Download - Ten reasons 20130621 v3
Ten Reasons Service Science Matters More Than Ever
Jim SpohrerDirector IBM University Programs
June 21, 2013
IBM University Programs
Congratulations KSRI!
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 2
EDUCAUSE Review Article
Spohrer, J., Fodell, D., & Murphy, W. (2012). Ten Reasons Service Science Matters to Universities. EDUCAUSE Review, 47(6), 52-54.
Goods-Dominant Logic (GDL):Sector Growth Argument
Service-Dominant Logic (SDL):Actor Competitiveness Argument
• Vargo, S. L., & Akaka, M. A. (2009). Service-dominant logic as a foundation for service science: clarifications. Service Science, 1(1), 32-41.
A2A Interactions:Competing for Collaborators
• Collaborators: Customers, Suppliers, Employees, Partners, etc.
• FP4 Operant Resources & FP9 Resource Integration – Operant resources are the fundamental source of competitive advantage– All social and economic actors are resource integrators
• From an upcoming Vargo & Lusch Publication: – “Not only do business enterprises and households engage in resource integration,
transformation, and exchange of service, but government agencies, schools, and a host of other nonprofit organizations do so as well.”
– “As a broad, abstract perspective, businesses, households, and other organizations engage in the acquisition, integration, and transformation of resources to create new resources and then use these new resources in exchange with other actors to co-create value. This perspective begins to direct attention to viewing businesses, households, and other organizations, including nonprofits and governments, as essentially and abstractly identical. This insight led us to define exchange and exchange systems in terms of actor-to-actor (A2A) interactions.”
Today’s Talk
• Definitions• Sciences & Applied Arts• Ten Reasons• Progress To Date• What’s Next?• IBM Example• Future Trends
Definitions
• Service– The application of knowledge for mutual benefits– Value co-creation phenomena between entities
• Service Innovations– Scale the benefits of new knowledge globally, rapidly, profitably– Platforms can help, e.g., smart phones, franchises, etc.– Growth businesses seek to scale benefits of knowledge
• Service System Entities– Business and societal systems with capabilities, rights, and
responsibilities– Dynamic configurations of people, technology, organizations, and
information linked by value propositions
Definitions
• Service Science– Study of service and service systems– Measures: Quality, Productivity, Compliance,
Innovativeness, Sustainability, Resilience, Competitive Parity
• SSME– Service Science, Management, and Engineering
• SSME+DAPP– SSME + Design Arts and Public Policy– “Big Tent”
Sciences & Applied Arts
• All sciences study systems– Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Information and
Computer Science, Service Science, etc.– Evolution of entities, interactions, outcomes– Discover abstract universal patterns
• All applied arts change systems– Management, Engineering, Design Arts, Public
Policy seek to apply rigorous scientific knowledge to create better worlds to inhabit
Definitions
• Transdiscipline– Borrows from disciplines without replacing them
• T-Shaped Service Innovation Professionals– Depth and Breadth: Disciplines, Sectors, Cultures– Adaptive Capacity and Boundary Spanners
• ISSIP– International Society for Service Innovation
Professionals– Pronounced I-ZIP– An umbrella professional association
What is a T-shaped Professional?
Many disciplinesMany sectors
Many regions/cultures(understanding & communications)
Deep in one sector
Deep in one region/culture
Deep in one discipline
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 12
www.ISSIP.org
• Pronounced I-ZIP• International Society of
Service Innovation Professionals
• Service is the application of knowledge for mutual benefitis (value co-creation phenomena)
• Service innovations scale the benefits of new knowledge globally and rapidly.
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 13
Ten Competitiveness Reasons: Regional Skills & Infrastructure
Skill Need Service Science Topics
Big Data Instrumenting Service Systems
Cloud Computing Interconnecting Service Systems
Cognitive Computing Intelligent Service Systems
Platforms Scaling Service Systems & Faster Revenue Growth
Social & Mobile Instrumented People as Service Systems (Open Data)
Cybersecurity Security of Private Information in Service System
Business Models Digital Age Business Models for Service Systems
Sustainability Cities as Higher Quality-of-Life Service Systems
Entrepreneurism Universities as More Competitive Service Systems
Regional Flows Circular Economy of Regional Service Systems
Progress Indicators
• Other Sciences– Computer Science (30 years)– Data Science (Hadoop)– Urban Science (Scale Law)– Service Science (S-D Logic)
• Service Science– Courses & Degree Programs (>500)– Conferences (>25)– Journals, Articles, Papers, Books & Citations (>10,000)– Professional Associations (>25)– Government & Business Investment (>$5B)
Information & Computer Science
• “The single strongest impulse for introducing computers on campuses in the mid-1950s did not come from the schools themselves or from any federal agency, but instead from IBM.”
Data Science
• “Data science incorporates varying elements and builds on techniques and theories from many fields… with the goal of extracting meaning from data and creating data products.”
By 2020, 35 Zettabytes per year
• What’s big today will look small in a decadeGoogle processes > 24 Petabytes of data in a single day
Facebook processes 10 Terabytes of data every day
The Hadron Collider at CERN generates 40 Terabytes of data / sec
For every session, NY Stock Exchange captures 1 Terabyte of trade information
Twitter processes 7 Terabytes of data every day250,000,000 tweets
2 Billion Internet users in 2011By 2013, annual internet traffic will reach 667 Exabytes
Urban Science
• Urban science is an interdisciplinary field that studies diverse urban issues and problems
The Well-Read Service Scientist
• http://service-science.info/archives/2708
What’s Next?
• Better Open Data Sets & Simulation Tools• Better Textbooks & Education Materials• Better Frameworks & Entity Architectures• Better Theories & Models• New Discoveries
– Scale Laws & “Periodic Table” of Entities– Comparative Parity & Learning Curves– Innovation Methods & Investment Strategies
Service Science Article
Spohrer, J., Piciocchi, P., & Bassano, C. (2012). Three frameworks for service research: exploring multilevel governance in nested, networked systems. Service Science, 4(2), 147-160.
If some entity architectures (EN and frameworks (FN) are better than others, then professionals working to solve real-world problems (PRW) might benefit, and generate better sets of recommendations (RE).
Service Science
• The transdisciplinary study of service, the application of knowledge for mutual benefits (value co-creation phenomena), in an evolving ecology of interacting many-to-many, nested, networked viable service system entities.
Observations
• Every nation/state/city-university I talk to:– We need help creating high skill, high pay jobs of the future.– We need help keeping our top talent from moving away after
graduation from university• Every business I talk to:
– We need help scaling the benefits of new knowledge and innovation globally, rapidly, profitably
– We need help making our employees and ecosystem more innovative
– We would rather hire people with some entrepreneurial experience (even if failed) than recent graduates, with no entrepreneurial experience.
Holistic Service Systems (HSS)
04/11/2023© IBM 2013 IBM University Programs
worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward)
25
http://www.service-science.info/archives/1056
Nation
State/Province
City/Region
UniversityCollege
K-12
Cultural &ConferenceHotels
HospitalMedical
Research
Worker(professional)
Family(household)
For-profits
Non-profits
U-BEEJob Creator/Sustainer
U-BEEs = University-Based Entrepreneurial Ecosystems
“The future is already here (at universities),it is just not evenlydistributed.”
“The best way topredict the futureis to (inspire the nextgeneration of studentsto) build it better.”
“Multilevel nested, networked holistic service systems (HSS) that provision whole service (WS) tothe people inside them. WS includes flows (transportation, water, food, energy, communications), development (buildings, retail ,finance, health, education), and governance (city, state, nation). ”
“Order of Magnitude Observation”:Unique Time in Human History
Type: Classes
Order Tokens:Instances
Individ-uals
Insti-tutions
Infra-structure
Inform-ation
Planet 10**0 1 10B Forbes 50
Continent 10**1 10 1B F 1000
Nation 10**2 100 100M F 2000 PRISM
State 10**3 1000 10M utilities nuclear
Metro 10**4 10,000 1M uni’s
City 10**5 100,000 100,000 colleges gas
District 10**6 1M 10,000 hospitals
Community 10**7 10M 1000 schools
Street 10**8 100M 100 parks
Family 10**9 1B 10 solar HAT
Person 10**10 10B 1 Soc. Med.
GDL & SDLGDL Reasons: Sector Growth Argument SDL Reasons: Actor Competitiveness
ArgumentService Economy Planet-wide Actors
Servitization/XaaS (Everything asa Service)
Continental Unions as Actors (HSS)
Globalization Nations as Actors (HSS)
Demographics States as Actors (HSS)
Urbanization Metros/Counties as Actors (HSS)
Social Services Cities as Actors (HSS)
Financial Services Districts as Actors (HSS)
IT Platforms & Services Communities as Actors (HSS)
B2B Services Streets/Apart. Buildings as Actors (HSS)
Service Innovation Needs Families as Actors (HSS)
Individuals as Actors
IBM University Programs
28
What’s UP at IBM?
IBM University Programs
29
Those in-the-know say, “IBM is helping to build a Smarter Planet…”
IBM University Programs
30
Smarter Planet = Smarter Systems
INSTRUMENTED We now have the ability to
measure, sense and see the exact condition of practically everything.
INTERCONNECTED People, systems and objects
can communicate and interact with each other in
entirely new ways.
INTELLIGENT We can respond to changes
quickly and accurately, and get better results
by predicting and optimizing for future events.
WORKFORCE
PRODUCTS
SUPPLY CHAIN
COMMUNICATIONS
TRANSPORTATION BUILDINGS
IT NETWORKS
IBM University Programs
31
City challenges
Ryan Chin:Smart Cities
IBM University Programs
32
Smart Startup: Streetline
IBM University Programs
33
Smart Neonatal ICU
IBM University Programs
34
Land-population-energy-carbon
Carlo Ratti:Senseable Cities
IBM University Programs
35
IBM University Programs
36
IBM University Programs
37
Four commandments for cities of the future: Eduardo Paes at TED2012
IBM University Programs
38
SC IOC as a Platform for Innovation
IBM University Programs
39
39
Identifies entrepreneurs developing businesses aligning with our Smarter Planet vision.
SmartCamp finalists raised more than $50m and received significant press in Wall Street Journal, Forbes and Bloomberg
in
Healthcare SmartCamp kickstart - Miami - May 15, 2012 Apply by April 27th
SmarterCities SmartCamp kickstart - New York - May 24, 2012 Apply by May 3rd
North America Regional SmartCamp - Boston - June 20 & 21, 2012 Apply by May 25th
apply now at www.ibm.com/isv/startup/smartcamp
Exclusive Networking andMentoring event
North America SmartCamp lead: Eric Apse, [email protected] Programs lead: Dawn Tew, [email protected]
IBM University Programs
40
What are the trends?
Digital ImmigrantBorn: 1988
Graduated College: 2012
Digital NativeBorn: 2012
Enters College: 2030
IBM University Programs
41
Transportation: Self-driving cars
Steve Mahan:Test “Driver”
IBM University Programs
42
Water: Circular Economy
IBM University Programs
43
Manufacturing: Circular Economy
Ryan Chin:Urban Mobility
Baxter: Building the Future
Maker-Bot: Replicator 2
IBM University Programs
44
Energy: Artificial Leaf
IBM University Programs
45
Technology: Cognitive Computing
IBM University Programs
4646
Example: Leading Through Connections with…Universities Collaborate with IBM Research to Design Watson for the Grand Challenge of Jeopardy !
Assisted in the development of the Open Advancement of Question-Answering Initiative (OAQA) architecture and methodology
Pioneered an online natural language question answering system called START, which provided the ability to answer questions with high precision using information from semi-structured and structured information repositories
Worked to extend the capabilities of Watson, with a focus on extensive common sense knowledge
Focused on large-scale information extraction, parsing, and knowledge inference technologies
Worked on a visualization component to visually explain to external audiences the massively parallel analytics skills it takes for the Watson computing system to break down a question and formulate a rapid and accurate response to rival a human brain
Provided technological advancement enabling a computing system to remember the full interaction, rather than treating every question like the first one - simulating a real dialogue
Explored advanced machine learning techniques along with rich text representations based on syntactic and semantic structures for the Watson’s optimization
Worked on information retrieval and text search technologies
http://w3.ibm.com/news/w3news/top_stories/2011/02/chq_watson_wrapup.html
IBM University Programs
47
Buildings: Circular EconomyChina Broad Group:30 Stories in 15 Days
IBM University Programs
48
Retail & Hospitality: Social Media
IBM University Programs
49
Finance: Crowd Funding
IBM University Programs
50
Health: Robotics & 3D Printing
IBM University Programs
51
Education: Challenge-Based Sport
IBM University Programs
52
Government: Parameterized Meta-Rules
• Innovativeness
• Equity
– Improveweakestlink
• Sustainability
• Resiliency
IBM University Programs
53
Competitive Parity – Achieved.• The NFL touts parity—the idea
that any team can win on any given Sunday. But this year, parity has truly run wild.
• Through six weeks, 11 of the NFL's 32 teams are 3-3.
• The Journal asked the statistical gurus of Massey-Peabody Analytics to run a coin-flip simulation…
IBM University Programs
54
2030 and Beyond…. Government, Health, Education, Finance, etc.
IBM University Programs
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 55
Questions
• What is ISSIP?
• What is a service platform?
• What is service science?
• What is a T-shaped professional?
• How is this related to your work at IBM with universities?
• What are the important future trends you see?
IBM University Programs
What is ISSIP?
• Pronounced I-ZIP• International Society
of Service Innovation Professionals
• SIG Education & Research– T-shapes– Service Science
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 57
IBM University Programs
What is a service platform?
• Access Places & Entities– Scale benefits– Of new knowledge– Globally & rapidly
• Smart Phones & Watson• Smarter City IOC• Franchises
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 58
IBM University Programs
Service Science
• Emerging Discipline– Service Science,
Management, and Engineering (SSME)
• Service– Not sector (ECON)– Not capability (CS)
• Value Co-Creation• Service System Entities04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide
accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 59
IBM SSME Centennial Icon of Progress
IBM University Programs
What is a T-shaped Professional?
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 60
Many disciplinesMany sectors
Many regions/cultures(understanding & communications)
Deep in one sector
Deep in one region/culture
Deep in one discipline
IBM University Programs
How do universities fit in?
• Best way to predict the future is to inspire the next generation to build it better
• The future is already here at universities it is just not well distributed
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 61
IBM University Programs
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 62
IBM operates in 170 countries around the globe
Acquisitions contribute significantly to IBM’s growth ; ~120 acquisitions in last decade
2012 FinancialsRevenue - $ 104.5BNet Income - $ 17.6BEPS - $ 15.25 (10 yrs of
EPS d/digit growth)Net Cash - $18.2B
24% of IBMs revenue in Growth Market countries; growing at 7% ( @cc) in 2012
Number 1 in patent generation for 20 consecutive years ; 6,478 US patents awarded in 2012
More than 40% of IBMs workforce does business away from an office
5 Nobel Laureates10 time winner of the President’s National Medal of Technology & Innovation – latest for LASIK laser refractive surgical techniques
The Smartest Machine On Earth
100 Years of Business & Innovation in 2011
New Era in IBM’s Leadership
IBM Growth Initiatives
IBM has ~425,000 employees worldwide
Context: IBM 101
IBM University Programs
IBM Platforms for Entrepreneurs
• Smarter Cities Intelligent Operations Center Platform• IBM helping university startups to scale up (growth)04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide
accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 63
IBM University Programs
64
University: Four Missions• Knowledge
– 1. Transfer (Teaching) – 2. Creation (Research)– 3. Application (Benefits)
• Commerce/Entrepreneurship• Governance/Policymaking
– 4. Re-Integration (Challenge)• Innovativeness, Equity• Sustainability, Resilience
• Nested, Networked Holistic Service Systems– Flows– Development– Governance
Nation
State/Province
City/Metro
UniversityCollege
K-12
Cultural &ConferenceHotels
HospitalMedical
Research
Worker(professional)
Family(household)
For-profits
Non-profits
U-BEEJob Creator/Sustainer
Third Mission (Apply to Create Value) is about U-BEEs = University-Based
Entrepreneurial Ecosystems
IBM University Programs Universities Matter #1
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 65
Japan
ChinaGermany
France
United KingdomItaly
Russia SpainBrazilCanada
IndiaMexico AustraliaSouth Korea
NetherlandsTurkey
Sweden
y = 0,7489x + 0,3534R² = 0,719
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
% g
loba
l G
DP
% top 500 universities
Nation’s % WW GDP and % Top 500 Universities (2009 Data)
IBM University Programs Universities Matter #2
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 66
…But it can be costly, American student loan debt is over $900M
IBM University Programs Universities Matter #3
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 67
“When we combined the impact of Harvard’s direct spending on payroll, purchasing and construction – the indirect impact of University spending – and the direct and indirect impact of off-campus spending by Harvard students – we can estimate that Harvard directly and indirectly accounted for nearly $4.8 billion in economic activity in the Boston area in fiscal year 2008, and more than 44,000 jobs.”
IBM University Programs Universities Matter #4
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 68
What is a U-BEE? A local job creator/sustainerInnovating “whole service” in all regions worldwide
http://www.service-science.info/archives/1056
Nation
State/Province
City/Region
UniversityCollege
K-12
Cultural &ConferenceHotels
HospitalMedical
Research
Worker(professional)
Family(household)
For-profits
Non-profits
U-BEEJob Creator/Sustainer
U-BEEs = University-Based Entrepreneurial Ecosystems
“The future is already here (at universities),it is just not evenlydistributed.”
“The best way topredict the futureis to (inspire the nextgeneration of studentsto) build it better.”
IBM University Programs On Campus IBMers
04/11/2023 © IBM 2013 IBM University Programs worldwide accelerating regional development (IBM UPward) 6969
Up-SkillCycle
University-Region1
University-Region2
= New Venture
= Acquisition
= High-Growth Acquisition/ New IBM BU (Growing)
= High-Productivity/ Mature IBM BU (Shrinking)
= IBMer moving from mature BU to acquisition
= IBMer moving intoOn Campus IBMer role(help create graduateswith Smarter-Planet skills,help create Smarter Planetoriented new ventures;Refresh skills
= Graduates withSmarter Planet skills
IBM
IBM University Programs
70
Measuring Quality-of-Life?A. Systems that focus on flow of things that humans need (~15%*)
1. Transportation & supply chain2. Water & waste recycling/Climate & Environment3. Food & products manufacturing4. Energy & electricity grid/Clean Tech5. Information and Communication Technologies (ICT access)
B. Systems that focus on human activity and development (~70%*)6. Buildings & construction (smart spaces) (5%*)7. Retail & hospitality/Media & entertainment/Tourism & sports (23%*)8. Banking & finance/Business & consulting (wealthy) (21%*)9. Healthcare & family life (healthy) (10%*)10. Education & work life/Professions & entrepreneurship (wise) (9%*)
C. Systems that focus on human governance - security and opportunity (~15%*)11. Cities & security for families and professionals (property tax)12. States/regions & commercial development opportunities/investments (sales tax)13. Nations/NGOs & citizens rights/rules/incentives/policies/laws (income tax)
0/19/02/7/42/1/1
7/6/1
1/1/0
5/17/27
1/0/2
24/24/1
2/20/24
7/10/3
5/2/2
3/3/10/0/0
1/2/2
Quality of Life = Quality of Service + Quality of Jobs + Quality of Investment-Opportunities
* = US Labor % in 2009.
“61 Service Design 2010 (Japan) / 75 Service Marketing 2010 (Portugal)/78 Service-Oriented Computing 2010 (US)”
IBM University Programs
Growth
71
IBM University Programs
72
Nesting
Matryoska dolls:Origin Japanese
IBM University Programs
73
I am nested in at least 10 systemsLevel AKA ~No. People ~No. Entities Example
0. Individual Person 1 10,000,000,000 Jim
1. Family Household 10 1,000,000,000 Spohrer’s
2.Neighborhood Street 100 100,000,000 Kensington
3. Community Block 1000 10,000,000 Bird Land
4. Urban-Zone District 10,000 1,000,000 SC Unified
5. Urban-Center City 100,0000 100,000 Santa Clara
6.Metro-Region County 1,000,000 10,000 SC County
7. State Province 10,000,000 1,000 CA
8. Nation Country 100,000,000 100 USA
9. Continent Union 1,000,000,000 10 NAFTA
10. Planet World 10,000,000,000 1 UN
IBM University Programs
74
Time
ECOLOGY
~14BBig Bang
(NaturalWorld)
~10KCities
(Human-MadeWorld)
sun (energy)
writing(symbols and scribes,
stored memoryand knowledge)
earth(molecules &
stored energy)
written laws(governance andstored control)
bacteria(single-cell life)
sponges(multi-cell life)
money(governed
transportable valuestored value,
“economic energy”)
universities(knowledge workers)
clams (neurons)trilobites (brains)
printing press (books)steam engine (work)200M
bees (socialdivision-of-labor)
60
transistor(routine
cognitive work)
Evolution of Natural Systems & Service Systems
Unraveling the mystery of evolving hierarchical-complexity in new populations…To discover the world’s architectures and mechanisms for computing non-zero-sum
IBM University Programs
75
Automobile
Inte
rnet
Technological Acceleration
0 25 50 100 125 15075Years
25
50
100TelephoneElectricity
Radio
Television
VCR
PC
Cellular
% P
enet
ratio
n
YEARS
IBM University Programs
76
•iPhone/iPad app developer•wireless marketing director•microfinance infrastructure designer•3D content developer for movies, TV•social network manager•deploying technology into the cloud •organic solar cell development•digital image management
Many top in-demand jobs in 2011 did not exist in 2005!
76
IBM University Programs
77 77
U.S Department of Labor estimates that today’s learner will have 10-14 jobs…
by the age of 38!
IBM University Programs
78
Estimates are 85% of the jobs today’s learners will be doing haven’t been invented yet
they'll be using technologies that don't exist to solve problems we don't yet know are problems78
IBM University Programs
79
Five historical cycles …
IBM University Programs
80
~100 years of US job transformations
Source: US Bureau of Economic Analysis; McKinsey Global Institute Analysis
CACM Article
• Maglio, P. P., Srinivasan, S., Kreulen, J. T., & Spohrer, J. (2006). Service systems, service scientists, SSME, and innovation. Communications of the ACM, 49(7), 81-85.
IMM Article
• Vargo, S. L., & Lusch, R. F. (2011). It's all B2B… and beyond: Toward a systems perspective of the market. Industrial Marketing Management, 40(2), 181-187.
10 GDL Reasons• 1. Service Economy
– Growth of service sector in GDP and Labor of nations• 2. Servitization
– Growth of revenue from service offerings of businesses• 3. Globalization
– Franchises and outsourcing, taxation, immigration, exports, • 4. Demographics
– Aging population, young populations, etc.• 5. Urbanization
– Growth of urban population, specialization, higher education, etc.• 6. Social Services
– Urban populations need more social services, crime, poverty, mental illness, etc.• 7. Financial Services
– Wealth effect, families outsource mode, business outsource more• 8. IT Platforms and Services
– From on-line retail to social media, gamification, big data, platforms,, to outsourcing and hyperspecializaion, self-service, digital business models, open data
• 9. B2B Services– Growth in number of businesses business, entrrepreneurship, open innovation
• 10. Service innovation needs– Overcome Baumol’s disease of low productivity in government, health, education, etc.
Service Science
• The transdisciplinary study of service, the application of knowledge for mutual benefits (value co-creation phenomena), in an ecology of interacting many-to-many, nested, networked viable service system entities.
Future Directions:Big Data & Cognitive Computing Age
• What new capabilities will service system entities (species?) have in the future?– Natural Language Interactions– Recommendations Rank Ordered– Historical Awareness
• Were recommendations followed?• What outcomes resulted?• Who has responsibility for negative outcomes?• What responsibility for privacy of data?