(gauteng division, pretoria) pretoria this 18th day of ... · mr ahmed timol will resume in the...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA)
PRETORIA THIS 18TH
DAY OF AUGUST 2017
FRIDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN SETLALE CC 151/16
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM
IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA THOMO CC 31/14
IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN LEKALAKALA CC 46/17
Page 2 of 20
URGENT COURT
IN COURT B AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN IN COURT C AT 10:00 PALACE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLEFE
FULL COURT CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE COLLIS
Name of Advocate for the State : Van der Merwe/ Voster
No. Case no. Name of Appellant
1. A8/17 Z Zulu
2. A287/16 Z C Mndebele
3. A843/16 R T Muyayi
Page 3 of 20
LAW SOCIETY MATTERS
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SKOSANA AJ
LAW SOCIETY VS JAN HENDRIK VILJOEN 24661/16
LAW SOCIETY VS ALLEN WILLIAM YOUNG 85251/16
ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE
1. R.BVUMBI ADV 44922/17
2. L. G MARX ADV 40355/17
3. B. M HLUNGWANI ADV 40335/17
4. P. N MOCWINI ATT 18806/17
5. N D MALALE ATT 47870/17
6. T. P SITHOLE ATT 44304/17
Page 4 of 20
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MALI BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SKOSANA AJ
7. K. K MALOME ADV 42330/17
8. I. GYARMATI ATT 44677/17
9. R.GARLIPP ATT 43416/17
10. N. K ZONDO ATT 46626/17
11. J. C PANDARO ATT 44723/17
12. J. K LAWRENCE ATT 45150/17
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 9;15 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MADIMA AJ IN COURT 2C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOGAGABE AJ
Page 5 of 20
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA IN COURT8F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MPHAHLELE IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAUTENBACH AJ IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTEPE AJ IN COURT 8C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWANEPOEL AJ
JUDGMENT
IN COURT 6D AT 10H00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA THE COMPENSATION FUND v HEADLINE CONSULTING (PTY) LTD t/a THSWANE AIR CASE NO: 92504/2015
CRIMSON KING PROPERTIES v J P WRIGHT & ANOTHER CASE NO: 38645/2015
Page 6 of 20
H D NAUDE & ANOTHER v J P WRIGHT CASE NO:
48306/2011
IN COURT 8G AT 10H00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE ACTING JUSTICE WANLESS
CASE 54245/16 JJP COMBO VS PL OLIVIER
IN COURT 8C AT 10h00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE SWANEPOEL AJ
1. HR ASSOCIATES v SARS 83546/15
2. CAMM TRANSPORT CC v GUMA GROUP +3 27337/15
3. HOER VOLKSKOOL HEIDELBERG v SAFTA PROPERTIES 80658/16
4.
5. IN COURT 4D AT 11:30
6. BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS
MOTI + 3 VS PRESIDENT OF RSA + 4 52776/2017
IN COURT 4A AT 09:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOLLAPEN
MAKAULA ZILWA INC & ANOTHER v BUSHBUCKRIDGE LOCAL MUNICIPALITY (4051A/2015)
IN COURT 4G AT 10;00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES J
CASE: 59677/16 BRAGAN CHEMICALS (PTY) LTD // SEASON FLAVOUR MANUFACTURERS CC
Page 7 of 20
CASE: 27161/16
RABIA MAHOMED N.O +1 OTHER // BHIKA KASSE t/a PATEL AND COMPANY
IN COURT 8E AT 9,00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DJP LEDWABA
MINISTER OF FINANCE / OAKBAY INVESTMENTS AND OTHERS - CASE NUMBER 80978/2016
IN COURT 8A AT 11.30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTEPE
1. Caroline Molekwa v RAF 54601/16 2. SM Luma v Minister of Police 90769/16 3. AO Chavez v K Kabongo 12285/17
LEAVE TO APPEALS
IN COURT 4A AT 09:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KOLLAPEN DR BRANDALINE KWENA KHOELE vs THE MINISTER OF DEFENCE AND MILITARY VETERANS & TWO OTHERS (25801/2016) IN COURT 6D AT 09H00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA THUPANE JOSEPH MAKGOKABA & OTHERS
v
MPONYANA LAZARUS LEDWABA N.O & OTHERS CASE NO: 16046/2017
IN COURT 6D AT 09H30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA
Page 8 of 20
KARIBA FURNISHER MANUGACTURER (PTY) LTD
v NORTH WEST DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION (PTY) LTD CASE NO: 73504/2014
INQUEST
IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 INQUEST UNTILL 14- 18 AUGUST BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE Mr Ahmed Timol will resume in the Pretoria High Court on Monday 24 July 2013 and will continue until Friday 18 Aug
PART HEARD MATTERS
IN COURT 6B 9;30 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE MAVUNDLA J
CASE NO.: 27826/2012
Ngululu Bulk Carriers (Pty) Ltd Plaintiff V The Premier of the Limpopo Provincial Government 1st Defendant
The Mec for Roads and Transport of the Limpopo Provincial Government 2nd Defendant
Page 9 of 20
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE IN COURT 6E AT 10:00(FROM 31/07/17 TO 25/08/17) BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAKGOKA IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JW LOUW IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI IN COURT 4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES
3RD
COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOKOSE AJ
Page 10 of 20
CIVIL NOTE
1 PLEASE TAKE NOTE OF THE FOLLOWING
2 MAKE SURE IF A MATTER IS REMOVED THAT COURT RULE 41 APPLIES AND NEEDS TO BE SERVED AND FILLED AT ROOM 7.40
3 IF A MATTER STANDS DOWN TO A DATE TO BE ALLOCATED/ OR POSTPONED
PLEASE UPLIFT THE FILE IN COURT AND BRING IT TO ROOM 7.40 THE TRAIL ROLLS CLOSE EVERY DAY AT 12 NOON 2 WORKING DAYS BEFORE THE HEARING DATE NO LATE FILLING
THE PRACTICE NOTE NEEDS TO BE STAPLED INTO THE LEFT SIDE OF THE FILE
CIVIL TRIALS ALLOCATIONS ONLY
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P AA C SWEENEY VS RAF P/P/21/6 44773/14 BB N MBELE VS RAF P/P/21/6 27164/16 CC J M SEKHOHOLA VS RAF P/P8/8 37303/15 DD J MASEKO VS RAF P/P15/8 21501/13 EE J E MASILELA VS RAF P/P21/06 2124/14 FF M MOODLEY VS RAF P/P4/8 89636/14 GG A J VISSER VS RAF P/P 15/8 1985/16 HH A K MUKASI VS RAF P/P 15/8 59347/16 II K RAMAWELA ` ` VS RAF PP 16/8/17 85423/15 JJ B P MAZIBUKO VS RAF 81227/14
Page 11 of 20
CIVIL TRIAL DRAFT ORDERS
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P A M M MAELANE VS RAF 46883/14 B M J THOBEJANE VS RAF 1499/12 C F CHAUKE VS RAF 31992/13 D M L LEHABA VS RAF 45937/13 E GS NKOSI VS RAF 30897/14 F E MACHATE VS RAF 2159/14 G T SIZANI VS RAF 28987/16 H L J PHETLA VS RAF 89187/15 I C FAKU VS RAF 67756/13 J N B BUTHELEZI VS RAF `` 41052/16 K M A BONGO VS RAF 25326/16 L N E MAKOFANE VS RAF 2816/16 M E GOUWS VS` RAF 95468/16 N T G MOALUSI VS RAF 81043/16 O ADV JJ SCHERMAN VS RAF 94718/15 P N MAPHANGA VS RAF 14193/13 Q H D MACEBELE VS RAF 84936/16 R MASINGITA M SIDUNA VS RAF 43026/16
Page 12 of 20
PRETORIA THIS 18TH DAY OF AUGUST 2017
CIVIL TRIALS IN COURT8E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AP LEDWABA DJ
1 BM KOBOLA VS RAF NO FILE
22883/16 NP
2 NB MAKHAYE VS RAF MERITS 57870/16
3 MADIGAGA JM VS RAF 37087/16
4 DT MAHLOELE VS RAF MERITS 60388/16
5 DC SANGWENI obo A KHUMALO VS RAF MERITS 58290/16
6 C GILDNER obo N MTHETHWA&T MFUNISI VS RAF MERITS 39232/16
7 CF GATES VS RAF MERITS 31810/15
8 SG MASONDO VS RAF NO FILE 40290/16NP
9 T MOLOI VS RAF NO FILE 40288/16NP
10 NKABINDE G L VS RAF 51322/15
11 MM MAMARU VS RAF MERITS 47516/16
12 AM MAMPANA VS RAF MERITS 13204/16
13 SB ZULU VS RAF MERITS 51111/15
14 BG TUMELO VS RAF MERITS 86329/15
Page 13 of 20
15 EM LEBEANE VS RAF MERITS 34958/15
16. MT SOKHULU VS RAF MERITS 56451/16
17 TL NEMARANZHE VS RAF MERITS 89972/15
18 VK NAYAGAR VS RAF MERITS 10523/16
19 V T NGOEPE VS RAF MERITS
55083/13
20 K M PHELADI VS RAF 37565/13
21 T L MARAIS VS RAF 69943/15
22 RP VAN DE MERWE VS RAF MERITS 93080/15
23 S MPHETSOA VS RAF MERITS 28217/14
24 BJ LETSELEBE VS RAF MERITS 23419/16
25 MBB PARUK VS RAF MERITS 23635/16
26 KP MASHABA obo AM VS RAF MERITS 23634/16
27 SE MADONSELA VS RAF MERITS 48915/16
28 A JONKER +BJ VS RAF MERITS 18098/16
29 DH ADAMS VS RAF MERITS 44535/15
30 EM MASHINININI VS RAF MERITS 59387/14
31 J MAHLANGU VS RAF MERITS 6169/16
32 JM PULE VS RAF MERITS 2997/15
Page 14 of 20
33 M C MABASO VS RAF 53991/16
34 PM MKHWANAZI VS RAF MERITS 41885/15
35 LG TSOKOLO VS RAF MERITS 24608/16
36 LS KUBHEKA VS RAF MERITS 2690/16
37 DL KROUKAMP VS RAF MERITS 57355/16
38 S HELGA VS RAF MERITS 42978/16
39 BOPAPE MMS VS RAF 4211/16
40 LS MOTLOUNG VS RAF MERITS REMOVED 28757/16
41 MUDAU AH VS RAF CERIFICATE 56328/15
42 LEGODU LB VS RAF NO FILE 4891/14NP
43. BOOYSEN WHP VS RAF CERTIFICATE 30828/15
44 VAN STADEN SF VS RAF CERTIFICATE 46436/15
45 B NDLOVU VS RAF CERTIFICATE 35746/15
46 PL VAN MOLENDORE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 46 06/15
47 GURA TT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 19031/15
48 LAAS M VS RAF NO FILE 24794/15NP
49 MASEKO DJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 14241/12
50 NHLAPO NE VS RAF CRTIFICATE 72134/12
Page 15 of 20
51 SHONGWE MC VS RAF CERTIFICATE 24124/10
52 TESSNELL DL VS RAF CERIFICATE 50901/14
53 MEYER DM VS RAF CERTIFICATE 22510/4
54 MOSTERT ME VS RAF CERTIFICATE 29278/14
55 RAPHALA EJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 989/14
56 RJ VAN DER MERWE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 10341/14
57 MAVUNDLA SL VS RAF CERTIFICATE 22343/15
58 MOTLHWEKENG NE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 62196/15
59 MOTHIBE PS VS RAF CERTIFICATE 15520/15
60. ENGEKBRECHT G VS RAF CERTIFICATE 19185/13
61 J VAN ROMBURGER VS RAF CERIFICATE 28973/15
62 SUVHADA CT VS RAF CERTIFICATE 16785/15
63 MATHABATHA MC VS RAF CERTIFICATE 12327/15
64 TEKANE D VS RAF CERTIFICATE 22198/12
65 SIMELANE ME VS RAF CERTIFICATE 8160/16
66 M AUGUST VS RAF NO FILE 8334/13NP
67. NGUBENI ZM obo SE DLAMINI VS RAF CERIFICATE REMOVED 68238/15
68 M YOLANDIE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 71102/13
Page 16 of 20
69 STUANTON MP VS RAF CERTIFICATE 67337/15
70 MOTAUNG ML VS RAF CERTIFICATE 66257/15
71 P A MOABI VS RAF NO FILE 26757/15NP
72 E MPNRELA VS RAF NO FILE 96667/16NP
73 MONAMA SHAUN VS MIN OF POLICE 41720/14
74 T A BOIKANYO VS RAF NO FILE 8749/15NP
75 S P MOKHUTSOQNE VS RAF CERT 70738/15
76 M KGOLOKO VS RAF NO FILE 57565/13NP
77 H POUWELS VS RAF NO FILE 60255/10NP
78 M SANGO VS RAF NO FILE 6083/12NP
79 V M MULAUDZI VS RAF CER 59721/12
80 S JACOBS VS RAF CERT 9615/14
81 ZACHEM DIV PTY LTD VS INSAL METAL CIVIL 91076/15
82 MAMPONE SEC VS MEM OF EXEC CIVIL 90965/15
83 S K NONYANE VS RAF 37840/12
84 S MAGOMA VS RAF CERT 17692/15
85 M COLLINS VS THE MIN OF SAFETY & SEC CIVIL 57842/12
86 M SMUTS VS THE MIN OF JUSTICE +1 CIVIL 24110/12
Page 17 of 20
87 MV DLAMINI VS MIN OF P-OLICE CIVIL 10894/13
88 M S MOHLALOGANYE VS RAF 50020
89 PREMIDIA VS EVEREST LEAD NO FILE 23961/16NP
90 XDP ELECTRICAL VS MEND WALLS REMOVED 98268/15
91 CAR CARTWRIGHT VS THE MIN OF DEFENCE NO FILE 23209/16NP
92 CH KRUGER +1 OTHER VS K KRUGER +4 OTHERS 86471/15
93 S ASANDE obo LC HAKUERI VS
THE MIN OF POLICE +2 OTHERS NO FILE 34706/14NP
94 M MUNAMATO VS
THE MIN OF POLICE +1 OTHER CIVIL 18756/15
95 B RADEBE VS MIN OF POLICE + 1 OTHER REMOVED 16581/12
96 DT MAGEZA VS THE MIN OF SAFETY & SEC CIVIL 70310/09
97 STD VS VD ALBERT CIVIL 34427/14
98 MC MASHABELA VS MIN OF HIGHER EDUCATION NO FILE 12180/15NP
99 MM MOLEFE VS V MOLEFE CIVIL 81552/15
100 T SETATI VS RAF CIVIL 27754/16
101 MS MATSHEO VS RAF CERT 4315/13
102 X MATHA VS RAF CERT 87544/15
103 MJ SEHOSANA VS RAF SERT 63062/12
Page 18 of 20
104 SALAN A O VS RAF 47800/14
105 MMEBE VS RAF 58369/14
106 M NTHANE VS RAF SERT 8337/16
107 VM SAMBO VS RAF 14441/13
108 B C CHILOANE VS RAF 13855/13
109 L S KHOZA VS RAF 25594/14
110 L S THOBEJANE VS RAF 44799/11
111 NAUME MS VS RAF 34900/16
112 LE ROUX VS RAF 10498/15
113 JANSE VAN NIEWENHUYS VS RAF 68190/15
114 J W HEIDENREICH VS RAF NO FILE 5535/10NP
115 S NDLOVU VS RAF 67947/15
116 STORM AG VS RAF 16624/15
117 C A MANHISE VS RAF 3500/16 NP
118 MACHAKA SM VS RAF 63030/16
119 BT SHABALALA VS MIN OF POLICE 10089/16
120 K V MOLAMU VS RAF 50315/15
121 APHANE T I VS RAF NO FILE 85350/14NP
122 T E BALOYI VS RAF 25156/11
123 T G MOALUSI VS RAF NO FILE 81043/16NP
124 M L MOBENI VS RAF 61416/15
125 T M UOANE VS RAF 78959/15
126 MOTHAPO RR VS RAF 81185/14
127 MABENA S M VS RAF CERT 24492/16
128 APHANE TI VS RAF NO FILE 85350/14NP
129 TSHAZI VS RAF 51772/15
Page 19 of 20
130 CM MOTHLE VS RAF NO FILE 5399/16NP
131 MASANABO E H VS RAF 13119/15
132 MBONGWA N VS RAF REMOVED 75652/14
133 N J LAAS VS RAF CERT 54795/15
134 L MAKONERO VS RAF NO FILE 12301/15NP
CIVIL COURT JUDGES
IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BASSON IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JACOBS AJ IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HAWYES AJ IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MILLER AJ
Page 20 of 20
COURTS AVAILABLE