icao pbn go team pbn implementation workshop the french ... meetings seminars and...

88
www.enac.fr École nationale de l’aviation civile The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop Minsk, BELARUS, 7-10 April 2015 ENAC / ATM Bertrand FOUCHER

Upload: others

Post on 22-Jun-2020

14 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

1

ICAO PBN GO TEAM

PBN Implementation Workshop Minsk, BELARUS, 7-10 April 2015

ENAC / ATM

Bertrand FOUCHER

Page 2: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

2

• ATCO in Paris Charles de Gaulle • ATC Supervisor in Paris Charles de Gaulle, • ATC Instructor at ENAC/ATM: TWR/APP/ACC (Toulouse/

France), • ATC Training Manager at ENAC/ATM:

– In charge of French ATC cadets training – Involved in ATCO PBN Training (France, India,

China..) – Member of ICAO EUR-NAT PBN Task Force, – Member of French PBN Implementation group,

PERSONAL BACKGROUND

Page 3: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

3

QUESTION: Taking into consideration that ATCos are reluctant to changes……

PBN TRAINING

This WAY…

Could we succeed in adapting a PBN Training for ATCos?

If Yes, what milestones would we have to implement ?

New Challenge!!!

Page 4: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

4

Two differents futures for aviation

Without Technological Improvements

With Technological Improvements

Make your choice: Red or

Green???

Page 5: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

5

Two differents futures for aviation accidents/millions

of flights

How did we succeed in enhancing the System?

years

Without improvements

4

2020 2012 2007

Graphical Timeline

8

12

Dark Future..

Page 6: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

6

Two differents futures for aviation accidents/millions

of flights • New Procedures, • New Technologies, • Feedback, • .. • And ATC/Pilots Training,

years

Without improvements

With improvements

4

2020 2012 2007

Graphical Timeline

Rate of Accident is flat…even is traffic is increasing!

Reality.. 8

12

Page 7: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

7

Two differents futures for aviation accidents/millions

of flights

years

Without improvements

With improvements

4

2020 2012 2007

Graphical Timeline

Harmonization/ Training are the Solutions

“States are now mapping their planning to respective block upgrades Modules in order to ensure the near-and longer-term global interoperability of their Air Navigation solutions”

B0-B1 module: Timeline

Implementation of GNSS approaches

Example

Aviation System Block Upgrades

Page 8: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

8

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

Page 9: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

9

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

PART I

Page 10: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

10

A Reference Document…

Page 11: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

11

ICAO DOC 9750 2013-2028 Global Air Navigation Plan

Page 12: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

12

C/N/S/I/A Roadmaps

C: Communication,

N: Navigation,

S: Surveillance,

I: Information Management,

A: Avionics.

Page 13: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

13

C S N Technological

world

Operational world ATM

I A

FANS GANP I:Information

A:Avionic

Page 14: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

14

When the technology is to be implemented

Which module(s) supports the technology..

Page 15: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

15

ASBU ICAO DOC.

Page 16: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

16

ICAO DOC 9750 2013-2028 Global Air Navigation Plan

Page 17: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

17

ICAO DOC 9750 2013-2028 Global Air Navigation Plan

Page 18: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

18

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

Page 19: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

19

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

PART II

Page 20: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

20

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

ATC SCHOOL BAG

How to calculate the aircraft position?

•Guidance material,

•Formal Training,

•PBN Tools,

•CBT,

•Continuous Training,

Knowing my position I can navigate

What is GNSS?

PBN Concept

Operational Aspects

Page 21: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

21

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

How to calculate the aircraft position?

• NDB, • INS/IRS/IRU • VOR, • DME, • GNSS,

• Introduce the notion of SENSORS • DME/DME, • VOR/DME, • GNSS • Inertial System,

Page 22: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

22

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

Knowing my position I can navigate

Conventional Way RNAV Way

• Waypoint: • Fly by vs Fly over

• Path Terminator: • CF, • CA, • …

Page 23: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

23

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

What is GNSS?

• On board receiver, • Positioning System, • Augmentation System:

• ABAS, • SBAS, • GBAS,

Page 24: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

24

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

How to calculate the aircraft position?

Knowing my position i can navigate

What is GNSS?

PBN Concept

Page 25: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

25

How to explain PBN Concept?

NAVAID INFRASTRUCTURE

NAVIGATION SPECIFICATION

NAVIGATION APPLICATION

• RNAV, • GNSS, • Position, • Navigation, • …

ATC SCHOOL BAG

THE CONCEPT

Page 26: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

26

Components of PBN Concept

NAVAID INFRASTRUCTURE

NAVIGATION SPECIFICATION

NAVIGATION APPLICATION

Page 27: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

27

Also includes…

Example of RNAV1 implementation

NAVAID INFRASTRUCTURE

NAVIGATION SPECIFICATION

NAVIGATION APPLICATION

STATE A:

• DME(policy decision not to allow GNSS)

STATE B:

•GPS(Cf Annex 10)

RNAV 1. SENSORS:

•DME/DME/IRU=STATE A

•DME/DME=STATE A

•GNSS= STATE B

RNAV 1 Terminal Area

NAV. SPEC. RADAR COVERAGE:

•RNAV SPEC

+Requirements :

-Flight crew

-On-board equipment

Page 28: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

28 28

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

How to calculate the aircraft position?

Knowing my position i can navigate

What is GNSS?

PBN Concept

Operational Aspects

Page 29: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

29

OK for the Theory but in Operational environment?

ATC

PILOT

Page 30: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

30 30

By the way, How to explain PBN ?

Operational Aspects

• RNAV Phraseology? • Speed constraints? • Altitude constraints? • Radar vectoring in Mixed environment? • Emergency procedures? • …

Page 31: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

31

1. As an ATM component , 2. In which ATCs are involved,

How to explain PBN Concept?

Page 32: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

32

1. As an ATM component, 2. In which ATCs are involved,

How to explain PBN Concept?

Page 33: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

33

C S N Technological

world

Operational world ATM

I A

FANS GANP I:Information

A:Avionic

NAVAID INFRASTRUCTURE

NAVIGATION SPECIFICATION

NAVIGATION APPLICATION

PBN

Page 34: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

34

1. As an ATM component, 2. In which ATCos are involved,

How to explain PBN Concept?

Page 35: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

35

1. As an ATM component, 2. In which ATCos are involved,

How to explain PBN Concept?

Page 36: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

36

ATS ASM

-ATC

-SAR -Air

-Traffic

-Flow

-Management

-Air…

-…Space

-Management

ATFM

How to explain PBN Concept?

ATFM ATM

-Air

-Traffic

-Services

Page 37: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

37

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

Page 38: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

38

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

PART III

Page 39: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

39

Let’s have a Look…

In France?

Page 40: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

40

Example of PBN application in FRANCE

En-Route Départure Arrival Approach

SID RNAV 1

RNAV5 STAR RNAV1 INA RNAV1

RNP APCH IAF IF

FAF/FAP

DER

Missed Approach Procedure

1NM 5NM 1NM 0.3NM then 1NM Accuracy 95% of flight time

Sensors example •DME/ DME •GNSS

•DME/VOR

•GNSS •GNSS

Page 41: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

41

PBN Operations in FRANCE

PBN

RNAV RNP

RNAV5 RNAV1 RNP APCH

En-route Terminal

RNAV (GNSS) SID STAR

ApprocheNPA

Approche APV

LNAV

(NPA)

LNAV/VNAV

(APV baro)

LPV

(APV sbas)

INA Airways

Type NavSpec

Name NavSpec

Flight Phase

Procedure designation

Minima Designation

Above FL 115

Page 42: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

42

RNAV 1 In Terminal Area

– SID/STARs • Implementation since 2008 in about fifteen TMA… • Better Flight flexibility

– CDOs

• CDO on 12 major airports • Benefit/ cost reduction

– New SESAR Concepts

• Point Merge System in extended TMA (Paris ACC): Operational since december 2013

• PMS in TMA under experimentations • Improvements on capacity, safety…

Page 43: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

43

Let’s have a Look…

PMS: A PBN APPLICATION

Page 44: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

44

PARIS ACC

70 NM

120 NM

120 NM

60 NM

60 NM 60 NM

Point Merge System in Paris ACC

Page 45: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

45

PARIS ACC

LFPO APP

LFPG APP

Paris ACC/APP organization

Page 46: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

PARIS TMA

• Variants in terms of – design and dimensions – operating method

• To gain more feedback

AP

TP TE

NW

NE

EXPERIMENTAL STEP 1 IMPLEMENTATION: Dec 2013…

EXPERIMENTAL STEP 2

PARIS PROPOSALS

Page 47: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

TECHNICAL PMS ASPECTS

After Implementation Before Implementation EUR OPS BULLETIN.

Page 48: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

48

Let’s have a Look…

CHARTS?

Page 49: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

49

Typical French IAC

• When possible: – 1 chart – 3 Differents types of Approaches…

APV SBAS

minima

NPA RNAV minima

APV BaroVNAV

minima

Page 50: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

50

Objective 2015/16

CAT1 ILS Network

Number of ILS in France is decreasing……

Today…

Page 51: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

51

Let’s have a Look…

PBN TRAINING FEEDBACK?

Page 52: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

52

Get feedback!!!!!

Page 53: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

53

Get feedback from Surveys

Insuffisantes16%

Suffisantes76%

Trop volumineuses

8%

Enough

Too much Not enough

Young ATCOs..

Page 54: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

54

Get feedback

Insuffisantes22%

Suffisantes54%

Trop volumineuses

24%

Enough

Too much Not enough

Women and men with experience in Civil Aviation..

Page 55: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

55

Get feedback

What about people who left ENAC 10 to15 years ago, before PBN Concept?

Page 56: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

56

Get feedback

OPERATIONAL QUESTIONS…

Page 57: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

57

THE SOLUTION:

Page 58: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

58

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

Page 59: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

59

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

PART IV

Page 60: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

60

The PBN Manual Doc 9613 has been published

by ICAO

PBN Origin Necessity to homogenize and to standardize those operational

requirements

So ICAO created the PBN concept

A Reference Doc.: Doc.9613(4th)

Page 61: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

61

The reference Documentation: DOC.9613

VOL.1 VOL.2 « Concept and implementation guidance » « Implementing RNAV and RNP Operations »

PART.A PART.B

ATTACHMENTS

A.1 A.2 A.3

PART.A PART.B

PART.C

« General » « Implementing RNAV operations »

« Implementing RNP operations »

ATTACHMENTS

A.A A.B

« The PBN Concept» « Implementation guidance»

« RNAV Systems» « Data Processes» « Certification»

« Barometric VNAV» « Aispace concept»

Page 62: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

62

The reference Documentation: DOC.9613

VOL.1 VOL.2 « Concept and implementation guidance » « Implementing RNAV and RNP Operations »

PART.A PART.B

ATTACHMENTS

A.1 A.2 A.3

PART.A PART.B

PART.C

« General » « Implementing RNAV operations »

« Implementing RNP operations »

ATTACHMENTS

A.A A.B

« The PBN Concept» « Implementation guidance»

« RNAV Systems» « Data Processes» « Certification»

« Barometric VNAV» « Aispace concept»

Page 63: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

63

A Reference Doc.: Doc.9613

Page 64: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

64

• The different ICAO Navigation Specification: – RNAV 10/RNP 10, – RNAV 5, – RNAV 2/1, – RNP 4, – RNP 2, – RNP 1, – ADVANCED RNP, – RNP APCH, – RNP AR APCH, – RNP 0,3: For helicopters needs.

A Reference Doc.: Doc.9613

Page 65: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

65

• The different ICAO Navigation Specification:

– RNAV 10/RNP 10, – RNAV 5, – RNAV 2/1, – RNP 4, – RNP 2, – RNP 1, – ADVANCED RNP, – RNP APCH, – RNP AR APCH, – RNP 0,3: For helicopters needs.

Each ATCo Training is divided in 2 parts:

=RNAV 5 Training 1- Core Training

TRAINING

2- NaV Spec. Training

A Reference Doc.: Doc.9613

Page 66: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

66

• Identify the needs, • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…, – Phraseology (« Cleared RNAV Approach..) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 67: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

67

• Identify the needs by the RoadMap • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…, – Phraseology (« Cleared RNAV Approach..) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 68: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

68

Page 69: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

69

• Identify the needs by the RoadMap • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…,

– Phraseology (« Cleared RNAV Approach..) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 70: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

70

• Identify the needs, • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…, – Phraseology (RNAV Approaches???) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 71: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

71

Example of phraseology in

Non Radar environment

Page 72: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

72

CIB

CI544

CI522

CI526

CI520

CI512

CI510

CI508

CI540 CI538

CI518

CI516

CI514

CI506

CI532

CI536

CI530

CI542

CI504 CI502

CI501 RW27

R-182A

R-191A

R-191B

R-191D D-172B

D-172A

Qatar 123, Cochin, cleared for take off (.).Calicut I departure, report

CIA 26 NM DME

Cochin, Qatar 123, passing CIA 26 NM DME

Indigo 054, Cochin, CI540 RNAV arrival, descend 9000ft QNH 1023

CI540 limit clearance Indigo 054, Cochin, cleared CI540 RNAV approach runway 27 QNH

1023, report CI508

QATAR 123

INDIGO 054

Page 73: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

73

Analysis

DOC.4444: Are there any specific Term for a RNAV (GNSS) Approach???

Page 74: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

74

Analysis

DOC.4444: What about RNAV/RNP/GNSS??

Page 75: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

Present Phraseology RNAV ?????

CONVENTIONAL APPROACH

Page 76: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

Present Phraseology RNAV ?????

CONVENTIONAL APPROACH

Page 77: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

RNAV ?????

Present Phraseology

CONVENTIONAL APPROACH

Page 78: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

RNAV ?????

Present Phraseology

ICAO ATM OPS PANEL in progress to amend Doc 4444

Page 79: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

79

And in France?

Present Phraseology

Page 80: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

Systematicaly use « RNAV »

The RNAV term is reserved to the approach phraseology to distinguish RNAV (GNSS) approach from a conventional approach.

• RNAV to precise aReaNAVigation not Conventional(eg: ILS or VOR/DME)

• GNSS sensor is the only sensor type available on final

Harmonize the Operations between ATCo and Pilots

For Charts..

Present Phraseology

Page 81: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

Present Phraseology

Radar Vectoring

RNaV App Impossible

Page 82: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

Participation to ICAO Groups

In order to harmonize the RNAV PHRASEOLOGY

Page 83: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

83

Example of WEB PBN for ATCO

Copyright @ ENAC/ATM 2014

Page 84: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

84

• Identify the needs, • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…, – Phraseology (« Cleared RNAV Approach..) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 85: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

85

• Identify the needs, • Adapt to the local needs, • Answer operational issues

– Operational impact for ATC, – Operational methods( « direct to » instructions,

« speed » and « altitude » constraints, vectoring…, – Phraseology (« Cleared RNAV Approach..) – Contingency situations, hazards…

• Train the Trainers,

An adapted Training

Page 86: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

86

Train the Trainers in 8 milestones

ATC Impact

PBN Ops. Flight Prep. ATC Interface Phraseology Speed use Direct Route Feedback Proc.Interruption

This Training can be adapted for:

•Pilots,

•Engineers,

•Operational staff..

Page 87: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

87

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions ?

AGENDA

Page 88: ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop The French ... Meetings Seminars and Workshops/PB… · The French Civil Aviation University 1 ICAO PBN GO TEAM PBN Implementation Workshop

www.enac.fr

Écol

e na

tiona

le d

e l’a

viat

ion

civi

le •

The

Fre

nch

Civi

l Avi

atio

n U

nive

rsity

88

1. PBN Introduction: GANP a global view 2. PBN in a few words… 3. What we have learned: French example 4. An adapted Training, 5. Questions,

hesitations, propositions.. ?

AGENDA

PART V

Contact: [email protected]