hiring great product managers

twitter.com/gayle facebook.com/gayle

gayle.com

Conducting Great PM Interviews

Reverse Engineering Interviews to Reduce False Negatives

Gayle Laakmann McDowell

AOL Bootcamp Oct 2014


gayle.com2

Gayle Laakmann McDowell

<dev>

</dev>

Author Interview Coach Interview Consulting

(CS) (MBA)


gayle.com3

The Problem(s)

1. Great employees often aren’t great interviewees.

2. Interviewers often aren’t good.

Rejecting great people


gayle.com4

What I Coach

Download at: CrackingThePMInterview.com


gayle.com5

What I Coach

Download at: CrackingThePMInterview.com


gayle.com6

Typical PM Questions

• Behavioral/Experience• Technical Questions• Strategy• Product• Analytical• Knowledge


gayle.com7

How “They” Interview

• Startups– Lean towards “practical”

• Google, Microsoft, Amazon, etc.– Lean towards hypotheticals


gayle.com8

Skills vs. Attributes

What do you want?


gayle.com9

Skills vs. AttributesKnowledge & Experience

TechnicalMetrics

Design SpecsIndustry Expertise

…

Personal Attributes

IntelligenceDrive

InitiativePassion

…


gayle.com10

Skills vs. Attributes


gayle.com11

What You WantProduct Knows what to build

Execution Will get it done

Culture Fit Works well with others


gayle.com12

What You WantProduct • Vision

• Empathy• Analytical

Execution • Initiative• Opinionated

• Drive• Project

mgmt

Culture Fit • Enjoyable• Open to

feedback

• No jerks


gayle.com13

Product

• Design a ___________.• Favorite product & why?• What would you improve about our product?


gayle.com14

What to Look For

• Do they really get the user?– Surface level & deep

• Do the features/design make sense?• Can they defend decisions?• Will they change their mind with other info?• Execution:– Can they prioritize?– Can they execute?


gayle.com15

Issues: Design a ___

• Yay: Starts from scratch• Nay: Bias towards knowledge• Nay: Coaching matters• Nay: Your bias• Nay: Hypothetical


gayle.com16

Issues: Favorite Product

• Yay: Something they know• Nay: Bias towards preparation• Nay: Some products better than others


gayle.com17

Issues: Our Product

• Yay: It matters• Yay: Ensures alignment• Nay: Group think• Nay: Uneven playing field


gayle.com18

Recommendation

• Need to know space?– Our product

• Else?– Hypothetical

• Encourage questions


gayle.com19

Execution

• What have they done?• Why?• How?• What would they do differently?• What if…?


gayle.com20

Common Issues

• “Lack of personal accomplishments”– Didn’t do much?– Or doesn’t boast much?

• Can’t immediately think of example


gayle.com21

Recommendation

• Look for initiative & drive– More than just following orders

• Don’t be overly specific• Probe deeper


gayle.com22

Culture Fit

Personality +

Your Culture


gayle.com23

Common Issues

• Lack of clarity around culture• Not structuring culture interview


gayle.com24

What about skills?


gayle.com25

Good Skills?

• Technical knowledge?• Industry expertise?• Metrics?


gayle.com26

What about the skills?

Proxy Knowledgevs

Deep Knowledge


gayle.com27

Proxy Knowledge

• Can reasonably expect that someone would know it

• But is that true?


gayle.com28

Deep Knowledge

• Need someone who really knows this• But is that true?


gayle.com29

Technical Skills

• How much is enough?• Talk to and work with developers


gayle.com30

Common Issues

• Requiring more than you need• Can be really intimidating


gayle.com31

My Recommendation

Explain prior work Push deeper


gayle.com32


gayle.com33

It’s About…

Job PerformanceNOT

Interview Performance


gayle.com34

Don’t get too caught up in the question.


gayle.com35

Approach interview process like an engineer

(it has bugs!)

hiring great product managers

Technology

knowledge nay

bias nay

technical skills

preparation nay

alignment nay

good skills

favorite product

product design