0ROGRAMMEFOR.EUROLOGICAL$ISEASESAND.EUROSCIENCE$EPARTMENTOF-ENTAL(EALTHAND3UBSTANCE!BUSE

7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION'ENEVA

'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY

7(/,IBRARY#ATALOGUINGIN0UBLICATION$ATA

7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION

!TLAS%PILEPSY#AREINTHE7ORLD

%PILEPSYnEPIDEMIOLOGY%PILEPSYnTHERAPY(EALTHCARESURVEYS-ENTALHEALTHSERVICESnSTATISTICS!TLASES)4ITLE))4ITLE!TLASOFEPILEPSYCAREINTHEWORLD

)3". .,CLASSIlCATION7,

7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION

!LLRIGHTSRESERVED0UBLICATIONSOFTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONCANBEOBTAINEDFROM7(/0RESS7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION!VENUE!PPIA'ENEVA3WITZERLANDTELFAXEMAILBOOKORDERS WHOINT2EQUESTSFORPERMISSIONTOREPRODUCEORTRANSLATE7(/PUBLICATIONSnWHETHERFORSALEORFORNONCOMMERCIALDISTRIBUTIONnSHOULDBEADDRESSEDTO7(/0RESSATTHEABOVEADDRESSFAXEMAILPERMISSIONS WHOINT

4HEDESIGNATIONSEMPLOYEDANDTHEPRESENTATIONOFTHEMATERIALINTHISPUBLICATIONDONOTIMPLYTHEEXPRESSIONOFANYOPINIONWHATSOEVERONTHEPARTOFTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONCONCERNINGTHELEGALSTATUSOFANYCOUNTRYTERRITORYCITYORAREAOROFITSAUTHORITIESORCONCERNINGTHEDELIMITATIONOFITSFRONTIERSORBOUNDARIES$OTTEDLINESONMAPSREPRESENTAPPROXIMATEBORDERLINESFORWHICHTHEREMAYNOTYETBEFULLAGREEMENT

4HEMENTIONOFSPECIlCCOMPANIESOROFCERTAINMANUFACTURERSPRODUCTSDOESNOTIMPLYTHATTHEYAREENDORSEDORRECOMMENDEDBYTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONINPREFERENCETOOTHERSOFASIMILARNATURETHATARENOTMENTIONED%RRORSANDOMISSIONSEXCEPTEDTHENAMESOFPROPRIETARYPRODUCTSAREDISTINGUISHEDBYINITIALCAPITALLETTERS

!LLREASONABLEPRECAUTIONSHAVEBEENTAKENBYTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONTOVERIFYTHEINFORMATIONCONTAINEDINTHISPUBLICATION(OWEVERTHEPUBLISHEDMATERIALISBEINGDISTRIBUTEDWITHOUTWARRANTYOFANYKINDEITHEREXPRESSORIMPLIED4HERESPONSIBILITYFORTHEINTERPRETATIONANDUSEOFTHEMATERIALLIESWITHTHEREADER)NNOEVENTSHALLTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATIONBELIABLEFORDAMAGESARISINGFROMITSUSE

0RINTEDIN$ESIGNEDBY4USHITA'RAPHIC6ISION3RL#(4HNEX

&ORFURTHERDETAILSONTHISPROJECTORTOSUBMITUPDATEDINFORMATIONPLEASECONTACT

$R,0RILIPKO0ROGRAMME,EADER.EUROLOGICAL$ISEASESAND.EUROSCIENCE$EPARTMENTOF-ENTAL(EALTHAND3UBSTANCE!BUSE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION!VENUE!PPIA#('ENEVA3WITZERLAND4EL&AXEMAILPRILIPKOL WHOINT

&/2%7/2$

%PILEPSYISONEOFTHEMOSTCOMMONSERIOUSDISORDERSOFTHEBRAINAFFECTINGABOUTMILLIONPEOPLEWORLDWIDE%PILEPSYACCOUNTSFOROFTHEGLOBALBURDENOFDISEASEOFTHEBURDENOFEPILEPSYISINTHEDEVELOPINGWORLDWHEREINSOMEAREASnOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYRECEIVENOTREATMENTATALL)TISIMPERATIVETORECOGNIZETHATEPILEPSYCONSISTSOFMORETHANSEIZURESFORTHEAFFECTEDINDIVIDUALANDIMMEDIATEEFFECTSONHISORHERFAMILY%PILEPSYLEADSTOMULTIPLEINTERACTINGMEDICALPSYCHOLOGICALECONOMICANDSOCIALREPERCUSSIONSALLOFWHICHNEEDTOBECONSIDEREDINORDERTOUNDERSTANDFULLYTHEIMPACTOFTHISCONDITION&EARMISUNDERSTANDINGANDTHERESULTINGSOCIALSTIGMAANDDISCRIMINATIONSURROUNDINGEPILEPSYOFTENFORCEPEOPLEWITHTHISDISORDERhINTOTHESHADOWSv

4HE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/ISRESPONSIBLEFORPROVIDINGTECHNICALINFORMATIONANDADVICETOITS-EMBER3TATESTOHELPTHEMTOIMPROVETHEHEALTHOFTHEIRCITIZENS4HISTASKISFACILITATEDBYCOLLABORATIONWITHVARIOUSSCIENTIlCANDPROFESSIONALGROUPSTHATHAVESIMILARGOALS4OBRINGEPILEPSYhOUTOFTHESHADOWSvA'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSYWASLAUNCHEDINhTOIMPROVEACCEPTABILITYTREATMENTSERVICESANDPREVENTIONOFEPILEPSYWORLDWIDEv4HE#AMPAIGNISCONDUCTEDBY7(/INPARTNERSHIPWITHTHE)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY),!%ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY)"%4HEAIMOFTHE#AMPAIGNISPRINCIPALLYTOREDUCETHETREATMENTGAPBYPROVIDINGBETTERINFORMATIONABOUTEPILEPSYANDITSCONSEQUENCESANDTOASSISTGOVERNMENTSANDTHOSECONCERNEDWITHEPILEPSYTOREDUCETHEBURDENOFTHEDISORDER4OGATHERINFORMATIONABOUTTHERESOURCESAVAILABLEFOREPILEPSYCARE

INCOUNTRIESTHE!TLAS%PILEPSY#AREINTHE7ORLDWASINITIATED4HIS!TLASREPRESENTSAUNIQUECOLLABORATIVEEFFORTBETWEEN7(/ANDTHETWOLEADINGNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSWORKINGINTHElELDOFEPILEPSY

4HERESULTSOBTAINEDFROMTHESTUDYOFCOUNTRYRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCONlRMTHATTHEAVAILABLERESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCAREINTHEWORLDAREINSUFlCIENTWHENSETAGAINSTTHELARGENUMBERSOFPEOPLENEEDINGSUCHCAREANDTHEKNOWNSUBSTANTIALBURDENASSOCIATEDWITHTHISDISORDER)NADDITIONTHEREARELARGEINEQUITIESACROSSREGIONSANDINCOMEGROUPSOFCOUNTRIESWITHLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESHAVINGEXTREMELYMEAGRERESOURCES3INCETHEPREVALENCEOFEPILEPSYISMUCHHIGHERANDRESOURCESAREMUCHSCARCERINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESTHEDATAREINFORCETHENEEDFORURGENTSUBSTANTIALANDSYSTEMATICACTIONTOENHANCERESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCAREINTHESECOUNTRIES

)TISHOPEDTHATTHEAVAILABILITYOFESSENTIALINFORMATIONWILLLEADTOGREATERAWARENESSAMONGPOLICYMAKERSOFTHEGAPSINRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCARE4HEINFORMATIONISLIKELYTOASSISTHEALTHPLANNERSANDPOLICYMAKERSTOIDENTIFYAREASTHATNEEDURGENTATTENTIONANDTOPLANTHEUPGRADINGOFRESOURCESINTHOSEAREAS4HEDATAWILLALSOSERVEASABASELINEFORMONITORINGTHEIMPROVEMENTINAVAILABILITYOFRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCARE7EHOPETHATPERSONNELINVOLVEDINCARINGFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYINCLUDINGHEALTHPROFESSIONALSANDNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSWILLUSETHE!TLASDATAINTHEIREFFORTSTOENSUREMOREANDBETTERRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCARE

$R"ENEDETTO3ARACENO$IRECTOR$EPARTMENTOF-ENTAL(EALTHAND3UBSTANCE!BUSE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION

0ROFESSOR'IULIANO!VANZINI0RESIDENT)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY

-R0HILIP,EE0RESIDENT)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY

!CKNOWLEDGEMENTS

0REFACE

%XECUTIVESUMMARY

)NTRODUCTION

-ETHODOLOGY

%PILEPSYTHEDISORDER

-ILESTONESINTHEHISTORYOFEPILEPSY

.UMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY

%PIDEMIOLOGY

!ETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYnREPORTEDFREQUENCY

!ETIOLOGYANDRISKFACTORS

%PILEPSYTHESERVICES

$IAGNOSTICSERVICES

0RIMARYCARE

0ROVISIONOFCARE

)NPATIENTCARE

%PILEPSYSPECIALISTSERVICES

!NTIEPILEPTICDRUGS

4HETREATMENTGAP

3UBSPECIALIZEDSERVICES

%PILEPSYSURGERY

#/.4%.43

%PILEPSYTHECAREPROVIDERS

-EDICALPROFESSIONALS

0ROFESSIONALSALLIEDTOMEDICINE

4RAININGINEPILEPTOLOGY

%DUCATIONINEPILEPTOLOGY

0ROFESSIONALASSOCIATIONS

,AYASSOCIATIONS

2OLEOF),!%INFOSTERINGEPILEPSYCARE

2OLEOF)"%INPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE

%PILEPSYTHEPUBLICHEALTHASPECTS

"UDGETANDlNANCING

$ISABILITYBENElTS

%PILEPSYANDRIGHTS

2EPORTINGANDDATACOLLECTION

0ROBLEMSENCOUNTERED

3TIGMAANDSOCIALISSUES

4HEATTRIBUTABLEANDADVERTABLEBURDENOFEPILEPSY

'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY

'LOSSARYOFTERMS

2EFERENCES

,ISTOF2ESPONDENTS

#/.4%.43

!#+./7,%$'%-%.43

4HE!TLAS%PILEPSY#AREINTHE7ORLDISONEOFTHEMOSTIMPORTANTPROJECTSWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHE),!%)"%7(/'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY'#!%h/UTOFTHE3HADOWSvREPRESENTINGAMAJORCOLLABORATIVEEFFORTINVOLVING7(/HEADQUARTERSREGIONALANDCOUNTRYOFlCESAND),!%AND)"%HEADQUARTERSANDTHEIRMEMBERS

4HEWORKWASSUPERVISEDANDCOORDINATEDBY$R,EONID0RILIPKOAND$R3HEKHAR3AXENAAT7(/HEADQUARTERSAND-RS(ANNEKEDE"OER#O#HAIR'#!%3ECRETARIAT$R"ENEDETTO3ARACENOPROVIDEDVISIONANDGUIDANCETOTHEPROJECTAND$R'IULIANO!VANZINIAND-R0HILIP,EEPROVIDEDTHEIRCONTINUOUSSUPPORTTOTHE#AMPAIGN$R4ARUN$UAWASRESPONSIBLEFORCOMPLETIONOFTHEDATACOLLECTIONDATAANALYSESANDOVERALLPROJECTMANAGEMENTANDFORMOSTOFTHEWRITINGOFTHISREPORT$R(ARRY-EINARDIAND$R'US"AKERPROVIDEDTECHNICALGUIDANCEANDSUPERVISION$R*EROME%NGEL*R$R!LEKSANDAR*ANCA-R0HILIP,EEAND$R(ARRY-EINARDIWEREINVOLVEDINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHESURVEYDESIGNANDQUESTIONNAIRE-S+ATHY&ONTANILLAWASINVOLVEDINTHEDATAMANAGEMENT

#OLLABORATORSFROM7(/REGIONALOFlCESINCLUDE$R#USTODIA-ANDLHATEAND$R4HERSE!GOSSOU!FRICAN2EGIONAL/FlCE$R#LAUDIO-IRANDAAND$R*OSE-IGUEL#ALDASDE!LMEIDA2EGIONAL/FlCEFORTHE!MERICAS$R6IJAY#HANDRA3OUTH%AST!SIA2EGIONAL/FlCE$R7OLFGANG2UTZAND$R-ATTHIJS-UIJEN%UROPEAN2EGIONAL/FlCE$R!HMED-OHITAND$R23RINIVASA-URTHY%ASTERN-EDITERRANEAN2EGIONAL/FlCEAND$R(ELEN(ERMANNAND$R8IANGDONG7ANG7ESTERN0ACIlC2EGIONAL/FlCEALLOFWHOMMADEVALUABLECONTRIBUTIONSDURINGTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHEPROJECTTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFKEYPERSONSINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYIN-EMBER3TATESANDTHEREVIEWOFTHERESULTS

4HEINFORMATIONFROMVARIOUSCOUNTRIESAREASORTERRITORIESWASPROVIDEDBYKEYPERSONSWORKINGINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYIDENTIlEDBY),!%)"%7(/REGIONALOFlCESANDTHEOFlCESOF7(/2EPRESENTATIVES+EYCOLLABORATORSWHOHELPEDINTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFKEYPERSONSINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYINSOMEOFTHECOUNTRIESINCLUDE$R#ARLOS!CEVEDO$R!MADOU'ALLO$IOP$R0ETER(ALASZ$R3HI#HUO,IAND$R3USAN3PENCER4HESURVEYRESPONDENTS

HANDLEDTHEMANYREQUESTSFORCLARIlCATIONARISINGFROMTHEDATA!LISTOFTHEIRNAMESISINCLUDEDATTHEENDOFTHE!TLAS

6ARIOUSSPECIALISTSCONTRIBUTEDBRIEFREVIEWSOFSELECTEDAREASINRELATIONTOEPILEPSYASFOLLOWS$R%DWARD(2EYNOLDSMILESTONESINTHEHISTORYOFEPILEPSY$R.ADIR%"HARUCHAEPIDEMIOLOGY$R*OSEMIR73ANDERAETIOLOGYANDRISKFACTORS$R0ATRICK+WANAND$R-ARTIN*"RODIEPROVISIONOFCARE$R!MADOU'ALLO$IOPTHETREATMENTGAP$R*EROME%NGEL*REPILEPSYSURGERY$R0ETER7OLFEDUCATIONINEPILEPTOLOGY$R'IULIANO!VANZINIROLEOF),%!INFOSTERINGEPILEPSYCARE-R0HILIP,EEROLEOF)"%INPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE-RS+ATHRYN0AHLAND-RS(ANNEKEDE"OEREPILEPSYANDRIGHTS-S$EE3NAPE$R!NN*ACOBYAND$R'US!"AKERSTIGMAANDSOCIALISSUES$R$AN#HISHOLMTHEATTRIBUTABLEANDAVERTABLEBURDENOFEPILEPSY-RS(ANNEKEDE"OER$R*EROME%NGEL*RAND$R,EONID0RILIPKO'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY

!NINTERNATIONALGROUPOFLEADINGEXPERTSINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYREVIEWEDTHEPROJECTREPORTANDPROVIDEDCOMMENTS4HEYINCLUDE$R#ARLOS!CEVEDO$R(ASAN!ZIZ$R#HARLES"EGLEY$R3AM"ERKOVIC$R.ADIR"HARUCHA$R:ENEBE'EDLIE$AMTIE$R3ALEH-!L$EEB$R!MADOU'ALLO$IOP$R*OHN$UNCAN$R*EROME%NGEL*R$R0ETER(ALASZ$R3HICHUO,I$R%MILIO0ERUCCA$R*OSEMIR73ANDER$R-ASAKAZU3EINO$R.IMAL3ENANAYAKEAND$R4ORBJRN4OMSON

!NUMBEROFCOLLEAGUESAT7(/GAVEADVICEANDGUIDANCEDURINGTHECOURSEOFTHEPROJECTINPARTICULAR$R*OS"ERTOLOTE$R-ICHELLE&UNKAND$R6LADIMIR0OZNYAK

-RS#AROLINE-ORTONHELPEDINTHEDATACOLLECTION!DMINISTRATIVESUPPORTWASPROVIDEDBY-S+ATHY&ONTANILLAAND-S2OSA3EMINARIO

4HECONTRIBUTIONOFALLOFTHEABOVEALONGWITHINPUTFROMMANYOTHERUNNAMEDPEOPLEHASBEENVITALTOTHESUCCESSOFTHISPROJECT

!SSISTANCEINPREPARINGTHE!TLASFORPUBLICATIONWASRECEIVEDFROM4USHITA"OSONETGRAPHICDESIGN3TEVE%WARTMAPSAND"ARBARA#AMPANINIEDITING

02%&!#%

4HEREISCONSIDERABLEEVIDENCETHATTHEGLOBALBURDENOFMENTALANDNEUROLOGICALDISORDERSISMASSIVEANDISINCREASING!TTHESAMETIMELITTLEISKNOWNABOUTTHERESOURCESAVAILABLETOMEETTHISBURDENINFORMATIONISSCARCEINTHEVASTMAJORITYOFCOUNTRIESWHILETHEINFORMATIONTHATISAVAILABLEISNOTCOMPARABLEACROSSDIFFERENTCOUNTRIESOROVERTIME!CCURATEANDUPTODATEINFORMATIONISREQUIREDONTHEAVAILABLERESOURCESFORTHESEDISORDERSANDTHEIRDISTRIBUTIONINVARIOUSREGIONSOFTHEWORLD

)NORDERTOTRYANDlLLTHISKNOWLEDGEGAPTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/LAUNCHED0ROJECT!TLAS4HEOBJECTIVESOFTHEPROJECTINCLUDECOLLECTIONCOMPILATIONANDDISSEMINATIONOFRELEVANTINFORMATIONABOUTRESOURCESFORMENTALANDNEUROLOGICALCONDITIONSINCOUNTRIES4HElRSTDOCUMENTINTHISSERIESWASPUBLISHEDINASTHE!TLASOFMENTALHEALTHRESOURCESINTHEWORLDFOLLOWEDBYTHE!TLASOFCOUNTRYRESOURCESFORNEUROLOGICALDISORDERSIN!MONGOTHERlNDINGSEPILEPSYWASCONlRMEDASONEOFTHEMAJORBRAINDISORDERSWORLDWIDE%PILEPSYPRESENTSAGLOBALPROBLEMAFFECTINGALLAGESSOCIALCLASSESGROUPSANDCOUNTRIES)TIMPOSESENORMOUSPHYSICALPSYCHOLOGICALSOCIALANDECONOMICBURDENSONINDIVIDUALSFAMILIESANDCOUNTRIES-ANYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYSUFFERINSILENCEAFRAIDTOBEFOUNDOUT4HESEPROBLEMSAREUNIVERSALBUTCAUSETHEMOSTSERIOUSIMPACTINTHEDEVELOPINGWORLD4HISISMOSTUNFORTUNATESINCEEPILEPSYPROVIDESTHECLEARESTEXAMPLEOFANEUROLOGICALDISORDERFORWHICHEFFECTIVEANDCOSTEFlCIENTTREATMENTISAVAILABLEANDSOMEOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYCOULDLEADNORMALLIVESIFPROPERLYDIAGNOSEDANDTREATED

)NORDERTOMAPTHERESOURCESAVAILABLEFOREPILEPSYCARE7(/DECIDEDTOPRODUCEAN!TLASONCOUNTRYRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYWITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHE'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY4HE'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY

nWHOSETHEMEISh/UTOFTHE3HADOWSvnISAPARTNERSHIPOFTHE)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY),!%WITHMEMBERORGANIZATIONSINMORETHANCOUNTRIESTHE)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY)"%WITHOVERFULLMEMBERSANDASSOCIATEMEMBERSAND7(/ASPECIALIZEDAGENCYOFTHE5NITED.ATIONSWITH-EMBER3TATES),!%MEMBERORGANIZATIONSCONSISTOFPROFESSIONALSCONCERNEDWITHMEDICALANDSCIENTIlCASPECTSOFEPILEPSYWHILETHOSEOF)"%ARECONCERNEDWITHSOCIALASPECTSANDTHEQUALITYOFLIFEOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY

4OGATHERINFORMATIONFORTHIS!TLASAQUESTIONNAIREWASDEVELOPEDBYANUMBEROFEXPERTSCOVERINGTHEPROlLEOFEPILEPSYRESOURCESAVAILABLEINCOUNTRIES4HEWORKSTARTEDINANDDATAHAVEBEENCOLLECTEDFROMCOUNTRIESSPANNINGALL7(/REGIONSANDCOVERINGOFTHEWORLDPOPULATIONMAKINGTHISAGLOBALEXERCISE7EARENOTAWAREOFANYOTHEREXERCISEINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYTHATCANCOMPAREWITHTHEPRESENTONEFORITSCOVERAGEANDCOMPREHENSIVENATURE

4HEDATACONlRMWHATPROFESSIONALSINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYHAVEKNOWNFORALONGTIMETHATEPILEPSYCAREISGROSSLYINADEQUATECOMPAREDWITHTHENEEDSINMOSTCOUNTRIEShWHENITCOMESTOEPILEPSYCAREMOSTCOUNTRIESAREDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESv4HEVALUEOFTHE!TLASISTHATITREPLACESIMPRESSIONSANDOPINIONSBYFACTSANDlGURES)NFOLLOWINGUNIFORMDElNITIONSANDUNITSITALLOWSFORCOMPARISONSTOBEMADEACROSSCOUNTRIESANDREGIONS

7EHOPETHATTHEREALITIESUNCOVEREDBYTHE!TLASWILLMOTIVATEGOVERNMENTSANDHEALTHCAREPROVIDERSTOIMPROVEEPILEPSYCARE4HEPICTUREISCLEARANDTHEGOALISWITHINREACHTOBRINGEPILEPSYOUTOFTHESHADOWS

-RS(ANNEKE-DE"OER#O#HAIR),!%)"%7(/'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY

$R,EONID,0RILIPKO0ROGRAMME,EADER.EUROLOGICAL$ISEASESAND.EUROSCIENCE$EPARTMENTOF-ENTAL(EALTHAND3UBSTANCE!BUSE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION

$R3HEKHAR3AXENA#OORDINATOR-ENTAL(EALTH%VIDENCEAND2ESEARCH$EPARTMENTOF-ENTAL(EALTHAND3UBSTANCE!BUSE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION

%8%#54)6%35--!29

%PILEPSYISONEOFTHEMOSTCOMMONSERIOUSDISORDERSOFTHEBRAINAFFECTINGABOUTMILLIONPEOPLEWORLDWIDE%PILEPSYACCOUNTSFOROFTHEGLOBALBURDENOFDISEASEOFTHEBURDENOFEPILEPSYISINTHEDEVELOPINGWORLDWHEREINSOMEAREASnOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYRECEIVENOTREATMENTATALL.OTMUCHINFORMATIONEXISTSREGARDINGTHERESOURCESAVAILABLEWITHINCOUNTRIESTOTACKLETHEHUGEMEDICALSOCIALANDECONOMICBURDENCAUSEDBYEPILEPSY)NORDERTOlLLTHISGAPINFORMATIONREGARDINGCOUNTRYRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYSERVICESANDCAREWASCOLLECTEDUNDERTHE'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY'#!%h/UTOFTHE3HADOWSv4HESTUDYREPRESENTSAMAJORCOLLABORATIVEEFFORTINVOLVING7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/HEADQUARTERSREGIONALANDCOUNTRYOFlCESTHE)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY),!%ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY)"%4HISWORKWASUNDERTAKENUNDER7(/S0ROJECT!TLASONGOINGSINCE

4HE!TLAS%PILEPSY#AREINTHE7ORLDTHE%PILEPSY!TLASPROVIDESANILLUSTRATIVEPRESENTATIONOFDATAANDINFORMATIONONTHECURRENTSTATUSOFEPILEPSYSERVICESANDCAREAVAILABLEFROMCOUNTRIESAREASORTERRITORIESCOVERINGOFTHEWORLDPOPULATION4HEINFORMATIONISPRIMARILYGATHEREDFROMKEYPERSONSINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYCAREINEACHCOUNTRYIDENTIlEDBY),!%)"%ANDINSOMECASESBY7(/REGIONALOFlCES)TISONEOFTHEMOSTCOMPREHENSIVECOMPILATIONSOFAVAILABLERESOURCESFOREPILEPSYEVERATTEMPTED,IMITATIONSARETOBEKEPTINMINDHOWEVERWHENINTERPRETINGTHEDATAANDTHEIRANALYSES4HEKEYPERSONSWEREAMONGTHEMOSTKNOWLEDGEABLEPERSONSINTHEIRCOUNTRIESBUTTHEPOSSIBILITYREMAINSOFTHEDATABEINGINCOMPLETEANDINCERTAINAREASEVENINACCURATE4HEDRAFTREPORTWASREVIEWEDBYLEADINGEXPERTSINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYANDREGIONALADVISERSOFTHESIX7(/REGIONSANDTHEIRCOMMENTSWEREINCORPORATED4HE%PILEPSY!TLASALSOINCLUDESBRIEFREVIEWSOFSELECTEDTOPICSSUMMARIZINGTHEMEDICALLIFESTYLESOCIALANDECONOMICISSUESSURROUNDINGPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY

4HEANALYSESOFTHEREPORTEDAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYSHOWTHATTRAUMACENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINFECTIONSANTENATALANDPERINATALRISKFACTORSCEREBROVASCULARDISORDERSANDIDIOPATHICAETIOLOGYAREAMONGTHEMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDGLOBALLYASWELLASINALL7(/REGIONS4HEINFORMATIONREGARDINGTHEAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYHASIMPLICATIONSFORMAKINGDECISIONSABOUTTHEDEVELOPMENTOFLOCALLYRELEVANTSTRATEGIESFORPREVENTIONANDMANAGEMENTRESEARCHGOALSANDEDUCATIONOFPRIMARYHEALTHCAREWORKERSANDCOMMUNITYPHYSICIANS4HETOPFOURMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDCAUSESOFEPILEPSYAREINFACTPREVENTABLE#ONCERTEDMULTIDISCIPLINARYEFFORTSCONCENTRATINGONTHERISKFACTORSEGENFORCEMENTOFSTRICTTRAFlCREGULATIONSANDIMPROVEMENTINPERINATALCAREORPROVIDINGSPECIlCPROTECTIONEGVACCINATIONFORTHESEPREVENTABLECAUSESCANHELPTODECREASESUBSTANTIALLYTHEBURDENATTRIBUTABLETOEPILEPSY

&ORAPPROPRIATEMANAGEMENTOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYDIAGNOSTICSERVICESCONSTITUTEANIMPORTANTRESOURCE#OMPUTER

IZEDAXIALTOMOGRAPHY#!4MAGNETICRESONANCEIMAGING-2)ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY%%'ANDLONGTERMVIDEO%%'MONITORINGAREAVAILABLETOHEALTHPROFESSIONALSINANDOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESRESPECTIVELY4HERAPEUTICDRUGMONITORINGANDNEUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESAREAVAILABLEINANDOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESRESPECTIVELY4HESElGURESDONOTINDICATEHOWEVERHOWMANYPEOPLEWHONEEDTHESERVICESCANINFACTMAKEUSEOFTHEMNORHOWAPPROPRIATELYTHESERVICESAREUSED4HEREISINEQUITYINAVAILABILITYOFDIAGNOSTICSERVICESACROSSDIFFERENTINCOMEGROUPSEGNEUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESAREAVAILABLEINOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES-OSTNEWTECHNOLOGIESAREAVAILABLEINMANYCOUNTRIESBUTTHEYAREOFTENCONCENTRATEDINONLYAFEWCENTRESORINMAJORCITIES4HEAIMSHOULDBETOIMPROVETHEIRCOVERAGEINORDERTOSERVETHEENTIREPOPULATION

4HEMOSTCOSTEFFECTIVEWAYTODECREASETHETREATMENTGAPINTHEMAJORITYOFCOUNTRIESWOULDBETODELIVERTHEEPILEPSYSERVICESTHROUGHPRIMARYHEALTHCARE4HEMAINTASKSOFTHEPERSONNELINPRIMARYCARESETTINGSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCAREASREPORTEDBYCOUNTRIESINCLUDEFOLLOWUPANDMONITORINGOFTREATMENTMAINTENANCEANDORPRESCRIPTIONOFANTIEPILEPTICDRUGSINFORMATIONANDEDUCATIONOFTHEPATIENTSANDCAREGIVERSREFERRALOFPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYFORSPECIALISTTREATMENTANDCASElNDING)NTERESTINGLYINFORMATIONANDEDUCATIONOFPATIENTSANDCAREGIVERSREGARDINGEPILEPSYWASMENTIONEDASONEOFTHElVEMAINTASKSBYOFTHELOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFTHEHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES

3EPARATEHOSPITALBEDSFOREPILEPSYMANAGEMENTMAYNOTBEDESIRABLEINMANYCOUNTRIESWHERETHEPRIORITYISSTILLTOPROVIDEAPPROPRIATEEPILEPSYTREATMENTATTHEPRIMARYCARELEVEL(OWEVERASPECIALFACILITYFORPROVIDINGREFERRALSERVICESASAPARTOFAGENERALHEALTHSERVICEISNECESSARYFORTHECOMPREHENSIVEMANAGEMENTOFEPILEPSY2EFERRALSERVICESAREALSOANIMPORTANTINDICATOROFTHELEVELOFORGANIZATIONOFEPILEPSYSERVICESINACOUNTRY.OINPATIENTFACILITYFOREPILEPSYCAREEXISTSINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES!TOTALOFHOSPITALBEDSFOREPILEPSYCAREAREREPORTEDTOBEAVAILABLEINCOUNTRIES/FTHETOTALNUMBEROFBEDSONETHIRDISREPORTEDTOBEFORSHORTTERMEPILEPSYCAREWHILETHERESTAREFORRESIDENTIALLONGTERMCARE

$ATAREGARDINGTHEINCLUSIONOFlRSTLINEANTIEPILEPTICDRUGSINTHECOUNTRYSLISTOFESSENTIALDRUGSSHOWTHATPHENOBARBITALISINCLUDEDINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESCARBAMAZEPINEINPHENYTOININANDVALPROICACIDIN!GOVERNMENTPOLICYREGARDINGTHEIRAVAILABILITYONLYBYPRESCRIPTIONEITHERFROMAGENERALPRACTITIONERORASPECIALISTEXISTSINMORETHANOFTHECOUNTRIES4HEMEDIANCOSTOFTHEDAILYDElNEDDOSE$$$OFTHESEININTERNATIONALDOLLARSVARIES7HILEWORLDWIDETHEMEDIANCOSTOFPHENOBARBITALISINTERNATIONALDOLLARSITISTHREEFOLDFORPHENYTOINELEVENFOLDFORCARBAMAZEPINEANDTIMESMOREFORVALPROICACID)NINTERNATIONALDOLLARSTHEMEDIANCOSTOFTREATMENTFOREPILEPSYISTHREEANDHALFTIMESHIGHERFORCARBAMAZEPINEPHENYTOIN

%8%#54)6%35--!29

ANDVALPROICACIDANDTWOTIMESHIGHERFORPHENOBARBITALINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES4HEINEQUITYINTHECOSTOFlRSTLINEANTIEPILEPTICDRUGSACROSSREGIONSCOUNTRIESANDINCOMECATEGORIESNEEDSTOBESPECIlCALLYCONFRONTED

4HEPRESENCEOFSUBSPECIALIZEDEPILEPSYSERVICESINDICATESTHELEVELOFORGANIZATIONANDDEVELOPMENTOFEPILEPSYCAREINACOUNTRY3UBSPECIALIZEDSERVICESAREIMPORTANTBECAUSEMANYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYREQUIREHIGHLYSPECIALIZEDSKILLSFORAPPROPRIATEDIAGNOSISANDMANAGEMENT3UCHSERVICESALSOPROVIDETHEBASISFORCONDUCTINGRESEARCHANDTRAINING4HERESPONDENTSREPORTEDAVAILABILITYOFSPECIALEDUCATIONINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESSOCIALREHABILITATIONINEPILEPSYSURGERYINANDSHELTEREDWORKIN4HEREISLARGEVARIATIONINTHEIRAVAILABILITYACROSSDIFFERENTINCOMEGROUPSOFCOUNTRIESEGEPILEPSYSURGERYISAVAILABLEINONLYOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES

3PECIALISTMEDICALPROFESSIONALSAREIMPORTANTMEMBERSOFTHETEAMPROVIDINGCOMPREHENSIVECAREESPECIALLYATTERTIARYLEVELFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY4HEYAREALSOESSENTIALFORTRAININGANDPROVIDINGSUPPORTANDSUPERVISIONTOPRIMARYHEALTHCAREPROVIDERSINEPILEPSYCARE4HERESPONDENTSWEREASKEDABOUTTHENUMBEROFSPECIALISTMEDICALPROFESSIONALSSUCHASNEUROLOGISTSNEUROPAEDIATRICIANSPSYCHIATRISTSANDNEUROSURGEONSSPENDINGORMOREOFTHEIRTIMEINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE4HISASSESSMENTISUSEDASAMARKEROFTHEIRPREDOMINANTINVOLVEMENTINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE!TOTALOFNEUROLOGISTSNEUROPAEDIATRICIANSPSYCHIATRISTSANDNEUROSURGEONSAREREPORTEDTOBEINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCAREINTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESANDCOUNTRIESREPORTEDNEUROLOGISTSNEUROPAEDIATRICIANSPSYCHIATRISTSANDNEUROSURGEONSRESPECTIVELY4HEMEDIANNUMBERSPERPOPULATIONOFNEUROLOGISTSNEUROPAEDIATRICIANSPSYCHIATRISTSANDNEUROSURGEONSINTHECOUNTRIESTHATREPORTTHEIRPRESENCEAREANDRESPECTIVELY4HEPERCENTAGEOFSPECIALISTMEDICALPROFESSIONALSINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINEPILEPSYCAREVARIESACROSSREGIONSANDINCOMEGROUPSOFCOUNTRIESEGOFTHETOTALNEUROLOGISTSAREINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCAREINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHINHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES-OREPSYCHIATRISTSAREINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINEPILEPSYCAREINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIESMEDIANPERPOPULATIONANDRESPECTIVELY/NEOFTHEPOSSIBLEREASONSFORTHISCOULDBETHEPRESENCEOFTHEPRACTICEWHEREPSYCHIATRISTSRATHERTHANNEUROLOGISTSTAKECAREOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY

0ROFESSIONALSALLIEDTOMEDICINESUCHASNEUROLOGICALNURSESPSYCHOLOGISTSANDSOCIALWORKERSAREIMPORTANTMEMBERSOFTHEMULTIDISCIPLINARYTEAMPROVIDINGCOMPREHENSIVECARETOPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY4HEYPLAYANIMPORTANTROLEINTHEDIAGNOSISTREATMENTANDREHABILITATIONOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY!TOTALNUMBEROFSUCHPROFESSIONALSINVOLVED

INEPILEPSYCAREEXISTINTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESANDCOUNTRIESREPORTEDNEUROLOGICALNURSESPSYCHOLOGISTSANDSOCIALWORKERSRESPECTIVELY4HEMEDIANNUMBERSPERPOPULATIONOFNEUROLOGICALNURSESPSYCHOLOGISTSANDSOCIALWORKERSINTHECOUNTRIESTHATREPORTTHEIRPRESENCEAREANDRESPECTIVELY,OWINCOMECOUNTRIESHAVEAMEDIANNUMBEROFPERPOPULATIONOFSOCIALWORKERSINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINEPILEPSYCAREWHEREASHIGHERMIDDLEANDHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIESHAVEANDPERPOPULATIONRESPECTIVELY4HEPERCENTAGEOFPROFESSIONALSALLIEDTOMEDICINEINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINEPILEPSYCAREISLOWEGONLYOFTHETOTALNUMBERSOFPSYCHOLOGISTSAREINVOLVEDPREDOMINANTLYINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE

%PILEPSYSPECIALISTSAREPROFESSIONALSINTHEHEALTHSECTORDEVOTEDPREDOMINANTLYTOPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE4HEYPLAYANIMPORTANTROLEINAWARENESSRAISINGADVOCACYANDEDUCATIONOFPROFESSIONALSPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYANDTHEGENERALPUBLIC4HESEASPECTSAREPERTINENTFORADISORDERSUCHASEPILEPSYWHERESOCIOCULTURALISSUESAREAMAJORBARRIERTOADEQUATETREATMENTANDREHABILITATION%PILEPSYSPECIALISTSAREREPORTEDTOBEAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES7HILETHEYPROVIDECARETOPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYINOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIESTHEYEXISTINONLYOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIES4HEMAINSERVICESPROVIDEDBYEPILEPSYSPECIALISTSINCLUDEPATIENTCAREBYDIAGNOSINGANDDOCUMENTINGCASESOFEPILEPSYANDCARRYINGOUTINVESTIGATIONSSUCHAS%%'ANDVIDEO%%'MONITORINGINOFTHECOUNTRIESPROVIDINGTREATMENTANDFOLLOWUPSERVICESPROVIDINGCONSULTATIONSERVICESFORREFERREDPATIENTSANDEDUCATIONSERVICESANDCOUNSELLINGTOPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYANDTHEGENERALPUBLICTHUSRAISINGAWARENESS

3PECIALISTTRAININGINEPILEPTOLOGYISNEEDEDONMULTIPLELEVELSTOREACHALLTHOSECONCERNEDWITHEPILEPSYMANAGEMENT4RAININGFACILITIESINEPILEPTOLOGYAREHOWEVERAVAILABLEINONLYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES.OFACILITYFORTRAININGINEPILEPTOLOGYISREPORTEDBYCOUNTRIESINTHE3OUTH%AST!SIA2EGIONWHEREASSUCHFACILITIESEXISTINOFTHECOUNTRIESIN!FRICAINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCINTHE!MERICASANDIN%UROPE%DUCATIONALMATERIALSINCLUDINGSTANDARDGUIDELINESFORDIAGNOSISANDCAREOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYOUGHTTOBEPRODUCEDANDDISTRIBUTEDINRESOURCEPOORCOUNTRIESWHERETRAININGFACILITIESCANNOTBEESTABLISHEDBECAUSEOFTHEHIGHCOSTSINVOLVED/PPORTUNITIESFORTHETRAININGOFPROFESSIONALSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCAREFROMLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESSHOULDALSOBEENCOURAGED

4HEPRESENCEOFPROFESSIONALORGANIZATIONSOFEPILEPSYSPECIALISTSISANIMPORTANTASPECTOFTHEPROVISIONOFTHEHIGHESTQUALITYOFCAREANDWELLBEINGFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYOROTHERRELATEDSEIZUREDISORDERS!PROFESSIONALORGANIZATIONOFEPILEPSYSPECIALISTSEXISTSINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESSUCHANORGANIZATIONDOESNOTEXISTINOFTHELOWINCOMECOUNTRIESORINOFTHEHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES4HEMEDIANNUMBEROFPROFESSIONALSPER

%8%#54)6%35--!29

POPULATIONWHOAREMEMBERSOFANORGANIZATIONOFEPILEPSYSPECIALISTSISIN!FRICACOMPAREDWITHIN%UROPE4HEPROFESSIONALORGANIZATIONSOFEPILEPSYSPECIALISTSAREMAINLYINVOLVEDINORGANIZINGPROFESSIONALMEETINGSANDCONFERENCESONEPILEPSYPUBLISHINGGUIDELINESANDRECOMMENDATIONSONEPILEPSYADVOCACYONEPILEPSYRELATEDISSUESANDADVISINGGOVERNMENTS!LARGENUMBEROFTHESEORGANIZATIONSWORKUNDERTHEUMBRELLAOF),!%LEADINGTOACOLLABORATIVEEFFORTINVARIOUSACTIVITIESRELATEDTOPATIENTCAREEDUCATIONTRAININGANDRESEARCH

4HELAYASSOCIATIONSHAVEASIGNIlCANTROLEINHANDLINGTHENONMEDICALASPECTSOFEPILEPSYINCLUDINGEDUCATIONEMPLOYMENTINSURANCEDRIVINGANDAWARENESSRAISINGTHESEACTIVITIESARECRUCIALINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCARE-ANYOFTHEPATIENTASSOCIATIONSAREMEMBERSOF)"%/FTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESHAVEATLEASTONEPATIENTORLAYASSOCIATIONWORKINGINTHElELDOFEPILEPSY.OPATIENTORLAYEPILEPSYASSOCIATIONEXISTSINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANIN!FRICAIN3OUTH%AST!SIAINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCINTHE!MERICASANDIN%UROPE

!DEQUATElNANCINGOFEPILEPSYSERVICESISESSENTIALTOPROVIDINGTHENEEDEDCARE(OWEVERONLYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESHAVEASEPARATEBUDGETFOREPILEPSYSERVICESWITHINTHEIRHEALTHBUDGETS/UTOFPOCKETPAYMENTTAXBASEDFUNDINGANDSOCIALINSURANCEARETHEPRIMARYMETHODSOFlNANCINGEPILEPSYCAREEACHMETHODBEINGUSEDINABOUTONETHIRDOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES0RIVATEINSURANCEANDPRIVATEFOUNDATIONSCONSTITUTEANDRESPECTIVELYASTHEPRIMARYMETHODOFlNANCING/UTOFPOCKETEXPENSESARETHEPRIMARYSOURCEOFlNANCINGEPILEPSYCAREIN!FRICA3OUTH%AST!SIAANDTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANSOCIALINSURANCEIN%UROPEANDTHE!MERICASANDTAXBASEDFUNDINGINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlC/UTOFPOCKETEXPENDITUREISTHEPRIMARYMETHODOFlNANCINGEPILEPSYCAREINOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES%PILEPSYSERVICESARESCARCEINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESANDONTOPOFTHATPATIENTSHAVETOPAYRESULTINGINFURTHERINEQUITYINTHEUTILIZATIONOFSERVICES%FFORTSNEEDTOBEMADETOINTRODUCESOMEFORMOFPUBLIClNANCINGINTOTHEHEALTHINFRASTRUCTUREOFCOUNTRIESTOCOVEREPILEPSYSERVICES

$ISABILITYBENElTSOFSOMEFORMFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYAREAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES$ISABILITYBENElTSAREAVAILABLEINONLYOFTHELOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES4HETYPESOFDISABILITYBENElTSAVAILABLEINCLUDEMONETARYBENElTSREHABILITATIONANDHEALTHBENElTSBENElTSATTHEWORKPLACEANDOTHERBENElTSINCLUDINGHOUSINGTRANSPORTEDUCATIONANDSPECIALDISCOUNTS%FFORTSNEEDTOBEMADETOADVOCATEBETTERPROVISIONOFBENElTSFORFUNCTIONALLYDISABLEDPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYESPECIALLYINRESOURCEPOORCOUNTRIESWHERETHEYAREMOSTNEEDED

!NORGANIZEDHEALTHREPORTINGSYSTEMISESSENTIALINASSESSINGTHESITUATIONSOASTOENABLETHEHEALTHPLANNERSTODECIDE

HOWTOUSEVARIOUSRESOURCES%PILEPSYISINCLUDEDINTHEANNUALHEALTHREPORTINGSYSTEMOFOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES%PIDEMIOLOGICALDATAFACILITATETHEGATHERINGOFINFORMATIONREGARDINGTHEDISEASEBURDENANDTRENDSANDHELPTOIDENTIFYTHEHIGHPRIORITYISSUES4HISINFORMATIONISHIGHLYUSEFULFORPLANNINGHEALTHSERVICESANDMONITORINGTRENDSOVERTIME!DATACOLLECTIONSYSTEMFOREPILEPSYEXISTSINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES%FFORTSNEEDTOBEMADETOINCREASETHENUMBEROFCOUNTRIESCOLLECTINGEPILEPSYDATA

-ANYCONSTRAINTSANDDIFlCULTIESHINDERTHEPROVISIONOFADEQUATEEPILEPSYCAREINCOUNTRIES1UALITATIVEDATAWEREALSOCOLLECTEDABOUTTHEMAJORPROBLEMSENCOUNTEREDBYHEALTHPROFESSIONALSANDPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY,ACKOFDRUGSUPPLYDUEEITHERTOLOGISTICSORTOECONOMYPOORCOMMUNITYKNOWLEDGEANDAWARENESSCULTURALBELIEFSSTIGMALACKOFGOVERNMENTRESOURCESPOORECONOMYANDLACKOFINFRASTRUCTUREAREIDENTIlEDASMAJORPROBLEMSBYBOTHHEALTHPROFESSIONALSANDPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY&ACTORSRELATEDTOHEALTHSERVICESINCLUDINGCAPITALANDHUMANRESOURCESAREIDENTIlEDMORECOMMONLYASMAJORPROBLEMSBYHEALTHPROFESSIONALSTHANBYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY,ACKOFSOCIALANDREHABILITATIONSUPPORTANDTHESOCIALBURDENOFTHEDISORDERHOWEVERAREIDENTIlEDMORECOMMONLYBYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYTHANBYHEALTHPROFESSIONALS4HESOCIALISSUESIDENTIlEDBYRESPONDENTSINCLUDEEMPLOYMENTDRIVINGMARRIAGESOCIALISOLATIONANDEDUCATIONOPPORTUNITIES4HETREATMENTGAPFOREPILEPSYTHUSHASTOBEUNDERSTOODINTERMSOFTHEECONOMICSOCIALPOLITICALANDCULTURALFRAMEWORKSWITHINWHICHITEXISTS!LLOFTHESEASPECTSNEEDTOBETACKLEDTODECREASETHETREATMENTGAP4HEREWEREDIFFERENCESREPORTEDINTHEPROBLEMSENCOUNTEREDAMONGVARIOUSREGIONSORINCOMECATEGORIES4HISMAYSUGGESTTHERELATIVEIMPORTANCEOFAPARTICULARISSUERATHERTHANITSABSOLUTEIMPORTANCEEGINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESAVAILABILITYOFEPILEPSYSURGERYISCONSIDEREDDESIRABLEBUTNOTAPRIMARYASSETTHATMUSTBEAVAILABLE!LSOTHEDATAREPRESENTTHEISSUESOFHIGHESTPRIORITYTHATNEEDIMMEDIATEIMPROVEMENT

/NTHEWHOLETHE%PILEPSY!TLASDATASHOWTHATTHEAVAILABLERESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCAREINTHEWORLDAREINSUFlCIENTWHENSETAGAINSTTHELARGENUMBERSOFPEOPLENEEDINGSUCHCAREANDTHEKNOWNSIGNIlCANTBURDENASSOCIATEDWITHTHISDISORDER)NADDITIONTHEREARELARGEINEQUITIESACROSSREGIONSANDINCOMEGROUPSOFCOUNTRIESWITHLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESHAVINGEXTREMELYMEAGRERESOURCES"ECAUSETHEPREVALENCEOFEPILEPSYISMUCHHIGHERANDRESOURCESAREMUCHLOWERINLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESTHE%PILEPSY!TLASREINFORCESTHENEEDFORURGENTSUBSTANTIALANDSYSTEMATICACTIONTOENHANCERESOURCESWITHINTHESECOUNTRIESFOREPILEPSYCARE

).42/$5#4)/.

4HEWORDEPILEPSYDERIVESFROMTHE'REEKEPILAMBANEINMEANINGTOBESEIZEDTOBEOVERWHELMEDBYSURPRISE%PILEPSYISONEOFTHEMOSTCOMMONSERIOUSDISORDERSOFTHEBRAINAFFECTINGATLEASTMILLIONPEOPLEWORLDWIDE)TKNOWSNOGEOGRAPHICALRACIALORSOCIALBOUNDARIES%PILEPSYACCOUNTSFOROFTHEGLOBALBURDENOFDISEASEDETERMINEDBYTHENUMBEROFPRODUCTIVELIFEYEARSLOSTASARESULTOFDISABILITYORPREMATUREDEATH!MONGPRIMARYDISORDERSOFTHEBRAINTHISBURDENRANKSWITHDEPRESSIONANDOTHERAFFECTIVEDISORDERS!LZHEIMERSDISEASEANDOTHERDEMENTIASANDSUBSTANCEABUSE!MONGALLMEDICALCONDITIONSITRANKSWITHBREASTCANCERINWOMENANDLUNGCANCERINMEN%IGHTYPERCENTOFTHEBURDENOFEPILEPSYISINTHEDEVELOPINGWORLDWHEREnOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYRECEIVENOTREATMENTATALL)TISALSONECESSARYTORECOGNIZETHATEPILEPSYCONSISTSOFMORETHANSEIZURESFORTHEAFFECTEDINDIVIDUALANDEFFECTSONHISORHERFAMILY%PILEPSYLEADSTOMULTIPLEINTERACTINGMEDICALPSYCHOLOGICALECONOMICANDSOCIALREPERCUSSIONSALLOFWHICHNEEDTOBECONSIDERED

&EARMISUNDERSTANDINGANDTHERESULTINGSOCIALSTIGMAANDDISCRIMINATIONSURROUNDINGEPILEPSYOFTENFORCEPEOPLEWITHTHISDISORDERhINTOTHESHADOWSv4HESOCIALEFFECTSMAYVARYFROMCOUNTRYTOCOUNTRYANDCULTURETOCULTUREBUTITISCLEARTHATALLOVERTHEWORLDTHESOCIALCONSEQUENCESOFEPILEPSYAREOFTENMOREDIFlCULTTOOVERCOMETHANTHESEIZURESTHEMSELVES3IGNIlCANTPROBLEMSAREOFTENEXPERIENCEDBYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYINTHEAREASOFPERSONALRELATIONSHIPSANDSOMETIMESLEGISLATION4HESEPROBLEMSMAYINTURNUNDERMINETHETREATMENTOFEPILEPSY

4OBRINGEPILEPSYhOUTOFTHESHADOWSvA'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSYWASLAUNCHEDINhTOIMPROVEACCEPTABILITYTREATMENTSERVICESANDPREVENTIONOFEPILEPSYWORLDWIDEv4HE#AMPAIGNISCONDUCTEDBYTHE7ORLD(EALTH/RGANIZATION7(/INPARTNERSHIPWITHTHE)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY),!%ANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY)"%4HEAIMOFTHE#AMPAIGNISPRINCIPALLYTOREDUCETHETREATMENTGAPBYPROVIDINGBETTERINFORMATIONABOUTEPILEPSYANDITSCONSEQUENCESANDTOASSISTGOVERNMENTSANDTHOSECONCERNEDWITHEPILEPSYTOREDUCETHEBURDENOFTHEDISORDER

-AJORADVANCESINTHEUNDERSTANDINGANDTREATMENTOFEPILEPSYHAVEOCCURREDINTHELASTCENTURYANDRESEARCHHASBEENCARRIEDOUTONTHEEPIDEMIOLOGICALDIAGNOSTICANDSOCIALASPECTSOFTHEDISORDER.OTMUCHINFORMATIONEXISTSHOWEVERREGARDINGTHERESOURCESAVAILABLEWITHINTHECOUNTRIESTOTACKLETHEHUGEMEDICALSOCIALANDECONOMICBURDENCAUSEDBYEPILEPSY4HEINFORMATIONTHATEXISTSCANNOTBECOMPAREDACROSSCOUNTRIESBECAUSEVARYINGDElNITIONSANDUNITSOFMEASUREMENTAREUSED,ACKOFINFORMATIONABOUTEXISTINGRESOURCESISAMAJORIMPEDIMENTFORTHEPOLICYMAKERSATLOCALNATIONALANDINTERNATIONALLEVELFORPLANNINGAPPROPRIATESERVICESFOREPILEPSYCARE)NORDERTO

IMPROVETHEAVAILABILITYOFRESOURCESINTHECOUNTRIESACCURATEINFORMATIONABOUTEXISTINGRESOURCESISCRUCIAL

)NORDERTOlLLTHEINFORMATIONGAPABOUTTHERESOURCESAVAILABLEFORCAREOFPATIENTSWITHMENTALANDNEUROLOGICALDISORDERS7(/LAUNCHED0ROJECT!TLASINAIMEDATCOLLECTINGCOMPILINGANDDISSEMINATINGINFORMATIONANDDATAONTHEEXISTINGRESOURCESANDSERVICES4HElRSTDOCUMENTINTHESERIESWASPUBLISHEDINASTHE!TLASOFMENTALHEALTHRESOURCESINTHEWORLDFOLLOWEDBYTHE!TLASOFCOUNTRYRESOURCESFORNEUROLOGICALDISORDERSIN"ECAUSEEPILEPSYCAREISONEOFTHEPRIORITYAREASOF7(/TOBRIDGETHEINFORMATIONGAPINTHISAREAITWASDECIDEDTOEXPAND0ROJECT!TLASINTOTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYANDTOCONDUCTASURVEYOFCOUNTRYRESOURCESAVAILABLEFOREPILEPSYCARE4HEMAINOBJECTIVESOFTHISLARGEINTERNATIONALSTUDYWERETOOBTAINEXPERTOPINIONABOUT

UAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYANDPROBLEMSENCOUNTEREDBYPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYANDHEALTHPROFESSIONALSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCARE

UAVAILABILITYOFEPILEPSYTREATMENTSANDSERVICESINCLUDINGANTIEPILEPTICDRUGS

UNUMBERANDTYPESOFHEALTHPROFESSIONALSINVOLVEDINTHEDELIVERYOFEPILEPSYCARE

UCHARACTERISTICSOFTRAININGINEPILEPTOLOGY

UBUDGETANDlNANCINGFOREPILEPSYCAREINCLUDINGVARIOUSTYPESOFHEALTHINSURANCEANDDISABILITYBENElTS

UPRESENCEANDCHARACTERISTICSOFINFORMATIONANDEPIDEMIOLOGICALDATACOLLECTIONSYSTEMSFOREPILEPSY

UAVAILABILITYROLEANDINVOLVEMENTOFPROFESSIONALPATIENTANDLAYASSOCIATIONSFOREPILEPSY

4HE%PILEPSY!TLASHASBEENANIMPORTANTACTIVITYOFTHE'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY4HESTUDYREPRESENTSAMAJORCOLLABORATIVEEFFORTINVOLVING7(/HEADQUARTERSREGIONALANDCOUNTRYOFlCES),!%AND)"%4HE%PILEPSY!TLASPROVIDESANILLUSTRATIVEPRESENTATIONOFDATAANDINFORMATIONONTHECURRENTSTATUSOFEPILEPSYSERVICESANDCAREAVAILABLEINDIFFERENTPARTSOFTHEWORLD)TISHOPEDTHATTHE%PILEPSY!TLASDATAWILLSTIMULATEGLOBALANDNATIONALEPILEPSYPROGRAMMES)TWILLBEAUSEFULREFERENCEGUIDEFORHEALTHPROFESSIONALSPLANNERSANDPOLICYMAKERSATNATIONALASWELLASINTERNATIONALLEVELSHELPINGTHEMINPLANNINGDEVELOPINGANDPROVIDINGBETTERCAREANDSERVICESFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYTHROUGHOUTTHEWORLD

-%4(/$/,/'9

!LLTHEINFORMATIONANDDATACONTAINEDINTHE%PILEPSY!TLASHAVEBEENCOLLECTEDINALARGEINTERNATIONALSURVEYWHICHWASCARRIEDOUTINTHEPERIODnANDINCLUDEDCOUNTRIESAREASORTERRITORIES

$ATACOLLECTION

4HE%PILEPSY!TLASISBASEDONTHEINFORMATIONANDDATACOLLECTEDBY7(/INCOLLABORATIONWITH),!%AND)"%WITHINTHEFRAMEWORKOFTHE'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSY!T7(/THEWORKWASLEDBYHEADQUARTERSINCLOSECOLLABORATIONWITHTHEREGIONALOFlCES4HElRSTSTEPINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHE%PILEPSY!TLASWASTOIDENTIFYSPECIlCAREASWHEREINFORMATIONRELATEDTORESOURCESANDSERVICESFOREPILEPSYCAREWASLACKING)NORDERTOOBTAINTHISINFORMATIONAQUESTIONNAIREWASDRAFTEDIN%NGLISHINCONSULTATIONWITHAGROUPOF7(/AND),!%)"%CONSULTANTS!GLOSSARYOFTERMSUSEDINTHEQUESTIONNAIREWASALSOPREPAREDINORDERTOENSURETHATTHEQUESTIONSWEREUNDERSTOODINTHESAMEWAYBYDIFFERENTRESPONDENTS3UBSEQUENTLYTHEDRAFTQUESTIONNAIREANDGLOSSARYWEREREVIEWEDBYSELECTEDEXPERTS4HEQUESTIONNAIREWASPILOTEDINONEHIGHINCOMEANDONELOWINCOMECOUNTRYANDNECESSARYCHANGESWEREMADE4HEQUESTIONNAIREANDTHEGLOSSARYWERETHENTRANSLATEDINTOSOMEOFTHEOTHEROFlCIALLANGUAGESOF7(/n!RABIC&RENCH2USSIANAND3PANISH

4HEQUESTIONNAIREANDGLOSSARYWERESENTTOTHEOFlCIALDELEGATESOFALLTHE#HAPTERSOF),!%)"%)NADDITION7(/REGIONALOFlCESWEREALSOASKEDTOIDENTIFYAKEYPERSONWORKINGINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYINTHOSECOUNTRIESWHERETHE),!%)"%LIAISONPERSONWASNOTAVAILABLEORNOTRESPONSIVE4HEKEYPERSONSWEREREQUESTEDTOCOMPLETETHEQUESTIONNAIREBASEDONALLPOSSIBLESOURCESOFINFORMATIONAVAILABLETOTHEM!LLRESPONDENTSWEREASKEDTOFOLLOWCLOSELYTHEGLOSSARYDElNITIONSINORDERTOMAINTAINUNIFORMITYANDCOMPARABILITYOFRECEIVEDINFORMATION4HE%PILEPSY!TLASPROJECTTEAMRESPONDEDTOQUESTIONSANDREQUESTSFORCLARIlCATION2EPEATREQUESTSWERESENTTOTHEKEYPERSONSINCASESWHERETHEREWASDELAYINPROCURINGTHECOMPLETEDQUESTIONNAIRE)NTHECASEOFINCOMPLETEORINTERNALLYINCONSISTENTINFORMATIONTHERESPONDENTSWERECONTACTEDTOPROVIDEFURTHERINFORMATIONORCLARIlCATIONWHEREAPPROPRIATEDOCUMENTSWEREREQUESTEDTOSUPPORTCOMPLETEDQUESTIONNAIRES

2ECEIVEDDATAWEREENTEREDINTOANELECTRONICDATABASESYSTEMUSINGSUITABLECODESANDANALYSEDUSING3TATASPECIALEDITIONVERSIONSOFTWARE6ALUESFORCONTINUOUSVARIABLESWEREGROUPEDINTOCATEGORIESBASEDONDISTRIBUTION&REQUENCYDISTRIBUTIONSANDMEASURESOFCENTRALTENDENCYMEANMEDIANSANDSTANDARDDEVIATIONSWERECALCULATEDASAPPROPRIATE#OUNTRIESWEREGROUPEDINTOTHESIX7(/REGIONS!FRICATHE!MERICAS3OUTH%AST!SIA%UROPE%AST

ERN-EDITERRANEANAND7ESTERN0ACIlCANDFOUR7ORLD"ANKINCOMECATEGORIESACCORDINGTOGROSSNATIONALINCOME'.)PERCAPITAACCORDINGTOTHE7ORLD"ANKLISTOFECONOMIES!PRIL4HE'.)GROUPSWEREASFOLLOWSLOWINCOME53ORLESSLOWERMIDDLEINCOME53nUPPERMIDDLEINCOME53nANDHIGHINCOME53ORMORE4HERESULTSOFTHEANALYSISAREPRESENTEDINTHE%PILEPSY!LTAS

2EPRESENTATIVENESSOFDATACOLLECTED

#OMPLETEDQUESTIONNAIRESWERERECEIVEDFROMVARIOUS7(/-EMBER3TATESAREASORTERRITORIES-EMBER3TATESOUTOFATOTALOFONE!SSOCIATE-EMBER4OKELAUANDFOURTERRITORIESWHICHAREHENCEFORTHREFERREDTOASCOUNTRIESFORTHESAKEOFCONVENIENCE&ROMTHE-EMBER3TATESDATAWEREAVAILABLEFROMCOUNTRIESINTHE!FRICAN2EGIONCOUNTRIESINTHE2EGIONOFTHE!MERICASCOUNTRIESINTHE3OUTH%AST!SIA2EGIONCOUNTRIESINTHE%UROPEAN2EGIONCOUNTRIESINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEAN2EGIONANDCOUNTRIESINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlC2EGION)NTERMSOFPOPULATIONCOVEREDTHEDATAPERTAINTOOFTHEWORLDPOPULATIONOFTHEPOPULATIONIN!FRICAINTHE!MERICASIN3OUTH%AST!SIAIN%UROPEINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANANDINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlC

,IMITATIONSU4HEMOSTIMPORTANTLIMITATIONOFTHEDATASETISTHATONLYONEKEYPERSONINEACHCOUNTRYWASTHESOURCEOFALLINFORMATION!LTHOUGHTHERESPONDENTWASAN),!%)"%#HAPTEROFlCIALANDWASABLETOCONSULTOTHERLOCALPEOPLEWORKINGINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYANDNUMEROUSSOURCESOFINFORMATIONTHERECEIVEDDATASHOULDSTILLBECONSIDEREDASTHEBESTESTIMATESBYTHERESPONDENTS)NSPITEOFTHISLIMITATIONTHE%PILEPSY!TLASISTHEMOSTCOMPREHENSIVECOMPILATIONOFRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYINTHEWORLDEVERATTEMPTED

U"ECAUSETHESOURCESOFINFORMATIONINMOSTCOUNTRIESWERETHEKEYPERSONSWORKINGINTHElELDOFEPILEPSYTHEDATASETMAINLYCOVERSCOUNTRIESWHERETHEREAREEXPERTSOROTHERSWITHANINTERESTINEPILEPSY

U#ERTAINQUESTIONSESPECIALLYINRELATIONTORESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCAREWEREFRAMEDINSUCHAWAYTHATRESPONSESCOULDBEhYESvORhNOv!LTHOUGHTHISFACILITATEDARAPIDGATHERINGOFINFORMATIONITFAILEDTOTAKEACCOUNTOFDIFFERENCESINCOVERAGEANDQUALITY2ESPONDENTSMAYHAVEREPLIEDPOSITIVELYTOTHEQUESTIONOFAVAILABILITYOFEPILEPSYSERVICESINTHECOUNTRYEVENIFONLYAVERYLIMITEDNUMBEROFSUCHFACILITIESWEREAVAILABLEINAFEWLARGECITIES!LSO

-%4(/$/,/'9

THERESPONSEDOESNOTPROVIDEINFORMATIONABOUTDISTRIBUTIONACROSSRURALORURBANSETTINGSORACROSSDIFFERENTREGIONSWITHINTHECOUNTRY

U7HILEATTEMPTSHAVEBEENMADETOOBTAINALLTHEREQUIREDINFORMATIONFROMALLCOUNTRIESINSOMECOUNTRIESITWASNOTAVAILABLE(ENCETHEDENOMINATORFORVARIOUSTHEMESISDIFFERENTANDTHISHASBEENINDICATEDWITHEACHTHEME4HEMOSTCOMMONREASONFORMISSINGDATAWASTHENONAVAILABILITYOFTHEINFORMATIONINTHECOUNTRY

U4HEDATAREGARDINGNUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYREPRESENTANESTIMATEANDHAVENOTBEENCOLLECTEDANDCALCULATEDUSINGSTRINGENTEPIDEMIOLOGICALRESEARCHMETHODSASFORPREVALENCESTUDIES

U)TISPOSSIBLETHATDElNITIONSFORVARIOUSTERMSVARYFROMCOUNTRYTOCOUNTRY!SARESULTCOUNTRIESMAYHAVEHADDIFlCULTIESININTERPRETINGTHEDElNITIONSPROVIDEDINTHEGLOSSARY4HEDElNITIONSREGARDINGVARIOUSHUMANRESOURCESFOREXAMPLEMAYNEEDTOBEAMENDEDANDEXPANDEDINFUTURE

U7HILEALLPOSSIBLEMEASURESHAVEBEENTAKENTOCOMPILECODEANDINTERPRETTHEINFORMATIONGIVENBYCOUNTRIESUSINGUNIFORMDElNITIONSANDCRITERIAITISPOSSIBLETHATSOMEERRORSMAYHAVEOCCURREDDURINGDATAHANDLING

$ATAORGANIZATIONANDPRESENTATION

4HEINFORMATIONINTHE%PILEPSY!TLASISPRESENTEDINFOURBROADSECTIONS4HEDATAINCLUDEDAREORGANIZEDINTHEMESANDAREPRESENTEDASGRAPHICSWORLDMAPSANDWRITTENTEXT"ARANDPIECHARTSAREPROVIDEDTOILLUSTRATEFREQUENCIESMEDIANSANDMEANSASAPPROPRIATE"ECAUSETHEDISTRIBUTIONOFMOSTOFTHEDATAISSKEWEDTHEMEDIANHASBEENUSEDTODEPICTTHECENTRALTENDENCYOFTHEVARIOUSVARIABLES4HETERMSUSEDINTHEPROCESSOFCOLLECTINGTHEDATAARECONTAINEDINTHE'LOSSARYPAGE)TWASNOTPOSSIBLETOPRESENTALLTHElNDINGSFROMTHEANALYSES4HERESULTSAREPRESENTEDASGLOBALREGIONALANDBYINCOMECATEGORIESWITHINEACHTHEME,IMITATIONSSPECIlCTOEACHTHEMEARETOBEKEPTINMINDWHENINTERPRETINGTHEDATAANDTHEIRANALYSES3ELECTEDIMPLICATIONSOFTHElNDINGSFORFURTHERDEVELOPMENTOFRESOURCESFOREPILEPSYCAREAREHIGHLIGHTEDWITHEACHTHEME4HE%PILEPSY!TLASALSOINCLUDESBRIEFREVIEWSOFSELECTEDTOPICSSUMMARIZINGTHEMEDICALLIFESTYLESOCIALANDECONOMICISSUESSURROUNDINGPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY

%PILEPSYTHEDISORDER

%0),%0394(%$)3/2$%2

0ROF%DWARD(2EYNOLDS

-),%34/.%3).4(%()34/29/&%0),%039

)NTRODUCTION

%PILEPSYISACOMMONMEDICALANDSOCIALDISORDERORGROUPOFDISORDERSWITHUNIQUECHARACTERISTICS%PILEPSYISUSUALLYDElNEDASATENDENCYTORECURRENTSEIZURES4HEWORDhEPILEPSYvISDERIVEDFROM,ATINAND'REEKWORDSFORhSEIZUREvORhTOSEIZEUPONv4HISIMPLIESTHATEPILEPSYISANANCIENTDISORDERINDEEDINALLCIVILIZATIONSITCANBETRACEDASFARBACKASMEDICALRECORDSEXIST)NFACTEPILEPSYISADISORDERTHATCANOCCURINALLMAMMALIANSPECIESPROBABLYMOREFREQUENTLYASBRAINSHAVEBECOMEMORECOMPLEX%PILEPSYISALSOREMARKABLYUNIFORMLYDISTRIBUTEDAROUNDTHEWORLD4HEREARENORACIALGEOGRAPHICALORSOCIALCLASSBOUNDARIES)TOCCURSINBOTHSEXESATALLAGESESPECIALLYINCHILDHOODADOLESCENCEANDINCREASINGLYINAGEINGPOPULATIONS

4HEPERIODICCLINICALFEATURESOFSEIZURESAREOFTENDRAMATICANDALARMINGANDFREQUENTLYELICITFEARANDMISUNDERSTANDING4HISINTURNHASLEDTOPROFOUNDSOCIALCONSEQUENCESFORSUFFERERSWHICHHASGREATLYADDEDTOTHEBURDENOFTHISDISEASE)NANCIENTTIMESEPILEPTICATTACKSWERETHOUGHTTOBETHERESULTOFINVASIONANDPOSSESSIONOFTHEBODYBYSUPERNATURALFORCESUSUALLYMALIGNOREVILINmUENCESREQUIRINGEXORCISMINCANTATIONSOROTHERRELIGIOUSORSOCIALAPPROACHES4ODAYSEIZURESAREVIEWEDASELECTROMAGNETICDISCHARGESINTHEBRAININPREDISPOSEDINDIVIDUALSATTRIBUTABLEINPARTTOPUTATIVEGENETICFACTORSUNDERLYINGNEUROLOGICALDISORDERSANDLARGELYUNKNOWNNEUROCHEMICALMECHANISMS!WIDERANGEOFDIFFERENTSEIZURETYPESANDEPILEPSYSYNDROMESHAVEBEENIDENTIlED0ATIENTSARENOWTREATEDWITHPHARMACOTHERAPYOCCASIONALLYWITHNEUROSURGICALTECHNIQUESASWELLASWITHPSYCHOLOGICALANDSOCIALSUPPORT(OWHAVEWEARRIVEDATTHISTRANSFORMATIONINOURUNDERSTANDINGOFEPILEPSY7HATHAVEBEENTHEMILESTONESALONGTHEWAY

!NCIENTDESCRIPTIONSANDCONCEPTS

4HEEARLIESTDETAILEDACCOUNTOFEPILEPSYISINTHE"RITISH-USEUM,ONDON)TISPARTOFA"ABYLONIANTEXTONMEDICINE3AKIKKU;!LLDISEASES=WHICHWASWRITTENOVERYEARSAGOIEBEFORE"#)HAVEHADTHEPRIVILEGEOFWORKINGWITHA"ABYLONIANSCHOLAR*AMES+INNIER7ILSONONTHETRANSLATIONOFTHISTEXT&IGURE4HE"ABYLONIANSWEREKEENOBSERVERSOFCLINICALPHENOMENAANDPROVIDEREMARKABLEDESCRIPTIONSOFMANYOFTHESEIZURETYPESMIQTUTHATWERECOGNIZETODAYINCLUDINGWHATWEWOULDCALLTONICCLONICSEIZURESABSENCESDROPATTACKSSIMPLEANDCOMPLEXPARTIALSEIZURESANDEVENFOCALMOTOR*ACKSONIANORGELASTICATTACKS4HEYALSOUNDERSTOODSOMEASPECTSOFPROGNOSISINCLUDINGDEATHINSTATUSASWELLASPOSTICTALPHENOMENA4HE"ABYLONIANSHADNOCONCEPTOFPATHOLOGYHOWEVERANDEACHSEIZURETYPEWASASSOCIATEDWITHINVASIONOFTHEBODYBYAPARTICULARNAMEDEVILSPIRIT4HUSTREATMENTWASNOTMEDICALBUTSPIRITUAL

4HISSUPERNATURALVIEWHASDOMINATEDTHINKINGABOUTEPILEPSYUNTILQUITERECENTLYANDEVENNOWREMAINSADEEPLYROOTEDNEGATIVESOCIALINmUENCEINSOMEPARTSOFTHEWORLD)TWASHOWEVERUNSUCCESSFULLYCHALLENGEDBYTHE3CHOOLOF(IPPOCRATESINTHCENTURY"#'REECEWHICHlRSTSUGGESTEDTHATTHEBRAINWASTHESEATOFTHISDISORDERASITWASTHEMEDIATORALSOOFTHEINTELLECTBEHAVIOURANDTHEEMOTIONS)NAFAMOUSTEXT(IPPOCRATESSTATEDh)DONOTBELIEVETHATTHE3ACRED$ISEASEISANYMOREDIVINETHANANYOTHERDISEASEBUTONTHECONTRARYHASSPECIlCCHARACTERISTICSANDADElNITECAUSE.EVERTHELESSBECAUSEITISCOMPLETELYDIFFERENTFROMOTHERDISEASESITHASBEENREGARDEDASADIVINEVISITATIONBYTHOSEWHOBEINGONLYHUMANVIEWITWITHIGNORANCEANDASTONISHMENT4HEBRAINISTHESEATOFTHISDISEASEASITISOFOTHERVERYVIOLENTDISEASESv)NTERESTINGLY(IPPOCRATESALSOHADSOMENOTIONTHATEPILEPSYCOULDBECOMECHRONICANDINTRACTABLEIFNOTTREATEDEARLYANDEFFECTIVELYALTHOUGHITISNOTCLEAREXACTLYWHATTREATMENTSHEHADINMINDh-OREOVERITCANBECUREDNOLESSTHANOTHERDISEASESSOLONGASITHASNOTBECOMEINVETERATEANDTOOPOWERFULFORTHEDRUGSWHICHAREGIVEN7HENTHEMALADYBECOMESCHRONICITBECOMESINCURABLEv

5NFORTUNATELYTHE(IPPOCRATICCONCEPTOFATREATABLEBRAINDISORDERHADLITTLEINmUENCEONTHEPREVAILINGSUPERNATURALVIEWASISWELLDESCRIBEDINTHESCHOLARLYHISTORYOFEPILEPSYFROMTHE'REEKSTOTHELATETHCENTURYBY4EMKIN

%PILEPSYASABRAINDISORDER

)TWASNOTUNTILTHETHANDTHCENTURIESTHATTHE(IPPOCRATICCONCEPTOFEPILEPSYASABRAINDISORDERBEGANTOTAKEROOTIN%UROPEnILLUSTRATEDFOREXAMPLEBYANh%SSAYOFTHEPATHOLOGYOFTHEBRAINANDNERVOUSSTOCKINWHICHCONVULSIVEDISEASESARETREATEDOFvBY4HOMAS7ILLIS$URINGTHESETWOCENTURIESEPILEPSYWASONEOFSEVERALKEYAREASOFDEBATEINTHEGRADUALIDENTIlCATIONANDSEPARATIONOFhNERVOUSDISORDERSvFROMhMENTALDISORDERSvWHICHLEDTOTHEBEGINNINGSOFMODERNNEUROLOGYINTHETHCENTURY!MAJORISSUEWASWHATTOINCLUDEWITHINTHECONCEPTOFEPILEPSYIEALLPERIODIChCONVULSIVEDISEASESvORONLYTHOSEWITHARATHERRESTRICTEDKINDOFMOTORCONVULSIONWITHORWITHOUTLOSSOFCONSCIOUSNESS4HUSMANYTREATISESONCONVULSIVEDISEASESAPPEAREDWHICHINCLUDEDHYSTERIATETANUSTREMORSRIGORSANDOTHERPAROXYSMALMOVEMENTDISORDERS4HELATTERWEREGRADUALLYSEPARATEDOFFFROMEPILEPSYINTHETHCENTURYASILLUSTRATEDINTHEDISTINGUISHED,UMLEIAN,ECTURESONCONVULSIVEDISEASESBY2OBERT"ENTLEY4ODDINAND*ACKSONIN

7ITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOFNEUROPATHOLOGYASANEWDISCIPLINEINTHETHCENTURYTHEREALSOBEGANAGREATDEBATEWHICHISSTILLWITHUSTOSOMEEXTENTASTOTHEDISTINCTIONBETWEENPUREPRIMARYIDIOPATHICEPILEPSYINWHICHTHEBRAINISMACROSCOPICALLYNORMALFROMSECONDARYSYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYASSOCIATEDWITHMANYDIFFERENTBRAINPATHOLOGIES

-),%34/.%3).4(%()34/29/&%0),%039

!LSOINTHETHCENTURYWITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHECONCEPTOFFUNCTIONALLOCALIZATIONINTHEBRAINANDTHEDISCOVERYFOREXAMPLEOFTHEMOTORCORTEXTHECONCEPTOFhEPILEPTIFORMvORhPARTIALvSEIZURESAROSEASMODELSFORTHESTUDYOFhGENERALIZEDvSEIZURES"YMETICULOUSLYSTUDYINGTHECLINICALFEATURESOFUNILATERALEPILEPTIFORMMOTORSEIZURES*ACKSONWASABLETOCONCLUDEASWASLATERCONlRMEDEXPERIMENTALLYTHATTHEMOTORCORTEXWASCONCERNEDWITHMOVEMENTSRATHERTHANINDIVIDUALMUSCLES0AROXYSMALEPISODESOFANINTELLECTUALEMOTIONALORBEHAVIOURALKINDINCLUDINGHYSTERIAORhHYSTEROEPILEPSYvWEREMOREDIFlCULTTOCLASSIFYANDLOCALIZEITWASNOTUNTILTHEDISCOVERYOFHUMANELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY%%'INTHETHCENTURYTHATTHECONCEPTSOFTEMPORALLOBEORFRONTALEPILEPSYWEREGRADUALLYCLARIlEDANDPSYCHOLOGICALCONCEPTSOFHYSTERIAEVOLVED

%LECTRICALBASISOFEPILEPSY

!STHECONCEPTOFABRAINDISORDERGRADUALLYTOOKHOLDBETWEENTHETHANDTHCENTURIESITWASWIDELYBELIEVEDTHATEPILEPSYMUSTHAVEAVASCULARBASISATTRIBUTABLETOEITHERACUTEANAEMIAORACUTECONGESTIONOFTHEBRAIN4HISVIEWWASCHALLENGEDBY4ODDWHOWASTHElRSTTODEVELOPANELECTRICALTHEORYOFBRAINFUNCTIONANDOFEPILEPSYINHIS,UMLEIAN,ECTURESOF4ODDWASANANATOMISTPHYSIOLOGISTANDPATHOLOGISTASWELLASANOUTSTANDINGPHYSICIANWITHANINTERESTINDISORDERSOFTHENERVOUSSYSTEM(EWASAWAREOFTHEGREATNEWDISCOVERIESINELECTROMAGNETISMTHROUGHHISCONTACTWITHHISCONTEMPORARYIN,ONDON-ICHAEL&ARADAYTHEGREATESTELECTRICALSCIENTISTOFALLTIME)NmUENCEDBY&ARADAY4ODDCONCEIVEDOFhNERVOUSFORCEvASAPOLARFORCEANALOGOUSTOELECTRICITYBUTMEDIATEDBYUNKNOWNMOLECULARORNUTRITIONALMECHANISMS(ETHEREFOREPREFERREDTHETERMhNERVOUSPOLARITYv!PPLYING&ARADAYSCONCEPTOFhDISRUPTIVEDISCHARGEvHEVIEWEDSEIZURESASTHERESULTOFELECTRICALDISCHARGESINTHEBRAINWHICHHECONlRMEDEXPERIMENTALLYINTHERABBITUSING&ARADAYSRECENTLYDISCOVEREDMAGNETOELECTRICROTATIONMACHINE

)TISOFTENTAUGHTTHAT*ACKSONWASTHElRSTTODEVELOPANELECTRICALTHEORYOFEPILEPSYWITHHISFAMOUSSTATEMENTTHATh%PILEPSYISTHENAMEFOROCCASIONALSUDDENEXCESSIVERAPIDANDLOCALDISCHARGESOFGREYMATTERv)TISDIFlCULTTOUNDERSTANDWHYINHIS,UMLEIAN,ECTURESOF*ACKSONDIDNOTACKNOWLEDGE4ODDSLECTURESONTHESAMESUBJECTYEARSEARLIER(OWEVERITISAPPARENTTHATTHE*ACKSONTHEORYWASNOTANELECTRICALONE!S'OWERSMAKESCLEAR*ACKSONSCONCEPTOFDISCHARGEWASAVAGUEONEOFADISCHARGEOFENERGYASFOREXAMPLEINABENTPINORSPRING*ACKSONSUPPOSEDTHEhLIBERATIONOFENERGYDURINGRAPIDDECOMPOSITIONKATABOLISMOFSOMEMATTERINORPARTOFTHOSECELLSv

!SAPHILOSOPHERPHYSICIANITISDOUBTFULIF*ACKSONHADANYSIGNIlCANTGRASPOFELECTROMAGNETISMINANERABEFORETHE

DISCOVERYOFTHEHUMAN%%')NFACTITWASONLYABOUTTHISTIMETHAT#ATONlRSTDISCOVEREDTHE%%'INRABBITSCATSANDMONKEYS"UTITWASNOTUNTILYEARSLATERINTHAT"ERGERREPORTEDTHEDISCOVERYOFTHEHUMAN%%'4HISLEDRAPIDLYTOTHECONlRMATIONTHATSEIZURESWERETHERESULTOFELECTRICALDISCHARGESINTHEBRAINFOREXAMPLEBY,ENNOXATTHE.EUROLOGICAL#ONGRESSIN,ONDONWHEREHEALSOlNALLYLAIDTORESTTHESTILLWIDELYBELIEVEDVASCULARTHEORIESOFEPILEPSY

)N(ODGKIN(UXLEYMADETHE.OBEL0RIZEWINNINGDISCOVERIESOFTHEIONICBASISOF4ODDSNERVOUSPOLARITYFORCE)NTERESTINGLYITWAS&ARADAYSMENTORATTHE2OYAL)NSTITUTIONIN,ONDON3IR(UMPHRY$AVYWHODISCOVEREDSODIUMPOTASSIUMCHLORINECALCIUMANDMAGNESIUMAMONGOTHERELEMENTS

4HEMODERNERA

)TISPREMATURETOASSESSRECENTDEVELOPMENTSINHISTORICALTERMSBUTINTHESECONDHALFOFTHETHCENTURYREMARKABLEPROGRESSWASMADEINDIAGNOSTICFACILITIESANDPOSSIBILITIESTHROUGHSTRUCTURALANDFUNCTIONALNEUROIMAGINGINCLUDING#!4AND-2)ASWELLASINVIDEOTELEMETRYANDMAGNETOENCEPHALOGRAPHY

4HEMODERNERAOFPHARMACOTHERAPYPROBABLYBEGANWITHBROMIDESPHENOBARBITALnSTILLTHEMOSTWIDELYUSEDDRUGINTHEWORLDnANDPHENYTOIN)NRECENTDECADESTHEREHASBEENAPROLIFERATIONOFNEWDRUGSINTHEDEVELOPEDWORLDFOREXAMPLENINEINTHE5NITED+INGDOMINTHELASTYEARS4OWHATEXTENTNEWERDRUGSAREMOREORLESSEFFECTIVESELECTIVEORTOXICTHANOLDERDRUGSISSTILLAMATTEROFDEBATEANDEVALUATIONASISTHEROLEOFPOLYTHERAPYINTHEEVENTOFFAILUREOFCAREFULLYMONITOREDMONOTHERAPY4HEMECHANISMSOFACTIONOFTHEDRUGSARELARGELYUNKNOWNANDITISUNCERTAINWHETHERTHEDRUGSMERELYSUPPRESSSEIZURESORINmUENCELONGERTERMPROGNOSISTHROUGHhARRESTINGvEPILEPSYOROTHERANTIEPILEPTICMECHANISMS

4HEFUNCTIONALLOCALIZATIONDETECTEDBYSTUDYINGFOCALORPARTIALSEIZURESPLAYEDAKEYROLEINDEVELOPINGNEUROSURGERYINTHELATETHCENTURYASDIDTHEDEVELOPMENTOFTHE%%'INTHElRSTHALFOFTHETHCENTURY4HEMODERNINTERESTINNEUROSURGERYFOREPILEPSYITSELFESPECIALLYINTRACTABLESEIZURESASSOCIATEDWITHFOCALCORTICALLESIONSINCLUDINGTEMPORALLOBEEPILEPSYWASPIONEEREDBY(ORSLEY0ENlELDAND&ALCONERAMONGOTHERS

4HEMODERNERAISALSOMARKEDBYANEXPANSIONOFINTERESTINBASICMECHANISMSUNDERLYINGSEIZURESANDEPILEPSIESSTIMULATEDBYDEVELOPMENTSINGENETICSMOLECULARBIOLOGYNEUROPHYSIOLOGYFUNCTIONALIMAGINGANDNUMEROUSNEUROCHEMICALTECHNIQUESFOREXPLORINGTHECONCEPTSOFEXCITATIONINHIBITIONMODULATIONNEUROTRANSMISSIONANDSYNCHRONIZATION%VERYADVANCESEEMSTOADDTOTHEENOR

MOUSCOMPLEXITYOFTHENERVOUSSYSTEMANDTHEPROBABILITYTHATMULTIPLEELUSIVEGENETICnMOLECULARnMETABOLICMECHANISMSCONTRIBUTETOTHEWIDERANGEOFEPILEPSIES

0UBLICHEALTHANDSOCIALDEVELOPMENTS

$ESPITESCIENTIlCADVANCESINTHETHCENTURYEPILEPSYREMAINEDAPROFOUNDSOCIALPROBLEMCOMPOUNDEDBYDEEPLYROOTEDHISTORICALCONCEPTSOFASUPERNATURALORSACREDDISORDER7IDESPREADIGNORANCEFEARMISUNDERSTANDINGANDSTIGMACONTRIBUTEDTOSEVERELEGALANDSOCIALPENALTIES

)N"UDAPESTINAGROUPOF%UROPEANPHYSICIANSFOUNDEDTHE)NTERNATIONAL,EAGUE!GAINST%PILEPSY),!%&ROMTHEBEGINNING),!%WASCONCERNEDWITHBOTHTHESCIENTIlCANDSOCIALASPECTSOFEPILEPSYANDWITHEDUCATIONTHROUGHINTERNATIONALCOLLABORATIONCONGRESSESANDITSJOURNAL%PILEPSIA5NFORTUNATELYTHEOUTBREAKOFTHE&IRST7ORLD7ARLEDTOTHEDEMISEOF),!%FORYEARSFROMTOWHENITWASREBORNANDRECONSTITUTEDATTHE3ECOND)NTERNATIONAL.EUROLOGICAL#ONGRESSIN,ONDON!PARTFROMABRIEFINTERRUPTIONDURINGTHE3ECOND7ORLD7ARTHE,EAGUEHASGROWNSTEADILYINTOATRULYINTERNATIONALORGANIZATION

"YITWASFELTTHATTHESOCIALDIMENSIONOFEPILEPSYREQUIREDANORGANIZATIONOFITSOWNINVOLVINGPATIENTSANDPUBLICANDTHE)NTERNATIONAL"UREAUFOR%PILEPSY)"%WASFOUNDED"YTHEENDOFTHETHCENTURY),!%HADOVER#HAPTERSAND)"%OVERFULLMEMBERSANDASSOCIATEMEMBERSCOVERINGEVERYCONTINENT2EGIONALSTRUCTURESFORBOTHORGANIZATIONSARENOWEVOLVING)NTHELASTYEARS),!%HASPLAYEDAKEYROLEINDElNINGANDCLASSIFYING

SEIZURESANDEPILEPSYSYNDROMESTHROUGHITS)NTERNATIONAL#OMMISSIONON4ERMINOLOGYAND#LASSIlCATION

!FTERSOMEINITIALTENSIONSINTHELATESANDEARLYSINCLUDINGAMERGERTHENSEPARATION),!%AND)"%HAVEWORKEDVERYWELLTOGETHERWITHINTERLOCKINGEXECUTIVECOMMITTEES4HEYAREBOTHNONGOVERNMENTALORGANIZATIONSAFlLIATEDTO7(/$URINGMYPRESIDENCYOF),!%n)PROPOSEDAMAJORNEWINITIATIVETOADDRESSTHEPUBLICHEALTHASPECTSOFEPILEPSYINCLUDINGSOCIALASPECTSINVOLVINGAPARTNERSHIPBETWEENTHE,EAGUEPROFESSIONALTHE"UREAUPATIENTSPUBLICAND7(/POLITICAL4HE),!%)"%7(/'LOBAL#AMPAIGN!GAINST%PILEPSYWASLAUNCHEDFROM'ENEVAAND$UBLININTHESUMMEROF)TSOBJECTIVESINCLUDERAISINGPOLITICALANDPUBLICAWARENESSOFEPILEPSYREDUCINGSTIGMAANDMISUNDERSTANDINGIMPROVINGEDUCATIONANDESPECIALLYTHEDELIVERYOFSERVICESTREATMENTANDCARETOMILLIONSOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYMAINLYINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWHERESTUDIESHAVESHOWNTHATBETWEENANDOFPATIENTSHAVENOACCESSTOMODERNTREATMENTTHESOCALLEDhTREATMENTGAPvDESPITETHEAVAILABILITYOFRELATIVELYCHEAPMEDICATION

&OLLOWINGTHElRSTPHASEOFPOLITICALANDPUBLICAWARENESSRAISINGnTHETHEN$IRECTOR'ENERALOF7(/$R'RO(ARLEM"RUNDTLANDLAUNCHEDTHESECONDPHASEOFTHE#AMPAIGNFROM'ENEVAANDRAISEDITSSTATUSTOTHEHIGHESTLEVELWITHIN7(/THElRSTNEUROLOGICALDISORDERTOBEACCORDEDTHISPRIORITY$EMONSTRATION0ROJECTSARENOWUNDERWAYINSEVERALDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESINCLUDINGIN!FRICAAND#HINAANDATHIRDPHASEOFTHE#AMPAIGNISBEINGPLANNED

-),%34/.%3).4(%()34/29/&%0),%039

-),%34/.%3).4(%()34/29/&%0),%039

"

!

"

.5-"%2/&0%/0,%7)4(%0),%039

)NTRODUCTIONU+NOWLEDGEABOUTTHENUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYISESSENTIALFORTHEIDENTIlCATIONOFNEEDSANDTHEPLANNINGOFAPPROPRIATESERVICES

3ALIENTlNDINGSU!TOTALOFABOUTPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYAREREPORTEDFROMCOUNTRIESCOVERINGOFTHEWORLDPOPULATION

U4HEMEANNUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYPERPOPULATIONIS3$MEDIANFROMRESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U4HEMEANNUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYPERPOPULATIONVARIESACROSSREGION7HILEITISANDINTHE!MERICASAND!FRICARESPECTIVELYITISIN3OUTH%AST!SIAINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANIN%UROPEANDINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlC

U4HEMEANNUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYPERPOPULATIONRANGESFROMINTHEHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIESTOINTHELOWINCOMECOUNTRIES

,IMITATIONSU4HEDATAREGARDINGTHENUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYWERENOTCOLLECTEDUSINGSTRINGENTRESEARCHMETHODSASFOREPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESSUCHMETHODSARECOSTLYANDARENOTEASYTOCARRYOUT

U4HESOURCESOFINFORMATIONVARYACROSSRESPONDINGCOUNTRIESLIMITINGTHEINTERPRETATIONOFTHEDATASET&OREXAMPLESOMERESPONDENTSPROVIDEDlGURESBASEDONGENERICPREVALENCEORlNDINGSFROMONEPARTICULARAREAOFTHECOUNTRYORONTHENUMBEROFPEOPLEELIGIBLEFORANTIEPILEPTICDRUGS/NEOFTHEREASONSFORLOWPREVALENCEREPORTEDFROMTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCCOULDBETHELOWER

PREVALENCERATESREPORTEDFROM0ACIlC)SLANDSITALSOPUTSABIASONTHEGLOBALOUTCOMEASTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCCOMPRISESOFTHEPOPULATIONINALL7(/REGIONS

U)NFORMATIONREGARDINGTHENUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHACTIVEEPILEPSYWASNOTOBTAINED

U)NFORMATIONREGARDINGTHENUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYAMONGSPECIALGROUPSEGCHILDRENWASNOTOBTAINED

#ONCLUSIONSU4HENUMBEROFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYISHIGHINMOSTREGIONSOFTHEWORLDTHUSCONSTITUTINGEPILEPSYASAMAJORPUBLICHEALTHCONCERN

U4HEREISANEEDTOCARRYOUTMULTINATIONALEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESUSINGSTANDARDIZEDDElNITIONSANDCASEASCERTAINMENTMETHODS

U3TUDIESOFTHEBURDENOFEPILEPSYSHOULDRAISETHEAWARENESSOFAUTHORITIESABOUTTHEIMPACTOFEPILEPSYONTHECOUNTRY

!

!

'-

'-)%

#$

#!")%#

$

#!"

!

)#

%)#

*

',+"

*+

*#

,)'(

*+)&

#+))

&&

*+

)

#

')$

.5-"%2/&0%/0,%7)4(%0),%039

4HESENUMBERSAREONLYINDICATIVEBASEDONTHEINFORMATIONPROVIDEDBY!TLASRESPONDENTS4HENUMBERSHAVENOTBEENCORRECTEDFORNONRESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

0ROF.ADIR%"HARUCHA

%0)$%-)/,/'9

7HATISNEUROEPIDEMIOLOGY

.EUROEPIDEMIOLOGYISTHESTUDYOFTHEDISTRIBUTIONANDDETERMINANTSOFNEUROLOGICALDISEASESINHUMANPOPULATIONS7HILETHECLINICIANISCONCERNEDWITHDISEASEINTHEINDIVIDUALPATIENTTHEEPIDEMIOLOGISTISCONCERNEDWITHTHEOCCURRENCEOFDISEASEWITHINACOMMUNITY%PIDEMIOLOGICALINFORMATIONBENElTSHEALTHPOLICYMAKERSPUBLICHEALTHOFlCIALSMEDICALPRACTITIONERSANDPATIENTSTHEPHARMACEUTICALINDUSTRYANDOTHEREPIDEMIOLOGISTS

$IAGNOSIS

!CCURACYOFMEDICALDIAGNOSISISFUNDAMENTAL$IAGNOSISISCLINICALANDSHOULDBECONlRMEDBYAPROFESSIONALWITHEXPERTISEINEPILEPSY%%'MAYHELPDIAGNOSISBUTISCERTAINLYNEEDEDTOCLASSIFYSEIZURETYPEANDGIVEAMEANINGFULPROGNOSIS-OSTEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESTODATEHAVELACKEDINVESTIGATORYFACILITIESINTHElELDESPECIALLYINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES

3TUDYINGEPILEPSYISBESETWITHDIFlCULTIES!CCURATEDIAGNOSISANDCASEASCERTAINMENTREMAINMAJORPROBLEMSBECAUSEEPILEPSYISONLYASYMPTOMOFMANYDISPARATECAUSATIVEENTITIES#ONlDENTDIAGNOSISOREXCLUSIONINALLCASESOFSEIZURESISDIFlCULTBECAUSESEIZURETYPESVARYUNUSUALBEHAVIOURANDBLANKSPELLSMAYNOTBERECOGNIZEDASSEIZURESTHEREMAYBENOACCOMPANYINGNEUROLOGICALSIGNSANDIFANEYEWITNESSACCOUNTISLACKINGTHEDIAGNOSISMAYNOTBEMADEATALL/THERCONDITIONSAREREADILYCONFUSEDWITHEPILEPTICSEIZURES4HEMOSTFREQUENTLYOCCURRINGNONEPILEPTICEVENTSREQUIRINGDISTINCTIONANDEXCLUSIONAREPSEUDOSEIZURESANDSYNCOPE

$ElNITIONOFSEIZURESANDEPILEPSIES

4OENSURECOMPARABILITYOFEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIES),!%SGUIDELINESFOREPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESONEPILEPSYSHOULDBEFOLLOWED4HETERMEPILEPSYSHOULDBEUSEDONLYFORRECURRENTUNPROVOKEDSEIZURES

3EIZURESARECATEGORIZEDASPARTIALORGENERALIZED!PARTIALSEIZUREISPRESUMEDTOSTARTINAPARTOFTHEBRAINANDMAYORMAYNOTSPREAD4HECAUSEMUSTALWAYSBESOUGHTANDEPILEPSIESMAYBECLASSIlEDACCORDINGTOAETIOLOGYANDTYPEOFSEIZUREASFOLLOWS

U!ETIOLOGYREMOTESYMPTOMATICOFKNOWNAETIOLOGYCRYPTOGENICPROBABLYSYMPTOMATICBUTUNKNOWNAETIOLOGYIDIOPATHICPRESUMEDGENETIC

U4YPEOFSEIZUREIFPARTIALTHEEPILEPSYISLOCALIZATIONRELATEDANDIFGENERALIZEDTHEEPILEPSYISEITHERGENERALIZEDORLOCALIZATIONRELATEDGENERALIZEDSEIZURESCANOCCURINBOTHGENERALIZEDANDLOCALIZATIONRELATEDEPILEPSIES

!CUTESYMPTOMATICSEIZURESARETHOSEOCCURRINGINCLOSETEMPORALASSOCIATIONWITHANACUTESYSTEMICMETABOLICORTOXICINSULTORINASSOCIATIONWITHANACUTECENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINSULT!CUTESYMPTOMATICSEIZURESTHOUGH

SOMETIMESLIFETHREATENINGANDVERYCOMMONARENOTCONSIDEREDEPILEPSY4HEYDOHOWEVERINCREASETHERISKOFFUTUREEPILEPSY&EBRILESEIZURESAREATYPEOFACUTESYMPTOMATICSEIZUREANDTHECOMMONESTSEIZUREDISORDERINCHILDREN

0ROGRESSIVESYMPTOMATICSEIZURESAREUNPROVOKEDSEIZURESOWINGTOPROGRESSIVECENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMDISORDERS4HEPROGNOSISISWORSE4HELASTGROUPISTHEUNDETERMINEDANDUNCLASSIlABLEEPILEPSIES%PIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESOFTENWRONGLYOMITTHISGROUPALTOGETHER

&AILURETOSEPARATEACTIVEFROMINACTIVEEPILEPSYCAUSESDIFFERENCESINRATES!PERSONWITHACTIVEEPILEPSYHASHADATLEASTONEEPILEPTICSEIZUREWITHINTHEPREVIOUSlVEYEARSREGARDLESSOFANTIEPILEPTICDRUG!%$TREATMENT)NGENERALPATIENTSWITHINACTIVEEPILEPSYDONOTNEEDCONTINUINGTREATMENT

)NCIDENCEANDPREVALENCE

4HEINCIDENCETHENUMBEROFNEWCASESPERYEAROFEPILEPSYISnPERPOPULATIONINDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIES4HEREAREFEWINCIDENCESTUDIESINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESNONEOFWHICHISPROSPECTIVETHEYSHOWRATESFROMTOPERPOPULATION(IGHERINCIDENCERATESINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESTHOUGHTTOBEATTRIBUTABLETOPARASITOSISPARTICULARLYNEUROCYSTICERCOSIS()6TRAUMAPERINATALMORBIDITYANDCONSANGUINITYAREDIFlCULTTOINTERPRETBECAUSEOFMETHODOLOGICALISSUESPARTICULARLYTHELACKOFAGEADJUSTMENTWHICHISIMPORTANTBECAUSEEPILEPSYHASABIMODALPEAKWITHAGE)NCIDENCERATESWORLDWIDEAREGREATERINMENTHANWOMEN)NDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESINCIDENCEAMONGTHEELDERLYISRISINGANDAMONGCHILDRENITISFALLING4HISISRELEVANTTODEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESASLONGEVITYRISESANDRISKOFCEREBROVASCULARDISEASEINCREASES#ONVERSELYBETTEROBSTETRICCAREANDINFECTIONCONTROLCANDIMINISHINCIDENCEINCHILDREN

4HEPREVALENCETHETOTALNUMBEROFCASESATAPARTICULARPOINTINTIMEOFACTIVEEPILEPSYINALARGENUMBEROFSTUDIESHASBEENSHOWNTOBEFAIRLYUNIFORMATnPERPOPULATION(IGHERPREVALENCESINSUB3AHARAN!FRICAAND#ENTRALAND3OUTH!MERICAHAVEBEENREPORTEDPOSSIBLYDUETOMETHODOLOGICALDIFFERENCESCONSANGUINITYORENVIRONMENTALFACTORSANDPARTICULARLYSOINRURALAREAS)TISDIFlCULTTOTEASEOUTRACIALANDSOCIOECONOMICFACTORS0REVALENCEDATAAREPRIMARILYUSEDBYHEALTHPLANNERSANDFORGENERATINGAETIOLOGICALHYPOTHESES

!ETIOLOGY

0OPULATIONBASEDPREVALENCEANDINCIDENCESURVEYSPRESENTPERCENTAGEFREQUENCIESOFPRESUMEDAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSY)NMOSTNOCAUSEISFOUND0RECISEDIAGNOSISREMAINSDIFlCULTnEVENINTHESTUDYIN2OCHESTER-.TWOTHIRDSOFCASESWERECLASSIlEDASIDIOPATHICORCRYPTOGENIC!ETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYISDISCUSSEDIN3ECTION

%0)$%-)/,/'9

3EIZURETYPEANDEPILEPSYSYNDROME

'ENERALIZEDSEIZURESARECOMMONINlELDSTUDIESESPECIALLYINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESOFTENBECAUSEPARTIALSEIZURESAREMISSED)NDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESOVERHALFTHEINCIDENCECASESAREPARTIAL0ARTIALANDGENERALIZEDSEIZURESVARYWITHAGEPARTIALSEIZURESBEINGMORECOMMONINTHEVERYYOUNGANDINELDERLYPEOPLE'ENERALIZEDTONICnCLONICSEIZURESOCCURUNIFORMLYTHROUGHOUTTHELIFECOURSEABSENCESEIZURESOCCURMAXIMALLYBETWEENANDYEARSOFAGEANDMYOCLONICSEIZURESINTHEUNDERlVEYEAROLDSANDAROUNDYEARS)DIOPATHICEPILEPSYISUSUALLYSEENINTHEYOUNGANDREMOTESYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYATTHEEXTREMES)NDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESHOWEVERSYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYCAUSEDBYINFECTIONSSHOULDBECONSIDEREDATANYAGE

$IAGNOSISBYSYNDROMEISIMPORTANTFORPROGNOSISANDTREATMENT&OREXAMPLEACRYPTOGENICSYMPTOMATICLOCALIZATIONSYNDROMETHECOMMONESTPAEDIATRICSYNDROMEISLIKELYTOBECAUSEDBYABRAINLESIONWHICHMAYBEAMENABLETOSURGERYIFSEIZURESAREMEDICALLYUNCONTROLLABLE#HILDHOODABSENCEEPILEPSYTHECOMMONESTIDIOPATHICGENERALIZEDEPILEPSYWHOSEPROGNOSISISPOORIFUNTREATEDANDEXCELLENTIFTREATEDMAYBEMISSEDALTOGETHERINPOPULATIONSCREENING

'ENETICSTUDIES

'ENETICSTUDIESHAVEIDENTIlEDRAREEPILEPSYSYNDROMESATTRIBUTABLETOSINGLEGENEMUTATIONSANDSIMPLE-ENDELIANINHERITANCE-OSTIDIOPATHICEPILEPSYSYNDROMESHAVECOMPLEXINHERITANCEPROBABLYBECAUSEOFINTERACTINGGENETICANDENVIRONMENTALFACTORS4HECATEGORYOFCRYPTOGENICEPILEPSIESISDIMINISHINGASRESULTSOFGENETICANDNEUROIMAGINGSTUDIESBECOMEAVAILABLE4HEREISSCOPEFORDEVELOPINGANDDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESTOCOLLABORATEINPROPERLYDESIGNEDINCIDENCEANDGENETICSTUDIESOFDIFFERENTEPILEPSYSYNDROMES'ENETICEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESWILLGIVEINFORMATIONONINDIVIDUALPROGNOSISANDRISKTOOTHERFAMILYMEMBERS7HENPATHOPHYSIOLOGICALMECHANISMSARECLEARERTAILORINGTHEDRUGTOTHEGENEWILLALSOBECOMEPOSSIBLE

0ROGNOSIS

/NEINTHREEPEOPLEWITHASINGLEUNPROVOKEDSEIZUREWILLHAVEASECONDSEIZUREOVERTHENEXTlVEYEARS4REATMENTSHOULDBECONSIDEREDONLYTOPREVENTRECURRENCENOTTOPREVENTEPILEPSY5NTREATEDAFTERASECONDSEIZUREWILLHAVEANOTHERSEIZUREWITHINTHENEXTONEORTWOYEARS7HETHERhSEIZURESBEGETSEIZURESvISUNCLEAR.UMEROUSPREDICTORSFORRECURRENCECONTROLREMISSIONANDINTRACTABILITYHAVEBEENDEVELOPEDATTHEONSETANDDURINGTREATMENT-OSTIMPORTANTAREDIAGNOSISBYSYNDROMEANDRESPONSETOTHElRSTAPPROPRIATELYPRESCRIBEDANDTAKEN!%$0ERSISTENCEOFSEIZURESAFTERTWO!%$SREQUIRESPRESURGICALEVALUATIONASCHANCESOFREMISSIONARELESSTHANWITHATHIRD!%$ANDnFOLLOWINGSUCCESSFULSURGERY

-ORTALITY

)NDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESMORTALITYMEASUREDBYTHESTANDARDIZEDMORTALITYRATIO3-2ISnTIMESTHATOFTHEGENERALPOPULATION$EATHSMAYBEATTRIBUTABLEEITHERTOTHECAUSEOFEPILEPSYWHENDEATHWILLOCCURSOONAFTERONSETORTOTHEEPILEPSYITSELFASINCHRONICEPILEPSYORITMAYBEUNRELATED#OMPARISONBETWEENSTUDIESISDIFlCULTBECAUSEOFDIFFERENTSTUDYDESIGNSANDDIFFERENTPOPULATIONSSTUDIED3YMPTOMATICEPILEPSYHASAHIGHERMORTALITYRATIOTHANIDIOPATHICEPILEPSY4HEIMPORTANTEPILEPSYRELATEDDEATHSARESUDDENUNEXPECTEDUNEXPLAINEDDEATHINEPILEPSY35$%0nOFALLDEATHSINEPILEPSYDEATHINSTATUSEPILEPTICUSANDSUICIDEn)NSTATUSEPILEPTICUSTHEMORTALITYDEPENDSONTHECAUSEANDISHIGHERINELDERLYSYMPTOMATICPATIENTS2ISKOFSUICIDEISGREATESTWHENEPILEPSYSTARTSINADOLESCENTSWITHAHISTORYOFASSOCIATEDPSYCHIATRICDISTURBANCE"OTHDEVELOPINGANDDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESNEEDPROSPECTIVEINCIDENCECOHORTSTUDIESWITHLONGTERMFOLLOWUP

-ORBIDITY

3OMEPSYCHIATRICANDPHYSICALCONDITIONSAREMORECOMMONINPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSY#EREBROVASCULARDISEASEANDBRAINTUMOURSMAYBECAUSALLYRELATEDTOEPILEPSY(EADINJURYANDPSYCHIATRICCONDITIONSMAYBECAUSEDBYORRESULTFROMEPILEPSY!%$TERATOGENICMORBIDITYNEEDSFURTHERSTUDY!LERTHEALTHPROVIDERSMUSTBEAWAREOFALLTHESEISSUESINORDERTOIMPROVETHEQUALITYOFLIFEOFSPECIALGROUPSSUCHASWOMENANDCHILDREN

)NTERVENTIONALEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIES

5PTOOFPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESDONOTRECEIVEAPPROPRIATETREATMENTANDOFAVAILABLE!%$SAREUTILIZEDBYOFTHEWORLDSSUFFERERS0HENOBARBITALISAN!%$THATISEFFECTIVETOLERABLECHEAPANDEASYTOUSEALLESSENTIALCONSIDERATIONSINDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIES3URGERYFORREFRACTORYEPILEPSYCOULDBECOSTBENElCIAL#OSTBENElTANDRISKBENElTRATIOSOFNEW!%$SSHOULDBEASSESSEDONALARGESCALEINDEVELOPEDCOUNTRIESSUCHINFORMATIONWOULDBEOFVALUEFORDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESAFTERAPPROPRIATELYDESIGNEDCLINICALTRIALS

#ONCLUSION

)NDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESWITHLARGERURALPOPULATIONSAFEWURBANANDSEMIURBANNEUROLOGISTSSUBSTANTIALBURDENOFDISEASEANDSCANTILYALLOCATEDHEALTHCARERESOURCESEPIDEMIOLOGYPROVIDESINFORMATIONNECESSARYFORALLINVOLVEDINPROMOTINGHEALTHTOOPTIMIZECAREINEPILEPSY.EUROEPIDEMIOLOGICALSTUDIESPROVIDEMORETHANINDICESOFBURDENTHEYSHOWTHEWAYFORWARD

!CKNOWLEDGEMENT

$R2OBERTA(2AVENFORHERHELPINPREPARINGTHISMANUSCRIPT

!%4)/,/'9/&%0),%039n2%0/24%$&2%15%.#9

)NTRODUCTIONU4HERESPONDENTSWEREASKEDTOPROVIDETHElVEMOSTFREQUENTLYENCOUNTEREDCAUSESOFEPILEPSY)GNORINGTHEORDEROFTHEINDIVIDUALRESPONSESTHEPROPORTIONOF

COUNTRIESTHATMENTIONEDEACHAETIOLOGYWASCALCULATEDGLOBALLYANDFOREACHOFTHEREGIONS

3ALIENTlNDINGSU'LOBALLYTRAUMAWASTHEMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U#ENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINFECTIONSINCLUDINGABSCESSESENCEPHALITISWITHALLAETIOLOGIESANDBACTERIALMENINGITISBUTEXCLUDINGPARASITICINFESTATIONSANTENATALANDPERINATALRISKFACTORSANDCEREBROVASCULARDISORDERSWEREAMONGTHEMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYBYANDOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESRESPECTIVELY

U)DIOPATHICEPILEPSYINCLUDINGTHEGENETICCAUSESWASMENTIONEDASONEOFTHElVEMOSTCOMMONAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U4RAUMACENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINFECTIONSANDIDIOPATHICEPILEPSYWEREMENTIONEDAMONGTHElVEMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYBYTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESACROSSDIFFERENTINCOMEGROUPSOFCOUNTRIES

U!MONGTHElVEMOSTCOMMONAETIOLOGIESTUMOURSWEREMENTIONEDBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESCONGENITALDEFECTSPARASITICINFESTATIONSEXOGENOUSCHEMICALSINCLUDINGALCOHOLANDDRUGSCRYPTOGENICDEGENERATIVEDISORDERSFEBRILECONVULSIONSHIPPOCAMPALSCLEROSISANDCEREBRALPALSY

U#EREBROVASCULARDISORDERSWEREALSOAMONGTHElVEMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYBYTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESINALLINCOMECATEGORIESEXCEPTLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESWHEREPARASITICINFESTATIONSWEREANIMPORTANTAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYASMENTIONEDBYOFCOUNTRIES

U0ERINATALCAUSESWEREREPORTEDAMONGTHElVEMOSTIMPORTANTAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYBYALLINCOMECATEGORIESEXCEPTHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES

,IMITATIONSU!ETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYASREPORTEDBYRESPONDENTSAREAROUGHESTIMATEDATAWERENOTCOLLECTEDANDCALCULATEDUSINGSTRINGENTEPIDEMIOLOGICALRESEARCHMETHODS4HEINFORMATIONISBASEDONTHEEXPERIENCEANDIMPRESSIONOFAKEYPERSONINACOUNTRYWORKINGINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYANDNOTNECESSARILYONACTUALDATAFROMRESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U)NMOSTCASESASPECIlCCAUSECANONLYBEDETERMINEDUSINGBASICINVESTIGATIONSINCLUDINGNEURORADIOLOGICALANDELECTROPHYSIOLOGICALSERVICES4HERECOULDBEMETHODOLOGICALDIFFERENCESAMONGVARIOUSCOUNTRIESBECAUSEMANYLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESHAVEPOORACCESSIBILITYTOEVENBASICINVESTIGATIONS

U)NALMOSTOFCASESOFEPILEPSYTHEAETIOLOGYCANNOTBEIDENTIlEDEVENWITHTHEMOSTSOPHISTICATEDMETHODS(OWEVERTHECAUSEBEINGUNKNOWNWASMENTIONEDBYONLYOFCOUNTRIES/NEPOSSIBLEREASONCOULDBETHEWAYINWHICHTHEQUESTIONWASFRAMED!NOTHERCOULDBETHEUSEOFTERMhIDIOPATHICvWHICHACCORDINGTOSOMEREFERSTOAGENETICSYNDROMEWITHSTRICTLYDElNEDCLINICALAND%%'lNDINGSWHILEOTHERSMAYUSEITFORANYCASEINWHICHAETIOLOGYHASNOTBEENESTABLISHED

U3OMEOFTHEENTITIESMENTIONEDSUCHASCEREBRALPALSYAREMANIFESTATIONSOFCEREBRALDAMAGEWHEREEPILEPSYCOEXISTSRATHERTHANBEINGTHECAUSEOFEPILEPSY

#ONCLUSIONSU)DENTIFYINGTHECORRECTAETIOLOGYISESSENTIALINORDERTOESTABLISHAPPROPRIATETREATMENTANDOFFERAPROGNOSISTOTHEPATIENTANDFAMILY

U4HEINFORMATIONREGARDINGTHECAUSESOFEPILEPSYALSOHASIMPLICATIONSFORMAKINGDECISIONSABOUTTHEDEVELOPMENTOFLOCALLYRELEVANTSTRATEGIESFORPREVENTIONANDMANAGEMENTRESEARCHGOALSANDEDUCATIONOFPRIMARYHEALTHCAREWORKERSANDCOMMUNITYPHYSICIANS

U4HEINEQUITYINAVAILABILITYOFDIAGNOSTICRESOURCESINCLUDINGHUMANRESOURCESREQUIREDFORASSESSINGTHEAETIOLOGYOFEPILEPSYNEEDSTOBEDEALTWITH

U4HETOPFOURMOSTFREQUENTLYREPORTEDAETIOLOGIESOFEPILEPSYTRAUMACENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINFECTIONSCEREBROVASCULARDISORDERSANDPERINATALRISKFACTORSAREPREVENTABLE#ONCERTEDMULTIDISCIPLINARYEFFORTSFOCUSINGONTHERISKFACTORSEGENFORCEMENTOFSTRICTTRAFlCREGULATIONSTOPREVENTTRAUMAORPROVIDINGSPECIlCPROTECTIONEGIMMUNIZATIONAGAINSTCOMMUNICABLEDISEASESFORTHESEPREVENTABLECAUSESCANHELPTODECREASESUBSTANTIALLYTHEBURDENATTRIBUTABLETOEPILEPSY

%(!

"'% "

%)#(&

&*&'!"

'#"

&

%"

'

%%

#)&(

%&

&

#$'

(!#(%

&

#"

"'

%&'

$#%'

*

#("'%

&

$#%'

*

#("'%

&

!%4)/,/'9/&%0),%039n2%0/24%$&2%15%.#9

!%4)/,/'9!.$2)3+&!#4/23

%PILEPSYISTHEPROPENSITYFORANINDIVIDUALTOHAVERECURRENTUNPROVOKEDEPILEPTICSEIZURES4HESESEIZURESAREPRODUCEDBYABNORMALDISCHARGESOFNEURONSANDMAYBEAMANIFESTATIONOFMANYDIFFERENTCONDITIONSWHICHMODIFYNEURONALFUNCTIONORCAUSEPATHOLOGICALCHANGESINTHEBRAIN-ANYENVIRONMENTALGENETICPATHOLOGICALANDPHYSIOLOGICALFACTORSMAYBEINVOLVEDINTHEDEVELOPMENTOFSEIZURESANDEPILEPSY4HEPRESENCEOFAFAMILYHISTORYOFEPILEPSYISKNOWNTOENHANCEMOSTRISKFACTORSFOREPILEPSY4HESUSCEPTIBILITYTOEPILEPSYMAYTHEREFOREBEPARTLYGENETICALLYDETERMINEDANDTHISMAYVARYACCORDINGTOTHESTAGEOFBRAINMATURATION

%PILEPSYISASSOCIATEDWITHAVARIETYOFSTATICORPROGRESSIVEPATHOLOGICALCHANGESEITHERCONGENITALORACQUIRED)NADDITIONANUMBEROFINHERITEDCONDITIONSMAYEXPRESSTHEMSELVESSOLELYTHROUGHEPILEPTICSEIZURES)TMAYTHEREFOREBEMOREAPPROPRIATETODESCRIBEEPILEPSYASASYMPTOMCOMPLEXRATHERTHANASAMEDICALCONDITIONINITSOWNRIGHT

!ETIOLOGICALLYTHEEPILEPSIESARECLASSIlEDINTOFOURGROUPSIDIOPATHICSYMPTOMATICCRYPTOGENICANDPROGRESSIVE4HEIDIOPATHICEPILEPSIESARETHOUGHTTOBEGENETICALLYDETERMINEDANDAREUSUALLYASSOCIATEDWITHPARTICULARCLINICALCHARACTERISTICANDSPECIlCELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY%%'lNDINGS3YMPTOMATICEPILEPSIESAREACQUIREDCONDITIONSANDAREUSUALLYASSOCIATEDWITHASTRUCTURALABNORMALITYOFTHEBRAIN%PILEPSYISCLASSIlEDASCRYPTOGENICWHENNOCLEARABNORMALITYORPUTATIVERISKFACTORISIDENTIlEDFORWHATISPRESUMEDTOBEASYMPTOMATICORACQUIREDEPILEPTICCONDITION4HETERMPROGRESSIVEEPILEPSYISUSEDWHENEPILEPSYISASSOCIATEDWITHANEVOLVINGNEUROLOGICALCONDITION

4HEPROBABLEAETIOLOGYORRISKFACTORFOREPILEPSYDEPENDSONTHEAGEOFTHEPATIENTANDTHETYPEOFSEIZUREn4HEMOSTCOMMONACQUIREDCAUSESINYOUNGINFANTSAREPERINATALHYPOXIAANDTRAUMAMETABOLICDISTURBANCESCONGENITALMALFORMATIONSOFTHEBRAINANDINFECTION)NYOUNGCHILDRENANDADOLESCENTSIDIOPATHICEPILEPSIESACCOUNTFORTHEMAJORITYOFCASESALTHOUGHTRAUMAANDINFECTIONPLAYAROLE&EBRILESEIZURESWHICHAREUSUALLYSHORTCONVULSIVEATTACKSOCCURRINGDURINGTHEEARLYPHASEOFAFEBRILEDISEASEARECOMMONINCHILDRENUNDERTHEAGEOFlVEYEARSANDNEEDTOBEDISTINGUISHEDFROMSEIZURESTRIGGEREDBYCENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMINFECTIONSCAUSINGFEVERSUCHASMENINGITISANDENCEPHALITIS5NLESSFEBRILESEIZURESAREPROLONGEDRECURRENTOROCCURRINGONABACKGROUNDOFNEUROLOGICALHANDICAPTHEPROGNOSISISEXCELLENTANDITISUNLIKELYTHATTHECHILDWILLDEVELOPCHRONICEPILEPSY

4HECAUSESOFADULTONSETEPILEPSYAREVERYVARIED"OTHIDIOPATHICEPILEPSYANDEPILEPSYATTRIBUTABLETOBIRTHTRAUMAMAYBEGININEARLYADULTHOOD/THERIMPORTANTCAUSESOFSEIZURESINADULTHOODAREHEADINJURYALCOHOLABUSEBRAINTUMOURSANDCEREBROVASCULARDISEASE)NDEVEL

OPINGCOUNTRIESPARASITICDISORDERSSUCHASCYSTICERCOSISANDMALARIAMAYBEIMPORTANTCAUSALAGENTSFOREPILEPSY

)DIOPATHICANDGENETICALLYDETERMINEDEPILEPSIES

4HEIDIOPATHICORPRIMARYGENERALIZEDEPILEPSIESARETHEMOSTCOMMONOFTHEGENETICALLYDETERMINEDEPILEPSIES4HEPRECISEMODEOFINHERITANCEFORMOSTOFTHESECONDITIONSISCURRENTLYUNKNOWN/THERINHERITEDCONDITIONSINWHICHSEIZURESARETHESOLECLINICALMANIFESTATIONINCLUDETHEIDIOPATHICPARTIALEPILEPSIESEGBENIGNROLANDICEPILEPSY)NADDITIONTOTHESECONDITIONSWITHSEIZURESASTHEMAINCLINICALEXPRESSIONTHEREAREMANYRAREINHERITEDDISORDERSTHATPRESENTASNEUROLOGICALORSYSTEMICILLNESSESINCLUDINGSEIZURES4HEMOSTCOMMONOFTHESEDISORDERSARETUBEROUSSCLEROSISANDNEUROlBROMATOSIS4RISOMY$OWNSSYNDROMEMAYBEACCOMPANIEDBYSEIZURESPARTICULARLYINLATERLIFE

3YMPTOMATICEPILEPSIES

#OMMONCAUSESOFSYMPTOMATICEPILEPSIESINCLUDEHEADTRAUMABIRTHTRAUMACEREBROVASCULARDISORDERSCEREBRALANOXIABRAININFECTIONSCORTICALMALFORMATIONSANDBRAINTUMOURS)NRESOURCEPOORCOUNTRIESPARASITICINFESTATIONSSUCHASMALARIANEUROCYSTICERCOSISANDPARAGONIMIASISAREIMPORTANTRISKFACTORS-OSTEPILEPSIESSTARTINGINADULTLIFEARESYMPTOMATICANDINVESTIGATIONSTODETECTANYUNDERLYINGAETIOLOGYAREMANDATORY

(EADTRAUMAISANIMPORTANTCAUSEOFSYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYANDMAYACCOUNTFORUPTOOFALLCASESOFEPILEPSY4HELIKELIHOODOFDEVELOPINGEPILEPSYAFTERHEADTRAUMADEPENDSONTHESEVERITYOFTHEINJURYANDTHEPRESENCEOFCOMPLICATINGFACTORSINCLUDINGPROLONGEDLOSSOFCONSCIOUSNESSPOSTTRAUMATICAMNESIAINTRACRANIALBLEEDINGMISSILEPENETRATIONORDEPRESSEDSKULLFRACTURE)TISUNUSUALFOREPILEPSYTODEVELOPUNLESSONEOFTHESEFACTORSISPRESENT3EIZURESOCCURRINGIMMEDIATELYAFTERTHEINJURYDONOTUSUALLYPRESAGETHEDEVELOPMENTOFCHRONICEPILEPSY

4HROMBOEMBOLICEVENTSANDCEREBRALHAEMORRHAGEAREIMPORTANTCAUSESOFSYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYSTARTINGINLATERLIFEWHERETHEYARERESPONSIBLEFORUPTOCASES)TISESTIMATEDTHATAPPROXIMATELYOFPEOPLEWITHSTROKESWILLEVENTUALLYDEVELOPEPILEPTICSEIZURES6ASCULARMALFORMATIONSANDCEREBRALANEURYSMSMAYALSOCAUSESYMPTOMATICEPILEPSYWHETHERORNOTHAEMORRHAGEHASOCCURRED

!NYINTRACRANIALINFECTIONWHETHERVIRALBACTERIALORFUNGALCANCAUSESEIZURES4HESEVERITYOFTHEEPILEPTICDISORDERUSUALLYDEPENDSONTHENATUREOFTHEINFECTIONANDTHEEXTENTOFTHEDAMAGE-ENINGITISTHEMOSTCOMMONINTRACRANIALINFECTIONISCOMMONINYOUNGCHILDRENBUTALSOAFFECTSOLDERAGEGROUPS%PILEPSYISANUNUSUALCOMPLICA

0ROF*OSEMIR73ANDER

!%4)/,/'9!.$2)3+&!#4/23

TIONOFACUTEBACTERIALMENINGITISOCCURRINGMAINLYINPEOPLEGIVENINADEQUATEORLATETREATMENT

)NTRACRANIALTUBERCULOSISCANCAUSECORTICALANDMENINGEALTUBERCULOMASTHATMAYPRESENTWITHSEIZURESSOMETIMESDEVELOPINGYEARSAFTERTHEPRIMARYINFECTION&UNGALINFECTIONSOFTHECENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMAREARARECAUSEOFEPILEPSYTHEMOSTCOMMONCRYPTOCOCCOSISANDBLASTOMYCOSISAREOFTENASSOCIATEDWITHIMMUNEDElCIENCIES3URVIVORSOFVIRALENCEPHALITISESPECIALLYRESULTINGFROMHERPESMAYDEVELOPEPILEPSYTHATISINTRACTABLETOMEDICALTREATMENT)NTRAUTERINEANDPERINATALINFECTIONSCAUSEDBYTOXOPLASMOSISRUBELLAANDSYPHILISMAYCAUSEEXTENSIVECORTICALDAMAGEANDSEVEREPARTIALEPILEPSYMAYRESULTIFTHECHILDSURVIVES

"RAINABSCESSESARERAREANDOFTENFATAL%PILEPSYDEVELOPSINABOUTTHREEQUARTERSOFSURVIVORSANDISUSUALLYVERYSEVEREANDINTRACTABLE

%PILEPSYMAYOCCURINTHECOURSEOFANUMBEROFPARASITICDISORDERSINCLUDINGNEUROCYSTICERCOSISFALCIPARUMMALARIASCHISTOSOMIASISANDPARAGONIMIASIS3UCHINFECTIONSMAYBERESPONSIBLEFORTHEHIGHERINCIDENCEOFEPILEPSYINSOMEPARTSOFTHETROPICALWORLDTHOSEMOSTFREQUENTLYASSOCIATEDWITHEPILEPSYARENEUROCYSTICERCOSISANDFALCIPARUMMALARIA.EUROCYSTICERCOSISISTHEMOSTCOMMONACQUIREDCAUSEOFEPILEPSYINRESOURCEPOORCOUNTRIES4HISOCCURSWHENAHUMANBECOMESTHEINTERMEDIATEHOSTFOR4AENIASOLIUMTHROUGHTHEINGESTIONOFEGGSCONTAINEDINHUMANFAECES#YSTSCONTAININGANEMBRYOMAYEMERGEINANYAREAOFTHECEREBRUMVENTRICLESORSUBARACHNOIDSPACEOFTHEINFESTEDPATIENTLEADINGTOAVARIETYOFNEUROLOGICALSIGNSINCLUDINGEPILEPSY#EREBRALMALARIAWHICHISTHEMOSTIMPORTANTCOMPLICATIONOFFALCIPARUMMALARIAMAYlRSTPRESENTASSTATUSEPILEPTICUS)TCARRIESAHIGHMORTALITYANDMORBIDITYSURVIVORSOFTENHAVENEUROLOGICALDISABILITIESANDPARTIALSEIZURESTHATRESPONDPOORLYTOTREATMENT

!NALLERGICREACTIONTOVACCINECOMPONENTSVERYOCCASIONALLYLEADSTOANACUTEENCEPHALOPATHYTHATMAYRESULTINCHRONICEPILEPSY)TISEXTREMELYRAREHOWEVERANDISBECOMINGEVENMOREUNCOMMONASMOREPURIlEDANDLESSANTIGENICVACCINESAREUSED!STHEINCIDENCEOFEPILEPSYISATITSHIGHESTINEARLYCHILDHOODTHEAGEATWHICHMOSTVACCINATIONSARECARRIEDOUTSOMECHILDRENWILLDEVELOPSEIZURESINTEMPORALASSOCIATIONWITHVACCINATIONBYCOINCIDENCE/THERCHILDRENEXPERIENCEAFEBRILEREACTIONTOSOMEVACCINATIONSANDMAYHAVEAFEBRILESEIZUREASARESULTWITHOUTLONGTERMSEQUELAE

%RRORSINNEURONALMIGRATIONDURINGEMBRYOGENESISMAYRESULTINCORTICALMALFORMATIONS4HESEMALFORMATIONSWEREUNTILRECENTLYCONSIDEREDTOBERAREHOWEVERWITHTHEDEVELOPMENTOFHIGHRESOLUTIONNEUROIMAGINGTHEYAREBEINGRECOGNIZEDWITHINCREASINGFREQUENCY4HEAETIOLOGYFORTHESECORTICALMALFORMATIONSISUNKNOWNATTHISSTAGE

BUTPOTENTIALCAUSESMAYINCLUDEINTRAUTERINEINFECTIONMATERNALILLNESSOREXPOSURETOTOXINSATCRUCIALPHASESOFBRAINFORMATION

(IPPOCAMPALSCLEROSISISTHEMOSTCOMMONLESIONIDENTIlEDINPATHOLOGICALSPECIMENSOFPATIENTSWITHTEMPORALLOBEEPILEPSYWHOHAVEUNDERGONETEMPORALLOBECTOMY)TCONSISTSOFATROPHICCHANGESWITHAVARIABLEDEGREEOFCELLLOSSANDGLIOSISINVOLVINGPARTORTHEWHOLEOFTHEHIPPOCAMPUS)TISUSUALLYUNILATERALANDCANBEIDENTIlEDBYBRAINIMAGING4EMPORALLOBEEPILEPSYWITHHIPPOCAMPALSCLEROSISISSTRONGLYASSOCIATEDWITHAHISTORYOFPROLONGEDFEBRILECONVULSIONSINCHILDHOOD2ESECTIONOFTHEATROPHICAREAWHENPOSSIBLEISASSOCIATEDWITHAGOODSURGICALOUTCOMEWITHCOMPLETESEIZURECONTROLINOVEROFCASES

#RYPTOGENICEPILEPSIES

#URRENTLYUPTOOFPATIENTSHAVENOIDENTIlABLECAUSEFORTHEIRSEIZURES4HISPROPORTIONISRAPIDLYDECREASINGASADVANCESINNEUROIMAGINGPARTICULARLYMAGNETICRESONANCEIMAGING-2)AREMADE4HETERMCRYPTOGENICEPILEPSYISSOMETIMESUSEDINTERCHANGEABLYWITHIDIOPATHICEPILEPSY4HISSHOULDBEAVOIDEDANDTHETERMIDIOPATHICEPILEPSYRESERVEDFORTHOSEINHERITEDCONDITIONSINWHICHSEIZURESOCCURASTHEONLYMANIFESTATIONOFTHEDISORDER

0ROGRESSIVEEPILEPSIES

4HEPROGRESSIVEMYOCLONICEPILEPSIESAREAGROUPOFDISORDERSCHARACTERIZEDBYTHEDEVELOPMENTOFMYOCLONICANDOTHERSEIZURESINASSOCIATIONWITHOTHERCLINICALINHERITEDDEGENERATIVEBRAINDISORDERSANDINBORNERRORSOFMETABOLISM4HESEINCLUDEADRENOLEUKODYSTROPHY!LPERSDISEASEAND4AY3ACHSDISEASE0HENYLKETONURIAPORPHYRIAANDNEURONALCEROIDLIPOFUSCINOSISMAYALSOCAUSESEIZURES

%PILEPSYMAYSOMETIMESCOMPLICATEDEGENERATIVEBRAINCONDITIONSSUCHAS!LZHEIMERSDISEASE(UNTINGTONSCHOREASTRIATONIGRALDEGENERATIONAND#REUTZFELD*AKOBDISEASEASMANYASOFPATIENTSWITH!LZHEIMERSDISEASEMAYDEVELOPSEIZURES

)NVOLVEMENTOFTHECENTRALNERVOUSSYSTEMEVENTUALLYOCCURSINTHEMAJORITYOFPEOPLEDEVELOPING!)$3)TMAYTAKETHEFORMOFOPPORTUNISTICINFECTIONORNEOPLASTICLESIONS!NENCEPHALOPATHYTHATSEEMSTOBECAUSEDBY()6ITSELFHASALSOBEENRECOGNIZED

)NTRACRANIALTUMOURSEITHERPRIMARYORMETASTATICMAYRESULTINEPILEPSY4UMOURSARERESPONSIBLEFORABOUTAlFTHOFSEIZURESSTARTINGBETWEENTHEAGESOFANDYEARSANDABOUTOFSEIZURESSTARTINGAFTERTHEAGEOFYEARS

%PILEPSYTHESERVICES

%0),%0394(%3%26)#%3

$)!'./34)#3%26)#%3

)NTRODUCTIONU4HERESPONDENTSWEREASKEDABOUTTHEAVAILABILITYOFDIAGNOSTICEQUIPMENTFORTHEMANAGEMENTOFEPILEPSYEGCOMPUTERIZEDAXIALTOMOGRAPHY#!4MAGNETICRESONANCEIMAGING-2)ANDELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY%%'4HEYWEREASKEDABOUTTHEAVAILABILITYOFLONGTERMVIDEO%%'MONITORINGTHERAPEUTICDRUGMONITORING

ANDNEUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESANDALSOWHETHERTHERAPEUTICDRUGMONITORINGANDNEUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESWEREAVAILABLEFREEOFCHARGEORWITHOUTSPECIALCONDITIONSWHENCOVEREDBYINSURANCE

3ALIENTlNDINGSU#!4AND-2)AREAVAILABLETOHEALTHPROFESSIONALSINANDRESPECTIVELYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U)N!FRICAWHILE#!4ISAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES-2)ISAVAILABLEINONLY#!4ISAVAILABLEINOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITH-2)WHICHISAVAILABLEINONLY

U%%'ISAVAILABLETOTHEHEALTHPROFESSIONALSDEALINGWITHPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES,ONGTERMVIDEO%%'MONITORINGHOWEVERISAVAILABLEINONLYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U%%'ISAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCIN3OUTH%AST!SIAIN!FRICAINTHE!MERICASINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANANDIN%UROPE

U,ONGTERMVIDEO%%'MONITORINGISAVAILABLEINOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES

U4HERAPEUTICDRUGMONITORINGISAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES)NABOUTTWOTHIRDSOFTHESECOUNTRIESITISAVAILABLETOPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYFREEOFCHARGEORWITHOUTANYSPECIALCONDITION

U4HERAPEUTICDRUGMONITORINGISAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESIN!FRICAINTHE7ESTERN0ACIlCIN3OUTH%AST!SIAINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEANIN%UROPEANDINTHE!MERICAS&URTHERMOREITISAVAILABLEFREEOFCHARGEORWITHOUTANYSPECIALCONDITIONFORPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYINTHREEQUARTEROFCOUNTRIESIN%UROPEWHERESUCHFACILITIESEXISTCOMPAREDWITHONETHIRDINTHE%ASTERN-EDITERRANEAN

U.EUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESAREAVAILABLEINOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES)NMORETHANHALFOFTHESECOUNTRIESTHEYAREAVAILABLETOPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYFREEOFCHARGEORWITHOUTANYSPECIALCONDITION

U.EUROPSYCHOLOGICALSERVICESAREAVAILABLEINOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESANDAREAVAILABLEFREEOFCHARGEINABOUTONETHIRDOFTHEM3UCHFACILITIESAREPRESENTINOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIESANDAREAVAILABLEFREEOFCHARGEINTWOTHIRDSOFTHEM

,IMITATIONSU"ECAUSETHESOURCESOFINFORMATIONINMOSTCOUNTRIESWEREKEYPEOPLEWORKINGINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYTHEDATAPERTAINMAINLYTOCOUNTRIESWHEREINDIVIDUALSWITHANINTERESTINPROVIDINGEPILEPSYCAREEXIST)TISTHEREFOREPOSSIBLETHATTHElGURESMIGHTBEOVERESTIMATED

U3OMEOFTHERESPONDENTSMENTIONEDTHATTHEEQUIPMENTWASPRESENTBUTNOTINWORKINGORDERANDTHEREFORENOTAVAILABLEFORPATIENTCARE

U2ESPONDENTSMAYHAVEREPLIEDPOSITIVELYTOTHEQUESTIONOFAVAILABILITYOFDIAGNOSTICFACILITIESINTHECOUNTRYEVENIFONLYAVERYLIMITEDNUMBEROFSUCHFACILITIESAREAVAILABLEINAFEWLARGECITIES.OINFORMATIONWASOBTAINEDONTHETYPEQUALITYANDESTIMATEDNUMBERSOFSUCHFACILITIES

U)NSOMECOUNTRIESTHEREAREPRIORITYRULESFORACCESSTO#!4OR-2)

#ONCLUSIONSU4HEDIAGNOSTICSERVICESARENEEDEDFORAPPROPRIATEMANAGEMENTOFEPILEPSYESPECIALLYATTHEREFERRALLEVELOFCARE4HEINEQUITIESOBSERVEDACROSSDIFFERENTINCOMEGROUPSANDREGIONSNEEDTOBEDEALTWITH

U-OSTNEWTECHNOLOGIESAREAVAILABLEINMANYCOUNTRIESTHOUGHTHEYMAYBECONCENTRATEDINAFEWCENTRESORIN

MAJORCITIES4HEAIMSHOULDBETOIMPROVETHECOVERAGETOINCLUDETHEENTIREPOPULATION

U3OMETIMESTHEEQUIPMENTCONSTITUTESAMAJORCOMPONENTOFTHECAPITALCOST)NLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESWHEREFEWERRESOURCESAREAVAILABLETHEHIGHRECURRENTCOSTSINVOLVEDINMAINTAININGTHEEQUIPMENTMAYALSOLIMITITSAVAILABILITY

$&!

&

"&

'

$)(

'(

'

)&$%

'(

(&&

##

'(

$*

&"

!

$*&"

!

!

$

%

!

!

%

"

#

$-'!

)#-'!

.

+0/&

./

.'

0-+,#

./#-*

#"'/#--

*# *

#./#

-* !'$

'!

+-("

'"#+

+1

+1#-)

'""(#

'%& #-) '

""(#

'%&

"

&

#

!

"

"

!

"!

"

!

!$

$)!'./34)#3%26)#%3

02)-!29#!2%

)NTRODUCTIONU4HERESPONDENTSWEREASKEDTOLISTTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYCAREWORKERSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCAREINTHECOUNTRY)GNORINGTHEORDEROFTHEINDIVIDUALRESPONSES

THEPROPORTIONOFCOUNTRIESTHATMENTIONEDEACHTASKWASCALCULATEDGLOBALLYANDFOREACHOFTHEREGIONS

3ALIENTlNDINGSU&OLLOWUPANDMONITORINGOFTREATMENTISREPORTEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCAREBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES4HISTASKINCLUDESMONITORINGOF!%$COMPLIANCEANDADVERSEEFFECTS

U-AINTENANCEORPRESCRIPTIONOF!%$SISMENTIONEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U)NFORMATIONANDEDUCATIONOFTHEPATIENTSANDCAREGIVERSREGARDINGEPILEPSYISDESCRIBEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERSBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES!FEWRESPONDENTSALSOMENTIONEDCOUNSELLINGREGARDINGDRIVINGSOCIALISSUESPREGNANCYSCHOOLEDUCATIONFORCHILDRENWITHEPILEPSYMEDICOnLEGALADVICEANDTRAININGINBASIClRSTAIDANDSEIZUREPREVENTIONAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCARE

U#ASElNDINGISREPORTEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERSBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U2EFERRALOFPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYFORCONlRMATIONOFDIAGNOSISINITIATIONOFTREATMENTSPECIALIZEDINVESTIGATIONSORSPECIALISTTREATMENTFORUNCONTROLLEDCASESAREALSOIDENTIlEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYCAREWORKERSBYOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U0SYCHOSOCIALSUPPORTANDCOMMUNITYREHABILITATIONOFTHERESPONDINGCOUNTRIESANDLIAISONWITHSPECIALISTSANDOTHERSERVICESAREALSOREPORTEDAMONGTHElVEMAINTASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERSINVOLVEDINEPILEPSYCARE

U/THERTASKSAREALSOREPORTEDANDINCLUDEEMERGENCYTREATMENTOFTHERESPONDENTSINITIATIONOFTREATMENTANDMAINTENANCEOFRECORDS

U)NFORMATIONANDEDUCATIONOFPATIENTSANDCAREGIVERSREGARDINGEPILEPSYISMENTIONEDASONEOFTHElVEMAINTASKSBYOFLOWINCOMECOUNTRIESCOMPAREDWITHOFHIGHINCOMECOUNTRIES

,IMITATIONSU4HEINFORMATIONISBASEDONTHEEXPERIENCEANDIMPRESSIONOFAKEYPERSONINACOUNTRYWORKINGINTHEAREAOFEPILEPSYANDNOTONACTUALDATAFROMRESPONDINGCOUNTRIES

U4HEDATAREPORTASSESSMENTSBYHEALTHPROFESSIONALSOFTHETASKSPERFORMEDBYTHEPRIMARYCAREWORKERSITISPOSSIBLETHATTHESEMAYDIFFERFROMTHEVIEWSOFTHEPRIMARYCAREWORKERSTHEMSELVES

U)NFORMATIONONTHEQUALITYOFSERVICESANDTHEIRAVAILABILITYWITHINEACHCOUNTRYWASNOTOBTAINED

U"ECAUSETHEINFORMATIONWASNOTOBTAINEDINASTRUCTUREDFORMATITMIGHTALSOUNDERESTIMATESOMEOFTHETASKSPERFORMEDBYTHEPRIMARYCAREWORKERS

#ONCLUSIONSU,ACKOFACCESSHASBEENIDENTIlEDASAMAJORBARRIERTOADEQUATETREATMENTINBOTHHIGHINCOMEANDLOWINCOMECOUNTRIES!DEQUATETRAININGOFTHEHEALTHWORKERSPROVIDINGlRSTLEVELOFCONTACTINCASEDETECTIONINITIATIONOFTREATMENTWITH!%$SWHERELOCALGUIDELINESPERMITFOLLOWUPANDMONITORINGFORCOMPLIANCEANDADVERSEEFFECTSMIGHTBETHEMOSTCOSTEFFECTIVEWAYTODECREASETHETREATMENTGAPINTHEMAJORITYOFCOUNTRIES

U0RIMARYHEALTHWORKERSARETHEMOSTAPPROPRIATECHOICEFORPROVIDINGINFORMATIONANDEDUCATIONTOTHEPATIENTSCAREGIVERSANDTHECOMMUNITYASAWHOLEABOUTTHEDISORDERTHEDRUGSANDTHEIRSIDEEFFECTSANDTHE

IMPLICATIONSANDSOCIALISSUESINVOLVED4HISROLENEEDSTOBEENCOURAGED

U(EALTHSERVICEREFORMSAREONGOINGINMANYCOUNTRIESWHICHPROVIDESTHEPOLICYMAKERSANDPLANNERSWITHANOPPORTUNITYTOINCLUDEADEQUATEEPILEPSYCAREAMONGTHETASKSOFPRIMARYHEALTHWORKERS

U#OMMUNITYBASEDREHABILITATIONNEEDSTOBEADVOCATEDFORBETTERINTEGRATIONANDIMPROVEDPSYCHOSOCIALFUNCTIONINGOFTHEPATIENTWITHEPILEPSY

U"ETTERLIAISONANDREFERRALNETWORKSERVICESBETWEENPRIMARYANDSECONDARYCAREAREREQUIREDTOENSURETHEBESTPOSSIBLECAREFORTHEPATIENTWITHEPILEPSY

(')+

.

',&+)

#*

'$$'-

,(&

%'

+')#&!

#&+

&&

' ),!

*

& ')%

+#'&&

,

+#'&

))

$

*

#&!

,((')

+&)

"#$#+

+#'&

##*'&

%)!

&.+)

+%

&+

+#+#

'&' +

)+%

&+

#&+

&&

' )'

)*

(')+

.

',&+)

#*

'$

$'-,(&

%'

+')#&!

#&+

&&

' ),!

*

& ')%

+#'&&

,

+#'&

))

$

*

#&!

02)-!29#!2%

02/6)3)/./!2%

)NTRODUCTION

4HEPRIMARYFOCUSOFCAREFORPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYISTHEPREVENTIONOFFURTHERSEIZURESWHICHMAYLEADTOADDITIONALMORBIDITYOREVENMORTALITY4HEGOALOFTREATMENTSHOULDBETHEMAINTENANCEOFANORMALLIFESTYLEIDEALLYBYCOMPLETESEIZURECONTROLWITHOUTORWITHMINIMALSIDEEFFECTSSOTHATTHEPATIENTSFUNCTIONALCAPACITYISRESTOREDTOHISORHERMAXIMALPOTENTIAL)FTHESEIZURESAREPROVOKEDBYEXTERNALFACTORSFORINSTANCESLEEPDEPRIVATIONOREXCESSIVEALCOHOLSIMPLEAVOIDANCEMIGHTBESUFlCIENTTOPREVENTFURTHERATTACKS&ORTHEMAJORITYOFPATIENTSHOWEVER!%$THERAPYISTHEMAINSTAYOFTREATMENT.ONPHARMACOLOGICALSTRATEGIESAREPRIMARILYRESERVEDFORDRUGRESISTANTEPILEPSY)NADDITIONTOSEIZURECONTROLPATIENTSWITHEPILEPSYHAVEARANGEOFPSYCHOSOCIALNEEDSTHATMAYREQUIREATTENTION$ESPITETHESHAREDCONCERNSOFPATIENTSANDDOCTORSTHEQUALITYOFCAREANDTHERAPEUTICOUTCOMEMAYDIFFERACROSSCOUNTRIESBECAUSEOFVARIATIONSINMEDICALSYSTEMS4HE#OMMISSIONOF%UROPEAN!FFAIRSOF),!%HASDElNEDSTANDARDSFORAPPROPRIATECAREWHICHHAVENOTYETBEENMETBYMANY%UROPEANCOUNTRIES4HESITUATIONINMANYDEVELOPINGCOUNTRIESISLIKELYTOBEEVENLESSSATISFACTORY

0HARMACOLOGICALTREATMENT

-ODERNPHARMACOTHERAPYOFEPILEPSYWASHERALDEDBYTHESERENDIPITOUSDISCOVERYOFTHEANTICONVULSANTPROPERTIESOFPHENOBARBITALINBY!LFRED(AUPTMANN$ESPITETHEDEVELOPMENTOFSUCCESSIVEGENERATIONSOF!%$SPHENOBARBITALHASRETAINEDAUNIQUEPOSITIONINTHETHERAPEUTICARMAMENTARIUMANDISSTILLTHEMOSTWIDELYPRESCRIBEDTREATMENTWORLDWIDE)TSADVANTAGESINCLUDERELIABILITYOFSUPPLYAFFORDABLECOSTBROADSPECTRUMOFACTIONANDEASEOFUSE4HEDRUGALSOHASDISADVANTAGESSUCHASSEDATIONBEHAVIOURALSIDEEFFECTSENZYMEINDUCTIONANDPOSSIBLETERATOGENESIS

!NOTHERSIGNIlCANTMILESTONEIN!%$DEVELOPMENTWASTHEINTRODUCTIONOFPHENYTOINTHElRSTNONSEDATING!%$INTHESASARESULTOFSYSTEMATICSCREENINGOFCOMPOUNDSUSINGNOVELANIMALMODELS!NUMBEROFOTHER!%$SHAVEBECOMEAVAILABLEINTHEENSUINGYEARSINCLUDINGCARBAMAZEPINEETHOSUXIMIDEPRIMIDONEVALPROICACIDANDSOMEBENZODIAZEPINES4HESEAGENTSAREGENERALLYREGARDEDAShOLDvORhESTABLISHEDv!%$S!FTERAHIATUSOFNEARLYYEARSTHEREHASBEENACCELERATEDDEVELOPMENTOFNEWER!%$SWITHCOMPOUNDSHAVINGBEENLICENSEDGLOBALLYSINCETHELATES4HESEAREINCHRONOLOGICALORDERVIGABATRINZONISAMIDEOXCARBAZEPINELAMOTRIGINEFELBAMATEGABAPENTINTOPIRAMATETIAGABINELEVETIRACETAMANDPREGABALIN!LTHOUGHNONEOFTHEMODERN!%$SHASDEMONSTRATEDSUPERIOREFlCACYTOTHEESTABLISHEDAGENTSTHEYMAYBETHEPREFERREDOPTIONFORSOMEPATIENTSASTHEYAREGENERALLYBETTERTOLERATEDANDPRODUCEFEWERDRUGINTER

ACTIONS7HETHERTHEIRSUBSTANTIALLYHIGHERCOSTISJUSTIlEDINTHEMAJORITYOFPEOPLEWITHEPILEPSYISOPENTODEBATE

!%$SDIFFERINMANYIMPORTANTASPECTSINCLUDINGTHEIREFlCACYAGAINSTDIFFERENTSEIZURETYPESIEABSENCEMYOCLONUSPARTIALTONICnCLONICANDATONICTHEIRSIDEEFFECTPROlLESIENEUROTOXICITYIDIOSYNCRATICREACTIONSLONGTERMCOMPLICATIONSANDTERATOGENICITYTHEIRPOTENTIALFORPHARMACOKINETICINTERACTIONSIEENZYMEINDUCTIONANDINHIBITIONANDTHEIREASEOFUSEIETITRATIONANDDAILYDOSING!N!%$SHOULDBESELECTEDTOhMATCHvTHECHARACTERISTICSOFTHEPATIENTSUCHASHISORHEREPILEPSYSYNDROMEAGEGENDERCOEXISTINGILLNESSESANDCONCOMITANTMEDICATION7HENMONOTHERAPYHASFAILEDTHEREAREINSUFlCIENTDATATOGUIDETHEPHYSICIANONHOWBESTTOCOMBINE!%$S#OMBINATIONSWITHLOWRISKOFPHARMACOKINETICINTERACTIONSSHOULDBEPREFERREDANDTHEREISSOMEEVIDENCETHATTHESUCCESSOFDUOTHERAPYCANBEIMPROVEDBYPAYINGATTENTIONTOMECHANISMSOFACTIONANDUSINGLOWERDOSAGES

0ATIENTSNEWLYDIAGNOSEDWITHEPILEPSYSHOULDBESTARTEDONASINGLE!%$WHICHWILLBEEFFECTIVEINCONTROLLINGTHEIRSEIZURESINAPPROXIMATELY4REATMENTMAYBESAFELYWITHDRAWNINSOMEPATIENTSWHOHAVEENTEREDREMISSIONPARTICULARLYINCHILDREN4HEREISSTILLNOCONSENSUSABOUTTHEDURATIONOFREMISSIONBEFORE!%$WITHDRAWALSHOULDSTART)NCHILDRENAPERIODOFSIXMONTHSHASBEENADVOCATEDANDINADULTSAPERIODOFATLEASTTWOYEARS7HENTWOSUCCESSIVE!%$SGIVENASMONOTHERAPYHAVEFAILEDMOSTAUTHORITIESWOULDRECOMMENDCOMBINATIONTHERAPY/UTCOMESTUDIESSUGGESTTHATAFTERFAILUREOFTWOORTHREETREATMENTSCHEDULESTHECHANCEOFSUBSEQUENTREMISSIONWITHFURTHERDRUGMANIPULATIONISSMALL"ETWEENANDOFPATIENTSWILLCONTINUETOHAVESEIZURESDESPITEhOPTIMALv!%$THERAPY4HESEINDIVIDUALSWITHREFRACTORYEPILEPSYSHOULDBEASSESSEDFORSUITABILITYOFNONPHARMACOLOGICALMANAGEMENTSTRATEGIESSUCHASSURGERYVAGUSNERVESTIMULATION6.3ORKETOGENICDIET

.ONPHARMACOLOGICALTREATMENT

%PILEPSYSURGERYISDISCUSSEDSEPARATELYIN3ECTION!NOTHERFORMOFNONPHARMACOLOGICALTREATMENTFORMEDICALLYINTRACTABLEEPILEPSYIS6.34HEVAGUSNERVESTIMULATORCONSISTSOFAPROGRAMMABLESIGNALGENERATORIMPLANTEDUNDERTHESKININTHEPATIENTSLEFTUPPERCHEST0OWEREDBYABATTERYTHESYSTEMDELIVERSINTERMITTENTELECTRICALSTIMULATIONTOTHELEFTVAGUSNERVEINTHENECKVIAACONNECTINGLEAD6.3HASDEMONSTRATEDEFlCACYAGAINSTPARTIALONSETANDGENERALIZEDSEIZURESALTHOUGHFEWPATIENTSHAVEBECOMESEIZUREFREE)TISGENERALLYWELLTOLERATEDANDIMPLANTATIONISNOTTECHNICALLYDEMANDING

4HEKETOGENICDIETISAHIGHFATLOWPROTEINANDVERYLOWCARBOHYDRATEDIETUSEDMOSTLYINCHILDRENWITHMEDICALLYINTRACTABLEEPILEPSY)TCANBEVERYEFFECTIVEINPATIENTS

$R0ATRICK+WAN0ROF-ARTIN*"RODIE

02/6)3)/./!2%

WHOHAVEFAILEDNUMEROUSDRUGTRIALS4HEMAJORPROBLEMINITSUSEISADHERENCETOTHERESTRICTIVEDIETARYREGIME#L