Environmental monitoring in soil contamination and remediation programs: how practitioners are using the Internet to share knowledge

Download Environmental monitoring in soil contamination and remediation programs: how practitioners are using the Internet to share knowledge

Post on 06-Mar-2017




0 download


<ul><li><p>CriticalReview</p><p>Environmental monitoring in soil contamination and remediation</p><p>programs: how practitioners are using the Internet to share knowledge</p><p>Turlough F. Guerin</p><p>Shell Engineering Ltd., NSW State Office, PO Box 26, Granville, 2142 New South Wales,Australia. E-mail: turlough.guerin@shell.com.au</p><p>Received 29th January 2001, Accepted 14th March 2001First published as an Advance Article on the web 24th April 2001</p><p>Internet listservers provide a means for professionals from all sectors of the industry and profession, to</p><p>communicate and collaborate with each other, as well as other stakeholders (e.g., suppliers, academics, the</p><p>general public and community members) in real time. This article highlights key Internet listservers in the field of</p><p>environmental monitoring in soil contamination and remediation and how to subscribe to them. The most active</p><p>and relevant listservers for environmental scientists, technologists and professionals in the soil contamination</p><p>and remediation profession are the Bioremediation Discussion Group (BioGroup), Phytonet, Phytoremediation</p><p>listserver, Groundwater listserver and Environmental Forensics listserver. Other observations and lessons so far</p><p>from the use of Internet listservers are: (i) that moderators provide an important role in maintaining the level of</p><p>quality and participation, (ii) do not underestimate the knowledge base held within these, and (iii) if not selected</p><p>and managed properly, e-mail from listservers can generate an excess of e-mail and waste time.</p><p>Introduction</p><p>The generation of knowledge in environmental monitoring ofsoil contamination and remediation has increased dramaticallyover the past 20 years. Over this time, international collabora-tion on soil contamination and remediation issues has becomeevident at the highest level between countries.1 Formation ofpartnerships for joint research and implementing site assess-ment and remediation solutions, are developing2,3 and there arenow numerous international organizations and collaborations,and websites resulting from these, providing access tocompleted reports and other shared learnings, e.g., US EPA,RTDF (Research &amp; Technology Development Forum), andNATOs Committee for Challenges of Modern Society.47</p><p>Lower-level interactions between organizations and individualpractitioners have also increased, particularly so with thewidespread adoption of the Internet in developed nations overthe past 510 years. International collaboration is nowbecoming a topic of interest at international conferences onsoil contamination and remediation. For example, this topicper se (excluding presentations based on the results ofinternational collaboration), was addressed as the primarycontent of up to 7% of all the presentations at two recentinternational soil contamination and remediation conferences.8</p><p>For effective technology transfer and adoption it isimportant to recognize and harness informal networks ofprofessionals.9 This applies to corporations with potentialtechnology adopters within operating business units, companypractitioners and consultants. It also applies to governmentsand non-governmental organizations.</p><p>Internet listservers have become an important mechanismfor technology and information transfer, a technology in itselfthat is enabling this networking. In a soil contamination andremediation context, the use of the Internet and Internetlistservers are contributing to the sharing of knowledge at allthese levels, encouraging contributions from a wide range ofpractitioners and allowing the widespread distribution of ideasin this diverse field.10 As previously described in a recentpublication on the Internet and listservers as sources ofinformation and knowledge, if moderated by an expert in thefield, listservers can be useful resources, particularly for rapid</p><p>exchange of ideas and discussion.11 From this perspective,Internet listservers have much to offer as a means of supportingcollaborative learning and technology transfer.</p><p>The purpose of this article is to provide environmentalscientists, technologists and professionals with information tohelp them decide which listservers to subscribe to and how todo this. The focus of this discussion is summarized in thefollowing question: How can environmental professionals,working in the field of soil contamination and remediation,access the knowledge of other related professionals using Internetlistservers? In addressing this focus, the discussion addressesthe following related questions.</p><p>What are Internet listservers and how can they be used?Which are the key Internet listservers available to environ-</p><p>mental scientists, technologists, and professionals working inthe field of environmental monitoring of soil contaminationand remediation?</p><p>What have we learnt so far about Internet listservers andtheir usefulness for environmental scientists, technologists, andprofessionals?</p><p>Internet listservers</p><p>Software issues</p><p>Listservers are subscribed electronic discussion groups thatallow the users on the mailing listserver to exchangeinformation with one another and post questions on a broadrange of topics. The exchange of information takes place viae-mail where the message that one posts to the listserver will bebroadcast to everyone on that particular listserver. Thesoftware responsible for the management and distribution ofe-mail messages to subscribers, are commonly called list-servers. A listserver automatically distributes an e-mailmessage from one member of a listserver to all other memberson that listserver.</p><p>There are two important facts that potential listserversubscribers need to know. First, in order to access theinformation on the listserver, one needs to subscribe to it viaan e-mail account. An Internet browser is required to openthese websites, such as Microsoft Internet Explorer, Netscape</p><p>DOI: 10.1039/b100984m J. Environ. Monit., 2001, 3, 267273 267</p><p>This journal is # The Royal Society of Chemistry 2001</p><p>Publ</p><p>ishe</p><p>d on</p><p> 24 </p><p>Apr</p><p>il 20</p><p>01. D</p><p>ownl</p><p>oade</p><p>d by</p><p> Nor</p><p>thea</p><p>ster</p><p>n U</p><p>nive</p><p>rsity</p><p> on </p><p>29/1</p><p>0/20</p><p>14 1</p><p>8:35</p><p>:35.</p><p> View Article Online / Journal Homepage / Table of Contents for this issue</p><p>http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/b100984mhttp://pubs.rsc.org/en/journals/journal/EMhttp://pubs.rsc.org/en/journals/journal/EM?issueid=EM003003</p></li><li><p>Communicator or Eudora. Second, every listserver has twoaddresses. The first is the listserver manager address. This isthe address to which administrative commands are sent (e.g.subscribe or unsubscribe). Only the software sees thesemessages. The other address is the listserver address. Thisis where messages are sent that are directed to everyone on thelistserver. Listservers, in many instances, are set up so that onlysubscribers may post.</p><p>Subscriptions to listservers</p><p>Once it has been decided which listservers are to be subscribedto, one can then manage these relatively easily. It is possible tobe subscribed to several of these listservers simultaneously.Many professionals indicate that subscription to listservers canfill their e-mail inboxes and of course that is true and alimitation of having information served up to an e-mailaccount. But this can be handled relatively simply withfunctions on the e-mail software, which can sort incominge-mails from various listservers into specific inbox folders.Microsoft Outlook for example, will allow subscribers to directincoming e-mails from a range of listservers to specific folders,within Microsoft Outlook, to keep listserver e-mails frompersonal e-mails. Alternatively, one can subscribe via adifferent account that one can freely access on the Internet(e.g. www.hotmail.com) and have subscriptions go there, whichagain can be handled relatively easily. A drawback with thesefree Internet service providers is that they can be very slow touse. Also, some listservers have a digest option that ensuresthat subscribers only receive one e-mail from that listserverover a specified period of time, e.g., over a 24 h period. Ifparticular listservers prove to be unsuitable for ones purposesafter a period of evaluation, it is simply a matter ofunsubscribing from that listserver.</p><p>The instructions for subscribing to each of the listservers areusually described at a website or URL (universal resourcelocator). At the time of publication of this article, the URLsgiven in this article were correct. Where there has been a changein homepage spelling, search the Internet using a powerfulsearch engine such as http://www.copernic.com to find the newURL location of the listserver, if it still exists.</p><p>First time users and housekeeping issues</p><p>It is prudent, as a first time subscriber, not to expect text-book answers, even from the most carefully worded questionsposted to a listserver. The main value of listservers lies in thevariety of responses and opinions surrounding the topic inquestion. On the other hand, be careful not to underestimatethe knowledge base that can contribute to these discussions.Dont think that there will be little value in joining. At least tryone of the listservers described in this article to see the widerange of contributions in terms of both style, skill andknowledge. Furthermore, dont be put off by a poor responseor an apparent personal attack when posting a messageit istypically best to ignore these. Sometimes questions or postingsto a listserver need to be reworded and clarifications made andthen resent. Requests should be worded carefully, thinkingthrough how others on the listserver will perceive a posting. Inthe case of the BioGroup, only y25% of first-time posts areaccepted.</p><p>One of the most valuable aspects of listservers is the varietyof participants, so also be willing to accept new ideas oropinions, even if they seem to run contrary to conventionalwisdom. Provide context for other subscribers wherever this ispossible though one should be sensitive when dealing withconfidential clients or particular contaminated sites, or specificenvironmental problems. This will help to ensure that onereceives the maximum number of relevant responses to a posted</p><p>question. A single sentence may be sufficient to providecontext.</p><p>In most cases, if one posts a message that is not quite ontopic, other subscribers will usually provide guidance onchoosing a more suitable forum or the participant will notreceive an answer. Some contributors will even suggest thatperhaps the right question is not being asked. This is valuablefeedback. It is worth looking at or searching the online archivesof these listservers (where these are available) prior to posting acontribution. These will provide an idea of the topics actuallycovered on the particular listserver of interest and the culture ofthe group including the level of detail of the discussion, theresponses to new ideas and spam.</p><p>It is important to remember to turn off the auto-reply for anye-mail address that is the recipient of messages from alistserver. This prevents all participants receiving unnecessarye-mails and helps keep participants focused on discussionsrelating to the reason for forming the listserver in the first place.</p><p>Netiquette</p><p>Listserver participants should understand and practice neti-quette. This is Internet language for manners. Much of onessuccess from the use of the Internet, in a broader sense, stemsfrom an understanding and practice of netiquette.</p><p>Netiquette is probably the most overlooked aspect of usingthe Internet and will be one of the most important challengesfor professionals being effective in using the Internet-basedcommunication technologies in the future. Subscribers shouldalso check the specific requirements of postings contributionsto listservers as these often vary. This also applies to the morefundamental aspects of listservers such as sending commandsto the correct listserver address, keeping messages succinct,using descriptive subject headers lines, subscribing/unsubscrib-ing in the correct manner. For example, an activity whichprovides a simple courtesy to other participants and also ofgreat valuable to busy participants, is to provide a clearsentence in the subject line header that gives the reader a clue asto what they are about to read and also includes anabbreviation of the listservers name such as BG: CurrentRemediation Options for PCE in Vadose Zone? for theBioGroup Listserver. Other netiquette issues are as follows:</p><p>Information that is easily obtainable from other codifiedsources, e.g., a library, database, or a readily available book,should not typically be requested on listservers.</p><p>Where possible post a summary of all answers to thelistserver that one received from personal e-mails answering aspecific query to a listserver, where the topic is likely to be ofgeneral interest.</p><p>With all these listservers, use English language at all times,unless the listserver has been established to accommodate otherlanguages.</p><p>As a general rule on listservers, do not post any attachmentsto messages.</p><p>Aim to keep messages as brief as possible or practical.Given the worldwide distribution of many listservers, it is</p><p>also imperative that acronyms be clearly defined in all postedmessages.</p><p>An excellent coverage of netiquette is given at http://www.collaborative-learning.org/resources/tools/e-mail.html#global.</p><p>Advertising and advertorials</p><p>It is important not to spam on listservers. Spam is anadvertisement or other unsolicited material sent to largenumbers of listservers with no consideration for whether ornot the material is appropriate for the listservers it is being sentto. Spam, which is usually posted by individuals external to theinterest groups on these listservers, is a good way for a listserver</p><p>268 J. Environ. Monit., 2001, 3, 267273</p><p>Publ</p><p>ishe</p><p>d on</p><p> 24 </p><p>Apr</p><p>il 20</p><p>01. D</p><p>ownl</p><p>oade</p><p>d by</p><p> Nor</p><p>thea</p><p>ster</p><p>n U</p><p>nive</p><p>rsity</p><p> on </p><p>29/1</p><p>0/20</p><p>14 1</p><p>8:35</p><p>:35.</p><p> View Article Online</p><p>http://dx.doi.org/10.1039/b100984m</p></li><li><p>moderator to decide to stop the listserver or to send faithfulsubscribers away.</p><p>Most listservers explicitly do not want commercial e-mails,and to most listserver members these would be unwelcomemessages or spam. However, there can be tremendous value inbeing able (in a tasteful and sensitive way) to get ones messagethrough to several hundred or several thousand people with aknown or likely interest in ones product or service. Listserversprovide a type of demographically preselected, focusedaudience, and indeed many members of such an audiencecould well benefit from learning about legitimate products andservices tailored for their needs and professions. Participantsneed to be sensitive to the need to avoid overtly commercialpostings to any listserver. If one decides to send out suchadvertisements, be sure to include something newsworthy or ofgeneral interest. The challenge is how to do it withoutalienating the majority of the members who dont wantcommercial messages on the listserver. Though unsolicitedvendor claims are typically unwelcome, advertisementannouncements within the following areas are usually toleratedproviding they are infrequent and substantive:</p><p>Information on events such...</p></li></ul>


View more >