QB7'#8=%(%-(H'99(%-()*#"$'G

O:&89(#'=':&9/I(EFAE(*-';(&"(;'-=#8,'(8&-'9?(%-(!"#$%&#'"()*%(#+,(#-.(,'%"*#/*0.1)(&2(H6"-'(%87(8-(

&"((!3./40#15/%*5%#/*#(%6.4"),(&#"(%"12G4(EFAE(-%/-(&6%&I(,/(,#8:<8:<(-=8':&8-&-(?#"7(%=%;'78%I(

<".'#:7':&(%:;(8:;*-&#/(&"<'&6'#I(8&(=#'%&'-(!*%.)("4#+,("2(C&/$8=%99/(H"#R-6"$-(%:;(

=":?'#':='-D(H6'#'(&6'('S$'#&-(=%:(TU"8:&9/($#".8;'(&6'(,'-&(%.%89%,9'(?%=&Q,%-';I(",U'=&8.'(

-=8':='(":(R'/($*,98=(6'%9&6(8--*'-VG2(W"H'.'#I(%(#'=':&(#'$"#&X(,/(!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(

+,-'#.%&"#/(C!)+D(%:;()%#&6(+$':(A"*#='(C)+AD(6%-(-6"H:(&6%&(EFAEY-(%=&8.8&8'-("?&':(%=&(%-(%(

.'68=9'(&"($#"7"&'(,*-8:'--Q?#8':;9/(Z-=8':&8[=Y(=":='$&-(%:;(7'&6";"9"<8'-(&"(,'(8:&#";*=';(

8:&"(:'H(?"";(%:;(6'%9&6($"98=8'-G(

EFAE()*#"$'(8-($#87%#89/(?*:;';(,/(8&-(7'7,'#(="#$"#%&8":-(8:=9*;8:<(JBA@I(!"=%Q!"9%I(\%:":'I(

]#%?&I(1=\":%9;Y-I(1":-%:&"I(^'-&9_I(A/:<':&%I(BU8:"7"&"(C&6'(H"#9;Y-(9'%;8:<($#";*='#("?(

%-$%#&%7'DI(%:;(O:89'.'#G`(B(-7%99($%#&("?(8&-(8:="7'(%9-"(="7'-(?#"7()OQ?*:;';(#'-'%#=6(

$#"U'=&-G(B:;(8:;'';I(EFAEY-(%#'%-("?(H"#R(6%.'(&"(,'(%$$#".';(,/(8&-(="#$"#%&'(7'7,'#-I(%:;(

%#'(*-*%99/(=9"-'9/(#'9%&';(&"(&6'()O(%<':;%G(

^"&(-*#$#8-8:<9/I(6'#'(8-(H6'#'()@AB(="7'-(8:G(@#"7()@ABY-(8:='$&8":(8:(2332I(&6'#'(6%.'(,'':(

-&#":<(98:R-(,'&H'':(&6'(?"";(-%?'&/(%<':=/(%:;(EFAEG(1%:/()@AB($%:'9('S$'#&-I(7'7,'#-("?(

&6'(-=8':&8[=(="778&&''(%:;(&6'(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(%#'(%=&8.'9/(8:."9.';(8:(EFAEY-(H"#RG

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 C

Page 2: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

EFAE(8-(-'':(%-(%:(8:;*-&#/(9",,/(<#"*$(,/(=%7$%8<:'#-(8:(&6'(OA(%:;()*#"$'I(%:;()@AB(6%-(

=9'%#9/(,'':(%($#87'(9",,/8:<(&%#<'&(?"#(EFAE()*#"$'G(J*&(EFAE(8&-'9?(-&#":<9/(;':8'-(&6%&(

a*%98[=%&8":(%:;(6%-(:"&(#'<8-&'#';(8:(&6'()*#"$'%:(b%#98%7':&(%:;(!"778--8":Y-(9",,/(

#'<8-&'#G(

E:(%(,#"=6*#'(='9',#%&8:<(EFAE()*#"$'Y-(2c&6(%::8.'#-%#/(8:(2344I(EFAE($#'-8;':&(d'#6%#;(

)8-':,#%:;(-%8;(&6%&(&6'("#<%:8-%&8":(!,'%(")%1#.*0%(#1)(/5)#(.4%1#,+#5,*0.5)#(%6"(0/*6#

,'%**%117#)("*1'"(%*5&7#0/154,1.(%#,+#/*)%(%1)1#"*0#'(,8/3/)/,*#,+#4,33&/*62(8:("#;'#(&"(

".'#="7'(%:/(-*-$8=8":(#'<%#;8:<(8&-(-=8':&8[=(",U'=&8.8&/Gc(

568-(=":&#".'#-/(-*##"*:;8:<(&6'($"98&8=%9(#"9'($9%/';(,/(EFAE(8-(($%#&8=*9%#9/($'#&8:':&(<8.':(

&6%&e

! )@AB(6%-(U*-&($#'-':&';(8&-(:'H(#*9'-(":(8:;'$':;':='(%:;(8-(%,"*&(&"(#':'H(&6'(

7'7,'#-68$("?('8<6&("*&("?(&':('S$'#&($%:'9-f(

! &6'()*#"$'%:(b%#98%7':&(8:(%(#'=':&(#'$"#&(6%-(;'[:';($%:'9(7'7,'#-(6%.8:<(98:R-(H8&6(

EFAE('S$98=8&9/(%-(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&f

! &6'()*#"$'%:(!"*#&("?(B*;8&"#-(8-(-"":(&"($*,98-6(8&-(#'$"#&(":(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&(%&(

)@AB(%:;("&6'#()O(%<':=8'-f

! &6'()*#"$'%:(!"778--8":(H899(&68-(/'%#(-&%#&(&"(#'.8'H()@ABY-(?"*:;8:<(#'<*9%&8":I(&6%&(

8-(%9-"(7'%:&(&"(<".'#:(8&-(8:;'$':;':='G

568-(,#8'[:<($#".8;'-(?*#&6'#('S$9%:%&8":(%-(&"(H6/(EFAE(-6"*9;(,'(#'<%#;';(%-(%:(8:;*-&#/(

9",,/(<#"*$f(H6/()@AB(%:;("&6'#()OQ#'9%&';('S$'#&-(-6"*9;(#'?#%8:(?#"7(6%.8:<(&8'-(H8&6(&68-(

<#"*$f(%:;(H6/(EFAE(-6"*9;(#'<8-&'#(8:(&6'()O(9",,/8:<(&#%:-$%#':=/(#'<8-&'#G(

CD$%-/%E1$F+(A$?#0*?#?$78$*&?21'(8

EFAE(6%-(%(J"%#;("?(\8#'=&"#-(%:;(%(A=8':&8[=(B;.8-"#/(!"778&&''(&6%&('%=6(6%.'(%:('a*%9(

:*7,'#("?(8:;*-&#/(%:;(:":Q8:;*-&#/(7'7,'#-I(-"7'&68:<(&6'("#<%:8-%&8":(-%/-(-%?'<*%#;-(8&-(

",U'=&8.8&/NG(W"H'.'#I(&6'(=6"8='("?(&"$8=-(%:;(;'.'9"$7':&("?(&6'(%=&*%9(H"#R(98'-(H8&6(&6'(EFAE(

&%-R(?"#='-(H68=6(%#'(%97"-&(':&8#'9/(="7$"-';("?(8:;*-&#/(#'$#'-':&%&8.'-G(5%-R(?"#='-(=%:(

8:.8&'(":'("#(&H"(:":Q8:;*-&#/('S$'#&-I(8?(;''7';(:'='--%#/G(@"#(8:-&%:='I(&6'(EFAE(&%-R(?"#='(":(

",'-8&/(8-(7%;'(*$("?('8<6&(8:;*-&#/(#'$#'-':&%&8.'-(?#"7(="7$%:8'-(8:=9*;8:<(^'-&9_I(\%:":'I(

!"=%Q!"9%I(]#%?&(%:;(Ag;h*=R'#IP(%:;(":'("*&-8;'(%=%;'78=GM

5%-R(?"#='-(*:;'#&%R'(%=&8.8&8'-(-*=6(%-(=":?'#':='-I(H"#R-6"$-I(%:;($*,98-6(#'$"#&-G(^'H(&%-R(

?"#='-(=%:(,'('-&%,98-6';(H8&6(&6'(%<#''7':&("?(&6'(J"%#;("?(\8#'=&"#-(%:;(&6'(A=8':&8[=(

B;.8-"#/(!"778&&''I(%:;(%#'(=":;8&8":%9(":(&6'(%$$#".%9("?(%&(9'%-&([.'(7'7,'#(="7$%:8'-GL(

568-(7'%:-(&6%&(EFAEY-(8:;*-&#/(7'7,'#-(?*99/(=":&#"9(H68=6(&"$8=-(EFAE(H"#R-(":G()S$'#&(<#"*$-(

%#'(&6':("?&':(?"#7';(&"(;"(&6'(%=&*%9(H"#RI(H8&6(!")#4%"1)2(6%9?("?(&6'(7'7,'#-("?('%=6(-%8;(&"(

,'(?#"7(%=%;'78%("#(<".'#:7':&G(56'-'(<#"*$-(6%.'(&"(?"99"H(&6'(&'#7-("?(#'?'#':='(%-(-'&(

"*&(,/(&6'(&%-R(?"#='G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 G

Page 3: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

E:;*-&#/(7'7,'#-("?('S$'#&(<#"*$-(%#'(:"&(#'87,*#-';(?"#(&6'8#(EFAE(%=&8.8&8'-G(J*&(:":Q8:;*-&#/(

'S$'#&(<#"*$(7'7,'#-(%#'("i'#';(#'87,*#-'7':&-(&"(=".'#(&6'(="-&-("?(%&&':;8:<(7''&8:<-I(

%#'($%8;(X33('*#"($'#(;%/(8?(&6'/(=6%8#I(#'$"#&("#(-$'%R(%&(%(H"#R-6"$I(%:;(#'='8.'(%:(

6":"#%#8*7("?(*$(&"(4I333('*#"(8?(&6'/(="Q%*&6"#(%:(EFAE($*,98=%&8":G43(

A"*#='e(EFAE(,#"=6*#'e(EFAE()*#"$'I(2c(/'%#-(&"H%#;-($*,98=(6'%9&6I(2344

GD$H),,*&9$)$16)?#$)$16)?#$I$)&?$%-/%$)$,+778$9(+26

B-(-%8;I(EFAE('S$98=8&9/(;':8'-(&6%&(8&(8-(%(9",,/(<#"*$G(56'("#<%:8-%&8":(6%-(8--*';(%(-$'=8%9(

-&%&'7':&(":(9",,/8:<(&6%&(-%/-e(!9%5".1%#:;<:#(%5%/=%1#"#>"?,(/)&#,+#/)1#,'%(")/*6#"*0#

(%1%"(58#+.*0/*6#+(,>#)8%#'(/=")%#1%5),(7#/)#/1#,+)%*#"11.>%0#/)#/1#"#4,33&/*6#,(6"*/@")/,*A#B8/1 #

/1#*,)#)(.%A#:;<:#0,%1#*,)#4,33&A#:;<:C1#D,0%#,+#-)8/51#"*0#E(6"*/@")/,*#<)"*0"(01#%F'(%114& #

'(,8/3/)#4,33&/*6#,*#3%8"4+#,+#"*#/*0/=/0."4#5,>'"*&#,(#6(,.'#,+#5,>'"*/%1A#G41,7#H8/4%#:;<: #

"0=,5")%1#)8%#.1%#,+#15/%*5%#/*#>"$/*6#0%5/1/,*1#)8")#"I%5)#)8%#8%"4)8#"*0#H%44#3%/*6#,+#)8%#

'.34/5#"*0#)8%#%*=/(,*>%*)7#/)#0,%1#*,)#>"$%#',4/5&#(%5,>>%*0")/,*1#,(#4,33&#+,(#1'%5/J5 #

',4/5&#0%5/1/,*1A244(

B&(&6'(-%7'(&87'(6"H'.'#I(&6'(EFAE(!";'("?()&68=-(-&%&'-e(!G0=,5"5&#,+#"*&#$/*0#/1#1)(/5)4&#

4/>/)%0#),#)8%#.1%#,+#%=/0%*5%K3"1%0#15/%*5%#"1#"*#"/0#/*#0%5/1/,*K>"$/*62G42(EFAE(&6'#'?"#'(

%;78&-(&"(=%##/8:<("*&(%;."=%=/I(%(.'#/(,#"%;(&'#7(<':'#%99/(#'?'##8:<(&"(8:>*':=8:<($*,98=(

$"98=/(%:;(;'=8-8":Q7%R8:<G(B;."=%=/(=%:(8:=9*;'(%=&8.8&8'-(#%:<8:<(?#"7(7';8%(=%7$%8<:-(&"(

$*,98-68:<(-=8':&8[=(%#&8=9'-(%:;(&#%;8&8":%9(9",,/8:<G(EFAE(6%-(=6"-':(&"(:%##"H(&6'(;'[:8&8":("?(

Z9",,/8:<Y(&"(%=&8.8&8'-(":9/(8:."9.8:<(;8#'=&(=":&%=&(H8&6(;'=8-8":Q7%R'#-(8:("#;'#(&"(%."8;(

,'8:<(9%,'99';(&6%&(H%/G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 J

Page 4: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

E:(&6'(;8-=*--8":(":(9",,/8:<I(&6'()O(8:-&8&*&8":-(*-*%99/(#'?'#(&"(T8:&'#'-&(#'$#'-':&%&8":VI(

H68=6(8-(%(7"#'(:'*&#%9(,*&(%9-"(%(,#"%;'#(&'#7(&6%:(T9",,/8:<VG(E&(8-(;'[:';(,/(&6'()*#"$'%:(

!"778--8":(%-(!"5)/=/)/%1#5"((/%0#,.)#H/)8#)8%#,3?%5)/=%#,+#/*L.%*5/*6#)8%#',4/5&#+,(>.4")/,*#

"*0#0%5/1/,*K>"$/*6#'(,5%11%1#,+#)8%#-.(,'%"*#/*1)/).)/,*12G4X#

E:(j*:'(2344(&6'()*#"$'%:(b%#98%7':&(%:;(!"778--8":(9%*:=6';(%(U"8:&(T&#%:-$%#':=/(

#'<8-&'#VI(%878:<(&"($#".8;'(8:?"#7%&8":(!,*#)8,1%#H8,#1%%$#),#/*L.%*5%#-.(,'%"*#',4/5&2G4`(

)*#"$'%:(!"778--8":(.8='Q$#'-8;':&(1%#"k(l'?m".8m(-%8;(%&(&6'(&87'e(!G44#,(6"*/1")/,*17#

H8%)8%(#)("0%#"*0#'(,+%11/,*"4#"11,5/")/,*17#MNE17#)8/*$#)"*$1#,(#,)8%(1#H8,#8"=%#*,)8/*6#), #

8/0%#H/44#3%#/*#)8%#(%6/1)%(#"*0#H/44#'(,=/0%#)8%#'.34/5#"*0#)8%#/*1)/).)/,*1#H/)8#/*+,(>")/,*#

"3,.)#)8%/(#H,($A#G44#)8,1%#H8,#"(%#*,)#/*#)8%#(%6/1)%(#H/44#8"=%#),#3%#"1$%0#H8&#)8%&#5"*C)#3%#

)("*1'"(%*)#K#"*0#)8%&#H/44#1%%#)8%/(#0"/4&#H,($#>"0%#>,(%#0/O5.4)#3&#*,)#3%/*6#(%6/1)%(%0#

nGGGoVG4c

p6%&'.'#(&6'(-$'=8[=(H"#;8:<I(&6'('--':='(8-(H6'&6'#(&6'(<"%9("?(%:("#<%:8-%&8":(8-(&"(

8:>*':='($*,98=($"98=/(%:;(;'=8-8":(7%R8:<G(B:;(&68-(8:=9*;'-(<#"*$-(-*=6(%-(EFAE(&6%&I(8:-&'%;(

"?(R:"=R8:<(":(<".'#:7':&(;""#-(":(%(;%89/(,%-8-I(8:.8&'(<".'#:7':&('S$'#&-(&"(&6'8#("H:(

8:;*-&#/Q?*:;';('.':&-I($*,98-6($%$'#-(H68=6(&6'/(7%R'(%.%89%,9'(&"($"98=/Q7%R'#-(%:;(

#'<*9%&"#/(,";8'-(-*=6(%-()@ABI(%:;(H68=6(#'<*9%#9/(-*,78&(="77':&-(&"($*,98=(=":-*9&%&8":-(

":(:'H($"98=8'-G(56'(="-&-("?(#*::8:<(%:("#<%:8-%&8":(98R'(EFAE(%#'(,"#:'(,/(EFAEY-(="#$"#%&'(

7'7,'#-G(56'/(H"*9;(:"&($%/(8?(&6'#'(H'#'(:"(,':'[&-(?"#(&6'7(0(%:;(%-(H'(6%.'(-'':I(&6'/(

<':'#%99/(;'=8;'(&6'(&"$8=-(EFAE(H"#R-(":G(

^"&(-*#$#8-8:<9/I(EFAE(6%-(:"&(-8<:';(*$(&"(&6'()O(&#%:-$%#':=/(#'<8-&'#G(A8789%#9/I(="#$"#%&'Q

?*:;';(&68:R(&%:R-(-*=6(%-(@#8':;-("?()*#"$'(6%.'(=9%87';(8:(&6'($%-&(&6%&(&6'/(-6"*9;(:"&(

6%.'(&"(#'<8-&'#(%-(%=="#;8:<(&"(&6'7I(&6'/(H'#'(:"&(9",,/(<#"*$-(%-(&6'/(;8;(:"&(#'$#'-':&(

%:/(-$'=8[=(8:&'#'-&-(,*&(8:-&'%;(,*&($#".8;';(;',%&8:<($9%&?"#7-G(J*&(%=="#;8:<(&"(

!"778--8":'#(A887(]%99%-I(#'-$":-8,9'(?"#(-'&&8:<(*$(&6'(&#%:-$%#':=/(#'<8-&'#I(&68:R(&%:R-(

H'#'(!%F'4/5/)4&#"*0#0%4/3%(")%4&#/*54.0%0#/*#)8%#)"(6%)#6(,.'2G(d8.':(&6'($"98&8=%99/(-&#%&'<8=(

:%&*#'(%:;(&878:<("?(&6'(;',%&'-I(&68-($"-8&8":(H%-(6%#;(&"(=6%99':<'(?"#(@#8':;-("?()*#"$'I(%:;(

&6'/('.':&*%99/(<%.'(8:(%:;(#'<8-&'#';(8:(A'$&'7,'#(2344G

JD$%-/%E1$*&B2#&0#$+&$6+,*08I<)A*&9

OA(<#"*$-(6%.'(,'':(%H%#'("?(&6'(:%&*#'("?(EFAEY-(%=&8.8&8'-(?"#(-'.'#%9(/'%#-G(@#"7(8&-(

8:='$&8":(8:(4LPM(*:&89(4LL4I(EFAE(H%-(6'%;';(8:(&6'(OA(,/(B9'S(1%9%-$8:%I(H6"(H%-(

-87*9&%:'"*-9/(&6'(.8='($#'-8;':&("?(!"=%Q!"9%G(W'(H%-(%,9'(&"($"-8&8":(EFAE(%-(%:(^d+(!/*#

,O5/"4#(%4")/,*12(H8&6(&6'(p"#9;(W'%9&6(+#<%:8-%&8":(CpW+D(%:;(H8&6(=":-*9&%&8.'(-&%&*-(%&(&6'(

@"";(%:;(B<#8=*9&*#'(+#<%:8-%&8":("?(&6'(O:8&';(^%&8":-(C@B+DG(W"H'.'#I(&6'(pW+(5",%=="(@#''(

E:8&8%&8.'((#'$"#&';(":(EFAEY-(?*:;8:<(?#"7(&6'(&",%=="(8:;*-&#/(8:(2334I(-6"H8:<(&6%&(&68-(9';(&"(

'i"#&-(&"(&6H%#&(&",%=="(=":&#"9($"98=8'-G4N(

E:(233c(&6'(^%&*#%9(q'-"*#='-(\'?':='(!"*:=89I(b6/-8=8%:-(?"#(A"=8%9(q'-$":-8,898&/I(&6'(J#'%-&(

!%:='#(@*:;I(E:&'#:%&8":%9(@';'#%&8":("?(j"*#:%98-&-I():.8#":7':&%9(p"#R8:<(d#"*$I(O:8&';(

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 K

Page 5: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

A&''9H"#R'#-("?(B7'#8=%I(%:;("&6'#(<#"*$-(H#"&'(%(9'&&'#(&"(&6'(pW+I(",U'=&8:<(&"(EFAEY-(#"9'(8:(

-'&&8:<(-&%:;%#;-(?"#(?"";(%:;(H%&'#G4P(56'(9'&&'#(-%8;(&6%&(!B8%#PQE#"*0#,)8%(#'.34/5#8%"4)8#

"6%*5/%1#(/1$#)8%/(#15/%*)/J5#5(%0/3/4/)&#"*0#>"&#3%#5,>'(,>/1/*6#'.34/5#8%"4)8#3&#'"()*%(/*6#

H/)8#:;<:r(%:;(&6%&(EFAE(!8"1#"#0%>,*1)(")%0#8/1),(&#,+#'.))/*6#)8%#/*)%(%1)1#,+#/)1#%F54.1/=%4&#

5,(',(")%#>%>3%(18/'#"8%"0#,+#15/%*5%#"*0#8%"4)8#5,*5%(*1VG(E:(233N(&6'(pW+(;'=8;';(&6%&(

EFAE(="*9;(:"(9":<'#(&%R'($%#&(8:(pW+(%=&8.8&8'-(-'&&8:<(-%?'&/(-&%:;%#;-(?"#(?"";(%:;(H%&'#I(

,'=%*-'("?(8&-(?*:;8:<(-"*#='-G

B(2344(#'$"#&(,/()%#&6(+$':(A"*#='(=":=9*;';(&6%&(EFAEY-(!*%.)("4#+,("2(8:(?%=&($#"7"&';(

8:;*-&#/Q?#8':;9/(-=8':&8[=(H%/-("?('.%9*%&8:<(&6'(-%?'&/("?(%($#";*=&(&"(<".'#:7':&('S$'#&-G(

56'(#'$"#&(?"*:;(&6%&(EFAEY-($#"$"-%9-(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&(?"99"H';(%(&#':;("?(7%R8:<(-%?'&/(

&'-&8:<($#"=';*#'-(9'--(#8<"#"*-(%:;(=6'%$'#(?"#(8:;*-&#/(0(%&(&6'('S$':-'("?($*,98=(6'%9&6(%:;(

&6'(':.8#":7':&G

p689'(EFAE(=9%87-(8&(;"'-(:"&(-':;(#'="77':;%&8":-("#("$8:8":-(&"()O(8:-&8&*&8":-("#("K=8%9-I(

&6'/("?&':(<8.'(T-=8':&8[=(8:$*&V(8:($*,98=(=":-*9&%&8":-A#E:(#'-$":-'(&"()@ABY-($*,98=(

=":-*9&%&8":(":#8&-($"98=/(":(8:;'$':;':='7#EFAE(#'="77':;';(%(=6%:<'(8:(&6'(&'S&(":($*,98=Q

$#8.%&'($%#&:'#-68$-(&"($"#&#%/(&6'7(7"#'($"-8&8.'9/e(!R.34/5K'(/=")%#'"()*%(18/'1#"(%#"*#

%1)"34/18%0#+%").(%#,+#(%1%"(58#/*#)8%#-S#"*0#H,(40H/0%A#B8%&#6(%")4&#1)/>.4")%#/**,=")/,*#

T%A6A#E-DU#VWWXY#"*0#)8%(%3&#8.>"*#'(,6(%11A#nGGGoV4M#568-(EFAE(#'="77':;%&8":I(%=='$&';(,/(

)@AB(8:(-"7'H6%&(;8i'#':&(H"#;8:<I(=%::"&(,'(#'<%#;';(%-(Z-=8':&8[=(8:$*&Y(<8.':(8&-($"98&8=%9(

:%&*#'I(#'>'=&8:<(8:;*-&#/Y-(H8-6(&"(*-'(&6'-'($%#&:'#-68$-(&"(?%=898&%&'(&6'(="#$"#%&'(=%$&*#'("?(

)O(#'-'%#=6(?*:;-G4L

EFAE(6%-(%9-"(%&&'7$&';(&"($#''7$&(;8-=*--8":-(":(#'<*9%&8":(&"(="7,%&(",'-8&/(,/(-"H8:<(

;"*,&(&6%&(",'-8&/(8-(:'='--%#89/(98:R';(&"(=%9"#8'(8:&%R'I($#"7"&8:<(&6'(.8'H(&6%&(7"#'($6/-8=%9(

'S'#=8-'(8-(&6'(-"9*&8":G(56'(EFAE(",'-8&/(&%-R(?"#='(%-(7':&8":';(%,".'(8-(7%;'(*$("?(

#'$#'-':&%&8.'-(?#"7(%(:*7,'#("?(="7$%:8'-(&6%&(7%R'(6*<'($#"[&-(,/(-'998:<(.%-&(a*%:&8&8'-(

"?(68<6Q=%9"#8'($#";*=&-I(-*=6(%-(!"=%Q!"9%(%:;(1%#-G(

B-('%#9/(%-(2333I(%:(EFAE(#'$"#&23(-&%&';(&6%&(-=8':&8[=(;%&%(<%.'(!*,#0%J*/)%#5,*54.1/,*1#

5,*5%(*/*6#)8%#5,*)(/3.)/,*#,+#+,,0#/*)"$%#'%(#1%#),#)8%#/*5(%"1/*6#'(%="4%*5%#,+#,3%1/)&2A(56'(

#'$"#&(=9%87';(&6%&(!,3%1/)&#>"&#3%#3%))%(#5,((%4")%0#H/)8#/*0/5"),(1#,+#'8&1/5"4#"5)/=/)&#)8"*#

H/)8#%*%(6&#/*)"$%12A(E:(2344I(H689'(%;78&&8:<(&6%&(",'-8&/(8-(%(7%U"#(=":='#:(?"#($*,98=(6'%9&6I(

&6'(EFAE(&%-R(?"#='(H#"&'(!)8%#.*0%(4&/*6#5".1%1#/*54.0/*6#)8%#(,4%#,+#5%()"/*#+,,01#/*#)8%#0/%)#

"*0#,)8%(#4/+%1)&4%#+"5),(1#"(%#1)/44#1.3?%5)#),#5,*1/0%("34%#0%3")%A2#B=="#;8:<(&"(&6'(&%-R(?"#='I(

&68-(H%-(;*'I(8:($%#&I#!),#)8%#4"5$#,+#15/%*)/J5#0")"#3.)#"41,#),#)8%#',4/)/5"4#*").(%#,+#)8%#/11.%A2#

56'(a*'-&8":(&6':(="*9;(,'($"-';(%-(&"(H6/(EFAE(%-(%(Z:'*&#%9($9%&?"#7(?"#($*,98=(6'%9&6Y(6%-(

:"&(7%:%<';(&"($#"7"&'(#'-'%#=6(&"(,'(;":'(&"(=#'%&'(7"#'(='#&%8:&/(%,"*&(&6'(#'9%&8":-68$(

,'&H'':(",'-8&/(%:;(=":-*78:<(68<6(=%9"#8'(?"";($#";*=&-(98R'(1%#-(,%#-G

E:(2343I(EFAEI(98R'(7"-&(,*-8:'--(9",,8'-(8:(J#*--'9-I(68#';(%(bq(%<':=/(?"#(="77*:8=%&8":-I(8:(

&68-(=%-'(?"#(&6'(;'.'9"$7':&("?(%:(EFAE(:'H-9'&&'#G(EFAE(=6"-'(B-$'=&(!":-*9&8:<24(%:(%<':=/(

H68=6($#'.8"*-9/(7%:%<';(&6'(d'"#<8%:(<".'#:7':&Y-(7';8%(#'9%&8":-(H8&6(&6'(p'-&(;*#8:<(

&6'(H%#(,'&H'':(&6'(q*--8%:(%:;(d'"#<8%:(<".'#:7':&-22G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 L

Page 6: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

KD$!"#$:=/>I%-/%$0+&&#0'*+&

B=&8.'(="99%,"#%&8":(H8&6(EFAE(-''7-(&"(,'(':;'78=(%7":<()@ABY-($%:'9('S$'#&-I(-=8':&8[=(

="778&&''(7'7,'#-(%:;(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(7'7,'#-G(56'/(6%.'(U"8:';(EFAE(&%-R(?"#='-(%:;(

H"#R8:<(<#"*$-I(%*&6"#';(8:>*':&8%9(EFAE(#'$"#&-(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&I(=6%8#(-'--8":-(%&(EFAE(

=":?'#':='-I("#(%#'(7'7,'#-("?(EFAEY-(,"%#;("?(;8#'=&"#-G

! 9,"(0#,+#0/(%5),(1Z#9[*[)/#"*0#\,=[]

E:(2343()@ABY-(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(%=R:"H9';<';(&6%&(8:."9.'7':&(H8&6(EFAE(="*9;(9'%;(&"(

=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&G(p6':(&6'(=6%8#("?()@ABY-(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(\8%:%(Js:s&8(-&'$$';(;"H:(

?#"7(6'#(#"9'(%&(EFAEI(&6'(,"%#;(-%8;(&6%&(-6'(6%;(!(%1/6*%0#+(,>#',1/)/,*1#H8/58#>"&#5(%")%#"#

',)%*)/"4#5,*L/5)#,+#/*)%(%1)1#H/)8#-^<G#"5)/=/)/%1A2()@AB(%;;';(&6%&(&6'(=6%8#("?(&6'(

7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(-6"*9;(:"&(6%.'(%(#"9'(8:(%:("#<%:8-%&8":(!(%'(%1%*)/*6#/*)%(%1)1#,+#)8%#

+,,0#58"/*7#,)8%(#)8"*#'.34/5#/*)%(%1)12AV_

W"H'.'#I()@AB(%$$%#':&9/([:;-(8&(%=='$&%,9'(?"#("&6'#(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(7'7,'#-(&"(6"9;(

9'%;8:<($"-8&8":-(8:(EFAEG(p6':(189%:(]".sm(;'=9%#';(68-(7'7,'#-68$("?(EFAEY-(,"%#;("?(;8#'=&"#-(

8:(1%#=6(2344I(:"(a*'#8'-(H'#'(7':&8":';(8:(&6'(78:*&'-(%,"*&(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&G(@"99"H8:<(

7';8%(-=#*&8:/I(6'(9'?&(&6'(EFAE(,"%#;(8:(j*9/(2344G(

! -F'%()#'"*%41Z#+,,0#"00/)/=%17#'%1)/5/0%17#N`E1#"*0#'"5$"6/*6#>")%(/"41

#

B(j*:'(2344(!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(+,-'#.%&"#/(#'$"#&(":(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&(%7":<(7'7,'#-("?(

)@ABY-(?"";(%;;8&8.'-($%:'9(CB^AD(?"*:;(&6%&((-8S("*&("?(&6'(23(7'7,'#-(6%;(%=&8.'(

="99%,"#%&8":-(H8&6(EFAEI(8:=9*;8:<(&6'(.8='Q=6%8#(C:"H(&6'(=6%8#D(E."::'(q8'&U':-G(@"*#("?(&6'(-8S(

?%89';(&"(;'=9%#'(&6'-'(EFAE(8:&'#'-&-(&"()@ABG(O:;'#()@AB(#*9'-I(?%89*#'(&"(;8-=9"-'(!"0=/5%#,(#

1%(=/5%1#/*#"#'"()/5.4"(#J%40#+"44/*6#H/)8/*#-^<GC1#(%>/)2I2`('.':(8?(*:$%8;I(=%:(9'%;(&"(&6'(

'S$'#&Y-(;8-78--%9(0(,*&(8:(&6'-'(=%-'-(;8;(:"&G

B(2344(#'$"#&(,/()%#&6(+$':(A"*#='('S$"-';(6"H(&H"(#'=':&(7'7,'#-(%:;(":'(=*##':&(

7'7,'#("?()@ABY-($'-&8=8;'(CbbqD($%:'9(0(B:<'9"(1"#'&&"I(B9%:(J"",8-(%:;(56'";"#*-(J#"=R(0(

%9-"(6%;(=9"-'(&8'-(&"(EFAEG2c

B:"&6'#(2344(#'$"#&2N(,/(!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(+,-'#.%&"#/(-6"H';(&6%&([.'(7'7,'#-("?(&6'(d1+(

$%:'9(%=&8.'(8:(233L(CH68=6(%$$#".';(&6'(B7>"#%($"&%&"D(6%;($%-&("#(=*##':&(&8'-(&"(EFAEe(W%##/(

]*8$'#(C=6%8#DI(d8U-(]9'&'#I(W%:-(!6#8-&'#(B:;'#--":I(j'#'7/(AH''&I(%:;(j'%:Q18=6'9(p%9G(

!"99%,"#%&8":-(#%:<';(?#"7(%*&6"#8:<(R'/(EFAE(#'$"#&-(&"(,'8:<(%(7'7,'#("?(%:(EFAE(H"#R8:<(

<#"*$G(5H'9.'(7'7,'#-("?(&6'(24Q-&#":<($%:'9(H'#'(?"*:;(&"(6%.'(98:R-(&"(8:;*-&#/G

A8789%#9/I(?"*#(7'7,'#-("?(&6'(?"";($%=R%<8:<($%:'9(C&6'(!)@($%:'9D(H'#'(8:."9.';(8:(EFAE(

%=&8.8&8'-(":(?"";($%=R%<8:<G(q"9%:;(@#%:h(8-(%(7'7,'#("?(&6'(-=8':&8[=(="778&&''("?(EFAEY-(

E:&'#:%&8":%9(A/7$"-8*7(":(@"";(b%=R%<8:<(;*'(&"(,'(6'9;(8:(J'#98:(9%&'#(&68-(/'%#2PI(%:;(

F%*#':='(!%-&9'(="Q%*&6"#';(%:(EFAE(-&*;/(":(T)-&87%&8:<(=":-*7'#('S$"-*#'(&"(=6'78=%9-(

78<#%&8:<(?#"7($%=R%<8:<(7%&'#8%9-VG2M

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 M

Page 7: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

! -^<GC1#<5/%*)/J5#D,>>/))%%#"*0#-^<GC1#P,($/*6#N(,.'#,*#BBD

B:"&6'#(2344(#'$"#&2LI(&68-(&87'(,/(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#R(CbB^D()*#"$'I(#'.'%9';(&6%&("?(&6'(

4X(7'7,'#-(":(&6'()@AB(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(":(&6'(T&6#'-6"9;("?(&"S8="9"<8=%9(=":='#:V(C55!DI(%:(

8:;*-&#/Q;#8.':(%$$#"%=6(&"(%99"H('S$"-*#'(&"(9'.'9-("?(=6'78=%9-(H8&6"*&(&"S8="9"<8=%9(&'-&8:<I(

'8<6&(6%;(?"#7%9(="::'=&8":-(&"(EFAEG(55!(6%-(,'':($#"7"&';(%:;(;'.'9"$';(,/(EFAE(?"#(".'#(%(

;'=%;'G(

56'-'(="99%,"#%&8":-(6%.'(:"&(,'':(H8&6"*&(87$%=&G(@"#('S%7$9'I(EFAE(8-(%==*-';("?e

! E:>*':=8:<()@ABY-(#'="77':;%&8":-(?"#(&6'(#8-R(%--'--7':&("?($'-&8=8;'-I(8:=9*;8:<(

H%&'#8:<(;"H:(&6'(-"Q=%99';(Z;%&%(#'a*8#'7':&-Y(C&'-&-(8:;*-&#/(6%-(&"(;"(8:(-*$$"#&("?(

8&-(%$$98=%&8":-(?"#(%$$#".%9DG(CA''(B::'S(4D

! p'%R':8:<()@ABY-(<*8;'98:'-(?"#(&6'(#8-R(%--'--7':&("?(d1(=#"$-G(CA''(B::'S(2D

! b#"7"&8:<(&6'(55!(=":='$&G()@AB(;'=8;';(&"(<8.'(%:("$8:8":(":(55!(":(8&-("H:(8:8&8%&8.'(

C:"&(8:(#'-$":-'(&"(%(#'a*'-&(,/(%($*,98=(%*&6"#8&/D(%:;(&6'(8:8&8%9("$8:8":(H%-(

?%."*#%,9'G(CA''(B::'S(XDG(B:"&6'#(8--*'("?(=":='#:(8-(&6'(="99%,"#%&8":(,'&H'':()@AB(

%:;(EFAE(":(&6'(1%#<8:("?()S$"-*#'(C1+)D(=":='$&G(CA''(B::'S(`DG(

)@AB(6%-(%9-"(<#%:&';(EFAE(=#';8,898&/(%-(%(T-=8':&8[=V("#<%:8-%&8":(,/("#<%:8-8:<(U"8:&('.':&-I(

$%/8:<('S$'#&-(&"(%&&':;(EFAE('.':&-(%:;(,/(,'8:<("K=8%99/(#'$#'-':&';(":(EFAE(H"#R8:<(<#"*$-G(

E:(233cI(?"#('S%7$9'I()@AB(%:;(&6'(p"#9;(W'%9&6(+#<%:8-%&8":(CpW+D("#<%:8-';(%(=":?'#':='(8:(

J#*--'9-(!H/)8#)8%#1.'',()#,+#)8%#:*)%(*")/,*"4#;/+%#<5/%*5%1#:*1)/).)%2(":(&6'(#8-R(%--'--7':&(

"?(-*,-&%:='-(&6%&(=%:(,"&6(;%7%<'(\^B(%:;(=%*-'(=%:='#G()@AB(6%-(%9-"($%8;('S$'#&-(&"(&%R'(

$%#&(8:(EFAE(%=&8.8&8'-G(@"";($%=R%<8:<($%:'9('S$'#&(1":%QF8-'(J8:;'#*$(-&%&'-(8:(6'#(;'=9%#%&8":(

"?(8:&'#'-&-(&6%&(-6'(H%-(!'"/0#3&#-^<G2(&"($%#&8=8$%&'(8:(%:(EFAE('.':&(!"1#"#(%'(%1%*)")/=%#,+#

-^<GC1#H,($/*6#6(,.'#,*#*"*,)%58*,4,6&2GX3

LD$N:;1$)&?$:=/>O$,*&A1$'+$%-/%$<#)&$)$0+&B*0'$+.$*&'#(#1'1$

E:(1%#=6(2342I(&6'()*#"$'%:(b%#98%7':&(,*;<'&(="778&&''(%;"$&';(%(#'$"#&(":()@ABY-(,*;<'&(

%:;(?"#(&6'([#-&(&87'(7%;'('S$98=8&(-&%&'7':&-(":(&6'(9",,/8:<(#"9'("?(EFAEG(q%$$"#&'*#(1":8=%(

1%=".'8(-*=='--?*99/(%#<*';(?"#($"-&$":8:<()@ABY-(,*;<'&(%$$#".%9I(;'7%:;8:<(&6%&()@AB(

!5,*1/0%(#"1#"#5,*L/5)#,+#/*)%(%1)#)8%#5.((%*)#,(#(%5%*)#'"1)#'"()/5/'")/,*#,+#/)1#`"*"6%>%*)#

9,"(07#'"*%4#"*0#H,($/*6#6(,.'#>%>3%(1#,(#1)"I#/*#:;<:#"5)/=/)/%1#1.58#"1#)"1$#+,(5%17 #

15/%*)/J5#5,>>/))%%1#,(#58"/(1#+,(#5,*+%(%*5%12AX4(

56'(#'$"#&(%9-"(!(%5"441#)8")#)8%#5.((%*)#D8"/(#,+#)8%#`"*"6%>%*)#9,"(0#+"/4%07#/*#VWaW7#),#

0%54"(%#8%(#>%>3%(18/'#,+#)8%#9,"(0#,+#U/(%5),(1#,+#:;<:b#*,)%1#)8")#:;<:#/1#J*"*5%0#3&#J(>1#/*#

)8%#+,,07#58%>/5"4#"*0#'8"(>"5%.)/5"4#1%5),(12A(

568-(7'%:-(&6%&(8?()@ABY-('S$'#&-(;"(:"&(,#'%R(&6'8#('S8-&8:<(&8'-(H8&6(EFAE(8:(&6'(:'%#(?*&*#'I(

)@ABY-(,*;<'&(="*9;(,'(,9"=R';G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 P

Page 8: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

^'H(#*9'-(8:&#";*=';(,/()@AB(8:(1%#=6(2342(H899(%9-"(7%R'(EFAEY-(98?'(7"#'(;8K=*9&(?#"7(:"H(

":G(E&(-''7-(&6%&(*:;'#(&6'-'(#*9'-I()@AB(-&%i(%:;('S$'#&-t(%=&8.8&8'-(H8&6(EFAE(H899(,'(

=":-8;'#';(Z%;(6"=(=":-*9&%:=/YX2G(B;(6"=(=":-*9&%:=/(H899(:"(9":<'#(,'(%99"H';('8&6'#(8:(&6'(

$%-&(%:;($#'-':&(?"#(=6%8#-(%:;(.8='(=6%8#-("?($%:'9-I(%:;(H899(":9/(,'(%99"H';(8:(&6'($%-&(?"#(

"#;8:%#/($%:'9(7'7,'#-GXX

568-(8-(%:(87$"#&%:&(87$#".'7':&(":(&6'($#'.8"*-(-8&*%&8":I(6"H'.'#(8&(H"*9;(6%.'(,'':('.':(

,'&&'#(8?(#'=':&(EFAE(%=&8.8&8'-(H"*9;(%9-"(,'(,%::';(?"#("#;8:%#/($%:'9(7'7,'#-G(B9-"I(8&(

#'7%8:-(&"(,'(-'':(6"H(&6'(#*9'-(H899($9%/("*&(8:($#%=&8='G

EFAE(="7$9%8:';(%,"*&(&68-(%&()@ABY-(-&%R'6"9;'#(?"#*7(7''&8:<(8:(1%#=6(2342I(%#<*8:<(&6%&(

&6'/(-6"*9;(#%&6'#(,'(-'':(%-(%=&8.8&8'-(8:(%(-=8':&8[=(%;.8-"#/(,";/GX`

MD$H+&0,21*+&

EFAEY-(%&&'7$&-(&"(7%8:&%8:(8&-(87%<'(%-(,'8:<(%(Z:'*&#%9($9%&?"#7Y(?"#('S$'#&-(&"(7''&(%#'(

*:98R'9/(&"(H"#R(%:/(9":<'#G(EFAE(7%/(6%.'(#'=':&9/(=6%:<';(8&-(-'9?Q;'-=#8$&8":(?#"7(!$%&#

'"()*%(#+,(#-.(,'%"*#/*0.1)(&2#&"(!$%&#'"()*%(#+,(#15/%*5%#/*#'.34/5#8%"4)82(":(8&-(H',-8&'IXc(8&(

-''7-(&"(,'(&""(9%&'(?"#(&68-(-$8:(&"(-&899(?""9(%:/":'G

EFAE()*#"$'(8-(%:(8:;*-&#/Q;#8.':("#<%:8-%&8":(&6%&(%87-(&"(8:>*':='(&6'()O(;'=8-8":Q7%R8:<(

$#"='--(,/(&#/8:<(&"(=#'%&'(a*'-&8":%,9'(Z-=8':&8[=(=":-':-*-Y(":(8--*'-(&6%&(%#'(87$"#&%:&(&"(

&6'8#(?"";(%:;(,8"&'=6(8:;*-&#/(7'7,'#-G(p6'&6'#(":'(=%99-(H6%&(EFAE(%87-(&"(;"(Z8:&'#'-&(

#'$#'-':&%&8":YI(Z%;."=%=/Y("#(Z9",,/8:<YI(EFAE(7*-&(#'<8-&'#(":(&6'()OY-(9",,/8:<(&#%:-$%#':=/(

#'<8-&'#I(8;':&8?/8:<(=9'%#9/(H6%&($"98=/(8--*'-(8&(%87-(&"(8:>*':='I(6"H(7*=6(7":'/(8&(#'='8.'-(

?"#(&6%&(%:;(?#"7(H6"7G

)O(8:-&8&*&8":-(%:;(%<':=8'-(-6"*9;(#'?#%8:(?#"7(6%.8:<(&#8'-(&"(EFAEG(EFAEY-(87$%=&(":()O(

;'=8-8":(7%R8:<(-6"*9;(,'(8:.'-&8<%&';(%:;($#"$'#9/(%=&';(":G(56%&(EFAEY-(=%$&*#'("?(&6'(

#'<*9%&"#/(-=8':='(%<':;%(#'9%&';(&"()@ABY-(H"#R(8-(:"H(#'="<:8-';(,/(&6'()*#"$'%:(

b%#98%7':&(,*;<'&(="778&&''(%:;(,/()@AB(8&-'9?(8-(%(<#'%&(-&'$(?"#H%#;(?"#()O(=8&8h':-G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 Q

Page 9: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

>&&#R$C$I$S+F$%-/%$*&B2#&0#?$:=/>E1$(#0+<<#&?)'*+&1$.+($'"#$(*1A$

)11#11<#&'$+.$6#1'*0*?#1O$'"#$<+21#$0)(0*&+9#&*0*'8$1'2?8

E:(%(#'=':&(#'$"#&IXN()%#&6(+$':(A"*#='('S$9%8:';(6"H(":'(-=8':&8[=("$8:8":(?#"7()@ABY-(b%:'9(

":(b9%:&(b#"&'=&8":(b#";*=&-(%:;(&6'8#(q'-8;*'-(Cbbq($%:'9D(8:(233P(H%-(8:>*':=';(,/(%:(EFAE(

W)AE(&%-R(?"#='e

56'(bbq(b%:'9(-*<<'-&-(&6%&(8:;*-&#/(="*9;(U'&&8-":(&6'(4Q/'%#(;"<(-&*;/(%:;(&6'(7"*-'(

=%#=8:"<':8=8&/(-&*;/(&6%&(?"#7($%#&("?(&6'(;%&%(#'a*8#'7':&-(?"#($'-&8=8;'-(%--'--7':&(

*:;'#(=*##':&(9%HG()@AB(-%/-(&6'(7"*-'(=%#=8:"<':8=8&/(-&*;/(T;"'-(:"&($#".8;'(%:/(

%;;8&8":%9(=":&#8,*&8":(&"(#8-R(%--'--7':&V(":(&"$("?(&6'(-%7'(-&*;/(;":'(":(%(-'=":;(

#";':&(-$'=8'-I(*-*%99/(&6'(#%&G

56'(bbq(b%:'9(=8&'-(%-(8&-(%*&6"#8&/(?"#(&68-(%#<*7':&(%(233N($%$'#(,/(EFAE(W)AE(&%-R(

?"#='(9'%;'#(%:;(&6':(A/:<':&%('7$9"/''I(j"6:()G(\"'G(1"#'&&"(%:;(J"",8-(%#'(="Q

%*&6"#-("?(&68-($%$'#G(\"'I(98R'(1"#'&&"(%:;(J"",8-I(8-(8:."9.';(8:(&6'(EFAE(W)AE(qEA]24(

$#"U'=&I(%-(&6'(8:;*-&#/(#'$#'-':&%&8.'("?(":'("?(&6'(&'%7-(H"#R8:<(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&G(

W'(8-($%8#';(H8&6(\"*<(p"9?("?(&6'(OA()bBG()@AB(;"'-(:"&(7':&8":(EFAEY-(8:;*-&#/(

,%=R8:<(8:(8&-(?%."*#%,9'(=8&%&8":G

B9%:(J"",8-(H%-(.8='Q=6%8#("?(&6'()@AB(bbq(b%:'9(233N0233LG(1"#'&&"(H%-(%(7'7,'#("?(&6%&(

b%:'9(&""(,*&(#'-8<:';(%?&'#(?%898:<(&"(;'=9%#'(%:(8:&'#'-&(H8&6(%(=":-*9&%:=/G(J"&6(6'9;(-&#":<(

&8'-(H8&6(EFAEG(J"",8-(H%-(=6%8#("?(&6'(J"%#;("?(5#*-&''-(%:;("?(&6'()S'=*&8.'(!"778&&''("?(EFAE(

W)AE(C*:&89(2343DI(%:;(%(5#*-&''("?(EFAE(%:;(EFAE()*#"$'G(W'(6%-(,'':(%(7'7,'#("?(&6'(,"%#;("?(

;8#'=&"#-(%&(EFAE()*#"$'(-8:='(2343G

B-()+A(",-'#.'-I(&6'(?%=&(&6%&(J"",8-(98-&-(68-(EFAE(#"9'-(8:(68-(\'=9%#%&8":("?(E:&'#'-&I(%;;8:<(

&6%&(68-(8:."9.'7':&(T6%-(:"&(8:."9.';(%:/(-*,-&%:='(#'.8'H';(,/()@ABVI(6%-(98&&9'(#'9'.%:='G(

EFAEY-(8:&'#'-&-(%#'(:"&(=":[:';(&"(%:/(-8:<9'(-*,-&%:='(%:;(%87(&"($#"7"&'(%:(8:;*-&#/Q

?#8':;9/(#'<*9%&"#/(':.8#":7':&G(

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 T

Page 10: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

>&&#R$G$I$S+F$%-/%$F#)A#&#?$:=/>E1$92*?#,*&#1$.+($'"#$(*1A$)11#11<#&'$+.$

UN$0(+61

EFAE(8&-'9?(=9%87-(&"(6%.'(8:>*':=';()@ABY-(<*8;'98:'-(":(d1+-G(56'(d'#7%:(^d+(5'-&,8"&'=6(

#'$"#&';(&6%&(1":-%:&"('7$9"/''(%:;(=6%8#("?(%:(EFAE(&%-R(?"#='(]'.8:(d9'::(,"%-&';(%&(%(

H"#R-6"$(8:(233N(&6%&(EFAEY-(8:$*&(6%;(%(6*<'(87$%=&(":()@ABY-(<*8;'98:'-G(EFAE(#'$'%&';(&68-(

=9%87(8:(":'("?(8&-(#'$"#&-G

5'-&,8"&'=6(8:(&6'8#(#'$"#&(T)*#"$'%:(@"";(A%?'&/(B*&6"#8&/e(B($9%/8:<(['9;(?"#(&6'(,8"&'=6(

8:;*-&#/VXP(H#"&'e

EFAE(=9%87-(&6'()@AB(<*8;'98:'-(%-(%(-*=='--("?(8&-(5%-R(@"#='G(]'.8:(d9'::(?#"7(

1":-%:&"(%:;(=6%8#("?(&6'(EFAE(5%-R(@"#='I($"8:&';("*&(%&(%(H"#R-6"$(233N(8:(B&6':-I(

&6%&(&6'(EFAE(C233`D(#'$"#&(6%;(6%;(%(6*<'(87$%=&G(J"&6(&6'()@AB(<*8;'98:'-(%:;(&6'(

:'<"&8%&8":-(":(&6'(8:&'#:%&8":%9(-&%:;%#;-(=":&%8:';(8:(&6'(!";'S(B987':&%#8*-(H'#'(

8:>*':=';(,/(&6'(EFAE(#'$"#&G

5'-&,8"&'=6(%#<*';(&6%&(&6'($#",9'7("#8<8:%&'-(8:()@ABY-(%--*7$&8":(&6%&(d1($9%:&-(%#'(

'a*8.%9':&(&"(:":Qd1($9%:&-G(56'($#"='--("?(<':'&8=(':<8:''#8:<(=6%:<'-($9%:&-(8:(

*:$#';8=&%,9'(H%/-(&6%&(=%:(9'%;(&"(6'%9&6(%:;(':.8#":7':&%9(#8-R-G(J*&(&6'(<*8;%:='(":9/(

#'a*8#'-(="7$%#8-":("?(&6'(9'.'9-("?(%(?'H(,%-8=(:*&#8':&-I(-*=6(%-($#"&'8:(%:;(?%&I(8:(&6'(d1(

$9%:&(H8&6(&6'(9'.'9-(8:(%(:":Qd1($9%:&G(B-(%(#'-*9&I(*:'S$'=&';(=6%:<'-(H899(,'(78--';G(

568-(%$$#"%=6I(R:"H:(%-(T="7$%#%&8.'(%--'--7':&VI(H%-I(8:(?%=&I(;'.'9"$';(,/(8:;*-&#/(%:;(

EFAE(,'&H'':(2334(%:;(233XG(\*#8:<(&68-($'#8";I(W%##/(]*8$'#(%:;(d8U-(]9'&'#(C,"&6(7'7,'#-("?(

&6'()@AB(d1+($%:'9(-8:='(233XD(H'#'(%=&8.'(H8&68:(&6'(EFAE(5%-R(@"#='(&6%&(;'.'9"$';(&68-(

=":='$&G(+&6'#(7'7,'#-(8:=9*;';(-&%i(?#"7(="7$%:8'-(8:=9*;8:<(!%#<899I(1":-%:&"I(J%/'#(%:;(

A/:<':&%G(

E:(233`I()@AB(%;"$&';(&6'(=":='$&(8:(8&-(d1(?"";(%:;(?'';(<*8;%:='G(A"(&6'(-%7'($'"$9'(H6"(

;'.'9"$';(&68-(=":='$&(?"#(8:;*-&#/(9",,/(<#"*$(EFAE(-8&(":(&6'(-%7'()@AB(d1+($%:'9(&6%&(

7%R'-(&6'(#*9'-(":(d1+(#8-R(%--'--7':&G(

(

B-(5'-&,8"&'=6(a*"&'-(?#"7(%(233M(EFAE(#'$"#&e

E:(2332I(%(&%-R(?"#='("?(8:&'#:%&8":%9(-=8':&8[=('S$'#&-I(=":.':';(,/(&6'(EFAE(E:&9G(@"";(

J8"&'=6:"9"</(!"778&&''(CE@J8!DI(%;;#'--';(&6'(&"$8=("?(&6'(-%?'&/(%:;(:*&#8&8":%9(

%--'--7':&-("?(?"";-(%:;(?'';-(&6%&(%#'(:*&#8&8":%99/(87$#".';(&6#"*<6(7";'#:(

,8"&'=6:"9"</G(E:(233`I(&6'(&%-R(?"#='Y-(H"#R(=*978:%&';(8:(&6'($*,98=%&8":("?(%(#'$"#&(

&6%&(8:=9*;';(%(-'#8'-("?(#'="77':;%&8":-(?"#(&6'(:*&#8&8":%9(%:;(-%?'&/(%--'--7':&-("?(

-*=6(?"";-(%:;(?'';-G(568-(;"=*7':&(6%-(<%8:';(<9",%9(#'="<:8&8":(?#"7("#<%:8h%&8":-(

-*=6(%-(&6'()*#"$'%:(@"";(A%?'&/(B<':=/(%:;(6%-(,'':(=8&';(,/(j%$%:(%:;(B*-&#%98%(8:(

233c(8:(&6'8#(="77':&-(&"(!";'S(B987':&%#8*-G(56'(-*,-&%:&8%9('a*8.%9':='($%#%;8<7I(

=%99';(&6'(="7$%#%&8.'(-%?'&/(%--'--7':&($#"='--(8:(&6'(233`(EFAE($*,98=%&8":I(8-(%(,%-8=(

$#8:=8$9'(8:(&6'(;"=*7':&G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 CV

Page 11: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

>&&#R$J$I$!"#$!"(#1"+,?$+.$!+R*0+,+9*0),$H+&0#(&$3!!H4

+:'("?(&6'(7"-&(#'=':&('S%7$9'-("?(6"H(EFAE(8-(-*$$"#&8:<I("#(-''78:<9/(=#*=8%99/(%;.%:=8:<(

=":&#".'#-8%9($"98=8'-(8-(&6'(56#'-6"9;("?(5"S8="9"<8=%9(!":='#:G(568-(=":='$&(6%-(,'':(6'%.89/(

$#"7"&';(,/(8:;*-&#/I(:"&%,9/(EFAEG()@AB(&""(?"#(-"7'(#'%-":(6%-(&%R':(%:(%=&8.'(8:&'#'-&(8:(

&68-(%$$#"%=6(%:;(6%-(-'&(*$(%(55!(H"#R8:<(<#"*$G()@AB(6%-(-&%&';(&6%&(8&(6%-(%9#'%;/(-&%#&';(

&"(*-'(55!(?"#(?"";(>%."*#8:<(-*,-&%:='-I(%:;(:"H(H%:&-(&"(8;':&8?/(8?(55!(=%:(,'(*-';(?"#("&6Q

'#(-*,-&%:='-G(

J*&(^d+-(8:=9*;8:<(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#R(CbB^D()*#"$'(-%/(&6%&(&6'(55!(%$$#"%=6(H"*9;(

%99"H(?"#(78-9'%;8:<(Z-%?'(9'.'9-("?('S$"-*#'Y(?"#(7%:/(=6'78=%9-(H68=6(6%.'(:"&(,'':(?*99/(

&'-&';(?"#(&"S8=8&/G(@"";($#";*=&-(:"H%;%/-(=":&%8:(%(9%#<'(.%#8'&/("?(=6'78=%9(#'-8;*'-(&6%&(

6%.'(:'.'#(,'':($#"$'#9/(&'-&';G(

56'(56#'-6"9;("?(5"S8="9"<8=%9(!":='#:(C55!D(%$$#"%=6(%--*7'-(&6%&(?"#(&6'(7%U"#8&/("?(

=6'78=%9-I(&6'#'(8-(%(="77":(&6#'-6"9;(*:;'#(H68=6(:"(:'<%&8.'('i'=&(=%:(,'(",-'#.';(C%9-"(

&'#7';(^+)FDI(%:;(*-'-($#",%,898&/(7%&6'7%&8=%9(7";'9-(&"(=%9=*9%&'(&6%&(&6#'-6"9;(8:-&'%;("?(

%=&*%9(&'-&-GXM(EFAE(6%-(,'':(":'("?(&6'(;#8.8:<(?"#='-(,'68:;(&6'(%;.%:='7':&("?(&6'(55!(

=":='$&G(E:(4LLNI(EFAE('-&%,98-6';(%(&%-R(?"#='(":(&6'(55!I(H68=6(6%-(,'':(%=&8.'(*:&89(&";%/G

B(bB^()*#"$'(#'$"#&XL($*,98-6';(8:(\'='7,'#(2344(6%-(?"*:;(&6%&(:*7'#"*-('S$'#&-(":()@ABY-(

55!(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(6%.'(=":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&(H8&6(&6'(-%7'(8:;*-&#/($*-68:<(?"#(&6'(55!(%$Q

$#"%=6I(:"&%,9/(H8&6(EFAEG(^"(9'--(&6%:('8<6&("*&("?(&6'(&68#&'':(7'7,'#-("?(&6'(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(

6%.'("K=8%9(="::'=&8":-(&"(EFAEG

E:&'#:%9('7%89-(#'a*'-&';(,/(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#R(?#"7()@AB(%:;(#'$"#&';(,/(F'(1":;'(

-6"H';(&6%&(A*-%:(J%#9"HI(=6%8#("?(&6'()@AB(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(":(55!I(6%;(%(9%#<'(-%/(8:(&6'(-'Q

9'=&8":("?(&6'(55!(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(7'7,'#-G`3(J%#9"H(8-(%($#8.%&'(=":-*9&%:&(H6"-'(=98':&-(8:Q

=9*;'(EFAEI(b[h'#(%:;(b'$-8="G(A6'(8-(%9-"(%(7'7,'#("?()@ABY-(-=8':&8[=(="778&&''G

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 CC

Page 12: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

>&&#R$KD$:=/>$)&?$%-/%$0+,,)7+()'*+&$+&$N)(9*&$+.$:R6+12(#$3NW:4

d':"&"S8=(-*,-&%:='-(%#'(-*,-&%:='-(&6'()O(%87-&(&"(':-*#'($'"$9'(%#'(:"&('S$"-';(&"I(

'-$'=8%99/(,'=%*-'(:"(-%?'(9'.'9(8-(R:"H:(<':'#%99/G(B=="#;8:<(&"(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#RI(

8:;*-&#/(6%-(,'':(&#/8:<(&"(=6%:<'(&68-($"98=/(?"#(;'=%;'-(%:;($#"$"-'-(T-%?'(&6#'-6"9;-V(%:;(

"&6'#(&""9-(9'%;8:<(&"(%(=":&8:*';(*-'("?(&6'(-*,-&%:='-G(+:'("?(-*=6(&""9-(8-(&6'(-"Q=%99';(

7%#<8:("?('S$"-*#'(C1+)DI(-&%&8:<(&6%&(8?(&6'(7%#<8:(,'&H'':('S$"-*#'(%:;(&6'(9'.'9(H6'#'(

=%:='#-(%#'(",-'#.';(8:(%:87%9(&'-&-(8-(68<6(':"*<6I(&6'(=":='#:(8-(9"H(%:;(&6'#'?"#'(&6'(*-'(

"?(&6'(-*,-&%:='(%=='$&%,9'G(568-I(%=="#;8:<(&"(bB^I(8-(=":&#%;8=&8":(&"()O($"98=/G`4

)@AB(6%-(':<%<';(8:(&68-(;',%&'('.':(&6"*<6(8&(-''7-("*&("?(&6'8#(#'78&I(-8:='(1+)(8-(%:(8--*'(

"?((#8-R(7%:%<'7':&(#%&6'#(&6%:(#8-R(%--'--7':&G().':(7"#'I()@AB(%:;(EFAE(U"8:&9/("#<%:8-';(%(

="99"a*8*7(":(1+)(8:(233cG(B&(&68-(7''&8:<I(%&&':;';(7"-&9/(,/(8:;*-&#/($'"$9'(%:;(EFAEQ

98:R';('S$'#&-I(1+)(H%-(':;"#-';G(EFAEQ98:R';($'"$9'(98R'(A=69%&&'#(C".'#%99(=6%8#DI(J%#9"H(

C".'#%99(q%$$"#&'*#DI(d%998I(]#"'-I(q':H8=RI(%:;(F%#-':(H'#'($#'-':&(%&(&6%&(&87'I(%99("?(&6'7(

8:."9.';(8:()@AB($%:'9-("#(H"#R8:<(<#"*$-G`2

q'=':&9/(&6'(-=8':&8[=(="778&&''("?()@AB(%<%8:(-*,78&&';(%:("$8:8":(":(1+)I`X(%<%8:(.'#/(

%$$#".8:<("?(&6'(=":='$&G(E:."9.';(8:(H#8&8:<(&6'("$8:8":(H'#'(%<%8:(A=69%&&'#(%:;(J%#9"HI(

H689'(-'.'#%9("&6'#(:%7'-(#'7%8:(*:;8-=9"-';G(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#RY-(W%:-(1*89'#7%:(

-%/-e(Tp8&6(&68-("$8:8":I()@AB(-6"H-(8&(':<%<'-(8:(%#'%-(&6%&(%#'("*&-8;'(&6'8#(#'78&I(%:;(%99"H(

&6'8#(8:-&8&*&'(&"(,'(*-';(?"#(;8--'78:%&8:<(8:;*-&#/Y-(%<':;%GV

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 CG

Page 13: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

4 (@"#7'#(;'-=#8$&8":(n%&(9'%-&(&899(A'$&'7,'#(2344o(":(EFAE(H',-8&'e(

6&&$euuHHHG89-8G"#<u)*#"$'ub%<'-u1'7,'#-68$G%-$S2 (EFAE()*#"$'(2c(/'%#-G(EFAE()*#"$'I(2344GX (!":>8=&-(":(&6'(1':*I(!)+(%:;()+A(@',#*%#/(2342` (6&&$euuHHHG89-8G"#<u)*#"$'ub%<'-u=*##':&7'7,'#-G%-$Sc (EFAE()*#"$'(2c(/'%#-G(EFAE()*#"$'I(2344GN (EFAE()*#"$'(2c(/'%#-G(EFAE()*#"$'I(2344GP (Ag;h*=R'#I(%(d'#7%:(="7$%:/I(8-(&6'(9%#<'-&(-*<%#($#";*='#(8:()*#"$'G

M (\#G(B98-":()9;#8;<'(C!6%8#D(0(^'-&9_I(\#G(A&'$6':(@#':=6(Q(!"Q!6%8#(0(1%#-I(\#G(]%#':(!*::8:<6%7(Q(

!"=%Q!"9%()*#"$'I(\#G(B9/-":(d#'':6%9<6QJ%99(Q(]'99"<<()*#"$'I(\#G(B::'(F9*=6(0(\%:":'I(\#G(W'#._(

^"#;7%::(BU8:"7"&"()*#"$'I(\#G(A"$68'(v8:"/(]#%?&(@"";-()*#"$'I(\#G(A*-%::'(w8'-':8&h(0(Ag;h*=R'#G(

56'(7'7,'#(?#"7(&6'(%=%;'78=(H"#9;(8-(b#"?G(p87(A%#8-("?(p%<':8:<':(O:8.'#-8&/G(L (p%/("?(H"#R8:<("?(EFAE()*#"$'('S$'#&-(<#"*$-I(!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%./,+#0%1+2/304"*%567589:;<=89:+>

89:&+,?(4-89:>+,89:"!089:&0@*("0'#A>(43 (p%/("?(H"#R8:<("?(EFAE()*#"$'('S$'#&-(<#"*$-I(!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%./,+#0%1+2/304"*%567589:;<=89:+>

89:&+,?(4-89:>+,89:"!089:&0@*("0'#A>(44 (EFAE(-$'=8%9(-&%&'7':&(":(9",,/8:<G(!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%B<-0*%72(04"(C2D54"0-,("='<*#E(42 (EFAE(-$'=8%9(-&%&'7':&(":(9",,/8:<G(!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%B<-0*%72(04"(C2D54"0-,("='<*#E(4X ()*#"$'%:(5#%:-$%#':=/(E:8&8%&8.'e(B(@#%7'H"#R(?"#(q'9%&8":-(H8&6(E:&'#'-&(q'$#'-':&%&8.'-(Cq'<8-&'#(

%:;(!";'("?(!":;*=&DI(!+1(C233MD(X2XI()*#"$'%:(!"778--8":I(233MI($%<'(XG(

!""#$%%02'0/,+#<'0/%",<4*#<,042=%A+2*%F9FG04'#A>4` ()!($#'--(#'9'%-'I(2X(j*:'(2344I(!""#$%%0/,+#<'0/%,<#(A%#,0**H0)0<*0*I2"(+4'A+J

,0>0,0420K5B%LL%MMFN>+,3<"KOPQ6N<-0AK:N)<4-/<-0K04N-/(6<4-/<-0K04(4c ()!($#'--(#'9'%-'I(2X(j*:'(2344I(!""#$%%0/,+#<'0/%,<#(A%#,0**H0)0<*0*I2"(+4'A+J

,0>0,0420K5B%LL%MMFN>+,3<"KOPQ6N<-0AK:N)<4-/<-0K04N-/(6<4-/<-0K04(4N (6&&$euuHHHGH6"G8:&u&",%=="u7';8%u':uEFAEG$;?4P (W'89$#8:(jG(pW+(&"(#'9/(9'--(":(OA(#'-'%#=6G(B--"=8%&';(b#'--G(2M(j%:*%#/(233NG(

6&&$euuHHHG7';R,G="7uOH'u@"#*7G%-$Su:*&#8&8":uc`LNu1":'/Q5%9R-Q8:Qp68-$'#-(4M ()@ABI(5'=6:8=%9(#'$"#&(":(b*,98=(=":-*9&%&8":(":(b"98=/(":(8:;'$':;':='I(4c(\'='7,'#(2344I(

6&&$euuHHHG'?-%G'*#"$%G'*u':u7,44424cu;"=-u7,44424cQ%SM,G$;?4L )O(#'-'%#=6(?*:;8:<e(?"#(H6"-'(,':'[&xI(!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(+,-'#.%&"#/I(c(\'='7,'#(2344I(

!""#$%%&&&'2+,#+,<"00/,+#0'+,-%#/@)(2<"(+4*%0/D,0*0<,2!D>/4A(4-D&!+*0D@040C"(I(23 (EFAE()*#"$'I(+.'#H'8<6&(%:;(",'-8&/(8:()*#"$'%:(=689;#':(%:;(%;"9'-=':&-I(2333I(

6&&$euuHHHG89-8G"#<G%#u,8,98"&'=%uEFAEy)*#"$%y1":"<#%[%-uEFAE+,'-n4oG$;?24 (A''((B-$'=&(!":-*9&8:<Y-($"#&?"98"e(6&&$euuHHHG%-$'=&=":-*9&8:<G'*u':u8:;'SG=?7u%,"*&Q*-u$"#&?"98"u22 (6&&$euuHHHG="#$"#%&''*#"$'G"#<u-8&'-u;'?%*9&u[9'-u-8&'-u;'?%*9&u[9'-u[9'-u#'-"*#='u!)+QF",,/8:<Q?"#Q

<".'#:7':&-G$;?2X ()@ABG()@AB(7%:%<'7':&(,"%#;(-&%&'7':&G(24(+=&",'#(2343G(

6&&$euuHHHG'?-%G'*#"$%G'*u':u$#'--u:'H-u="#$"#%&'434324G6&72` ()@AB($"98=/(":(;'=9%#%&8":-("?(8:&'#'-&-G()@ABG(c(+=&",'#(233PG(

6&&$euuHHHG'?-%G'*#"$%G'*u':uR'/;"=-u;"=-u;"8$"98=/G$;?(2c (q",8:-":(!G()*#"$'Y-($'-&8=8;'(%:;(?"";(-%?'&/(#'<*9%&"#-e(p6"(;"(&6'/(H"#R(?"#x()%#&6(+$':(A"*#='G(

B$#89(2344G2N (!"#$"#%&'()*#"$'(+,-'#.%&"#/G(B$$#".8:<(&6'(d1($"&%&"e(!":>8=&-("?(8:&'#'-&I(>%H';(-=8':='(%:;(

['#='(9",,/8:<G(^".'7,'#(2344G(

6&&$euuHHHG="#$"#%&''*#"$'G"#<u-8&'-u;'?%*9&u[9'-u$*,98=%&8":-uB7>"#%y!+Ey#'$"#&y2344G$;?(2P (!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%./,+#0%B<-0*%BQ*=3#+L9*2(04"(C22+33(""00'<*#E(2M ()@ABG(F%*#':='(!%-&9'(\'=9%#%&8":("?(E:&'#'-&G(24(\'='7,'#(2343G(

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 CJ

Page 14: ILSI blurring the lines between science and lobbyism

!""#*$%%0**'0>*<'0/,+#<'0/%A+(%A+(&0@%#<40)%R.S%&-%TUVM:F(2L (B(5"S8=(18S&*#'(Q(E:;*-&#/(,8%-(?"*:;(8:()@AB(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&(?"#(&"S8=(=6'78=%9-I(

bB^()*#"$'I(\'='7,'#(2344(X3 ()@ABG(\'=9%#%&8":-("?(E:&'#'-&("?(!)@($%:'9-(23440234`(%:;(233M02344G(

6&&$-euu'--G'?-%G'*#"$%G'*u;"8u;"8H',u$%:'9u!)@uH<u`cLP3XX4 (!""#$%%&&&'0/,+#<,)'0/,+#<'0/%A+2/304"%<2"(W("(0*%2+4"%9:L9:T%9:L9:T:TIPPT9UXM%9:L9:T:TIPPT9UXM.Y'#A>(X2 (b'#-":%9(",-'#.%&8":(?#"7(7'7,'#("?()@AB(A&%R'6"9;'#(@"#*7(%&(%(@"#*7(7''&8:<I(1%#=6(2342XX (A''()@AB(:'H(8:;'$':;':='(#*9'-I(B::'S(Ev(C$G(XP(":H%#;-DI(

6&&$euuHHHG'?-%G'*#"$%G'*u':uR'/;"=-u;"=-u8:;'$':;':='#*9'-G$;?X` (b'#-":%9(",-'#.%&8":(?#"7(7'7,'#("?()@AB(A&%R'6"9;'#(@"#*7(%&(%(@"#*7(7''&8:<I(1%#=6(2342Xc(!""#$%%&&&'()*('+,-%./,+#0%B<-0*%Q03@0,*!(#'<*#E(XN (!""#$%%&&&'0<,"!+#04*+/,20'+,-%(4A0E'#!#%,0#+,"*%L:D0/,+#0*D#0*"(2(A0D<4AD>++AD*<>0"=D,0-/)<"+,*D&!+DA+D"!0=D

&+,?D>+,XP ()*#"$'%:(@"";(A%?'&/(B*&6"#8&/e(%($9%/8:<(['9;(?"#(&6'(,8"&'=6(8:;*-&#/I(2343I(

6&&$euuHHHG&'-&,8"&'=6G;'u':u:";'u`X4XM (T56#'-6"9;-("?(5"S8="9"<8=%9(!":='#:e(B(b#"$"-%9(?"#(q';*=8:<(B:87%9(5'-&8:<(8:(q8-R(B--'--7':&G(Cb%#&(

4DVI(W'%9&6(%:;():.8#":7':&I(j%:*%#/(2X(2342I(!""#$%%@("')=%ERZH[\XL (B(5"S8=(18S&*#'(Q(E:;*-&#/(,8%-(?"*:;(8:()@AB(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&(?"#(&"S8=(=6'78=%9-I(

bB^()*#"$'I(\'='7,'#(2344

`3 (b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#R()*#"$'G()@AB(6%;(:"(=":&#"9(".'#(8:[9&#%&8":("?(&"S8=-(H"#R8:<(<#"*$(,/(

8:;*-&#/(:'&H"#RI(;"=*7':&-(#'.'%9G(b#'--(#'9'%-'G(2X(j%:*%#/(2342G(6&&$euuHHHG$%:Q

'*#"$'G8:?"u^'H-ubqu42342XG6&79`4 (b'#-":%9(="77*:8=%&8":(H8&6(b'-&8=8;'(B=&8":(^'&H"#RI(1%/(2342`2 ()@ABG(233NG()@ABupW+(8:&'#:%&8":%9(=":?'#':='(H8&6(-*$$"#&("?(EFAE()*#"$'(":(#8-R(%--'--7':&("?(

="7$"*:;-(&6%&(%#'(,"&6(<':"&"S8=(%:;(=%#=8:"<':8=G(4NQ4M(^".'7,'#(233cI(J#*--'9-I(J'9<8*7G`X ()@AB(A=8':&8[=(!"778&&''f(A=8':&8[=(+$8:8":(":(&6'(%$$98=%,898&/("?(&6'(1%#<8:("?()S$"-*#'(%$$#"%=6(

?"#(&6'(-%?'&/(%--'--7':&("?(87$*#8&8'-(H68=6(%#'(,"&6(<':"&"S8=(%:;(=%#=8:"<':8=(8:(-*,-&%:='-(

%;;';(&"(?"";u?'';G()@AB(j"*#:%9(2342

!"#$%&'#(&)'*+&),$-*.#$/0*#&0#1$%&1'*'2'#$3%-/%45$)$0+(6+()'#$,+778$9(+26 CK