chp. 13- the early renaissance - lacour-paper...

[CHP. 13- The Early Renaissance] P A G E | 1

Learning Goals (AAT4)After reading Chapter 13, you should be able to do the following:

Identify the works and define the terms featured in the chapterCompare Italian fifteenth-century painting with that of the NetherlandsDescribe humanism, using literary and artistic examplesLocate the leading art centers on a map of Italy and the NorthDiscuss the importance of the competition for the Florence Baptistery doorsDraw and label the plans of Florence Cathedral, Santo Spirito in Florence, and Sant' Andrea in MantuaDescribe the structure of Brunelleschi's domeDescribe the use of mathematical linear perspective as it is used in fifteenth-century paintingDiscuss the new emphasis on biography and autobiography in the RenaissanceDescribe the emergence of mythological subject matter and PlatonismCompare perspective in Chinese painting and Persian miniatures with linear perspectiveDescribe the development of sculpture in Florence in the fifteenth centuryDiscuss the writings and architecture of AlbertiDiscuss the role of patronage in the arts during the RenaissanceDiscuss interpretations of the Arnolfini Portrait using different methodologies

The Early Renaissance, 15th centuryFlorence in the age of HumanismCompetition for the Baptistery doors (1401)Italian artists: Brunelleschi; Ghiberti; Pisanello; Masaccio; Donatello;

Rossellino; Gentile da Fabriano; Alberti; Uccello; Castagno;Verrocchio; Fra Angelico; Piero della Francesca; Mantegna; FraFilippo Lippi; Botticelli; GhirlandaioLeonardo Bruni's humanist tomb

Art theory: Alberti, On Painting (c. 1435)History: Bruni, Praise of the City of Florence and History of the Florentine PeopleThe condottiere and fame; the Platonic AcademyNorthern painters: Campin; van Eyck; van der Weyden; Memling; van der Goes

Summary of the Renaissance The word "Renaissance" comes from the French and means rebirth, the rebirth of ancient learning. In Italian, the word is Rinascenza. The Italian Renaissance period is usually divided into Early Renaissance (1420-1500) and High Renaissance (1500-20).

Key Terms“triangle composition”

aerial (or atmospheric) perspective

a technique for creating the illusion of distance by the use of less distinct contours and a reduction in color intensity.

aisle a passageway flanking a central area (e.g., the corridors flanking the nave of a basilica or cathedral).

ambulatory a vaulted passageway, usually surrounding the apse or choir of a church.

arcade a gallery formed by a series of arches with supporting columns or piers, either freestanding or blind (i.e., attached to a wall).

architrave the lowest unit of an entablature, resting directly on the capital of a column.

atmospheric perspective

basilica (a) in Roman architecture, an oblong building used for tribunals and other public functions; (b) in Christian architecture, an early church with similar features to the Roman prototype.

bay a unit of space in a building, usually defined by piers, vaults, or other elements in a structural system.

bistre/bister a brown medium made from the soot of burnt wood.

bust a sculptural or pictorial representation of the upper part of the human figure, including the head and neck (and sometimes part of the shoulders and chest).

caryatid a supporting column in post-and-lintel construction carved to represent a human or animal figure.

centering the temporary wooden framework used in the construction of arches, vaults, and domes.


central plan

chiaroscuro the subtle gradation of light and shadow used to create the effect of three-dimensionality.

chiaroscuro

choir part of a Christian church, near the altar, set aside for those chanting the services; usually part of the chancel.

coffer, coffering a recessed geometrical panel in a ceiling.

colonnade a series of columns set at regular intervals, usually supporting arches or an entablature.

column a cylindrical support, usually with three parts—base, shaft, and capital.

contrapposto a stance of the human body in which one leg bears the weight, while the other is relaxed, creating an asymmetry in the hip-shoulder axis.

convention a custom, practice, or principle that is generally recognized and accepted.

corbelling brick or masonry courses, each projecting beyond, and supported by, the one below it; the meeting of two corbels would create an arch or vault.

Corinthian see Order.

cornice the projecting horizontal unit, usually molded, that surmounts an arch or wall; the topmost member of a Classical entablature.

Deësis a tripartite icon in the Byzantine tradition, usually showing Christ enthroned between the Virgin Mary and Saint John the Baptist.

disegno (“drawing with line”)

dome a vaulted (frequently hemispherical) roof or ceiling, erected on a circular base, which may be envisaged as the result of rotating an arch through 180 degrees about a central axis.

double shell dome

drum (a) one of the cylindrical blocks of stone from which the shaft of a column is made; (b) the circular or polygonal wall of a building surmounted by a dome or cupola.

engaged (half-) column

a column, decorative in purpose, that is attached to a supporting wall.

engraving sacra conversazione (sacred conversation)

entasis the slight bulging of a Doric column, which is at its greatest about one third of the distance from the base.

equestrian monument

Eucharist (a) the Christian sacrament of Holy Communion, commemorating the Last Supper; (b) the consecrated bread and wine used at the sacrament.

façade the front or "face" of a building.

Flemish painting

flutes, fluting a series of vertical grooves used to decorate the shafts of columns in Classical architecture.

foreground the area of a picture, usually at the bottom of the picture plane, that appears nearest to the viewer.

foreshortening

frieze (a) the central section of the entablature in the Classical Orders; (b) any horizontal decorative band.

gilding a decorative coating made of gold leaf or simulated gold; objects to which gilding has been applied are gilded or gilt.

Gospel one of the first four books of the New Testament, which recounts the life of Christ.

grisaille a monochromatic painting (usually in shades of black and gray, to simulate stone sculpture).

guild organizations of craftsmen, such as those that flourished in the Middle Ages and Renaissance.

humanism

International Style

isocephaly, isocephalic

the horizontal alignment of the heads of all the figures in a composition.

lantern the structure crowning a dome or tower, often used to admit light to the interior.


Latin cross a cross in which the vertical arm is longer than the horizontal arm, through the midpoint of which it passes.

Leonardo’s inventions

Lorenzo the Magnificent (1449-1492)

Medici

Neoplatonism

oil paint

patron the person or group that commissions a work of art from an artist.

pedestal the base of a column, statue, vase, or other upright work of art.

pediment (a) in Classical architecture, the triangular section at the end of a gable roof, often decorated with sculpture; (b) a triangular feature placed as a decoration over doors and windows.

pilaster a flattened, rectangular version of a column, sometimes load-bearing, but often purely decorative.

polyptych a painting or relief, usually an altarpiece, composed of more than three sections.

printmaking

proportion the relation of one part to another, and of parts to the whole, with respect to size, height, and width.

putto, putti a chubby male infant, often naked and sometimes depicted as a Cupid, popular in Renaissance art.

quatrefoil an ornamental "four-leaf clover" shape —i.e., with four lobes radiating from a common center.

Republic of Florence

reverse the side of a coin or medal considered to be the back; opposite of obverse.

rib an arched diagonal element in a vault system that defines and supports a ribbed vault.

sarcophagus a stone coffin, sometimes decorated with a relief sculpture.

schiacciato

sfumato (“smokiness”)

sibyl a prophetess of the ancient, pre-Christian world.

single or one-point perspective (linear perspective)

Sistine Chapel

stained glass windows composed of pieces of colored glass held in place by strips of lead.

symmetry the aesthetic balance that is achieved when parts of an object are arranged about a real or imaginary central line, or axis, so that the parts on one side correspond in some respect (shape, size, color) with those on the other.

tempera a fast-drying, water-based painting medium made with egg yolk, often used in fresco and panel painting.

thrust the lateral force exerted by an arch, dome, or vault, which must be counteracted by some form of buttressing.

tondo (a) a circular painting; (b) a medallion with relief sculpture.

transept a cross arm in a Christian church, placed at right angles to the nave.

Treatise on Architecture by Alberti (completed in 1452, first published in 1485)

triptych an altarpiece or painting consisting of one central panel and two wings.

type a person or object serving as a prefiguration or symbolic representation, usually of something in the future.

vanishing point in the linear perspective system, the point at which the orthogonals, if extended, would intersect.

Vitruvius (late 1st century B.C. Roman architect)


Chronology1468 Rossellino: Matteo Palmieri1470 Alberti: Church of San Andrea, Mantuac. 1475 Pollaiuolo: Herakles and Antaios1478 Botticelli: Primaverac. 1480 Botticelli: The Birth of Venusc.1483-1488 Verrocchio: Equestrian Monument of Colleoni, Venice

The Early Renaissance was a time of experimentation; it was during this time that artists discovered the mathematical formulas necessary for representing perspective and space accurately on a two-dimensional surface. There was innovation not only in architecture and painting, but also in sculpture, where the movement toward an art of realism based upon observation was at the same time interpreted in a Classical mode.

The Artist's Knowledge of the Visual WorldWhereas artists during the Middle Ages had relied upon established archetypal images as sources for their depiction of the human figure, the Renaissance artist, living in an era that allowed for humankind to examine itself and its surroundings, slowly began to shift this visual attention to the natural world. By the fifteenth century, it was an accepted practice to utilize nature as a source for one's artistic production; by the sixteenth century, concise theories encompassing the naturalistic representation of the human figure and the visual world were established.These changes in the core values concerning the manner in which art was produced paralleled changes in thought concerning how humankind was to know its world. Instead of the traditional modes of thought typical of the Middle Ages, in which people were to come to know God and the world through philosophy and reason, the people of the Renaissance came to rely on direct human experience for their knowledge. This approach supported the notion of experimentation that emerged with the scientific method of investigating natural phenomena.

The Fifteenth Century in FlorenceMany historians consider Florence to have been the source of the Renaissance, which commenced at the beginning of the fifteenth century. Florence was then governed by wealthy families from the merchant class, including the Albizzi, Capponi, Medici, Pazzi, and Strozzi. By the 1430s, however, it was the Medici family that ruled the city, though not by title. The Medici were also great patrons of the arts and literature.

Relief Sculpture: The Baptistery Doors CompetitionRepresentative of the new artistic era of Florence was a competition held in 1401 for the design of the north doors of the Baptistery of Florence, which was built in the eleventh century. The south doors of the Baptistery, cast in bronze, had been designed by Andrea Pisano and were Gothic in style. Six artists were selected from those who entered the competition, and they were given one year to design and produce a panel cast in bronze depicting the Old Testament story of the sacrifice of Isaac. At the end of the year, the works of the artists were judged, and the field was narrowed down to the work of two young artists: Filippo Brunelleschi (1377-1446) and Lorenzo Ghiberti (c. 1381-1455). As it happened, their entries to the competition also were the least conservative and traditional of the works submitted.

Brunelleschi's EntryBrunelleschi's entry depicted the exact instant Abraham's thrust of the knife toward his son Isaac's throat was stopped by an angel of the Lord. Brunelleschi's placement of the figures within the panel seemed to be in response to the four-lobed (quatrefoil) form of the panel itself, with the angel on the left, Abraham on the right, and Isaac in the middle-a fairly symmetrical composition. The stances of the figures as well as the sweeping drapery that enveloped them appeared to reflect the shape of the panel.

13.2 Filippo Brunelleschi- Sacrifice of Issac, competition panel for the east

doors of the FLorence Bapistery Florence (1401-1402) Gilded bronze

relief; 21 x 17 inches. Museo Nazionale del Bargello, Florence.

Photo: LaCour Slide Library.


Ghiberti's EntryThe panel that Ghiberti submitted-and for which he won the prize-portrayed Abraham and Isaac at a moment in time when Abraham was about to thrust the knife into his son's throat. His placement of the figures within the panel was asymmetrical, with the focus of attention upon Abraham in the middle and Isaac on the right. Ghiberti's treatment of the figure of Isaac reveals, in part, the direction the Renaissance was to flow. His Isaac was obviously based upon earlier Classical works, as reflected in the figure's musculature and wellproportioned form; the panel reflects both a sense of realism and the quality of idealized beauty. Ghiberti's design for the doors followed the format established by Pisano on the south doors, with the space divided up into twenty-eight quatrefoils, each representing a figure or a biblical scene. As in his prize-winning panel, Ghiberti's style as seen in his treatment of the figures and his use of space represented a shift from Gothic idealism to naturalism.

13.3 Lorenzo Ghiberti- Sacrifice of Issac, competition panel for the east

doors of the FLorence Bapistery Florence (1401-1402) Gilded bronze

relief; 21 x 17 inches. Museo Nazionale del Bargello, Florence.

Photo: LaCour Slide Library.Ghiberti's Gates of ParadiseSoon after Ghiberti's doors were completed and installed, he was offered the opportunity to create yet another set of doors, this time for the eastern side of the baptistery facing the cathedral. These doors took twenty-five years to complete and were finally set in place in 1452. His design for these doors changed somewhat from the earlier ones, as seen, for example, in the manner in which he reduced the number of panels from twenty-eight to ten and used the same figural proportion throughout, so that the foreground figures were all the same size. His treatment of space, perspective, and the figure suggests his continued study of nature. These doors so impressed the artist Michelangelo that he referred to them as the Gates of Paradise, a title still in use today.

13.17 Lorenzo Ghiberti- Self-Portrait, from the east door of the Florence

Baptistery (single panel of. fig 13.18) (1424-1452)

Florence Baptistery, Florence, Italy Gilded bronze relief;

36 inches high. Photo: LaCour Slide Library

Art Across Time Slide Set (wncc)

13.18 Lorenzo Ghiberti- Gates of Paradise,

east door of the Florence Baptistery Approx. 17 feet high. (1424-1452) Florence Baptistery, Florence, Italy

Gilded bronze relief; 36 inches high.

Photo: LaCour Slide Library Art Across Time Slide Set (wncc)

Jacopo della QuerciaAnother artist who submitted a panel for consideration in the baptistery competition of 1401 was Jacopo della Quercia (c. 13741438). His relief panel, The Expulsion from the Garden of Eden (1430), part of a series he created for the Church of San Petronio in Bologna, consisted of well-muscled figures that reflected the Classical period. Though sculpted in relief, the forms seem nearly powerful enough to stand on their own.

Nanni di Banco


The Quattro Santi Coronati (1410-1414), found in an outside niche of the Church of Or San Michele in Florence, do stand on their own. The life-size figures commemorate the martyrdom of four Christian sculptors who refused the Roman emperor Diocletian his request for pagan images. Sculpted by Nanni di Banco (c. 1384-1421), they reflect a partial resolution to the problem of integrating sculpture and architecture. Though the niche is part of the architecture, the treatment of its space conveys a sense of separation. The figures relate to one another, not only because they are installed in a semicircular pattern, but also because they are gesturing toward and looking at each other; while one "speaks," the others "listen."

Sculpture DonatelloThe movement toward an art of realism based upon observation of the world, yet at the same time interpreted in a Classical mode, comes together with the work of the sculptor Donato di Niccolo di Betto Bardi (1386-1466). Better known as Donatello, he is considered to be the progenitor of modern sculpture. As a youth, Donatello was one of a number of assistants who worked with Ghiberti on the first set of the bronze doors for the Baptistery of Florence.

An early work, St. Mark (1411-1413), commissioned for the Or San Michele in Florence, reflects Donatello's awareness of Classical Greek and Roman sculpture, his familiarity with the Bible, and his desire to imbue his works with a sense of animation. The pose of St. Mark and the manner in which the figure's weight is distributed are distinctly Greek, and it is here that we first see the use of contrapposto since the Classical period. At the same time, Donatello has imbued the figure with a personality, perhaps the result of his readings of the Gospel. Though the figure was placed within a niche, in a sense removing it from the immediate environment of the viewer, it is freestanding and self-sustaining, and its impact upon the viewer owes little to the environment within which it exists. The figure of St. Mark is very lifelike, and the enveloping drapery is not independent of the body beneath, but seems to move with it.

13.29 Donatello- St. Mark, shown in its original Gothic nice on the outside

wall of Or San Michele, Florence (1411-1415) Marble.

Florence, ItalyPhoto: LaCour Slide Library.

In 1415, Donatello was commissioned by the armorers' guild to do a sculpture of St. George (1415-1417) for the Or San Michele in Florence. This work is considered by many to be of special significance because, they feel, more than appealing to the viewer schematically on a purely symbolic level, it also reaches out psychologically. Donatello achieved this psychological effect by imbuing the figure with personality. The character and inner strength of St. George are apparent; the niche within which he stands is shallow, and he appears to share the space of the viewer more than that of the architecture. Here we see another change occurring in the Renaissance, the shift from saint as symbol to man as hero.

During the next twenty years, among other works, Donatello sculpted five statues for the campanile of the Cathedral of Florence. One of the most interesting, reflecting Donatello's attention to personality and the inner psyche, is the figure of a prophet (1423-1425) that has come to be known as Zuccone, or "pumpkin head." Zuccone is bald, and his features, figure, and costume are realistically sculpted in the manner of portrait sculpture from Roman times. The somewhat disheveled appearance of the drapery that envelops Zuccone belies the power and intensity of his stare. Close scrutiny is required to grasp the subtlety of the craftsmanship.


Donatello's David (c. 1425-1430) is honored as being the first free-standing nude statue to be presented in the round since antiquity. Classical in nature, the nude David is portrayed as neither an athlete nor a god but as a self-conscious, introspective figure, albeit a sensuous one, reflecting Donatello's ability to combine naturalism and idealization and to infuse a figure with a sense of both action and inaction. As a milestone in Renaissance art, David represents the achievement of high-quality bronze casting, the acceptance of free-standing sculpture, and the use of the nude as a subject, which had been considered generally inappropriate during the Middle Ages.

From between 1445 to 1450, Donatello worked on a commission in Padua. The work was an equestrian statue of Erasmo da Narni, also known as Gattamelata, who was a captain-general of the Venetian army. Like the equestrian statues of Rome, Donatello's equestrian statue of Erasmo da Narni conveyed a sense of restrained power of both beast and man. Though dressed in Roman armor, da Narni's costume reflects the style of the period. Also interesting to note is the manner in which Donatello modeled the features of the figure's face so that it would most effectively be perceived from ground level rather than at eye level.

The Portrait Bust

Throughout the latter half of the fifteenth century, Donatello's successors continued to develop his innovations in sculpture. During this age of humanism, the portrait bust again became popular. Antonio Rossellino's portrait bust of Matteo Palmieri (1468) is realistic and lifelike in its sense of individuality but does not possess the death mask quality that is typical of many of the earlier Roman portrait busts.

Andrea del Verrocchio

Probably the most significant sculptor of the latter half of the fifteenth century was Andrea del Verrocchio (1435-1488), whose students included, among others, Leonardo da Vinci. Like Donatello, Verrocchio also made a bronze David (1465). Verrocchio's David possesses the physicality, stance, and attitude of a young man who has just achieved a great victory. Whereas Donatello's David was relaxed, Verrocchio's possesses the tension of the fight.

Another comparison may be made between the work of the two master sculptors by way of Donatello's equestrian statue of Erasmo da Narni (1445-1450) and Verrocchio's equestrian statue of Bartolommeo Colleoni (c. 1483-1488). Given the challenge of representing the condottiere, Verrocchio created a work of great power and energy. Bartolommeo Colleoni's horse does not walk, it prances; its powerful neck twists to one side, muscles rippling with excitement as it is reined in by its rider. The condottiere himself is portrayed as a powerful figure, with the stirrups bearing his weight as he seems to lift himself from the saddle while turning to address his troops.

Antonio del Pollaiuolo

Though much of the figure sculpture made during this time portrayed individuals at rest or at intervals of motion, the bronze sculpture Herakles and Antaios (c. 1475) by Antonio del Pollaiuolo (1431-1498) is worthy of notice because it depicts two individuals in motion as combatants and because it represents a return to Classicism for subject matter as well as style.

Painting

At the same time that Donatello was struggling with naturalism and animation in his sculpture, the early


Renaissance painters were grappling with these same concepts as they applied to the flat, two-dimensional surfaces upon which they worked.

Tommaso Guidi Masaccio

One painter whose work was highly influential was Tommaso Guidi Masaccio (1401-1428). Masaccio combined contemporary advances in perspective and the naturalistic style with the style of Giotto to arrive at a new way of representing space on a flat surface. His best-known work, The Tribute Money (c. 1427), reflects his mastery of composition in the manner in which he depicts three episodes of the story in the same painting. The focal point of the painting is the group of Apostles with Christ in the middle, placed just off-center in the composition. Here, Christ is telling Peter to pay the tax collector with a coin he will find in a fish's mouth. To the left Peter is depicted at the water's edge removing the coin from the fish's mouth. This episode is not apparently that significant to Masaccio, for it is placed at the very edge of the composition. Attention is then called to the conclusion of the story, where, on the right, Peter pays the tax collector. Masaccio's use of architecture as background effectively separates the two figures from the rest of the composition.

Like Donatello, Masaccio's use of contrapposto imbues his figures with substance and weight. The drapery that envelops them reflects the structure of the forms and the flesh underneath and allows the viewer to believe that the figures are capable of movement. Masaccio's use of light and shadow imparts a dramatic sense of modeling to the figures and the illusion of depth within the picture plane. A sense of real space is created by arranging the group of Apostles in a circle around Jesus; as the space within the painting recedes, forms and colors become less distinct as they do in the visual world we live in.

Perspective and Representation of the Human Figure

Other Renaissance painters would continue to focus their efforts toward perfecting the application of perspective and the representation of the human form structurally. The painting Battle of San Romano (c. 1455), by Paolo Uccello (1397-1475), reflects the artist's passion for depicting perspective and his lesser interest in convincingly representing the human form.

Andrea del Castagno (1423-1457), in his Last Supper (c. 1445-1450), employs perspective in so rigid a manner that it limits the perceived potential for movement on the part of the characters he portrays.

A contemporary of Castagno, Domenico Veneziano (1410-1461) also strove to master the phenomena of perspective and naturalistic figure depiction. His St. Lucy Altarpiece (1445), an early genre example of the sacra conversazione, in which figures appear to be in conversation with the viewer or one another, reflects his level of craftsmanship.

The work of Piero della Francesca (c. 1420-1492), a student of Domenico and a great admirer of Masaccio, incorporated the rules of geometry and mathematics as a basis for pictorial composition. In his fresco painting The Resurrection (c. 1460), Piero has arranged his figures in such a way as to form a triangle, with the sleeping soldiers at the base and Christ's head at the apex, his body forming the vertical axis of the painting. By arranging Christ in a pose that has his left leg raised and bent and his right arm lifted while holding a staff and banner, Piero has softened the symmetrical arrangement of the composition. Though there is a definite structure that contributes to the strength of the composition, the figures themselves are fluid and natural in their poses.

The Depiction of Realism in the Human Figure

Antonio del Pollaiuolo, mentioned earlier as a sculptor, was also an engraver and a painter. His engraving Battle of Ten Naked Men (c. 1465-1470) reflects his interest in pursuing the depiction of realism in the human figure [see illustration 5]. By creating a scene of battle, he has provided himself with the opportunity to portray the human figure in action in a variety of poses and from many different angles. Though Pollaiuolo was familiar with human anatomy, his figures appear to be somewhat stiff due to the fact that he has depicted his combatants with all their muscles contracted, not realizing that in reality, while some muscles are contracting others are relaxed. The power of this image reflects Pollaiuolo's use of outline rather than modeling to indicate action. His treatment of the figures' faces reflects the strain portrayed in their poses, linking physical action and emotional level.

Sandro Botticelli


A major painter of this era was Sandro Botticelli (c. 1444-1510) who, like Raphael and Michelangelo, had the good fortune to receive the patronage of the Medici family. Botticelli's paintings Primavera (1478) and The Birth of Venus (c. 1480) are two large works that the Medici family commissioned for their villa. Both works reflect the artist's interest in Greek and Roman myths as sources for his paintings, as well as his interest in the portrayal of the feminine form. His women are sensuously modeled and seem nearly weightless; it is obvious that his attention is focused upon them rather than upon the space of the composition, which is rather flat and shallow. In both paintings, Venus is the main subject, reflecting a shift away from the traditional female subjects of Eve and Mary. Botticelli's Birth of Venus is especially significant because his nude Venus is the first portrayal of a large female nude since the Classical period.

Architecture

Filippo Brunelleschi as Architect

Though Filippo Brunelleschi's entry to the competition for the bronze doors of the Baptistery of Florence was not selected for the commission in 1401, he continued to work as a sculptor and goldsmith for several years before turning toward architecture as an avocation. In his travels to Rome, he became familiar with Roman architecture and building techniques and, through his drawings of various buildings and monuments, contributed much to the growing body of knowledge having to do with linear perspective.

In 1420 an architectural competition was held, the prize being the honor of designing the dome (1420-1436) of the Cathedral of Florence. Again, as in the competition of 1401, both Brunelleschi and Ghiberti entered. This time, Brunelleschi received the commission. Though construction of the cathedral had begun in 1297, the dome was never finished because the technology had not then existed to cover a space that was 140 feet in width. The traditional system of buttressing would not work in this case, given the octagonal drum already in place. Brunelleschi's solution was to construct the dome out of three shells around a framework of ribs, with the two innermost shells connected by ribs and bearing most of the weight. Brunelleschi was responsible for the design of many buildings in Florence, including the Ospedale degli Innocenti, the Church of San Lorenzo, the Church of Santo Spirito, and the Pazzi Chapel.

Leone Battista Alberti

Like Brunelleschi, the architect Leone Battista Alberti (14041472) began his career as an artist. His Palazzo Rucellai (1446-145 1) in Florence consists of three stories with a somewhat classical facade. The design of the facade was likely based upon that of the Roman Colosseum, but the columns are nearly flush with the exterior wall, reflecting Alberti's desire to integrate Classical motif with non-Classical architecture.

In 1450, Alberti received a commission to renovate the exterior of the Gothic Church of San Francesco in Rimini. His solution was to literally build an outer structure around the older building. The facade of the building consists of three large arched niches, the middle one encasing the entrance being the largest. On either side of the niches are columns sitting on blocks, similar to those found on the Arch of Constantine in Rome. Whereas the columns of the Palazzo Rucellai are nearly flush with the exterior wall, allowing for a horizontal orientation to the structure, the columns of the Church of San Francesco contribute to the facade's strong vertical orientation, as they do in earlier basilica.

Alberti resolved the problem of integrating the Classical motif with non-Classical architecture in his design for the Church of San Andrea in Mantua in 1470. His solution can be seen in its facade. Here, in the center, Alberti placed a deep, arched niche. He again used flat columns, so as to not draw attention away from the surface of the facade, but these columns are not as flush as those of the Palazzo Rucellai and thus serve as an accent. The two outer pairs of columns stand the full three stories of the structure, while the columns that support the arch are only two stories tall and are etched with vertical lines.


Art Works know these works by sight, title, date, medium, scale, and location (original location also if moved) and be able to explain and analyze these in relation to any concept, term, element, or principle

Art of the Florentine Republic at the beginning of the 15th century FILIPPO BRUNELLESCHI, Sacrifice of Isaac, competition panel for east doors, baptistery, Florence, Italy, 1401–1402. Gilded bronze, 1’ 9” x 1’ 5”. LORENZO GHIBERTI, Sacrifice of Isaac, competition panel for east doors, baptistery, Florence, Italy, 1401–1402. Gilded bronze relief, 1’ 9” x 1’ 5”. LORENZO GHIBERTI, east doors (Gates of Paradise), baptistery, Florence, Italy, 1425–1452. Gilded bronze, 17’ high. Modern copy, ca. 1980. LORENZO GHIBERTI, Isaac and His Sons (detail of FIG. 21-10), (Gates of Paradise), baptistery, Florence, Italy, 1425–1452. Gilded bronze, 2’ 7 1/2” x 2’ 7 1/2”. Lorenzo Ghiberti, North Doors (set #2), Baptistry of San Giovanni, Florence, 1403-1424, bronze NANNI DI BANCO, Four Crowned Saints, Or San Michele, Florence, Italy, ca. 1410–1416Marble, figures 6’high. DONATELLO, Saint Mark, Or San Michele, Florence, Italy, 1411–1413. Marble, 7’ 9” high. DONATELLO, Feast of Herod, panel on the baptismal font of Siena Cathedral, Siena, Italy, 1423–1427. Gilded bronze , 1’ 11 1/2 ” x 1’ 11 1/2”.DONATELLO, Prophet (Zuccone), from the Florence Campanile, 1423-1425, marble

Later works in Donatello’s career DONATELLO, Gattamelata (equestrian statue of Erasmo da Narni), Piazza del Santo, Padua, Italy, ca. 1445–1450. Bronze, 12’ 2” high. DONATELLO, Equestrian Monument to Gattamelata, Padua, Italy, 1447-1453, bronze

Painting in Florence at the beginning of the 15th century SLIDE: ***GENTILE DA FABRIANO, Adoration of the Magi, altarpiece from Strozzi Chapel, Santa Trinità, Florence, Italy, 1423. Tempera on wood, approx. 9’ 11” x 9’ 3”. SLIDE: ***MASACCIO, Tribute Money, Brancacci Chapel, Santa Maria del Carmine, Florence, Italy, ca. 1427. Fresco, 8’ 4 1/8” x 19’ 7 1/8”. SLIDE: ***MASACCIO, Expulsion of Adam and Eve from Eden, Brancacci Chapel, Santa Maria del Carmine, Florence, Italy, ca. 1424–1427. Fresco, 7’ x 2’ 11”. SLIDE: ***MASACCIO, Holy Trinity, Santa Maria Novella, Florence, Italy, ca. 1424–1427. Fresco, 21’ 10’ 5/8” x 10’ 4 3/4”.

Architecture in the first half of the 15th century FILIPPO BRUNELLLESCHI, cutaway view of the dome of Florence Cathedral, Florence, Italy, 1420-1436 ( after Piero Sanpaolesi). FILIPPO BRUNELLESCHI, facade of the Pazzi Chapel, Santa Croce, Florence, Italy, begun ca. 1440. FILIPPO BRUNELLESCHI, plan of the Pazzi Chapel, Santa Croce, Florence, Italy designed ca. 1423, begun 1442. FILIPPO BRUNELLESCHI, interior of the Pazzi Chapel (looking northeast), Santa Croce, Florence, Italy, designed ca.1423, begun 1442, with glazed terracotta roundels by Luca della Robbia.

The Medici as patrons around the middle of the 15th century PAOLO UCCELLO, Battle of San Romano, ca. 1455 (?). Tempera on wood, approx. 6’ x 10’ 5”. DONATELLO, David, late 1440–1460. Bronze, 5’ 2 1/4” high. ANTONIO DEL POLLAIUOLO, Hercules and Antaeus, ca. 1470–1475. Bronze, 1' 6” high with base.

Other artworks in Florence and Italy around the middle of the 15th century ANTONIO DEL POLLAIUOLO, Battle of the Ten Nudes, ca. 1465. Engraving. 1 3 1/8” x 1’ 11 1/4” . FRA ANGELICO, Annunciation, San Marco, Florence, Italy, ca. 1438–1447. Fresco, 7’ 1” x 10’ 6”. ANDREA MANTEGNA, Camera Picta (Painted Chamber), Palazzo Ducale, Mantua, Italy, 1465–1474. Fresco, 8’ 9” in diameter. ANDREA MANTEGNA, Foreshortened Christ, ca. 1500. Tempera on canvas, 2’ 2 3/4” x 2’ 7 7/8”. Pinacoteca di Brera, Milan.

Painting in Florence in the later half of the 15th century Domenico Ghirlandaio, Giovanna Tornabuoni(?), 1488. Oil and tempera on wood, 2’ 6” x 1’ 8”. SANDRO BOTTICELLI, Birth of Venus, ca. 1484–1486. Tempera on canvas, approx. 5’ 9” x 9’ 2”.

Art at the Sistine Chapel in Rome PERUGINO, Christ Delivering the Keys of the Kingdom to Saint Peter, Sistine Chapel, Vatican, Rome, Italy, 1481–1483. Fresco, 11’ 5 1/2” x 18’ 8 1/2”.

Architecture of the later half of the 15th century LEON BATTISTA ALBERTI, Sant’Andrea, Mantua, Italy, designed 1470, begun 1472.

An Umbrian admonition... LUCA SIGNORELLI, Damned Cast into Hell, San Brizio Chapel, Orvieto Cathedral, Orvieto, Italy, 1499–1504. Fresco, 23’ wide.


Summary and Study GuideI. INTRODUCTIONWhen you hear the word “RENAISSANCE” what comes to mind?

Italy as a nation-state does NOT exist Instead the area was divided into a number of AUTONOMOUS (self-governing) regions. By 1350, northern Italy was a highly urban region. Three cities (Genoa, Venice, Florence) had populations of about 100,000 people, a huge cities for the time. These were COSMOPOLITAN (worldly, sophisticated, urbane) centers of trade and commerce. Fertile places for new ideas.

3. Rise of Wealthy Merchant Families: As trade grew, a new class of merchants and bankers rapidly arose and had a powerful impact upon the Renaissance providing, For the first time in centuries, new patrons of the arts. The Church is still very important4. Important Point - The Renaissance was noticed in Italy first. However, major artistic developments began to occur simultaneously in Northern Europe. We will study the Northern Renaissance after our investigation of the Italian Renaissance. C. Humanism1. Humanism means the rediscovery of the art and literature of ancient Greece and Rome2. Humanists were scholars, writers, and artists who rediscovered and then studied the cultural heritage of Greece and Rome.D. “Man is the Measure of all Things”1. This rediscovery of the Greco-Roman heritage sparked a renewed interest in HUMANS including

Human formHuman emotions and personalitiesHuman potentialHuman achievements – especially heroic deeds

E. Natural world1. Curiosity about the natural world2. Detailed observation of nature3. Accurate representation of nature – will lead to important breakthroughs in artF. Individualism1. What is the reward for heroic achievement?

FameWealth

2. Artists have names from now on3. Portraits

Of patronsOf themselves – self-portraitsAutobiographies

G. A Historically Self-Conscious AgeClassical CivilizationMiddle Ages sometimes called the “Dark Ages”The Renaissance or “rebirth”

The Early Renaissance (1400s)A.k.a. – The QuattrocentoMasaccioDonatelloBotticelliGhibertiBrunelleschiAlberti


Major Time Periods in Renaissance Art: 15th Century More detailed observation of man himself and of nature followed in the 15th century with the growth of interest in anatomy, perspective, details of nature, landscape backgrounds, and form and color in light. Paintings of the 15th century also reflect the growing curiosity about man's achievement in Italy's past--that is, the Classic past.

It is this preoccupation with and study of Classic culture and art that gave the Renaissance in Italy its particular character. Classic culture also brought with it mythology and the ideal of beauty.

Ideas and Concepts: Humanism, Neoplatonism, and Aristotelianism The art of a period is a reflection of the psychological, religious, and political forces at work during that period.

Humanism Humanism was the basic concept of the Italian Renaissance. It is the term used to

define that philosophical movement in Italy at the end of the 14th century and during the 15th and 16th centuries which asserted the right of the individual to the use of his own reason and belief, and stressed the importance and potential of man as an individual.

This concept can be identified with a belief in the power of learning and science to produce "the complete man". This rational and scientific conception of the world is the basis of our modern civilization. Modern Humanism originated in the Renaissance when scholars, writers, poets, artists, philosophers and scientists sought regeneration in the freer intellectual spirit of Classical times.

The Humanists saw no conflict between the New Learning--the newly rediscovered wisdom of the ancient world--and the authority of the Church. They felt that the study of the ancient great writers of Greece and Rome was a tool for the understanding of true Christian doctrine, and that Platonic philosophy (the belief in the ideal of physical beauty as the mani-festation of God, the One Supreme Being) could only illumi-nate, never undermine, theology.


Ideas and Concepts:HumanismNeoplatonismAristotelianism

Neo-Platonism Neo-Platonism in the Renaissance was the philosophy based on the teachings and doctrines of a group of thinkers of the early Christian era who endeavored to reconcile the teachings of Plato with

Christian concepts. The Neo-Platonists, being at the same time both lovers of the pagan past with its

Platonic ideals of physical beauty, and being Christians, wanted to fuse this pagan idealism with Christian doctrine. The art and taste during the Renaissance for complicated mythological fantasies intermingled with allegories and symbolisms tried to achieve this fusion of the Platonic idealism with Christian doctrine. The allegorical value of the art lies in this union of the Classical antique and the Christian.

The Neo-Platonists conceived of the Christian religion as an eternal doctrine existing even before the advent of historical Christianity. The main object of the Neo-Platonic Academy in Florence in the 15th century was the reconciliation of the spirit of antiquity with that of Christianity.

The meaning of God to the Neo-Platonists was thus: God was Beauty and the source of Beauty. God's image is Man. Therefore, the ideally beautiful Man is the closest approximation of God on this earth. Michelangelo was the greatest Neo-Platonic artist who believed that the spirit of Classical art inspired and guided the formation of the concetto (concept) of beauty in the mind.

Aristotelianism In the Renaissance, another school of classical learning was coterminous and was finally reconciled with Neo-Platonism, called Aristotelianism. Leon Battista Alberti (1404-72) first formulated this concept of art based on the writings of Aristotle via Vitruvius (early 1st century A.D. classical author). It is the Aristotelian conception of the visible world as ultimate reality. Alberti's concept of beauty in a work of art is the harmony between all the parts so that nothing can be added to it or taken from it without impairing the whole. The work of art is synthesized by adding together the most beautiful observable examples of the component parts. Leonardo da Vinci, always the scientist, even when a painter, was the chief exponent of the Aristotelian concept.


The Classical in the Renaissance In the broadest artistic sense, Classical art is that art which is based on the study of classical models, and art which emphasizes qualities considered to be characteristically Greek and Roman in style and spirit:

Reason Objectivity Discipline Restraint Order Balance

Discipline Restraint

These characteristics can be summed up in one term: Harmony. The essential conditions that encourage Classical art are:

Pride in the past Peace in the present Confidence in the future


The Renaissance's Five Great Achievements There are five fundamental elements in the great achievements of the Italian Renaissance in the world of Art:

Naturalism Organization of space Invention of parallel perspective by Filippo Brunelleschi: the scientific use of a perspective based on lines that come together at a single vanishing point on the horizon The use of classical motifs The new dignity of the individual

Characteristics of Renaissance Painting Harmonious proportions among all elements of a painting Reintroduction of chiaroscuro: the gradations of light and dark within a picture, especially one in which the forms are largely determined, not by sharp outlines but by the meeting of lighter and darker areas The perfection of geometric or parallel perspective

Characteristics of Renaissance Sculpture The reintroduction of contrapposto: the pose of the human form in which the head and shoulders face in a different direction from the hips and legs -- a spiral twist The systematic study of anatomy and of the organic functions of the body Free-standing monumental statues

Characteristics of Renaissance Architecture A harmony of all parts with symmetry and order of geometric proportions and designs using Classical architectural elements.

FIFTEENTH CENTURY ITALIAN ART

1. Man: The Measure of All Things

While religion had been the focus lof much of medieval thought, the Italians of the fifteenth century were very much interested in humanity. For the Italians, the person literally became the "measure of all things." Interest in nature was combined with a passion for mathematics, for structure, and with a great belief in man's capacity to reason. Art was much more closely linked to science and mathematics in Florence than it was in the North. The interest in man and mathematics in fifteenth century Italy can be symbolized by the image known as "Vitruvian Man," which combines the figure of man with a combination of the circle and the square. These two basic geometric figures were thought to reflect the perfect harmony in the universe.

The plan of Brunelleschi's Pazzi Chapel combines the favorite Renaissance forms—the square and the circle (Figure 16 21). The Chapel is an excellent illustration of an architecture scaled to the person. The scale of medieval churches was intended to overwhelm people, to make them feel


small in the presence of God, while the scale of Brunelleschi's chapel was intended to make people feel as though they were the masters (Figure 16 20). The chapel was attached to a medieval cathedral; notice the height of the wall of the medieval building compared to the smaller scale of the chapel. Compare the Gothic tower of the Sainte Chapelle spiraling upward toward God (Figure 10 28) with the low rounded dome of Brunelleschi's chapel. The contrast is even stronger when we compare the interior of the Pazzi Chapel (Figure 16 22) with the interior of Cologne cathedral (Figure 10¬48). Use the benches as a human scale and imagine yourself kneeling in each of the buildings. How would you feel about your own sense of worth in each case?

The growth of portraiture reflected the Renaissance concern with individualism and is another reflection of man as the measure of all things. In fifteenth century Italy humanity was significant for itself, not merely as part of a religious hierarchy. Earlier portraits had most often been done in connection with devotional foundations, and they were often imaginary representations, for example the thirteenth century representations of Ekkehard and Uta in Naumburg Cathedral that represented earlier benefactors of the cathedral (Figure 10 54).

In fifteenth century Italy monuments and portraits praising the worldly accomplishments of individuals became increasingly popular. One popular type showed a condottiere, or military leader, on horseback. One of the most important of these monuments (Figure 16 13), done by the sculptor Donatello about 1445 to 1450, is a portrait of Erasmo da Narni, known as the "Gattamelata." This portrait of a famous mercenary leader was erected in the city square of Padua by a thankful populace. This is one of the first times since the Roman period that monumental sculpture was removed from a religious context; its sole purpose was to praise an individual. The form itself was freed from the medieval attachment to architecture, as had been the case with Donatello's earlier figures of St. Mark (Figure 16¬5) and St. George (Figure 16 6). Medieval statues were attached to the church, subordinate to it. Literally as well as symbolically, humanity and sculptured representations freed themselves from the church as the Renaissance progressed. The military leaders in Italy were important in the shift from exclusive concern with salvation to the concept of worldly glory. Andrea del Castagno painted another popular commander, Piippo Spano (Figure 16 31), and Verrocchio created an even more imposing evocation of worldly power in his monument to Colleoni (Figure 16 53), which was erected in Venice in the 1480s.

We see a full range of fifteenth century Italians in portraits like the apostolic legate and author, Matteo Palmieri by Rossellino (Figure 16 49), Ghirlandaio's magnificently dressed young woman (Figure 16 58), the unknown young man painted by Botticelli (Figure 16 59), or the delightful child carved by Desiderio (Figure 16 50). The entire family of the Duke of Mantua was painted by Mantegna in the famous frescoes of the Camera degli Sposi in the Ducal palace in Mantua (Figure 16 64). Ghirlandaio gave us a marvelous glimpse of upper middle class Florentine life disguised as a painting of the Birth of the Virgin (Figure 16 57).

Suggested Images: Figures 10 28,10 48,10 54,16 5,16 6,16 13, 16 20, 16 21, 16 22, 16 31, 16 49, 16 50, 16 57, 16 58, 16 59, 16 60, 1644

2. Linear Perspective

Perhaps the most important manifestation of "man as the measure of all things" was the establishment of what we call linear perspective in Florence in the 1420s. Credit for the invention or discovery is generally given to Brunelleschi, the architect of the Pazzi Chapel. Brunelleschi is said to have cut a hole in a panel, then looked through the hole at a cityscape and painted exactly what he saw. One important aspect of this exercise was that it limited the spectator to a single position in space and then related the painted composition to the exact position of the spectator's eye. The basic principles of perspective can be seen in Masaccio's Trinity fresco in the Church of Santa Maria Novella in Florence (Figure 16 28). In linear single point perspective all the orthogonals, that is those lines that are perpendicular to the picture plane, meet at a single point on the horizon. We call this the vanishing point. The orthogonals of the ceiling are above our eye level. If each were extended they converge at a single point at the base, which would correspond to our eye level. Conversely, any orthogonals that are below our eye level seem to converge upward as we see in Piero della Francesca's Flagellation of Christ (Figure 16 33). Notice how the lines that are above the figures seem to converge downward to the vanishing point while those that are below converge upward. It is easy to construct a perspective drawing once one has located the vanishing point. All lines perpendicular to the picture plane must converge on that point, whether they are above the horizon line or below it. Notice the squares of the floor are below the eye level. The extension of these lines converge on the same vanishing point as do extensions of the lines at the ceiling overhead. The level of the horizon line depends on the position of the spectator. A very high viewpoint will create a very high horizon line. We call this a Wrd's eye view. In the opposite situation, called a worm's eye view, the spectator is placed very low and the horizon line is also very low. Depicting a scene from below is also referred to by the Italian term di sotto in su.

In 1435 the theoretician and architect Albert wrote down the rules of perspective:

Rule 1. There is no distortion of straight lines.

Rule 2. There is no distortion of objects parallel to the picture plane.

Rule 3. Orthogonals converge in a single vanishing point depending on the position of the observer's eye.


Rule 4. Size diminishes relative to distance.

For the Medieval western and Byzantine artist, size had been a function of the importance of the subject. In the Romanesque fresco of Figure 9 37, for example, the Virgin and Child are much larger than the Magi or the Apostles. When Domenico Veneziano shows the Virgin and Child surrounded by sainb (Figure 16 32), they all must obey the laws of Renaissance space. Castagno's setting for the Last Supper (Figure 16 30) follows all the rules of perspective. Look at the converging orthogonals of the benches, the walls, and particularly the ceiling. The ceiling, with its alternating black and white squares, might have been done by an Op artist of the 1960s.

Perspective techniques were applied to relief sculpture, as well as to painting, as you can see from the panels from Ghiberti's cast doors of the Florence Baptistry (Figure 16 11). Notice the complex architectural setting of the meeting of Isaac and his Sons. There are many figures and a multitude of architectural details, yet the composition is very clear and uncluttered, the figures move easily and gracefully in this rational, logically constructed space.

In his Christ Giving the Keys to St. Peter (Figure 16 62), Perugino painted one of the favorite perspective exercises of fifteenth¬century Italian artists, a city square or piazza. The piazzas, which were often paved with marble squares, were so popular with artists because the structure of converging orthogonals was already laid out for them. The moldings on the surrounding buildings added other ready made elements for the perspective structure. By placing the centralized church right in the center of the composition, Perugino avoided one of the problems that often arose from a strict application of the laws of perspective, which was that the lines converging in a single point tended to create a visual hole in the center of the canvas. The squares of the piazza serve to give the correct relationships between the sizes of the figures that are placed at varying distances from the spectator. One becomes more intrigued with Perugino's solution to formal problems than with the theme of the painting itself. As you can see, the unification of vision with theory, of art with science, was a tremendous challenge for fifteenth century Italian artists.

The science of perspective became an absolute passion for the Florentine painter, Paolo Uccello. His biographer, Vasari, relates the problems Uccello's wife had in getting him to leave his work and come to bed when he was involved in a problem of perspective. He turned his commission to do four battle scenes for the Medici into just such a problem. One solution is shown in Figure 16 29. It seems strange to Wnk about a battle in terms of geometry, but that is how Uccello saw it. Notice how he has used the broken lances on the ground to create his perspective grid work. Even the dead knight is carefully foreshortened and is laid out precisely on a receding orthogonal.

The Florentine passion for perspective was exported in the second half of the century to other parts of Italy. We already examined a work by one of the most accomplished masters of the new art, Piero della Francesca (Figure 16 33). Study the other example of his work in Figure 16 34. Andrea Mantegna, who worked in Mantua, set himself elaborate perspective problems such as the worm's eye view in the painting of St. James led to martyrdom (Figure 16 63). Even more astounding is the sharply foreshortened view of the dead Christ (Figure 16 66). You might want to give the definition of the term foreshortening which is "the apparent visual contraction of an object viewed as extended in a plane that is not perpendicular to the line of sight." One of the most beautiful fifteenth century rooms was painted by Mantegna for the Gonzaga family in the Palace at Mantua. Mantegna decorated all the walls (Figure 16 64) and the ceiling (Figure 16 65) of the Camera degli Sposi about 1474 with a series of frescoes showing all of the members of the Gonzaga household welcoming home a son who had joined the papal court in Rome. All the wal}s and the ceiling are painted to relate to a spectator standing in the center of the room. Most startling of all are the figures painted on the ceiling (Figure 1645), for they are strongly foreshortened and are the first example of an illusionistic painting style that became extremely popular in the Baroque period. This technique is sometimes referred to as na worm's eye viewn but is more commonly known by its Italian name di sotto en su perspective.

Suggested Images: Figures 9 37, 16 11, 16 28, 16 29, 16 30, 16¬32, 16 33, 16 34, 16 62, 16 63, 1644, 16 65, 1646

3. Classical Humanism and the Renaissance

Many Renaissance artists and thinkers believed that their own period represented a rebirth of the great classical age. The term "Renaissance" literally means Rebirth." In the medieval view of history the period of the classical Greek and Roman civilizations had been an age of darkness. With the birth of Christ light had entered the world and progress had continued since that time. The great fourteenth century writer, Dante, considered classical antiquity to be equal to Christian times. He couldn't condemn the great Greek philosophers to damnation but, instead, in his Divine Comedy, placed them in limbo with the unbaptized babies.

His compatriot, Petrarch, took the definitive step when he presented the position that it was the Christian period, not the classical one, that represented the Dark Ages. He longed for a return to the shining age of classical antiquity. This spirit grew among fifteenth century Italian artists and scholars, and these men came to believe that they were truly living in a new age, in a revival of the glorified past. The painter Mantegna made a pilgrimage on the birthday of the Roman writer Virgil.


Lorenzo de' Medici, the ruler of Florence in the second half of the fifteenth century, established an academy of scholars who devoted themselves to the revival of classical philosophy, literature, and art. These scholars felt their major task was to harmonize the tenets of classical humanism as represented in the works of the great pagan philosophers with the beliefs of the Christian church.

Classical forms slowly found their way into Christian art. At first Greek and Roman forms were adapted to Christian representations, as we saw in the great pulpit that Nicola Pisano created for the baptistry of Pisa Cathedral about 1260 (Figure 15 1). The interest in the forms of classical antiquity became almost a passion with many fifteenth century Florentine artists. The architect Brunelleschi and the sculptor Donatello made a trip to Rome, where they carefully observed and measured all the ancient Roman buildings and statues they could find there. Donatello's mounted equestrian portrait (Figure 16 13) is a clear reflection of the Roman statue of Marcus Aurelius he saw in Rome (Figure 6 77). Apparently Donatello was fascinated also by the classical nude figures he saw, their idealized forms representing man at his most glorious. Donatello's bronze David (Figure 16 12) clearly reflects this interest, even though it represents a Biblical subject. It is the first freestanding nude figure since classical times. The figure illustrates Donatello's rediscovery of the classical device of "contrapposto,~ or Weight shifts in which the weight is thrown on one foot, with the consequence that one side of the body is shown relaxed while the other has a contrasting tension. This pose had been discovered by the ancient Greeks in the fifth century and had been used by them and by the Romans (Figure 5 68).

The greatest reconciliation of classical and late medieval form in painting is seen in the work of Sandro Botticelli (Figure 16 60). Many of Botticelli's paintings are firmly anchored in the philosophic speculations of the members of Lorenzo de' Medici's Platonic Academy. Humanists like Poliziano and Marsilio Ficino attempted to reconcile the concepts of pagan philosophy with the principles of Christianity, just as Botticelli synthesized the visual styles. The careful detailing, the flattened space, and the decorative linear forms all refer to the International Gothic style, and the painting seems to be closely related to the amine fleur" tapestries. Although the nude Venus is based on a classical prototype (Figure 5 63), she does not stand solidly on her feet. Classical figures always had a firm sense of body solidity, but Botticelli's Venus seems to float. She is a very beautiful figure, and for the Neo Platonic philosopher, Beauty was synonymous with Truth. The composition illustrates the progression of Beauty and guides the soul upward from the material world to the realm of pure truth, to union with God.

Earthly, natural beauty can lead us to contemplation of celestial beauty. This hierarchy of beauty is clearer if you understand Plato's definition of reality. Plato believed that truth resides in the pure ideas in the mind of the Boned In the Republic, Plato used the illustration of a group of people chained in a cave in such a way that they could only look in one direction. Behind them a great fire blazed and it threw shadows on the wall that could be seen by the chained beings. The shadows they saw were cast by figures moving and dancing behind them, but since the shadows were the only thing they could see, they mistook them for reality. A philosopher escaped from the chains and saw the real objects that were casting the shadows. Plato explained that the things we saw around us were like the shadow, mere reflections of the true and perfect forms that exist on a higher plane.

For the Neo Platonic philosophers everything in the world emanates from the God head, but each thing is more or less perfect according to the degree of nearness or remoteness from the source. Next to the original none," reason is most perfect. It contains in itself the Ideal World and the whole of true and changeless being. From reason emanates the World soul that actualized the ideal forms in sensible matter. Matter is undetermined and has no being in itself. The visible world is a transcription of the World soul. In a sense the World soul is like a computer program, containing the true essence of the reality that will be realized when the program has been implemented. As the World soul links reason and matter, so the individual souls partake of both reason and sense. Souls come down from the rational or light world, which is their real home and they retain a recollection of it and a longing to return. The strongest incentive for the return of the soul to its original home is the love of Beauty. The contemplation of earthly Beauty can lead us to an understanding of pure Beauty, and since Beauty and Truth are synonymous for the Neo Platonist we are carried through Beauty and Truth into the realm of pure being and so merge with God, the source of all being.

Suggested Images: Figures 5 63, 5 68, 6 77, 15 1, 16 12, 16 13, 16 60

4. Classical Influence on Fifteenth Century Architecture

Fifteenth century architects combined passion for geometry with ideas adapted from classical buildings. As noted above, Brunelleschi and Donatello had made a trip to Rome where they carefully measured all the ancient Roman buildings they could find. The dome of the Pazzi Chapel (Figure 16 20) may be an echo of the Pantheon (Figure 6 56), as may be its centralized structure and its porch with architrave and elegant classical columns. Brunelleschi used classical pilasters in the interior as well as on the facade of the Ospedale degli Innocenti (Figure 16 17) where he also added windows topped by classical pediments. While he did not slavishly copy classical prototypes, the logic and clarity of his designs is much closer to classical models than to the architecture of the Middle Ages.

Brunelleschi used the column arch combination that was found in late Roman (Figure 6 82) and Early Christian (Figure 7 5) buildings, a combination that Alberti did not believe was sufficiently pure. Alberti had studied the writings of the Roman architect Vitruvius and wrote a book of his own on architecture, De re aedificatoria, which was to have a profound influence on later architects. Alberti himself adopted many Roman elements in his buildings: converting the columned articulation of the Colosseum (Figure 6 48) to the flat facade of the Rucellai Palace (Figure 16 38), and attaching columns and the triple arches of a Roman triumphal arch (Figure 6 95) as a shell around the medieval structure of San Francesco, Rimini (Figure


1641). He used the triumphal arch with attached pilasters as the basis for his design of the facade of Sant' Andrea, Mantua (Figure 1642) and decorated its barrel vaults (Figure 1644) with classical Roman coffering (Figure 6 91).

Alberti added a small, beautifully proportioned classical temple at the top of the west facade of Santa Maria Novella (Figure 16 39). This small temple is related to the lower parts of the facade through simple numerical ratios. In his writings Alberti stressed the importance of harmonic ratios, of measure, of mathematics as the basis for beauty. These harmonic ratios were related to the old Greek concept of the harmony of the spheres and thus tied the macrocosm to the microcosm. He used the basic and perfect geometric forms of square and circle in his facade, forms that united heaven and earth. For the Humanists the perfect circle that had no end was the symbol of the unity, the infinite essence and the uniformity of God. The square symbolized earth, and bringing the two together created a symbolic unity between heaven and earth.

Alberti believed that the centralized church was the ideal type. Alberti tried, but never succeeded, in building one. Brunelleschi had approximated it with the Pazzi Chapel (Figure 16 21), and he tried to develop it more fully in Santa Maria degli Angeli (Figure 16 23), which was never finished. Guliano da Sangallo came close with Santa Maria delle Carcere (Figures 1645 and 1646). The full realization of the ideal had to wait until the High Renaissance when Bramante built the Tempietto in Rome (Figure 17 6).

Suggested Images: Figures 6 48, 6 56, 6 82, 6 91, 6 95, 7 5, 16¬17, 16 20, 16 21, 16 23, 16 38, 16 39, 16 41, 1642, 1644, 1645, 1646, 17 6

Study Guide1. Compare Italian fifteenth-century painting with that of the Netherlands.2. Describe humanism, using literary and artistic examples.3. Locate the leading art centers on a map of Italy and the North.4. Discuss the importance of the competition for the Florence Baptistery Doors.5. Draw and label the plans of Florence Cathedral, Santo Spirito in Florence, and Sant' Andrea in Mantua.6. Describe the structure of Brunelleschi's dome.7. Describe the use of mathematical linear perspective as it is used in fifteenth-century painting.8. Discuss the new emphasis on biography and autobiography in the Renaissance.9. Describe the emergence of mythological subject matter and Platonism.10. Describe the development of sculpture in Florence in the fifteenth century.11. Discuss the writings and architecture of Alberti.12. Explain the role of fame in art and philosophy.13. Discuss the role of patronage in the arts.14. Discuss the Arnolfini Portrait using different methodologies.15. Compare Italian with Netherlandish fifteenth-century painting

Potential Exam Essay Questions1. In what ways do you think the work of Durer and Leonardo da Vinci resembled each other, and in what ways do you think they were

different?2. List what you believe to be the six most important works of art created between 1500 and 1520 in Europe. Include at least one from the

Netherlands and one from Germany. Why do you believe they are the most important? What differences do you see between the ones you have selected from the north and those from Italy? What do you think these differences reveal about the different conceptions of man held by the two regions? Which set of beliefs do you think is closest to the one we hold today?

3. How does Bosch's conception of the creation and man's fate compare with Michelangelo's as expressed in the Sistine ceiling and the Last Judgment frescoes? Compare both the iconography and the styles of the two artists.

4. Compare the International Style with the monumental Renaissance style using examples from this chapter.5. Discuss the use of linear perspective in the work of Lorenzo Ghiberti and Piero della Francesca. Refer to specific works by the artists.6. Discuss the Renaissance concept of fame, and its expression in works illustrated in this chapter.7. Compare and contrast the techniques and esthetic effects of fresco and oil painting.8. Compare the Mérode Altarpiece with Gentile da Fabriano's Adoration of the Magi. Consider style, patronage, and function.9. Compare fifteenth-century painting of the Northern Renaissance with that of fifteenth-century Italy, using examples from this chapter.

Identify both differences and areas of mutual influence.

chp. 13- the early renaissance - lacour-paper...

Documents