good intentions without critical thinking create disasters
TRANSCRIPT
GOOD
INTENTIONS
WITHOUT
CRITICAL
THINKING
CREATE
DISASTERS.BY ROBIN LOW
DISASTERS EVERYWHERE
2 Earthquakes & 3+ Hurricanes + Fire (Sept 2017)
MOST COMMON “HELP”
1) Facebook Likes
2) Thought and prayers
3) Donations
4) Volunteer
5) Virgil / Solidarity
…
Fundraising, etc.
How effective is it?
DEFINE HELP
Help is any form of assistance.-- Wikipedia
WHY DO WE HELP?
• Religion?
• Branding?
• Good Intentions?
• Guilt?
POPULAR FORM OF
HELP: DONATIONS
Individuals and business like to help by
donating money.
Some donate a certain portion of profits
while others a certain amount every regular
interval.
This is a minimal form of helping and one
of the most common form.
NEPAL EARTHQUAKE
Twin Earthquakes 7.8 and 7.3 magnitude
About 9,000 people killed
650,000 families displaced
600,000 homes destroyed beyond repair
DONATIONS
Nepal received USD$4.1 billion from
International Communities and World
Bank.
Guess what is progress at the 1 year
anniversary?
REAL IMPACT IN
NEPAL IN MAY 2016
Some construction on infrastructure
started.
Some rebuilding on UNESCO sites.
Number of homes rebuilt =
0
PROBLEMS IN NEPAL
• Political indecision (Nepal
Reconstruction Agency)
• Unofficial Blockade on Indian border
• Politicians are PUSHING OF BLAME
• Survivors are WAITING FOR HELP
RESULTS
• People died from exposure from
environment.
• People displaced living in tents
• Farmers living in tents on their
farms, reduced income and food.
• Jobs lost (no Fuel)
• Unequal distribution of support.
MANY PEOPLE WANT TO
HELP, FEW KNOW HOW
Everyone thinks helping is easy.
Most do it out of convenience.
Does anything think about the impact of
their deeds?
Some help out of pity, and they get angry
when they see the recipients have a nice
meal or buy something nice.
COMMON HELP MISTAKES IN
DISASTERS
1) Bottled Water
100,000 liters of bottled water – 40,000 people a day
Cost + Logistics $50,000
Cost for NGO with Filter to purify 100,000 of water - $300
NO PLASTIC WASTE!
COMMON HELP MISTAKES IN
DISASTERS
2) Canned Food
…
List goes on.
COMMON HELP MISTAKES IN
DISASTERS
Clothes and Toys
NGOs do not have the capacity to provide
“non-essential” aid.
Most clothes and toys WILL be wasted as it
will be improperly stored and create a
health hazard.
COMMON HELP MISTAKES IN
DISASTERS
Many International NGOs spend in the
country the money is donated to buy
supplies, and this means that businesses
in the disaster areas are excluded.
People in charge are not on site and
bureaucracy prevents them from reacting
to changes or identifying gaps on the field.
CURSE OF
EXCLUSION OF
LOCALS IN
DISASTER RELIEF
AND RECOVERY
CAN’T HAITIANS
DRIVE?
Haiti Earthquake 2010
Food donation & delivery.
Trucks of Aid to Port-au-Prince.
5 year old saw the Dominican driver
and asked, “Can’t Hatians Drive?”
AID AND TRADITIONAL
NONPROFITS ARE UNABLE
TO GENERATE
SUSTAINABLE ECONOMIC
ACTIVITY.
Most organizations choose to
deal with immediate needs of
displaced people during an
“emergency” period
Almost NONE think of how to
integrate the survivors into
existing political and economic
systems.
Both skilled and unskilled labor
supply go under utilized because
of POLICIES.
Transforming Survivors into
refugees.
When you volunteer and cook for
disaster survivors in a shelter,
have you thought about asking if
there are professional chefs or
cooks who would do a better job?
Are you making them feel
helpless?
Is helping any help?
Not really…At least not in the way we are doing it…
Often when we help…
We make life decisions for
those we are helping.
Often when we help…
We fail to see the whole pictureand feel content to help.
Often when we help…
We search the approach most efficient to us not to those we are trying to help.
Often when we help…
We destroy the very same environment we are trying to help.
Often when we help…
we displace local capacity.
Often when we help…
we measure our success by the delivery of help or completion of actions not
actual impact.
WHAT HAPPENS WHEN DISASTER STRIKES IS AN UNFORTUNATE TWIST OF FATE.
WHAT HAPPENS AFTERWARDS IS OUR RESPONSIBILITY…
When disaster strikes…
Some people are given a burden:
The burden of enduring the disaster and the conditions that follow
When disaster strikes…
Some people are given a gift:
The gift of being sparedfrom disaster.
How can we not use our
gift to lift the burden of
others?
Disaster Response Lies…
• Only experts can help.
• You will be a burden in the field.
• We don’t need anything, we have all we need.
• Do not send clothes or food, send money.
We all can respond…
• And guarantee an efficient response…
• Donate Action, not money, not words…
• But how?
Disaster Response Basics:You can be useful in the field if…
• Bring your own supplies and food to the field.
– Or buy them locally if possible.
• Engage the local stakeholders and work for them, with them.
• Are connected.
• Have independent mobility.
• Listen, learn, respect.
Relief 2.0 (what is it?)
• A focus on running the last mile in disaster relief
• through independent units of local stakeholders and foreign volunteers in the field
• supported by mobile technologies and social networks
• to fill the gaps created by bureaucracy and slow response from top-down hierarchies.
Relief 2.0 (how does it work?)
• Individuals and organizations report incidents, needs and requests from the field using their mobile phones and the Internet.
Relief 2.0 (how does it work?)
• These incidents are reviewed, verified, completed, enhanced and their information spread to others
by individuals and groups on social networks
– Housewives, youngsters, volunteers, anyone.
until they are addressed, solved or matched
with someone who takes care of it.
Relief 2.0 (the last mile)
• Small independent units then complete the cycle by actually addressing those issues and delivering the response required and supported by the social network.
When disaster strikes…The social infrastructure remains, people’s capacity is untouched…
What appears to be random or chaosis neither…
There is order, social structure…
There is people,like you and me, willing and able.
Who are the people who survive disaster?
Disasters create survivors,they don’t create refugees.
It is the conventional relief system what turns survivors into refugees.
Disasters do not destroy knowledge or capacity
Teachers are still teachers, doctors are still doctors, nurses are still nurses, carpenters are still carpenters…
DANGERS OF SOCIAL
INTERVENTION
Making life decisions for those we are
helping
Is there “Over Helping?”
REFUGEE CAMP
IN EUROPE
40 volunteers per 100 refugee…
Refugees don’t need to cook,
clean or even do laundry…
Is this what we want?
ARE YOU HELPING?
Should you do nothing?
Should you support status quo?
SO THEN
WHAT
CAN WE DO?
NEVER HELP
ENGAGE, ENABLE,
EMPOWER & CONNECT
POOR PEOPLE ARE
NOT STUPID
SOCIAL INNOVATION
The point is, everyone can contribute.
Not just with money, not just doing
little tasks with no real impact.
We have innovative ideas, knowledge
and skills to solve complex problems.
There are interesting projects near
you or you can gather friends to work
on something you care about.
There are so many new
problems happening
everyday.
Complaining does not solve
problems, protesting does not
solve problems.
There is only so much the
government or NGOs can do.
Being big and bureaucratic
allows them access to
resources, but they are slow
to respond to changes.
We need innovation and
people to take actions and
accountability.
The crisis is not a crisis of
resources. It is a crisis of
imagination. When the plight
of humans is approached as a
crisis of resources, the natural
response is to produce
handouts.
For some, it means creating
businesses that address those
needs, and developing
plausible pathways to scale
those businesses so that
solutions stretch to the scale
of the challenge.
Then it is to look at how we
can support these businesses.
The solutions to the problems
the world face are complex
and getting to this solutions is
not an easy task.
There is definitely a solution
out there.
Let us not just engage in quick
fixes and follow status quo.
Let us not believe it is not our
problem and that we cannot make
a difference.
Let us engage the benificiaries
and think about the impact of our
actions.
Perhaps this is your
PURPOSE in this world – to
solve problems, not just to
eat, sleep and work.
After all, we all live on the
same planet.
LETS CONNECT
https://www.facebook.com/socialhub