harvard university - public access: practical ways …...1/12/2018 1 public access: practical ways...

92
1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research Integrity Michelle Benson, PhD Assistant Director for Research Integrity and Compliance, Columbia University Public Access to Publications Stephanie Scott, MS, CRA Director of Policy and Research Development, Sponsored Projects Administration, Columbia University Public Access to Research Data Kristin Briney, PhD Data Service Librarian, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jul-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

1

Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies

Public Access and Research IntegrityMichelle Benson, PhDAssistant Director for Research Integrity and Compliance, Columbia University

Public Access to PublicationsStephanie Scott, MS, CRADirector of Policy and Research Development, Sponsored Projects Administration, Columbia University

Public Access to Research DataKristin Briney, PhDData Service Librarian, University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee

Page 2: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

2

Public Access and Research Integrity:

One University's Approach to Promoting Research and Data Integrity

Michelle Benson, PhDAssistant Director for Research Integrity and Compliance

Columbia University

Page 3: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

3

OSTP Memo

• Issued in February 2013

• Federal agencies with more than $100M in R&D expenditures to develop plans to make the published results of federally funded research freely available to the public within one year of publication– Agencies had 6 months from 2/22/2013 to issue draft plans

• Plans include access to publications and data

• Implementation dates have varied across federal agencies

https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/blog/2013/02/22/expanding-public-access-results-federally-funded-research

Page 4: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

4

Columbia University Webpage on Public Access

• Hyperlinks to policy and repositories

• Additional pages devoted to NIH and NSF

• Joint effort between SPA, Libraries and Research Compliance

Page 5: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

5

Columbia University Website on Research Data

https://research.columbia.edu/research-data-columbia

Page 6: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

6

What Public Access Means for Research Integrity

• Increased visibility of research results and the data supporting them

– Researchers need to be aware of their data quality and management

• Columbia University initiated the Research and Data Integrity (ReaDI) Program in 2014 to enhance data management and research integrity– www.research.columbia.edu/ReaDI-Program

Page 7: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

7

ReaDI Program Overview

Resources: Tutorials, templates, guidelines, robust website repository of resources targeting researchers at all career stages and addressing discipline-specific requirements

Outreach: Presentations to departments, centers, new-faculty and student orientations, special programs

Consults: PI-initiated meetings or discussions via phone and/or email

Increasing Number of Researchers

Outreach

Resources

Consults

Page 8: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

8

ReaDI Program Resources

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

160

180V

ery

Som

ew

hat No

ASA

P

Eve

ntu

ally

Nev

er

Yes

Som

ew

hat No

Ab

solu

tely

May

be

No

How UsefulWas Content

ImplementPractices

LearnedSomething

Recommend toa Colleague

Notebook (n=99) Instrumentation (n=64) Samples (n=57)Tutorial Survey Results

Types of Resources for Research and Data Integrity

Experimental Design

Guidelines

Lab Management

Data Management

Tutorials

Reproducibility

Page 9: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

9

www.research.columbia.edu/ReaDI-Program

Page 10: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

10

Making the ReaDI Program Available Outside Columbia

• Resources are relevant to many researchers at most institutions

• Columbia University has created a version of the ReaDI Program that can be linked to from your institutional webpages– For more information contact Michelle Benson at

[email protected]

Page 11: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

11

Preview: ReaDI Program Outside Columbia University

Page 12: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

12

Public Access to Publications

Stephanie F. Scott, MS, CRADirector of Policy & Research Development

Columbia [email protected]

Page 13: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

13

OSTP Feb 22nd 2013 Memo -Publications Summary*

• Use a 12-month post-publication embargo period as a guideline for making research papers publicly available.

• Easy public access to the peer-reviewed publication.

• “Repositories could be maintained by the Federal agency funding the research, through an arrangement with other Federal agencies, or through other parties working in partnership with the agency including, but not limited to, scholarly and professional associations, publishers and libraries.”

• *Source: “Expanding Public Access to the Results of Federally Funded Research.” 2013. Whitehouse.Gov. February 22, 2013. https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/blog/2013/02/22/expanding-public-access-results-federally-funded-research.

Page 14: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

14

Where are we now?Federal

Agency

Public Access System System for Publication Uploads and

Management

Effective Date

- CAUTION -

wide variation

NIH PubMed Central NIHMS (uploads) and MyNCBI (management) 4/7/2008

NSF NSF-Public Access Repository (PAR) NSF-PAR via Research.gov 1/25/2016

DoD PubDefense: powered by the Defense

Technical Information Center (DTIC)

Enterprise Content Management System

(ECMS)

accomplished

incrementally

DOE PAGES DOE STI Management System 10/1/2014

NASA NASA PubSpace (manuscripts stored in PMC) NIHMS - use ‘NASA researchers’ with ORCID

login

10/1/2015

AHRQ PubMed Central NIHMS and MyNCBI Memo

released

2/19/2016

Page 15: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

15

PMC Plays a Big Role• National Institutes of Health (NIH)

• Administration for Community Living (ACL)

• Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ)

• Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation

• Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC)

• Environmental Protection Agency (EPA)

• Food and Drug Administration (FDA)

• Howard Hughes Medical Institute (HHMI)

• National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA)

• National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)

• Office of the Assistant Secretary for Preparedness and Response

(ASPR)

• U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs (VA)

Page 16: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

16

Not Just Federal Agencies• Health Research Alliance (HRA) Public Access Initiative

• https://www.healthra.org/about-hra/working-groups/ostf/

• Partnered with the National Library of Medicine (NLM) to enable HRA member-funded awardees/grantees to deposit their publications into PubMed Central (PMC).

• Example, American Heart Association’s (AHA) Public Access Policy:

• https://professional.heart.org/professional/ResearchPrograms/AwardsPolicies/UCM_461225_Open-Science-Policy-Statements-for-AHA-Funded-Research.jsp

Page 17: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

17

Participant PollPlease select your institution type (best answer):

• Private Institution of Higher Education (IHE)

• Public/State Controlled IHE

• Nonprofit other than IHE

• For-profit (includes organizations and individual consultants)

• Non-Domestic (non-US) entity

• Other

Page 18: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

18

Participant PollWhich department at your institution has primary responsibility in assisting faculty with fixing and troubleshooting non-compliant NIH publications?• Sponsored Projects Office

• Libraries

• Both Sponsored Projects and Libraries collaborate.

• Other Department

• Faculty are just told to correct them.

• Don’t know.

• N/A – due to Institution Type

Page 19: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

19

Types of Support for Researchers

Training

•Why & how to be compliant

• In-person

•Hands-on

•Live webinars

•Targeting PIs and all potential authors.

Resources

•Tips/cheat sheets

•Copyright Agreement boilerplate language/templates

•Videos

•Dedicated webpages of information

•Use existing training materials from sponsors

Troubleshooting

•Correcting problems when a paper is non-compliant.

• Instructing how to prevent non-compliance next time.

Page 20: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

20

Who Supports the Researchers?

Collaborative Partnership

Research Administration

Sponsored Projects Office

Research Compliance and Integrity

Legal/General Counsel

LibrariesCopyright Advisory

Page 21: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

21

Practical Areas of Assistance & Training – The Main Opportunities

Communicating with publishers

Troubleshooting non-compliant

papers

Systems Required

Page 22: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

22

Explaining this to ResearchersNIH Public Access Policy

• The National Institutes of Health (NIH) Public Access Policy requires that all peer-reviewed publications arising from NIH-funded research must be submitted to the digital archive PubMed Central (PMC) upon acceptance for publication.

• The Policy requires that these papers are accessible to the public in PubMed Central no later than 12 months after publication. The full policy can be found here: http://publicaccess.nih.gov/policy.htm

22

Page 23: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

23

More about the Policy

• PIs must use MyBibliography in MyNCBI to manage their papers, which autopopulate in the RPPR.

• PIs/Authors may need to use the NIH Manuscript System (NIHMS) to deposit the peer-reviewed articles, which will eventually go into PMC.

Page 24: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

24

Communicating the Why & Benefits• Results of NIH-funded research become more prominent,

integrated and accessible, making it easier for all scientists to pursue NIH's research priority areas competitively.

• PMC materials are integrated with large NIH research data bases such as Genbank and PubChem, which helps accelerate scientific discovery.

• Clinicians, patients, educators, and students can better reap the benefits of papers arising from NIH funding by accessing them on PMC at no charge.

• The Policy allows NIH to monitor, mine, and develop its portfolio of taxpayer funded research more effectively, and archive its results in perpetuity.*

*Source: “Frequently Asked Questions about the NIH Public Access Policy | Publicaccess.Nih.Gov.” n.d. Accessed January 1, 2018. https://publicaccess.nih.gov/faq.htm.

24

Page 25: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

25

Challenging Policy to Communicate

• PubMed Central; NIHMS; MyBibliography/MyNCBISystems

• ‘no later than 12 months’, ‘upon acceptance for publication’, NIHMS IDs – provisionally compliant for 3 months

Dates

• Methods A – DPublishers’

Involvement

• Research Team, Subrecipients, Postdocs, TraineesPotential Authors

• Multiple offices potentially involved to provide support and training.

Central Support

Page 26: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

26

This is the Key• The process starts while communicating with the publisher,

prior to the manuscript being accepted for publication.– TIP: Create a checklist of all the points to be discussed with the publisher

• It has to be accessible to the public no later than 12 months after publication. – this is about the embargo period and communicating that with the publisher!!

• Really have only 3 months to get into compliance, to obtain that PMCID#. – this is important for the PI!

• It can be archived in PMC, with a PMCID#, until it is made available to the public at the 12-month mark.

Page 27: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

27

PubMed

Indexed citations and abstracts

PubMed Central

Full-text journal articles with figures, PDFs, and

supplemental files

27

Page 28: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

28

Show & Tell: PubMed

Page 29: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

29

Show & Tell: PMC

Page 30: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

30

Example – archived in PMC, but not yet available

Page 31: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

31

It’s Compliant! Even though article is not publicly available in PMC.

Page 32: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

32

Preventing Non-Compliance – Checklist for Communicating with Publishers

1. Is the journal reputable?

– See NOT-OD-18-011

– See Open Mike Blog: Continuing Steps to Ensuring Credibility of NIH Research: Selecting Journals with Credible Practices

– Journal should be transparent about its fees, practices and peer-review process.

– Get assistance from Libraries.

Page 33: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

33

Preventing Non-Compliance – Checklist for Communicating with Publishers

2. Communicate to the journal the paper was funded by NIH, and the need to comply with the NIH Public Access Policy.

3. Clarify that information is documented.

a) Is it in the copyright agreement? – Get help if it is not!!!

b) Does it state the embargo is 12 months?

4. Read the Instructions to Authors. What are the publisher’s expectations regarding PubMed Central?

5. Clarify your roles! – who will do what?

Page 34: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

34

Expanding on Clarifying the Roles!• Who will do what?

– Will publisher ensure the paper is in PMC? By when? (Method A)

– Will publisher ensure the paper is in PMC, but for a fee? – Open Access Journal? (Method B)

– Will publisher initiate submitting the paper in NIHMS, and will you have to complete the process? How will you be alerted? (Method D)

– Will I have to submit the peer-reviewed manuscript into NIHMS? (Method C)

Page 35: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

35

Chart comes from: “Submission Methods | Publicaccess.Nih.Gov.” n.d. Accessed January 1, 2018. https://publicaccess.nih.gov/submit_process.htm.

Page 36: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

36

Public Access vs Open Access• “Public access” refers to unrestricted access to a publication in

a public online repository, often following an embargo period imposed by the publisher (typically 12 months). Copyright rules are still in place.

• “Open access” implies not only public access, but also includes free and unrestricted re-use of information. Users are permitted to read, download, copy, distribute, print, search or link to the full text of the article(s), to crawl them for indexing, to pass them as data to software, or use them for any lawful purpose (Budapest Open Access Initiative, 2/14/2002).

36

Page 37: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

37

Systems• Helpful one-stop shop:

https://era.nih.gov/grantees/manage_publications.cfm• NIHMS, use the tutorials:

https://www.nihms.nih.gov/db/sub.cgi?page=stepbystep

• MyBibliography in MyNCBI:• https://publicaccess.nih.gov/my-bibliography-faq.htm

– Ensure MyNCBI account is linked to eRA Commons.– Add citations.– Edit each citations ‘status’ to indicate how it complies with Public

Access Policy.– Associate the citation to each grant award that supported it.

• Training resources will be accessed either when author is working with a publisher during acceptance phase, or when trying to correct a non-compliance publication.

Page 38: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

38

Overview of the NIHMS process (Methods C & D)

Blog Post on NIHMS:http://ncbiinsights.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/2015/02/03/nihmss-new-look-streamlines-the-manuscript-submission-process/

Page 39: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

39

Non-compliant papers

• NIH delays processing of non-competing continuation grant awards if publications arising from the award are not in compliance with the public access policy.

• The award will not be processed until recipients have demonstrated compliance.

• Compliance with the Public Access Policy is not a factor in the scientific and technical merit evaluation of grant applications.

• Non-compliance will be addressed administratively, and may delay or prevent awarding of funds.

39

Page 40: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

40

Demonstrating Compliance Retrospectively

• If article has already been published and you are in non-compliance, you will need to immediately follow the steps outlined below to bring your article(s) into compliance:

• Is there a person designated with the PACM role in the eRACommons?– Public Access Compliance Monitor (PACM) Tool - good starting place

• Tells me if process started, and by whom

• Sometimes it is a matter of telling the PI/author that they missed an email, or

• It will tell me nothing has been done.

• https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/utils/pacm/

– Also check NIHMS

– PubMed40

Page 41: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

41

PACM Example

Page 42: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

42

If nothing was done….

• Advise the PI to….– Contact the Journal and request permission to

deposit the manuscript into NIHMS (Method C).

• Then direct them to systems tutorials.

– Double-check the embargo period.

– Double-check the Copyright Agreement.

Page 43: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

43

Public Access Wizard

• http://publicaccess.nih.gov/

• Show me specific instructions for my publication!!!

43

Page 44: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

44

In Conclusion• Close collaboration between SPA & Libraries promotes

better communication to faculty.

• Try a preventive medicine approach:– Checklist for authors on communicating with journals.

– Importance of the copyright agreement.

– Don’t overcomplicate it.

• Troubleshooting is everyone’s problem.– PACM Tool – use it!

• Use as much of the existing resources provided by sponsors as possible with regards to systems training.– Don’t re-invent the wheel!

Page 45: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

45

Public Access Resources

• NIH Public Access Homepage:• http://publicaccess.nih.gov/

• NIH Manuscript System (NIHMS):• http://nihms.nih.gov/

• PubMed Homepage:• http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed

• PubMed Central (PMC) Homepage:• http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/

• MyNCBI:• http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/myncbi/

45

Page 46: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

46

Public Accessto Research Data

Kristin Briney

Data Services Librarian

University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee

Page 47: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

47

Learning Objective

• Learn to navigate grant mandates around data management and sharing, and provide support for researchers' data needs at key places in the data lifecycle.

Page 48: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

48

Why Data?

Page 49: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

49

“a scientific publication is not the scholarship itself, it is merely

advertising of the scholarship”

Buckheit, J. B., & Donoho, D. L. (1995). WaveLab and Reproducible Research. In Lecture Notes in Statistics Volume 103 (pp. 55–81). New York: Springer.

Page 50: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

50

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/04/28/magazine/diederik-stapels-audacious-academic-fraud.html

Page 51: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

51

Vines, T. H., Albert, A. Y. K., Andrew, R. L., Débarre, F., Bock, D. G., Franklin, M. T., … Rennison, D. J. (2014). The availability of research data declines rapidly with article age. Current Biology : CB, 24(1), 94–7. http://doi.org/10.1016/j.cub.2013.11.014

Page 52: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

52

Data Requirements

1. Data sharing

2. Data management plan

Page 53: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

53

Page 54: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

54

Data Management Plans (DMP)

Page 55: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

55

Participant Poll

• Have you ever helped a researcher with a DMP?

– Yes

– No

Page 56: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

56

What is a DMP?

• 2-page document

• Describes:

– What data will be produced

– How the data will be managed during the project

– How the data will be handled after the project

– How the data will be shared

Page 57: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

57

NSF General Template

• Types of data produced

• Data and metadata standards

• Policies for access and sharing

• Policies for re-use, redistribution

• Plans for archiving and preservation

Page 58: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

58

DMP FYI

• DMP expectations are tightening over time

• Poor data management plans can make the difference in getting funding!

Page 59: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

59

Researchers Need

• Help navigating DMP requirements

– Usually easy to find requirements

– Sometimes hard to fulfill them

• Assistance with DMP drafts

– Ask for boilerplate language/examples

– Need holes filled

Page 60: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

60

Researchers Need

• Help navigating DMP requirements

– Usually easy to find requirements

– Sometimes hard to fulfill them

• Assistance with DMP drafts

– Ask for boilerplate language/examples

– Need holes filled

Page 61: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

61

Agency DMP Requirements

• Always check grant information for specifics

• DMPTool

– https://dmptool.org/guidance

• SPARC

– http://datasharing.sparcopen.org/

Page 62: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

62

NSF General Template

• Types of data produced

• Data and metadata standards

• Policies for access and sharing

• Policies for re-use, redistribution

• Plans for archiving and preservation

Page 63: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

63

Alfred P. Sloan Foundation

• Description

• Management

• Dissemination

• Archiving and Stewardship

Page 64: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

64

Researchers Need

• Help navigating DMP requirements

– Usually easy to find requirements

– Sometimes hard to fulfill them

• Assistance with DMP drafts

– Ask for boilerplate language/examples

– Need holes filled

Page 65: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

65

DMP Examples

• DMPTool

– https://dmptool.org/public_dmps

– Good and bad examples

Page 66: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

66

Common Pitfalls

1. Not including enough background on data

2. Not being specific about what happens to different data

– What data is being created v. what is being shared?

Page 67: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

67

Common Pitfalls

3. Not detailing timelines for sharing and retention

– Sharing is common at time of publication

– Retention is MINIMUM 3 years, better 10 years

4. Insufficient information on sharing

– Sharing “by request”

– Not listing an option for where data may be shared

Page 68: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

68

Common Pitfalls

5. Copying old DMPs without improving them

– Reviewers can spot boilerplate

• 1 sentence is fine, half of the DMP is not

– Sharing expectations shifting

Page 69: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

69

Researchers Need

• Help navigating DMP requirements

– Usually easy to find requirements

– Sometimes hard to fulfill them

• Assistance with DMP drafts

– Ask for boilerplate language/examples

– Need holes filled

Page 70: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

70

DMP Help

• Librarians!

• DMPTool

Page 71: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

71

dmptool.org

Page 72: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

72

Data Sharing

Page 73: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

73

Participant Poll

• Have you ever helped a researcher meet their data sharing mandates?

– Yes

– No

Page 74: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

74

Participant Poll

• Have you ever gotten push back from a researcher about data sharing mandates?

– Yes

– No

Page 75: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

75

Data Sharing

• Data sharing usually occurs with publication

• Share what is needed to reproduce the research

• Limitations for human subject/sensitive data

Page 76: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

76

Data Sharing FYI

• No compliance measures for following sharing plan from DMP

• Researchers are not all on board with new data sharing requirements

• Sharing expectations still shifting

• New sharing requirements from journals

Page 77: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

77

Researchers Need

1. To know how to share

– Several data sharing venues exist

2. Help identifying where to share

– Many data repositories exist

3. Help identifying what to share

Page 78: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

78

Researchers Need

1. To know how to share

– Several data sharing venues exist

2. Help identifying where to share

– Many data repositories exist

3. Help identifying what to share

Page 79: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

79

Sharing Venues

• By request

• On researcher’s personal website

• In the institutional repository

• In a data repository

Page 80: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

80

Sharing Venues

• By request

• On researcher’s personal website

• In the institutional repository

• In a data repositoryPreferred

Page 81: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

81

Researchers Need

1. To know how to share

– Several data sharing venues exist

2. Help identifying where to share

– Many data repositories exist

3. Help identifying what to share

Page 82: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

82

Where to Share Data

• What repositories does the researcher know about?

• Journal recommended repositories

Scientific Data: https://www.nature.com/sdata/policies/repositories

• re3data: https://www.re3data.org/

Page 83: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

83

Where to Share Data

• Defaults:

– Dryad (biology): www.datadryad.org

– ICPSR (social science): www.icpsr.umich.edu

– Figshare: figshare.com

– Zenodo: zenodo.org

Page 84: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

84

Researchers Need

1. To know how to share

– Several data sharing venues exist

2. Help identifying where to share

– Many data repositories exist

3. Help identifying what to share

Page 85: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

85

What Data to Share

• Depends…

– on the project

– on disciplinary norms

• Reproducibility is target

– Include enough to let someone redo your work

• Exclusions for sensitive data

– Usually human subjects data

Page 86: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

86

Researchers Need

1. To know how to share

– Several data sharing venues exist

2. Help identifying where to share

– Many data repositories exist

3. Help identifying what to share

Page 87: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

87

Don’t Forget

• Many of these details will go in the DMP

Page 88: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

88

Data Sharing Help

• Librarians!

Page 89: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

89

Conclusion

Page 90: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

90

Data Requirements

1. Data management plan

– Help navigating DMP requirements

– Assistance with DMP drafts

2. Data sharing

– To know how to share

– Help identifying where to share

– Help identifying what to share

Page 91: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

91

Data Requirements

1. Data management plan [MANDATORY]

– Help navigating DMP requirements

– Assistance with DMP drafts

2. Data sharing [NO COMPLIANCE MEASURES]

– To know how to share

– Help identifying where to share

– Help identifying what to share

Page 92: Harvard University - Public Access: Practical Ways …...1/12/2018 1 Public Access: Practical Ways to Assist Faculty to Comply with Public Access Policies Public Access and Research

1/12/2018

92

Note on Copyright/Licensing

• Copyright does not always apply to data

– Cannot copyright facts (Feist v. Rural)

• Best to license data when sharing

– Data is meant to be used

• CC0 and CC BY preferred

– Panton Principles argue for CC0

– Some repositories have a default license