finding the right fit: how to leverage alternative portfolio structures
TRANSCRIPT
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
FINDING THE RIGHT FIT: HOW TO LEVERAGE ALTERNATIVE PORTFOLIO STRUCTURES
Wednesday, October 25 | 2:00pm - 3:00pm ET
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
DISCLAIMERThis materials is intended for informational purposes only, and is not a legal opinion or analysis and cannot be relied upon as authoritative. Matters discussed in this presentation must be referred to your counsel for review.
The enclosed materials may contain sensitive, proprietary and confidential information. Please use every effort to safeguard the confidentiality of these materials. Please do not copy, distribute, use, share or otherwise provide access to these materials to any person inside or outside DST Systems, Inc. without prior written approval.
If we permit your printing, copying or transmitting of content in this presentation, it is under a non-exclusive , non-transferable, limited license, and you must include or refer to the copyright notice contained in this document. You may not create derivative works of this presentation or its content without our prior written permission. Any reference in this presentation to another entity or its products or services is provided for convenience only and does not constitute an offer to sell, or the solicitation of an offer to buy, any products or services offered by such entity, nor does such reference constitute our endorsement, referral or recommendation.
Our trademarks and service marks and those of third parties used in this presentation are the property of their respective owners.
@2017 DST Systems, Inc. All rights reserved
DISCLOSUREThis presentation is for information purposes only and does not constitute a financial promotion, investment advice or an inducement or incitement to participate in any product, offering or investment. It does not constitute or form part of any offer to issue or sell, or any solicitation of any offer to subscribe or purchase any investment, nor shall it or the fact of its distribution form the basis of, or be relied on in connection with, any contract. No representation, warranty or undertaking, express or implied, is given as to the accuracy or completeness of the information or opinions contained in this presentation by FS Investments, its members or employees and no liability is accepted by such persons for the accuracy or completeness of any such information or opinions.
FS Investment Solutions, LLC 201 Rouse Boulevard, Philadelphia, PA 19112 www.fsinvestmentsolutions.com
877-372-9880 Member FINRA/SIPC
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Subject Matter Experts
Chris Shaw, Moderator
Managing Director,
DST Asset Manager
Solutions
John Alshefski, Panelist
Senior Vice President,
SEI Investment Manager
Services
Zachary Klehr, Panelist
Executive Vice President
Fund Management,
FS Investments
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Fund rationalization driving asset managers to differentiated strategies1
Mutual funds/ETFs not a panacea for all retail investment strategies
Distributor receptivity to BDCs and interval funds improving
Advisors' active allocations more thoughtful around a passive core
portfolio2
A More Constructive Time For Alternatives
1 Financial Times, U.S. asset managers embrace interval funds – March 20172 Financial Times, Investors gravitate to core/satellite portfolios – March 2015
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Average allocations to alternatives should rise from
10% to 14% of client portfolios within three years
That shift would represent a projected increase of
nearly $150 billion in net flows to alternatives in the independent advisory channel1
Increased Allocations, Increased Sales
Source: Blackstone Group/Investment News, Alternatives in the Mainstream – March 2017
The rise of alternatives in client allocations
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
• Evolving investor demand• Alternative funds offer some of the return potential of hedge funds and commodity
funds in a regulated vehicle
• Diversification among traditional asset classes • Alternative 40 Act funds offer investments in asset classes less correlated to traditional
markets and often with higher returns than fixed-income funds
• Many sponsors have moved away from “absolute returns”
• Mainstream asset class• Increased popularity and sales has led to tremendous growth within this asset class
• Managers extending reach down market• Creating an alternative mutual fund provides access to the retail consumer
• Mutual funds offer transparency, daily liquidity and custodial safeguards derived from 1940 Act restrictions, responding to concerns about some hedge funds’ illiquidity and suspensions of redemptions and/or gating
Current Trends
Source: SEI, FUSE
Growth drivers
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Expectations for future returns are falling
The odds of a 60/40 portfolio earning 5% real returns per year for the next 10 years is 0%1
Finding low-correlated assets is challenging
The correlation of a 60/40 portfolio to the S&P 500 is 0.992
Today’s Market Requires Finding Alternative Sources Of Return
“Take the 5% Challenge! (or The ‘Lloyd Christmas’ Lesson)” as of October 2016, published by Research Affiliates, LLC, using data provided by MSCI Inc., Bloomberg and Barclays.
Probabilities are rounded to the nearest whole number. The probability of the 60% U.S. stocks/40% U.S. bonds portfolio earning a 5% annualized real return over the next 10 years is
0.2%.
For the period of 12/31/2000–6/30/2017. 60/40 portfolio is composed of 60% S&P 500 Total Return Index and 40% Barclays Capital U.S. Aggregate Bond Index, rebalanced monthly.
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
0%
Probability
0.99
Correlation
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Low Interest Rates Have Profound Impact On Wealth Management
1. Morningstar and Bloomberg as of December 31, 2016
2. 72% decline as of December 31, 2016
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
U.S. 10-year treasury rate: declined 72% since 19871,2
-1%
1%
2%
3%
4%
5%
6%
7%
8%
9%
10%
1987 2016
12.43%
7.70%6.33%
3.62%
1980s 1990s 2000s '10-'16
Japan Mexico
Asia TMT
HousingEMU & China
Commodities
Barclays AGG Average Annualized Return (%)1
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Risk Is Rising…
1. Bloomberg. Estimated duration of the U.S. bond market based on the Barclays U.S. Aggregate Bond Index. Data through June 30, 2017. Duration is a measure of a bond’s sensitivity
to interest rate changes. The higher the bond’s duration (which is measured in years), the greater its sensitivity to the change. Generally, for every 1% increase or decrease in interest
rates, a bond’s price will change approximately 1% in the opposite direction for every year of duration. Note that the 6% decline shown above is an approximation. Shown for illustrative
purposes only.
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
U.S. bond market duration at highest on record
Duration (years)1
3
4
5
6
7
1989 2003 2017
A 1% increase in rates = a 6% decline
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
…While Expected Returns Are Falling
Note: Target Date Fund (“TDF”).
1. Research Affiliates, LLC using data provided by MSCI Inc., Bloomberg, and Barclays. As of October 2016.
Note: Probabilities are rounded to the nearest whole number. The probability of the 60% U.S. stocks/40% U.S. bonds portfolio earning a 5% annualized real return over the next 10 years
is 0.2%.
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
The traditional 60/40 portfolio will fall short over the next decade
Odds of mainstream portfolios earning a 5% annualized real return in the next 10 years1
7%6%
9%
13%
0%
5%
10%
15%
20%
25%
60% US Stocks/40% US Bonds Public Pension TDF (T+10) TDF (T+20) TDF (T+30)
0%
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Certain investment strategies can fit within a mutual fund structure:• Traditional equity long/short or market neutral
• Multi-strategy/multi-manager
• Merger arbitrage/event-driven/special situation
• Global tactical allocation and global macro strategies
• Credit strategies/convertible arbitrage/senior debt
• Managed futures/commodities
Hedge fund strategies which are not a fit for a mutual fund:• Illiquid strategies
• Highly concentrated portfolios
• Nonfinancial investments
Other requirements that could hinder an adviser’s ability to effectively deploy certain investment strategies
• Liquidity needs for fund redemptions
• Prohibited investments,
• ‘40 Act restrictions
• IRS tax restrictions
Which Alternative Strategies Fit Within AMutual Fund?
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Structure
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
Avoid the mismatch
BDC REIT CEF Mutual Fund
Structure
liquidityLow High
Asset liquidity Low High
Investment
horizonLonger Shorter
The dog should wag the tail, not the other way around.
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
The Manager Matters
Source: Morningstar, Lipper TASS database. Bonds represented by Morningstar U.S. Core Bond Funds. Stocks represented by Morningstar U.S. Large Cap Core Funds. Alternative
strategies represented by the following TASS fund classifications: Fixed Income Arbitrage (Long/Short Credit); Convertible Arbitrage (Relative Value); Long/Short Equity; Event-Driven;
Global Macro; and Managed Futures. Performance measured from December 31, 2004 through December 31, 2014.
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
Performance spread between top and bottom-decile managers
2004-2014
2.5%5.0%
13.3% 12.9%
18.0% 17.3%19.3% 21.5%
-2.9%-6.1%
-10.5%
-13.2% -12.5%-16.1% -16.3% -16.4%
-20.0%
-15.0%
-10.0%
-5.0%
0.0%
5.0%
10.0%
15.0%
20.0%
25.0%
Str
ate
gy p
erf
orm
an
ce
Bonds Stocks Relative
value
Long/short
credit
Event-
driven
Global
macro
Managed
futures
Long/short
equity
Traditional strategies Alternative strategiesStrategy
Performance
spread
Long/short
equity37.9%
Managed
futures35.6%
Global macro 33.4%
Event-driven 30.5%
Long/short
credit26.1%
Relative value 23.8%
Stocks 11.1%
Bonds 5.4%
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
The Issue Of Scale
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
While the processes between the qualified purchaser (QP), accredited and retail markets are similar, volumes are dramatically different.
QP/ Accredited
1,000xRetail
40,000x
Average order: $1,000,000 Average order: $25,000
To raise $1,000,000,000…
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Retail Investing And Illiquid Alternatives
CONFIDENTIAL. FOR ADVISOR USE ONLY. NOT FOR INVESTOR USE.
Historically, qualified purchasers and accredited investors could invest in alternatives through private placement offerings, but retail investors could not.
Retail investors have gained access to illiquid, institutional grade alternative investments through products like non-traded BDCs, closed-end funds and REITs.
The illiquid alternative investment processes is geared towards qualified purchasers and accredited investors, and has not evolved to meet the needs of retail investors.
Qualified purchaser
Accredited investor
Retail investors
Non-traded funds
Subscription document
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Increasingly important for asset managers
• 15 U.S. regulatory bodies oversee the financial services industry
• Rules are constantly evolving
• Failure to comply represents material risk and potential financial liability to stakeholders
• For illiquid alternatives, regulations vary by state and product and require manual controls
Regulation Is At The Core Of Financial Services
Challenge
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Liquidity Constraints Need to be Considered When Deciding on Structure of Product
Investor liquidity
Asse
t liq
uid
ity
Hedge
Funds
(LPs)
40 Act
Interval
funds
40 Act
Mutual
Funds
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Hedge Fund (LP) 40 Act Interval Fund40 Act Alternative
Mutual Fund
Who Can Invest? Accredited Investors Any Investor Any Investor
How Many
Investors Can
Invest?
3(c)(1): 100 investors
3(c)(7): Unlimited
Qualified Purchasers
No LimitNo Limit
Performance Fee?Yes, if limited to
Qualified Clients
Yes, if limited to
Qualified Clients
Yes, if limited to
Qualified Clients, but not in
practice
12b-1 Fee? N/AYes, but exemptive
relief requiredYes
Multiple Share
Classes?Yes
Yes, but exemptive
relief requiredYes
How Long to
Launch?Approximately 60 day
• Approximately 180 days in
total
• Initial SEC registration at
least 3 months; often
longer
• Afterwards, new Interval
Funds require same
process
• Approximately 180 days in
total
• Initial SEC registration at
least 3 months; often
longer
• Afterwards, new mutual
funds can be launched in
75 days
Product Structure Comparison for Alternative Strategies
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Hedge Fund (LP) 40 Act Interval Fund40 Act Alternative
Mutual Fund
Asset Liquidity
Restrictions?None
Must maintain liquid
assets sufficient to meet
Repurchase Offers during time
between notice of Repurchase
Offer to shareholders
and Repurchase Pricing Date
Illiquid securities limited
to 15% of net assets
Liquidity
Structure?
As determined by the
manager of the fund
Repurchase offers required at
interval chosen by fund
(e.g., quarterly, semi-annually or
annually), unless changed by
Shareholders
Daily redemptions
Can Payment of
Redemption
Proceeds be
Delayed?
Yes
No. Repurchase
Payment Deadline must
occur seven days after
the Repurchase Pricing Date
No. Must pay
redemption proceeds
within seven days
following receipt of a
redemption request
NSCC Traded No No Yes
Product Structure Comparison for Alternative Strategies
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Hedge Fund (LP) 40 Act Interval Fund40 Act Alternative
Mutual Fund
Use of Leverage Unlimited 33% 33%
How is the
Registration
Statement Updated?
N/A
• Annual update filing via Rule 486
under the Securities Act of 1933
• Automatic effectives
• Annual update filing via
Rule 485 under the
Securities Act of 1933
• Automatic effectiveness
Can 1099s be
issued?No, K-1’s only
Yes, if Fund meets Subchapter M
diversification
Yes, if Fund meets
Subchapter M
diversification
Exempt from ERISA
Plan Assets Rule?No Yes Yes
Product Structure Comparison for Alternative Strategies
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
• No side pockets
• No side letters
• No carried interest payments or performance fees
• No gates or restrictions on transfers or redemptions
• No discounts on/negotiated advisory fees
Hedge Fund Features Not Allowed in 40 Act Mutual Funds
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Don’t know how to distribute
• Looking for distribution partners with resources to help distribute. Don’t want to build sales force. Typically this approach is not successful
• Their strategies can be complex – The rules didn’t contemplate these financial instruments or strategies.
• Leads to grey areas that need to be interpreted. Fact specific so hard to leverage and leads to risk.
• We don’t have portfolio management experience
• Don’t understand portfolio managers concerns/options
• Don’t/Can’t test for all restrictions on a secondary basis. Need to rely on manager which provides additional risk to SEI in series trust model
• Additional/more complex agreements are involved such as ISDA and prime brokers. Impacts series trust model
Don’t have the necessary policies and procedures in place
Need more hand holding/guidance
• Requires more resources with ‘40 Act expertise especially legal/compliance and fund accounting
• What level of risk are we comfortable with? Traditionally we’ve stayed away from providing guidance
Challenges
Alternative managers may not know the market or restrictions
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Expertise
Quantitative
• Quicker time to market and less expensive
• Sharing of trust level expenses and scale = Lower cost of ownership
• Trustee fees
• Legal fees
• Insurance fees
Qualitative
• Proven and accepted model
• Investment managers can focus resources on core competencies and value add activities
• Managing infrastructure is not a value add
• Funds should operate much like a private account with the exception of annual renewal of advisory agreement
• Less risk
• Maintain brand control
Why Firms Choose a Series TrustMutual Fund Structure
• Audit fees
• Compliance program expenses
23
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
Turnkey Series Trust Provides Complete Mutual Fund Infrastructure
XYZ
Investment
Adviser
Manages the
fund's portfolio
according to the
objectives and
policies described
in the Fund's
prospectus.
Provides
oversight of sub
advisers.
Independent Trustee
Counsel
Best practice for
independent trustees.
Chief Compliance Office
(CCO)
Adviser and sub-adviser
oversight. Reports directly to
Board of Trustees.
Board of Trustees
(Majority of boards must be independent trustees)
Oversees the fund's activities, including approval of the contract
with the management company and certain other service providers.
A C
DB
E G
HF
Distributor
Principal
Underwriter
Sells fund shares,
either directly to
the public or
through other
firms.
Administrator
Oversees the
performance of the
other companies
that provide
services to the
funds and ensures
that the fund's
operations comply
with the applicable
federal
requirements.
Transfer Agent
Executes
shareholders
transactions,
maintains records of
the transactions.
and other
shareholder account
activity, and sends
account statements
and other
documents to
shareholders.
Custodian
Holds the fund's
assets,
maintaining them
separately to
protect the
shareholders
interests.
Independent
Public
Accountant
Certifies the
fund's financial
statements.
Fund Counsel
Prepares and files
fund registrations
statements,
provides general
advice and board
support.
Sub Advisors
Mutual Funds
24
Q&AQUESTIONS & ANSWERS SESSION
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
www.nicsa.org | #WebinarWednesdays
WEBINAR SPONSORED BY: