fundamentals of soil mechanics for sedimentary and residual soils (wesley/fundamentals soil...

17
CHAPTER 4 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND 4.1 VERTICAL STRESS IN THE GROUND Consider a site where the ground is level. If we drill a hole in the ground, we will normally find that at some point the soil will become wetter and water will start to flow into the hole. If we leave the hole for some time, the water level will rise and then become stable. The depth at which this occurs is known as the groundwater level or, more commonly, the water table. This is illustrated in Figure 4.1. We can determine the stress state on the soil element shown at depth D . We will assume that the unit weight of the soil is γ and is the same above and below the water table. This will normally be the case if the soil is clay in a temperate climate but may not be the case in a dry climate or if the soil is a coarse silt or sand. The vertical stress on the element is given by σ v = γ D , where σ v is the total vertical stress on the soil element. It is called the total stress because it is the stress resulting from the total weight of material above it. We can also determine a second stress acting at depth D . This is the pressure in the water contained in the void space (or pore space) of the soil. This pressure is called the pore water pressure or just the pore pressure. This void space is totally interconnected so that in this situation, with a level water table, the pore pressure is hydrostatic and is given by: u = γ w (D H w ) where u is the pore pressure and γ w is the unit weight of water. 49 Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils Laurence D. Wesley Copyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN: 978-0-470-37626-3

Upload: laurence-d

Post on 06-Jun-2016

217 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

CHAPTER 4

STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATEIN THE GROUND

4.1 VERTICAL STRESS IN THE GROUND

Consider a site where the ground is level. If we drill a hole in the ground,we will normally find that at some point the soil will become wetter andwater will start to flow into the hole. If we leave the hole for some time,the water level will rise and then become stable. The depth at which thisoccurs is known as the groundwater level or, more commonly, the watertable. This is illustrated in Figure 4.1.

We can determine the stress state on the soil element shown at depth D .We will assume that the unit weight of the soil is γ and is the same aboveand below the water table. This will normally be the case if the soil is clayin a temperate climate but may not be the case in a dry climate or if thesoil is a coarse silt or sand.

The vertical stress on the element is given by σv = γD , where σv is thetotal vertical stress on the soil element. It is called the total stress becauseit is the stress resulting from the total weight of material above it.

We can also determine a second stress acting at depth D . This is thepressure in the water contained in the void space (or pore space) of the soil.This pressure is called the pore water pressure or just the pore pressure. Thisvoid space is totally interconnected so that in this situation, with a levelwater table, the pore pressure is hydrostatic and is given by:

u = γw(D − Hw) where u is the pore pressure andγw is the unit weight of water.

49Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils Laurence D. WesleyCopyright © 2009 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. ISBN: 978-0-470-37626-3

Page 2: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

50 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

D

Hw

Ground surface

Water table

Drilled hole

Equilibrium level ofwater in hole

Soil unit weight = γ

Soilelement

Figure 4.1 Water table and stress state in the ground.

The difference between these two stresses is called the effective stress,that is,

σ′ = σv − u = γD − γw(D − Hw)

where σ′ is the effective vertical stress.This relationship between total stress, pore pressure, and effective stress

applies generally within the soil mass, not just in the vertical direction, andis normally written simply as

σ′ = σ − u (4.1)

Equation 4.1 is undoubtedly the most important equation in soil mechan-ics, as it expresses a concept known as the principle of effective stress,which will be covered more fully in Chapter 6. This principle states thatsoil behavior is governed by effective stress and not by total stress. Defor-mation, compression, or changes in strength of the soil only occur as aresult of changes in effective stress, not changes in total stress, althoughchanges in the latter may well cause changes in the former. To predicthow soil will behave in any particular situation, it is essential to considerhow the effective stresses are changing. This will become clear in laterchapters.

4.2 PORE PRESSURES ABOVE WATER TABLEAND SEASONAL VARIATIONS

Although it might be thought that the pore pressure above the water tablewill be zero, this is not normally the case. The pore spaces between the soil

Page 3: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

PORE PRESSURES ABOVE WATER TABLE AND SEASONAL VARIATIONS 51

particles act as fine tubes and water is drawn into this space, or retained init, by capillarity or surface tension forces. In a fine-grained soil, made upentirely of clay-sized particles (smaller than 0.002 mm), the effective poresize will be about 20 percent of this, which is 0.0004 mm. The theoreticalcapillary rise in such a material would be about 75 m. With most fine-grainedsoils water will thus not drain out of their void space under gravity forces.It is only when the material is of fine sand size that water will begin todrain out of the pore space from gravity forces alone. Even in fine sand,drainage will be limited, and considerable water will still remain in the voidspace. Only in course sands and gravels will water drain almost completelyfrom the pore space.

Measurements in the field have shown that many clays remain fullysaturated for many meters or tens of meters above the water table, andonly in the top 1 or 2 m is the soil less than fully saturated. This partialsaturation occurs not because of gravity drainage downward, but because ofwater loss by evaporation at the surface. The pore pressure and saturationstate in relation to the water table are illustrated in Figure 4.2. The porepressure shown is the hydrostatic or equilibrium state, the pore pressurebeing negative above the water table and positive below it. No seepageflow occurs in this state.

The depth of the partially saturated zone is governed by the particlesize of the soil and the climatic conditions. In areas with temperate or wetclimates, the depth of the partially saturated zone in clay is unlikely to bemore than 1 or 2 m below the surface. However, for dry climates this depthcould be meters or tens of meters.

Par

tially

satu

rate

dzo

neF

ully

sat

urat

ed z

one

Water table

Ground surface

Saturation boundary for a

fine grained soil (clay)

Saturation boundary for a coarsegrained soil (silty sand, fine sand)

Neg

ativ

e po

re p

ress

ure

Pos

itive

por

epr

essu

re

Saturation boundary for a medium

grained soil (silty clay or silt)

PositiveNegativePore water pressure

a

b

u = − γwa

u = γwb

Hydrostatic(equilibrium)

pore pressure

Figure 4.2 Pore pressure and saturation states in relation to the water table.

Page 4: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

52 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

The pore pressure state above the water table tends not to receive muchattention in soil mechanics, possibly because it is not of great importancewith sedimentary soils. However, with residual soils, the pore pressure stateabove the water table is of considerable importance for two reasons. First,the water table is often deep and the zone of prime interest to geotechnicalengineers is above the water table. Second, the high permeability of manyresidual soils means that seasonal changes in pore pressure can be verysignificant and govern the behavior of the soil. For these reasons, the porepressure state above the water table, and the way it is influenced by climateseasons, is described in some detail in the following sections.

4.2.1 Case A: Coarse-Grained Soils

Case A is the simplest case and is illustrated in Figure 4.3. Sand (or gravel)acts like a “reservoir” into which water flows under gravity during wetweather, causing the water level to rise and from which water is lost byevaporation during dry weather with an accompanying drop in the watertable. Below the water table the soil is fully saturated and the pore pressurestate is hydrostatic. Above the water table the soil has a very low (almostzero) degree of saturation, and the pore pressure is essentially zero. Seasonalchanges extend at least to the bottom of the sand layer. In many situations,the water table in the sand may be governed by external controls, such as theproximity of a river, rather than by the influence of weather at the surface.We should note in passing that with coarse-grained soils the soil propertiesgoverning the way the water table changes with seasons are the perme-ability and the porosity (storage capacity) of the soil. These are describedin Chapter 7.

Negative

Water table

Hydrostatic pore pressurebelow the water table

Water table

NegativePositive PositivePORE PRESSURE PORE PRESSURE

Water trickles downwardtoward water table

WET WEATHER STATE- rainfall on ground surface

DRY WEATHER STATE- evaporation at surface

Water tablevariation

Water evaporates andtravels upward towardthe surface

Figure 4.3 Seasonal variation in water table and pore pressures: coarse-grainedsoil.

Page 5: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

PORE PRESSURES ABOVE WATER TABLE AND SEASONAL VARIATIONS 53

4.2.2 Case B: Low-Permeability Clays

Low-permeability clays are at the opposite end of the spectrum tocoarse-grained soils. Because of their low permeability the seasonalinfluence is not deep and may not reach the water table, as illustrated inFigure 4.4.

During dry weather, water is lost by evaporation at the surface, causingthe pore pressure to become more negative and water to flow toward thesurface. The ground shrinks and a zone close to the surface may becomepartially saturated. During wet weather, the pore pressure is zero (or veryslightly positive) at the surface, and water will enter the soil and seepdownward. The soil will gradually absorb water and swelling will occur.The equilibrium state shown in Figure 4.4 is a transient state that can beexpected to occur briefly during the year when the seasons are changing.Most heavily overconsolidated sedimentary clays, such as London clay,belong in case B.

4.2.3 Case C: Medium- to High-Permeability Clays

Case C is intermediate between the above two and is illustrated inFigure 4.5. The seasonal influence now extends beyond the water table,which rises in the summer and falls in the winter. The pore pressure is

Negative

Water table (constant)

Dry weatherstate

Wet weatherstate

Positive

Zone of negativepore pressureEquilibrium (hydrostatic)

pore pressure state

Limiting values of porepressure change

Depth limit of seasonal changes

PORE PRESSURE

Figure 4.4 Seasonal variation in water table and pore pressures: low-permeabilityclay.

Page 6: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

54 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

Negative

Winter water table

Summer water table

Dry season: hydraulicgradient upward

- seepage upward

Wet season: hydraulicgradient downward

- seepage downward

Positive

Hydrostatic(equilibrium)

state

PORE PRESSURE

Water tablevariation

PLimit of seasonal changes

Average water table

Figure 4.5 Seasonal variation in water table and pore pressure: moderate- tohigh-permeability clay.

hydrostatic with respect to the average position of the water table, whichwill occur from time to time, especially midway between the wet and dryseasons. At other times the pore pressure will not be hydrostatic, eitherbelow or above the water table. The term “hydraulic gradient,” used in thefigure, can be ignored at this stage. It governs the direction and rate ofseepage flow and is explained fully in Chapter 7.

We should note the following with respect to cases B and C:

(a) There is a limit to the depth influenced by seasonal effects.(b) The governing parameters are the permeability and compressibility

of the soil or, in their combined form, the coefficient of consolida-tion. These are described fully in Chapter 8.

(c) The pore pressure is not necessarily hydrostatic below (or above) thewater table, except transiently in the “average” situation between theextremes caused by the seasonal influence.

The pattern of behavior illustrated in Figures 4.4 and 4.5 is essentiallytheoretical, based on the seepage and consolidation principles presented inChapters 7 and 8. Field evidence confirming this pattern has been obtainedfrom measurements on a number of sites, such as, for example, Kennyand Lau (1984), Urciuoli (1998), and Pun and Urciuoli (2008). Pun and

Page 7: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

HILL SLOPES, SEEPAGE, AND PORE PRESSURES 55

Dry

sea

son

Wet

sea

son

Time

Dep

th

Pore pressure changeswith time and depth

Limit of seasonal changes

Cha

ngin

g (t

rans

ient

)po

re p

ress

ures

Constant (steady state)pore pressures

Figure 4.6 Decline of seasonal pore pressure variation with depth. (Adapted fromPun and Urciuoli, 2008)

Urciuoli (2008) installed piezometers at three different depths at a site inItaly and recorded pore pressures over a 10-year period. These show regularseasonal changes which progressively decrease with depth; they are shownconceptually in Figure 4.6.

This is the same behavior as portrayed in Figure 4.5 presented in adifferent form. We can note that the behavior in Figure 4.6 is not relatedto any particular water table position. The water table could be below thelimit of seasonal changes or could be fluctuating within the zone of seasonalchanges.

4.3 HILL SLOPES, SEEPAGE, AND PORE PRESSURES

In the previous section we considered only level sites and assumed nohorizontal movement of water. In most natural situations this will not be thecase. The ground will be sloping and the water table will also be sloping.This means water will be continually seeping through the ground in the“downhill” direction. Figure 4.7 illustrates the situation for a clay slope

Page 8: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

56 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

Zone of infiltration from

rainfall on ground surface

See

page

com

ing

from

adj

acen

t cat

chm

ent

Water table (variable)

Seepage emerging

at the ground surface

Limit of seasonal changes

Figure 4.7 Seepage in a hillside coming from direct rainfall and from an adjacentcatchment.

assumed to be fully saturated, except possibly for a shallow zone at thesurface. Where seepage is occurring in a horizontal direction, especially inman-made structures such as earth dams, the term phreatic surface is oftenused in place of water table.

Water enters the upper part of the slope from two possible sources. One issurface rainfall, and the other is seepage from an adjacent rainfall catchment.Water emerges again at the lower part of the slope and the valley floor andcontributes to the flow in the streams and rivers normally found in valleys.The dotted arrows indicate the likely seepage pattern. Although this is anaccurate portrayal of the general shape of the seepage pattern in a hill slope,it is not strictly correct near the ground surface. The slope will be subjectto the same seasonal influences described in the previous section for levelsites, which will result in continuous changes to the seepage pattern, atleast close to the surface. Near the ground surface, the flow will fluctuatebetween upward and downward, depending on the weather (or the season),in the same way as for level sites. As for level sites, there will be a lowerlimit to the zone of seasonal changes, as indicated in the figure.

4.4 SIGNIFICANCE OF THE WATER TABLE (OR PHREATIC SURFACE)

The significance of the water table (or phreatic surface) in fine-grained soilsshould be clearly understood. In particular, the following points should benoted:

Page 9: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

HORIZONTAL STRESS IN GROUND 57

(a) The water table is not a boundary line below which the soil is fullysaturated and above which it is unsaturated or partially saturated.

(b) It is not a boundary below which seepage is occurring and abovewhich there is no seepage.

(c) It is simply a line of zero (atmospheric) pore pressure, below whichpore pressures are positive and above which they are negative.

(d) The water table therefore does not constitute a discontinuity in theseepage pattern. Seepage occurs in a continuous fashion above andbelow the water table according to the same physical laws (providedthe soil remains fully saturated). These laws are described later inChapter 7.

(e) If the soil consists of coarse material, such as sand or gravel, then thesituation is different, as water will drain out of the sand above thewater table. In this special case the water table will be the upper limitof the seepage zone.

(f) To understand the seepage situation in any slope, it is not sufficientto measure only the depth of the water table. Measurements of porepressure need to be made at a number of locations over a period oftime to get an accurate picture.

4.5 HORIZONTAL STRESS IN GROUND

There are situations in geotechnical engineering when it is necessary, or atleast useful, to know the magnitude of the horizontal stress in the ground.Deep excavations and tunneling are examples of such situations. A numberof factors affect the value of the horizontal stress, and there are no simpleways of knowing what the value may be in any particular situation. It isaffected by the type of soil, the way the soil has been formed, and anyfurther stresses the soil has been subjected to after formation.

The relationship between the horizontal stress and the vertical stress ina natural soil deposit is usually expressed as a value of Ko , called thecoefficient of earth pressure at rest:

Ko = σh′/σv

′ (4.2)

The terms “at rest” or the “Ko state” are used to describe a situationwhere the soil is restrained in the horizontal direction so that no lateraldeformation can occur. This is the case with a sedimentary soil formed bydeposition in a marine or lake environment. Because sedimentation occursover a wide area, no significant horizontal deformation can occur. Verticalcompression occurs because of the stress from the increasing thickness ofthe deposit.

However, the term Ko can also be used somewhat loosely to indicate thehorizontal stress in the ground even if this stress is caused by factors such

Page 10: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

58 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

Effective vertical stress (σ′v )

Effe

ctiv

e ho

rizon

tal s

tres

s (σ

′ h )

Loading

Unloadingσ′h =

σ′v

Figure 4.8 Relationship between horizontal and vertical effective stresses duringloading and unloading of a soil in a Ko condition (no horizontal deformation).

as tectonic movement, in which case the condition of zero lateral movementno longer applies

The way in which the horizontal stress relates to the vertical stress inthis situation is illustrated in Figure 4.8. As the vertical load increases, thehorizontal stress also increases, but at a much lower rate. The relationshipis close to linear and the value of Ko in this situation is usually betweenabout 0.3 and 0.5. This is in reasonable accordance with expectations fromelastic theory, which predicts the following relationship between Ko andPoisson’s ratio:

Ko = υ′

1 − υ′ where υ′ is Poisson′s ratio (4.3)

Poisson’s ratio for soils is normally between about 0.2 and 0.4, giv-ing Ko values from 0.25 to 0.67. Experimental measurements on sand andnormally consolidated clay suggest the following relationship between Koand the angle of shearing resistance (friction angle) φ′ of the material. Anexplanation of the angle of shearing resistance is given in Chapter 9:

Ko = 1 − sin φ′, where φ′ is the friction angle (4.4)

In some situations the soil layers may undergo up-lift as a result oftectonic forces followed by erosion. The vertical stress on the soil is reducedand the soil becomes overconsolidated, as described in Chapter 1. Duringreduction in vertical stress the soil does not behave elastically and thehorizontal stress does not decrease in proportion to the decrease in thevertical stress. Initially the decrease in horizontal stress is much less than thedecrease in vertical stress, as indicated by the unloading line in Figure 4.8.As unloading continues, the horizontal stress may become equal to the

Page 11: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

HORIZONTAL STRESS IN GROUND 59

vertical stress and then exceed the vertical stress. Measurements in heavilyoverconsolidated clays have indicated Ko values as high as 3.

In residual soils the situation is quite different and less predictable,and there is very little information on Ko values. It is possible to makesome comments based on intuition and an understanding of the weather-ing process. Generally, the weathering process that forms residual soilsis accompanied by some loss of material and a reduction in the stiff-ness and strength of the material. Removal of material tends to relieveany “locked-in” stresses in the soil or its parent material. There may wellbe horizontal stresses in the parent material caused by formation processes.

Vaughan and Kwan (1984) suggest a theoretical method of analysis toinvestigate the possible influence of weathering on the horizontal stress.They postulate a decrease in stiffness and strength of the material as weath-ering progresses and analyze the influence of this on the stress state, makinguse mainly of elastic theory concepts. In summary, their analysis suggeststhat the influence of the initial horizontal stress in the parent rock dis-appears quite early in the weathering process, and the stress state tendstowards the “at-rest” Ko value given by simple elastic theory, expressed inEquation 4.3 Because Poisson’s ratio is likely to be quite low, especiallyin weakly cemented material, the value of the horizontal stress is likely tobe low.

In contrast to the above, if the principal effect of the weathering processis the removal of cementing material and the release of active clay minerals,the opposite trend may occur. The active clay minerals may take in waterand swell, causing an increase in horizontal stress. This may well be thecase with some mudstones and shales. Figure 4.9 illustrates the way theparameter Ko can vary with time in sedimentary and residual soils.

2

1

0

Parentrock

Time

Weathering of igneous rocks

Sedimentarysoil

Deposition stage(of sedimentary soil)

Uplift and unloading stage(of sedimentary soil)

Ko

(rat

io o

f effe

ctiv

e ho

rizon

tal

stre

ss to

effe

ctiv

e ve

rtic

al s

tres

s)

?

?

Residual soils

Weathering of rocks containing clay mineral

Figure 4.9 Possible changes in Ko with time in sedimentary and residual soils.

Page 12: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

60 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

Zone of high horizontal stressbuttressing the valley slopes

Zone of low horizontalstress, or even atension zone

Soil tends to moveor “creep” down the slopes

Ground surfa

ce

Figure 4.10 Influence of topography on the horizontal stress state in the ground.

There are other factors that influence the magnitude of the horizontalstress in both sedimentary and residual soils and possibly lead to situationswhere the horizontal stress may exceed the vertical stress. For example,tectonic movement may be forcing one land block against another, induc-ing very large horizontal stresses. Also, at the base of valleys the naturaltendency for soil on the slope to slide toward the bottom means that hori-zontal stresses are likely to be higher at the base of valleys where the soilis buttressing the soil on the slopes. This is illustrated in Figure 4.10.

Similarly, at the crest of slopes the horizontal stress is likely to be verylow, and in some cases a zone of tension may develop where Ko would bezero or even tending to be negative.

Returning to Figure 4.1 and the stress state on the soil element at depthD , we can calculate the horizontal stresses as follows:

Total vertical stress σv = γD

u = γw(D − Hw)

σ′v = σv − u = γD − γw(d − Hw)

Horizontal effective stress σ′h = Koσ

′v

Total horizontal stress σh = σ′h + u

Thusσh = Ko σv

′ + u (4.5)

4.6 WORKED EXAMPLES

4.6.1 Worked Example 1

Figure 4.11 shows a sand layer overlying a clay layer below which solidrock is found. The unit weights of the materials are shown. Note that theunit weight of the sand is less above the water table than below it. This is

Page 13: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

WORKED EXAMPLES 61

Sand γ = 18.2 kN/m3

Ko = 0.35

Sand γ = 21.5 kN/m3

Ko = 0.35

Clay γ = 16.4 kN/m3

Ko = 0.48

Ground surface

Water table

Hard rock

2.5 m

3 m

3 m

Figure 4.11 Soil conditions for worked example 1.

because in a coarse material such as sand some water drains from the voidspace above the water table. The sand above the water table is thus partiallysaturated. Determine the total stress, pore pressure, and effective stress inboth the vertical and horizontal direction throughout the soil profile.

The stress changes within the soil are linear within each unit, so we onlyneed to determine the values at each change depth, which in this case are2.5, 5.5, and 8.5 m.

At 2.5 m :

Vertical total stress σ = 2.5 × 18.2 = 45.5 kPa

Pore pressure u = 0

Vertical effective stress = 45.5 kPa

Horizontal effective stress = 0.35 × 45.4 = 15.9 kPa

Horizontal total stress = 15.9 + 0 = 15.9 kPa

At 5.5 m :

Vertical total stress σ = 2.5 × 18.2 + 3 × 21.5 = 110.0 kPa

Pore pressure u = 3 × 9.8 = 29.4 kPa

Vertical effective stress = 110.0 − 29.4 = 80.6 kPa

Horizontal effective stress within sand = 0.35 × 80.6 = 28.2 kPa

Horizontal total stress within sand = 28.2 + 29.4 = 57.6 kPa

Page 14: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

62 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

We must now note that the value of Ko is different in the clay fromthat in the sand, so that there is a discontinuity in the horizontal stress atthe boundary between the sand and clay. We must therefore also determinethe horizontal stress in the clay as well as in the sand. We thus have twovalues for horizontal stresses, one marginally above the boundary and onemarginally below it:

Horizontal effective stress within clay = 0.48 × 80.6 = 38.7 kPa

Horizontal total stress within clay = 38.7 + 29.4 = 68.1 kPa

We can continue in this manner at 8.5 m and complete the calculation.It is normally convenient to carry out these calculations using a table suchas Table 4.1.

The complete picture is presented in Figure 4.12. It should be noted thatthere cannot be any discontinuities in the vertical stress, whether this isexpressed as the total stress or the effective stress, because there cannot bestatic equilibrium within the soil mass if there are any discontinuities invertical stress state. The situation with regard to the horizontal stresses isdifferent; there can be sudden changes at soil boundaries (as at 5.5 m in theexample) because the condition of horizontal equilibrium is still satisfied.

4.6.2 Worked Example 2

Figure 4.13 shows a submerged surface in a lake or river. The initial depth ofwater is only 1 m but during a flood rises by a maximum of 3 m. Determinethe vertical total stress and vertical effective stress at point P initially andduring the flood peak.

Initially:

Total (vertical) stress = 1 × 9.8 + 3 × 20.5 = 71.3 kPaPore pressure = 4 × 9.8 = 39.2Effective (vertical) stress = 32.1 kPa

Table 4.1 Stresses in Worked Example 1

Depth (m) Vertical Pore Vertical Horizontal HorizontalTotal Pressure Effective Effective Total

Stress (kPa) (kPa) Stress (kPa) Stress (kPa) Stress (kPa)

Surface 0 0 0 0 02.5 45.5 0 45.5 15.9 15.95.5 (within

the sand)110.0 29.4 80.6 28.2 57.6

5.5 (withinthe clay)

110.0 29.4 80.6 38.7 68.1

8.5 159.2 58.8 100.4 48.2 107.0

Page 15: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

WORKED EXAMPLES 63

Sand γ = 18.2 kN/m3

Ko = 0.35

Sand γ = 21.5 kN/m3

Ko = 0.35

Clay γ = 16.4 kN/m3

Ko = 0.48

Water table

2.5 m

3 m

3 m

20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160Stress (kPa)

Vertical effective stress

Vertical total stress

Horizontal total stress

Horizontal

effective stress

2.5

5.5

8.5

Dep

th (

m)

Pore pressure Pore pressure

Rock layer

Figure 4.12 Stresses throughout the soil profile analyzed in worked example 1.

Final water level

Initial water level

Lake bed

Sandy siltγ = 20.5 kN/m3

P

3 m

3 m

1 m

Figure 4.13 Estimation of stress state beneath a submerged surface in a river orlake

During flood:

Total stress = 4 × 9.8 + 3 × 20.5 = 100.7 kPaPore pressure = 7 × 9.8 = 68.6Effective stress = 32.1 kPa

We see from these calculations that while there is a large increase in thetotal stress at point P there is no change in effective stress. This is to beexpected in this situation as the change in water level produces identical

Page 16: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

64 STRESS AND PORE PRESSURE STATE IN THE GROUND

increases in the total stress and the pore pressure so the effective stressremains constant.

REFERENCES

Kenny, T. C. and K. C. Lau. 1984. Temporal changes of groundwater pressure ina natural slope of non fissured clay. Canadian Geotechnical Journal, Vol. 21,No. 1, pp. 138–146.

Pun, W. K. and G. Urciuoli. 2008. Soil nailing and subsurface drainage forslope stabilisation. Proceedings Tenth International Symposium on Landslidesand Engineered Slopes. Vol.1, pp. 85–125. London: Taylor & Francis Group.

Urciuoli, G. 1998. Pore pressures in unstable slopes constituted by fissured clayshales. In A. Evangelista and L. Picarelli (eds.), Proceedings Second Interna-tional Symposium on the Geotechnics of Hard Soils—Soft Rocks, Vol. 2, pp.1177–1185. Rotterdam: A. A. Balkema.

Vaughan, P. R. and C. W. Kwan. 1984. Weathering, structure and in situ stress inresidual soils. Geotechnique, Vol. 34, No. 1, pp. 43–59.

EXERCISES

1. A layer of sand extends from the ground surface to an indefinite depth.The water table is at a depth of 2.5 m. Groundwater extraction froma neighboring site causes the water table to drop to a depth of 5 m.Calculate the change in vertical effective stress in the sand layer at adepth of 8 m. Assume the unit weight of the sand is 18 kN/m3 abovethe water table, and 21 kN/m3 below it.(�σ′ = 17.0 kN/m3)

2. A soil profile, from the surface downwards, consists of the following:(a) 4 m of clay, unit weight = 16 kN/m3 (above and below the water

table), Ko = 0.5(b) 8 m of sand, unit weight = 21 kN/m3, Ko = 0.3(c) hard rock from 8 mThe water table is at a depth of 2 m.Estimate the following:(i) The total vertical stress, the pore pressure, and the effective vertical

stress throughout the layers.(ii) The effective horizontal stress and the total horizontal stress

throughout the layers.

Page 17: Fundamentals of Soil Mechanics for Sedimentary and Residual Soils (Wesley/Fundamentals Soil Mechanics) || Stress and Pore Pressure State in the Ground

EXERCISES 65

Draw graphs illustrating your results [one graph for (i) and one graphfor (ii)].

Depth (m) σv u σ′v σ′

h σh

0 0 −19.6 19.6 9.8 −9.82 32 0 32 16 16

4 (clay) 64 19.6 44.4 22.2 41.84 (sand) 64 19.6 44.4 13.3 32.9

12 232 98.1 133.9 40.2 138.3

(Answer: stresses in kPa)