depth perception: surgical film and the problem of anatomical legibility

55

Upload: miriam-posner

Post on 29-Jan-2018

2.837 views

Category:

Education


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 2: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 3: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 4: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 5: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 6: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

MY FATHER, RABBI ISRAEL SARNOFF

Page 7: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

,

THE CINIiJfA IN SURGERY

Recording in JIOtion picturea the operation tor the removal. ot a twiated ovarian qat

Page 8: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

NES INFLATED BY TH E MO-V! MEiHOD

Page 9: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 10: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 11: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 12: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 13: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1896First commercial film exhibition

Page 14: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1896First commercial film exhibition

Page 15: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 16: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 17: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1921

AMA bans surgical films

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 18: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1921

AMA bans surgical films

1924Sarnoff makes “Circulatory System”

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 19: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1928

AMA closes motion-picture theaters altogether

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1921

AMA bans surgical films

1924Sarnoff makes “Circulatory System”

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 20: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1928

AMA closes motion-picture theaters altogether

1935American College of Surgeons begins endorsing films

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1921

AMA bans surgical films

1924Sarnoff makes “Circulatory System”

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 21: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

1928

AMA closes motion-picture theaters altogether

1935American College of Surgeons begins endorsing films

1941

AMA reintroduces motion-picture theaters

1898

Eugène-Louis Doyen begins making surgical films

1921

AMA bans surgical films

1924Sarnoff makes “Circulatory System”

1917Sarnoff begins making films

1896First commercial film exhibition

1915

AMA introduces motion picture theaters

Page 22: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

Eugène-Louis Doyen separating “Siamese twins” Radica and Doodica in 1902

Page 23: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 24: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 25: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 26: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 27: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 28: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 29: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“There is a personal flavor about the photograph which is absent in the drawing or the outline.”

Page 30: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 31: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“spoiled by beautiful photoengravings”

Page 32: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“spoiled by beautiful photoengravings”

“simple diagrams would have been most instructive”

Page 33: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 34: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“depriving us of diagrams”

Page 35: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“depriving us of diagrams”

“due place”

Page 36: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 37: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 38: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“connected sequence”

Page 39: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 40: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 41: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

Animation frames, 1951

Page 42: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 43: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“We need diagrams ...

Page 44: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“We need diagrams ...

...that will show the actual technic”

Page 45: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 46: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“interpolate animation where [photography] fails”

Page 47: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility
Page 48: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“your own ability to think in diagram”

Page 49: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 50: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 51: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

American College of Surgeons Multimedia Atlas of Surgery (2006)

Page 52: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

American College of Surgeons Multimedia Atlas of Surgery (2006)

Page 53: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)

Page 54: Depth Perception: Surgical Film and the Problem of Anatomical Legibility

“Circulatory System” (Jacob Sarnoff, 1924)