devolved centerlines

25
DEVOLVED CENTERLINES WEST BOTTOMS PHOTO ESSAY SARAH MURPHY FA2010 - KCDC

Upload: kansas-city-design-center

Post on 30-Mar-2016

240 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

West Bottoms Photography by Sarah Murphy

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Devolved Centerlines

DEVOLVED CENTERLINESWEST BOTTOMS PHOTO ESSAY

SARAH MURPHYFA2010 - KCDC

Page 2: Devolved Centerlines
Page 3: Devolved Centerlines

INTRODUCTION:Photography has the ability to capture what we see, crop it (by removing both periphery and sequence), order it (through the creation of tight, meaningful instances) and present itself (allowing us the attention span to interpolate the surrounding moments or scenes). The moments here are stills isolated from the experience of walking and biking through a city that is, in character, devolved or degenerative. The city itself seems to exist sans-inhabitants; it is a place where people are seen in the context of large forms (drivers in or among their big rigs, people opening doors obviously not intended for human use) and therefore writes its own story, its own drama, independent of the humans who created it or dwell within it.

At this massive scale--the scales of industrialism and urban design--how can we take the features which fit within the viewfinder and re-create a city from them? How can we use these features to understand in what context open space lies? Partially informed by Kyle Rogler and Jared Nook’s academic parsing of void space in the West Bottoms, partially by Treib’s The Presence of Absence, this collection explores the balance between built and unbuilt.

Page 4: Devolved Centerlines

01. DEVOLVED CENTERLINESThe character of the West Bottoms is that of a reversal of figure and ground. According to Trieb, “while we read certain urban open spaces as positives, we read others as voids.” (1) The weight of the photos, like the weight of this city is not on the centroid of the mass, but rather on the center line of the void. The sky is the quintessential flat background with an infinite focal range, given depth only by clouds and gradient. The gaps in the urban grid are marked with this neutrality.

If it is the space that is the figure and the forms that are the ground, it becomes unclear whether the autonomous forms of the stand-alone buildings are for containing the program within or serve only our public urbanism, filling the role of bounding facades.

1. Treib, Marc. “The Presence of Absence: Places by Extraction” in Places vol. 4, no. 3 (1987): 15.

Page 5: Devolved Centerlines

two facades - james streetf/4; 1/60s; ISO 400focal length: 50mm camera: Nikon D50

Page 6: Devolved Centerlines

f/18; 1/60s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@24mmcamera: Olympus E-410

f/22; 1/200s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42mmcamera: Olympus E-410

Page 7: Devolved Centerlines

st. louis avef/18; 1/250; ISO400focal length 14-42@35mmcamera: Olympus E-410

alley to centralf/8; 1/250s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42mmcamera: olympus E-410

Page 8: Devolved Centerlines

1100 block of hickoryf/18; 1/40s; ISO 400focal length: w14-42@42camera: olympus E-410

f/13; 1/125s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42mmcamera: Olympus E-410

Page 9: Devolved Centerlines

faultless tankf/8; 1/250; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@31mmcamera: olympus E-410

two semis, st. louis ave.f/13; 1/125; ISO 400focal length 14-42@42mmcamera: Olympus E-410

Page 10: Devolved Centerlines

02. INFRASTRUCTUREInfrastructure commands the deleted space. In plan, bridges and viaducts are figures with right-of-way ground to either side. Spatially, they serve as frames and permeable boundaries. “Geometry is not taken as a pure abstraction but becomes instead an abstract ordering tempered by the particularities of the site’s topography” (2). Here the geometries themselves are the peculiarities of the site, bending around built context and forcing all new spaces to bend along with the most dynamic element.

2. Treib, Marc. “Presence of Absence,” 10.

NEXT PAGE: 12th st viaductf/18; 1/125s; ISO 400

focal length: 14-42@42 camera: Olympus E-410

Page 11: Devolved Centerlines
Page 12: Devolved Centerlines
Page 13: Devolved Centerlines
Page 14: Devolved Centerlines
Page 15: Devolved Centerlines

LEFT:Standard Seed f/8; 1/250s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@31mmcamera: Olympus E-410

RIGHT:670f/10; 1/125s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42camera: Olympus E-410

PREVIOUS SPREAD, left:12th st viaductf/18; 1/125s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42camera: Olympus E-410

I-70 at Santa Fef/8.0; 1/250s; ISO 800focal length: 14-42@14camera: Olympus E-410

PREVIOUS SPREAD, right:james viaductf/4.0; 1/60s; ISO 400focal length: 50camera: Nikon D50

Page 16: Devolved Centerlines

03. SPLIT FRAMEThe deletions and appendices serve as both frames and portals, allowing the viewer to choose from and experience multiple spatial situations simultaneously. This emphasizes the quality of sub-city and feeling of discovery (already present for so many spending time in the West Bottoms), creating a cinematic experience that changes with each new step, direction, and decision.

Here, the combination of loading dock porches and grids askew creates diagonal connections across the site--a matter of a few steps reveals a hidden scene. While this is true in all photography (the still is a nonrepresentative image of a larger situation), the Bottoms seems unaware of its capacity to confound. Here, these architectural tricks and spatial play are givens, not contrived constructions.

RIGHT:under 670 at liberty

f/9.4; 1/1000s; ISO 800focal length: 50mm camera: Nikon D50

FOLLORWING SPREAD, left:porch-through

f/22; 1/200s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42mm

CAMERA: olympus E-410

Page 17: Devolved Centerlines
Page 18: Devolved Centerlines
Page 19: Devolved Centerlines
Page 20: Devolved Centerlines

union and hickoryf/4.8; 1/90s; ISO 400focal length: 50mm camera: Nikon D50

Page 21: Devolved Centerlines

8th and mulberryf/3.5; 1/3200s; ISO 800focal length: 14-42@14mm camera: Olympus E-410

liberty and 13thf/22; 1/125s; ISO 400focal length: 14-42@42mm camera: Olympus E-410

Page 22: Devolved Centerlines

The space between 8 storey solid forms invites us to use void, not buildings as the reference point we rotate ourselves around. “The void induces us to participate in ways that the solid cannot.” (3). The void changes itself as we move in ways that something we understand as prismatic and static cannot. It is the quality of openness that we have defined as particular to the West Bottoms, and one of the greatest sources of potential: how to program and define space without losing its ever-changing dynamism.

3. Treib, Marc. “Presence of Absence,” 18.

04. VANTAGE POINT

Page 23: Devolved Centerlines
Page 24: Devolved Centerlines
Page 25: Devolved Centerlines