Transcript
Page 1: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Edward A. Thomas Esq. PresidentNatural Hazard Mitigation Association (NHMA)

July 23, 2015

Natural Hazard Mitigation Association

International Hazard Mitigation Practitioners Symposium

Crafting and Designing Programs By Practitioners for a Safer Future

Page 2: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

On behalf of:

Ed Thomas, PresidentNatural Hazard Mitigation Association

This presentation is not and cannot be technical engineering or legal advice, nor does this portion necessarily represent the views of anyone other the presenter.

Howdy!

Page 3: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Approaching Our Problems TogetherAs we think in a systems analysis manner to solve our serious problems

we must including sea level rise and climate variability, uncertainty and climate change.

We must stop making things worse!We need to work with many persons and groups to solve our serious

disaster, water resources, and other related issues.Right now we have a system which rewards dangerous behavior.Yet, some places—like Tulsa, Oklahoma; Metropolitan Denver, through

the work of the UDFCD; Charlotte- Mecklenburg County, North Carolina and others—are heroically overcoming obstacles and reducing losses.

First some thoughts on disasters, Flood Insurance, and opportunities for change

Page 4: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Report on the 2013 Colorado Floods

Really excellent analysis which clearly shows the advantages of the thoughtful, collaborative, systematic approach and of the UDFCD over the past 40+ years

Page 5: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Three Major Situations We See When Dealing With Development Issues in Hazardous Locations

a) undeveloped property, which gives us the best chance to get things right;

b) existing development which gives us challenging, but possible opportunities for preparedness, retrofitting, etc. to reduce the risks and consequences of natural events;

c) redevelopment of property following a disaster using the “Living Mosaic" of available processes and programs.

Page 6: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

• Dramatic Increases in Flood and Wind DisastersTrends in Damages Following Natural Events

Page 7: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

7

1980 1982 1984 1986 1988 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012

Overall losses(in 2013 values)*

Insured losses(in 2013 values)*

Source: Munich Re. Losses adjusted to inflation based oncountry CPI.

Overall and Insurance Losses in the US 1980 – 2013, US $ billions

US$ bn200

150

100

50

Page 8: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Flood losses increasing?

This was not supposed to happen!The Flood Insurance Program was designed to reduce such losses.In 1976 a HUD sponsored economic analysis predicted that by the

year 2000 or 2025 flood losses would begin to decline.I believe that the NFIP is the most cost effective program of Hazard

Mitigation in the history of the Nation.Colorado has been a National Leader in reducing flood losses.Can the NFIP be improved?Is it now being improved?What happened?What can we do?

Page 9: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Disaster Risk Reduction and Flood Insurance

FEMA has programs to help owners reduce their risk and save money on flood insurance Community-wide discounts through the Community Rating

System (CRS)

FEMA grant programs support rebuilding and relocating

Use of higher deductibles to lower premium costsThe smartest way to save is to build higher!

Well, unless you have steep slopes as described in Brian Varella’s brilliant webinar for the Natural Floodplain Functions Alliance (NFFA):http://www.aswm.org/-nffa/1790-webinars

Page 10: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Excellent Webinar on Floodplain Management, Wildfires & Development in Mountain AreasPreventing Flood

Disasters from Becoming Disastrous – Brian Varrella, Chair, Colorado Association of Stormwater and Floodplain Managers

Located at:http://www.aswm.org/-

nffa/1790-webinars

Page 11: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

USACE SlideCourtesy of Pete Rabbon

Page 12: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Initial Risk

No or Inadequate Warning/Evacuation Plan

Sea Level Rise and Upstream Development Increases Flood Heights

Lack of Awareness of Flood Hazard, Absence of Flood, Business Interruption, and DIC Insurance

Critical Facilities Not Properly Protected From Flooding

Increased Development: more people and more costly development

Buildings & Infrastructure Not Properly Designed or Maintained

Vastly Increased Residual Risk

RISK

Risk Increase Factors

Page 13: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Residential/ commercial

1 Improved building codes

Oil and gas

6 Floating production systems

7 Replacing semi-subs with drill ships

8 Levees for refineries and petrochemical plants

Infrastructure/ Environmental 3 Wetlands restoration3

2 Beach nourishment

4 Levee systems3

Electric utility 9 Improving resilience of electric utility systems

68

15

14

4

9

10

4

2

2

9

Benefit (loss averted)2

$ Billions

Let’s Take a Few Minutes to Discuss Efficient Resilience Options

5 Improved standards for offshore platforms

Total

Average C/B ratio

x

0.7

1.3

1.6

0.7

0.5

3.3

0.7

3.8

1.0

Cost1

$ Billions

64

17

6

1

6

15

5

6

11

10

1 Total capital and operational costs, discounted, across 20 years2 Total loss averted, discounted, across 20 years 3 Included despite high C/B ratios due to strong co-benefits, risk

aversion 13Many thanks to Cynthia McHale of CERES for this information

But, what form of mitigation/adaptation is missing from list?

Page 14: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

How Can We Accomplish Disaster Risk Reduction

Many folks tell me that there are insufficient funds for Hazard Mitigation/Climate Adaptation/Disaster Risk Reduction

Do you at least sort of agree with the old saying that “Well Begun is Half Done?”

If so, is “Half-Done” very, very “Well Begun”?

Page 15: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

1515

Demographic Trends: The Future

Dr. Arthur “Chris” Nelson, FAICP at the Rocky Mountain Land Use Institute March 13, 2015“More than half of the built environment of the United

States we will see in 2050 does not exist in today.” Update on information contained in: Journal of the American Planning Association, Vol. 72, No. 4, Autumn 2006.

Page 16: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

16

16

Page 17: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

We Will Have Development

Demographic Pressures Will Drive DevelopmentOften in Areas Where there Are Considerable

Natural Hazards:TornadoesFloodsTsunamis Earthquakes

We Need To Develop Safely and AffordablyWe Can Do It!

Page 18: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

For Years You folks in Colorado Had A Great Record of Avoiding Disaster Losses

Page 19: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Let’s Look At Our System Of Disaster Relief

From a Study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Flood insurance Payments Not Included

Page 20: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Assistance Not Including Flood Insurance Payments

From a Study by the Federal Reserve Bank of New York

Page 21: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

NY Federal Reserve Study:How Will We Pay For Superstorm Sandy?

“With this expansion of federal disaster assistance, payments from private insurance companies and the federal government exceeded the total economic cost of events since Katrina by about 25 percent. This pattern suggests that an excess amount was distributed to state and local governments and affected individuals and businesses… Clearly, though, some businesses or individuals may not have been fully reimbursed for their out-of-pocket expenses, despite the excess payments in aggregate."

http://libertystreeteconomics.newyorkfed.org/2012/12/how-will-we-pay-for-superstorm-sandy.html#.U5sjaEDyTgA

Page 22: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

A Quick Note On:Koontz v. St. Johns River Water Management District, No. 11-1447, (U.S. June 25, 2013)

22

This Supreme Court decision produces all sorts of fairly wild and alarmist articles quoting Attorneys who basically are predicting that the sky is falling the monetary requirement is "devastating“ to land use planning

Other Attorneys view this case a major victory for property owners; and a defeat for government regulation

Case is really an enormous opportunity to promote Resilience

Page 23: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Can Koontz be an Opportunity to Promote More Resilient Communities?

The Supreme Court clearly agrees with the idea of safe development based planning. Justice Alito wrote in the majority opinion:

"Insisting that landowners internalize the negative externalities of their conduct is a hallmark of responsible land-use policy, and we have long sustained such regulations against constitutional attack. See, Village of Euclid v. Ambler Realty Co., 272 U. S. 365 (1926). [emphasis added]

See, e.g., Turning Koontz into an Opportunity for More Resilient Communities located on the ABA website at: http://www.americanbar.org/content/dam/aba/administrative/state_local_government/land_use.authcheckdam.pdf 23

Page 24: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Some win; some loose “In this day in age, with population densities rising,

behaviors with harmful side effects have been growing more important. To foster continued prosperity, and even more drastically--the planet’s survival, requires clear thinking about how to mitigate the resulting damage” Robert H. Frank, Ronald Coase, a Pragmatic Voice for Government’s Role, http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/15/business/ronald-coase-a-pragmatic-voice-for-governments-role.html

24

Negative Externality is a Cost of a Transaction Not Paid By the Party Which Benefited

Page 25: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

25

When one group pays maintenance or replacement of something yet different person or group uses that same something, we often have problems

Poorly designed/constructed development followed by disaster assistance is a classic example of externality Who Pays For Disaster Assistance? Who Benefits?

Economics and Externality

Page 26: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

26

Who Pays For Disaster Assistance? Costs of flooding are usually largely borne by:

a) The federal and sometimes the State taxpayer through IRS Casualty Losses, SBA loans, Disaster CDBG funds, and the whole panoply of Federal and private disaster relief described in the publication:Planning and Building Livable, Safe & Sustainable Communities: The Patchwork Quilt Approach

b) By disaster victims themselves

Page 27: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

2727

Cui Bono? (Who Benefits?)………. From Unwise or Improper Development In Areas

Subject to Foreseeable Natural Hazardsa) Developers? b) Communities?c) State Government? d) Mortgage companies?e) The occupants of floodplains? Possibly in the

short-term, but usually NOT in the long-term

Page 28: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Our Challenge

Disasters are bad, getting worse; will continue to get worse unless we change our development and redevelopment practices quite dramatically;

There are multiple paths to reduce misery and suffering include:

Architect and Engineer “Standard of Care” Insurance Industry efforts Government efforts California earthquake building codes,

mitigation grants 28

Page 29: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

29

A Standard of Care Thought from the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE)

The first Fundamental Canon of the American Society of Civil Engineer's (ASCE) Code of Ethics states that:

“Engineers shall hold paramount the safety, health, and welfare of the public….”

“This canon must be the guiding principle for rebuilding the hurricane protection system in New Orleans.

And it must be applied with equal rigor to every aspect of an engineer’s work – in New Orleans, in America, and throughout the world.”

Page 30: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Standard of Care for Planners

“Planners are required to address social equity in their work as part of APA’s AICP Code of Ethics and Professional Conduct. As Hurricane Katrina and heat wave mortality figures teach us, lower-income and elderly populations are more at risk and will bear the brunt of many climate change impacts. As a consequence, planners need to ensure that the responses they develop to address the impacts of climate change take into account the varied needs of all sectors of the community, in order to equitably meet the significant challenges facing us.”

(From “Policy Guide on Planning and Climate Change,” American Planning Association, April 11, 2011 emphasis added)

Page 31: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Suggested Changes to Federal PoliciesReforming Federal Support for Risky Development, by David Conrad and

Ed ThomasThis paper suggests ways to reduce federal expenditures by approximately

$40 billion over a 10 year period.

Published by the Hamilton Project of the Brookings Institute in 2013 in 15 Ways to Rethink the Federal BudgetAvailable online for your reading pleasure:

http://www.brookings.edu/research/papers/2013/02/reform-federal- support-risky-development

31

Page 32: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Key Issues

We are losing the battle for a safe and sustainable society in the United States and throughout the world

Looking to the past for a vision of future risks, in an era of climate variability and change is even less likely to work than ever before

32

Page 33: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Looking Only at Past Events For Future Guidance Is Like:Driving Down the Highway at 80 Miles an Hour Steering By Looking in the Rear View Mirrors Only

33

Climate Adaptation permits,even requires us to look forward too!

Unlikely to produce safe results!

Page 34: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Could Climate Change be to Blame for Recent Extreme Colorado Weather Events?Climate change can make heat waves more likely and more

severe, according to a study in the Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society that found fewer clear links to extreme weather such as drought and storms.

With Respect to Colorado Flooding:

“(T)he chances of heavy rainfall like the deluge that caused flooding in Boulder, Colorado, last year, are probably lower because of human-caused weather changes.

Link at: http://www.propertycasualty360.com/2014/09/30/could-climate-change-be-to-blame-for-extreme-weath?eNL=542b08b0140ba017428b4567&utm_source=PC360DailyeNews&utm_medium=eNL&utm_campaign=PC360_eNLs&_LID=118409543

34

Page 35: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

How To Use Basic Principles To Address The Growing Toll Of Disasters?

Business as usual is not working well enoughBuild bridges-linksMake more friends and allies - many have very little

knowledge or strong positive feelings about hazardsWe need to reach those we may not like:

government, civil servants, bureaucrats, and a whole lot more

Those who believe things we don’t believe!ENGAGE POTENTIAL ROADBLOCKS!

35

Page 36: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

We Need to Reach Folks Who Normally Do Not Like Or Agree With Us

Our message of better, safer design must be prepared for delivery to many audiences

We need to know and understand what they care about, so we can develop a message rooted in economics & safety they will care about

36

Page 37: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

So, How Do You Know An Audience?

Listen

Discussion

Talk

Learn

Show you care about what concerns them, so they care about you and your message

37

Page 38: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

For Years NHMA Has Been Saying We Need To Reach Others With Well Considered and Crafted MessagesNow others are saying much the same thing!The World Bank:Stéphane Hallegate from the World Bank located

in Washington, DC observed at a Conference I just attended that in order to make adaptation work in practice, we need an entirely new narrative - a new way of conceiving of adaptation: “Policymakers need another story than ‘We need to prevent a disaster!’ The real story of adaptation is that it leads to improving things. We have to help people recognize the benefits.”

38

Page 39: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Messaging Many folks who fervently believe Climate

Change is hooey or a plot have other beliefs… E.g. belief in God, the United States, helping

one’s neighbor, and the need to love and protect land & quality of life for future generations

Belief in reducing the role of government in our lives

So… How do we get a harm prevention message across to them?

39

Page 40: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Today We Will Also DiscussImplications of An Ongoing Success:

Hide from the Wind Tornado Safe Rooms in

Central Oklahoma

Prepared by

The Natural Hazard Mitigation Association for the Federal Emergency Management Agency

This Report Funded in Part by the Federal Emergency Management Agency

Page 41: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Background: Mileti Research

Dr. Dennis Mileti, Former Director of the Natural Hazards Center and Professor Emeritus at the University of Colorado at Boulder, has conducted detailed research:

How to communicate the risks and consequences

from disasters

Change public perception and behavior so that the potential devastation caused by disasters can be mitigated

Page 42: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Are There Implications for the Safe Room Successes We Are Seeing on Risk Perception and Behavior for Other Hazards?

In short: YES!

NHMA believes that Dr. Mileti’s research findings are enormously supported by the analysis found in the NHMA report, Hide from the Wind: Tornado Safe Rooms in Central Oklahoma

These methods can and should be applied widely to efforts promoting Disaster Risk Reduction from all natural hazards.

Page 43: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Summary of Mileti ResearchA. Be ClearB. Use Varied SourcesC. Render Information Consistently,

Through Multiple Outlets and Repeat It D. Tell People What to DoE. Support People in Their Search for More

Information F. Use Words and Great Graphics G. Position Additional Information in the

Community

Page 44: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Needed: A Common Message of Disaster Risk Reduction-Delivered By Multiple Folks

We need to deliver knowledgeable messages of disaster vulnerability reduction, safety, and security, with regional and locally based mitigation suggestions, such as:

build a safe rooms, and have higher wind load building standards in areas subject to high probability of high winds/tornadoes;

carry out community and individual wildfire protection in areas subject to such risks;

design and retrofit to reduce earthquake damage;build with higher freeboard (generally 4 feet or more) in areas subject

to floods, understand the limitations of flood frequency projections based on the past, which include many unrealistic assumptions;

recognize the need to protect water quality, and threatened and endangered species

Page 45: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Disaster Risk Reduction Ambassador Curriculum

Emphasis is placed on the concept of disaster resilience, or “the ability to prepare and plan for, absorb, recover from, and more successfully adapt to adverse events” (National Research Council 2012).

The curriculum provides citizen leaders with best practices, the science underlying our understanding of natural hazards phenomena and a critical analysis of the policies, programs, and plans in place that are intended to help societies manage the effects of natural hazards and disasters, to include actions that increase disaster resilience. 

45

Page 46: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Multihazards are addressed. The curriculum addresses the broad set of DRR natural hazards and risks, and best mitigation practices to

improve economic, social, and environmental quality of life, and to

protect public health and safety.

Multidisciplinary. The curriculum provides an overview of many

expert disciplines, to show connections gained through collaborative

teamwork.

Part of the larger national and international efforts to support

Community Resilience. The curriculum recognizes the need to connect across the separate sectors of those engaged in the larger scope of climate science, emergency management, and comprehensive planning, to coordinate with others committed to build a more resilient future.

4-46

The DRR Ambassador Curriculum will be CROSS-CUTTING

Page 47: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Key Themes We need to think in a systems analysis manner to solve the serious problems

we faceWe need collaboration among diverse groups to solve serious issues

surrounding the mounting toll of losses following foreseeable natural eventsWe must develop a system that rewards resilient and safe behavior; and

discourages unsafe development

Page 48: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Resilience and Disaster Risk Reduction

Think of the arrows being shot at the target as development resources

Resilience & Climate Adaptation are a huge conceptsThey are also moving targets as the climate varies

We at NHMA focus in on the Disaster Risk ReductionPortion of Climate Adaptation and Resilience

Page 49: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Brilliant Publications Designed to Promote True Resilience Including Disaster Risk Reduction

NAACP Publication:Equity in Building Resilience in Adaptation Planning

Page 50: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

SummaryFundamentally our society must choose either:

Better standards to protect resources and people or

Standards which inevitably will result in destruction and litigation

We Need To Make Allies and Friends To Get Our Message Across

FIND THE COMMON VALUES AND START THERE

All of us can and should play a key role in planning a safe and sustainable future 50

Page 51: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Final Thought Courtesy of Ben Franklin: All of US Who Care About a Safer, Better Future Need To Work Together

Library of Congress

Page 52: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Who Has to Unite?

What do you folks think?

Page 53: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

53

Questions and AnswersAt the Conclusion of the Panel, Please

Thank You

Page 54: Crafting & Designing Programs by Practitioner's for a Safer Future

Edward A. Thomas Esq. PresidentNatural Hazard Mitigation Association (NHMA)

July 23, 2015

Natural Hazard Mitigation Association

International Hazard Mitigation Practitioners Symposium

Crafting and Designing Programs By Practitioners for a Safer Future


Top Related