enron broadband services. ac_00_communications-1 today’s message the broadband explosion is real,...

72
Enron Broadband Services

Upload: sydney-banks

Post on 30-Dec-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Enron Broadband Services

AC_00_Communications-

2

Today’s Message

The Broadband Explosion Is Real, It Is Here Now and It Will Fundamentally Change the Existing Internet Delivery Platform

The Enron Business Model, Which Emphasizes Open, Robust Networks and Markets, Will Enable Enron to Develop the Most Efficient Broadband Delivery Network in the World

Enron Broadband Has Already Established the Superior Broadband Delivery Network

AC_00_Communications-

3

Key Metrics

1997 1998 1999 2000 2001

Fiber Route Miles

1999

15,00018,000

12,325

2001E 2000E

5,538

1,755

19981997

1997 1998 1999 2000 2001

13

Pooling Points

1999

40

2001E 2000E

30

1997

0

1998

Servers

1997 1998 1999 2000 20011999 2001E 2000E

1,500

3,000

222

1997

0 0

1998

1997 1998 1999 2000 2001

Total Headcount

1999 2001E 2000E

1,100

775

490

8925

19981997

AC_00_Communications-

4

Enron’s Target Market

Bandwidth Market

High Bandwidth Applications–Video–Large File Transfer

Illustrative

Low Bandwidth Applications–Voice–Text

1999Today

2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008

Volume

AC_00_Communications-

5

The Internet

• Open• Ubiquitous• Flexible

• Designed for Text World–Slow Speed–Limited Data Interchange

Advantages Disadvantages

A B

AC_00_Communications-

6

A

Proposed Solution

A B A B

Add Intelligence

to the System

Bypass Internet With Point-to- Point Connection

B

AC_00_Communications-

7

A

Add Intelligence to the System

Players

Caching

– Inktomi

Route Selection

– Akamai

Router Upgrade

– RSVP Protocol

Issues

Big Improvement for Lower Bandwidth Applications

Does Not Solve Problem for High Bandwidth Applications

B

AC_00_Communications-

8

A B

Bypass Internet with Point-to-Point Connection

Players

MCI Worldcom

Qwest

AT&T

Williams

Level 3

Issues

Lack of Ubiquity, Flexibility

High Capital Intensity

AC_00_Communications-

9

A B

Enron’s Approach

MCI WorldComQwest

AT&TWilliams

AC_00_Communications-

10

Enron’s Approach

Advantages Extremely High Quality of Service (QoS)

Extremely High Capacity; Ability to Handle the Highest Bandwidth Applications

Ubiquitous

Flexible - Ability to Provision Bandwidth Real-Time

Absolutely Lowest Cost

Other Features

Ability to Differentiate QoS

Ability to Forward Reserve Bandwidth

Ability to Provide Full Range of Financial Products and Services Along-Side Physical Capacity

– Forward Price Contracts– Derivatives and Hedges– Financing

AC_00_Communications-

11

Enron Broadband Services

Enron Intelligent

Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

AC_00_Communications-

12

Enron Broadband Services

BandwidthIntermediation

Enron Intelligent

Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

Be the World’sLargest Buyer

andSeller of

Bandwidth

Bandwidth Management

Trading

Finance

AC_00_Communications-

13

Enron Broadband Services

Enron Intelligent

Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

Streaming Broadband Services

Data Asset Management Services

ContentServices

Be the World’s Largest Provider

of Premium Broadband

Delivery Services

Be the World’sLargest Buyer

andSeller of

Bandwidth

BandwidthIntermediation

Bandwidth Management

Trading

FinanceCD Track 3CD Track

1

AC_00_Communications-

14

Today’s Discussion

Enron Intelligent Network

Business Centers

Intermediation

Content Services

Financials

BOS

AC_00_Communications-

15

Enron Intelligent Network(EIN)Enron

Intelligent Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

ContentServices

BandwidthIntermediation

Be the World’sLargest Buyer

andSeller of

Bandwidth

Be the World’s Largest Provider

of Premium Broadband

Delivery Services

Bandwidth Management

Trading

Finance

Streaming Broadband Services

Data Asset Management Services

AC_00_Communications-

161997 1998 1999 2000E 2001E

5,538

12,32515,000

18,000

1,755

EIN Route Miles

FiberOwned and Contracted

Dallas

London

Paris

Copenhagen

Munich

Amsterdam

Rome

Omaha

San Francisco

San Jose

Los Angeles

San Diego

TokyoPhoenix

AlbuquerqueLas Vegas

HoustonSan Antonio

Orlando

Miami

New Orleans

Seattle

Portland

Sacramento

Boise

Denver Chicago

Minneapolis

Kansas CityWashington D.C.

Philadelphia

Charlotte

Jackson

Atlanta

Boston

Detroit

Albany

Salt Lake City

Cleveland

St. Louis

Toronto

New York

CD Track 3CD Track 2

AC_00_Communications-

17

Fiber

State of the Art Fiber Optic Network

–Pure Internet Protocol (IP)

–12 Fibers, Each Upgradable to

OC-192

–Low Capital and Operating Costs

Low Cost Scalability

Provides Guaranteed Backstop for Enron’s Firm Delivery Commitments

AC_00_Communications-

18

Servers

Dallas

London

Paris

Copenhagen

Munich

Amsterdam

Rome

Omaha

San Francisco

San Jose

Los Angeles

San Diego

TokyoPhoenix

AlbuquerqueLas Vegas

HoustonSan Antonio

Orlando

Miami

New Orleans

Seattle

Portland

Sacramento

Boise

DenverChicago

Minneapolis

Kansas City Washington D.C.

Philadelphia

Charlotte

Jackson

Atlanta

Boston

Detroit

Albany

Salt Lake City

Cleveland

St. Louis

Toronto

New York

1998 1999 2000E 2001E

0222

1,500

3,000

CD Track 3CD Track 3

AC_00_Communications-

19

Servers

18 GB Storage and 500-1,000 Broadband Stream Capacity

Automated, Flexible Market Interconnects

Co-Located With Distribution Partners

High-Capacity Broadband Servers “One Hop” From End Users

Enron’s Distributed Server Architecture Capable of Serving 2-3 Million

Broadband Streams Simultaneously by 2001

AC_00_Communications-

20

Pooling Points

Los Angeles

Public

London

New York

AC_00_Communications-

21

This Slide is Not in Your Book

AC_00_Communications-

22

Pooling Points

Large-Scale Electronic Bandwidth

“Switches” that Enable Real-Time Circuit

ProvisioningOff the Shelf, Proven Lucent Equipment

Proprietary Enron Software

Highly Scalable

Connects Multiple Carriers and Multiple

CircuitsEnron’s Pooling Points Provide Real-Time Access to Bandwidth and Ability to

Dynamically Scale Network

Enron’s Pooling Points Provide Real-Time Access to Bandwidth and Ability to

Dynamically Scale Network

AC_00_Communications-

23

Network Connectivity

Dallas

London

Paris

Copenhagen

Munich

Amsterdam

Rome

Omaha

San Francisco

San Jose

Los AngelesSan Diego

TokyoPhoenix

AlbuquerqueLas Vegas

HoustonSan Antonio

Orlando

Miami

New Orleans

Seattle

Portland

Sacramento

Boise

Chicago

Minneapolis

Kansas City Washington D.C.

Charlotte

Jackson

Atlanta

Boston

Detroit

Albany

Salt Lake City

Cleveland

St. Louis

Toronto

New York

Denver

Philadelphia

Fiber Network

Servers

Public Pooling Points

AC_00_Communications-

24

Network Control Software

Routing – Network Element

Control

Bandwidth Reservation

Quality of Service

Metering

Applications Management

AC_00_Communications-

25

ContentProvider

ISP

ISP

Poor Quality Video Stream

The EIN: UnparalleledContent Delivery, Quality and Reliability

CD Track 3CD Track 6

Dallas

London

Paris

Copenhagen

Munich

Amsterdam

Rome

Omaha

San Francisco

San Jose

Los AngelesSan Diego

TokyoPhoenix

AlbuquerqueLas Vegas

HoustonSan Antonio

Orlando

Miami

New Orleans

Seattle

Portland

Sacramento

Boise

Chicago

Minneapolis

Kansas City Washington D.C.

Charlotte

JacksonAtlanta

Boston

Detroit

Albany

Salt Lake City

Cleveland

St. Louis

Toronto

New York

DenverPhiladelphia

EIN

InternetHigh Quality

Low Quality

AC_00_Communications-

26

Supplier Functionality

The EINMajor Industry Participants

DWDM Equipment Maximizes Broadband Transmission Capacity Over the EIN Network

Routers Control Physical Flow of Data

Software Provides Data Storage and Retrieval

Servers Interconnect Network and Physically Store Data “One Hop” From End Users

Lucent Bandwidth Manager Enables Real Time Switching of Circuits

DWDM and Optical Switching

Lucent TechnologiesBell Labs Industries

Caching Software Distributes Data Among Servers Closest to End Users

AC_00_Communications-

27

The EINComments by Leading Industry Participants

Business Model Technology

Jonathan SchwartzVice President, Venture and

Strategic Investments

Graeme FraserV.P. of Engineering, Optical

Networking

David Peterschmidt Dr. Adam BeguelinChief Executive Officer Senior Scientist

CD Track 3CD Track 7

AC_00_Communications-

28

Today’s Discussion

Enron Intelligent Network

Business Centers

Intermediation

Content Services

Financials

BOS

AC_00_Communications-

29

Intermediation

Outsourcing of Bandwidth

Customized Bandwidth Solutions

Bandwidth Optimization

Pricing and Structuring

Risk Management

Physical Services

Trading Finance

Structured Financial Solutions

Investments

Bandwidth Management

AC_00_Communications-

30

Ease of Creating a Commodity Intermediation Business

Attitude of Participants

Favorable

Unfavorable

Natural Gas1980’s

Electricity1990’s

Bandwidth 2000’s

Motivated Monopoly Massive Take or Pay

MostlyTied to Monopoly

Monopoly Motivated

Motivated Motivated Motivated

Sellers Interconnection BuyersSellers

AC_00_Communications-

31

Ease of Creating a Commodity Intermediation Business

Number of Players

FavorableUnfavorable

Sellers Interconnection Buyers

Natural Gas1980’s

Electricity1990’s

Bandwidth 2000’s

Many Few Many

Many Few Many

Many Many Many

Sellers

AC_00_Communications-

32

Bandwidth Management

AggregateDiscreteBandwidthObligations

Reconfigure& OptimizePortfolios

Build Large Market & Supply Portfolios

Deliver New Products & Contract Structures

AC_00_Communications-

33

Bandwidth Management –Typical Capacity Utilization Profile

100%

90%

80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%

1/2/2000 1/3/2000 1/4/2000 1/5/2000 1/6/2000 1/7/2000 1/8/2000 1/9/2000 1/10/2000

Peak UtilizationAverage

25%

AC_00_Communications-

34

0

20

40

60

80

100

Aggregate Discrete Bundles of Bandwidth Into Diversified Portfolios

• Allows More Efficient Allocation of Bandwidth

• Creates Incremental Bandwidth “Headroom”

• Provides Framework for Tiered QoS Bandwidth

Allocation

Media

0

20

40

60

80

100

Financial

0

20

40

60

80

100

Enron

0

20

40

60

80

100

One Week

One Week

One Week

One Week

Financial

Media

Enron

Retail

%

%

%

%

Composite

0

20

40

60

80

100

One Week

AC_00_Communications-

35

Reconfigure and Optimize Portfolios

0

20

40

60

80

100

Avg.

QoS SensitiveApplications

QoS Insensitive Applications

Incremental Firm Capacity

AC_00_Communications-

36

By Identifying Non-QoS or Time Sensitive Applications and Routing Them Over Alternate Routes or in “Time Troughs”, Enron Can Create More

Firm “Headroom”

0

20

40

60

80

100

New Product and Contract Structures

QoS SensitiveApplications

QoS Insensitive Applications

3rd Party QoS Insensitive Applications

Capacity Available for Resale

AC_00_Communications-

37

Outsourcing of Bandwidth Management

Enables Enron to Accelerate Creation of Portfolios

Businesses, ISP’s, Media Companies and Telecom Resellers Will Increasingly Outsource Bandwidth Requirements as Broadband Becomes More Predominant

Outsourcing is a Direct Application of Enron Energy Services Outsourcing Skill Set

AC_00_Communications-

38

Replace With One Term Enron Broadband Contract– Flexible and Reliable– Price Certainty– Expandable

Replace With One Term Enron Broadband Contract– Flexible and Reliable– Price Certainty– Expandable

Global Corporate Customer– 20 Offices Globally– 35 Circuits– $10 Million per Year

Global Corporate Customer– 20 Offices Globally– 35 Circuits– $10 Million per Year

Enron Solution

Outsourcing of Bandwidth Management

Today

Enron

AC_00_Communications-

39

Trading

Trading of Bandwidth Enables Reconfiguration of Portfolios

Establishment of Benchmark and Market Pricing for Outsourcing and Portfolio Management

Foundation for Risk Management Services and New Product Development

Enron Has Been the Primary Architect of Market Structures in Most Major

Markets in Which It Participates

AC_00_Communications-

40

TradingCreating Cash and Forward Markets for

BandwidthStandardized Benchmark and Emerging Liquidity Become Foundationfor Reliable Market

- Segment City Pair: NY to LA- Bandwidth Unit TDM DS-3 (44.7 Mbps)- Term 1 Month Increments- QoS Errored Seconds: Not More Than 400 Errored Seconds Per Day Severely Errored Seconds: Not More Than 4 Severely Errored

Seconds Per Day Unavailable Seconds: Not More Than 26 Unavailable

Seconds Per Month

With Emergence of Liquidity, Price Discovery and Standardization, Risk Management Products Evolve

Alternative Routes and QoS Will Trade At a Discount or Premiumto Benchmark

AC_00_Communications-

41

Finance

Apply Enron Finance Expertise as Tool to Aggregate Portfolios

Lever Structured Finance, Investments and Risk Management Skills into Opportunities that Enhance the Performance and Content of the Network

Enron Has Been the Leader in Creating New Finance Alternatives in Markets in

Which It Participates

AC_00_Communications-

42

Structured Finance Investments

Providing Capital Access Solutions for Customers and

Suppliers

Leading Edge Network Technologies and Enron’s

Broadband Content

• Equipment Funding Pools

• Bandwidth Monetization

Structures

• DSL Implementation Fund

NetworkTechnologyEquinixAviciSycamore Networks

BroadbandContentDENSalus MediaM.Show.com

Finance

AC_00_Communications-

43

Trading

Risk Management

Pooling Point

Research

Logistics

Structuring

Finance

Risk Assessment Interface

Intermediation Services Organization

Business Development

Rich DiMichele (6)

Joint Ventures

M & A

Technology

Content

Portfolio Management

Bandwidth Origination

Bandwidth Outsourcing

Bandwidth Restructures

VenturesKevin Garland

(9)

Global FinanceKevin Howard

(12)

Global Trading &

Risk Management

Tom Gros (20)

Bandwidth Management Ted Seitz (10)

AC_00_Communications-

44

Content Services

Enron Intelligent

Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

ContentServices

BandwidthIntermediation

Be the World’sLargest Buyer

andSeller of

Bandwidth

Be the World’s Largest Provider

of Premium Broadband

Delivery Services

Bandwidth Management

Trading

Finance

Streaming Broadband Services

Data Asset Management Services

AC_00_Communications-

45

Content Services

High Quality Streaming Video

Usage-Based Business Model

Other Broadband Applications

Video File Transfer

Engineered CAD/CAM Data Management

Storing/Archiving Data

Digital AssetManagement

Services

StreamingBroadbandServices

AC_00_Communications-

46

Demand for Streaming Video

The Internet is Inadequate for Premium Broadband Content Delivery

The Internet is Inadequate for Premium Broadband Content Delivery

Red Herring December 1999

In 1998, 9% of U.S. Organizations Were Using Streaming Video on Their Web Sites….This Percentage is Expected to Grow to 25-35% in the Next Two Years

- Gartner/Dataquest

Today, Rich Media Ads Account For 1% of Internet Ads….by 2002, 60% of All Internet Banner Ads Will Be Rich Media

- Jupiter Communications

An Estimated 45 Million Users Actually Stream Media Each Month

- Vision Consultancy

AC_00_Communications-

47

Enron’s Solution

Provide EIN Solutions to Enable Enron’s Customers to Effortlessly Utilize Streaming Media to Access Their Customers

- Access Large, Diverse Customer Base

- Encoding Content

- Scheduling and Reserving Bandwidth

- Distribute Content to Servers at the Edge of Network

- High Quality and Reliable Serving of Streams

- Accurate, Quality of Service and Appropriate Billing

Enable Customers to Tailor the Quality of Service That Is Appropriate for the Content

Initial Target Market: Early Adopters

- Financial Services

- Media and Entertainment

- Technology

AC_00_Communications-

48

Content ServicesCustomer Base

Financial Services

– Major Financial Institutions

– Major Consulting Firms

– Financial News Services

Media and Entertainment

– Traditional Broadcast Networks

– Emerging Internet-Based Production Companies

– Professional Sports

– Movie Production Companies

Technology

Sample ofDEN

Content

CD Track 3CD Track 8

AC_00_Communications-

49

This Slide is Not in Your Book

AC_00_Communications-

50

Content Services Organization

Business Development

Media Services

Financial Services

Sales Engineering

North American Distribution

European Distribution

Media Transport

Media Cast

Video Conferencing

QA & Testing

Marketing Communication

Corporate Communication

Strategic Alliances

Jim Crowder (4)

SalesDavid Cox

(90)

Project DevelopmentJohn Bloomer

(39)

MarketingClaudia

Johnson (6)

AC_00_Communications-

51

Digital Entertainment Network

Content ServicesCustomer Comments

Jim RittsChief Executive Officer

Greg CarpenterChief Technology Officer

CD Track 3CD Track 9

AC_00_Communications-

52

Today’s Discussion

Enron Intelligent Network

Business Centers

Intermediation

Content Services

Financials

BOS

AC_00_Communications-

53

Internet Services2Internet Services2Telecommunications Services1

Telecommunications Services1

U.S. Network Industry Growing Rapidly(Billions)

1Includes Long Distance Voice and Data, Wireless, Local Voice, Access Charges, and Managed Data Services (Source: Dataquest; Enron Analysis)

2Includes Basic Internet Access, Premium Broadband Delivery Services, and Web/Application Hosting (Source: Morgan Stanley Dean Witter; IDC; JP Morgan; Forrester; Enron Analysis)

CAGR = 8% CAGR = 35%

2000 2004

$255

$345

2000 2004

$35

$117

AC_00_Communications-

54

Internet ServicesTelecommunications Services

Long-Haul Bandwidth Transport

Enron Is Targeting Two Segments Of The Network Industry

Content Services - Be the World’s Largest Provider of Premium Broadband Delivery Services

Bandwidth Intermediation - Be the World’s Largest Buyer and Seller of Bandwidth

Premium Broadband

Delivery Services

AC_00_Communications-

55

Bandwidth Capacity in Use (Voice and Data)*Index (2000 = 1.0)

Long-Haul Bandwidth Transport – Rapid Growth Despite Price Declines

PriceIndex (2000 = 1.0)

Long-Haul Bandwidth Transport Market(Billions)CAGR = 57%

CAGR = -15%

*Includes Bandwidth Transport for Internet Infrastructure Services and Traditional Carrier Revenues; Midpoint of Lehman Brothers Bandwidth Capacity Forecast; Excludes Dark Fiber

CAGR = 34%

Source: FCC; Lehman Brothers; Enron Analysis

AC_00_Communications-

56

Growth Of Bandwidth Capacity In UseIndex1

1Indexed Against Year 2000 Total Estimate of 16,347 E15 Bits

2Lehman Brothers October 1998 Forecast; Alternative Estimates: Pioneer Projects Internet Backbone Use to Grow at 76% From 1998-2003; Mutooni Projects Data Traffic to Grow at 130% From 1998-2004

3Data Includes Private Line; Residential and Business Internet; Traditional Data Services Such As Frame Relay, ATM, SMDS, and X.25

4Lehman 2004 Value Estimated by Extrapolating 1998-2002 Expected Growth Rates to 2004

Voice

Data2,3

Total

Service

Lehman

Lehman

Pioneer

Mutooni

Lehman

Source

0.4

2.0

2.2

6.4

2.4

2002

0.54

5.74

6.8

34.1

6.1

2004

10%

70%

76%

130%

57%

CAGR

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.2

0.5

1998

AC_00_Communications-

57

Enron Intermediation Operating Income

(Millions)

Bandwidth Intermediation Opportunity (U.S. Only)

Bandwidth Transport Market(Billions)

Bandwidth Intermediation Market

(Billions)

Share Intermediated(Percent)

Transaction Velocity(Ratio)

Enron Market Share(Percent)

Enron Operating Income Margin(Percent)

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

Source: Dataquest; Lehman Brothers; Enron Analysis

$9 $40$115

$260

$545

AC_00_Communications-

58

International Operating Income

Bandwidth Intermediation Value (Millions)

*Assumes Discount Rate of 11%**Global Telecom Long Distance Market Approximately 3x U.S. Market in 2000; Assumes Worldwide Opportunity Reaches 2x U.S. Opportunity for Bandwidth Intermediation in 2004

2004 Operating Income $1,090 million

2004 Value at 20X Multiple $22 billion

Value as of January 2000*

2004 Operating Income $1,090 million

2004 Value at 20X Multiple $22 billion

Value as of January 2000*

U.S Operating Income

**

Global Operating Income

$9

$2

$11

2000

$40

$15

$55

2001

$115

$70

$185

2002

$260

$210

$470

2003

$545

$ 545

$1,090

2004

Source: Enron Analysis

$14 billion

AC_00_Communications-

59

U.S. Internet Services Market

CAGR 35%

(Billions)

*Defined As Delivery of Primarily High Bandwidth Content and Applications Requiring Guaranteed/Tiered QoS; J. P. Morgan Forecasts U.S. Market Size for “Intelligent Delivery Network Service” of $24.7 Billion in 2004; Morgan Stanley Dean Witter Projects a $44 Billion U.S. Market for “Intelligent Content and Application Distribution” in 2004

**Defined As Colocated and Shared/Dedicated Web Hosting and Application Hosting (Source: IDC; J.P. Morgan; Forrester; Morgan Stanley Dean Witter)

***Defined As Business and Consumer Narrowband (Dial-up) and Broadband (Cable, DSL, T1/OC3/DS3, Internet Access, (Source: Morgan Stanley Dean Witter)

CAGR151%

Hosting**

Basic Access***

CAGR

64%

CAGR18%

EnronFocus

$117

$87

$60

$45

$35 2

Premium Broadband Delivery Services*

1

AC_00_Communications-

60

Enron Content Services Revenues

(Millions)

Content Services Opportunity (U.S. Only)

X

X

X

*Estimated by Morgan Stanley Dean Witter, Broadband Users Defined As Those With Greater Than 100 Kbps Access;Business Users 250 Days/Year, Consumer 365 Days/Year**Enron Analysis

X

U.S. Broadband Internet Users*(Millions)

Premium Delivery (Primarily Streaming)**(Minutes/day)

Average Access Speed*(Kbps)

Premium Delivery Service Charge**(¢/MB)

Premium Broadband Delivery Services Revenues (Billions)

Enron Market Share(Percent)

Source: Enron Estimates; Morgan Stanley Dean Witter; Enron Analysis

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2008$45 $240 $690

$1,280$2,400

$5,870

AC_00_Communications-

61

2008 Revenues $11,740 Million

2008 Operating Income @ 30% Margin $3,520 Million

2008 Value at 20X Multiple $70 Billion

Value As of January 2000*

2008 Revenues $11,740 Million

2008 Operating Income @ 30% Margin $3,520 Million

2008 Value at 20X Multiple $70 Billion

Value As of January 2000*$18 Billion

Content Services Value

*Assumes Discount Rate of 17%**Global Broadband Internet Users 3x U.S. in 2000 and 5x U.S. In 2004; Assumes Worldwide Opportunity for Premium Delivery Services Reaches 2x U.S. Opportunity in 2008

(Millions)

U.S Revenues

International Revenues**

$2,400

$1,200

$3,600

2004

$5,870

$5,870

$11,740

2008

Global Revenues

$45

$9

$54

2000

$240

$70

$310

2001

Source: Enron Analysis

$690

$280

$970

2002

$1,280

$580

$1,860

2003

AC_00_Communications-

62

Bandwidth Intermediatio

n

Content Services

Enron Broadband Services Potential Value

Source: Enron Analysis

(Billions)

TotalG & A*

$14

$18

$3

$29

* Excluding Depreciation; $125 Million in 2000 Escalated at 12% until 2008 and 5% thereafter; Discount Rate @ 11%

AC_00_Communications-

63

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

Enron’s Intermediation MetricVolumes

(DS-3* Months Delivered)

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

1,740,000

640,000

170,00041,0005,000

* DS-3 Equals Approximately 45 Mbps

AC_00_Communications-

64

Terabytes Delivered

Enron’s Content Services MetricTotal Contract Value

(Millions)

$0

$1,000

$2,000

$3,000

$4,000

$5,000

$6,000

$5,390

$3,720

$1,940

$920

$160

2000 2001 2002 2003 2004

Source: Morgan Stanley Dean Witter; Enron Analysis

AC_00_Communications-

65

Financial Targets - 2000

Capital Expenditures $650 Million

IBIT ($60) Million

Financials

Metrics

Bandwidth Intermediation 5,000 DS-3 Months

Content Services $160 Million TCV

AC_00_Communications-

66

Today’s Discussion

Enron Intelligent Network

Business Centers

Intermediation

Content Services

Financials

BOS

AC_00_Communications-

67

Broadband Operating System (BOS)Proposed Standard Protocol for Accessing Real-Time Bandwidth

– Routing - Network Element Control

– Bandwidth Reservation

– Metering

– Verification of User Authorization

– Data Transmission Encryption

– Quality of Service Definition; Confirmation

Single OS Paradigm for All Network Resources: Switches, Routers, Servers and Applications

Direct Software Link Between Applications and the Network Resources

Protocol Consistent With EIN and Enron’s Bandwidth Provisioning Architecture

To Be Made Available to All Software Developers Through Published Application Programming Interface (API)

AC_00_Communications-

68

Central Role of BOS

Dallas

London

Paris

Copenhagen

Munich

Amsterdam

Rome

Omaha

San Francisco

San Jose

Los AngelesSan Diego

TokyoPhoenix

AlbuquerqueLas Vegas

HoustonSan Antonio

Orlando

Miami

New Orleans

Seattle

Portland

Sacramento

Boise

Chicago

Minneapolis

Kansas City Washington D.C.

Charlotte

JacksonAtlanta

Boston

Detroit

Albany

Salt Lake City

Cleveland

St. Louis

Toronto

New York

DenverPhiladelphia

Third Party Software

BOSAPI

AC_00_Communications-

69

This Slide is Not in Your Book

AC_00_Communications-

70

Our Goal: Be the Broadband Platform

Enron Intelligent

Network

Deploy the Most Open, Efficient Network with

Broad Connectivity

Fiber

Servers

Pooling Points

Software

ContentServices

BandwidthIntermediation

Be the World’sLargest Buyer

andSeller of

Bandwidth

Be the World’s Largest Provider

of Premium Broadband

Delivery Services

Bandwidth Management

Trading

Finance

Streaming Broadband Services

Data Asset Management Services

AC_00_Communications-

71

Market Opportunity - U.S.(Revenues in Billions)

2000E 2001E 2002E 2003E 2004E

$30$38

$50

$68

$9534% CAGR

2000E 2001E 2002E 2003E 2004E 2008E

$1 $2

$7

$13

$24

$54

Long Haul Bandwidth Transport

Premium Broadband Delivery Services

Source: Dataquest; J.P. Morgan; Lehman Brothers; Morgan Stanley Dean Witter; Enron Analysis

84% CAGR