haiti: past, present, future. where is the hope?

Upload: tim-detellis

Post on 04-Jun-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    1/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    2/92

    !"#$#% '"($) '*+(+,$) -.$.*+ / 01+*+ #( $1+ !23+4 !" $%& '($())%*

    +,-".%/01 2 3454 !" $%& '($())%*

    6)) 7%/01* 7(*(.8(9:;? 5@ABCAA@5C5@D

    ;5E? BCF@5@ABCAA@5C5@C

    GH!)%*0(9 !"? 6'I6>$6JK =LLM(V M%R/ \P&(*

    I(.*%,R: +,-".%/01 2 5BF3 $0,&P* >()*,RT ;RS:

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    3/92

    !"#$#% '"($) '*+(+,$) -.$.*+ / 01+*+ #( $1+ !23+4

    5

    61#( 7228 #( 9+9#:"$+9 $2 ;< ="$1+*) '"($2* >+2*?+

    @+6+AA#(B C "; =2*+D+* $1",8=.A $2 1#; 7+:".(+ 1#( A#=+ #( ",

    +E";3A+ 2= $*.+ (+*D",$ A+"9+*(1#3B !+ ?"D+ $2 3+23A+ $1"$

    :2.A9 ,+D+* 3"< 1#; 7":8B

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    4/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    F

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    5/92

    !"#$#% '"($) '*+(+,$) -.$.*+ / 01+*+ #( $1+ !23+4

    G

    !"#$%&'()*+($,-

    C.(/ D+>DE+ ;.F+ B>(%#",-%+: %> %;"$ ,>>GH "( . F.#"+%/

    >? I./$J

    K I>-E: E"G+ %> %;.(G A/ D.#+(%$H '.$%># L+>#)+ .(:

    M+.((+ N+O+EE"$ ?># %;+"# $%+.:?.$% E+.:+#$;"D .$ %;+/ $+#F+

    %;+ D>>#+$% >? %;+ D>>#J O;+/ .#+ A/ #>E+ A>:+E$ .(: ;.F+

    E.": %;+ ?>-(:.%">( ?># . (+I )+(+#.%">( >? E+.:+#$ "( P."%"J

    O> A/ I#"%+#H O>A L"EEH I;> ;.$ I+EE B#.?%+: A/ ;+.#%

    ?># P."%" .(: B>AA"%A+(% %> E+.:+#$;"D >( %;+ ?>EE>I"()

    D.)+$J

    O> '.% O;+#".-E% ?># ;"$ B>F+# :+$")( .(: B#+.%"F+

    "(D-%J

    O> %;+ %+.A .% Q+I C"$$">($H K .:A"#+ %;+"# :+:"B.%">(

    %> %;+ B.EE"()J

    @(: %> A/ I"?+ =;+#/E ?># ,+E"+F"() "( %;+ D>I+# >?

    ;+ED"() >%;+#$ ?-E?"EE %;+"# L>:R)"F+( D>%+(%".EJ

    !"(.EE/H %> C"G+ M.("BS+G I"%; !"#$%&$'( *++,- ?>#

    $++"() %;+ D>%+(%".E >? %;"$ A+$$.)+ %> "AD.B% "(:"F":-.E$

    .(: %;+( B;.()+ %;+ E"F+$ >? ?-%-#+ E+.:+#$ "( %;+ %;"#:R

    I>#E:J

    O;+ ,+$% "$ /+% %> B>A+J

    RO"A N+O+EE"$

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    6/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    H

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    7/92

    ./0'( %2 3%$,($,-

    !"#$%&'()*+($,-......................................................./

    1$,2%)3",4%$ ................................................................5

    6789,(2 :$(..............................................................;#+ %;.( +F+#H %;+ I>#E: ;.$ $++( %;+ D."( .(:

    $-??+#"() >? %;+ D+>DE+ >? P."%"J O;+ :./ ,+?>#+ %;+ ;"$%>#"B

    M.(-.#/ 20H 0121H +.#%;T-.G+H P."%" I.$ .E#+.:/ %;+ D>>#+$%

    B>-(%#/ "( %;+ U+$%+#( ;+A"$D;+#+J Q>IH %;+ E"%%E+

    "(?#.$%#-B%-#+ P."%" ;.: "$ B#-$;+: %> %;+ )#>-(:J U"EE

    E+.:+#$;"D B>A+ %> %;+ $;>#+$ >? P."%"V W# I"EE E+.:+#$;"D

    ?#>A %;+ D+>DE+ >? P."%" #"$+ -DV O;+ ?-%-#+ >? P."%" "$

    B#/"() >-% ?># E+.:+#$;"D

    O;+ A.(%E+ >? E+.:+#$;"D "$ . D#"F"E+)+ .BB>AD.("+: ,/

    )#+.% #+$D>($","E"%/J U;+( E+.:+#$ .#+ B;>$+(H %;+/ .#+ )"F+(

    . A.(:.%+ %> .BB>ADE"$; %;+ F"$">( >? %;>$+ I;> $+E+B%+:

    %;+AJ O> ,+ $-BB+$$?-EH E+.:+#$ A-$% ,+ )"F+( .-%;>#"%/ %>

    A.G+ :+B"$">($ .(: %;+ #+$>-#B+$ (+B+$$.#/ %> ?-E?"EE %;+

    F"$">( A-$% ,+ A.:+ .F."E.,E+J

    X-.E"%/ >? E+.:+#$;"D B.((>% ,+ A+.$-#+: >(E/ ,/ %;+

    ?-E?"EEA+(% >? . A.(:.%+ YT-.(%"%/ZJ C.(/ ?.B%>#$ :+%+#A"(+

    %;+ %>%.E ># D.#%".E $-BB+$$[?."E-#+ >? . E+.:+# .(: %;+ A"$$">(

    %> I;"B; ;+ "$ B.EE+:J O;"$ B.( ,+ .($I+#+: "( D.#% ,/

    .$G"()H \N": %;+ E+.:+#]^

    ]+??+B%"F+E/ -$+ %;+ #+$>-#B+$ .F."E.,E+V

    ]?-E?"EE .EE %;+ )>.E$ >? %;+ F"$">(V

    ]).#(+# $-DD>#% ?#>A ;"$ $-,>#:"(.%+$ %> %;+

    ?-E?"EEA+(% >? %;+ %.$G$ .% ;.(:V

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    10/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    KL

    ]A+(%># >%;+#$ "( E+.:+#$;"D #>E+$V

    ]A.G+ #>>A ?># >%;+#$ .% %;+ %>DV

    ]$++G .:F"B+ ?#>A %;>$+ I"%; +_D+#"+(B+V

    .$/&/0 1$-&2 13(-(%&2 45&53( -$+$ %;+ +_D+#"+(B+$ >?

    P."%"H %;+ I>#E:`$ ?"#$% ,E.BG #+D-,E"BH %> "EE-$%#.%+ %;+ ?.B%>#$

    >-%E"(+: .,>F+J O;>-); A-B; >? P."%"`$ ;"$%>#/ "$ B;+BG+#+:

    I"%; B>##-D%">(H )#++:H .F.#"B+H ,+%#./.EH .(: D>F+#%/ %;+

    (.%">( B>(%"(-+$ %> A>F+ ?>#I.#:J O;"$ $D+.G$ I+EE >? %;+

    A.a>#"%/ >? %;+ D+>DE+b

    P."%".($ I.(% %> $-BB++:J O;+/ .#+ F"%.EE/ "(%+#+$%+: "(

    +:-B.%">(H ;+.E%;B.#+H $+E?R)>F+#(A+(%H D#>$D+#"%/ .(:

    (.%">(.E :+F+E>DA+(%J U;.% P."%" (++:$ A>#+ %;.( .(/%;"()

    .#+ E+.:+#$ I;> E>>G %> %;+ B>AA>( )>>: #.%;+# %;.( %;+"#

    D+#$>(.E I+.E%;J P."%".($ E>() ?># %;+ :./ I;+( ;-()+# .(:

    D>F+#%/ .#+ "( %;+ D.$%c. :./ I;+( +F+#/ B"%"S+( ;.$ +(>-);

    %> +.% .(: %;+ A+.($ %> D#>F":+ .( "(B>A+ ?># %;+"# ?.A"E/J

    O;.% :./ "$ B>A"()]$>>(+# %;.( %;+ I>#E: A./ %;"(Gb

    d>-() P."%".($ .#+ #"$"() -D $> %;+"# F>"B+$ B.( ,+ ;+.#:

    .,>F+ %;+ B#"+$ >? :+$%"%-%">(J O;+$+ />-() D+>DE+ ;.F+ .

    F"$">( ?># %;+"# B>-(%#/ %;.% )>+$ ,+/>(: %;+ D.$% .(:

    #+.B;+$ I+EE "(%> %;+ ?-%-#+c. F"$">( "( I;"B; P."%" I"EE

    .)."( ,+ %;+ \M+I+E >? %;+ @(%"EE+$J^

    e+.:"() %;"$ ,>>G I"EE ;+ED />- E+.#( E+$$>($ F"%.E %>

    %;+ $-BB+$$ >? .(/ E+.:+#J P."%".($ ;.F+ :+A>($%#.%+:

    B>-#.)+ .(: .( "(:>A"%.,E+ $D"#"% %;.% D>"(%$ %> %;+ A>$%

    "AD>#%.(% ?.B%># >? E+.:+#$;"D* '+>DE+ .#+ %;+ A>$% F.E-.,E+

    #+$>-#B+ .F."E.,E+b '+>DE+ I"EE A.G+ ># ,#+.G . E+.:+#J O;+/

    I"EE ;+ED . B.-$+ $-BB++: ># I"EE ?>#B+ . B.-$+ %> ?."EJ O;+

    A.$$+$H D+>DE+H ;>E: %;+ %#-+ D>I+#J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    11/92

    !"#$#% '"($) '*+(+,$) -.$.*+ / 01+*+ #( $1+ !23+4

    KK

    d>- A./ (>% %;"(G >? />-#$+E? .$ . E+.:+#H ,-% %;+ %#-%;

    "$ %;.% />- .#+J fF+#/>(+ ;.$ T-.E"%"+$ >? E+.:+#$;"D .(: ;.$

    >DD>#%-("%"+$ %> E+.: "( %;+ ?.A"E/H .% I>#GH "( #+E.%">($;"D$

    .(: .% %;+ B>AA-("%/ E+F+EJ O;+ "$$-+ "$ I;+%;+# />- I"EE

    (-#%-#+ %;>$+ T-.E"%"+$ .(: .EE>I %;+A %> $%#+()%;+(J .$/&/0

    1$-&2 13(-(%&2 45&53( I"EE ;+ED />- -(E>BG %;>$+ E.%+(%

    T-.E"%"+$ I"%;"( .(: $;>I />- ;>I %> -$+ %;+A "( . L>:E/

    A.((+#J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    12/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    KM

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    13/92

    K5

    #$%&' ()&

    8('"%+( ,% 9/5/)7-(

    6+" -$7 $88 &9$& 9( 9$" :$"(2 $%" /& 7$- #(3;

    '++"< !%" &9(3( 7$- (#(%/%'2 $%" &9(3( 7$-

    :+3%/%'=&9( -/>&9 "$;< YL+(+$"$ 2*32Z

    U;.% "$ D.#.:"$+V P>I I>-E: I+ G(>I "? I+ ;.F+?>-(: "%V =>A+ DE.B+$ >( +.#%; .#+ $> ,+.-%"?-E I+ B.( >(E/

    :+$B#",+ %;+A .$ D.#.:"$+J P>I+F+#H "$ ,+.-%/ %;+ >(E/

    B#"%+#".V

    M>"( A+ >( .( "A.)"(.#/ a>-#(+/ "(%> I;.% ;.$ ,++(

    :+$B#",+: .$ D.#.:"$+J g+%`$ $++ I;.% I+ B.( :"$B>F+# .$ I+

    "A.)"(+]

    $."E"() >( I.%+# $> BE+.# />- B.( $++ 41 ?++% %> %;+

    ,>%%>A .(: ?"EE+: I"%; $-B; .,-(:.(% $+. E"?+ />-

    A.#F+E .% "%$ :"F+#$"%/

    :"$B>F+#"() .( "$E.(: A>-(%."( #.()+ #"$"() >-% >?

    %;+ $+. $> ;"); %;.% "% B.( ,+ $++( ?#>A ,+/>(: %;+;>#"S>(

    :#>DD"() .(B;># .% %;"$ ?+#%"E+ "$E.(: D.#.:"$+

    B>F+#+: I"%; E-$; F+)+%.%">(H %++A"() I"%; I"E:E"?+

    .(: I.%+#+: ,/ B>-(%E+$$ ?#+$;RI.%+# $%#+.A$

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    14/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    KF

    ,+"() )#++%+: ,/ . D+>DE+ I;> %;"(G />- ;.F+ B>A+

    ?#>A ;+.F+( %> ,+ I"%; %;+A

    O;"$ "$ I;.% )#++%+: h;#"$%>D;+# h>E-A,-$ I;+( ;+

    :"$B>F+#+: %;+ "$E.(: G(>I( %>:./ .$ P"$D.(">E. .(: $+% ?>>%

    >( I;.% I>-E: ,+B>A+ %;+ (.%">( >? P."%"J

    !"#$%&"'(% *+,+ -./0'1/ ,'(23.2#4

    fF":+(B+ >? ;-A.( ;.,"%.%">( >( P"$D.(">E. ;.$ ,++(

    :.%+: .$ +.#E/ .$ 451 @JNJ I"%; %;+ h",>(+/$ I;> A")#.%+:

    ?#>A %>:./`$ Q>#%; @A+#"B.J @#>-(: 711 @JNJ %;+ O."(>$H

    A+A,+#$ >? %;+ @#.I.G (.%">( >? @A.S>( F.EE+/ >#")"($H

    .##"F+: ?#>A I;.% "$ %>:./ =>-%; @A+#"B.JO;+ O."(>$ I+#+ . D+.B+?-E D+>DE+ I;> E"F+: "( E.#)+

    $+%%E+A+(%$ .(: #+E"+: >( .)#"B-E%-#+ ?># %;+"# $-$%+(.(B+J

    h>#( I.$ %;+"# D#"A.#/ B#>D .(: . $%.DE+ "( %;+"# :"+%J O;+/

    .E$> I>F+ ,.$G+%$ .(: B#+.%+: -$+?-E "%+A$ E"G+ %;+

    ;.AA>BGJ O;+ O."(>$ B.EE+: %;+ "$E.(: \@/"%"H^ I;"B;

    A+.($ \E.(: >? A>-(%."($J^@(>%;+# D+>DE+ )#>-D "(;.,"%"() %;+ "$E.(: I+#+ %;+

    h.#",$J i"+I+: .$ #-%;E+$$ I.##">#$ ,/ %;+ O."(>$ j h.#",

    A+.($ B.((",.E "( %;+ O."(> E.()-.)+ j %;+ h.#",$ I+#+

    G(>I( %> G"EE %;+"# A.E+ +(+A"+$ .(: +($E.F+ %;+ ?+A.E+$J

    Q+F+#%;+E+$$H P"$D.(">E. I.$ E.#)+ +(>-); ?># %;+$+

    B>AD+%"() D+>DE+ )#>-D$ %> B>R+_"$%J O;+ E-$; F+)+%.%">(.(: .,-(:.(% I"E:E"?+ A.:+ "% D>$$",E+ ?># %;+$+ +.#E/

    "(;.,"%.(%$ %> ?E>-#"$;J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    15/92

    N1"3$+* O,+% 0+A:2;+ $2 '"*"9#(+

    KG

    ,5%&6/ '& 75/ !'1"8'&

    U;+( h;#"$%>D;+# h>E-A,-$ $."E+: >( ;"$ ?"#$% F>/.)+H

    ;"$ +/+$ I+#+ $+% >( ?"(:"() . D.$$.)+ %> h;"(. .(: %;+ !.#R

    f.$%J U;+( ;+ ?"#$% $.I %;+ A>-(%."($ >? P"$D.(">E. #"$"()

    .,>F+ %;+ :"$%.(% ;>#"S>( ;"$ ;+.#% A-$% ;.F+ ,+)-(

    D>-(:"() "( ;"$ B;+$%J @?%+# A>(%;$ .% $+. $."E"() "(

    -(B;.#%+: I.%+#$ E.(: I.$ ?"(.EE/ "( $");%J h>-E: %;"$ ,+ %;+

    .($I+# %> ;"$ D#./+#$ .(: :#+.A$V

    U;+( h>E-A,-$ .(B;>#+: %;+ =.(%.RC.#". (+.# %;+

    B>.$% >? %>:./`$ h.D+ P."%".(H %;+ (.%"F+ @#.I.G$ YO."(>$Z

    I+#+ :+E");%+:J !"(.EE/H ;+ED ?#>A ;+.F+( I.$ B>A"() %;.%

    I>-E: +(.,E+ %;+A %> .((";"E.%+ %;+ ?"+#B+ h.#",$J O;>-);

    %;+ D+>DE+ I+#+ :"$.DD>"(%+: %;.% h>E-A,-$ .(: ;"$ A+(I+#+ (>% %;+"# $.F">#$H %;+/ $%"EE B+E+,#.%+: %;+ $;"D$` .##"F.E

    .(: ;+ED+: ,-"E: g. Q.F":.:H %;+ ?"#$% f-#>D+.( $+%%E+A+(%

    "( %;+ Q+I U>#E:J

    h>E-A,-$ E+?%

    ?># =D."( >(E/ %>

    #+%-#( I"%; .E.#)+# +_D+:"%">(

    >? 29 $;"D$ .(:

    2011 =D.("$;

    $>E:"+#$ .(: B#+IJ

    k/ %;+ %"A+ ;+ #+%-#(+: %> g. Q.F":.:H "% ;.: ,++( :+$%#>/+:

    ,/ %;+ h.#",$H .(: %;+ @#.I.G .(: f-#>D+.( $+%%E+#$ ;.:,++( $E.-);%+#+:J h>E-A,-$ .,.(:>(+: %;+ $"%+ .(: A>F+:

    ?-#%;+# f.$% >( %;+ "$E.(:`$ Q>#%; $;>#+ %> +$%.,E"$; . B>E>(/

    "( I;.% "$ (>I %;+ N>A"("B.( e+D-,E"BJ

    !"# %&'()'*+, -#*# "'*," '(+

    *./"0#,, )( /"#)* +12)('/)1( 13

    /"# ('/)4# &0#5 !1+'67 '021,/(1 )(+)8#(1., 9'*)::#'(

    ;(+)'(, ,.*4)4#5

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    16/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    KH

    L>E: I.$ ?>-(: (+.# %;+ (+I $+%%E+A+(%H $> %;+

    =D.(".#:$ I;> %#.F+E+: I"%; h>E-A,-$ +($E.F+: %;+ (.%"F+

    D>D-E.%">( .(: ?>#B+: %;+A %> A"(+ %;+ D#+B">-$ A+%.EJ

    g+.F"() %;+ =D.(".#:$ "( B>(%#>E >? P"$D.(">E.H h>E-A,-$

    $+% $."E %> +_DE>#+ %;+ >%;+# "$E.(:$ "( %;+ #+)">(J

    9/"6& '0 :/11'1

    O;+ =D.(".#:$ I+#+ ;.#$; .(: #-%;E+$$ "( %;+"#

    :>A"(.%">( >? %;+ (.%"F+ D+>DE+J h>($":+#+: E+$$ %;.(

    ;-A.(H %;+ (.%"F+ O."(> .(: h.#", D+>DE+$ I+#+ +_D+(:.,E+

    "( %;+ =D.(".#:$` T-+$% ?># #"B;+$J g+$$ %;.( ?"?%/ /+.#$ .?%+#

    %;+ ?"#$% :"$B>F+#/ >? )>E: >( P"$D.(">E.H %;+ O."(> I+#+

    B>ADE+%+E/ +#.:"B.%+:J O;+ h.#",$ ?.#+: E"%%E+ ,+%%+#J O>:./H.EA>$% (> "(:")+(>-$ h.#",,+.( K(:".($ $-#F"F+J

    Q+F+#%;+E+$$H %;+ E.$%"() E+).B/ >? %;+"# @#.I.G >#")"($ B.(

    ,+ $++( "( %;+ ?.B+$ >? $>A+ >? %;+"# h-,.( .(: N>A"("B.(

    :+$B+(:+(%$J

    @$ %"A+ D.$$+:H %;+ B#-+E :/(.$%/ >? )#++: %;.%

    h>E-A,-$ "(%#>:-B+: "( %;+ Q+I U>#E: )#+I +F+# A>#+,.#,.#"BJ f$%"A.%+$ DE.B+ %;+ (-A,+# >? Q.%"F+ @A+#"B.(

    :+.%;$ ?#>A 311H111 %> A>#+ %;.( >(+ A"EE">( ,+%I++( 2470

    .(: 2551J C>$% I+#+ %;+ #+$-E% >? :"$+.$+H ,-% F">E+(B+ .(:

    $-"B":+ .E$> %>>G %;+"# %+##",E+ %>EEJ K( 2502 %;+ %":+ >?

    %/#.((/ %-#(+: %>I.#: C+_"B> I;+( E.#)+# )>E: #+$+#F+$

    I+#+ :"$B>F+#+: "( %;+ E.(: >? %;+ K(B. .(: @S%+BJ

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    17/92

    N1"3$+* O,+% 0+A:2;+ $2 '"*"9#(+

    KP

    !%"7" ;# *'1&

    P"$D.(">E. #+A."(+: A>$%E/ -(D>D-E.%+: ?># 95 /+.#$

    .?%+# %;+ =D.(".#:$ A>F+: >( %> C+_"B> "( %;+"# T-+$% ?>#

    )>E:J '"#.%+$ A>F+: "(H .(: ,/ %;+ /+.# 2631 !#+(B; .(:

    k#"%"$; k-BB.(++#$ I+#+ #.":"() =D.("$; %#+.$-#+ $;"D$ ?#>A

    . ,.$+ >( %;+ "$E.(: >? O>#%-). Y"E+ :+ E. %>#%-+ZJ k/ 2644

    %;+/ ;.: +$%.,E"$;+: . $+%%E+A+(% (+.# '>#%R:+R'."_ >( %;+

    (>#%; $;>#+ >? P."%" YP"$D.(">E.ZJ

    O;+ B>($%.(% D"#.%+ #.":$ >( =D.("$; $;"DD"() +F+(%-.EE/

    E+: %;+ h#>I( >? =D."( %> B+:+ %;+ U+$%+#( %;"#: >? %;+

    P"$D.(">E. %> !#.(B+ %;#>-); %;+ O#+.%/ >? e/$I"BG Y2679ZJ

    O;"$ D>#%">( >? %;+ "$E.(: I.$ D#>AD%E/ #+(.A+: =."(%

    N>A"(")-+H E.%+# %> ,+B>A+ \g. e+D-,E"T-+ :`P."%"J^ P."%"I.$ ,>#(J

    E>(/ I.$ B>($":+#+: . %#+A+(:>-$

    +B>(>A"B $-BB+$$H %>%.E"() "( +_B+$$ >? 241 A"EE">( :>EE.#$J

    O;+ ?+#%"E+ $>"E .(: A"E: BE"A.%+ >? %;+ h.#",,+.(B>(%#",-%+: %> %;+ +B>(>A"B $-BB+$$ >? =."(% N>A"(")-+ .$

    :": >%;+# ?.B%>#$J P>I+F+#H .EE I+#+ D.E+: ,/ %;+ ,E");% >?

    ;-A.( $E.F+#/J

    !%"7"? P"$D.(">E. ;.: E>() ,++(

    :+B"A.%+:H $> %;+#+ I.$ (> B;+.D E.,># %> I>#G >( %;+

    DE.(%.%">($J O> >F+#B>A+ %;"$ >,$%.BE+H DE.(%.%">( >I(+#$

    %-#(+: %> $E.F+$ "AD>#%+: ?#>A @?#"B. %> ?"EE %;+ F>":J =;"D

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    18/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    KI

    .?%+# $;"D B.##/"() ;-A.( B.#)> ?#>A %;+ h>()>H K,>H Q.)>H

    C.(:"()-+H @#.:.H N.;>A+ .(: >%;+# U+$% @?#"B.(

    B"F"E"S.%">($ .##"F+: %> >??RE>.: $E.F+$ $>E: .% A.#G+%$ .#>-(:

    P."%"J O> %;+$+ (+I "(;.,"%.(%$H %;+ "$E.(: I.$ . ,#-%.E DE.B+

    >? %>#%-#+H $%.#F.%">(H :"$+.$+ .(: ,.BGR,#+.G"() E.,>#J

    @% %;+ :.I(

    >? %;+ 28%;B+(%-#/H

    $E.F+#/ I.$ .

    ?"_%-#+ "( f-#>D+.(

    .(: @#., $>B"+%"+$J

    O> ?.B"E"%.%+ %;+

    +_D>#% >? $-).# .(:

    #-A %> f-#>D+H B#>D /"+E: ;.: %> "(B#+.$+J O;.% "(B#+.$+

    #+T-"#+: E.,>#+#$ I;> I>-E: I>#G ?># E"%%E+ ># (> D./A+(%H $>

    $E.F+#/ I.$ %;+ A>$% E>)"B.E B;>"B+J

    =E.F+R#.":"() D.#%"+$ I>-E: $%#"G+ "( U+$% @?#"B.(

    $+%%E+A+(%$ %> #>-(:R-D A+(H I>A+( .(: B;"E:#+( %> ,+ $>E:

    .$ $E.F+$ "( %;+ Q+I U>#E:J O;+$+ D+>DE+ I>-E: %;+( ,+

    ?>#B+: "(%> %;+ ;>E:$ >? $E.F+ $;"D$H .(: D.BG+: $> %");%E/

    %>)+%;+# %;.% ?#++:>A >? A>F+A+(% I.$ "AD>$$",E+ .(:

    $-??>B.%">( I.$ (>% -(B>AA>(J =;"D B.D%."($ +_D+B%+: .(

    .F+#.)+ :+.%;R%>EE >? 20 D+#B+(% >( %;+"# F>/.)+ .B#>$$ %;+

    @%E.(%"B WB+.(J ( .##"F.EH %;+ $-#F"F>#$ I+#+ ?+:H \>"E+:^

    .(: D.#.:+: %;#>-); %;+ $%#++%$ %> %;+ $E.F+ A.#G+% I;+#+ %;+/

    I>-E: ,+ .-B%">(+: >?? ?># )-($H E"T-># .(: >%;+# )>>:$J

    =E.F+$ I+#+ A+#+ B>AA>:"%"+$ "( %;+ (>%>#">-$

    O#".()-E.# O#.:+ ,+%I++( f-#>D+H @?#"B. .(: %;+ @A+#"B.$J

    !># B>-(%E+$$ %;>-$.(:$H %;+"# I>#%; I.$ A+.$-#+: "( ;>I

    E>() %;+/ B>-E: I>#G 24l ;>-# :./$ .(: $%./ .E"F+J K( ?.B%H

    %;+ .F+#.)+ E"?+R$D.( >? .( @?#"B.( $E.F+ I.$ 9 /+.#$J C.(/

    %0'4#, -#*# 2#*# 2#*)

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    19/92

    N1"3$+* O,+% 0+A:2;+ $2 '"*"9#(+

    KJ

    :": (>% $-#F"F+ %;#>-); %;+ ?"#$% /+.#J O;"$ D+#">: >?

    .:a-$%A+(%H ># \$+.$>("()^ .$ "% I.$ B.EE+:H I.$ ,#-%.E .(:

    >?%+( ?.%.EJ Q>% >(E/ I+#+ %;+$+ D+>DE+ $-,a+B% %> "(;-A.(+

    %#+.%A+(%H ,-% A>$% I+#+ $+D.#.%+: ?#>A %;+"# ?.A"E"+$ .(:

    B-E%-#+H I+#+ "( .( -(?.A"E".# +(F"#>(A+(% .(: I+#+ ?>#B+:

    %> .:>D% (+I B-E%-#.E B-$%>A$ .(: E.()-.)+J

    =E.F+ >I(+#$ #+T-"#+: B>ADE+%+ E>/.E%/ ?#>A %;+"#

    \D#>D+#%/^ .(: :+A.(:+: %;+"# $E.F+$ $+F+# .EE %"+$ %> %;+"#

    ;>A+E.(: .(: ?.A"E/J =E.F+$ I+#+ .E$> G+D% ?#>A >%;+#$ >?

    %;+"# %#",.E ># B-E%-#.E ,.BG)#>-(: %> D#+F+(% .(/ #+,+EE">( >#

    -D#"$"() ?#>A >BB-##"()J Q+F+#%;+E+$$H $E.F+$ I+#+ I"EE"() %>

    ,+ %>#%-#+: .(: G"EE+: "? %;.% I.$ %;+ D#"B+ >? ?#++:>AJ

    ?//@# '0 9/./(("'&

    O;+ ;.#$; .(: "(;-A.(+ %#+.%A+(% >? $E.F+$ :": (>% )>

    -((>%"B+: .A>() B+#%."( B"#BE+$ "( ,>%; f-#>D+ .(:

    @A+#"B.J O;+ #+B>)("%">( %;.% $E.F+#/ :"A"("$;+$ .( +(%"#+

    $>B"+%/ I.$ )."("() )#>-(: .$ %;+ F>"B+$ >? @?#"B.( $E.F+$ "(

    f-#>D+ .(: @A+#"B. I+#+ BE.A>#"() %> ,+ ;+.#:Jg"G+I"$+H %;+ $E.F+$ >? P."%" ,+).( %> B>($":+# %;+"#

    DE");% "( %+#A$ >? (-A,+#$ #.%;+# %;.( B>(:"%">($J !.# A>#+

    $E.F+$ "(;.,"%+: P."%" %;.( I;"%+ $E.F+R>I(+#$H $> %.EG >? .(

    >#).("S+: #+,+EE">( ,+).( %> B"#B-E.%+J O;+ D>E"%"B.E BE"A.%+

    I.$ $;"?%"() "( !#.(B+ .$ I+EEJ O;+ !#+(B; e+F>E-%">( %>>G

    %;+ D>I+# >? )>F+#(A+(% >-% >? %;+ ;.(:$ >? %;+ .#"$%>B#.B/.(: D-% "% "(%> %;+ ;.(:$ >? %;+ D+>DE+J

    Q>I "( P."%"H %;+ e+D-,E"B.( .(: e>/.E"$% D>E"%"B.E

    D.#%"+$ ,+).( %> )#>I "( $%#+()%; .(: (-A,+#$J kE.BG$H

    A-E.%%>+$ .(: I;"%+$ I+#+ .EE F/"() ?># %;+ D>I+# (+B+$$.#/

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    20/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    ML

    %> ?-#%;+# %;+"# D.#%"B-E.# B.-$+cA."(%."( %;+ $%.%-$ T-> >#

    ?#++:>A ?#>A $E.F+#/ .(: B>##-D%">(J

    h>(:"%">($ "( P."%" I+#+ #"D+ .(: %;+ I"(:$ >? B;.()+

    I+#+ T-"BGE/ )#>I"() "(%> . ;>IE"() ).E+J O;+ $++:$ >?

    #+,+EE">( .(: #+F>E-%">( ;.: $D#>-%+: .(: )#>I(H .(: (>I

    %;+ ;.#F+$% I.$ .% ;.(:J U;.% I>-E: B>A+ >? %;+$+ %#>-,E"()

    %"A+$V U>-E: P."%" $-#F"F+V

    A/%@/1#5"$ :1/%#21/ BC

    '>%+(%".E "$ .( >DD>#%-("%/ ?.B"() +.B; E+.:+#J O;+

    :"#+B%">( %;.% D>%+(%".E ?E>I$ "$ %;+ E+.:+#`$ #+$D>($","E"%/J

    U"EE "% ,+ ?># %;+ )#+.%+# )>>: ># I"EE "% ,#"() ;.#A .(:

    :+$%#-B%">(V O;-$ E+.:+#$ A-$% %#+.% D>%+(%".E I"%; %;+

    -%A>$% #+$D+B% .(: ;>(># "% .$ . E"?+`$ B.EE"() .$ %;+"# E+).B/

    I"EE #+A."( E>() .?%+# %;+/ ;.F+ )>(+J

    P."%" %+.B;+$ -$ %;.% . (+I ?#>(%"+# "$ %+$% >? F"$">( .(:

    $%+I.#:$;"DJ

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    21/92

    MK

    #$%&' *+,

    :/7,7;- ($)($"(

    ?; 9$%"- 9$#( :$"( @+&9 9($#(% $%" ($3&92

    $%" &9(; $3( :/%(< A2 &9( BCDE2 9$#( -F+,(%G

    K$.".; 66*0H QgO

    0+ (++ 3*#9+ 2.*(+AD+( #, Q+"*#,? $1+ ;"(8 2=

    1#?1R(3#*#$+9,+(() $12.?1 2,A< S2.) >29) "*+

    1#?1 "72D+ "AAB T;7#$#2, (++8( 12,2* ",9 ?A2*B"+%/ I"EE (.%-#.EE/$+)#+).%+ "(%> )#>-D$ >? %;>$+ I;> ;.F+ .(: %;>$+ I;> ;.F+

    (>%J '#>$D+#"%/ "$ (>% %;+ (>#A ?># %;+ A.a>#"%/ >? $>B"+%/ .$

    2N2,=+((#2,(WX$B T.?.($#,+m k>>G 0H h;.D%+# 6H D 45m h>D/#");% n

    0113H k#":)+ g>)>$

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    22/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    MM

    %;+ I+.E%; .(: #+$>-#B+$ .#+ B>(%#>EE+: ,/ . A"(>#"%/ >?

    B"%"S+($ "( )>F+#(A+(%H ,-$"(+$$ ># ,>%;J

    =-B; I.$ %;+ B.$+ "( P."%" ,/ %;+ /+.# 2987J h>($":+#+:

    %> ,+ %;+ #"B;+$% B>E>(/ "( %;+ U+$% K(:"+$H .(: A>$%

    D#>,.,E/ %;+ #"B;+$% "( %;+ ;"$%>#/ >? %;+ I>#E:H =."(%R

    N>A"()-+ I.$ ,E+$$+: I"%; ?+#%"E+ $>"E .(: .( ":+.E BE"A.%+J

    P>I+F+#H %;+ ;.#F+$% >? %;"$ "$E.(: D.#.:"$+ I.$ $>I( .(:

    ).%;+#+: ,/ %;+ %>"EH $I+.% .(: ,E>>: >? $E.F+ E.,>#J (:"%">($H %;+ D>># ,+B.A+ D>>#+# I;"E+ %;+ #"B;

    ,+B.A+ #"B;+#J

    D%1%@"#/ A'#7E

    !>-# :"$%"(B% D+>DE+ )#>-D$ I+#+ .B%"F+ "( =."(%RN>A"()-+ I;+( %;+ !#+(B; e+F>E-%">( ,+).( "( 2987H

    "(BE-:"()*

    U;"%+$ Y.DD#>_"A.%+E/ 01H111 A>$%E/ !#+(B;Z

    !#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># Y.DD#>_"A.%+E/ 31H111 j ;.E? >?

    I;"B; I+#+ %;+ A-E.%%> B;"E:#+( >? I;"%+ !#+(B;A+(.(: $E.F+ I>A+(H ;.E? >? I;"B; I+#+ ,E.BG $E.F+$

    I;> ;.: D-#B;.$+: %;+"# ?#++:>AZ

    kE.BG $E.F+$ Y.DD#>_"A.%+E/ 511H111Z

    C.#>>($ Y#-(.I./ $E.F+$ E"F"() "( %;+ A>-(%."($H

    G++D"() @?#"B.( B-$%>A$ .(: #+E")">( .E"F+Z

    f.B; D+>DE+ )#>-D I.$ :#"F+( ,/ "%$ >I( D#+F."E"()

    D>"(% >? F"+IH ,-% .E$> "(BE-:+: %;>$+ I"%; B>AD+%"()

    $D+B".E "(%+#+$%$J O;"$ B>(?-$">( .::+: %> %;+ B.-E:#>( >?

    A"$%#-$% .(: ;+ED+: ?-+E %;+ ?"#+$ >? :"$B>(%+(%J =."(%R

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    23/92

    N1"3$+* 6Q2% !"#$#U( -#?1$ =2* C,9+3+,9+,:+

    M5

    N>A"()-+ I.$ %++%+#"() D#+B.#">-$E/ >( %;+ +:)+ >? #+F>E%J

    U;"%+$ .(: ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># I+#+ -D$+% I"%; %;+ %#.:"()

    D>E"B"+$ >? %;+ !#+(B; A>%;+#E.(:m >%;+# I;"%+$ I+#+ ?-#">-$

    I"%; D>E"B"+$ %;.% .EE>I+: .(/ (>(RI;"%+$ %> >I( E.(: >#

    B>(:-B% ,-$"(+$$m %;+ ,E.BG $E.F+$ I+#+ $> :>I(R%#>::+(

    %;+/ (++:+: %> #"$+ >-% >? %;+ A"#+ ># ?.B+ $-#+ :+.%;m %;+

    A.#>>($ I.(%+: @?#"B. "( %;+ @A+#"B.$J U;.% I.$

    ;.DD+("() "( D.#.:"$+V

    9/./(("'& '0 75/ *(%>F ?(%G/#

    =."(%RN>A"()-+ I.$ (>% D.#.:"$+ ?># %;+ ,E.BG $E.F+

    D>D-E.%">(J W-%(-A,+#"() %;+ I;"%+$ .(: ?#++ D+>DE+ >?

    B>E># ,/ . A.#)"( >? %+( %> >(+H .(/ >#).("S+: -D#"$"() B>-E:;.F+ :#.A.%"B #+$-E%$J !#>A %;+ ,+)"(("()H %;+ $E.F+$

    #+$"$%+: .(: >?%+( #>$+ "( #+,+EE">(H ,-% %;+"# .%%+AD%$ ?>#

    ?#++:>A I+#+ T-"BGE/ .(: ;.#$;E/ $-,:-+:J Q+F+#%;+E+$$H

    B;.()+ I.$ "( %;+ ."#J h"F"E I.# "( !#.(B+ .(: B;.>$ .A>()

    %;+ I;"%+$ "( =."(%RN>A"()-+ B#+.%+: . ;>$D"%.,E+

    +(F"#>(A+(% ?># %;+ $++:$ >? #+,+EE">( %> )#>IJO;+ ,+)"(("() >? %;+ A.$$"F+ $E.F+ #+,+EE">( %;.% I>-E:

    +F+(%-.EE/ E+.: %>

    %;+"# ?#++:>A .(:

    %;+ +$%.,E"$;A+(%

    >? %;+ I>#E:`$ ?"#$%

    ,E.BG #+D-,E"B B.(,+ $+% .% %;+

    +F+("() >? @-)-$%

    02H 2972J =E.F+$ ;.: ,++( :+$+#%"() %;+ DE.(%.%">($ "(

    -(D#+B+:+(%+: (-A,+#$ D#"># %> %;"$ ;"$%>#"B :./ .(: .$ .

    ?/"# 3011+8'/#, "10+)(8 :'

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    24/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    MF

    #+$-E%H %;+ #.(G$ >? %;+ A.#>>($ ;.: $I+EE+: .$ %;+$+

    #-(.I./ $E.F+$ ;.: ,++( .$$"A"E.%+: "(%> %;+"# $>B"+%/J

    O;+ A.#>>($ D#.B%"B+: i>>:>> .$ %;+"# D#"A.#/

    #+E")">(H I;"B; I.$ . %;#>IR,.BG %> %;+"# @?#"B.( #>>%$J W(

    %;+ +F+("() >? @-)-$% 24H 2972H %;+ '+%I> i>>:>> B-E% ;+E:

    . $+#F"B+ "( I;"B; . I>A.( ,+B.A+ D>$$+$$+: ,/ %;+

    I.##"># $D"#"%H W)>-(J U;"E+ D>$$+$$+:H %;"$ I>A.(

    $.B#"?"B+: . ,E.BG D") .(: %;+( $D+.G"() "( %;+ F>"B+ >? %;+

    $D"#"%H (.A+: k>-GA.(H M+.(R!#.(B>"$H k".$$>- .(: M+((>%

    .$ %;+ )+(+#.E$ I;> I+#+ %> E+.: %;+ $E.F+$ .(: A.#>>($ "( .

    #+F>E% .)."($% %;+ I;"%+ $E.F+ >I(+#$J O;+$+ E+.:+#$ I+#+

    .E$> %> +_.B% ;.#$; a-:)A+(% .)."($% %;+ I;"%+$ ,+B.-$+ >?

    %;+"# >DD#+$$">( >? %;+ ,E.BG $E.F+$J

    WF+# %;+ ?>EE>I"() I++GH I>#: $D#+.: #.D":E/ .A>()

    %;+ $E.F+$ .(: %;+ A.#>>($ >? %;+ ;"$%>#"B .(: D#>D;+%"B

    #+E")">-$ $+#F"B+J O;+(H >( @-)-$% 02H 2972H %;+ ?E>>:).%+$

    ;>E:"() ,.BG %;+ #"$"() I.%+#$ >? #+,+EE">( ,-#$% #+E+.$"() .

    ?E>>: >? #+F>E-%">( %;.% I>-E: (>% #+B+:+ -(%"E "% B>F+#+: .EE

    >? =."(%RN>A"()-+H .(: .EE %;+ $E.F+$ I+#+ ?#++J

    H5' ;# I"657"&6 H5'3E

    f.#E/ "( %;+ #+F>E% %;+ E"(+$ >? ,.%%E+ I+#+ D>>#E/ :#.I(J

    O;+ ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># ;.: ?>#A+: . $%#.()+ .EE".(B+ I"%;

    %;+ ,E.BG $E.F+$H +F+( %;>-); %;+/ %+(:+: %> ,+ A>#+ ,#-%.E

    $E.F+ >I(+#$ %;.( %;+ I;"%+$J O;+ I;"%+$ :":(`% I.(% %>.-%>A.%"B.EE/ "$$-+ %;+ #");%$ >? B"%"S+($ %> %;+ ?#++ D+>DE+ >?

    B>E>#H ,-% :":(`% I.(% %> ?");% .)."($% %;+A +"%;+#J W%;+#

    I;"%+$ :+A.(:+: . B;.()+ "( %;+ I./ !#.(B+ ;.(:E+: "%$

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    25/92

    N1"3$+* 6Q2% !"#$#U( -#?1$ =2* C,9+3+,9+,:+

    MG

    %#.:+ .)#++A+(% I"%; =."(%RN>A"()-+J O;+/ I.(%+: .(

    .)#++A+(% %;.% I.$ A>#+ +T-"%.,E+ .(: D#>?"%.,E+J

    W( =+D%+A,+# 01H 2972H . A.a># $;"?% >( %;+ "$E.(:

    >BB-##+: .$ %;+ h>E>(".E @$$+A,E/ .-%;>#"S+: B"%"S+($;"D >?

    .EE ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># #+).#:E+$$ >? %;+"# D#>D+#%/ .(: ,"#%;

    $%.%-$J O;+ !#+(B; @$$+A,E/ ?>EE>I+: $-"% ,/ )#.(%"() ?-EE

    B"%"S+($;"D ?># ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># >( @D#"E 4H 2970J O;"$

    ;+ED+: ).EF.("S+ %;+ ,.%%E+RE"(+$ >? %;+ P."%".( #+F>E-%">(

    "(%> $E.F+$ .(: A.#>>($ >( >(+ $":+H I;"%+$ .(: ?#++ D+>DE+

    >? B>E># >( %;+ >%;+#J

    @( +A"$$.#/ ?#>A !#.(B+H g+)+# !+E"B"%+ =>(%;>(._H

    .##"F+: "( =."(%RN>A"()-+ >( =+D%+A,+# 28H 2970 I"%;

    >#:+#$ ?#>A o"() %> T-+EE %;+ -D#"$"()J Q>% >(E/ I+#+ %;+

    $E.F+$ "( #+F>E%H ,-% %+($">($ ,+%I++( :"??+#+(% ?.B%">($ >?

    %;+ I;"%+ A"(>#"%/ %;#+.%+(+: .(/ $>E":.#"%/ %;.% A./ ,+

    ?>#)+: .A>() %;+AJ g"G+I"$+H ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># I+#+ $%"EE

    -($-#+ >? %;+"# $%.%-$ .BB>#:"() %> %;+ !#+(B; )>F+#(A+(%J

    =>(%;>(._ ?+E% ;+ ;.: .BB>ADE"$;+: ;"$ %;#++ A.a>#

    )>.E$ I"%;"( ?>-# A>(%;$ >? ;"$ .##"F.EJ O;+ )>.E$ "(BE-:+:*

    '.B"?"B.%">( ># B>(%."(A+(% >? %;+ $E.F+ #+,+EE">(

    N+?+.% >? %;+ D#"A.#/ I;"%+ #+$"$%.(B+

    P>E: %;+ B>E>(/ ?># !#.(B+

    P>I+F+#H ;"$ .BB>ADE"$;A+(%$ :": (>% E.$%J N-#"()

    !+,#-.#/ 2973H !#.(B+ :+BE.#+: I.# >( k#"%."(H I;"B; A+.(%

    %;.% =>(%;>(._` $-DDE/ E"(+$ %> !#.(B+ I+#+ B>AD#>A"$+:

    ,/ %;+ $-D+#"># k#"%"$; (.F/J N-#"() %;+ $.A+ A>(%; o"()

    g>-"$ piK I.$ D-% %> :+.%; A.G"() !#.(B+ . #+D-,E"B

    I"%;>-% . G"()J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    26/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    MH

    U"%; g>-"$ piK`$ :+.%;H $-$D"B">( )#+I %>I.#: %;+

    !#+(B; )>F+#(A+(%J =E.F+$ I+#+ +A,>E:+(+: %> D"BG -D %;+

    #+,+EE">(H ?#++ D+>DE+ >? B>E># I+#+ +F+( A>#+ -($-#+ >?

    %;+"# $%.%-$ .BB>#:"() %> %;+ !#+(B; )>F+#(A+(% .(: %;+

    I;"%+$ I+#+ $DE"% ,+%I++( %;+ #>/.E"$%$ I;> :+A.(:+: .

    G"() .(: %;>$+ $-DD>#%"() "(:+D+(:+(B+J

    J3%&>"$%7"'& A''3# '& 75/ !'1"8'&

    !+.#"() %;.% ,>%; %;+ k#"%"$; .(: =D.("$; I>-E: .%%.BG

    =."(%RN>A"()-+H =>(%;>(._ ,+).( D#+D.#.%">( ?># %;+

    "(+F"%.,E+J O;+ !#+(B; )+(+#.EH L.E,.-:H ,+%#./+:

    =>(%;>(._ "( .( .%%+AD% %> :+D>#% .EE %;+ B>AA"$$">(+#$H

    "(BE-:"() =>(%;>(._H "( >#:+# %> I>#G I"%; %;+ k#"%"$; ?>#%;+ #+%-#( >? %;+ .(B"+(% #+)"A+H %;-$ (+).%"() .(/ B"%"S+(

    $%.%-$ >? %;+ ?#++ A+( >? B>E>#J

    @ ,.%%E+ +($-+: .(: "% .DD+.#+: %;.% L.E,.-: I>-E:

    D#+F."EH $> =>(%;>(._ :": I;.% ;+ :++A+: (+B+$$.#/ %> T-+EE

    %;+ A-%"(/J P+ D#+$$+: 25H111 ,E.BG $E.F+$ "(%> ;"$ .#A/ %>

    :+?+.% L.E,.-: I"%; %;+ D#>A"$+ >? +A.(B"D.%">( ?>#$+#F"()J O;+/ .)#++: -(:+# %;+ B>(:"%">( %;.% %;+"# ?.A"E"+$

    ,+ ?#++: .$ I+EE I;"B; A+.(% 31H111 %> 41H111 ,E.BG$

    ,+B.A+ B"%"S+($J

    =>(%;>(._ ;.: ")("%+: %;+ "#+ >? .EE %;+ I;"%+$ .(: ?#++

    A+( >? B>E># I"%; ;"$ :+B"$">( %> +A.(B"D.%+ %;+ $E.F+ .#A/

    -$+: %> :+?+.% L.E,.-:J O;+ #+A."("() $E.F+$H ;>I+F+#H $.I%;"$ .$ %;+"# >DD>#%-("%/ ?># ?#++:>AJ =>(%;>(._H G(>I"()

    .(/ ;+ED ?#>A %;+ ;>A+E.(: I.$ "AD>$$",E+ I"%; %;+

    >()>"() I.#H :+B#++: >( @-)-$% 07H 2973 %;+ +A.(B"D.%">(

    >? $E.F+#/ "( =."(%RN>A"()-+J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    27/92

    N1"3$+* 6Q2% !"#$#U( -#?1$ =2* C,9+3+,9+,:+

    MP

    :5/ ?71266(/ 0'1 D'K/1

    O;+ I.#$ I"%; =D."( .(: k#"%."( ,#>-);% )#+.% ;.#:$;"D

    %> =."(%RN>A"()-+J K(%+#(.E $%#"?+ .(: I;"%+$ I;> I+#+

    .EE"+: I"%; %;+ k#"%"$; A.:+ "% :"??"B-E% %> G(>I I;> %;+

    +(+A"+$ #+.EE/ I+#+J =D."( ?"(.EE/ D-EE+: >-% :-+ %> %;+"#

    :+?+.% "( f-#>D+ .(: %;+ k#"%"$; $>>( ?>EE>I+:J C+.(I;"E+H

    =>(%;>(._ I.$ $-AA>(+: ,.BG %> !#.(B+ %> +_DE."( ;"$

    :+B"$">( %> +A.(B"D.%+ 511H111 ,E.BG $E.F+$b

    O;+ ,E.BG )+(+#.EH O>-$$."(%H ;.: ,++( %;+ D#"A.#/

    ?>#B+ %> B>(%+(: I"%; ?#>A C./ 2974 %> WB%>,+# 2978J

    N-#"() %;.% %"A+ ;+ ;.: :#"F+( %;+ k#"%"$; >-% >? =."(%R

    N>A"()-+H ;.: >F+#$++( %;+ #+%#+.% >? %;+ =D.("$;H >-$%+:

    .EE )+(-"(+ !#+(B; .-%;>#"%/ .(: ;.: ,+B>A+ B>AA.(:+# "(B;"+? .(: )>F+#(>#R)+(+#.E >? =."(%RN>A"()-+J

    O>-$$."(% B>(%"(-+: ;"$ #"$+ %> D>I+# .(: ,+B.A+ F+#/

    ,-$/ ,#>G+#"() %#.:+ :+.E$ I"%; !#.(B+H k#"%."( .(: %;+

    I>#G"() %>I.#:"(:+D+(:+(B+ ?#>A

    !#.(B+ .(: E+.("()

    %>I.#: . %#.:+

    .)#++A+(% I"%; %;+

    >A+: I"%; %;+A-E.%%> ?>#B+$ -(:+# e").-:H . ?>#A+# .EE/J O>-$$."(%

    $-BB+$$?-EE/ :+?+(:+: ;"$ D>$"%">( .(: "( 2812 I.$ (.A+:

    )>F+#(>#R)+(+#.E ?># E"?+ "( %;+ (+I #+D-,E"B`$ B>($%"%-%">(J

    C"#( ,0'4#*6 -', *#,/1*#+ 1( /"#

    ),0'(+ 13 D.'+'0. )( /"#9'*)::#'(7 E')/)'( 0#'+#*, '8')(

    *1,# )( *#:#00)1(7 +#/#*2)(#+ (1/

    /1 81 :'

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    28/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    MI

    P+ I.$ ?"(.EE/ .##+$%+: .(: #+%-#(+: %> !#.(B+ I;+#+ ;+ E.%+#

    :"+:J

    Q.D>E+>(H I;> ;.: .$$-A+: D>I+# "( !#.(B+H $+(%

    ,+%I++( 26H111 .(: 01H111 %#>>D$ %> T-+EE %;+ #+,+EE">( "(

    P."%" .(: #+R+$%.,E"$; %;+ B>E>(/ -(:+# %;+ A>#+ D#"A"%"F+

    #-E+ >(B+ +(a>/+: %;+#+J O;+ !#+(B; ,-$"(+$$A+( I;> I+#+

    :"$DE.B+: I"%; %;+ +A.(B"D.%">( >? %;+ $E.F+$ .(: I;> ;.:

    E>$% D#>D+#%/ .(: B>AA+#B+ >( %;+ "$E.(: I.(%+: #+B>-#$+H

    $> Q.D>E+>( ,>I+: %> %;+ D#+$$-#+J

    ;&@/$/&@/&>/ L%MN

    U;+( $E.F+#/ I.$ #+$%>#+: >( %;+ "$E.(: >? L-.:.E-D+

    "( %;+ h.#",,+.(H P."%".( E+.:+#$ .)."( #>$+ "( #+,+EE">(H:+%+#A"(+: (>% %> )> ,.BG %> $E.F+#/J N-#"() %;.% %"A+H

    k#"%."( .(: !#.(B+ .)."( :+BE.#+: I.#H I;"B; T-"BGE/

    :+DE+%+: %;+ #+$>-#B+$ (+B+$$.#/ %> #+R%.G+ P."%"J Q.D>E+>(

    $>E: g>-"$".(. %> %;+ AA.(:+# %;+( ?E+: %> M.A."B. .(: P."%" I+(% -(:+# %;+

    B>(%#>E >? M+.(RM.BT-+ N+$$.E"(+$H . ?>#A+# ?"+E: $E.F+J

    P."%" ?>#A.EE/ :+BE.#+: "(:+D+(:+(B+ ?#>A !#.(B+ >(

    M.(-.#/ 2H 2814H ,+B>A"() %;+ I>#E:`$ ?"#$% ,E.BG #+D-,E"BJK( 2815H N+$$.E"(+$ :+BE.#+: ;"A$+E? fAD+#># >? P."%"

    ;+.#G+("() %;+ ,+)"(("() >? . (+I +#. ?># %;+ '+.#E >? %;+

    @(%"EE+$J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    29/92

    N1"3$+* 6Q2% !"#$#U( -#?1$ =2* C,9+3+,9+,:+

    MJ

    =7 H5%7 ,'#7E

    U;.% I.$ %;+ B>$% >? P."%"`$ "(:+D+(:+(B+V P>I B.(

    >(+ +F+( B>-(% %;+ %#-+ B>$% >? 23 /+.#$ >? I.#V

    O;+ (+I (.%">(`$ "(?#.$%#-B%-#+ I.$ B>ADE+%+E/ "( .

    $;.A,E+$J O;+ D#+F."E"() .%%"%-:+ >? %;+ #+F>E-%">(.#/

    I.##">#$ I.$ %> +#.:"B.%+ .EE f-#>D+.( "(?E-+(B+$ ?#>A P."%"H

    "(BE-:"() %;+ DE.(%.%">($H ?.B%>#"+$H .(: ;>E:"()$ >? %;+ $E.F+

    >I(+#$J

    E: %;>-$.(:$ ;.: E>$% %;+"# E"F+$ ># E>F+: >(+$ %>

    F">E+(B+H :"$+.$+ .(: :"$.$%+#J O;+ $;+.# ,#-%.E"%/ >? .B%$

    B>AA"%%+: ,/ ,>%; $":+$ )>+$ ,+/>(: #.%">(.E ;-A.(

    B>($B"+(B+J f.B; $":+ %#.:+: .%#>B"%/ I"%; .%#>B"%/H %;+

    :+$B#"D%">($ >? I;"B; .#+ $"BG+("() .(: ,+/>(: ,+E"+?H +F+(%> %;>$+ .BB-$%>A+: %> ;-A.( ,#-%.E"%/ %>I.#: >%;+#$J

    O>#%-#+H #.D+H ,#-%.E A-#:+#$H A.$$ A-#:+#$ >? (>(R

    B>A,.%.(%$H A-%"E.%">(H ?>#B"() ?.A"E"+$ %> I.%B; %;+ %>#%-#+H

    #.D+ .(: :+.%; >? E>F+: >(+$ .(: >( .(: >(J O;+ E.$% /+.# >?

    %;+ P."%".( e+F>E-%">( I.$ .$ $.F.)+ .$ .(/ B>(?E"B% >(+ B.(

    #+.: >? "( ;-A.( ;"$%>#/J K% %#-E/ ,+B.A+ . I.# >? #.B".E+_%+#A"(.%">( >( ,>%; $":+$J

    U"%; (> BE+.# F"$">( ?># %;+ ?-%-#+H %;+ (+I (.%">( $D+(%

    %;+ (+_% 211 /+.#$ "( -%%+# %-#A>"E .$ (.%-#.E #+$>-#B+$ I+#+

    :+DE+%+: .(: E+.:+#$ A.#B;+: "( .(: >-% >? >??"B+J O;+ #+F>E%

    ,+).( "( . i>>:>> $+#F"B+ .$ . :+A>( $D>G+ %;#>-); .

    I>A.( .(: (.A+: >??"B+#$ >? %;+ ?E+:)E"() ,E.BG .#A/J k/F"#%-+ >? %;.% \D#>D;+B/^ .E>(+H %;+ +(%"#+ +??>#% I.$ ;.(:+:

    >F+# %> =.%.( %> -$+ %;+ A+( .(: I>A+( >? P."%" .$ ;+

    :+$"#+: %> ,#"() .,>-% ;"$ -()>:E/ D-#D>$+$J M+$-$ $.":*

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    30/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    5L

    HI9( &9/(J K+:(- +%8; &+ -&($8 $%" ,/88 $%"

    "(-&3+;L A 9$#( K+:( &9$& &9(; :$; 9$#( 8/J(2

    $%" 9$#( /& &+ &9( J588;( 21*21Z

    U"EE P."%" B;>>$+ E"?+V

    A/%@/1#5"$ :1/%#21/ BO

    O;+ )#+.%+$% I.# . E+.:+# ?.B+$ "$ %;+ ?");% .)."($% $+E?R

    B+(%+#+: F"$">( %;.% E>>A$ E.#)+# %;.( B>(B+#( ?># >%;+#$J

    h>(B+#( ?># $+E? >F+# >%;+#$ E+.:$ %> :+$%#-B%"F+ :+B"$">($

    %;.% ,#"() ;.#A %> %;>$+ -(:+# %;+ E+.:+#`$ B.#+J

    P."%" %+.B;+$ -$ %;.% . I.# ?-+E+: ,/ )#++: #+$-E%$ "(

    :+.%;J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    31/92

    5K

    #$%&' * '&&

    4-%'/,() /$) !'%$(

    .( -(%& "$3,%(-- $%" :$"( &9( 8$%" "$3,=

    J+3 9$" &9(; %+& 3(@(88(" $'$/%-& 9/- 7+3"-N

    '$.EA$ 215*08

    O;+ "AA>#.E ,E");% >? $E.F+#/ :#+I =."(%RN>A"()-+"(%> %;+ %;#>+$ >? #+F>E-%">(J @?%+# %;"#%++( /+.#$ >? F">E+(B+

    .(: "(;-A.(+ ,E>>:$;+:H . (+I (.%">( I.$ ,>#(]P."%"H %;+

    I>#E:`$ ?"#$% ,E.BG #+D-,E"BJ

    @$ %;+ ?E+:)E"() (.%">( $>-);% %> ,#"() $%.,"E"%/ %> "%$

    I.#R%>#( B>-(%#/$":+H B>AD+%"() "(%+#+$%$ I"%;"( %;+

    #+F>E-%">(.#/ #.(G$ E+: %> "(R?");%"() .(: +F+( A>#+F">E+(B+J W(+ E+.:+# I.(%+: %> +$%.,E"$; . G"():>A I"%;

    ;"A .$ G"()J @(>%;+# I.(%+: ?#++H :+A>B#.%"B )>F+#(A+(%

    $"A"E.# %> %;+ %;+

    B>AA>( A.$$+$J!># %;+ F.$% A.a>#"%/ >? P."%".($H %;+ +$%.,E"$;A+(% >?

    )>F+#(A+(% I.$ +BE"D$+: ,/ %;+ :."E/ $%#-))E+ %> $-#F"F+J

    !#++:>AH I;"E+ ?.# $-D+#"># %> %;+ "(;-A.(+ $E.F+#/ %;+/

    ;.: +_D+#"+(B+:H D#+$+(%+: (+I .(: :"??+#+(% B;.EE+()+$ %>

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    32/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    5M

    >F+#B>A+J =.:E/H P."%" I>-E: E+.#( %;.% $E.F+#/ B>A+$ "(

    A.(/ ?>#A$ +.B; >? I;"B; E+.:$ %> :+.%;J

    :' H5'3 L' H/ :21&

    O;+ B.EE %> ,.%%E+ I.$ #+B+"F+: :-#"() . i>>:>> #"%-.E "(

    @-)-$% >? 2972J N-#"() %;.% $+#F"B+H . I>A.( ,+B.A+

    D>$$+$$+: ,/ W)>-(H %;+ I.##"># $D"#"%H .(: %;+( (.A+: %;+

    )+(+#.E$ I;> I>-E: E+.: %;+ #+F>E%J O;+ #+F>E-%">( I.$

    B>(B+"F+: .(: %;+ (+I (.%">( ,"#%;+: -(:+# %;+ :.#G(+$$ >?

    >BB-E%H i>>:>> I>#$;"DJ O;"$ $.A+ :.#G(+$$ ,+B.A+ .

    $;#>-: %;.% :+$B+(:+: >F+# %;+ E.(: .(: :-EE+: %;+ A"(:$ >?

    %;+ D+>DE+J O;+"# +/+$ I+#+ (>% ?>B-$+: >( L>:H ,-% >( +F"EH

    $.%.("B #"%-.E$ .(: ":>E I>#$;"DJ M+$-$ $.":*

    O+53 (;( /- $ 8$:F J+3 ;+53 @+";< ! F53( (;(

    8(&- -5%-9/%( /%&+ ;+53 -+58< *5& $% (#/8 (;(

    -95&- +5& &9( 8/'9& $%" F85%'(- ;+5 /%&+

    "$3,%(--< AJ &9( 8/'9& ;+5 &9/%, ;+5 9$#( /-

    3($88; "$3,%(--2 9+7 "((F &9$& "$3,%(-- 7/88@(GYC.%%J 6*00R03 QgOZ

    O;+ B>(:"%">($ M+$-$ :+$B#",+: I+#+ +A,>:"+: "( %;+

    (.%">( >? P."%" .$ %;+/ #-$;+: ;+.:E>() "(%> . (+I +#. "EER

    +T-"DD+: %> ;.(:E+ %;+ $%#+$$ .(: $%#."( >? ?>#A"() . (.%">(J

    @ D.#.EE+E B.( ,+ :#.I( I"%; %;+ ?>#A.%">( >? .(>%;+# (.%">(I;>$+ $%>#/ "$ %>E: "( %;+ k",E+J

    O;+ B;"E:#+( >? K$#.+E I+#+ $E.F+$ "( %;+ (.%">( >? f)/D%

    ?># A>#+ %;.( 411 /+.#$J !"(.EE/H B>(:"%">($ ,+B.A+ $>

    ,#-%.E %;.% %;+/ B#"+: >-% %> L>: ?># ?#++:>AJ L>: ;+.#:

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    33/92

    N1"3$+* 61*++% C(2A"$+9 ",9 TA2,+

    55

    %;+"# B#/ .(: $.I %;+"# %+##># $> P+ B.EE+: -D>( C>$+$ %>

    E+.: %;+A >-%J

    C>$+$ ?.B+: A.(/ %#".E$ .$ ;+ B>(?#>(%+: %;+ f)/D%".(

    G"() .,>-% $+%%"() K$#.+E ?#++J O+( ,#-%.E DE.)-+$H %;+ E.$% >?

    I;"B; BE."A+: .EE %;+ ?"#$%,>#( >? f)/D%H ?"(.EE/ ?>#B+: %;+

    G"() %> #+E+.$+ %;+ D+>DE+ %> %;+"# ?#++:>AJ O;+(H ?>EE>I"()

    C>$+$H %;+/ ?E+: "(%> %;+ :+$+#%$ >? ="(."J

    O;+ (++: ?># L>:`$ ;+ED %> E+.: %;+ D+>DE+ I+");+:

    ;+.F"E/ >( C>$+$H $> ;+ B>(%"(-.EE/ B#"+: >-% %> L>: "(

    D#./+# ?># )-":.(B+ .(: -(:+#$%.(:"()J O;+ D+>DE+H

    ;>I+F+#H )#>.(+: .(: )#-A,E+: .,>-% %;+ B>(:"%">($ %;+/

    +(B>-(%+#+: E"F"() "( %;+ :+$+#%J O;"$ B-EA"(.%+: I"%; %;+"#

    ,-"E:"() . )>E:+( B.E? %> I>#$;"DJ

    U;+( C>$+$ :"$B>F+#+: %;+ %#+.B;+#/ ;+ B#"+: >-% %> L>:

    ?># A+#B/H G(>I"() %;.% a-:)A+(% I>-E: ?>EE>I $-B; .

    )#"+F>-$ .B%J O;.% :./H A>#+ %;.( 3H111 $>-E$ I+#+ G"EE+: "( .(

    +.#%;T-.G+ ?>EE>I+: T-"BGE/ ,/ . :+.:E/ DE.)-+J W(E/ I;+(

    %;+ D+>DE+ #+D+(%+:

    :": %;+"# ?>#%-(+$

    %-#(J

    W(+ ?>#A >?

    $E.F+#/ I.$ ,#>G+(

    I;+( %;+ B;"E:#+(

    >? K$#.+E E+?% f)/D%J Q+F+#%;+E+$$H .(>%;+# ?>#A >? $E.F+#/ E./

    "( I."% "( %;+ F.$% ,.##+((+$$ >? ="(."H $++G"() %> >F+#I;+EA

    %;+ D+>DE+ .(: #+%-#( %;+A %> ,>(:.)+J

    A/7 I1//@'3 9"&6E

    D1+ "'+ :##( )(/*1+.

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    34/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    5F

    AJ ;+5 "+ 79$& /- 3/'9&2 7/88 ;+5 %+& @(

    $KK(F&("N *5& /J ;+5 "+ %+& "+ 79$& /- 3/'9&2

    -/% /- K3+5K9/%' $& ;+53 "++3L /& "(-/3(- &+

    9$#( ;+52 @5& ;+5 :5-& :$-&(3 /&< YL+(J 4*9Z

    L>:`$ I>#:$ %> h."( #+?E+B% %;+ %#-%; %;.% B>(?#>(%+:

    P."%"J ="( "(:++: B#>-B;+$ .% %;+ :>>#H I."%"() %> >F+#I;+EA

    -$ .(: ,"(: -$ "( $"(J =B#"D%-#+ BE+.#E/ %+.B;+$ %;.% ,>(:.)+

    %> $"( "$ . ?>#A >? $E.F+#/H .(: $"( "$ I;.% +()-E?+: P."%"

    %;#>-); i>>:>> #"%+$ .(: $.%.("B I>#$;"D #"%-.E$J L>: ;.:

    ,++( "(%#>:-B+: %> %;+ "$E.(:H ,-% %;>$+ I;> "(%#>:-B+: P"A

    :": (>% :+A>($%#.%+ %;+ "(%+)#"%/ >? %#-+ h;#"$%".( I"%(+$$J

    O;+#+?>#+H %;+ @?#"B.($ I;> I+#+ ,#>-);% %;+#+ .$ $E.F+$

    ;+E: >( %> %;+"# .(B"+(% D.).( #+E")">( .(: I+#+ .)."( ,>-(:

    >F+# %> %;+ :.#G(+$$ .(: $E.F+#/ >? $"(J

    KAA+:".%+E/ .?%+# "(:+D+(:+(B+H N+$$.E"(+$ :+BE.#+:

    ;"A$+E? fAD+#># >? P."%" .(: $>-);% %> B#+.%+ . B>-#%J

    O;>-); ;"$ +??>#%$ I+#+ A+% I"%; #":"B-E+ ,/ %;+ A>#+

    +:-B.%+: A-E.%%>+$H N+$$.E"(+$ :": D#>A>%+ B+#%."( >%;+#$ %>

    B#+.%+ .( .#"$%>B#.B/ I;"E+ #+$+#F"() #>/.E%/ ?># ;"A$+E?J P+

    .E$> +(B>-#.)+: A.##".)+$ ,+%I++( %;+ ,E.BG .(: A-E.%%>

    ?.B%">($H %;>-); %;+ >??+# >? ;"$ :.-);%+# %> @E+_.(:#+

    '+%">( I.$ #+a+B%+:J

    fB>(>A"B.EE/H P."%" I.$ "( #-"($J O> #+F"F+ D#>:-B%">(

    >? )>>:$H N+$$.E"(+$ .%%+AD%+: %> #+R"(%#>:-B+ ?>#B+: E.,>#

    >( %;+ DE.(%.%">($J O;"$ +??>#% ?."E+:H .$ :": ;"$ +??>#% %>

    $+B-#+ B>(%#>E >? %;+ =D.("$; +.$%+#( $":+ >? P"$D.(">E.J O;+

    $+E?RD#>BE."A+: +AD+#># I.$ +F+(%-.EE/ .$$.$$"(.%+: .(:

    P."%" I.$ .)."( >( %;+ ;-(% ?># . E+.:+#J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    35/92

    N1"3$+* 61*++% C(2A"$+9 ",9 TA2,+

    5G

    OI> $%#>() B>(%+(:+#$ +A+#)+:H P+(#" h;#"$%>D;+ .(:

    @E+_.(:#+ '+%">(J O;+ A-E.%%> +E"%+ $+E+B%+: h;#"$%>D;+H .

    ,E.BG )+(+#.EH %> ,+ D#+$":+(% .(: '+%">( %> $+#F+ .$ ;+.: >?

    %;+ E+)"$E.%-#+J O;+ +E"%+ B>(%#>EE+: h;#"$%>D;+ .(: .$$-A+:

    %;.% >%;+# $%.(:R"( ,E.BG E+.:+#$ I>-E: ?>EE>I ;"$ E+.:+#$;"DJ

    O;"$ I.$ (>% %> ,+J h;#"$%>D;+ A.#B;+: >( '>#%R.-R

    '#"(B+H ,-% ;"$ A"E"%.#/ .B%">( ?."E+:J '+%">( ;.: ?>#%"?"+: %;+

    B"%/ .(: -$"() %;+ .#%"EE+#/ %;.% h;#"$%>D;+ E.BG+:H I.$ .,E+

    %> %;I.#% %;+ .%%.BGJ h;#"$%>D;+ %;+( A.#B;+: (>#%; .(:

    B.D%-#+: h.D P."%"+(H :+BE.#"() ;"A$+E? o"() P+(#/ K >?

    P."%" .(: #+(.A"() %;+ B"%/ %> h.D P+(#/J h;#"$%>D;+ %;+(

    ,#>-);% "( I.##">#$ ?#>A N.;>-A+/ "( h+(%#.E @?#"B. %>

    $+#F+ .$ ;"$ +E"%+ )-.#:J C+.(I;"E+H '+%">( I.$ B;>$+( ,/

    %;+ +E"%+ %> ,+ D#+$":+(%R?>#RE"?+ >? %;+ e+D-,E"B >? P."%" .(:

    $+%-D >??"B+ "( %;+ B.D"%.E B"%/H '>#%R.-R'#"(B+J

    o"() P+(#/ K Yh;#"$%>D;+Z .(: '#+$":+(%R?>#Rg"?+H

    '+%">(H ;.: F+#/ :"??+#+(% ":+>E>)"+$ #+).#:"() )>F+#(A+(%J

    h;#"$%>D;+ G+D% %;+ DE.(%.%">($ "(%.B% .(: %;+ ?>#A+# $E.F+$

    B>-E: (>% E+.F+ %;+AJ O;>-); ?#++ A+( %;+/ I+#+ (>% .%

    E",+#%/ %> :> .$ %;+/ I"$;+:J Q+F+#%;+E+$$H I>#G"()

    B>(:"%">($ I+#+ +.$"+# .(: +.B; I>#G+# #+B+"F+: >(+ T-.#%+#

    >? %;+ B#>D .$ I.)+$J

    o"() P+(#/`$ #-E+ I.$ $+F+#+H ,-% .$ +_D>#% D#>:-B%">(

    "AD#>F+:H $> :": %;+ $%.(:.#: >? E"F"()J P>I+F+#H %;+ G"()

    B>-E: (>% :> I"%;>-% . D.E.B+ $> ;+ $.B#"?"B+: ,+%I++(

    21H111 .(: 01H111 E"F+$ %> ,-"E: =.( =>-B" .(: %;+ B"%.:+EH

    g. !+##"+#+J

    '+%">(H "( %;+ $D"#"% >? %;+ !#+(B; e+F>E-%">(H :"F":+:

    %;+ E.(: "( %;+ $>-%; "(%> $A.EE D.#B+E$ %> ?.B"E"%.%+ %;+

    B#+.%">( >? . $>B"+%/ >? ?#++ /+>A+(J P"$ $>E:"+#$ #+B+"F+:

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    36/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    5H

    %;+ D.#B+E$ ?#++ I;"E+ >%;+#$ D.": . $A.EE D#"B+J O;"$ D>E"B/

    +(.,E+: +.B; ?.A"E/ %> D#>:-B+ ?>>: ?># %;+"# >I(

    B>($-AD%">(H ,-% :": (>% E+(: "%$+E? %> ,-"E:"() .(/ +_D>#%

    +.#("()$ %> D./ ?># "AD>#%$J U"%;>-% $-).# B.(+ D#>:-B%">(

    "( %;+ $>-%;H %;+ $-).# A"EE$ .(: >%;+# $-,$":".#/ +(%+#D#"$+$

    I+#+ ?>#B+: %> BE>$+J

    '+%">( I.$ I":+E/ #+$D+B%+: .(: ;>(>#+: I;+( ;+ :"+:

    "( 2828H .(: I.$ $-BB++:+: ,/ L+(+#.E M+.(R'"+##+ k>/+#H

    >(+ >? ;"$ .":+$J o"() P+(#/ +F+(%-.EE/ $-??+#+: . $%#>G+

    .(: B>AA"%%+: $-"B":+ #.%;+# %;.( ?.B+ ;.#$; %#+.%A+(% ,/

    ;"$ $-,a+B%$J ( P+(#/`$ :+.%;H k>/+# E+: .( .#A/ (>#%;

    .(: B.D%-#+: h.D P."%"+(H %;-$ #+-("%"() P."%"J

    k>/+#`$ E+.:+#$;"D :": E"%%E+ ?># %;+ P."%".( +B>(>A/ .(: "%

    $%.)(.%+: -(:+# ;"$ #-E+J O> ?-#%;+# B>ADE"B.%+ A.%%+#$H k>/+#

    A.:+ . E.#)+ D./A+(% %> %;+ !#+(B; )>F+#(A+(% %> $+B-#+ ?"(.E

    .BB+D%.(B+ >? P."%".( "(:+D+(:+(B+J O;"$H B>-DE+: I"%; .

    $%.)(.(% +B>(>A/H B.-$+: B>(:"%">($ "( P."%" %> :+%+#">#.%+

    +F+( A>#+H E+.:"() %> .( +F+(%-.E #+,+EE">( %> #+A>F+ ;"A

    ?#>A >??"B+J

    O;#>-);>-%

    %;+ 27%; B+(%-#/

    .(: "(%> %;+ 01%;

    B+(%-#/H P."%"

    $%#-))E+: -(:+#

    ?.B%">-$ E+.:+#$H

    +.B; B.#F"() >-% . ;-)+ $E"B+ ?># %;+A$+EF+$ .(: E+.F"()

    E"%%E+ ?># %;+ B"%"S+($J OI> D>E"%"B.E D.#%"+$ +A+#)+:H %;+

    Q.%">(.E '.#%/H B>(%#>EE+: ,/ ,E.BG$ .(: %;+ g",+#.E '.#%/H

    B>(%#>EE+: ,/ %;+ A-E.%%>$ >? %;+ B"%"+$J

    =(+)(8 /"# :011+,"#+ -', /"#

    133)

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    37/92

    N1"3$+* 61*++% C(2A"$+9 ",9 TA2,+

    5P

    K( 2725 L+(+#.E L-"EE.-A+ =.A )."(+: %;+ D#+$":+(B/

    .(: "AA+:".%+E/ ;.: 269 D>E"%"B.E D#"$>(+#$ +_+B-%+:J O;"$

    "(B"%+: . A.$$"F+ #">% "( '>#%R.-R'#"(B+ B.-$"() =.A %> ?E++

    %> %;+ !#+(B; +A,.$$/ ?># $.?+%/J O;+ A>, ,#>G+ %;#>-); %;+

    !#+(B; :+?+($+$ .(: %>>G =.A .I./J O;+ #">%+#$ %;+( %>#+

    =.A %> D"+B+$ .(: D.#.:+: ;"$ :"$A+A,+#+: ,>:/ %;#>-);

    %;+ $%#++%$J O;"$ %>%.E ,#+.G:>I( >? E.I .(: >#:+# I.$ -$+:

    .$ a-$%"?"B.%">( ?># >:$;+: I.$ %;+ >??"B".E B.-$+ >? %;+ BB-D.%">( >? P."%"H ,-% )#>I"() L+#A.( "(%+#+$%$ %;+#+ A./

    ;.F+ .E$> ,++( .( -(:+#E/"() #+.$>(J O;+ )#>I"() Q.S" I.#

    A.B;"(+ "( f-#>D+ .(: M.D.(`$ .))#+$$"F+ "(F.$">( >?

    $-##>-(:"() %+##"%>#"+$ "( @$". .::+: %> %;+ %;#+.% >? )E>,.E

    B>(?E"B%J P."%"`$ E>B.%">( "( %;+ h.#",,+.( =+. +(.,E+: #B+$ %> G++D I.%B; >( %;+ '.(.A. h.(.E .(: D#>%+B% (

    E.$%+: ?#>A 2725 %;#>-); 2734 :-#"() I;"B; %"A+H

    B>($":+#.,E+ "(?#.$%#-B%-#+ I.$ D-% "( DE.B+J

    ( %;+ I"%;:#.I.E >? >D$H e.?.+E O#-a"EE>

    C>E"(.H B>AA.(:+# >? %;+ @#A/ "( %;+ N>A"("B.( e+D-,E"B

    B.A+ "(%> B>(%#>E >? %;+ N>A"("B.( e+D-,E"BJ P"$ "(%+#+$%$

    $D.((+: ,+/>(: %;+ +.$%+#( %I>R%;"#:$ >? P"$D.(">E. .(:

    $D"EE+: >F+# "(%> P."%"J O> %;.% +(:H O#-a"EE> $+(% $D"+$ .(:

    .)+(%$ "(%> P."%" %> ;+ED ;"A #+.B; ;"$ )>.E$J O;>-);

    O#-a"EE> ;.: .$D"#.%">($ >? B>(%#>EE"() %;+ +(%"#+ "$E.(:H P."%"

    #+A."(+: .( "(:+D+(:+(% #+D-,E"B .(: #+,-??+: O#-a"EE>`$

    :+$")($J

    @(>%;+# A.( >( %;+ E"$% >? :"B%.%>#$ I.$ !#.(B>"$

    N-F.E"+#H . A+:"B.E :>B%># I;> I>( . ?#++ .(: >D+( +E+B%">(

    ?># %;+ D#+$":+(B/J O;>-); N-F.E"+#H \'.D. N>BH^ I.$ %;+

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    38/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    5I

    E+)"%"A.%+ I"((+# >? %;+ +E+B%">(H ;+ ;.: (> $B#-DE+$

    #+).#:"() ;"$ -$+ >? D>I+# .(: ?>#B+ %> #+A."( "( >??"B+J P+

    #-E+: P."%" ?#>A 2759 -(%"E 2792H -$"() ?+.#H %>#%-#+ .(:

    :+.%; %> ;.F+ ;"$ I./J O;+ \%>( %>( A.G>-%$H^ N-F.E"+#`$

    +_+B-%">( $T-.:$H #>.A+: %;+ P."%".( B>-(%#/$":+ G"EE"()

    .(/>(+ I;> >DD>$+: %;+ :"B%.%>#J

    !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+# :"+: "( 2792 .(: E+.:+#$;"D D.$$+: %>

    ;"$ $>(H M+.(RhE.-:+ N-F.E"+#H \k.,/ N>BJ^ M+.(RhE.-:+ :":

    (>% $;.#+ ;"$ ?.%;+#`$

    %.$%+ ?># #-E"() .$

    A-B; .$ ;"$ %.$%+ ?>#

    E-_-#/J O> ?++: ;"$

    "($.%".,E+ E-$% ?>#

    #"B;+$H k.,/ N>B

    -$+: B>##-D%">( .(: %;+?%J

    O;+ N-F.E"+#`$ #+")( +_.B%+: .( +(>#A>-$ %>EE >( P."%".(

    $>B"+%/J K% "$ +$%"A.%+: %;.% 51H111 P."%".($ I+#+ +_+B-%+:

    :-#"() %;+ #+")( >? '.D. N>B .(: k.,/ N>BJ !"(.EE/H "( 2786

    %;+ N-F.E"+#`$ #+")( >? %+##># +(:+:J

    H5%7 ;# P/Q7E

    U"%; %;+ N-F.E"+#`$ )>(+H . (+I +#. ;.$ $+%%E+: -D>(

    P."%"J Q>IH A>#+ %;.( +F+#H P."%" "$ .% . B#>$$#>.:$J h>##-D%

    E+.:+#$;"D .(: ?."E+: +B>(>A"B D#>)#.A$ ;.F+ E+?% .( "$E.(:

    D.#.:"$+ :+(-:+: >? %;+ ;.#:I>>:$ %;.% >(B+ ?E>-#"$;+: >("%$ ?+#%"E+ ;"EE$":+$H .(: "$ :+F.$%.%+: ,/ ?E>>:$ .(:

    A-:$E":+$J O;+ I.%+#$ $-##>-(:"() P."%" :> (>% ;.F+ +(>-);

    .T-.%"B E"?+ %> $-$%."( .(/ ?"$;"() +(%+#D#"$+$ .(: +_D>#%$ .#+

    >-% >? %;+ T-+$%">(J =.:E/H P."%".( ?"$;+#A+( ,.#+E/ B.%B;

    E'*+-11+, /"'/ -#*# 1(

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    39/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    40/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    FL

    P."%" %+.B;+$ -$ %;.% A.(`$ F"$">( >?%+( E+.:$ %> %;+

    +_DE>"%.%">( >? >%;+#$ %> ?-E?"EE %;+ :#+.AJ

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    41/92

    FK

    #$%&' -,.'

    .=( ?(@/-,/,7$* 757,6/' B+>,7$(--

    HA 7/88 9/"( :; J$K( J3+: &9(:2M P&9( BCDEQ

    -$/"2 H$%" -(( 79$& &9(/3 (%" 7/88 @(L J+3 &9(;

    $3( $ F(3#(3-( '(%(3$&/+%2 K9/8"3(% 79+ $3(

    5%J$/&9J58RI9(; :$"( :( S($8+5- @; 79$& /-

    %+ '+" $%" $%'(3(" :( 7/&9 &9(/3 7+3&98(--

    /"+8-RA 7/88 -(%" 7$-&/%' J$:/%( $'$/%-& &9(:2

    K+%-5:/%' F(-&/8(%K( $%" "($"8; F8$'5(RM

    N+-%+#>(>A/ 30*01R02H 04 YQKiZ

    O;+ D+>DE+ >? P."%" I+#+ :+%+#A"(+: %> +_"$% .$ .

    $>F+#+")( (.%">( "( %;+ I>#E:J C+A>#/ >? %;+ $.B#"?"B+$

    A.:+ :-#"() %;+ /+.#$ >? #+F>E-%">( #+"(?>#B+: %;+"# #+$>EF+

    .(: G+D% %;+A E>>G"() ?># %;+ #");% E+.:+# %> )-":+ %;+AJ

    W(+ .?%+# .(>%;+#H E+.:+#$ B.A+ .(: I+(%J O> a-:)+

    %;+"# ;+.#%$ "$ (>% >-# D-#D>$+H ,-% +_.A"(.%">( >? %;+ ?#-"% >?%;+"# .:A"("$%#.%">($ #+F+.E$ ?."E-#+ .?%+# ?."E-#+ >( %;+ D.#%

    >? %;+$+ A+(J Q>(+ I+#+ .,E+ %> ,#+.G %;+ />G+ >? D>F+#%/

    %;.% %;#+.%+(+: %> B#-$; %;+ D+>DE+J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    42/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    FM

    U+ ;.F+ .E#+.:/ $++( ;>I %;+ E.(: ;.: ,++( $%#"DD+:

    ,.#+ .(: %;+ $-##>-(:"() >B+.( :+DE+%+: >? ?"$;J

    ? %;+ E-$; ?>#+$%$ ?># B;.#B>.E

    D#>:-B%">( ;.F+ E+?% %;+ P."%".( B>-(%#/$":+ . ,.##+(H

    +#>$">(R$B.##+: E.(:$B.D+ ?"EE+: I"%; D+>DE+ I;> ,.#+E/ )+%

    ,/ ?#>A :./R%>R:./J e-(>?? ?"EE+: I"%; %;+ "$E.(:`$ $>"E

    B;>G+$ %;+ #"F+#$ .(: $D"EE$ "(%> %;+ $+. E.:+( I"%; $"E%J O;"$

    +(:E+$$ B/BE+ .E%+#$ %;+ :+E"B.%+ ,.E.(B+ >? E"?+ "( %;+ $+. $>

    %;.% ?"$;+#A+( (> E>()+# ;.F+ ?"$; %> B.%B; .(: ?.A"E"+$ )>

    ;-()#/J

    h>##-D% E+.:+#$ "(%+(% >( E"("() %;+"# D>BG+%$ I"%; )>E:

    ;.F+ B>(%#",-%+: %> %;+ :+$>E.%">( >? P."%" .$ I+EEJ U;+( %;+

    F"$">( >? %;+ E+.:+# "$ %> %.G+ I;.% ;+ I.(%$ I;+( ;+ I.(%$

    "%H %;+ D+>DE+ $-??+#J ,>-(: %> D>F+#%/V K$ %;"$ I;/ %;+ D+>DE+ $-??+# $>V

    ?$"1"72%( D'G/17M S? D5M#">%( D'G/17M

    U+ ;.F+ .E#+.:/ E+.#(+: %;.% %;+ E+.:+#$ >? %;+#+F>E-%">( #+B+"F+: %;+ :"#+B%"F+ %> )> %> I.# ?#>A .

    \I.##">#^ $D"#"% "( %;+ A":$% >? . i>>:>> #"%-.EJ O;+ F+#/ .B%

    >? #+.B;"() >-% %> %;+$+ $D"#"%$ .BG(>IE+:)+$ %;+A .,>F+

    L>: .(: P"$ =>(H M+$-$ h;#"$%J K($%+.: >? :+D+(:"() >(

    L>:`$ P>E/ =D"#"% %> )-":+ .(: :"#+B%H P."%".( E+.:+#$

    :+D+(:+: >( -()>:E/ $D"#"%$ ?># E+.:+#$;"DJO;+ =B#"D%-#+ T->%+: .% %;+ ,+)"(("() >? %;"$ B;.D%+#

    $;>I$ L>:`$ .%%"%-:+ %>I.#: %;+ h;"E:#+( >? K$#.+E I;+(

    %;+/ .,.(:>(+: P"A .(: $>-);% )-":.(B+ ?#>A %;+ )>:$ >?

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    43/92

    N1"3$+* -2.*% 61+ @+D"($"$#,? -";#,+ 2= X3#*#$."A Y;3$#,+((

    F5

    f)/D%J L>: ;": P"$ ?.B+ ?#>A %;+A .(: %-#(+: %;+A >F+# %>

    .EE %;+ $.:(+$$H A"$+#/ .(: :+D#.F"%/ %;.% -()>:E"(+$$ ,#"()$J

    K$#.+E`$ :"$>,+:"+(B+ E+: %> $D"#"%-.E D>F+#%/ %;.%

    $-#D.$$+: .(/%;"() %;+/ ;.: +F+# +_D+#"+(B+: .$ $E.F+$ "(

    f)/D%J O;+/ ;.: E>$% %;+"# F"$">( >? L>: .$ %;+"# '#>F":+#H

    =-$%."(+# .(: e+:++A+# .(: ;.: %-#(+: %> %;+ I>#$;"D >?

    :+A>($*

    I9(; :$"( 9/: S($8+5- 7/&9 &9(/3 J+3(/'% '+"-

    $%" $%'(3(" 9/: 7/&9 &9(/3 "(&(-&$@8( /"+8-E$ >? %;+"# ?.E$+ I>#$;"D I>-E:

    (>%H B>-E: (>% $.F+ K$#.+EH .(: P"$ .()+# ,-#(+: .$ P+

    B>($":+#+: %;+"# #+,+EE">(*

    T+7 79(3( $3( &9(/3 '+"-2 &9( 3+K, &9(; &++,

    3(J5'( /%2 &9( '+"- 79+ $&( &9( J$& +J &9(/3

    -$K3/J/K(- $%" "3$%, &9( 7/%( +J &9(/3 "3/%,

    +JJ(3/%'-N B(& &9(: 3/-( 5F &+ 9(8F ;+5G B(&

    &9(: '/#( ;+5 -9(8&(3G YN+-%J 30*39R38Z

    K$#.+E I.$ ,+)"(("() %> E+.#( %;.% $D"#"%-.E D>F+#%/ E+.:$

    %> D;/$"B.E D>F+#%/J O;+/ ,+).( %> #+.E"S+ %;.% . (.%">( I;>

    %-#($ .I./ ?#>A L>: (+F+# I"EE D#>$D+#J O;+"# >(E/ B;>"B+

    I.$ %> %-#( .)."( %> L>: "( #+D+(%.(B+H :+BE.#"() P"A .$

    %;+"# =>F+#+")( g>#: "( >#:+# %> %.G+ ;>E: >? P"$ D#>A"$+$*

    AJ ;+5 J588; +@(; &9( BCDE ;+53 6+" $%"

    K$3(J588; J+88+7 $88 9/- K+::$%"- A '/#( ;+5

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    44/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    FF

    &+"$;2 &9( BCDE ;+53 6+" 7/88 -(& ;+5 9/'9

    $@+#( $88 &9( %$&/+%- +% ($3&9< !88 &9(-(

    @8(--/%'- 7/88 K+:( 5F+% ;+5 $%" $KK+:F$%;

    ;+5 /J ;+5 +@(; &9( BCDE ;+53 6+"0

    O+5 7/88 @( @8(--(" /% &9( K/&; $%" @8(--(" /%

    &9( K+5%&3;< I9( J35/& +J ;+53 7+:@ 7/88 @(

    @8(--("2 $%" &9( K3+F- +J ;+53 8$%" $%" &9(

    ;+5%' +J ;+53 8/#(-&+K,=&9( K$8#(- +J ;+53

    9(3"- $%" &9( 8$:@- +J ;+53 J8+K,- %;+ ?.B% %;.% %;+ D#>A"$+$ )"F+(

    %> K$#.+E $> A.(/ B+(%-#"+$ ,+?>#+ I+#+ ?># %;+A .$ I+EEJ

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    46/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    FH

    O;+"# A"(:$ I+#+ :.#G+(+: %> %;+ ?.B% %;.% L>: I.(%$ P."%"

    %> ,+ ,E+$$+: .(: %> ,+ D#>$D+#>-$J

    O;+ +AD%"(+$$ "( P."%"`$ :+DE+%+: (.%-#.E #+$>-#B+$

    A"##>#$ %;+ B>(:"%">( >? %;+ $>-E$ >? %;+ (.%">(`$ )#+.%+$%

    #+$>-#B+H %;+ D+>DE+J =D"#"%-.E A.E(>-#"$;A+(% "$ #.AD.(% "(

    . (.%">( >? :+$D+#.%+ D+>DE+ E>>G"() ?># $>A+%;"()H ,-% %;+/

    :>(`% G(>I I;.%]># I;>J

    P."%" +(%+#+: 211 /+.#$ >? "$>E.%">( .?%+# %;+ #+F>E-%">(

    .(: +_D+#"+(B+: .

    D-$; ,.BG %> %;+

    %#",.E E"?+ >? %;+"#

    @?#"B.( ;+#"%.)+J

    O;"$ ,#>-);% .,>-%

    . D+#">: >? :++D

    $%.#F.%">( %;+ E"G+$

    >? I;"B; %;+ D+>DE+ ;.: (+F+# ,+?>#+ +_D+#"+(B+:J O;+

    :+F.$%.%">( >? (.%-#.E #+$>-#B+$ #+$-E%+: ?#>A %;"$ $%.#F.%">(

    >? %;+ $>-E .$ D+>DE+ ,+).( %> %.G+ :+$D+#.%+ A+.$-#+$ %>

    ,+%%+# %;+"# D;/$"B.E E"F+$J O;"$ "( %-#( B.-$+: %;+ T-.E"%/ >?

    E"?+ ?># +F+#/>(+ %> :"A"("$; .(: ,#>-);% I"%; "% (+IH

    )#+.%+# E+F+E$ >? ;>D+E+$$(+$$ .(: :#+.:J

    O;+ ._">A %;.% :+$D+#.%+ D+>DE+ :> :+$D+#.%+ %;"()$ "$

    %#-+ .$ "$ +F":+(B+: ,/ %;+ "(B#+.$"() :+$D."# "( %;+ (.%">( >?

    P."%" .% %;+ :.I( >? %;+ 01%; h+(%-#/J \U;.% ;.$ ?#++:>A

    ,#>-);% %> -$V^ I.$ %;+ B#/ >? B>-(%E+$$ P."%".($ .$ %;+/

    $%#-))E+: %> ?++: %;+A$+EF+$ .(: %;+"# ?.A"E"+$J \U;.% "$ %;+

    A+.("() >? .( +_"$%+(B+ ?"EE+: I"%; ;-()+#H :"$+.$+ .(:

    :+.%;V^

    ='*06 E')/)'( 0#'+#*, :#0)#4#+

    /"# 0)#, 13 G11+11 ,&)*)/,7

    +#21(, -"1 -'(/#+ /1 +#,/*16

    :1/" /"#2 '(+ /"# 0'(+5

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    47/92

    N1"3$+* -2.*% 61+ @+D"($"$#,? -";#,+ 2= X3#*#$."A Y;3$#,+((

    FP

    d+% %;+ $.B#"?"B+$ %> :+A>($ B>(%"(-+:J @EE+)".(B+ %>

    ?.E$+ )>:$ "(B#+.$+:J =/(B#+%"$AH %;+ ,E+(:"() >? h;#"$%".(

    .(: i>>:>> ,+E"+?$H

    ,+B.A+ +F+# A>#+

    ":>E.%#>-$J P>I ?.#

    I>-E: P."%" ?.EE

    ,+?>#+ $;+ ;"%

    ,>%%>AV

    ;# :5/1/ % L'>7'1 "& 75/ !'2#/E

    P."%".($ ,+B.A+ :+$D+#.%+ ?># .(/ B;.()+ %;.% I>-E:

    A.G+ %;+"# E"F+$ ,+%%+# .(: ,#"() $%.,"E"%/ %> %;+"# B>-(%#/JO;+/ G(+I %;+"# (.%">( I.$ "EE .(: "( (++: >? #.:"B.E

    %#+.%A+(%$ %> ,#"() "% %> %;+ D>"(% I;+#+ ?.A"E"+$ B>-E: A>F+

    ,+/>(: A+#+ $-#F"F.E .(: ?E>-#"$;J

    K($":+ %;"$ ,>"E"() B.-E:#>( >? ;>D+E+$$(+$$ .(: :+$D."#

    . />-() B>-(%#/ :>B%># ,+).( %#+.%"() /.I$H . F"B">-$

    %#>D"B.E :"$+.$+ %;.% +.%$ .I./ %;+ F"B%"A$` ?E+$;H A-B; E"G+E+D#>$/J \'.D. N>BH^ .$ %;+ D+>DE+ E>F"()E/ B.EE+: ;"AH

    %#.F+E+: %;+ E+()%; .(: ,#+.:%; >? %;+ E.(: %#+.%"() %;+ D>>#

    .(: ;+ED"() %;+A >F+#B>A+ %;+ :#+.:+: :"$+.$+J

    O;+ P."%".( +E"%+ E>>G+: :>I( -D>( %;+ D+.$.(%$ .(:

    B>($":+#+: %;+A -(I>#%;/ >? A+:"B.E B.#+J P>I+F+#H N#J

    !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+#H :#"F+( ,/ .( +F+(% ;+ I"%(+$$+: /+.#$+.#E"+#H I>#G+: %"#+E+$$E/ %#+.%"() %;+ D>># .(: +#.:"B.%"()

    /.I$ ?#>A %;+ E.(: >? P."%"J O;"$ $"ADE+ B>-(%#/ :>B%># I.$

    B#+:"%+: I"%; $.F"() ;-(:#+:$ >? %;>-$.(:$ >? E"F+$ .B#>$$

    E')/)'(, :#

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    48/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    FI

    %;+ E.(:H +(:+.#"() ;"A "( %;+ ;+.#%$ .(: A"(:$ >? %;+

    D>D-E.%">(J

    g"%%E+ :": %;+$+ $"ADE+ ?>EG G(>I I;.% "AD.B% N#J

    !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+# I>-E: ;.F+ >( %;+"# E"F+$ .(: %;+ E"?+ >?

    %;+"# (.%">(J P>I B>-E: .(/>(+ G(>I %;+ (");%A.#+ I>-E:

    -(?>E: "( a-$% . ?+I $;>#% /+.#$V

    A/%@/1#5"$ :1/%#21/ BT

    O;+ #>>%$ >? . %#++ :+%+#A"(+ "%$ )#>I%;J K? %;+ #>>%$ .#+

    I"%;+#+: .(: :#/H %;+ %#++ $-??+#$J K? %;+ #>>%$ .#+ :++D "(

    ?+#%"E+ $>"E .(: I+EE I.%+#+:H %;+ %#++ I"EE ?E>-#"$;J g"G+I"$+H

    . E+.:+#`$ #>>%$ :+%+#A"(+ ;"$ )#>I%;J O;+ :+D%; >? ;"$ ?."%;H

    %;+ DE.B+ >? ;"$ ;>D+ .(: %;+ A.$%+# ;+ $+#F+$ $+.E$ %;+E+.:+#`$ ?.%+ Y0 h>#J 3*03ZJ

    P."%" %+.B;+$ -$ %;.% I+ B.( >(E/ $+#F+ >(+ A.$%+#J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    49/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    50/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    51/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    52/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    53/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    54/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    55/92

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    56/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    GH

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    57/92

    GP

    #$%&' -/0&

    :%>( C%-, D ?5(/+-

    ?/-=()

    O+5 7/88 %+& @( '/#(% $ F3+F(3 @53/$82 J+3 ;+5

    9$#( "(-&3+;(" ;+53 %$&/+% $%" -8$5'9&(3("

    ;+53 F(+F8(R K$.".; 24*01 YQgOZ

    62 8,2Q +D+, 2,+ A#=+ 1"( 7*+"$1+9 +"(#+*

    7+:".(+ fA+#$>(

    U;.% "$ %;+ A+.$-#+ >? $-BB+$$V O;+ $"S+ >? .( .A.$$+:

    ?>#%-(+m %;+ T-.(%"%/ .(: T-.E"%/ >? .BB-A-E.%+: )>>:$m %;+

    D>I+# >(+ ;.$ >F+# .(>%;+#m #+.B;"() %;+ ;");+$% E+F+E$ >?

    )>F+#(A+(% ># ,-$"(+$$V W# "$ "% .$ fA+#$>( $.": "( %;+

    T->%+ .,>F+H \O> G(>I +F+( >(+ E"?+ ;.$ ,#+.%;+: +.$"+#

    ,+B.-$+ />- ;.F+ E"F+:^V P>I >(+ .($I+#$ %;.% T-+$%">(

    :+%+#A"(+$ %;+ B>-#$+ >? %;+"# E"?+ .(: .??+B%$ %;+"# .%%"%-:+%>I.#: >%;+#$ I;> +"%;+# ;+ED ># ;"(:+# %;+"# D#>)#+$$J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    58/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    GI

    ,%2(@1'& '0 L"#>'&7/&7

    !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+# I.$ ,>#( "( . P."%" %;.% "(B#+.$"()E/

    $%#-))E+: %> ?++: "%$ ;-()#/ A.$$+$J O;+ .)+R>E: $%#-))E+

    ,+%I++( I;"%+$H A-E.%%>$ .(: ,E.BG$ $;>I+: (> $")( >?

    .,.%"() .(: %;+ D>># ,+B.A+ +F+( D>>#+#J

    W(+ :./ "( 2704 I;+( N-F.E"+# I.$ . %++(.)+# ;+

    I.%B;+: .$ . A.( .(: %;#++ I>A+( ;+E: . $%#-))E"() B;"E:

    I;"E+ "%$ A>%;+# $B#-,,+: .% %;+ #-(("() $>#+$ B>F+#"() ;"$

    E"%%E+ ,>:/J O;+ A>%;+# $B#-,,+: :+$D"%+ %;+ B;"E:`$ B#"+$H ;+#

    >I( ?.B+ %I"$%+: "( . D."( %;.% >(E/ A>%;+#$ B.( -(:+#$%.(:J

    P+# E"%%E+ ,.,/ I.$ "(?+B%+: I"%; /.I$H . %+##",E+ ?E+$;R+.%"()

    :"$+.$+ %;.% I.$ #.AD.(% .B#>$$ %;+ P."%".( B>-(%#/$":+J

    O;.% :./H I;"E+ N-F.E"+# I.%B;+: "( $"E+(B+H ;+ :+B":+:%> ,+B>A+ . :>B%># $> ;+ B>-E: ;+ED %;>$+ "( %;+ A>$% (++:J

    O#-+ %> ;"$ F>IH !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+# )#.:-.%+: ?#>A A+:"B.E

    $B;>>E "( M-E/ >? 2734J

    KAA+:".%+E/H

    N-F.E"+# ,+).( %>

    I>#G %> ;+ED.EE+F".%+ %;+ D."( >?

    %;>$+ "(?E"B%+: I"%;

    /.I$J O> ;"AH %;"$ I.$ %;+ A>$% D#+$$"() B#"$"$ ?.B"() %;+

    P."%".( D>D-E.%">(H +$D+B".EE/ .A>() %;+ #-#.E D>>#J

    @(>%;+# ?.B%># %;.% $;.D+: />-() N-F.E"+# I.$ %;+ BB-D.%">( >? P."%" ?#>A 2725R2734J O;>-); A-B;R(++:+:"(?#.$%#-B%-#+ I.$ ,-"E% .(: $%.,"E"%/ "( )>F+#(A+(% I.$

    ,#>-);% %> %;+ (.%">(.E B>-(%#/$":+H P."%".($ #+$+(%+: %;+

    I;"%+ $>E:"+#$ .(: I.(%+: %;+A %> E+.F+ %;+"# (.%">(J O;+

    %;+ "$E.(: (.%">(H

    B.4'0)#* +*#'2#+ 13 E')/) :#)(8

    3*## 13 31*#)8( )(30.#(

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    59/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    GJ

    ,-% .E$> I.(%+: %> ;.F+ . A"E"%.#/ D#+$+(B+ (+.# %;+ '.(.A.

    h.(.E %> D#+F+(% .(/ "(%+#?+#+(B+ I"%; ?#++ D.$$.)+ ,/ Q.S"

    L+#A.(/J

    N-F.E"+# :#+.A+: >? P."%" ,+"() ?#++ >? ?>#+")(

    "(?E-+(B+ .(: )>F+#(+: ,/ %;+ ,E.BG A.a>#"%/J P+ /+.#(+:

    ?># %;+ :./ I;+( ,E.BG F>"B+$ B>-E: ,+ ;+.#: .(: D>I+# I.$

    %.G+( ?#>A ;.(:$ >? %;+ I+.E%;/ +E"%+ .(: D-% "(%> %;+ ;.(:$

    >? %;+ D+>DE+J O> %;.% +(:H ;+ B>ADE+%+E/ $-DD>#%+: . A.(

    I;> D#>A"$+: $-B; . ,E.BG #+F>E-%">(H N-A.#$."$ f$%"AqJ

    f$%"AqH $B#-D-E>-$E/ ;>(+$% "( %;+ A":$% >? B>##-D%">(H

    I.$ +E+B%+: %> %;+ D#+$":+(B/ .?%+# . A"E"%.#/ a-(%. :+D>$+:

    fE"+ g+$B>%J P"$ B.AD.")( #.( >( %;+ DE.%?>#A >? D-%%"() .

    ,E.BG A.( "( D>I+# .(: #-(("() %;+ )>F+#(A+(% I"%;

    ;>(+$%/ .(: "(%+)#"%/J @?%+# :+B.:+$ >? I;"%+ .(: A-E.%%>

    #-E+H %;"$ D#>F+: %> ,+ $-BB+$$?-E $%#.%+)/J P"$ D#+$":+(B/

    $.I %;+ ,E.BG$ +E+F.%+: "( ,-$"(+$$ .(: )>F+#(A+(% (>

    E>()+# #+E+).%+: %> A"(># ># "($")("?"B.(% #>E+$J !># . %"A+H

    %;+ ,E.BG$ +(a>/+: D#>$D+#"%/ .(: $.I %;+"# B>(:"%">(

    "AD#>F+H ,-% .)."( B>##-D%">( >F+#%>>G %;+ D>$"%"F+ )."($J

    O;>-); f$%"Aq I.$ (+F+# "ADE"B.%+: "( .(/ $B.(:.E$H ;+

    I.$ $%"EE :+D>$+: ,/ .( .#A/ B>-D .(: ?>#A+# .#A/ B>E>(+EH

    '.-E C.)E>"#+H .$$-A+: %;+ D#+$":+(B/J

    !># N-F.E"+#H %;"$ I.$ . %#.)+:/J P+ :"$B>F+#+: %;.% %;+

    .#A/ ;.: +(>-); D>I+# %> A.G+ ># ,#+.G . D#+$":+(B/H $>

    ;"$ A"$%#-$% >? %;+A )#+I +_D>(+(%".EE/J O;"$ $++: >?

    A"$%#-$% ,+).( %> )+#A"(.%+ "( N-F.E"+#H E.%+# %> )#>I "(%>

    %;+ A>$% F"E+H ,#-%.EH E.IE+$$H )>F+#(A+(%R$.(B%">(+: ,>:/

    "( P."%".( ;"$%>#/J

    N-#"() %;"$ $.A+ %"A+H ,>%; %;+ h.%;>E"B .(: '#>%+$%.(%

    B;-#B;+$ "( P."%" $%+DD+: -D %;+"# B.AD.")( %> >-%E.I %;+

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    60/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    HL

    F>>:>> #+E")">(J U"%; ?"+#/ #;+%>#"BH BE+#)/ :+(>-(B+: %;+

    D#.B%"B+ >? F>>:>> .(: %;+ D#"+$%$ Y;>-().($Z I;> >??"B".%+:

    .% %;+ F>>:>> B+#+A>("+$J O;+$+ %.B%"B$ :": (>% $+% I+EE I"%;

    ,E.BG P."%".($H I;> #+$+(%+: I;"%+ f-#>D+.( D#"+$%$ %+EE"()

    %;+A ;>I %> I>#$;"DJ e+E")">( "( P."%" ;.: E>() ,++(

    $-,a+B% %> $/(B#+%"$A I"%; %;+ ,E+(:"() >? F>>:>> .(:

    h.%;>E"B[h;#"$%".( :+"%/ .(: I>#$;"DJ

    N-F.E"+#H I;> ;.: ,++( >( %;+ ?#"()+ .$ ?.# .$ F>>:>>

    I.$ B>(B+#(+:H (>I :+F>-#+: .EE ;+ B>-E: E+.#( .,>-% %;+

    #+E")">(J P"$ $%-:"+$ B.##"+: ;"A :++D "(%> %;+ %#.:"%">(.E

    ,+E"+?$ >? F>>:>> .(: %;+ $D"#"%$ YE>.$Z I;> I+#+ I>#$;"D+:J

    @$ ;"$ "(%+#+$% )#+IH ;"$ ;-()+# ?># A>#+ ,+B.A+ "($.%".,E+J

    O;+ $%.)+ I.$ ,+"() $+% .(: %;+ DE./+#$ ,+"() .$$+A,E+: ?>#

    . (+I ,E.BG \#+F>E-%">(J^

    H5' "# D%$% L'>E

    O;+ %#>D"B.E :"$+.$+H /.I$H ;.: #"$+( %> +D":+A"B

    D#>D>#%">($ :-#"() %;+ 2741`$ I"%; (+.#E/ 95r >? %;+ P."%".(

    D>D-E.%">( "(?+B%+:J h.-$+: ,/ . ,.B%+#". >? %;+ $.A+ ?.A"E/%;.% B.-$+$ $/D;"E"$H

    #+E.D$"() ?+F+# .(:

    >%;+# :"$+.$+$H /.I$

    "$ .E$> ;");E/

    B>(%.)">-$J N-#"()

    2743H %;+ K(%+#R@A+#"B.( @??."#$

    h>AA"$$">( $+(% N#J

    M.A+$ NI"(+EE+ %>

    P."%" %> .(.E/S+ %;+ $"%-.%">( .(: ?"(: E>B.E :>B%>#$ %> I>#G "(

    B.4'0)#* :#0)#4#+ /"'/ /"# 1(06

    -'6 /1 ,104# /"# *'

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    61/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    HK

    #-#.E BE"("B$ I;+#+ %;+ :"$+.$+ I.$ A>$% D#+F.E+(%J W(+ >?

    %;>$+ "(%+#F"+I+: I.$ N#J !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+#J

    N#J NI"(+EE+ ;"#+: N-F.E"+# .(: DE.B+: ;"A .% %;+ e-#.E

    hE"("B >? L#+$$"+#H 25 A"E+$ $>-%;I+$% >? '>#%R@-R'#"(B+H %;+

    A>$% /.I$R"(?+B%+: .#+. >? %;+ (.%">(J N"F+#%+: ?#>A ;"$

    >,$+$$">( I"%; F>>:>>H N-F.E"+# "AA+#$+: ;"A$+E?

    B>ADE+%+E/ "(%> B-#"() %;+ A.$$+$ -$"() D+("B"EE"(

    %#+.%A+(%$J P"$ $-BB+$$ I.$ $-B; %;.% F.#">-$ "(%+#(.%">(.E

    A+:"B.E a>-#(.E$ D-,E"$;+: %;+ #+$-E%$ >? ;"$ #+$+.#B;J \'.D.

    N>BH^ .$ ;+ I.$ E>F"()E/ B.EE+: ,/ ;-(:#+:$ >? %;>-$.(:$ >?

    ;"$ D.%"+(%$H ;.: ;"% ;"$ $%#":+J

    U;+( f$%"Aq ,+B.A+ D#+$":+(%H ;+ %.DD+: N-F.E"+# >(

    %;+ $;>-E:+# %> $+#F+ .$ ;"$ ? g.,># .(:

    E.%+# .$ %;+ '-,E"B P+.E%; .(: g.,># C"("$%+#J O;+ ,E.BG

    #+F>E-%">( ,+)-( ,/ f$%"Aq #+"(?>#B+: N-F.E"+#`$ ,+E"+? %;.%

    %;+ >(E/ I./ %> $>EF+ %;+ #.B".E D#>,E+A$ "( P."%" I.$ %>

    #+>D+( %;+ ,E>>:/ B>(?E"B% ,+%I++( ,E.BG$ .(: A-E.%%>$ "(

    >#:+# %> ,#+.G %;+"# #-E"() BE.$$ $%#-B%-#+J O> :#"F+ ;"$ D>"(%

    ;>A+H N-F.E"+#H .E>() I"%; g>#"A+# N+("$H I#>%+ 61+

    '*27A+; 2= NA"((+( 61*2.?12.$ !"#$#U( !#($2*E"%"B.E $":+ >? N-F.E"+# I.$ ,+)"(("() %> +A+#)+J

    D1/#"@/&7 0'1 A"0/U I1%&>'"# L2G%("/1

    k/ C./ >? 2756H ?>-# B.(:":.%+$ ;.: .((>-(B+: %;+"#

    :+B"$">( %> #-( "( .( +E+B%">( %> #+DE.B+ >-%R)>"() D#+$":+(%H'.-E C.)E>"#+J O;+ B.(:":.%+$ "(BE-:+:H hEqA+(% M-A+EE+H

    N.("+E !")(>EqH g>-"$ Nqa>"+ .(: \'.D. N>B^ !#.(B>"$

    N-F.E"+#J O;#>-); . E>() .(: :.()+#>-$ B.AD.")(H N-F.E"+#

    "($"$%+: %;.% ,E.BG P."%" ,+ )>F+#(+: ,/ ,E.BG$J k+B.-$+ >?

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    62/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    HM

    ;"$ I>#G %;#>-);>-% %;+ #-#.E .#+.$ +#.:"B.%"() /.I$H '.D.

    N>B I.$ E>F+: .(: +F+( #+F+#+: ,/ %;+ D+>DE+J L.#(+#"()

    %;"$ )#.$$R#>>%$ $-DD>#%H N-F.E"+# I>( %;+ +E+B%">( >(

    =+D%+A,+# 00H 2756 I"%; . $%.))+#"() A.a>#"%/ >? 697H884

    F>%+$ B>AD.#+: %> Nqa>"+`$ 066H770m %;+ >%;+# %I>

    B.(:":.%+$ ;.: :#>DD+: >-% >? %;+ #.B+J

    !#>A %;+ ,+)"(("() >? N-F.E"+#`$ #+")(H ;+ $+% >-% %> #":

    ;"A$+E? >? ;"$ +(+A"+$ .(: >DD>(+(%$J W(+R,/R>(+ %;+/

    I+#+ +E"A"(.%+: ,/ "(%"A":.%">(H "AD#"$>(A+(%H %>#%-#+ >#

    :+.%;J @E$> .A>() %;+ ?"#$% .B%$ >? %;+ (+I D#+$":+(% I.$ %;+

    +A.$B-E.%">( >? %;+ .#A/J N-F.E"+# G(+I %;.% %;+ .#A/

    B>-E: #+A>F+ ;"A ?#>A >??"B+H $> ;+ B#+.%+: .( "(F"(B",E+

    ?>#B+ >? B"F"E".($ B.EE+: %;+ i>E-(%++#$ >? Q.%">(.E =+B-#"%/

    Yi=QZH B>AA>(E/ B.EE+: %;+ O>(%>( C.B>-%+$J O;"$ .#A+:

    B"F"E".( A"E"%". I.$ #+$D>($",E+ >(E/ %> %;+ D#+$":+(% .(:

    $%>>: .,>F+ +F+( %;+ .#A/ .(: D>E"B+J C>$%E/ B>AD#"$+: >?

    "EE"%+#.%+ D+.$.(%$H %;+ i=Q I.$ F"#-E+(% "( %;+"# E>/.E%/ %>

    P"$ f_B+EE+(B/ .(: I>-E: :> .(/%;"()H "(BE-:"() %>#%-#+ .(:

    A-#:+# %> ?>#I.#: %;+ D#+$":+(%`$ .)+(:.J O;+ i=Q ,+B.A+

    . ?+.#+: .(: ;.%+: +(+A/ >? %;+ D+>DE+ >F+# %;+ (+_% %;#++

    :+B.:+$ >? N-F.E"+# #-E+J

    N-F.E"+#`$ >,$+$$">( I"%; F>>:>> B>(%"(-+: %> )#>I

    :++D+#J P"$ I"?+H ="A>(+H I.$ :++DE/ "AA+#$+: "( %;+

    #+E")">( .$ I+EEH .(: ;.: ,++( .EE ;+# E"?+J N-F.E"+# G(+I %;.%

    %> )."( B>ADE+%+ A.$%+#/ >F+# %;+ D+>DE+H ;+ (++:+: P."%"`$

    A>$% D>I+#?-E $D"#"%$ %> .EI./$ ,+ .% ;"$ $":+J O> .BB>ADE"$;

    %;"$ ;+ I+(% %> %;+ B.F+H O#>- !>,.(H G(>I( $"(B+ %;+ %"A+

    >? $E.F+#/ .$ %;+ ;>A+ >? +F"E $D"#"%$ I;> ;.: #>.A+: %;+

    B>-(%#/$":+ -(%"E %;+/ ).%;+#+: %;+#+ .(: $+%%E+:J O;+ DE.B+

    I.$ )#+.%E/ ?+.#+: ,+B.-$+ >? %;+ $-D+#(.%-#.E A");% >? %;+

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    63/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    H5

    $D"#"%$ %;.% "(;.,"%+: "%$ :+D%;$J W(E/ %;+ A>$% D>I+#?-E

    ;>-().($ B>-E: B>(a-#+ %;+$+ $D"#"%$ ,+B.-$+ %;+/ I+#+

    (>%;"() %> ,+ %.G+( E");%E/J

    h>(?":+(% "( ;"$

    A"$$">(H N-F.E"+# .(:

    . ;>-().( %#+GG+: %>

    %;+ B.F+ .(: ,+).( .

    B+#+A>(/ %> "(F"%+ %;+

    $D"#"%$ I;> E"F+: %;+#+

    %> A>F+ "(%> $D+B".E

    #>>A ,-"E% ?># %;+A "( %;+ D.E.B+J O;+ B+#+A>(/ E.$%+: -(%"E

    I+EE "(%> %;+ (");%H ,-% +(:+: $-BB+$$?-EE/ .$ %;+ $D"#"%$

    .BB>AD.("+: N-F.E"+# ,.BG %> %;+ D.E.B+ .(: %>>G -D

    #+$":+(B+ %;+#+J O;+/ #+A."(+: I"%; ;"A -(%"E ;+ :"+:H .(:

    ,+B.-$+ >? %;+A B.A+ %;+ E+)+(: %;.% (> ;-A.( ,+"() B>-E:

    +F+# >F+#%;#>I ;"AJ

    O;+ #+")( >? %+##># D#>D.).%+: ,/ !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+#

    E.$%+: -(%"E ;"$ :+.%;H ,-% N-F.E"+#"$AH . %>%.E"%.#".(

    :"B%.%>#$;"DH E.$%+: E>() .?%+# %;#>-); ;"$ $>(H M+.(RhE.-:+J

    U;+( %;+ N-F.E"+#$ $.I $>A+%;"() %;+/ I.(%+:H %;+/ %>>G

    "%J K? $>A+>(+ I.$ "( %;+ I./H %;+/ I+#+ #+A>F+:c.E"F+ >#

    :+.:H "% :":(`% A.%%+#J

    h>(("F"()H $;#+I:H $-$D"B">-$H F">E+(%H $.:"$%"B .(:

    "AA>#.E .B%$ >BB-##+: "( %;+ D.E.B+ >( . :."E/ ,.$"$J @

    $D+B".E #>>A D."(%+: ,E>>: #+: I.$ -$+: %> "(%+##>).%+ .(:

    %>#%-#+ D#"$>(+#$J W?%+(H %;+ D#+$":+(% I>-E: $"% .(: D++#

    %;#>-); . D++D;>E+ %> I.%B; .$ %>#%-#+ I.$ .:A"("$%+#+:J

    W%;+# %"A+$H ;+ I>-E: E"$%+( %> %.D+$ >? %;+ %>#%-#+ .(: ?"(:

    $D+B".E a>/ "( %;+ )#>.($ .(: B#"+$ >? %;+ D+#$>( ,+"()

    %>#%-#+:J O;-$ %;+ +(")A. >? '.D. N>BH $.F"># >? ;-(:#+:$

    B.4'0)#* @(#- /"'/ /1 8')(

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    64/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    HF

    >? %;>-$.(:$ :-#"() %;+ /.I$ +D":+A"Bm %>#%-#+# .(: $E./+#

    >? %+($ >? %;>-$.(:$ :-#"() ;"$ D#+$":+(%".E #+")(J

    =$1"( OCU CVWC

    !"(.EE/H >( @D#"E 02H 2792H %;+ ;+.#% >? !#.(B>"$

    N-F.E"+# ).F+ >-% .(: P."%" +(%+#+: . (+I B;.D%+# >?

    B>##-D%">(H )#++: .(: .D.%;+%"B "(:"??+#+(B+ %> %;+ (++:$ >?

    %;+ D+>DE+J '.D. N>B I.$ :+.:H ,-% ;"$ $-BB+$$># ;.:

    .E#+.:/ ,++( :+$")(.%+:H M+.(RhE.-:+ N-F.E"+#H %;+

    D#+$":+(%`$ $>(J

    O;+ :./ >? !#.(B>"$` ?-(+#.E A.#G+: . %#.($"%">( %;.%

    ?+I B>-E: ;.F+ ?>#+$++(J !#.(B>"$ I.$ "(%"A.%+E/ "( %-(+

    I"%; .EE %;+ I>#G"()$ >? %;+ )>F+#(A+(% .(: A.:+ :+B"$">($>( +F+#/ :+%."Em M+.(RhE.-:+ ;.: (> "(%+#+$% "( %;+

    )>F+#(A+(% .(: I.$ "EERD#+D.#+: %> ,+ "%$ ;+.:J

    @$ %;+ ?-(+#.E D#>B+$$">( I>-(: %;#>-); %;+ $%#++%$ >?

    '>#%R@-R'#"(B+ %> %;+ B+A+%+#/H . ;+.F"E/ $+:.%+: M+.(R

    hE.-:+ #+A."(+: "( %;+ D.E.B+J =-::+(E/H . ?"+#B+ I;"#EI"(:

    %;.% >#")"(.%+: >( %;+ D.E.B+ )#>-(:$ ?>EE>I+: %;+ $.A+#>-%+ .$ %;+ ?-(+#.E D#>B+$$">( %> %;+ B+A+%+#/J O+##"?"+:

    P."%".($ $B#.A,E+: %> )+% >-% >? %;+ I./ >? %;+ ;>##+(:>-$

    I"(:H ,+E"+F"() %;.% %;+ $D"#"%$ N-F.E"+# ;.: ,#>-);% %> E"F+

    I"%; ;"A I+#+ .BB>AD.(/"() ;"A %> %;+ B+A+%+#/J W( %;.%

    :./H P."%".($ ,+E"+F+:H %;>$+ $.A+ $D"#"%$ +(%+#+: %;+ ,>:/

    >? !#.(B>"$` $>(H M+.(RhE.-:+J O;+ E+).B/ I>-E: B>(%"(-+%;#>-); . (+I D#+$":+(%R?>#RE"?+J

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    65/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    HG

    X/%&Y,(%2@"#3

    O;+ (+I D#+$":+(% I.$ (>% D>E"%"B.EJ K($%+.:H ;+ I.$ %;+

    $>( >? . I>#G.;>E"B :"B%.%># I;> #+$+(%+: ;"$ ?.%;+#`$

    .,$+(B+ .(: E.BG >? ?.%;+#E/ E+.:+#$;"DJ M+.(RhE.-:+ ?>-(:

    $>E.B+ I"%; ;"$ ?#"+(:$ .% D.#%"+$ I;+#+ .EB>;>EH :#-)$ .(:

    I>A+( I+#+ ?#++E/ .F."E.,E+J P"$ >(E/ "(%+#+$%$ I+#+

    D.#%/"()H #":"() A>%>#B/BE+$ .(: #.B"() B.#$J W,+$"%/ :": (>%

    $++A %> ;.AD+# %;"$ ;.#:RE"F"() DE./,>/H ,-% %;+( ;+ :":(`%

    ;.F+ %> I>#G ?># . E"F"() E"G+ >%;+#$ "( P."%"J

    U;+( M+.(RhE.-:+ .$$-A+: %;+ D#+$":+(B/H ;"$ "(%+#+$%$

    #+A."(+: %;+ $.A+J K($%+.: >? .%%+(:"() %> A.%%+#$ >? $%.%+H

    ;+ E+?% "% -D %> %;+ h.,"(+%J K? D#+$$-#+ A>-(%+: "( . B+#%."(

    .#+.H ;+ I>-E: ?"#+ %;+ h.,"(+% C"("$%+# #+$D>($",E+ .(:#+DE.B+ %;+A I"%; $>A+>(+ +E$+J O;"$ #+F>EF"()R:>># >?

    B.,"(+%RE+F+E A"("$%+#$ :": E"%%E+ %> +()+(:+# B>(?":+(B+ "(

    ;"$ )>F+#(A+(%J

    M+.(RhE.-:+`$ D#"A.#/

    )>F+#(A+(%.E "(%+#+$% I.$

    ,#"()"() "( A"EE">($ >?:>EE.#$ >? .": ?#>A >%;+#

    B>-(%#"+$H +$D+B".EE/ %;+

    AA-("$% ;.(: E"G+ . D#>J U"%; B>AA-("$%

    h-,. (+_% :>>#H %;+ A+: . ?#"+(:E/ F>"B+ "( %;+ #+)">(:+$D"%+ %;+ $;>#%B>A"()$ >? %;+ #+)"A+ "( DE.B+J

    O;+ A>(+/ $+(% %> P."%" ?># ;-A.("%.#".( .": .(:

    "(?#.$%#-B%-#+ #+D."#[B>($%#-B%">( #.#+E/H "? +F+#H ?>-(: "%$

    "(%+(:+: %.#)+%J K($%+.:H M+.(RhE.-:+`$ C"("$%+# >? !"(.(B+

    !"# 21(#6 ,#(/ /1 E')/)

    31* ".2'()/'*)'( ')+ '(+

    )(3*',/*.

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    66/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    HH

    I>-E: $T-"##+E %;+ ?-(:$ .I./ "( =I"$$ ,.(G .BB>-(%$ ?>#

    %;+ D#+$":+(%`$ D+#$>(.E -$+J W%;+# ?-(:"() I>-E: ,+ -$+: %>

    D./R>?? B>##-D% >??"B".E$ "( ,>%; %;+ -#B+$ ?># %;+ A>$% ,.$"B ?>>: "%+A$J

    =%.#F.%">( -(:+# M+.(RhE.-:+ )#+I %> (+I E+F+E$ .(: ;-()#/

    P."%".($ ,+B.A+ %;+ (+I ,.#)."("() B;"D ?># ;"A %> -$+ %>

    $T-++S+ .::"%">(.E .": A>("+$ >-% >? I+.E%;/ (+");,>#"()

    B>-(%#"+$H +$D+B".EE/ %;+ -(%#/ $D"#.E+: :>I(I.#:H %;+ D+>DE+ %-#(+: %>

    :+$D+#.%+ A+.$-#+$ %> +($-#+ %;+"# $-#F"F.EJ C>%;+#$ #+$>#%+:

    %> "(?.(%"B":+ ,+B.-$+ %;+#+ I.$ (>% +(>-); ?>>: %> #."$+

    .(>%;+# B;"E:J C+( I>#G+: E"G+ $E.F+$ "( %;+ $-).#B.(+ ?"+E:$

    >? %;+ N>A"("B.( e+D-,E"B %> %#/ .(: ?++: %;+"# $%.#F"()

    ?.A"E"+$J f(%"#+ ?>#+$%$ I+#+ $%#"DD+: ,.#+ .(: %;+ I>>:

    %-#(+: %> B;.#B>.E %> ,+ $>E: .$ B>>G"() ?-+EJ

    O;+ B>-(%#/ I.$ "( :"#+ $%#."%$ .(: %;+ D+>DE+ I+#+

    ,+B>A"() "(B#+.$"()E/ #+$%E+$$J M+.(RhE.-:+`$ A>%;+#H

    ="A>(+H #+A+A,+#+: %;+ D.B% ;+# ;-$,.(: A.:+ I"%; %;+

    :+F"E 00 /+.#$ +.#E"+# +($-#"() ;"$ #+")( I>-E: ,+ $-D#+A+J

    OI+(%/R%I> I.$ . A.)"B (-A,+# "( N-F.E"+#"$A F>>:>> $> "%

    I.$ %"A+ %> #+(+I %;+ D.B%J O;+ D#>,E+A I.$ %;.% %;+ $D"#"%$

    I>-E: (>% ;>(># M+.(RhE.-:+ ,+B.-$+ ;+ I.$ %>> />-()H .(:

    ="A>(+ B>-E: (>% +(%+# %;+ D.B% >( M+.(RhE.-:+`$ ,+;.E? .$

    ;"$ A>%;+#J O;+ >(E/ I./ ="A>(+ B>-E: #+(+I %;+ D.B% I"%;

    %;+ :+F"E I.$ %> :> $> .$ M+.(RhE.-:+`$ I"?+J

    W( =+D%+A,+# 00H 2797 "( . #"%-.E"$%"B F>>:>>

    B+#+A>(/ %;.% I.$ F.E":.%+: .% h.%;>E"B A.$$+$ .#>-(: %;+

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    67/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    HP

    (.%">(H ="A>(+ .(: M+.(RhE.-:+ I+#+ I+:J W(B+ %;"$ I.$

    :>(+H ="A>(+H .$ P."%"`$ !"#$% g.:/H B>(%.B%+: %;+ :+F"E >(

    ,+;.E? >? ;+# D#+$":+(%R?>#RE"?+ \;-$,.(:^ .(: (+)>%".%+: .

    #+(+I+: D.B% %;.% I>-E: E.$% -(%"E =+D%+A,+# 00H 0112J

    :5/ P/K I"1#7 A%@M

    K(%> %;"$ I>#E: >? B>##-D%">( .(: I.(%>( :+,.-B;+#/

    B.A+ . (+I ?>#B+ %> ,+ #+BG>(+: I"%;H C"B;sE+ k+((+%%H

    M+.(RhE.-:+`$ ?-%-#+ I"?+J K(%#>:-B+: .% . D.#%/ ,/ >(+ >?

    M+.(RhE.-:+`$ ?#"+(:$H C"B;sE+ .(: %;+ D#+$":+(%

    "AA+:".%+E/ ?+EE "( E>F+J !"(.EE/ M+.(RhE.-:+ ;.: ?>-(:

    $>A+>(+ I;> B>-E: $.%"$?/ ;"$ "($.%".,E+ E-$%J

    C$J k+((+%% I.$ (>% I"%;>-% . ;"$%>#/J =;+ .(: M+.(RhE.-:+ ;.: )>(+ %> %;+ $.A+ $B;>>E .$ B;"E:#+( .(: ;+ I.$

    ?.$B"(.%+: I"%; ;+# %;+( +F+( %;>-); .% .)+ 20 C"B;sE+ ;.:

    . #+D-%.%">( .A>() %;+ ,>/$J P+# ?.%;+# I.$ (>% G++( >(

    %;+ ":+. >? ;+# ;.F"() .(/ G"(: >? #+E.%">($;"D I"%;

    N-F.E"+#`$ $>(J

    U;+( C"B;sE+ #+R+(%+#+: M+.(RhE.-:+`$ E"?+H $;+ ,E+I"( E"G+ %;+ ?"+#B+ $%>#A$ %;.% $I++D .B#>$$ %;+ :+(-:+:

    P."%".( E.(:$B.D+J =;+ I.$ ,+.-%"?-EH D+%"%+H $%#>()H

    >-%$D>G+(H .(: %;+ >,a+B% >? M+.(RhE.-:+`$ B>ADE+%+

    .??+B%">(J O;+#+?>#+H C"B;sE+ )>% .(/%;"() .(: +F+#/%;"()

    $;+ I.(%+:J

    U;.% +$D+B".EE/ B.-);% ;+# +/+ I.$ %;+ D>$"%">( >? !"#$%g.:/J @EE $;+ (++:+: %> :> I.$ A.##/ %;+ D#+$":+(% .(:

    A>F+ ="A>(+ >-% >? %;+ I./J O;+"# +().)+A+(% I.$

    .((>-(B+: A-B; %> %;+ :"$DE+.$-#+ >? %;+ D-,E"BJ C"B;sE+

    I.$ :"F>#B+: I"%; B;"E:#+(H I;"B; I.$ .(.%;+A. %> P."%".(

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    68/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    HI

    A>#+$J @::+: %> %;+ D-,E"B >-%B#/ I.$ %;+ :"$.DD#>F.E >?

    ="A>(+ .(: ;+# A>%;+#J P>I D#+$-AD%->-$ >? %;"$ B>.#$+H

    D#>A"$B->-$H ?>-ERA>-%;+: A-E.%%> %;.% $;+ B>-E: ,+B>A+

    %;+ I"?+ >? '#+$":+(%R!>#Rg"?+ M+.(RhE.-:+ N-F.E"+#b

    N+$D"%+ .EE %;"$H M+.(RhE.-:+ .(: C"B;sE+ I+#+ A.##"+: >(

    C./ 09H 2781J O;+"#

    I+::"() I.$ .( >F+#R%;+R

    %>DH +_%#.F.).(% .??."# %;.%

    B>$% %;+ $%.#F"() D+>DE+ >?

    P."%" t3H111H111J O;"$

    :./ I.$ A>#+ %;.( .

    I+::"() :.%+m "% I.$ .E$>

    %;+ ,+)"(("() >? %;+ +(:

    ?># M+.(RhE.-:+ .(: N-F.E"+#"$AJ

    C"B;sE+ %;#+I ;+#$+E? "(%> %;+ #>E+ >? !"#$% g.:/ I"%; .EE

    ;+# F")>#J KA.)"("() ;+#$+E? $>A+%;"() >? . P."%".( fF"%.

    N-#.%+H @#)+(%"(.`$ A>$% ;.%+:H A>$% E>F+: !"#$% g.:/J K(

    %;"$ #>E+H $;+ ?>-(:+: . ;>$D"%.E ?># D#+)(.(% I>A+( .(:

    %;+"# ,.,"+$J =.:E/H %;"$ F+#/ D#>a+B% ,+B.A+ >(+ >? %;+ A>$%

    ?>-E DE.B+$ "( P."%" .$ %;+ B>(:"%">($ %;+#+ I+#+ ?"E%;/ .(:

    :"$+.$+R#"::+(J g.%+#H "% ,+B.A+ . B>B."( I.#+;>-$+ ?>#

    C"B;sE+`$ :#-)R#-(("() ?.A"E/ A+A,+#$J

    L2G%("/1"#3

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    69/92

    N1"3$+* -#D+% !23+ Z2($ R @*+";( @"(1+9

    HJ

    A-#:+#$H B>+#B">(H %>#%-#+ .(: :+.%; ,/ $%.#F.%">( "( %;+

    D#"$>($J

    k/ E.%+ 2785H M+.(RhE.-:+`$ ;>E: >( %;+ (.%">( I.$

    B#-A,E"()J h>(:"%">($ I+#+ $> ,.: %;.% %;+ $"E+(% A.$$+$

    ?"(.EE/ ,+).( %> #">% "( $+.#B; >? .( +(: %> %;+"# B>(%"(-.EH

    )(.I"() ;-()+#J @$ %;+ F">E+(B+ $D#+.:H )>F+#(A+(%$

    $-##>-(:"() P."%" ,+).( %> E>,,/ ?># %;+ D#+$":+(% %> #+$")( .(:

    E+.F+ $> %;.% :+A>B#.%"B +E+B%">($ B>-E: ,+ ;+E:J O;+ I"%;;>E: F"%.E .": A>(+/ .(: $-DDE/ $;"DA+(%$ I+#+

    :#.$%"B.EE/ B-%J

    !"(.EE/H >( !+,#-.#/ 9H 2786H M+.(RhE.-:+ B>-E: ;.() >(

    (> E>()+#J P+H C"B;sE+H %;+"# B;"E:#+(H ="A>(+ .(: >%;+# ?.A"E/

    A+A,+#$ ,>.#:+: . ( ?"EE+: I"%; $%.#F"() D+>DE+J O;+

    :#+.A >? %;+ I>#E:`$ ?"#$% ,E.BG #+D-,E"B ,+"() )>F+#(+: ,/

    ,E.BG$ I.$ $;.%%+#+:J0

    A/%@/1#5"$ :1/%#21/ BZ

    @ E+.:+#`$ )#+.%+$% :#+.A $;>-E: ,+ %> ;+ED $>EF+ %;+

    D#>,E+A$ >? >%;+#$m %> ;+ED ?-E?"EE %;+"# :#+.A$H (>% ;"$ .E>(+J

    U;+( %;+ :#+.A "$ .EE .,>-% />-H />- I"EE A"$$ "%$

    D>I+#J d>-# .($I+# %> %;+ T-+$%">(H [!2Q 92 C 1+A3 2$1+*(

    A#D+ 7+$$+*4\I"EE +_D>$+ />-# :#+.AJ

    P."%" %+.B;+$ -$ %;.% L>:`$ :#+.A +(B>AD.$$+$ A.(/H(>% a-$% >(+J

    0!># .( +_B+EE+(% %#+.%"$+ >( %;+ /+.#$ >? N-F.E"+# #-E+ "( P."%"H K#+B>AA+(: %;+ ,>>GH!"#$#% 61+ @.D"A#+*( ",9 61+#* Z+?":

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    70/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    PL

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    71/92

    PK

    #$%&' 1/2

    :/7,7;- E(& F($(5/,7%$

    V#(% 79(% A $: +8" $%" '3$;2 "+ %+& J+3-$,(

    :(2 C 6+"2 &/88 A "(K8$3( ;+53 F+7(3 &+ &9(

    %(>& '(%(3$&/+%2 ;+53 :/'9& &+ $88 79+ $3( &+

    K+:(< '$.EA$ 92*28 YQKiZ

    O;+ :+D.#%-#+ >? M+.(RhE.-:+ N-F.E"+# "( %;+ =D#"() >?

    2786H .(: %;+ $-,$+T-+(% B>EE.D$+ >? ;"$ )>F+#(A+(%H E+?% .

    F.B--A >? E+.:+#$;"D %;.% ;.: %> ,+ ?"EE+:J L+(+#.E P+(#"

    Q.AD;/ $%+DD+: "( .$ %;+ (+I D#+$":+(% >? P."%" .(: ,+).(

    %> I>#G $>#%"() >-% %;+ A+$$ E+?% ,/ %;+ N-F.E"+#`$J

    O;+ D#>F"$">(.E )>F+#(A+(% #+A."(+: "( DE.B+ -(%"E2771 I;+( M+.(Rk+#%#.(: @#"$%":+ I.$ :+A>B#.%"B.EE/

    +E+B%+:J O;+ (.%">( #+A."(+: "( %-#A>"EH ;>I+F+#H .$

    @#"$%":+ I.$ $>>( :+D>$+: ,/ . B>-D .(: $>-);% .$/E-A "(

    %;+ (:"%">($ .A>() %;+ D>>#

    B>(%"(-+: %> :+%+#">#.%+J P-()+# #.( #.AD.(% I;"E+ %;+

    (.%">(`$ "(?#.$%#-B%-#+ B>(%"(-+: %> B#-A,E+ -(:+# %;+ $%#."(JO;+ D+>DE+ I.(%+: D>I+#H ,-% I+#+ D>I+#E+$$ %> )+% "%J

    f:-B.%">( ;+E: %;+ G+/H ,-% "( P."%"H +:-B.%">( "$ F+#/ B>$%E/J

    h;.()+ I.$ "(+F"%.,E+H ,-% I;.% G"(:V !#.(B>"$ N-F.E"+#

    D#>A"$+: B;.()+ %;#>-); . ,E.BG #+F>E-%">(H ,-% %;+ $%.%+:

  • 8/13/2019 Haiti: Past, Present, Future. Where is the hope?

    72/92

    6#; @+6+AA#(

    PM

    D#>A"$+$ .(: :#+.A+: >? #+$-E%$ (+F+# A.%+#".E"S+:J K( %;+"#

    DE.B+ I+#+ B>##-D%">(H )#++:H ,#-%.E"%/H $%.#F.%">( .(: :+.%;J

    K(%> %;"$ F>":H P."%"`$ (+_% )+(+#.%">( ,+).( %> ?>#AJ

    Q>% $.%"$?"+: I"%; +AD%/ D#>A"$+$ .(: -(?-E?"EE+: :#+.A$H

    %;"$ (+I P."%" ,+).( %> +A+#)+J k"#%;"() D."($ .#+ (>%

    DE+.$.(%H (+"%;+# "$ %;+ -(B+#%."(%/ >? %>A>##>IH ,-%

    #+%-#("() %> %;+ >E: N-F.E"+#"$A I.$ >-% >? %;+ T-+$%">(J

    !"#7'1M '0 J@2>%7"'& "& !%"7"

    P."%".($ G(+I ?#>A %;+ ,+)"(("() .?%+# "(:+D+(:+(B+

    %;.% +:-B.%">( ;+E: %;+ G+/ %> %;+"# ?-%-#+ $-BB+$$J O;"$

    G(>IE+:)+ E+: %;+ I#"%+#$ >? %;+ 2815 B>($%"%-%">( %> "(BE-:+

    . D#>F"$">( ?># ?#++ .(: B>AD-E$>#/ D#"A.#/ +:-B.%">(J k/2801 %;+#+ I+#+ ("(+%++( D#"A.#/ $B;>>E$ .(: %;#++

    $+B>(:.#/ $B;>>E$J O;+ f:-B.%">( @B% >? 2848 B#+.%+: #-#.E

    D#"A.#/ $B;>>E$ I"%; . A>#+ E"A"%+: B-##"B-E-A .(:

    +$%.,E"$;+: B>EE+)+$ >? A+:"B"(+ .(: E.IJ

    N+$D"%+ %;+$+ )>F+#(A+(% .B%">($ (> +??+B%"F+

    +:-B.%">(.E $/$%+A I.$ :+F+E>D+:H I;"B; B.-$+: %;++A+#)"() +E"%+ "( %;+ B"%"+$ %> $+(: %;+"# B;"E:#+( %> $B;>>E "(

    !#.(B+J C+.(I;"E+H %;>-); +:-B.%">( I.$ D#>F":+: ?># "(