chapter 7: preventing & treating drug use psy 302: substance abuse
TRANSCRIPT
Chapter 7:Preventing & Treating Drug Use
PSY 302: Substance Abuse
PreventionPrevention
Protective Factors◦ Emphasis put on enhancing these
Risk Factors◦ Emphasis put on reducing these
Models for PreventionModels for PreventionInformation Model The underlying assumption is that the presentation of factual information about drugs and the biological, social and psychological effects, the risk and dangers of drug use and its consequences would have sufficient preventive impact
Ellickson (1995)
Click on picture for video
Models for PreventionModels for Prevention
Affective ModelDrug abuse has its main cause in the shortcomings of young personalities low level self-esteem, inability to make rational decisions and express feelings and inadequate problem-solving skillsThe main goal of prevention should be enhancing self-esteem, improvement of decision-making and problem-solving skills
Ellickson (1995)
Affective ModelAffective Model
Reconnecting Youth ProgramSelf-esteem EnhancementDecision MakingPersonal Control Interpersonal Communication
Models for PreventionModels for Prevention
Social Influence Model Behavior is the result of positive or negative influencesPrograms designed within the framework of this model should be based on a negative influence resisting
Ellickson (1995)
Social Influence ModelSocial Influence Model
LifeSkills Training (LST) ProgramSubstance abuse and violence prevention program that targets the social and psychological factors that promote the initiation of substance use and other risky behaviorsDesigned to provide information relevant to the important life transitions that adolescents and young teens face
Social Influence ModelSocial Influence Model
LifeSkills Training (LST) ProgramMathias (2003)Positive effects extended beyond the typical low-risk youths to those who were at higher than average riskLST “significantly reduced initiation of drug use among urban, middle school students who were doing poorly academically and had substance-abusing friends
Prevention ResearchPrevention Research
Technical Problems and CriticismsDifficulty in implementation of prevention programsSchool staff are usually more enthusiastic about their programs than the empirical data indicatesPrevention programs need to make goals explicit from the start
Drug TestingSeveral methods used to test for drugs:UrinalysisHair AnalysisSweat Patch Drug Residues LimitationsCannot determine exact time or how muchTests cannot distinguish the casual user from a chronic userFalse readingsSeveral ways to avoid detection
See next slide
METHODS TO AVOID METHODS TO AVOID DETECTIONDETECTIONAbstentionDilution (Hydration)AdulterationSubstitution
Professor David Cowan (right), head of the London 2012 lab, shows UK Olympics minister Hugh Robertson around the drug-testing facility in east London
ABSTENTIONABSTENTION
Stop using prior to the test
Switch to a different drug that is not part of the testing panel
Pre-employment tests most vulnerable
DILUTION (HYDRATION) DILUTION (HYDRATION)
Most popular method to avoid detection“Water-loading”, “Flushing”, “Detoxing”Use of diuretics, Lasix, vitaminsAdding water to the sample
ADULTERATIONADULTERATION A urine specimen that has been alteredNot a normal constituent for that type of specimen Shows an abnormal concentration of an endogenous substance
OXIDIZING ADULTERANTA substance that acts alone or in combination with other substances to oxidize drugs or drug metabolites to prevent the detection of the drug
SUBSTITUTIONSUBSTITUTION Substituting human or animal urine via a variety of ways, etc.
Desperate people do desperate things
Click on photo
CHEATERS GETTING CHEATERS GETTING CREATIVECREATIVE
asdfsadf
Cane
Binoculars Books
Cell Phone FlaskBooks
17
Man got shot to avoid drug test
Microwaving urine, blew up (man hospitalized)
Leaves found in urine
Man claimed to be positive due to bedbugs
Man faked heart attack during testing
DESPERATE PEOPLE
Treatment concernsTreatment concerns
There is no one gold-standard approach to treating addiction.
Anyone can start a treatment center or SA therapy without credentials or scientific research to back up their methods.
Options vary widely in price and relapse rates (the latter of which is rarely reported).
18
Treatment concernsTreatment concerns
People should seek out treatment plans that include a reliable and valid diagnosis and a valid way of reducing their relapse rates.
19
The Cure Industry
ScreeningIdentifies individuals with hazardous or harmful drug use or dependence and associated risk behaviorsDiagnosisReferences common to the mental healthTreatmentBased on a plan developed with the client and establishes goals in accord with identified needs and sets interventions to meet those goals
Diagnosing Substance Diagnosing Substance DependenceDependence
A variety of scales exist to document:◦ Physical health (no standardized instrument for
this)◦ Alcohol and drug use◦ Psychiatric Disturbance◦ Personality◦ Cognition◦ Family Adjustment◦ Social Adjustment◦ Legal problems◦ Financial history◦ Risk (suicidal? Violent?)
21
Determination of abuse or dependency
Determination whether detoxification is needed Medical Social
Treatment Plan most appropriate for severity of use and type of drug Detoxification
Residential or outpatient Outpatient
Group, individual, family Residential
28-90 days Psychiatric referral Combination
Risk Management Plan for managing medical or psychiatric crises
Medication-Assisted Medication-Assisted TreatmentTreatmentNicotineNicotine gum and the transdermal nicotine patch are used in conjunction with behavioral support to relieve withdrawal symptomsElectric cigarettes provide nicotine without the attendant fire and smoke of a regular cigarette.
Click on picture for video
Medication-Assisted Medication-Assisted TreatmentTreatmentAlcoholAntabuseNaltrexoneCampral
AntabuseMost studies suggest that Antabuse has been only moderately effectiveWhen effective, it supplements the alcoholic’s own commitment to quitDaily routine of pill ingestion may reaffirm commitment not to drinkMany quit taking the pill and continue to drink
Medications for Alcohol Abuse
CampralReduces the physical distress and emotional discomfort people usually experience when they quit drinking, apparently by reducing excitatory neurotransmittersShould be used as part of a complete treatment program that includes both counseling and psychological supportRestores the natural balance of chemicals in the brain (neurotransmitters)
Medications for Alcohol AbuseMedications for Alcohol Abuse
Opioid Addiction Opioid Addiction TreatmentsTreatmentsAntagonist Maintenance
◦ Naloxone ◦ Naltrexone◦ Ultra-rapid opioid detox
Agonists Maintenance◦ Methadone◦ Buprenorphine◦ Combination treatments
Abstinence-based◦ Residential (with or after
detox)◦ 12 Step Programs
Medication-Assisted Medication-Assisted TreatmentTreatmentOpioid AntagonistsBlock or counteract the effects of opioidsBind with opiate receptor sites and prevents stimulation; displaces an opiate already at the siteAn opiate similar to heroin and morphine but is absorbed and metabolized slowlyPerceived to be less harmful than other drugsAssumed to satisfy the cravings associated with the previous drug use and allow the person to carry on with their life
Antagonist MaintenanceAntagonist Maintenance
Naloxone Used for testing for opiate dependence before admission to a methadone programNo effect on non-dependent person
Antagonist Maintenance NaloxoneEmergency Treatment
◦Used to counter the effects of opiate overdose, for example heroin or morphine overdose
◦Specifically used to counteract life-threatening depression of the central nervous system and respiratory system
◦Naloxone has been distributed as part of emergency overdose response kits to heroin and other opioid drug users, and this has been shown to reduce rates of fatal overdose
Antagonist MaintenanceNaltrexone (ReVia)Blocks opioid receptorsReduce cravingTablets or implantable
pelletsReduces alcohol slipsUsed for opioids as well
as alcohol
Injectable Naltrexone Injectable Naltrexone (Vivitrol)(Vivitrol)Intramuscular injection of depot naltrexone given monthlyRecently FDA approved for alcoholAdminister in physician office, not at home
Naltrexone Implant
Oral naltrexone compounded by pharmacy into pellet◦Inserted subcutaneously (minor
surgery)◦Lasts for 1-3 months, may be replaced
Antagonist maintenance◦Similar to oral/intramuscular naltrexone
therapyRequires detoxification from
opioids firstNot approved by FDA
Opiod Agonists Maintenance Pharmacotherapy for OpioidsLong-acting medication in
controlled setting◦ Counseling◦ Social services
Avoid withdrawal & craving
Reduce disease & crimeMaintenance vs.
detoxification issues
MethadoneMethadoneOpioid substitution therapyHarm reduction
◦Individual◦Society
Highly regulated◦Narcotic treatment programs must
be licensedVery effective but controversial
Methadone MaintenanceSingle daily dose of the long-acting
opioid in a controlled settingUse of methadone for >180 days (6 mo.)Counseling and social servicesReferral for primary medical services
Methadone An opiate similar to heroin and morphine but is absorbed and metabolized slowlyPerceived to be less harmful than other drugsAssumed to satisfy the cravings associated with the previous drug use and allow the person to carry on with their life
Medications for Opiate Abuse
Blocking DoseMajority of opioid receptors are
blocked by methadone◦Can’t “feel” heroin effects
However, some typical opioid effects◦Sedation◦Reassuring feeling
Less side effects◦ No withdrawal symptoms◦ No craving
Beneficial EffectsEnhanced recoveryReduced mortality
◦ 70% reduction in each of the following: Overdose Trauma Homicide Medical illnesses
Improved health◦ Medical◦ Psychiatric
Improved psychosocial functioning◦ Employment◦ Criminal activity◦ Family responsibilities
Methadone Forever? No federal limit for time on methadone Some states restrict time
◦ Virginia: evaluate every 2 years to see if can come off the treatment within that time frame
Individual variability◦ Time required to stabilize (use, housing, family, job)◦ Long-term clients (decades)
Initial: can’t imagine life without something Stable: able to consider coming off
◦ Taper off comfortably over months/years
Click on picture for video
Buprenorphine
Alternative to methadone for opioid addiction treatment
Long-acting partial opioid agonistMultiple forms available
◦ Combined with naloxone (Suboxone): most common
◦ Buprenorphine only (Subtex)◦ Used for treatment of acute pain
(Buprenex)Used for detox or maintenance
◦ Only mildly addictive
Buprenorphine
Binds to opioid receptors in bodyOnly activates receptor around
40%, not 100% like other opioids (heroin, methadone)◦If already in withdrawal, 40% is pretty good
◦If not in withdrawal, dropping from 100% to 40% receptor activation causes withdrawal
Very low risk of overdose
Buprenorphine/Naloxone
This combination of drugs helps reduce abuse
Naloxone only active when Suboxone is injected
Results in withdrawal for users trying to get high
Buprenorphine alone has similar effect when injected by those who are opioid dependent and not in withdrawal already
Buprenorphine:Office-based opioid therapyBuprenorphine is less restricted
than methadone Get prescription from pharmacy
with refills (up to 6 months)◦Outpatient physician visits for
medication checks as neededAddiction counseling is separate,
patient may be referred to another provider for this service
Taking Buprenorphine
Sublingual tablet◦ Dissolve under tongue◦ Takes around 5 min. to dissolve◦ Won’t be active if swallowed
Comes in 2mg and 8mg tabletsTypical dose is 12-16 mg once dailyCan take 3 times a week
Methadone or Buprenorphine?Treatment efficacy equivalent Similar opioid side effectsAbuse potential
◦Slightly higher for buprenorphine in opioid non-dependent persons
Buprenorphine has fewer drug interactionsMethadone has no ceiling effectBuprenorphine more convenient (less
restricted)Methadone less expensive
◦Higher cost of buprenorphine, counseling separate cost
Buprenorphine not age-restricted (can use with teens)
Methadone Clinic Buprenorphine
• Criteria:
Withdrawal
12 months use
• Criteria:
DSM 5
No time criteria
• Dose regulated • MD sets dose
• Age > 18 • Age > 16
• Limited take homes • Take homes (30 days)
• Services “required” • Services must be “available”
Methadone Treatment Decreases Methadone Treatment Decreases HIV SeroincidenceHIV Seroincidence..
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
Baseline 1 yr. 2 yr. 3 yr.
% s
erop
ositiv
e
Methadone Out-of-treatment
Metzger et al. (1993)
Treatment for Cocaine and MethamphetamineCocaineCocaine agonists and antagonists that typically affect neurotransmitters playing a role in cocaine dependence have been tested as possible treatment agents, but no drug effectively treats the cocaine-dependent patient MethamphetamineNo approved drug for treating methamphetamine dependence
Chemical DetoxificationThe use of chemicals to facilitate drug withdrawal can serve to attract the drug dependent into treatment and increases the probability that they will complete detoxification
Rapid Detox•Addicted patient is strapped down, anesthetized, and put on a respirator. •Patient then receives intravenous doses of naltrexone that dislodge opiate molecules from their receptor sites—the patient experiences instant withdrawal that is complete in about four to six hours
50
Anesthesia Assisted Rapid Opioid Detoxification Induce acute withdrawal with naloxonePatient under deep sedation/anesthesiaShortens course, but still uncomfortableHigh riskHigh costNot recommended
Click on pictures for videos
Psychological TreatmentPsychological Treatment• Psychoanalytic Approach
• Psychotherapy• Behavior Modification
• Aversion Treatment• Cognitive Behavior Therapy
• Contingency Management • Contingency Contracting
52
Psychoanalytic ApproachPsychoanalytic ApproachStep 1: Take a detailed history of the
problems that have been caused by the patient’s use of drugs or alcohol.Inquire systematical about trouble in:
- Work- Medical health- Relationships with friends- Relationships with family- Legal problems- Mental health (depression, shame,
anxiety)53
Psychoanalytic ApproachPsychoanalytic Approach
Step 2: Diagnose client’s level of use and any comorbid disorders
Step 3: Select appropriate treatment plan
Step 4: Support clients’ attempts to change
54
TherapyTherapyBehavior ModificationAversive Conditioning
Scene from “A Clockwork Orange”
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)CBT focuses on changing the clients’
thoughts so that they do not support substance abuse behavior
Common Characteristics of CBT:• Emphasizes stoicism (calmness when
dealing with problems)• Has specific agendas for each
session, and the whole relationships is briefer and time-limited compared to other types of psychotherapy
• Homework is a central feature of CBT
56
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)
Strives to have drug abusers understand their cravings and to develop coping skills
•This may include detailed planning on how to get from one day to the next without using drugs•CBT is a short-term outpatient approach focused on helping patients to recognize, avoid, and cope
57
Drug Treatment Programs
Drug Courts: PurposeWhy Do we Need A Specialized Court?Drug Offenders pose a unique challenge to our court system; they are different than offenders who break other criminal lawsTraditional Court Systems focus on determination of guilt and sanctions, not the addiction problemJudges need specialized training and courts need specialized services and supervision for drug offenders
How Do Drug Courts Operate?Drug courts represent the coordinated
efforts of justice and treatment professionals to actively intervene and break the cycle of substance abuse, addiction, and crime.
Drug Courts are an alternative to less effective interventions,
Drug courts quickly identify substance abusing offenders and place them under ongoing judicial monitoring and community supervision, coupled with effective, long-term treatment services.
Drug Types Vary by Location
Urban Drug Courts: cocaine/crack is the primary drug of choice for urban drug court clients
Suburban Drug Courts: marijuana is the primary drug of choice for suburban drug court clients
Rural Drug Courts: methamphetamine is the primary drug of choice for rural drug court clients
Impact of Drug Courts: Do They Work?
OVERALL IMPACT: According to over a decade of research, drug courts significantly improve substance abuse treatment outcomes, substantially reduce crime ,and produce greater cost benefits than any other justice strategy
Drug Treatment ProgramsTherapeutic Community (TC)Residential, self-help; drug-free treatment programAA model incorporated
63
TC Philosophy and TC Philosophy and PerspectivesPerspectivesView of the “disorder”
View of the “person”
View of “recovery”
View of “healthy living”
64
View of the “Disorder”View of the “Disorder”
The “problem” is the individual not the drug
Detox is a condition of entry
The GOAL is abstinence
65
View of the “Person”View of the “Person”Dimensions of:
Psychological dysfunction Social deficits Vocational/educational deficits
Habilitative vs. rehabilitative needsPersonality disturbances either as a cause
or result of the substance use disorder
66
View of “Recovery”View of “Recovery”
Change in lifestyle and personal identity
Motivation: pressure(s) to change
Treatment is through staff and peers
Social learning
67
View of “Healthy Living”View of “Healthy Living”Clear “moral” positions are held
Right and wrong behaviors are identified
Specific values are stressed Guilt (as a central issue in recovery)
is addressed
Focus is on“here and now” The past is explored only to illustrate
current patterns and attitudes
68
Usual Patient Usual Patient CharacteristicsCharacteristics
Who comes for treatment?Social profiles
Psychological profiles
Psychiatric diagnoses
Criteria for treatment
69
Social ProfilesSocial Profiles70-75% maleMost from broken homes/disrupted
families<33% were employed full-time >66% have been arrested30-40% have prior treatment
70
Psychological ProfilesPsychological Profiles
High anxiety/depression Poor socialization IQ = dull (70-84) to normal (85-115)Low self esteemDisturbed thinkingImmature/antisocial
71
Psychiatric DiagnosesPsychiatric Diagnoses>70% lifetime psychiatric symptoms33% current serious mental disorderTemporary, substance-induced
conditionsIndependent disorders:
Antisocial personality disorder Bipolar disorder Anxiety disorders
72
The TC Approach to The TC Approach to TreatmentTreatment
Structure and social organization of the TC Role of staff Role of the patient(s)
Treatment tools used via the social structure
Work as therapy Mutual self-help Peers as role models Staff as rationale authorities
73
The Recovery The Recovery Process Process Typical Daily Regimen
Community meetingWork timeGroupsRecreational activities Individual counseling
Program stages I: Orientation (0-60 days) II: Primary treatment (2-12 months) III: Advanced treatment and aftercare (13-24 months)
74
Effectiveness of the TC Effectiveness of the TC ApproachApproachSuccess reflected in improvements
in several variablesPost-treatment outcomes most
influenced by “time in program” (TIP)
Retention rates: predictors of this are important
Drop-out is expected, but there are some predictors of this
75
Success RatesSuccess RatesSubstantial improvements 40-60% reduction in drug useUp to 40% in decreased arrest ratesUp to 40% in employment gainsTIP and outcomes (success = no drug use or criminality):90% for program graduates50% for drop-outs after 1 year of treatment25% for drop-outs prior to 1 year of treatment
NIDA (2001)
76
RetentionRetention
Completion rate: 10-25% of all admissions
Dropout rates highest first 30 days (30-40%)
Retention very weakly predicted by client variables
Treatment entry variables stronger, more consistent predictors of retention
Chemical Dependency Chemical Dependency ProgramsPrograms
The Minnesota Model of TreatmentA period of residential or inpatient care (28days-6mo)A focus on the substance use disorder (little attention to psychological factors)Heavy emphasis on AA self-help concepts, resourcesReferral to AA or another self-help group on dischargeMinimal or no family therapy or counselingNegative attitudes towards ongoing psychotherapies and pharmacotherapies for SA disorders
12-step programs12-step programsAlcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics AnonymousAnonymous
90-day induction period (daily attendance to meetings)
Sponsorship relationships (same-sex)Meeting attendance in which a leader
and 2-3 speakers share their experiences of how 12-step relates to their recovery
12-steps1. Admitting powerlessness2. Higher power can restore us to sanity
78
12-step programs12-step programsAlcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics Alcoholics Anonymous and Narcotics AnonymouAnonymouss
12-steps cont’d3. Decide to turn our will and our lives over to the care of
God (as we understand him)
4. Make a fearless moral inventory of ourselves
5. Add to God, ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our groups
6. Are entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character
7. Humbly ask God to remove our shortcomings
8. Make a list of all persons we have harmed
9. Make direct amends wherever possible
10. Continue to take personal inventory and admit errors
11. Improve conscious contact with God through prayer and mediation
12. Try to carry this message to other alcoholics 79
12-Step Effectiveness12-Step EffectivenessAlcoholics Anonymous Study (2008)The most recent survey of AA members, conducted in 2007, found that 33% had been continuously sober for more than 10 years, 12% had between 5 and 10 years of sobriety, 24% between 1 and 5 years, and 31% less than 1 yearComprehensively, the average length of sobriety for all members was more than 8 years, with 52% of the membership being between 41 and 60 years of age
12-Step Effectiveness12-Step EffectivenessResidential Use Studies
◦Alford (1980) Highly effective: Two years after discharge
50% still abstinent◦Alford (1991) AA/NA model inpatient treatment for
adolescents Mixed results: Over 70% remain abstinent
six months after completion of program; but this drops to about 40% after two years after completion of program
12-Step Effectiveness12-Step Effectiveness
AA contends that 75% of its members maintain abstinence
Little research because of members anonymity but indications are most don’t stick to it
Those with commitment to program leads to abstinence
CreditsCredits
Some slides prepared with the help of the following websites:hivaidsukraine.wikispaces.com/file/.../Module_5_2_ENG.pptwww1.appstate.edu/.../School-Based%20Drug%20Prevention....www.madisonpublicschools.org/.../lib/.../10_Toxicology.ppttransit-safety.volpe.dot.gov/DrugAndAlcohol/.../Final_Smith_...www.nvcc.edu/home/gstratton/Sum12.260/SA.Treatment.pptwww.alcoholmedicalscholars.org/web/presentations/ppt/tc.pptwww.vsias.org/presentations10/VSIASMAT.pptwww.aegisuniversity.com/powerpoint/CM%20final%20Portlanhttp://edition.cnn.com/2012/04/12/sport/drugs-london-2012-olympics-laboratory/index.html