gonzalez costello open letter 10012015

46
An Open Letter to the Members of the Select Committee of Affordable Health Care Access From Representatives Julio Gonzalez and Fred Costello October 1, 2015 Dear Members of the Select Committee of Affordable Health Care Access: As the only two health care providers in the Florida House who are not members of the Select Committee on Affordable Health Care Access, we want to share with you our vision for the future of Florida's health care system and of the interventions we believe will help maintain the high quality of care Floridians demand while keeping health care in Florida affordable. Our approach is founded on the notion that the best solution for health care is individual ownership, and the best way to promote individual ownership is through jobs and financial security. We also acknowledge that every regional health care system requires the inclusion of a safety net, strictly defined and 1

Upload: julio-gonzalez

Post on 23-Jan-2016

81 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

An Open Letter to the Members of the Select Committee of Affordable Health Care Access

From Representatives Julio Gonzalez and Fred Costello

October 1, 2015

Dear Members of the Select Committee of Affordable Health Care Access:

As the only two health care providers in the Florida House who are not members of the

Select Committee on Affordable Health Care Access, we want to share with you our vision for

the future of Florida's health care system and of the interventions we believe will help maintain

the high quality of care Floridians demand while keeping health care in Florida affordable. Our

approach is founded on the notion that the best solution for health care is individual ownership,

and the best way to promote individual ownership is through jobs and financial security.

We also acknowledge that every regional health care system requires the inclusion of a

safety net, strictly defined and efficiently operated, so that those members who are not able to

access care continue to have access to the care they need.

In the pages that follow, we share with you our vision for a health care system that will 1)

maximize access to quality health care through the unleashing of free market forces designed to

optimize price lowering pressures; 2) create more attractive conditions with the aim of bringing

health care professionals to our state; 3) improve health care workforce flexibility while

maintaining safety and quality of care, and 4) provide a targeted safety net that essentially

guarantees some form of coverage for every Floridian-Everyone Gets Access.

1

Page 2: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

We are very excited about the work you will be undertaking through this Select

Committee and look forward to supporting you in every way possible.

We begin by providing you with a summary of our recommendations and then proceed to

develop our thoughts in greater detail.

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Florida's approach to creating the nation's model health care system should be founded on

the concept that the best solutions for health care lie with individual ownership, and the best way

to promote individual ownership is through jobs and financial security.

With the numerous and conflicting priorities the state must balance, health care

expenditures for the state must be capped at 33% of the state's budget. To achieve these ends we

identify at least three areas that must be prioritized: A) maximizing financing options for an

individual's health care; B) increasing the size, versatility, and quality of the health care

workforce; and C) enhancing quality promoters within the state's health care system. We present

our recommendations at achieving each of these goals.

A) Maximizing Financing Options for an Individual's Health Care.

1. Pass legislation asserting that Direct Primary Care (DPC) agreements are not insurance

agreements.

2. Pass legislation that will disrupt the price-fixing influences of third-party payers.

3. Allow surgery centers to deliver overnight care to postoperative patients.

4. Explore the possibility of adding surgical recovery centers.

5. Discontinue the certificate of need requirement for building hospitals.

2

Page 3: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

6. Promote individual ownership of health care coverage plans.

7. Create the Florida Health Savings Account (FHSA) Program.

8. Request federal waivers to allow flexibility in employer health insurance policies including

portability.

9. Revamp Medicaid to provide for a targeted approach to coverage, defined by Floridians and

run by Floridians, and designed to provide variable levels of coverage for those truly

needing health care coverage when they need it.

10. Remove mandated reimbursement fees from Medicaid contracts and create a fee-savings-

sharing program with beneficiaries.

11. Implement the Medicaid Direct Primary Care Plan (MDPCP) as a viable Medicaid

contracting alternative that encourages beneficiaries to participate in price negotiations

with their providers and share in the cost savings with the State.

B) Increasing the Size, Versatility, and Quality of the Health Care Workforce;

1. Repeal Article X; Section 26 of Florida's Constitution requiring removal of licensure with

three successful medical malpractice claims.

2. Provide advanced registered nurse practitioners (ARNPs) and physician assistants (PAs)

working under physician supervision the authority to prescribe Schedule II medications.

3. Increase funding for graduate medical education in Florida for physicians and educational

opportunities for ARNPs and PAs.

4. Establish a loan forgiveness program for health care providers graduating from Florida

schools and practicing in underserved areas.

5. Expand medical research opportunities within the state.

3

Page 4: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

6. Define the practice of telemedicine and require that only health care providers licensed in

Florida be authorized to deliver telemedicine services within the state. Additionally,

require that third party payers in the state honor and reimburse telemedicine services.

7. Require that only physicians or dentists own outpatient medical or dental practices.

8. Prohibit the bundling of payments to health care providers within the state.

C. Enhancing Quality Promoters Within the State’s Health Care System;

1. Promote tighter oversight of health care boards over practitioners whose performance has

fallen below the standard of care.

2. Explore and implement health care quality enhancement measures into Florida's health care

delivery system, including expedited censure of healthcare practitioners when they do not

meet the standard of care.

I. INTRODUCTION:

Health care and its availability have become a matter of great public and governmental

importance within the State of Florida. The onslaught of federal regulatory intrusions, the ever-

changing insurance environment, and the dynamics of our state's demographics have made health

care access an issue that will continue to figure prominently for years to come.

There have been numerous approaches in implementing a system to maximize Floridians'

access to healthcare. Of course, no approach will hold complete solutions to all the complex

health care challenges confronting our state. However, any plan will have significant and direct

impacts upon the lives of millions of Floridians. Consequently, and in light of the direct and

4

Page 5: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

palpable effects these important decisions will have upon our citizens, Florida must build a

healthcare delivery system that upholds the highest quality standards for patients while observing

the keenest sense of fiscal responsibility and stewardship for its taxpayers.

II. FLORIDIANS DESERVE THE BEST HEALTHCARE SYSTEM AVAILABLE

Florida's impact to the nation with its status as the third most populous state and

possessive of the country's fourth largest gross state product is immeasurable.1 The

implementation and maintenance of a quality health care system accessible to all is of

compelling state and national importance. As a result, it should be the goal of the state of Florida

to achieve and maintain the highest quality health care system available that preserves and

promotes the practice of medicine as a scientific pursuit and an art to be developed, and which

promotes the robustness and vibrancy of its ancillary professions. Florida's health care system

ought to be of such high standards that it motivates providers from around the nation and the

globe to come to our state to practice their professions.

We believe Florida's health care system must also demand accountability from its

providers and a commitment for continued intellectual and professional improvement. We

further believe that an ideal health care system will employ a team-centered approach that

maximally employs the skills and expertise of each member. In order to maximize the quality

and efficacy of the care delivered, the health care team must be headed by a physician, defined as

a doctor of medicine or doctor of osteopathic medicine in the medical arena, and a doctor of

1 In 2015, Florida's GSP is $800.492 billion dollars accounting for nearly 4.8% of the nation's gross domestic product. U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis; http://www.bea.gov/newsreleases/regional/gdp_state/gsp_newsrelease.htm on June 3, 2015.

5

Page 6: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

dentistry in the dental arena.2 Although much independence and autonomy may be imparted

upon every other member of the health care workforce to maximize productivity and efficacy,

only these health care team-leaders possess the necessary skills and expertise to 1) coordinate the

delivery of health care in an effective manner and 2) maximally identify and prevent

complications and pitfalls in care.

Additionally, we recognize that Florida is in possession of only a finite number of

resources for the delivery of care. Consequently, those persons relied upon to deliver health care

to Florida's patients are also required to act as responsible stewards of those limited and precious

resources. Just as these professionals must apply their assets with great care and deliberation, it

also falls upon the legislature, governor, and policymakers to devise a plan that responsibly

applies these assets in as cost-effective a manner as possible while providing the state's health

care workforce the flexibility it needs to adapt and accommodate to the very fluid challenges

before them. We believe there is no greater check on the spending and expansive tendencies of

health care professionals than the oversight of patients empowered with the ability to

individually contract with those professionals and who possess a say in the direction, price, and

extent of their care.

2 The term "team" is used as it applies to the coordinated structure of health care providers throughout the state and their ancillary and supporting members.

6

Page 7: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

III. CHALLENGES TO BECOMING THE FINEST HEALTHCARE STATE IN THE

NATION

Building a health care system uniquely suited to meet Floridians' needs is a demanding

task. As of 2015, the State of Florida had a total budget of approximately $78.7 billion.3

Medicaid expenditures within the state accounted for $25.8 billion, or approximately 32.9% of

Florida's budget.4 With the numerous and conflicting priorities the state must balance, such as

protecting and maintaining its water supplies and natural resources, its infrastructure, and its

educational system, we certainly believe these non-health care expenditures must account for at

least 67% of the state's overall budget, leaving approximately 33% of the state's budget for health

care related expenditures. It is therefore our aim to work within a framework of health care

expenditures capped at 33% of the state's budget.

We recognize at least four components to Florida's health care funding structure: 1) the

private component, 2) the Medicare component, 3) the VA component, and 4) the safety net, or

state run component, which includes Medicaid. Each component has its own individual and

indispensible roles.

The private component of health care funding is central, and the one component to which

the general population should be directed. Floridians engage in privately funding for their health

3 2015 Legislative Sessions Including Special Session A: Fiscal Analysis in Brief. General Appropriations Act Chapter 2015-232, Laws of Florida Adjusted for Vetoes and Supplementals. The Florida Legislature. August, 2015, http://www.flsenate.gov/UserContent/Session/2015/Publications/2015FiscalAnalysisBrief.pdf on September 6, 2015.4 Id.

7

Page 8: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

care in at least three ways: 1) self-financing; 2) financing through the individually contracting of

third party payers; and 3) group contracting of third party payers.

The number of Floridians in a position to finance their own health care without third

party payer assistance is admittedly small to negligible. Presently, approximately, 5% of

Floridians are enrolled in some form of private insurance plan designed to offset medical care

costs as individuals, and 48% of Floridians are enrolled in some form of group coverage plan,

mostly through their employer.5 These three groups essentially make up the totality of the

private component.

The second component is the federally funded Medicare system tailored to our nation's

seniors and to those Americans who have been deemed completely disabled. Presently 14% of

Floridians are enrolled in Medicare.6

The third component, also largely federally funded, is the VA health care system tailored

to our nation's veterans. There are presently 544,022 veterans in Florida who receive their care

from the VA system.7

The state's government-funded health care component addresses those residents who

cannot provide for themselves and are afflicted by medical conditions. The exact number of

Floridians unable to afford any insurance is debatable. Although the American Community

Survey finds that approximately 3.6 million Floridians are uninsured,8 recent estimates place the

number of adult Floridians who have earned-incomes under Federal Poverty Level (FPL) at

5 State Health Facts; Health Insurance Coverage of the Total Population, The Henry J Keiser Family Foundation, http://kff.org/other/state-indicator/total-population/ on June 5, 2015.6 Id.7 Email from Donal Davis, VISN8 Strategic Planner September 9, 2015. 8 The Florida Senate Committee on Health Policy, Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement for SB 2-A, 2 June 1, 2015 quoting Kaiser Family Foundation, State Health Facts, Health Insurance Coverage of the Total Population (2013), http://kff.org/other/state-indicator/total-population/ (last visited May 26, 2015).

8

Page 9: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

approximately 900,000.9,10 Additionally, there are 250,000-800,000 people who earn between

100% and 138% of the FPL, are not eligible for participation in Medicaid, and are also not

eligible to receive subsidies to participate in the federal healthcare exchange.11 These two

groups add up to about 1.7 million Floridians who would greatly benefit from assistance

provided by a state run health care program. The level of care, its expense, and its intensity,

however, vary amongst the members of that group at any particular time, from no significant

care requirements to intensive, expensive, and life preserving care. Only by maximally

employing all available assets as efficiently and economically as possible can Florida stand to

make its health care delivery system the best in the nation.

IV. SPECIFIC AIMS TOWARDS MAKING FLORIDA THE NUMBER ONE

HEALTHCARE STATE IN THE NATION

Making Florida's health care system a beacon for the rest of the country requires a

multifaceted approach aimed at optimizing the efficiency and delivery capacity of each of the

previously identified components. Ultimately, the desired aim is to create an environment where

Floridians can maintain the highest standard of health possible. Such a system is necessarily one

that provides robust and achievable funding options for the individual and contains a vibrant and

dynamic set of health care professionals who stand prepared to deliver that care. To achieve

these ends we identify at least three areas that must be prioritized: A) maximizing financing

9 The Florida Senate Committee on Health Policy, Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement for SB 2-A, 2 June 1, 2015, quoting Kaiser Family Foundation, State Health Facts, Health Insurance Coverage of the Non-Elderly (0-64) with Income Below 100% Federal Poverty Level (FPL) http://kff.org/other/state-indicator/nonelderly-up-to-139-fpl/ (last visited May 26, 2015). 10 Federal Poverty Level determinations are made yearly by the United States Census Bureau.11 Justin Senior, Oral Testimony at the Health and Human Services Committee Workshop on Bill SB 2-A, June 1, 2015.

9

Page 10: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

options for an individual's health care; B) increasing the size, versatility, and quality of the health

care workforce; and C) enhancing quality promoters within the state's health care system.

A. Maximizing financing options for an individual's health care: The ultimate goal of the

state with regard to health care delivery is to create and maintain a health care system that

allows for maximum access to quality health care tailored to the unique circumstances and

needs of each citizen. To accomplish this, each of the financing components of the health

care system need be groomed so as to maximally play its role in supporting the state's health

care delivery system. Additionally, although we acknowledge the necessity of a safety net

for those unable to finance their own health care, every effort should be undertaken to

minimize the size requirement of that safety net. In other words, every effort should be made

to optimize the opportunity for productive economic endeavors for Floridians, to keep the

cost of living down so that a greater percentage of an individual's personal budget is available

for provisions such as accessing health care, and to make health care as affordable as possible

so that as many as possible of those financially stable individuals are able to access the care

they need. Below we provide some ideas that may help accomplish these aims.

1. Improve Florida's economy. As previously asserted, possessing a stable and well-paying

job is the most effective way to secure access to health care. Regardless of whether one's

health care is financed through one's employer, through contracting with a third party

payer on an individual basis, or through the achievement of sufficient wealth so that one's

health care may be directly funded, financial self-sufficiency is the optimal method of

10

Page 11: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

ensuring access to health care and should be the aspirational goal of the state's health

policy.

Indisputably, efficiency is maximized and the cost of delivery minimized, when the

individual receiving care has a primary stake in his or own health care and has the

principal say in the make up of the care received and the price that is paid for it.

Consequently, accessing quality health care in Florida tailored to the patient's needs is

inextricably linked to achieving financial self-sufficiency, which in turn depends upon

building and maintaining a vibrant, freely accessible economy. We therefore strongly

support and encourage any measure by the legislature designed to improve job creation

and economic growth.

2. Improve the efficiency and private access to Florida's health care system: Improving

the efficiency and private access to Florida's health care system may be accomplished

through a number of interventions.

a. Promote Direct Primary Care in Florida: DPC is a health care delivery model

where the patient directly contracts with a primary care provider for access to health care

delivery services. Usually contracted as a monthly payment plan between the patient and

the primary care provider, this arrangement allows for a direct contractual relationship

where the patient gains direct access to his or her physician in exchange for a periodic

fee. The DPC arrangement carries the advantage of allowing for the unfettered access to

a physician, ARNP, or PA without interference from third party payers or intervening

institutional policies or directives. The arrangement also produces greater efficiency in

11

Page 12: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

health care delivery since billing costs and reimbursement procurement efforts are

minimized. The plan generally does not cover the costs of ancillary services such as

laboratory costs, imaging services, or care from other providers although some DPC

agreements include provisions for negotiated discounts for these services. Most

significantly, the plan will also not cover hospitalization costs. However, using a DPC

model as a component of a multi-faceted health care financing plan may represent a

viable, cost effective alternative for many Floridians.

One threat to DPC is a judicial interpretation that such plans represent health insurance

plans rather than individual contractual agreements or club membership. Interpreting

DPC as an insurance plan is problematic because it would immediately threaten the

ability of health care providers to engage in such arrangements.

Legislative Opportunity: Improve the state's legislative DPC environment by passing

legislation asserting that DPC agreements are not insurance agreements.

b. Implement measures that help diminish the cost of health care delivery: No

measures will help in controlling the cost of health care delivery greater than those

fostering competition and the abilities for individuals to independently contract for health

care services. These free-market pressures are tempered in at least three ways within the

arena of health care delivery. First, in contradistinction to many other industries,

competition within the health care arena must be more strictly regulated since measures

aimed at achieving a competitive advantage by vendors could concurrently endanger

patient safety. Second, much of the pricing discretion by health care providers is

12

Page 13: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

inhibited by the cost fixing effects of third-party payers.12 Third are the inflationary

effects of meritless litigation.13

Since the minimum safety precautions cannot be tampered without negatively

impacting safety and quality, the most effective methods of ascertaining that market-

based, cost cutting pressures are felt evenly throughout the market are ones that disrupt

the artificial price-stabilizing pressures imposed upon the market and those streamlining

our civil justice system.

Legislative Opportunity: Florida should pass legislation that will disrupt the price-

fixing influences presently countering the cost-containing effects of market competition

and contract negotiations and increase the efficiency with which our civil justice system

disposes of medical malpractice cases.

12 In Sarasota County, for example, where there is a sizable elderly population, Medicare can account for over 70% of the medical market share. Under such circumstances, the costs savings accommodations the health care market is willing to offer in response to competition is essentially fixed by the colossal influence of one consumer; Medicare13 The cost of medical liability to the nation has been estimated to run in excess of $55.6 billion. Michelle Mello, et al, National Costs of the Medical Liability System, accepted for publication in Health Affairs 2010, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3048809/ on September 6, 2015. According to the Office of Insurance Regulation, Florida's total malpractice premium costs is the fourth largest in the nation, with about $540 million worth of premiums expended in 2013. Medical Malpractice Financial Information Closed Claim Database and Rate Filings, Annual Report, October 2014, Florida Office of Insurance Regulation, 8 October 1, 2014, http://www.floir.com/siteDocuments/MedicalMalReport10012014.pdf on September 6, 2015. The average cost of defending a case is $27,000.00 regardless of the outcome, and more tellingly, the cost of defending a case requiring formal adjudication where a defense verdict will be obtained (the health care provider prevails) runs about $125,000.00. Aeron Carroll, et al, The Impact of Defense Expenses in Medical Malpractice Claims, The Journal of Law, Medicine, and Ethics, Vol. 40, Issue 1, March 27, 2012, http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1748-720X.2012.00651.x/pdf on September 6, 2015.

13

Page 14: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

Market interventions designed to promote less expensive and innovative ways of

delivering health care should be an integral component of the state's cost cutting efforts.

During the 2015 legislative session, the Florida House explored some of these measures

as possible ways in which to foster greater competition within the market. Amongst

these were the expansion of surgery centers as possible venues for delivering surgical

care normally requiring overnight stays, the creation of surgical recovery centers

allowing for the 3-day delivery of postoperative care, and the discontinuation of

certificates of needs. We agree that these market disrupters represent potential price

reducing interventions that when properly administered will serve to lower the cost of

health care to consumers.

Legislative opportunity: Allow surgery centers to deliver overnight care to

postoperative patients. Explore the possibility of adding surgical recovery centers and

discontinuing the certificate of need requirement for hospitals.

c. Promote individual ownership of health care coverage plans: Ideally, health

care insurance should be portable and uniquely suited to address the needs of each

individual. Consequently, Florida should undertake those measures that help to increase

the portability of health care insurance. This includes minimizing mandates that serve to

artificially increase the price of health care insurance within the State of Florida and

providing incentives for individuals to purchase their own private health care insurance

plans. Admittedly, these efforts are restricted by the regulatory restraints stemming from

federal regulations. Nevertheless, measures promoting individual ownership in health

14

Page 15: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

care should be explored and maximized. One option to maximize individual ownership

lies with health savings accounts (HSAs).

HSAs are a form of private health insurance arrangement where the owner of the

account owns the funds in the account and manages them. The owner would then be able

to negotiate the price of services as well as the extent of treatments and evaluations. A

truly effective HSA program would make the funds devisable and provide tax rewards to

offset funds that are placed into the accounts. The FHSA could be such a program.

With FHSAs, Floridians would be able to yearly deposit money into a health savings

account to be used for medical expenses. Fifty percent of any contributions would be tax

deductible from the individual's sales taxes. Such accounts would be devisable.

Floridians would be able to purchase an electronic card that would track their FHSA and

earned tax credits. At the time of any taxable transaction within the State of Florida, the

purchaser would present the FHSA card and the deductible sales tax would be adjusted at

the time of purchase from applicable earned credits. The tax credit would then be reset at

the end of each calendar year.

Legislative Opportunity: Create the Florida Health Savings Account Program

c. Group and Employer health care insurance: Although group coverage plans

suffer from a lack of flexibility and portability, the premium lowering advantages of cost

averaging amongst the different members provides significant advantages for many.

Florida can help cut costs on employer-mandated insurance policies by diminishing

regulations that deter cost cutting options for employers and contracting beneficiaries.

15

Page 16: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

Additionally, Florida can incentivize employer participation through corporate tax

adjustments.

Unfortunately, many restrictions on employer health insurance stem from federal

regulations and severely curtail the state's ability to enact meaningful reform.

Consequently, until these federal regulations are repealed, many of the interventions that

the state could implement remain unavailable. However, members of the state legislature

may work with Congress to help open up those avenues and promote badly needed

reforms to the employer and group health insurance laws.

Legislative Opportunity: Request federal waivers to allow flexibility in employer

health insurance policies. Require that employees who change jobs be given the

opportunity to privately keep their policy for up to three years after changing jobs by

paying both the employer and employee portions of the same rate they enjoyed under the

previous employer.

e. The safety net. Practically speaking, Florida's safety net is Medicaid, covering

approximately 17% of Floridians.14 Presently, Medicaid is suboptimally designed to

balance the availability of resources with the effort at maximizing access and cannot

achieve this end without a significant redesign.

14 The number of Medicaid enrollees in Florida obtained from Presentation by Health and Human Services Committee Workshop on Bill SB 2-A, June 1, 2015, Slide 3 http://myfloridahouse.gov/Sections/Documents/loaddoc.aspx?PublicationType=Committees&CommitteeId=2857&Session=2015A&DocumentType=Meeting%20Packets&FileName=hhsc%206-1-15.pdf on September 7, 2015.

16

Page 17: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

i. Prioritization: With the limitations on available resources, Florida cannot fund

healthcare coverage for all Floridians, nor should it, as this would run counter to the goal

of moving citizens out of Medicaid and into private healthcare insurance programs. Until

now, Florida's approach has been to participate in national programs that define the

patient groups to be covered and the terms of allocations of those associated funds.

We disagree with this approach. We believe Florida's goal ought to provide full-

service coverage to that limited portion of its citizens truly in need of coverage and

unable to provide for themselves regardless of federal definitions or requirements. The

state's analysis should therefore begin by calculating the cost of providing health care

services to those Floridians needing assistance. It should then design a system of variable

coverage where the driving factor for the allocation of funds and system design is not

participation or compliance with federal programs, but rather tailoring the resources

available to the variable needs of the various subpopulations of Florida's poor and

disabled. Additionally, Florida must allocate a reserve fund to cover the care of those

individuals actuarially predicted to require care over the span of a year. In this way, all

Floridians unable to purchase health care insurance on their own will be covered, but

only to the extent of services they require. Those who did not have health care coverage,

but through an unforeseen event develop a condition under circumstances where the state

would have to intervene and then regain the ability to provide for themselves are enrolled

in a payback program through the Department of State by which the beneficiary would

pay back the state for the funds allocated towards his or her care during the temporary

time of need.

17

Page 18: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

In other words, although only a few exceptionally needy Floridians will need full

state-arranged and administered coverage, all needy Floridians will be covered if a

debilitating and unexpected health event were to take place. Everyone Gets Access.

Legislative Opportunity: Revamp Medicaid to provide for a targeted approach to

coverage, defined by Floridians and run by Floridians, and designed to provide variable

levels of coverage for those truly needing health care coverage when they need it.

ii. Medicaid Cost-Containment Measures: Commensurate with its prioritization

efforts, steps to contain costs within the state's Medicaid healthcare system must also be

implemented.

A) Reimbursement provisions in Medicaid contracts ought to be written as "no

more than" 100% of Medicare reimbursement rates, leaving the beneficiary

free to negotiate a lower fee with the provider. Savings in the agreed-upon

price for the service will be split equally between the state and the patient.

A binding fee schedule would be applicable to emergency room visits and

urgent care delivered within Florida's hospitals since these situations

represent times where the patient would be unable to effectively negotiate an

appropriate reimbursement fee. Being that most providers are hesitant to

accept reimbursements of less than Medicare rates, Medicare rates would be

used as the benchmark for reimbursing Florida's providers.

18

Page 19: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

Legislative Opportunity: Remove mandated reimbursement fees from Medicaid

contracts and create a fee-savings-sharing program with beneficiaries.

B. Implement the Medicaid Direct Primary Care Plan. Under the MDPCP,

Medicaid would contract with participating providers to enter into DPC

relationships with patients. The arrangements could be designed, for

example, so that Medicaid would offer to pay up to $100.00/mo per patient

to the provider, or $1,200.00 per year, for participation in the program. The

patient would then use only his or her DPC health care provider in accessing

care except in emergency situations. Any discounts negotiated by the

patient would be shared equally with the state. Medicaid would also cover

basic laboratory and imaging services. Emergency room visits and

hospitalizations would be covered by the conventional fee arrangements

between Medicaid and hospitals.

An incentive program could be established whereby health care

providers with a practice of at least 500 DPC Medicaid patients would be

eligible for financial assistance in staffing the practice with ancillary

personnel, including ARNPs and PAs who themselves are caring for over

500 DPC patients.

Under this model, a physician would conservatively be able to handle

approximately 1,000 patients per year,15 and that's without the broad practice

expansion capabilities made possible with additional ARNPs. Recruitment

15 John Goodman, Everyone Should Have a Concierge Doctor, Forbes, August 28, 2014 http://www.forbes.com/sites/johngoodman/2014/08/28/everyone-should-have-a-concierge-doctor/ on September 2, 2015.

19

Page 20: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

of 100 strategically located physicians would allow for over 100,000

Medicaid patients to be serviced.

Using the MDPCP program, the overall savings to Medicaid would be

sizeable. According to one study, employing DPC with a Value-in-

Prevention approach combining DPC with a comprehensive prevention

management realized $119.4 million in cost savings in the five states

employing the program (Florida, Virginia, New York, and Arizona).16

Interestingly, when broken down per capita, the cost savings were even

larger, with a cost savings estimate of $2,551 per patient, which incidentally,

was greater than the per capita cost of participation in the program. This

program would maximally be used in regions where high concentrations of

Medicaid patients reside.

The versatility of the MDPCP, if innovatively applied, we believe will

be staggering. For example, we foresee the merging of the MDPCP with

Florida's hospitals allowing for agreements to be made to contract for

unlimited access to necessary hospital services by patients enrolled in the

MDPCP. The patient then would have access to a primary care physician

through MDPCP, and also, if faced with a serious condition or emergency,

would be able to also gain access to the hospital through a Medicaid Direct

Catastrophic Care Plan (MDCCP). As an incentive, patients who do not

inappropriately access hospitals for a calendar year may then have credits

applied to their HSAs.

16 Andrea Klemes, et al., Personalized Preventive Care Leads to Significant Reductions in Hospital Utilization. The American Journal of Managed Care, Vol. 18, No12, 453 December 2012.

20

Page 21: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

We also believe that giving participants the ability to directly negotiate

with the provider while splitting the negotiated cost savings with the

Department would maximize the cost lowering pressures on the industry,

thus improving economic efficiency. When this program is combined with

the robust utilization of ARNPs and PAs delivering care under physician

supervision, the program design would unleash even greater potential for

cost containment and volume expansion to meet the demands of Florida's

Medicaid population.

Legislative Opportunity: Create MDPCP as a viable Medicaid

contracting alternative while allowing the beneficiaries to participate in

price negotiations with their prospective providers and sharing in the cost

savings with the State; authorize the creation of MDCCPs with incentives

for beneficiaries who do not misuse hospital Emergency Rooms.

B. Increase the size and versatility of the healthcare workforce: Florida is presently

undersupplied with health care providers. Certain areas, such as psychiatry and primary care,

are demonstrating critical regional shortages. In order to alleviate this undersupply, certain

steps should be considered:

1. Promote an economic, professional, and legislative environment that will encourage

health care providers to move to Florida and establish their practices here. A hostile tort

environment, economic considerations, a high dependence on Medicare with its

21

Page 22: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

depressive effects on reimbursement rates, and the negative image resulting from a three-

strikes-you're-out rule relating to medical licensure play integral roles in deterring health

care providers from moving to the Sunshine State. Addressing these issues would be

very beneficial in improving the supply of medical personnel throughout the state.

Legislative opportunity: Sponsor legislation placing a constitutional amendment

on the ballot to Repeal Article X; Section 26 of Florida's Constitution.

2. Implement measures that will increase the use and productivity of the various support,

ancillary, and physician-extension health care professionals. Improving the versatility

and scope of the medical workforce is critical to improving Florida's health care system.

However, these measures cannot be undertaken at the expense of patient safety and

quality.

ARNPs, PAs, and other health care workers play a vital role in supporting the

delivery of health care within the state. However, none of these providers is an adequate

substitute for a physician or dentist, which is the only member of the healthcare

workforce trained to independently evaluate disease, diagnose it, and develop a plan to

treat or cure it. As a result, physicians and dentists are best suited, by virtue of their

training, to identify complex medical conditions that may escape the evaluation of other

members of the health care workforce.

Presently, ARNPs and PAs share a substantial degree of autonomy in delivering

health care to Florida's patients. However, while PAs must remain within a reasonable

distance of the overseeing physician, ARNPs are not restricted by the reasonable distance

rule so long as they are governed by a supervisory agreement with a physician.

22

Page 23: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

Additionally, neither ARNPs nor PAs possess the authority to prescribe Schedule II

medications such as narcotic medications.17

Legislative Opportunity: Provide ARNPs and PAs with the authority to prescribe

Schedule II medications so long as the care they deliver continues to be delivered under

the supervision of a Florida-licensed physician.

3. Support training and research efforts to turn Florida into the leading medical research

forum in the nation. Expanding intrastate medical training opportunities is an established

method for increasing a state's medical workforce.18 However, in order for such growth

efforts to be successful, intrastate class expansion must be tied to effective graduate

medical education efforts.

Residency training is the phase in a physician's training following medical school.

It does little good to spend state funds in initiating the training of new physicians if we

lose them to other states through the scarcity of post-graduate training programs.

Consequently, the expansion of graduate medical education in Florida is crucial to

enhancing retention. In 2015, the legislature explored a $20 million allocation in

17 Commentary is appropriate regarding prior efforts to expand the scope of practice of ARNPs. Due to the paucity of scientific data on the matter, we harbor significant concerns about the advisability of promoting the unrestricted practice of medicine by ARNPs. Until additional data becomes available that would allow for the further assessment of the risks and benefits of such a broad scope of practice expansion, we believe it is best for the Florida legislature to expand scope of practice of ARNPs only to the point of allowing for the prescription of narcotic medications, which would place Florida in line with the plurality of states (and with Florida's addition, the majority), which similarly limit ARNP scope of practice. House of Representatives Staff Analysis PCB SCHCWI 14-01, Advanced Practice Registered Nurses, 11 February 27, 2014.18 Recent Studies and Reports on Physician Shortages in the U.S., AAMC, October 2012, https://www.aamc.org/download/100598/data/ on September 6, 2015.

23

Page 24: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

recurring general revenues with a $30 million federal match for the expansion of graduate

medical education opportunities within the state. We favor this approach.

Additionally, as the role of ARNPs and PAs in the delivery of health care

expands, the demand for ARNP and PA education opportunities will also predictably

increase. The legislature ought to promote ARNP and PA training opportunities within

the state in order to create an ample supply of these professionals to address the state's

health care delivery needs.

Legislative opportunity: Increase funding for graduate medical education in

Florida for physicians and educational opportunities for ARNPs and PAs.

Another key method by which the legislature may improve retention is the

development of a robust loan forgiveness program. A loan forgiveness program for

health care providers serving in underserved areas will go a long way towards promoting

the establishment of a robust health care delivery environment within our state and foster

the relocation of health care resources to regions where their services are required.

Legislative Opportunity: Establish a loan forgiveness program for physicians,

dentists, PAs, and ARNPs graduating from Florida schools and practicing in

underserved areas for prescribed periods of time.

Finally, few interventions will attract more health care professionals than a robust

medical research environment. Programs such as those undertaken at the Children's

24

Page 25: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

Research Institute at All Children's Hospital,19 Moffitt Cancer Center, the Mayo Clinic in

Jacksonville, the Miller School of Medicine, and at Shands Hospital, to name a few,

represent near limitless opportunities for the promotion of a vibrant medical research

environment within Florida, which will promote the economy, grow jobs, and ultimately

result in advances that alleviate human suffering and cure diseases. No better location

can exist to house these noble endeavors than in Florida.

Legislative Opportunity: Expand medical research opportunities within the state.

4. Promote telemedicine opportunities within Florida. Telemedicine, or the practice of

medicine from remote locations appears to be a very versatile and powerful method of

both, increasing competition within the health care market and increasing the effective

number of health care providers practicing within the state. Statutorily, telemedicine

remains undefined and consequently fraught with difficulties in reimbursement. Florida

can easily alleviate this deficiency by defining telemedicine and requiring that

telemedicine services be mandatorily reimbursed by participating insurers.20 A

prerequisite to guaranteeing appropriate oversight of a telemedical practice is that

19 All Children's Hospital in St. Petersburg has combined with Johns Hopkins University and created a pediatric biorepository program that is unique in the field of medical research.20 Possible telemedicine definition and reimbursement requirement: Telemedicine is the use of telecommunications technology by two or more health care professionals all of whom are licensed to practice medicine, advanced nurse practice, or dentistry within the State of Florida, but who may be separated by great distances for the purposes of providing health care services to a patient physically within the State of Florida exclusive of audio-only transmissions, email messages, or facsimile transmissions. Any telemedicine healthcare services provided using a telemedicine platform shall be subject to the same billing and reporting guidelines as face-to-face interactions and shall be reimbursable subject to the same rules as would apply to face-to-face healthcare services.

25

Page 26: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

telemedicine professionals delivering care inside Florida be licensed to practice in

Florida.

Legislative Opportunity: Define the practice of telemedicine while requiring that

only health care professionals licensed in Florida be authorized to deliver telemedicine

services within the state. Additionally, require that third party payers in the state honor

and reimburse telemedicine services.

5. Support measures that will counteract hospital intrusions into the health care

practice market. A significant threat to quality of care and to the persistent autonomy of

the patient-physician relationship is the ongoing expansion of hospitals into the outpatient

health care delivery market with a resultant decrease in competition and often a

concurrent price increase.21 Driven largely by national policy forces, hospitals

throughout the state are gobbling up practices that traditionally have been free-standing

and independent organizations, resulting in mini, regional monopolies where the care and

price are dictated by the area's hospital at the expense of practice autonomy and patient

care. This trend must be countered within the state.

Another nationally driven model is that of bundling of payments. Payment

bundling is a technique whereby the facility, in this case the hospital, gets reimbursed for

what the third party payer believes is the full cost of the care delivered, then leaving to

the hospital the responsibility of distributing the funds to the participating providers as it

sees fit. We believe the policy of allowing a hospital to control who to pay and how

21 Anna Wilde Mathews, Health-Care Providers, Insurers Supersize, The Wall Street Journal, Sept. 21, 2015, http://www.wsj.com/articles/health-care-providers-insurers-supersize-1442850400 on September 23, 2015.

26

Page 27: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

much to be an ominous threat to the independent practice of medicine and to patient

autonomy.

The Florida legislature can counteract the tendencies of hospital-centered

oligopolies by requiring that only physicians or dentists possess any ownership interests

in Florida's outpatient clinics22 and by prohibiting the bundling of payments to Florida's

health care providers.

Legislative Opportunity: Require that only physicians or dentists own outpatient

medical or dental practices. The Florida legislature should also prohibit the bundling of

payments to health care providers within the state.

C. Promote quality enhancers in Florida: The quality of health care delivery must remain

unparalleled in the nation.

1. Enhance the robustness of the oversight of the Board of Medicine. The legislature

ought to tighten up the guidelines by which failing health care providers are sanctioned so

as to minimize the presence of dangerous practitioners within the state.

Legislative opportunity: Promote tighter oversight of health care boards over practitioners.

2. Implement measures to cut down on Medicaid fraud. Medicaid fraud represents a

significant drain on taxpayer dollars. We strongly favor and encourage attempts by the

Florida Legislature to improve the ability for law enforcement to detect, prosecute, and

22 This is the same standard maintained by Florida's lawyers.

27

Page 28: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

punish those who engage in what is essentially the theft of the people's money for their

personal and illegal gain.

Legislative Opportunities: Explore and implement methods to detect, stop, and

punish Medicaid fraud perpetrators.

28

Page 29: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

In closing, we once again express our anticipation at seeing the results of the work

you are about to undertake and thank you for taking the time to review our ideas. We

look forward to the prospect of interacting with you in committee and hope that together

we may promote the betterment of our great state. Please let us know if we may be of

any assistance in this endeavor.

Sincerely,

Representative Julio Gonzalez Representative Fred CostelloDistrict 74 District 25

29

Page 30: Gonzalez Costello Open Letter 10012015

30